Added: 3 years ago
From: Bergstaller01
Views: 32,045
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (128)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i'm thinkin and the only thing i can come up with is they got damn good noise cancelling headsets and they're forgot they're flying an RG. thats the only thing i can think of.

  • Beep! Beep! Beep! Beep! Beep!

    I'm just saying.

  • You can't feather a prop on a single. Beep, beep, beep... A side from not using checklists, these guys must be deaf.

  • You can't feather the prop on c172rg guy

  • @incidlt no, this would have caused extensive damage to the aircraft, at bare minimum they would have had fuselage and structural damage, I didn't see a prop strike, but if there was, the engine would most probably been replaced or at least removed and extensively tested. This looks like a plain and simple mistake on the part of the pilots the beeping sounds like a gear warning, if they had had a gear failure they would have shut down the engine and feathered the prop (to stop it spinning) to p

  • could it be some kind of practice maybe?

  • The landing gear warning happens when ever your motor goes below a certain rpm (depending on the plane) and your gear is still up. it can come on at really random times so it gets to become just like back ground noise, you forget its on.

  • Actually i dont think it was aircraft fail because pilots should shut down the engines before a landing like that.

  • Think GUMP. Gas, Undercarriage, Mixture and Props. :)

  • landing gear warning horn beeping and you and failure to read before landing checklist and you still land gear up. You are an idiot of a pilot, I hope you never fly again.

  • @gypsykingg Wow, if you read the description, you'd find out that this is not my personal video......

    Just sayin'

  • @Bergstaller01 he mad

  • @gypsykingg Shut up.

  • Has anyone figured that maybe the landing gear failed to come down, and the pilots did what they could to compensate?

  • @Bergstaller01 If that was true, they would have shut down the engine short final because if the engine is still on, it takes a lot more damage from a prop strike than if it was shut down. Second, you can pull the circuit breaker and shut off the alarm if you know the alarm/landing gear are U/S.

  • @Bergstaller01 Funnily enough i thought the self same thing. I mean its not a thing which u are likely to forget

  • "what's that alarm for??"  "idk it's probably not important"

  • @DiamondPilotDan the alarm beeps to tell us that the gear is up!!!!1

  • @Saahil2910 i know, it was sarcasm. i was pointing out that the Gear up alarm was kind of hard to ignore but they still managed to do it

  • Lol "Whats that beeping?" *lands* "Ohhhh..."

  • lol i think the sound beep beep beep means >>the gear you idiot<<!!

  • did you not hear the warning sound? loser, clearly did not do downwind checks.

  • Any chance you remember the tail number? If so, would you post it?

  • Look at the instructor's cute little bomber jacket...he must think he's such a good pilot.

  • but what about the alarm? i don´t think he forgot to drop the gear down... there was a failure?

  • That idiot can't fly. Many mistakes over and over. That is the kind of GA pilot in USA now. Wonder why these planes pilots are so hard to insure?

  • It's very unlikely that they forgot the gear, especially with the blaring configuration warning. Come on get real. Where's the source for this video? The real story? I suspect that this was the result of a mechanical failure and the pilot had no choice.

  • @Arrowhead2k1 If this was the result of a mechanical failure and the gear-up was anticipated, then the pilot should have shut down the fuel flow, and the door should have been opened before touchdown. Noise cancelling headphones, combined with poor cockpit discipline could have caused them to miss the gear horn.

  • @CounterCultureLives I still don't really buy it. They appeared to make an emergency short final wihch indicates a problem (Either that or they were simulating an engine failure). Your theory is sound though, and such a thing could have very well happened. It's hard to accurately assess the situation from this video alone however. So again, where's the REAL story or incident report?

  • @Arrowhead2k1 They do, in fact, appear to be making an emergency short final. I suppose they might have been simulating an engine failure, but they wouldn't deliberately leave the gear up and damage the plane in the name of a training exercise. (unless they were training to become JetBlue or Colgan pilots!! ;o) ) So, if this was a training exercise, there were still factors of pilot error. On the other hand, if this was a genuine emergency, there were still factors of pilot error.

  • What happened to their G.U.M.P.S. procedure? Gas, UNDERCARRIAGE, mixture, props, seat belts. Very simple procedure to perform.

  • It happens all the time. I doubt this was staged, very dangerous and expensive.

  • Forget the height of the approach, you're telling me that WITH that gear warning alarm he didn't notice?!

  • I think these guys were practising a forced landing after an engine failure and got so used to the gear horn going and were concentrating so hard on positioning the aircraft for the landing that they just plain forgot to dangle the Dunlops at the appropriate time.

  • twas done on purpose. notice they did not react?

  • I am thinking this has been a staged wheels up landing. I can understand maybe forgetting if you were IFR in bad weather conditions but the pilots don't seem to be shocked when they hit the ground.

  • configuration warning!!!!!!

  • there are 2 kinds of pilots operating retracted gear airplanes. The ones who already had a gear up landing ... and the ones who will.

  • How would you forget to put the landing gear down? Did they notice notice the annoying alarm? lol

  • That was a very expensive noise...

  • Neither they had hydraulic issues nor gear malfunction. I think those pilots do not know what CRM is. And please don't think CRM is only useful for big airliners: This stupid and really embarrassing situation is only because of a bad CRM, or even a NO CRM.

  • were they drunk?

  • Lol ! Didn't you notice the gear warning sound ?

  • um .... beep beep beep beep beep beep beep .... thats not the stall horn

  • failed

  • Let's see the gear horn is going off, NO GUMPS CHECK!!!! TOTAL DUMB ASS WHO DOESN'T NEED TO BE IN THE LEFT SEAT WITH AN INCOMPOTENT INSTRUCTOR!!!!! MORONS!

  • @AcepilotC172 before you shoot your mouth off hotrod how about you learn the story first.

  • @navyocs --there is NO EXCUSE for a gear up landing. SERIOUSLY!!!! Are you the MORON flying it or did I just tell you the TRUTH about your so called flying skills Moron.

  • @AcepilotC172 well how about a gear malfunction.  if you loose the pressure in the lines, then you wouldn't even be able to hand pump the gear down, but the gear warning horn would still be going off because of the flaps and the manifold pressure. wow what an ace pilot you are, NOT!!!

  • @navyocs More then likely the cause of the loss of pressure is because the hydraulic fluid was low or even out. Per the POH on the airplane, the PIC is responsible to check to see how much hydraulic fluid is in the hydraulic fluid resivour. So again, IT IS STILL PILOT ERROR because of failure to perform a required pre-flight check on the aircraft.

  • @AcepilotC172 well from my experience things don't always happen per the POH, and also the hydraulic fluid resivoir is only required to be checked every 25 hours. yes it is pilot error and it probably was a stupid ass bunch of pilots that landed this thing gear up. however there is always a side of a story that you don't know so maby you shouldn't be so judgmental. i'm pretty sure that you could forget the gear too, after doing a steep spiral and the horn has been sounding for five minutes.

  • DUMB ASS!

  • i bet they're pissed, lolz

  • They came in really high too on the approach. Not the brightest people.

  • @lodragon25 ??? I doubt that reflects intelligence.  Leave those comments to pilots! Lol.

  • @lodragon25 ??? I doubt that reflects intelligence. Leave those comments to pilots! Lol. If you notice they are talking about what seems to be something that has nothing to do with the flight, not to mention there's a freaking gear horn blaring.

  • @lodragon25 ??? I doubt that reflects intelligence. Leave those comments to pilots! Lol. If you notice they are talking about what seems to be something that has nothing to do with the flight, not to mention there's a freaking gear horn blaring... THAT'S what reflects intellect.

  • apparently they didn't hear the warning because they were wearing high-end noise-canceling headphones. this is what a plane enthusiast told me..

  • dumbasses.........

  • beep beep beep beep beep

  • didint they hear beep beep beep beep

  • the wheels up horn was going off too!!! LOL neither of them caught it!

    i guess i can understand that though. whenever you are in a reduced power setting, the horn goes off, so maybe they were so used to hearing it, it didn't mean anything to them.

  • OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOPS! Not a good idea.

  • Hey, that's not the outer marker genius!!

  • So totally fake. You folks as so gullable.

  • @marcumb Why do youtube know it all teenagers always say "FAKE!!" at anything that does not seem normal. How did you come to this conclusion, genius? Since we "as" so "gullable" then explain it to us, rather than just throwing around misspelled unsubstantiated words.

  • The BEEP BEEP is the gear up warning horn that comes on when the throttle is pulled back and the landing gear is not down. There are only two kinds of pilots, those who have landed gear up, and those who will land gear up someday.

  • i come here whenever i have a bad day makes me feel good :)

  • gee, i wonder what the BEEP BEEP BEEP BEEP means!

  • Not fake. Prop strike happened before you heard the scraping after which the camera panned back to the right. I was at the FAA seminar where the pilots explained how this happened - cockpit distractions after a disruption in the normal landing routine. If you'r not a pilot, you don't know how much is going on during an approach to landing - no excuse for this kind of mistake (they clearly tuned out the warnig horn), but it does happen.

  • @PilotFishBob You heard from the actual pilots that this was not a planned gear-up, i.e. a gear malfunction? They were surprised due to their error? Looks like they were approaching very high - were they doing an engine-out exercise and that was the distraction that got them?

  • Yes, it was an FAA Safety seminar. It was a biennial review, I think - guy on right is an instructor. They were concentrating on landing exactly on a pre-determined spot and managed to tune out the horn - amazing what can happen if you get fixated. There original youtube posting with a comment from the vidographer is K4QHpVXtxI.

  • Hummm ! do you heard the sweet noise of fuselage scraping on the runway !

  • lol idiot pilot..

  • Not to mention the extremely high approach and landing on the last half of the runway.

  • A little more attention to the task at hand and less cockpit chatter may have helped a bit. I'll bet going back the next morning to find your gloves is not so important now. BEEP BEEP BEEP BEEP BEEP BEEP

  • So calm and collected but the Dash Slap at the end says it all.

    LOL

    All I can is I am glad it was you and not me.

  • this is the problem with active noise cancellation headsets, with intercoms not linked to aircraft audible warnings.

  • @wharbio

    Yeah and not using the pre-landing checklist EVERYTIME.

  • wow

  • idiot

  • @krlos116

    Are you a pilot?

  • to low Gear beep beep to low gear

  • bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bib bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bip bbbbiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiipppppppp wtf

  • looked like a high approach and im glad i didnt fly with them. I ALWAYS go over checklists. Well, this is a good example of how to get your license taken away haha.

  • Comment removed

  • Don't these idiots hear the annunciator? Save the prop? Once the prop strikes the runway, it's toast. Nice flare out though.

  • Might be stuck...

  • Might be stuck? I didn't hear the pilot going over the landing checklist. If he new the gear was stuck, he would be on the radio telling the tower to get the crash truck in place. I fly C-182s with the Civil Air Patrol and we stress SITUATIONAL AWARENESS in the cockpit. there was no situational awareness in this cockpit. The proof is when the pilot slaps the dash at the end of the clip - "gee, I could have had a V-8" (from the V-8 juice commercial)

  • He was in ciruit practicing landings. He was leaving the gear down but on the previous landing he put it up out of habbit and forgot about it, didn't check for 3 green and crashed.

  • I flew 182s with CAP as well.

  • CAP would never do something like this

  • You would be surprised.

  • wouldn't beep if lever is down.

  • The original video is elsewhere on youtube "accidental gear up in a cessna 182" The pilot didnt have the guts to post it. A friend of the cameraman in the back seat did.

    Based on the info in the original video, I looked for this incident on ntsb website to read the report. Didnt find any record that this was reported if his info was correct.

  • ..thank you for flying air transat ?! LOL

  • heehee, maybe they needed to re-paint the underside of the plane,?

  • @CKOI969 where do u hear that?

  • lol

    the face of the pilot at

    0:39

    like, im gotta get owned

    then the copilot looking at him

    what did you do!?!?!

  • ROFL

  • Wouldn't you cut engine before something like this? I would at least try to save my engine!

  • Uh, you wouldn't need to worry about saving the engine

    Saving the prop would be a concern there.

  • AFAIK, a sudden stoppage of the engine results in a necessary complete teardown of the engine for inspection

  • Well, true.. Talk about pre-takeoff checklist next time you fly

  • @Bergstaller01 Thats correct...a propstrike necessitates opening of the crankshaft.

  • @Bergstaller01 yeah but you pull the mixture right before touchdown to get the prop to stop spinning so it does not kill the prop and make the aircraft even harder to control.

  • @navyocs To me in this case, the pilot wasn't aware the gear wsn't down, therefore how would he know to pull the mixture?

  • dude, he didn't forget to put it down?

    He declared an emergency, after circling the field, due to gear failiure.

    He then decided to land on the belly.

    The beeping sound is indicating the gear is not down, 100 % correct.

  • As humiliating as this must be for the poor guy who was PIC during this flight, I am glad he had the guts to post it. This is wonderful reminder of why you want to check for three on the tree before impact! You don't wish this on anyone.

  • we actually use BC gumps

  • and what's that beeping noise anyway? 0_0 I hate flying.. you guys are all nuts to me. ;P

  • I believe the beeping is a warning that the gear isnt down after dropping the flaps....not 100% sure tho

  • That's what I thought. But then they're really retarded. Muuhhh?? There's a beeping noise but I'm gonna keep landing anyway and maybe if I ignore it'll go away. *cross eyed*

    :P

  • Mmh, I think it has rather something to do with speed to great for landing or tank is empty (no joke).

  • No, it's gear warning. When the flaps are 20 degrees or manifold pressures is less than 14 and the gear is not down, you get that horn.

  • yeah i know what an idiot lol he is so going to get his license revoked

  • @Bergstaller01

    correct

  • @Bergstaller01 The beeping is because he has put down a certain amount of flaps or has pulled back a certain amount of engine rpm(depends on the aircraft) and the aircraft thinks it is landing and is trying to warn the pilot. In their defense when you do a steep spiral manuever where the horn is sounding for several minutes you forget it is there and can make a mistake. I love how he smacks the dash at the end though"oh shit!"

  • Very poor cockpit discipline.

  • I guess this idiot has never heard of a GUMPS check.

  • gumps?

  • Gas

    Undercarriage

    Mixtures

    Props

    Seatbelts

    It's a quick before landing checklist.

  • Ah ok. We use

    Pitch

    Undercarriage

    Flaps/Cowl Flaps

    Landing Clearance

    Airfield Clear

    Believe it or not pittsdriver whilst conducting a glide approach yesterday my fate was almost that of the gentlemen in this video.

  • ooh! Be careful. I wouldn't want to see you become a statistic. Fly safe!

  • Well you know what they say, there's 2 types of pilots - those who have had a wheels up landing, and those who haven't yet.

    Takes a lot of power to taxi back to base also.

  • LOL. There's a lot of truth in that statement.

  • Didn't they hear the gear warning horn? It certainly was loud enough.

  • apparently not, notice the pilot slapping the dashboard at the end? its kind of like he said *DOH!*

  • It's a 'done' I think...

  • Comment removed

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more