Added: 2 years ago
From: StateofSeptember
Views: 13,783
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (166)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • thats ausome 

  • this song is just awesome

  • You could sing a little stronger :) but seeing this video is quite older so yeah XD

  • the vocalist is too sloOww!!

  • Scream scream this song is not fit for you

    if wont scream :[

  • umm..."I wont explain,or say I'm sorry.I'm unashamed I'm gonna show my scar.Give me a cheer for all the broken.Listen here,cause this is who we are." ....That part was missing I think. O.o...

  • the singer NEEDS TO SCREAM!!!!!! NOT SOFT!

  • Is the Drummer a girl??

  • Too slow work on it

  • I enjoyed that and gave it an applause at the end .welldone guys good attempt

  • It was actually really good, but the singer needs to be a little more creative haha hes singing like a robot. sing off note every once in a while, be unique...

  • Even with just 3 tom drums, this is the best band cover I've seen. Keep it up.

  • The guitarist on the left is great (: x

  • OMG! Great Job!! Keep going! :D

    Very Talented :D

  • drummer started a little late i think

  • Swagg

  • wow singer was great just lacks a little energy

    

  • Loved it all besides the singer. He's still young though, there's plenty of room for improvement.

  • I don't like the voice, but he's still young...

  • 'When I was a young boy...' YOU'RE STILL YOUNG.

  • the drummer is wrong it's completely messed up

  • @FacePlant34 I only had 3 tom drums cause it's a cheap drumset, not 4 tom drums like MCR. So i had to adapt the all fills etc because I didn't have enough toms to play the original version, so of course it sounds different.

  • @StateofSeptember dont even say its cheap bc of only 3. many sets cost more that are just bass and two small toms.

  • @FacePlant34 wtf r u talking about everything i hear was PERFECT!

  • @FacePlant34 Dont be ignorant. its a 3 tom drumset

  • Winder who the 11 year old....it's the one player the guitar isn't it?

  • Besides the tempo, this is incredible

  • One day I'm gonna make a better MCR cover than this, and you will all look up at me.

    but that's going to take a VERY long time, lol.

  • THIS KID IS GREAT! YOU MAKE MCR PROUD!

  • Awesome cover. Nice song choice btw :)

  • Screw all the hater man, this is awesome. :DDD could use the back up vocals though xD

  • Screw all the hater man, this is awesome. :DDD

  • sooooooooooo gooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­od

  • really good singer must just flow more >.<

  • You kids are incredible. Keep it up guys. Don't let the haters bring you down.

  • Good Job. This is awesome.

  • R u guys Mormon

  • It was good but the singer needs to learn how the song gos if Ur gona cover a song do it exactly

  • WOW! This is unfuckinbelieveble!!!!!!!!!! I just fel in love with you!!! xD

  • That's cool! We've got a female drummer too and she's badass!

    Great Cover!!!

  • You'll need an older vocalist to pull of gerard ways music. But everything else was great

  • That boy sounds like me when I sing this!And I'm a girl!

  • AWWWWWWW that little boy at the begginning ruuuules

    ah, we will hear of him in the future

  • the boy's voice is great

  • The singer is also lacking the edge that Gerard has when he sings. He still did good, he just needs to have his voice mature.

  • Okay cover, but the singer was trying to sing it too much like pop and needs to have his voice mature. He did well though.

  • I think the cover it's ok, let me see, I think the drums should be played with more energy, the lead guitar player rocks, and the voice of the kid I think it gives a "pop touch" to the song, and it's interesting how the song changes with that.

    P.D. sorry for my english if it's not ok

  • You have an amazing voice dude! C:

  • i like the mix of ages. really shows great cooperation. quite refreshing actually

  • its a little slow when he sings at the beginning

  • @12345MISSalice if you do a cover you should at least make it sound like the original song. this band just needs to stick to writing their own stuff instead of making other bands stuff sound bad.

  • you pronounce everythig so clearly!! :) This is quite good! :)

    watch?v=XGXpJvucju0&list=PLDD8­8AFC73279A7EB

  • fucking amazing!

  • so awesome ! great job !

  • the awkward moment when he sings about being a young boy, when he clearly is about 12...

  • the sound of the cymbals sucks (: BUT, actually a good cover (:

  • u need an older singer

  • @12345MISSalice Cheers. Thanks for the positive feedback. :)

  • go away beiber..

    

  • nice cover but cmon its mcr how r u not running around going absolutly insane at least headbang or somthing!

  • I like it.

  • embarassing amps..

  • BIEBER?!?!?!?

  • Good, if the singer was stronger wouldve been perfect. But it develops with age, but after his voice changes might be impossible to sing.

  • would've been better with a different drummer.. gawd.

  • i like it, but....... i could totally sing better than that kid. It would sound pretty wrong though, since I'm a girl......

  • Great cover :) but tbh the singer just doesn't have the screemo voice..... yet :)

  • ohhhhhhhhhh he said damned!!!

  • Oh look, it's justing bieber with a neck tie covering McR ^^

  • oh dear!!! I know people probably say 'you are really good' but you lot play this song better than mcr do live

  • It was slow, pop-ish and no one moved.. i mean you need more feeling and move around a little bit... BUT i really liked it, they sound really good, the lead singer's voice rocks!! Keep rockin'

  • to slow

  • sorry guys but kinda look like posers

  • He took it from a rock song to a Maria Carry song. Good Lord.

  • I dont see why people are saying this sucks, its pretty good and that 11 year old has balls.

  • way off on the lyrics

  • I agree with the closer thing but hes only 11 you cant expect him to be leaping round the stage :D GOOD JOB!!

  • it lacks confidencee, people that do covers focus on perfecting it but they forget about the style very good thoo, singer needs to break outa comfort zone and everyone needs to be a lil closer with ea other

  • The lead guitarist executed perfectly

  • YEAH!!! u rock!!! xD

  • The way he just changes verse to verse proves that having Ray as a back up singer is a very good idea.

  • nice .. but the singer was ...  ...

  • yo singer ur still a young boy so the is no need to say when i was a young boy wow haha

  • ok when i refer to the band, i refer to the performance

    you play very good, but your perform is GARBAGE!

  • this is MCR's song not high school musicals

  • GOD! perfect sound

    but the band???????? they are garbage

  • @MsYukote How can you say the band are garbage but the sound is perfect, when the band is the one making the so called "perfect sound"?!?

  • @StateofSeptember  they mean the sound quality FUCK!

  • @StateofSeptember i see what u mean

    he most likely means the quality

  • @StateofSeptember I believe hes is trying to say MCR is bad but who the fuck cares what he's trying to say you guys are tight!

  • @MsYukote dude you can go jump off a bridge. really. who cares if they aren't the best in the world? if you ask me, they're off to a good freaking start.

  • @MsYukote dude... I'd LOVE to see you get up there and do better..

  • I think the singer is great i think its the best ive seen?

  • no offense but is that justin beiber singing?

  • its pretty good but he is singing too slow at the beginning.

  • vocals have no emotion but hey not bashing on the kid

    good cover 

  • "dekamated"

    :|

  • junior mcr..

  • the singer.. Wicked props to that dude.

  • bad drumming,.

  • I thought it was JUSTIN BIEBER singing!! haha LMAO

  • Not bad for so young! The vocalist didnt really seem to put his heart into the song... but amazing for eleven!! and the rest of the band did a great job too! keep up the good work! ^^ <3

  • is he gay?

  • the singer needs some more practice to get the beginning right. other than that the sound from the band itself was amazing. good job

  • it would of been better of if the 11 year old put his 11 year old energy into and got into the song and moved around some XD

  • the singer went for a classical tone in the song he couldn't get the rock sound goin on the band was great but the singers voice seemed a little robotic

  • OMFG JUSTIN BIEBER I WANNA RAPE HIM

  • very good the singer and the cover...

    i didnt like very much the drums..

  • way to slow at the beging

    

  • lol.... I want a singer like that.... = [ ... so bad....... dudes gotan amaisin voice for an 11 year old ^.^ i was insanely impressed

  • great!

  • wtf ?? he's to slow !!

  • Whoa! Thats an awesome stage u got there! Howd u get the background?

  • Realize these kids are from New Zealand, so the accent might make it sound weird, since Gerard doesn't have one.

  • What's up with your singer stamping?

  • @Wolf2008lllll Ahh he was 11 actually :)

    He was a last minute ring in because all the other [older] people we tried couldn't pull off some of the notes as it goes pretty high in the vocal line.

  • @StateofSeptember it was great as previously said in many comments, but the kid needs to pick his tempo up, the notes arent all quarter notes. but good

  • Nice cover, but you guys have to move arround alot more

  • the singer sang some words for too long and some of the tunes he sang were wrong

  • The way he says city :L plus the timing of the words in the intro are all wrong

  • really good.much better than most of the covers for this songs, just try to move around some on stage

  • this is awesome. i like the fact that they do it in their own style but stay true to the original. HUGE potential. welldone!

  • pretty damn good

    the intro was a bit slow

    remember that for next time

    also the singer could improve

  • @skateETF666 haha hes like 4

  • pahahah :L

  • they were good but the drummer needed to work on it alittle. the kids voice was good , but i dont think its just right for that song. but over all 4 out 5 starrs not bad

  • was it just me or did the singers voice seem robotic? idk that what ruined it for me :/

    good instrumentals though i guess

  • It could be because he accents the word on the first beat of every bar in a lot of the song? Just a maybe though.

  • @StateofSeptember Well....by doing that his tempo is pretty precise...ha ha. He's so cute.

  • Drummer wasn't great... didn't play all the guitar parts, the singer was to soft, nobody moved, the drumer is playing really... soft ._.''. Drummer forgot all the fills o.e'' Nobody looked like they cared. Any of those ruin it for you? Ruined it for me.

  • the singer WILL be great, all of his problems will easily be mended by time, he was indeed a little pitchy and this song it almost too low for him. other than that, good luck to you all, great cover

  • What an angel voice! :3

    But the drummer needs to work on his/her drumkit.

  • HER. And i just got a new drum kit a week ago, a waaaay better sounding one - loving it :)

  • (Y)

  • Huh? What does (Y) mean??

  • Thumps up, try it on MSN.

  • @StateofSeptember (Y) = "thumbs up" :P try it on msn xD

  • @StateofSeptember It's a thumbs up.. Lol  (MSN)

  • @StateofSeptember thumbs up

  • wow! that was amazing!

    good job!

  • Wow...the singer is awsome. Tell him I say congrats, He should stick with it

  • the singer is pretty good, how old is he? cuz if hes young he better keep going

  • He's 11. :)

  • hes great for his age than!!

  • its like the singer has sum sort of tourettes syndrome.  But he's good for his age and only 2 days practicing with the band.

    lead guitar, leave this band and join a better one because you have talent

    drummer-garbage

  • it was pretty good. Except wtf is the singer doing with his foot. He was probably nervous .But still. Its ticking me off. :p

    good job though.

  • 0:36

    he still IS a young boy. fail :D

  • Haha i'd never thought about the lyrics much when he sung them. Crack up.lol

  • wow,that was pretty cool guys, the drummer need morepractice, and the singer was a little young, but pretty cool

  • the tempo is to slow

  • singing and drums r very meh

  • Yeah, the singing is iffy, but the drumming sucks ass.

  • why is everyone saying the singer sucks? the drums are what need the most work...

  • Just to put it out there, the singer actually only joined us two days before the auditions, so not a bad effort considering.

  • singer sucks, lead guitar is good drums are good.

  • singer should stop singing soon. otherwise, it was okay

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more