Added: 4 years ago
From: EdgarEmigholz
Views: 294,264
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (507)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I watched ww2 movies I like war movie (Action is my favorite type)

    most of them are from Hollywood,,America

    so it is America point of view.....But are German people always be BAD PEOPLE?

    So I started to looking for other point of view

  • look I know you guys are having a debate but HOLY SHIT DID YOU SEE THAT GUYS FOOT!!!!!!!!! :O

  • Here we are with them and fought

  • this is a great series! loving it, shows interesting side of such a brutal war we almost never hear about. nice to see someone made this movie.

  • what happen in the 4:10 ?

  • a very nice film!!

  • Could some one tell me if the begging man was German or Russian?

  • Responder a este vídeo... 

  • August 1914 was a tragedy for all of Western peoples.

    Russian was taken over because of this tragedy.

    If the Czar's men at the Kremlin had NOT given up hope laying down their rifles and instead fought to the man, Lennin stated their coup/revolution would have failed!

    Never give up hope. Then with the US siding with STALIN, along with LONDON go to war over POLAND, then GIVEN to THE USSR in 1945 speaks clearly.

    Admiral CANARIS played a large part in hurting Germany and he was hung in 1944.

  • August 1914 was a tragedy for all of Western peoples.

    Russian was taken over because of this tragedy.

    If the Czar's men at the Kremlin had NOT given hope laying down their rifles and instead fought to the man, Lennin stated their coup/revolution would have failed!

    Never given hope. The US siding was STALIN, and LONDON go to war over POLAND that WAS GIVEN to THE USSR in 1945 speaks for its self.

    Admiral CANARIS played a large part in hurting Germany and he was hung in 1944.

  • 48th Panzer Corps tried to break through to the Stalingrad pocket but couldn't. Entire German 4th Army was killed wounded or surrendered.

  • I think it also tries to show that not all Nazi soldiers where hartless killing machines, just like any human being they where induviduals with family of their own, who were just serving their country for the wrong reasons.

    There is no excuse of what the nazis did but when one happends to be in a country with a dictator trying to dominate europe with mad ideas which include mass mudering, its out of the hands for most common folks.

  • MAn that made me hungry

  • I think this is a movie about the dangers of winter and frostbite. thanks for uploading!

  • I think anti-German, anti-Nazi and pro-communist remarks, comments SHOULD be removed from yoru site. No free-speech for rapists and mass-murderers. Only a well-directed AK-47 ratatatatatatatatata!

  • @tiborvivi AK-47 is communist

  • @Neo9105 what u talkl bro? AK-47 is a Kalashnikov machine gun, designed by a Russian not a communist. How can be a weapoon communist , pls enlight me on this bro...

  • @tiborvivi i think he is trying to say that the weapon is made by a communist country or communist person.either way so what if its commmunist , socialist ,capitolist..it dont matter a gun is a gun.

  • @waffenss470 Yes i understand u, however the Chinese-made Kalashnikov guns are craps, they jam a lot, while the Russian-made AK-47s work great in bonecracking temperatures as well.

  • @tiborvivi yeah.each weapon is made for the standards of that specific country.i understand you to.i have 1 of each and the cinese one is crap.while mine doesnt jam alot it does not feed very well with great magazines.

  • @tiborvivi Stupid asshole

  • Was ist mit seinem Fuß passiert???

  • Hollywood put a lot of little jabs and kicks below the belt on yet another one of their movies.

    Thank you.

  • Western peoples were tragically hurt by the criminal War started by England in August 1914 for the London NYC bankers, that was our Waterloo from N.Z. to Russia!

  • @AndrielYT Germany hollywood? you fucking crazy? , this is an anti-war movie. Guess you need to be older then 12 to see that , oh wel that day wil come too for you in a few years. Fucking moron go outa here , go play outside and tell you mama that your not old enough to sit infront of the pc and watch youtube all day

  • 5:13  This is the best 1000 yard stare acting I have ever seen.

  • @Yodan82 agreed!!!

  • 6:36 Where is his socks?

  • Everytime I see these kind of movies I always cry inside myself.

  • I am from Israel. My grand father was officer in red army and survive all war from 41-45. He has never told about war and never watched movies about war. I can not imagin how many terrible things he saw during the war.

  • i have read mein kampf and i know what dreams Hitler had...

    he was a mental patient i think...

    only because of his mentality , the great german nation was destroyed....

    but the brave germans build their country again , stronger and wealthier ..

    my salute to the brave Germans !!!

  • @AK47infidel bla bla bla

  • k don't get mad at me i like germany i don't like the nazis but i like germany

  • This makes me sad.

  • I'm not antigerman, but I am antirussian because my grandfather and his brother were killed by russians.

  • @NewVahan2 my german friend's grandfather served in the ostheer at the age of 17 as a machine gunner, he gunned down over 300 soviet troops in under an hour during the battle for stalingrad, most of them never had weapons he went out to survey the battlefield and what he found were kids about the same age as him some even younger lying dead, he told me that he fell to his knee's and started crying as it was against his morales to fight and kill children every he went to the battlefield and cried

  • .... Apparently the bottom is filled with trolls...

    Meh, time to bring out a meme I guess in due time.

  • @SamPD2 What's a meme? Though people say I have no problems with the written word, I am completely RETARDED in " newspeak " Lol!

  • @Noodles37UK Look it up on ROCKETBOOM.

  • The Soviet Union and Russia won this war. German soldiers at that time was one of the best Germany has conquered almost all of Europe is practically very easily without encountering any serious resistance, and only in Russia was defeated, meeting in front of a courageous, heroic, loyal to the Motherland, not afraid of death of a Russian soldier! Glory to Russia!

  • sin duda a rusia le estamos en deuda

    todo el mundo...

  • can i get subtitles

  • Sau geil, dass du den Film hochgeladen hast, aber du hast ja einen riesigen Teil weggeschnitten...

  • I can understand a bit of german like numbers and basic stuff but I would really appreciate it if you could put on some important subtitles. just a few that can tell me what's going on in English

  • Comment removed

  • I hope that some time the day comes, where Germans aren`t Nazis for every little kid, that doesnt know anything about history, but wants to tell some sh*t.

    Guys, theese soldiers were men like everyone else. They were forced to fight and do horrible things.

    And hey, some of you are saying stuff like the Germans didnt suffer or German cities havent been destroyed. Have a look in some history books and then you will see that most of the big cities in Germany were almost completly destroyed.

  • Edgar I am a fan of your videos, and I don't want to start an argument or anything, but you seem anti-Russian. I thought you were not racist or a supporter of national socialism? Its just disrespectful, I can tell you are angry, but there is no need for talk like that.

  • @CueWunAye I tell you why. If people place anti german comments on my video's , im not going to be nice to those people but i reply with an iron fist. If some one insults my country and my people , what you think im going to do? be nice to them? hell no , im not anti anything , but as soon as some people want to fight ,i fight back. So thats why i reply with so mutch fire and facts. If people are nice to me ,i am nice to them. If people insult me , my people , my country , i fight them with fire

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    Seems fair enough to me. Personally, I am very fond of the German people. They are very kind hearted. I like them. Allthough I'm sure the Russians are very nice as well.

  • @EdgarEmigholz grow up

  • @EdgarEmigholz Reality check. THIS IS FUCKING YOUTUBE.

    This place is troll paradise. Best thing to do, ignore the fuckers.

    That is usually what I do if I have to fight with some ignorant damn twelve year old.

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    I know your feeling, if people insult me saying im chinese when i'm korean, I tend to get angry...... very angry

  • @EdgarEmigholz GREAT COMEBACK!!!...God Bless You & your family!

  • @wilatemodel Thank you very mutch! , check out my channel for more german world war two video's

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    Yes, but there are some people on the internet with no dignity. They have nothing to do so they spend their time trying to offend people and create fights. By arguing with trolls you are giving them what they want.

  • @EdgarEmigholz Except the damn war has been over for almost a century.

    Or at least will be after a few decades. Honestly, I do not understand why we humans continue to wage a "War" so to speak even though it ended after 70 plus fucking years. It's retards like those who are demeaning to the human race. Perhaps a mercy it would've been if we just screwed ourselves over with the nukes eh? But I digress. (End Rant)

  • @EdgarEmigholz Reply with an iron fist? It's only YouTube. I am proud to be German and of my heritage. But I don't really waste time with anti's. I like to be polite and mature towards them. You always come off on top with a political discussion. You also look more educated.  I also like what you say on your channel, Germans should accept there history.

  • @EdgarEmigholz .

    Your contry and my country can fuck off : )

    i dont know how many people can love a country ?

  • ich friere und fühle mit diesen männern, sogar in meinem gut geheizten zimmer... arme kerle.

  • these german bigots were killing russian women and children. so happy we have revenged 'em with 2mln of assraped german whores.

  • @mihanich listen very carefully you communist fuck , Russia lost 23,954,000 people during world war two , Germany lost 6,593,000 to 8,863,000 and fighting on more fronts , you know how that comes? because Russians are pigs and dont care about their own people. And what you say is true , Russians are raping swines because they are all to ugly to get a girlfriend. Germany humiliated the Red Army , numbers dont lie like you. Germans killed like 4 times more Russian pigs then the Russians could kil

  • @EdgarEmigholz Agreed 100%

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    Lieber Edgar, your logic doesn't add up. Are you saying that the Jerries were better people because they killed more? Is this how you evaluate the German people?

  • @runbambirun they were better soldiers , way better, and the numbers show that. And also civilized , Russian people in villages were living like it was the middle ages , German soldiers never raped children and old people , the Russians did. We were so advanced on technology , we invented the rocket , guided missiles , assault rifles , yet fighters Now stop placing stupid comments. If you compare the Russian warcrimes of FRONTLINE soldiers and compare them , yes Germans are more civilized.

  • @runbambirun No and Yes. THe Germans themselves conquered half europe, and are onky a small country. So if USA, UDssR, China, and the Rest of the World couldnt kill more than a small country with small allies like Japan and Austria + Italia, then they had better soldiers and tactics

  • @andromedarr Too much wrong with this comment to really rectify in 500 characters. For starters Germany did not face half the countries you mention until mid way through the war. When she did she lost quickly. None of Germany's allies were small either, Japan especially was a major power with a large army. 2/3rds of the US navy and half her ground forces went to the pacific until 1944. Germany's allies fielded roughly 30% of the total axis forces on the eastern front, pretty significant.

  • @Mcplkelly Japan and Italy and Germany had far smaller armys than Russia, USA and GB and China.

    The Axis hold out about 4 Years against all theese Countrys, that, except for russia, wherent weakended in 2 Years of War, with far less men, so i think the Germans where better.

    If you look at russia and USA, and Russia (today) Russia has 140.000.000 Inhabitants, and USA 310.000.000 inhabitants, Germany had 80.000.000.

  • Again you are wrong. Japan had an military of 9 million, which was larger than Great Britains Military for example. Germany fielded more army divisions than the USA and GB combined, some 300 vs 120. The US had more divisions in action against Japan than Germany until D-day. From mid 1941 until mid 1944, Germany faced Russia almost exclusively, and was defeated by Russia almost exclusively. Maybe you forget the US and British were trapped behind the English channel for most of the war.

  • @Mcplkelly I dont know the exact numbers....

    But England and AMerica didnt watch the fight between R and G without doing anything...Germany was bombed excessively during this time, weakening Germanys Factorys, and so on.

    And Russia is far bigger than Germany...

    But what i know is, that Russia lost far more men than Germany, maybe the US and england too, it was far bloodier on the allied side than at the Axis side...

  • @andromedarr The Allied bombing raids did not come into their own until middle of 1944. More bombs were dropped after d-day than before by the Allied air forces. Bombing was only really effective for the last 10 months of the war.

    Russia is bigger than Germany, but by the end of 1941 50% of Russia's population was in German controlled territory, meaning its population advantage was not that great until it began liberating its territory in late 1943.

  • @andromedarr Russian losses were higher than the German ones for most of the war. However this ignores several facts. The Russians were more than capable of inflicting larger losses on the Germans, as in Bagration, Lvov and Romania in 1944. Also Stalin felt he was in a race with the west, the Russians accepted heavy losses in order to get as much territory as possible from the Germans per operation. Had the Red Army been more casualty conscious, losses would have been much less.

  • @Mcplkelly Ya, right.

  • @andromedarr And half the US popuilation is now made up of illegal immigrants.....who hate the US. It's like having a 5th column within your country.

  • @Mcplkelly Actually, I think the Japanese can be blamed for losing WWII for the Axis. First of all, Japan did not declare war on Russia, as per the agreement. And second of all, the Japanese did not know how to use their submarines like the Germans...and she lost her naval war, with Battleships that dwarfed every other nations's including the the US and Germany. Japan had a chance to reproduce Tiger Tanks, V1 rockets and she failed...and that left Germany isolated.

  • Germany carries a lot of blame, not just Japan. For starters Germany never informed Japan about the non-agression pact with the USSR in 1939, and than never informed Japan that they would break it in 1941. Japan had already committed to going to war against the US/British/Dutch by June 1941 when Germany went to war against the USSR, and Germany never did ask for assistance until 1943.

    Unlike the Allied powers who cooperated heavily, the axis powers rarely did.

  • @EdgarEmigholz It's a shame they didn't rape your mother, you soulless german bastard. Maybe that would teach you a lesson of compassion. The fact is we won the war, we won the war against a stronger opponent. You should be praising us for not exterminating your population like your kind did to ours. My grandparents were thrown into gaswagen, and it left my mother and 2 of her sisters to be orphans. 1 sister died, another was raped by german serviceman and commited suicide.

  • @russianinja2008 Well the kept an P38 pistol at home , she would first kill 6 Russian pigs and save the last bullet for herself. America won the war, without America , Russia would be wasteland now. We had beter quality men and weapons but at the end of the war it was a 10 : 1 ratio in men and material , so stronger opponent? dont think so. Your family deserved it , should all have been raped and killed. Still 23,954,000 other Russian werent so lucky , they got what they deserved.

  • @EdgarEmigholz Shut up, Britain won the war. America didn't join till 1943. They like to take credit and be big headed. You are a dickhead. If ur famiy were killed. U wouldn't be makin these vids. You little basterd. I ain't anti german but i ain't exactly happy with what they did. I am more anti american than german anyway.

  • @TheSpecOpsAirsoft1 Easy when you talk to me, what did England do until 1943? Only front was Africa and before they got American supplies Rommel was beating em. In 1940 Britisch Army was humiliated by the Germans , Brittian could only survive with American help. You are a dickhead for not knowing history and thinking you can be tough on the internet, None of my family died during the war , but my fathers stories made me make a tribute channel. So go back to school and stop playing with toy guns.

  • @EdgarEmigholz what a fool you are yes we had to have the help of the U.S and others ,,,,,the germans did not only start the war thy also had a lot of help from others ..as for being humiliated i dont recall england being taken or surrendering there country in 1945 ....do you ...fucking tool

  • @TheSpecOpsAirsoft1 Hate to break it to you but Britain didn't stand a chance without America.

  • @HowDumb they did they beat Italian and German Forces at El-Alamein the closest thing to being american in africa was the Sherman tank and the Brits sunk the bismarxk and fought in the pacific too... am Half British and Half german so What the heck XD

  • @russianinja2008 I am sorry to hear about the horrible things that happened to your family. I am an Armenian and war hasn't hurt Armenia although I had family members fought and killed in war. That being said, however, I believe that most Germans are decent people now and learned their lesson. There is no necessity to be provoked. Our generation has to learn to live in peace.

  • @russianinja2008 I agree with you. I have feelings for the people that had family members killed and the germans did actually kill women and children in villages and burnt down their houses and what's the point n denying that germans did rape russian women. I can understand why some people are anti-german but I am not even though my british grandfather was held down by german snipers.

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    Hey, Edgar, I was born in the USSR. My grandfather killed 300 Nazi German soldiers in one battle. True, you killed 23-27 million people of which only 10 million were soldiers. That means, that the Nazi Germany has committed a Genocide - nothing to be proud of. Soviets killed and raped innocent German civilians too (nothing to be proud of) but the extent was a much smaller one. Had the USSR wanted, Germany would not exist today. But our generation needs to learn with peace...

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    (continuing from the previous post). Our generation has to learn to live in peace. If you hadn't enough, go on, attack Russia again and see what happens. But I'm sure most of today's Germans are very decent people and learned the lesson of war. As to a girlfriend, I, myself not being a Russian, would prefer a Russian girlfriend over a German one any day.

  • @mihanich shut up you fucking noob ou know nohting about history germany only lost about 5 million people totaly russian lost 20 million xD and even russian maked the same

  • was hat der typ am fuß?

  • i hate it how people say we waited till the german army was exuasted well wrong we fought the germans out of france and led the invations o the western front and liberated france lol i dont think the germans was exuasted at all when we first invaded they was only exuasted on the eastern front which america had nothing to do with and we onley went to war because japan attacked pearl harbor and then we declared war o them which led germany declarin o us cus they was axis allies comm me if im wrong

  • @KillYouForFood US had to fight like against 20% of the German Army. In a 1 on 1 US army wouldent stand a change against the fighing will and superior weapons of the German Army , had the war progressed into 1946/1947 Germany would be able to drop atombombs on every city in the world ,the skies would be cleared by jet fighters. Thanks to SS-Colonel Werner Von Braun US was able to fly to the moon ,if Germany wasent to superior in its development the world would still fly in propeller planes

  • @EdgarEmigholz its not firpower itsalso overwhelming numbers and skills of the fighter which both sides had but americans had way more numbers and was pretty good in skills btw we had atom bombs first so guess what that means we bomb germany first so we would hit the german heart if it was 1-1 and how did the germans lose on the eastern front? lots of russians and also US was one of the ones with the most supureier navey around the time especially if we was able to beat japan germ lose in lots

  • @KillYouForFood lol bro you are soooo off

  • @EdgarEmigholz and thats just my friendly oppinion so please no argueing

  • @KillYouForFood if dont want to argue about your dumb and incorrect oppinion and false facts , what a fact is that in late 1945 Germany would have had an Atom bomb aswel , so you may be pleased that New York is not a waste land now.

  • @EdgarEmigholz the issue with a german atom bomb is the delivery system even the v2 rocket didnt have enough range to hit new york and the Kreigsmarine would not have been able to get past the U.S. navy.

  • @diggman88 If you look at some of the prototype german yet planes it would be possible to drop an atom bomb om moscow/new york, late 45 , early 46. There was no asnwer against the yet fighters , the skies would be filled with yet planes. If you look at some of the prototypes they stil look modern today! Like the flying wing , a German design. The Germans were planning long range yet bombers , but it was too late. But late 45 early 46 it would have been a diffrent story

  • @EdgarEmigholz I agree with you, without Germany, many techological innovations would have either not been invented.

  • Die menschliche Natur, die in extremen Situationen auftreten.

    Der Film ist nicht Nazi in das menschliche Drama.

  • CoD has nothing on this

  • @fainyance11 how the fuck would it anyway ?

  • wie heißt das lied bei 7:15

  • Go To My Channel , The Entire Movie Is Re-Uploaded In Beter Quality!

  • Otto is the best actor! 

  • wanna fuck me com and meet me in 1 week berlin i front of spandau rathaus

  • @Tristan0904 yeah how about i kick your gay ass infront of the spandau rathaus?

  • When I first saw this movie... I loved this part :P... Where they found food at least

  • Nur mal so als Hinweis der heist G Edgar Micholz also Gefreiter Micholz.

    G ist die DG abk..

  • Will you all stop fucking argueing I swear to jesus christ if this doesnt stop, I will get EdgarEmigholz to remove every dumb comment that makes a peron sound like hes whining like a little fucking child, so STOP ARGUEING.

  • dankeee süperrrr film danke für hochladen

  • Hitler should have finish his job. Now all the black and Jewish guys insult us but we can't say them back because it's inappropriate.

  • @RuugaQ

    ...What? You wouldn't happen to be running around shouting "Heil Hitler!" would you? I don't see why a black or Jewish person would have any reason to make fun of you for being German unless you were a staunch neo-nazi.

  • I think the Hitler was the mad and the General Börman or what was him name...and then Goebbels war MAAAD!

    And then ***tapo!

    Not the soldiers

  • Excellent movie! This one express a reality about german soldiers, not like Hollywood shit loves to do!

    I hope german people do more movies about your history, your own people! Not Hollywood with your nazi actors (Only germans nazi are the bad guys in WW2, but and Hiroshima and Nagasaki... a lot of innocent people vaporized?).

    Cheers to German!

    Coffin to Hollywood!

  • sait vrai tous se que vous dite tous ceux qui on combatu pour l allmangne pandent la gerre n'etai pas forsement nazi ait surtou quil n'avai pas le choi soit il tuer soi il se faiser tuer et si il ne vouler pas faire la guerre hitler les foutai au ploton d'execution

  • @Sereniama I forgot, the Russians too. They never wanted to head to Stalingrad. But it was ordered... and if they didn't comply, you're head gets shot.

  • ich find das das viodo nur zeig das die deutschen soldaten gute kämpfer waren

  • @ualuegamer zie wierem hitzer allklien die warz achtun weirem mechsti volksen juden.

  • this movie is bullshit, it makes the nazis look like the good guys!

  • @Yorsefener yeah and your comment shows what a moron you are, in war there are no good or bad guys like in your american cowboy movies yeah?, this movie shows a group of german soldiers , not nazi , who are trying to survive a hell called stalingrad. an american army whould have already surrenderd when the first snow fell

  • @EdgarEmigholz My grandfather always said Germans are ethier at your throat or at your feet.

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    I think it's fair to say that the Nazis were the bad guys.

  • @2210ethan The winners write history, nazi were bad , but not worse then stalin or roosevelt, the warcrimes of the so called heroes are being forgotten or like they dont matter, warcrimes from atomic bombs on cities to rape and murder in berlin 1945 after the war in berlin. There wasent a Neurenberg trial for russian rapers or murderes?, stalin wasent hanged for crimes against humanity? so i thinks it fair they were all bad guys, it doesent matter how many you have killed, its all just terrible

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    Totally disagree. Obviously Stalin was a monster, no better than Hitler, but the Western Allies were totally different, and any suggestion of parity is -to my mind- infamous. The atomic bombs saved lives.

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    germany started it.

    and if japan had been invaded as apose to an atomic bomb more people would have died on both sides.

  • @EdgarEmigholz , I agree! I posted two clips: Roumanian armee Stalingrad 1942 and Roumanian Armee 1942 - The Don Bend . They are sin 1942! At the Don Bend river 11 000 germans were in the 3rd Roumanian Armee Front Sector. They together with 12 000 roumanian troops have been encircled in Stalingrad. At Staligrad fought, on the german side, soldiers from 32 countries!

  • @2210ethan If you look at it yourway, SS, Gestapo, and Nazi party members were the "bad guys". This is the regular troops who where drafted or joined on there own. So they are not the "bad guys". And if we still look at your way the SS was responsible for the Holocaust. Ordered by the Nazi party. And when your in a situation like this, its all about survival even if they are good or bad.

  • @CueWunAye

    Well, it wasn't only the SS that was responsible for the holocaust. Some Germans had the courage to resist Hitler.

  • @2210ethan

    Lol only a fucking idiot thinks there are good and bad guys in this world.

  • @CoeurGermanique

    The good guys were the ones who didn't commit genocide. Hope this helps.

  • @2210ethan so there are no good guys because they all committed genocide, americans , russians , germans they all did

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    When did the Allies commit genocide in WW2?

    Stalin certainly murdered huge numbers of his own people, and I definitely don't see the Red army as 'The Good guys' but I think it's fair to say that Brit/commonwealth/US forces are owed a great debt, and were certainly not guilty of genocide in WW2.

  • @2210ethan Not in World War Two , but i call the murder of the orginal people of the USA a genocide , and when the Americans came to Europe to 'Liberate' Europe from the Nazi's , black people did not even had the same rights as white people in America, talking about a free world and liberating Europe , its a joke its because they wanted the power in Europe ,

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    The Black civil rights movement reflects poorly on the US, but to suggest some kind of equivalence with Nazism is absurd. Many black Americans volunteered to serve their imperfect country because they knew what Fascism was, just as Indians volunteered in huge numbers to serve the people who colonized them.

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    The Black civil rights movement reflects poorly on the US, but to suggest some kind of equivalence with nzism is absurd. Many black Americans volunteered to serve their imperfect country because they knew what ascism was, just as Indians volunteered in huge numbers to serve the people who colonized them.

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    Whilst black Americans have been poorly treated by their own country, I think it's a stretch to say that that makes the fight against Fascism hypocritical!

    many black Americans volunteered to serve their imperfect country against the (far,far) greater evil, just as millions of Indians volunteered to serve the country that colonized them.

  • @2210ethan So did many people from Europe volunteered the fight on the Eastern Front in the Waffen SS. The Americans did not fight for freedom , the fought for control of Europe , and they still are doing it in the Middle East , the war in the Middle East is not about freedom , its about power and control. For many black Americans going to fight was beter then sitting home. And it's what you call Evil , Stalin greastest massmurderer of all times , wye dident you liberated Russia aswell?

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    Stalin was almost as bad as Hitler, and for a time it did look as if Britain would go to war against the Nazi-Soviet alliance, but that's not how it ended up.

    Comparing the men who volunteered to fight fascism with SS volunteers is, to my mind, obscene. The US has never been interested in Europe and had to be persuaded on their eventual 'Germany First' policy with some difficulty. Middle East is a different conversation.

  • @2210ethan No, USA always have been interested in Europe , wye did the come in WW1 then? because Germany wasent allowed to have power in Europe , America wanted the power in Europe. They did not had to be persuaded they just waited till the German army was exhausted against the Russian Army , so they would face light resistance ,America couldent take on Germany alone, thats wye German held out so long. They did the same thing as in WW1 ,wait till Germany is exhausted, en then take the power

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    WW1- Submarine warfare.

    WW2- Pearl Harbor.

    And the German army was far from exhausted in December 1941.

    And after both wars the US showed (or wanted to show) magnanimity to the defeated powers. Look at the Marshall Plan, they rebuilt Europe.

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    WW1- Submarine warfare

    WW2- Pearl Harbor.

    Hope this helps.

    The US had to be persuaded in its 'Germany First' Policy.

    After both wars they showed greater magnanimity than their allies.

  • @2210ethan WW1 - Submarine warfare is American propaganda , like saddam hussein has weapons of massdestruction so we need to invade Iraq , but everybody knows its because the USA wants control of the Middle East and its oil. What does Pearl Harbor has to do with Germany? , and wye dident they invaded in 1942? , wye did all of Europe had to 'suffer' for 2 more years. You are believing in propaganda. America still have Army Bases in Europe? wye? we need em? no because they want to rule the world

  • @EdgarEmigholz

    Germany Declared war on the US on December 11, 1941. It was a direct result of the attack on Pearl Harbor by the Japanese. The US declaration of war with Germany was a response to Germany's declaration.

    Get your facts straight.

  • @pcc68 US would declare war on Germany anytime soon , so it wasent a big shoke for US , because they were already supplieing the russian and brtisch army. And who declared war on Germany? , France and England after the attack on Poland, wye dident they declared war on Russia? , Russia invaded Poland togheter with Germany. In WW1 US declared war on Germany , so they would have done in WW2 , because US wants to rule to world. I know my facts smartass , studied history and world war two.

  • @EdgarEmigholz you don't know your history, you make subjective statements you want to be true about the US motives in Europe but they aren't based on any facts.  They us always had an isolationist policy and wanted to be left out. Only when drawn or convinced to join did we. Not like we are going to jump in day one when we are on the other side of the planet. Grow up.

  • @Trenz73 then explain Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan, Iraq thats not on the other side of the world? Also countries they wanted the rule , dident work out very well tough. And how is this not a fact that US still has army bases in europe since 1944? , isent it clear to you that US wants to rule the world? US doesent join anything , they started in Korea , Vietnam Afghanistan and Iraq.

  • @EdgarEmigholz you easlily forget the situations that create these wars to fulfill you own agenda and suppositions. You seem bent on blaming the US for all the worlds problems... i wont likely change your mind, but for someone who claims to understand history... you are limiting yourself with your own bias and your statements carry less weight... you're more of a propagandist than a historian

  • @Trenz73 And what else then Power should America search for in Europe? , cant be recourses because America already got everything , wye did the Americans joined World War Two , and wye would they fight thousends of miles away from home. They rule the world and to take over countries , they did in 1944 and they are still doing it , and that are facts , because could you name some facts wye did America come to war? ofcourse America doesent want us to know , but a clear mind can see right trough it

  • @Trenz73 might be hard for you to understand, but a lot of had to do with principle and that it was the right thing to do... considering we were attacked by Japan and all our alliances (as the Nazis) would dictate the domino effect... same thing happened in WWI with the European powers... your conjecture on America just wanting power is pure BS.

  • @Trenz73 Principle sure , America the world police since 1917. So America has to invade every country if the principle is right? You got to be kidding me ,war is big buissnes , the war factory's mad big profits ,US just did not wanted that Germany would rule Europe , wich they would have twice now if US stayed where they belong. Humans never do something out of principle , he always search for profit. Iraq is not a principle, they admitted it! , because Sadam was dangerous they said ,its the oil

  • @EdgarEmigholz you have a very cynical view of how things work. If America really wanted to get into WW2 just for profit, they wouldn't have waited to be attacked to do so. They would have just joined the fight. Believe it or not, the choice of sending hundreds of thousands of men to their deaths weighed heavily on the politicians who sent them. You'll believe what you want just because you want to believe Germany had a moral leg to stand on... which they didn't.

  • @Trenz73 When would you attack? , when the enemy is strong or when the enemy is weak? , America waited 3 years to invade Europe , because German army was already very weak in that stage , they just cowardly waited till the German army was weak and they attacked , if they invaded in 1941 or 1942 it would have been a humaliation on the beaches. They dident expacted so many deaths , the war should have been over in late 1944 according to the Yanks , but they underestimated the German will to fight

  • @EdgarEmigholz Nonsense. After Dunkirk, there was no Western Front. When America did get involved it had to mobilize. They started in North Africa because they were unsure of their fighting capability then took on Italy to find a way into Europe. The eastern front didn't truly open up for the Russians until the Germans had to move divisions westward to fight after Normandy. England was just as much out of the war militarily until D-Day. The build up and planning wasn't rash, but planned.

  • @Trenz73 Dunkirk was in 1940 , America wasent even in the war then. Americans just waited as long as they could , mobilizing doesent take 3 years. They just waited until the German Army was exhausted , because they knew if they would fight against the Germany army full strenght they wouldent stand a change , and even in 1944 America sufferd enormous against the weakend German Army. Italy wasent the way into Europe , they just wanted Italy out of the war. On D-Day US army was still in Italy!

  • @EdgarEmigholz no Montgomery created operation market garden to end the war by christmiss 

  • @2210ethan

    The americans did not commit genocide ?

    Tell that to the Indians you destroyed, the vietnamiese villagers you burned with napalm, the japanese whose cities you wiped off the map !

    Not to mention plans to reduce Germany to rubble and wipe off its population after WW2...

    Americans are the worst hypocrites ! At least the soviets killed you but told you they were gonna do it first !

  • @CoeurGermanique That is true , great comment thx!

  • @EdgarEmigholz I agree with your comment but us americans wouldnt have quit. we would have just bitched and wined about the cold.