Added: 3 years ago
From: lsf1114
Views: 73,668
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (77)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • It's AMAZING how Salonga has grown into the role of Fantine: from this moment before she started her stint on Broadway and had just started studying Hugo's book thoroughly, to her spectacular and very informed performance in Les Miz's 25th anniversary in October 2010 where she showed her ACTING AND VOCAL SUPERIORITY over the great Patti Lupone and the much-overrated Ruthie Henshall. It's no surprise that critics have dubbed Salonga as THE Legendary Fantine!

  • chills.

  • I guess she is Brilliant! The music is not.

  • yes lea is brilliant.. no one .. this song is LEA .... EVEN NOW KRYSTAL VOICE...

  • After hearing Boyle's I went on here to find other versions. After I heard this one I realized that Boyle was only modestly talented. =)

  • To compare susan boyle to lea salonga is stupid. leah salonga already got 2 awards for broadway performance and she's been in broadway since 1990. susan is new pls people do your research.

  • Too much vibrato for me, but otherwise a very nice performance.

  • @luvjackandsally Agree completely...Elaine and Susan have "fuller" voices and I think it suits the music better...Nevertheless, beautiful voice!

  • No disrespect to Susan but Lea Salonga is different class but i like Susan's version better than anyone elses Elaine Paige included.

  • lol - no disrespect for Susan either - but it's amazing how, in a day, with right media coverage ("instant craze") you can a make a bigger fame as an amateur (an amazing one for a change in this case) than a quite remarkable professional (such as Salonga) in his/hers successful career

  • it's not surprising though. becoz lea salonga is in theater and theater artists doesn't usually get same attention as recording artists...

  • susan boyle is good but Lea Salonga is way-way better....

  • Lea is absolutely brilliant. i actually got to see her play as Fantine on Broadway.... it was fantastic!

  • wow!

  • just wow! very blessed voice! a gift from heaven!

  • ruthie henshall is the best in the sound of musicals.

  • No one compares to our very own Leah Salonga....The Best...

  • This was NOT Lea's best by far and still it's was outstanding. For those who yearn for a more 'earthy' version of Fantine, I suggest viewing a clip of Lea's actual onstage performance or perhaps her appearance at the 'Broadway in Bryant Park' where she sang with only a piano accompaniment. IMHO Lea sings this song better than anyone else.....she is actually acting as well as singing when she performs. BRAVO; we are all blessed to have heard her.

  • I don't know so much about the "roughness" you speak of. This is fantastic. the softness of those notes means so much. the feeling we get with the thought of a young girl being left with a child from a love of the summer. I like it. i like Patti. i like Ruthie. I love Debbie Byrne. I love Evelyn Falconer. this is different. this is lea's version. she's allowed that.

  • Enough about SBoyle, Lea IS very good but I much prefer Ruthie Henshall.

  • i LOVE lea salonga. i think she was one of the most beautiful voices in recorded musical theatre history, but for me, i prefer fantine to have a "rougher" voice. like, patti lupone or ruthie henshall.

  • Lea is amazing, but I think she's better as Eponine. Ruthie Henshall is the perfect Fantine, done.

  • This is sublime!

  • BRAVO!!!!!!!!!

  • LEA is peerless.....!

    whats with Susan Boyle by the way??? gosssh!

  • cant deny that susan boyle also has a good voice(though not as good as lea's or ruthie henshal's)..she probably just didnt have professional training or something..

  • I was just thinking how amazing Lea would sound singing this, and was I impressed! :]

  • is it just me or is that too slow! still brilliant tho!

  • If you like this, try Neil Diamond's version. Check out the change of lyrics.

    Video link posted above.

  • Lea salonga voice is really best from what i heard but i don't feel emotions in this song. I think RUTHIE HENSHALL perfoms this song better.

  • she has the best low notes that i have heard from this song. Way to go :)

  • Hear her voices in

    Alladin (A whole New world)

    MUlan (Reflection)

    Kim (Miss Saigon)

    Eponine (Les Miserables-10th year)

    Fantine (Les Miserables)

    Two words (During her wedding day)

    and her versions of other disney songs (Tarzan, Pocahontas, Anastasia, Hercules, etc...)

    Perfect! Two Thumbs Up!

    Two Thumbs Up Too for Susan Boyle! I watched her clips for several times...

  • thanks to Susan Boyle

    i knw this song because of her

    *****!!!!!!!!!

  • check your ears...you must be hearing impaired! lea is perfect here.

  • Am a Filipina and I am Lea's fan too but in fairness to Susan Boyle she sang this song effortless and I would like to raise the question born to a have a golden voice? or trained to be a professional singer? Susan Boyle is a church choir singer and as she said she didnt have that opportunity before plus her look issue...cheers!

  • susan boyle is only an overnight success thats all but you can never put down salonga and renshall

  • Are you kidding me? Comparing Susan Boyle to Lea Salonga? Boyle is good, but if she was young and pretty, this whole bruhaha would not have happened! Think about it...

  • No one can compare to Lea Salonga. :) Great voice!

  • I think that SB has a very good voice but u can´t compare with a professional singer. I´m sure that when SB has some voice training she will be one of the greatest.

  • There's no doubt that Lea's a wonderful singer but that is because she is well-trained all her life and at the moment is considered a professional. Unlike the incredible and astounding Susan Boyle, who's aged, unemployed, and was only trained in a church choir but still captured the world! Can you beat that?!

  • Susan Boyle also had a professional voice teacher for some time.

  • let's see where she will be 6 months from now when all the bruhaha about her back story has faded... don't want to put her down but comments like this against professionals like salonga and renshall who have worked so hard to get where they are now just puts me off boyles!!!

  • well said stigie1978. on many videos of lea (im a huge fan!) i see comments comparing susan boyle and lea, and about SB's potential to be greater than lea.  i mean.. boyle's good.. but to say she can be better than lea/ruthie JUST because she has the POTENTIAL? there are millions out there with "potential." people make it sound like lea/ruthie took what they had for granted and just got famous overnight without working.. Please, that would be boyle.

  • i love lea salonga!

  • MAJESTIC VOICE!!!!

    much much better than susan boyle's!

    CHEERS FOR LEA!!!

  • i get goosebumps from susan boyles version than this lady

  • my nipples were hard after listening to this.

  • lmao. goose nipples

  • susan brought me here...XD

  • true for me too! Susan made this song a youtube best seller!

  • Maybe you are right, donperry1, but it's true just for the people who didn't know Les Miserables before Susan Boyle's performance. I already knew this song thanks to professional singers like the great Lea Salonga.

  • Lea rules.

  • Our very own Lea is so much better than the rest

  • Lea has a great voice! But Susan Boyle's voice is majestic and celestial. Nobody has been able to to match that out of all the singers performing that song in YouTube.

  • There are many reasons why millions view her video. BGT can't be watched at the same time in other countries so when they heard about SB, they go to YouTube. Her age and looks made her voice and singing seem so extraordinary as it wasn't expected. That now diverts people from thinking of economic woes and talk about her, watch and listen to her instead. YouTube wasn't ready for the other singers during their time but they have their CDs or albums which fans can buy. May Susan last like them.

  • You cannot be serious. It is SB has an okay voice, but Lea Salonga is majestic , celestial, angelic etc etc. For goodness sake listen to them singing. Lea's singing is pure natural talent, forget the training. SB has an ok voice, but that all!!!

  • I think she sang it better in Bryant Park than in concert halls or even in the play. For me that is the test of a great singer, to sing beautifully in an open space without the orchestra, no back up, and with all the distractions around and still hold the audience captive.

  • If you want evidence of how good Lea Salonga's voice is.....click on the On My Own video...better quality and does her voice justice....Susan Boyle my a***

  • Lea Salonga is an excellent professional singer...

    Susan Boyle is a unemployed lady from Scotland and she did an excellent job... It is not enough difference?

  • fuck you 2 gregthegolly... u piece of shit.. hope u rot in hell after i pee on you

  • Susan Boyle brought me here from Glapwell, UK

  • HORRIBLE VIDEO OF A GREAT VOICE

  • Comment removed

  • McArdle's version (you can link to it on the right) is a little better than this one, but Lea's voice is unbeatable.

  • OMFG!

  • she's got a great voice!!! :) i love her!!! she rules!!!

  • galing! wala akong masabi!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more