@mitch1234129 Searched, listened, dismissed. She doesn't sing badly, but this kid is no Judy. Trying to compare her to Judy is like trying to compare a nicely made dollhouse to a real mansion. What ever you put inside it, you simply cannot live in it. You can live in Judy's music,
When she was fourteen years old, she sang "You Made Me Love You" in "Broadway Melodies of 1938". Go listen to it and tell me you think Ariana Grande compares well in any way. If you do, your taste has been corrupted!
She is the only one of her kind. Magnificent! The only female singer that approaches her talent is Barbra. No one else. What a shame she died so young. I didn't see this till I was fifteen or sixteen, but I saw "Over The Rainbow" quite young, around seven or so, and fell in love with Judy instantly. Never fell out. I'm almost seventy, but I like lots of current female singers. Whitney, for instance, & Beyonce, etc.. I love Leona Lewis. But there has never been anyone like Judy.
George Cukor, the director of this movie, could not believe that Judy Garland thought that she was worthless. He tried to tell her she was special, but she wouldn't believe it. I say Judy, you were unforgettable, God bless your spirit.
Harold Arlen (music) and Ira Gershwin (lyrics) wrote this for Judy to sing in the film. Skip Martin arranged it, and the studio orchestra under Ray Heindorf accomapanies her...
I am speechless, perfection. Class and elegance. I love this movie and introduced it to my daughters. I have seen this movie and this number over 100 times. Still get goose bumps, still brings me to tears. The pain is in every note. And, ladies, we all have been there. Never has there been her equal
i will never EVER forget the first time i heard this when i was a young boy about twelve and we had maybe seven channels of tv. i was clicking away (when you had to get up and do that) and 'a star is born' came on one of the uhf channels. a voice like no other ...STILL.... and i yelled to my mother 'who is this singing?' and she said " oh, that's dorothy darling." absolutely mesmerizing ! her magic still works today and i agree with many here who have commented: no one comes close !!
I wish there will be someone who comes along very soon that has even 10% of the talent that she had. There will never be another person just like Judy, now they're all driven by fame and money. She was driven by her love of music and entertaining her fans.
I can say with great disappointment, I was born in the wrong era =(
She was just as beautiful here as she was in the wizard of oz she is so pretty. She should've won the Oscar for this role I saw it for the first time on tcm on june 10 Judy's b-day a couple of days ago Grace Kelly didn't deserve the award Judy did. This is such a beautiful song and movie. She always did sing her heart out.
The greatest entertainer of all time still brings the house down with the simple memory of his most momerable moment in film. We'll never see the likes of her again.
Okay I am under 25 or 30 years old and I am speaking with honesty every film up in to the 60s had decadence class grace and eloquence the stars of the Hollywood golden era are my favorite and I cry because never again will there be another time in film it's such a shame film after the 70s were all porn sex and violence but gene Kelly Judy garland Debbie Reynolds Fred aistaire all those films musicals MGM classics and walt Disney classics and modern ones too.
I think Judy did this scene, without Making-People Sad, or Cry. (Watch her interactions with the musicians, during the Film...). She sang this song, many times, it became a signature-song, yet: Please don't Feel Sad. Judy Remains All-Around, BLESSINGS!
I watch this video every single day. There is honestly no other person like her. Watch her face and hand motions, you're only going to see that once. RIP Judy, one in six billion.
@zerty3 so do i, judy was a fantastic woman that died too young, and i appreciate this spectacular music, i mean, i am only 14 years old,and i prefer this to new music!
@RobotMice You're kidding. Please, no. Beyonce is beautiful but she shouldn't kid herself, neither should Clint.. She cannot stand on the same stage as Judy. Presuming to do that would be a travesty and an insult to Judy's memory and all of us who love her still.
Truely haunting.... I fell in love with this song in the movie, "P.S. I Love You" and found it here on YouTube. Thank you for sharing, this will always be a favorite of mine.
I love the very last part were she goes "uuuuuuhhh waaaaaaaaaaaay" and she has this sweet little mile-long stare and also very Triumphant. Like shes thinking to herself "yessss!!! I just nailed this song"
I think that there are only two people who can sing like this. Her...And some Kid out there who wants to go and be as Famous as she still is. I swear when that kid comes along, they are going to be just as amazing as she is....I hope.
I got goosebumps all over, I've loved Judy Garland since the first time I saw The Wizard of Oz at about age 3. :) I'm only almost 15 now, but this is true talent. No one today or after her has ever or will ever compare to her.
R.I.P. Judy, we know you are somewhere over the rainbow now.<3
This is not called the golden era of movies for nothing. These artists could really sing, dance and act. You needed to be versatile to succeed in those days. We will never see another Judy Garland in our life time. She was a diamond in the rough.
@ThePharaoho The wonderful thing about Judy is that she was also an unassuming and personable young lady in her early years. I had the pleasure of chatting with her backstage at The Hippodrome in Birmingham, England in, I think, 1953 and it was one of most the precious hours in my memory bank. As an icon she was most approachable. Thank you Judy for a lovely memory.
No one should ever redo this performance. It is, and always will be, absolute perfection. Thank you for making it more available to all of us. I'm very moved, very..................
There is only one that came after her as far as giving her soul in a performance and that is Whitney like her or not she was our Judy. Not as talented but closer than anyone else, now only if she can make a real comeback will I ever mention the two in the same story again....
@jackiescanlon I so agree with you AND Groucho and I am sure so many other people ..That was Oscar's BIGGEST BLUNDER EVER !! oh , that and Crash winning for Best Picture ...LOL .xoxo
I saw a documentary on Judy that said this number was all shot in one take. She is just about the best there ever was. This is my favorite song and favorite scene in all of her films.
I think there was some bullshit about how alot of BITCHES (& I'm not talkin about women) in Hollywood told her she wasn't attractive enough 2 b a star they fucked themselves up there asses though well even though I think she's just alright nothin like Marilyn Monroe but she wasn't that horrible she sure was a GR8 singer
Probably the best filmed video and interpretion of a song of all time. Dam, it makes my furr stand up on the back of my neck.! RIP my beloved Judy! You were the greatest atrist of my generation!
@SUPERyoshi95 ain't that the truth! I love Grace Kelley but Judy's performance in "A STAR IS Born" was the greatest perfomance of an actor in a musical in Hollywood history. We will never see the likes of a PERFORMER LIKE JUDY IN OUR LIFETIME, other than Streisand
So sad that MGM referred to Judy as their "property", prescribing so many amphetamines to work her to death, and Seconal to sleep that the DEA looked into
how many drugs she was prescribed! ANd this was in the 40's and 50's when they were prescribed to people like candy. Louis B. Mayer was a monster.
Probably the greatest torch song ever written, sung by the greatest singer of songs to ever stand before a mic or audience. You can't beat that combo. It's heartening to know there are still people out there who appreciate the talent(s).
By my reckoning, this is the greatest torch song ever written, sung by the greatest singer of songs to ever stand before a mic..or an audience. You can't beat that combo. It's heartening to know there are still people out there who appreciate the talent.....
A true raw once in a lifetime talent. Just a fabulous beautiful talent gone now forever other than what we have on film and on recording. She was truly a gift.
Arguably the greatest torch song sung by the queen of the torch song...Judy was total talent, she could do it all, drama, comedy, dance and sing, (duh!!)
I can't believe that Judy lost to G Kelly; the academy voters must have been doing some good glue at the time....that's nuts
I can't imagine Beyonce coming anywhere NEAR to Judy when singing this song in the new version of this movie. it would be a joke.. That band is fabulous, by the way, who is backing her on this tour de force??
Judy deserved the Oscar for Best Actress more than Grave Kelly! Just like Beauty & The Beast deserved the Oscar for Best Picture more than Silence Of The Lambs.
I've heard this performance many many times and it's still the only song that brings me to tears everytime I hear it... There's never been anyone like Judy..
UGH THIS WOMAN. She is untouchable. This number emphasizes that. Nobody will ever compare. I swear if anyone from Glee performs this number -- knock on wood -- and butchers it, I will cut someone or something.
Judy seemed to hate that head of hair of hers. She was always messing with it in some of the live performances I've seen, and to see it here in the final cut of a movie is kind of funny to me.
No doubs WHATS So Ever that Ms Garland was one of the vioces of the 20th Centurry, the other of course Ms Streisen, who both have us the songs of our emotional expressions we have for each other! Thank You Both. Of course, 5 Stars!!
Judy Garland was always 'larger than life' itself, and her performance in 'A STAR IS BORN ' is nothing short of MIRACULOUS......a performance UNPARALLELED in motion picture history.--Judy Garland,56 years later, remains EASILY the greatest female singer in the entire history of film. Easily. Grace Kelly,winning the Academy Award for 'the country girl' is,i think, one of the LOWEST moments in Academy Award history...the Oscar was 'clearly' Judy's !!! Brad Savage ---
One word, talent.
DebsTasha45 1 week ago
An incredibly powerful voice, each note stronger than the previous.
abelsincain 2 weeks ago
@mitch1234129 Searched, listened, dismissed. She doesn't sing badly, but this kid is no Judy. Trying to compare her to Judy is like trying to compare a nicely made dollhouse to a real mansion. What ever you put inside it, you simply cannot live in it. You can live in Judy's music,
When she was fourteen years old, she sang "You Made Me Love You" in "Broadway Melodies of 1938". Go listen to it and tell me you think Ariana Grande compares well in any way. If you do, your taste has been corrupted!
peterotooled 2 weeks ago
She is the only one of her kind. Magnificent! The only female singer that approaches her talent is Barbra. No one else. What a shame she died so young. I didn't see this till I was fifteen or sixteen, but I saw "Over The Rainbow" quite young, around seven or so, and fell in love with Judy instantly. Never fell out. I'm almost seventy, but I like lots of current female singers. Whitney, for instance, & Beyonce, etc.. I love Leona Lewis. But there has never been anyone like Judy.
peterotooled 2 weeks ago
George Cukor, the director of this movie, could not believe that Judy Garland thought that she was worthless. He tried to tell her she was special, but she wouldn't believe it. I say Judy, you were unforgettable, God bless your spirit.
frank47hammer 3 weeks ago
Everybody search ariana grande and listen to her singing one of judys songs!
mitch1234129 1 month ago
every word.........i feel like she means it. she's so powerful.
dj268 1 month ago
Her gestures here really remind me of Liza Minelli's in 'New York New York', when she sings 'The World Goes Round'. They are both utterly wonderful.
Ysaedda 1 month ago
The greatest performer that ever lived with a song that's all hers...forever. Thanks so very much.
tropicalpancake56 1 month ago
My Idol. I love you so much Judy!
sennaaaaloves 1 month ago
No one did it like Judy... No one ever will do it like Judy.... No one can do it like Judy.... Just Perfection...
mscarolannstaples 2 months ago 2
I can't even .... speechless.
VanessaKrystle 2 months ago
My absolute fave Judy song...ever!
flgaterz 2 months ago
beyonce is going to attempt to play the fab judy garland ((((puke))))
missingyou90s 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my first love
naruto231000 2 months ago
Harold Arlen (music) and Ira Gershwin (lyrics) wrote this for Judy to sing in the film. Skip Martin arranged it, and the studio orchestra under Ray Heindorf accomapanies her...
fromthesidelines 2 months ago
Have a look at a new version of this. The John Wilson Orchestra at the BBC Proms with Caroline O'Conner singing. Fantastic !
CDB8939 3 months ago
She is so unreal. This performance is so unreal. Completely takes my breath away.
Sunnysavenue 3 months ago
Judy Garland, I love you.
talexander123321 3 months ago 6
She sure belts it
goback3spaces 3 months ago
This is the greatest performance by any singer....ever.
jpaparozzi 3 months ago 2
genius
iloveejh 3 months ago
who dislikes this song!!!!?????
helenajesstarzak 3 months ago
This is absolutely beautiful.
Fobsessed99 3 months ago
<3
hannaraven 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Wow what a voice, what a song, what an arrangement.
Makes the hair on the back of my neck.................
hollybrook252 4 months ago
The greatest singer that ever came out of North America. I just wish she would have had more personal happiness.
zyxquark 4 months ago
No words.
MAYINSANTI 5 months ago
I am speechless, perfection. Class and elegance. I love this movie and introduced it to my daughters. I have seen this movie and this number over 100 times. Still get goose bumps, still brings me to tears. The pain is in every note. And, ladies, we all have been there. Never has there been her equal
firewalk2126 5 months ago
At her best........ class!
osalindra 5 months ago
4 people are the men that got away. From good taste.
erumping94 5 months ago 12
I love this song! Even through it is sad
MMfan1997 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
God said let's send them a musical genius and an angel named Judy Garland.
WinehouseTearsDry 5 months ago
God said let's send them a musical genius and he sent an angel named Judy Garland.
WinehouseTearsDry 5 months ago
i will never EVER forget the first time i heard this when i was a young boy about twelve and we had maybe seven channels of tv. i was clicking away (when you had to get up and do that) and 'a star is born' came on one of the uhf channels. a voice like no other ...STILL.... and i yelled to my mother 'who is this singing?' and she said " oh, that's dorothy darling." absolutely mesmerizing ! her magic still works today and i agree with many here who have commented: no one comes close !!
dflartist 5 months ago
She put all of her effort into her music, but this is just perfection!
DebsTasha45 6 months ago
I wish there will be someone who comes along very soon that has even 10% of the talent that she had. There will never be another person just like Judy, now they're all driven by fame and money. She was driven by her love of music and entertaining her fans.
I can say with great disappointment, I was born in the wrong era =(
MyMusicalSoul941 6 months ago
Judy's still the greatest....awesome!
MommysGirl920 6 months ago 3
She was just as beautiful here as she was in the wizard of oz she is so pretty. She should've won the Oscar for this role I saw it for the first time on tcm on june 10 Judy's b-day a couple of days ago Grace Kelly didn't deserve the award Judy did. This is such a beautiful song and movie. She always did sing her heart out.
cinderelmo 7 months ago
@cinderelmo I also loved her singing "A new world" from the same film.not posted yet.
TZEITEL10 1 month ago
w.o.w...
alissafox 7 months ago
This should be required viewing! A legend at the top of her game!
billyboylb 7 months ago
This is how I feel
Gurlsugar 7 months ago
The greatest entertainer of all time still brings the house down with the simple memory of his most momerable moment in film. We'll never see the likes of her again.
flavio136 7 months ago
@welovecheesecake123-3 idiots
Lynnsey5 7 months ago
I've seen it a hundred times and she is always amazing. It's interesting seeing it in this different perspective. Thanks
coldocean 8 months ago
Okay I am under 25 or 30 years old and I am speaking with honesty every film up in to the 60s had decadence class grace and eloquence the stars of the Hollywood golden era are my favorite and I cry because never again will there be another time in film it's such a shame film after the 70s were all porn sex and violence but gene Kelly Judy garland Debbie Reynolds Fred aistaire all those films musicals MGM classics and walt Disney classics and modern ones too.
cinderelmo 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
never cheting site and only one in trully benaughtyman.info
kristincoyn 8 months ago
Wow! Are you sure this isn't Liza?
Broadwayfan100 8 months ago
@Broadwayfan100
Where do you think she got it from?
VirgiliaCoriolanus 8 months ago
I think Judy did this scene, without Making-People Sad, or Cry. (Watch her interactions with the musicians, during the Film...). She sang this song, many times, it became a signature-song, yet: Please don't Feel Sad. Judy Remains All-Around, BLESSINGS!
tubetoad 9 months ago
who could disike this?:O
welovecheesecake123 9 months ago
I watch this video every single day. There is honestly no other person like her. Watch her face and hand motions, you're only going to see that once. RIP Judy, one in six billion.
anibani23 9 months ago
What a gorgeous song sung by the incomparable Judy Garland. Sinatra does an equally moving male version of this song.
yvettealicemorton 9 months ago
Almost as good as Britney!!!
7beers 9 months ago
I guess a lot of men have gotten away! : (
1bol390 10 months ago
just so much emotion! amazing idol and forever alive
silvershields 10 months ago
PS I love you :)
alejmusica 11 months ago
Thank you, God for allowing your Angel Judy Garland to visit us for
a little while.
CherubimandAngels 11 months ago
@zerty3 so do i, judy was a fantastic woman that died too young, and i appreciate this spectacular music, i mean, i am only 14 years old,and i prefer this to new music!
DebsTasha45 11 months ago
Clint eastwood plans on doing remake with beyonce as judy garland role
Just no
10000000000 No's Judy garland not beyonce
RobotMice 11 months ago
@RobotMice
I have to agree with you. I really like Beyonce, but shes not Judy. People shouldn't touch perfection.
gilmoregirlsfan131 11 months ago
@RobotMice You're kidding. Please, no. Beyonce is beautiful but she shouldn't kid herself, neither should Clint.. She cannot stand on the same stage as Judy. Presuming to do that would be a travesty and an insult to Judy's memory and all of us who love her still.
windchimeisland 11 months ago
Truely haunting.... I fell in love with this song in the movie, "P.S. I Love You" and found it here on YouTube. Thank you for sharing, this will always be a favorite of mine.
laurahimes 11 months ago
that little laugh at the end:'), wow she does give it all! she has something i call talent
DebsTasha45 11 months ago
What a voice!
jackiescanlon 11 months ago
there's nothing better!!! PERFECTION!!!!! have loved judy my entire life and this clip shows why!
jacksonbrownepuppy 11 months ago
P.s. i love you!
itorresfelix9 11 months ago
the very best
Tracey079699 11 months ago
I love the very last part were she goes "uuuuuuhhh waaaaaaaaaaaay" and she has this sweet little mile-long stare and also very Triumphant. Like shes thinking to herself "yessss!!! I just nailed this song"
caliking100 1 year ago
Such a heart rendering song sung from her very soul and then that little giggle at the end... mind blowing!
trerenee1 1 year ago
Best place to find lsian women **busizz4me.info**
jaidenjaniya 1 year ago
this is my favorite from her <3
TheHeyB 1 year ago
This knocks me dead every single time. Groucho Marx was right.
MsCatfeet 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Real benaughty brides are there **benaughtyman.info**
jendykrishna 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hi brother needs to chat a, latin women busizz4me.info
tharindudansh 1 year ago
I think that there are only two people who can sing like this. Her...And some Kid out there who wants to go and be as Famous as she still is. I swear when that kid comes along, they are going to be just as amazing as she is....I hope.
RIP Judy, You are still Marching On. <3
UnknownBroadwayBaby 1 year ago 30
This has been flagged as spam show
Online Russian girls gettop5.info
yoshiko4b 1 year ago
I got goosebumps all over, I've loved Judy Garland since the first time I saw The Wizard of Oz at about age 3. :) I'm only almost 15 now, but this is true talent. No one today or after her has ever or will ever compare to her.
R.I.P. Judy, we know you are somewhere over the rainbow now.<3
Gracieglimmerr 1 year ago 20
This is not called the golden era of movies for nothing. These artists could really sing, dance and act. You needed to be versatile to succeed in those days. We will never see another Judy Garland in our life time. She was a diamond in the rough.
cboncklis 1 year ago 6
Icon and Legend
ThePharaoho 1 year ago 2
@ThePharaoho The wonderful thing about Judy is that she was also an unassuming and personable young lady in her early years. I had the pleasure of chatting with her backstage at The Hippodrome in Birmingham, England in, I think, 1953 and it was one of most the precious hours in my memory bank. As an icon she was most approachable. Thank you Judy for a lovely memory.
02lensman 1 year ago
now that's a true singing voice!
risendreams 1 year ago 2
P.s I love you :)
GraceConnolly1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Meet thousands of Russian women online gettop5.info
DesgWamrt 1 year ago
They don't make pipes like that anymore.
v0zbox 1 year ago
What a beautiful classic song we are actually watching this Film in my Film Study class and i was left Speechless.
topshow20 1 year ago
No one should ever redo this performance. It is, and always will be, absolute perfection. Thank you for making it more available to all of us. I'm very moved, very..................
jamesrdeen 1 year ago
JUDY!! Love her *tear*
robthetreble23 1 year ago
I must have listened to this song 6 times in a row now. Magical!
NOIRIST 1 year ago
Other than Streisand and Midlertoday's singers don't even compare! Can you imagine Brittnary Spears singing this song?No way no how!
RImusclebear 1 year ago
Gilmore Girls <3
broadwaylover6 1 year ago 4
this gave me goosebumps i love it. I love how this song is in ps i love you
panamanianprincess12 1 year ago 2
There is only one that came after her as far as giving her soul in a performance and that is Whitney like her or not she was our Judy. Not as talented but closer than anyone else, now only if she can make a real comeback will I ever mention the two in the same story again....
fawnsworld81 1 year ago
@fawnsworld81 Would be great for Whitney to make a comeback.
Jayee123 1 year ago
so true... the lyrics are so true for anyone whose ever gone through this knows this. No one sings it better than wonderful Judy!
honeybee7700 1 year ago
she sang the hell out of this song.
noirpoetix1 1 year ago 91
@noirpoetix1
To quote Groucho Marx on Judy's Oscar loss: 'The biggest robbery since Brinx!'
jackiescanlon 11 months ago
@jackiescanlon I so agree with you AND Groucho and I am sure so many other people ..That was Oscar's BIGGEST BLUNDER EVER !! oh , that and Crash winning for Best Picture ...LOL .xoxo
PeaceFan1 1 month ago
I love this song so much!! when i'm sad, something about listening to it makes me feel better
cherrymontana 1 year ago
THE Greatest song ever captured on film, PERIOD !!!! xo
PeaceFan1 1 year ago
No one sings like this. Ok, maybe Liza. Two of the brightest stars this planet has ever seen.
Picardy 1 year ago
im 18 years old and love this song x
Brennanator21 1 year ago 2
what key is this in?
theatergirlll 1 year ago
@theatergirlll Pretty sure F major.
That's what the official music score shows anyway.
NakedSalad 1 year ago
@NakedSalad Do you know where I could find the music score for this? xx
hannahbanana51 1 year ago
I saw a documentary on Judy that said this number was all shot in one take. She is just about the best there ever was. This is my favorite song and favorite scene in all of her films.
kjsmith97 1 year ago 4
I think there was some bullshit about how alot of BITCHES (& I'm not talkin about women) in Hollywood told her she wasn't attractive enough 2 b a star they fucked themselves up there asses though well even though I think she's just alright nothin like Marilyn Monroe but she wasn't that horrible she sure was a GR8 singer
A kinda like this song better "Over The Rainbow"
AziaXtreme 1 year ago 3
@MicheleBell1 I think they already did release a DVD
AziaXtreme 1 year ago
I love her laugh at the end
demigrl21 1 year ago 2
Somehow this woman always leaves me speechles, even after I,ve seen and heard her songs many times ,what a talent!!
Choefoe 1 year ago 2
Probably the best filmed video and interpretion of a song of all time. Dam, it makes my furr stand up on the back of my neck.! RIP my beloved Judy! You were the greatest atrist of my generation!
RImusclebear 1 year ago 3
I get the best chills in the world when I hear this song :)
SUPERyoshi95 1 year ago
@SUPERyoshi95 ain't that the truth! I love Grace Kelley but Judy's performance in "A STAR IS Born" was the greatest perfomance of an actor in a musical in Hollywood history. We will never see the likes of a PERFORMER LIKE JUDY IN OUR LIFETIME, other than Streisand
RImusclebear 1 year ago 2
She was robbed of that Oscar.
ThatSideOfParadise 1 year ago 5
pure class
jessica7993xx 1 year ago
She was just an absolutely stunning singer and performer. No one will ever sing this song like her, a pure joy to listen to:)
Bluesilvahalo 1 year ago
So sad that MGM referred to Judy as their "property", prescribing so many amphetamines to work her to death, and Seconal to sleep that the DEA looked into
how many drugs she was prescribed! ANd this was in the 40's and 50's when they were prescribed to people like candy. Louis B. Mayer was a monster.
prettyvacant3 1 year ago 2
This gives me chills EVERY SINGLE TIME. she's amazing....
partytimex42 1 year ago 2
.....has run off and undone you......... something I think everyone can relate to. Such powerful words!
macksfischer 1 year ago
!!!!amo esta cancion !!!!!!!!
TheNena199 1 year ago
Stunning.
chrisman737 1 year ago
WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!
east215 1 year ago
Just want to say THANKS for this clip. Judy is the only one who could sing this song.
mauretania111 1 year ago 2
I'm only 28, but this has definitely become one of my favorite songs. Judy is greatly missed.
Beautifulstar24 1 year ago
genius
brickmajors31 1 year ago
Probably the greatest torch song ever written, sung by the greatest singer of songs to ever stand before a mic or audience. You can't beat that combo. It's heartening to know there are still people out there who appreciate the talent(s).
oldgypsytap 1 year ago
By my reckoning, this is the greatest torch song ever written, sung by the greatest singer of songs to ever stand before a mic..or an audience. You can't beat that combo. It's heartening to know there are still people out there who appreciate the talent.....
oldgypsytap 1 year ago
Just saw this again via the wonderful TCM (June 19th 2010) I will have this WONDERFUL song in my mind and on my lips in the coming weeks Happy Ears!
Sheliabluerose 1 year ago
@MicheleBell1 ~ Judy's masterpiece? How about George Cukor's masterpiece?
edwardjames50 1 year ago
Perfection. Story is Judy did the performance on camera in one take. That's a pro!
sinomaniac 1 year ago
This is my favorite song from Judy Garland, thanks for posting it.
pickosa71 1 year ago
A true raw once in a lifetime talent. Just a fabulous beautiful talent gone now forever other than what we have on film and on recording. She was truly a gift.
dumbdems 1 year ago
where can you get the sheet music for the band for this great music?
SaverinoMusic 1 year ago
Arguably the greatest torch song sung by the queen of the torch song...Judy was total talent, she could do it all, drama, comedy, dance and sing, (duh!!)
I can't believe that Judy lost to G Kelly; the academy voters must have been doing some good glue at the time....that's nuts
I can't imagine Beyonce coming anywhere NEAR to Judy when singing this song in the new version of this movie. it would be a joke.. That band is fabulous, by the way, who is backing her on this tour de force??
SSGTA440 1 year ago
another "classic" clip from a truly remarkable film simply an "OUTSTANDING performance from the one and only Judy Garland totaly PERFECT..........
frankyagogo 1 year ago
Amazing song...and Judy's delivery on it is perfect! You can feel the emotion on every note!
Thanks for posting this...it's one of my favorite films.
soulgirl66 1 year ago
The combination of Garland, Arlen, and Gershwin is heaven sent!
billyboylb 1 year ago 2
Iconic
ThePharaoho 1 year ago 2
Judy deserved the Oscar for Best Actress more than Grave Kelly! Just like Beauty & The Beast deserved the Oscar for Best Picture more than Silence Of The Lambs.
OurGangFan 1 year ago
love her!!
SheryeS 1 year ago 2
No one could sing this song BUT Judy. I have the album on 78 & the film - it's primo!
KathyExpat 1 year ago
this is how its how its done that stupid idiot Lauren from over the rainbow take note
love Judy and i have loved this song and finally go to see a star is born and i loved t one of judy's best performances
MissSong09 1 year ago
It's so rare when you get to see real perfection. And Judy gave the world that
sexytwizzlers 1 year ago 5
I've heard this performance many many times and it's still the only song that brings me to tears everytime I hear it... There's never been anyone like Judy..
GWENKER 1 year ago 30
she is such a natural performer and you can tell this by little things the performer does like how she brushed her fringe away :) just amazing
and obviously an amazing singer!
05rwynn 1 year ago 4
I get chills watching this.
cityondown78 1 year ago 4
UGH THIS WOMAN. She is untouchable. This number emphasizes that. Nobody will ever compare. I swear if anyone from Glee performs this number -- knock on wood -- and butchers it, I will cut someone or something.
chocolateapple 1 year ago 2
This video was shot in one take!
spudparty 1 year ago
Genius
MrJixthenumpty 1 year ago 2
Wow.
iluvmotown 1 year ago 3
It was meant to be viewed according to the way director George Cukor envisioned it.
edwardjames50 1 year ago
Too. Much. Talent.
This woman's brilliance ought to make any sane person get a grip.
Really ... no one can touch the mere hem of her skirt.
Vengeance509 1 year ago
love the different perspective. love this song!!!!!!!!!
musicallvr247 1 year ago
Have always loved this song and her talent. Thanks for the video!
bearbass63 1 year ago
She has so much passion and heartache in this song :(
hithereameliarox 1 year ago
Word is that Beyonce' is set to "star" in a remake of "A Star Is Born" alongside Russell Crowe.
TornTeddy22 1 year ago
@TornTeddy22 YIKES!!!
roccoh21 1 year ago
Simply beautiful!! No one will ever sing like Judy!!!
fireandicecube 1 year ago
I don't eat. I don't sleep - i just watch this video! :)
xxx
LillyArwen 1 year ago 2
Why trim some scenes out? It's ruined.
MissGreenDay7 1 year ago
i love it so so much when she laughs at the end it shows her enormous sense of humor goodness she blows me away marvelous great i loved it
maxie102 1 year ago 2
Too bad the other one has been removed;-( was a better Q in sound and video, but I,ll take it ;-)
Choefoe 1 year ago 2
They filmed this song in one take.....just amazing!
spudparty 1 year ago 2
I adore this song, real emotion thank's JUDY ! RIP merci !!
domi88cc 1 year ago 3
j'aime cette chanson !!! RIP JUDY !!! I adore this song !!!!
domi88cc 1 year ago 2
Adore this song. Amazing vocals and so much emotion.
I agree with DF09 These are the voices of the 20th Century. Thank you for everything you've given us!
NickyLess 1 year ago 4
<3 <3 <3
xcrazyrandomerx 1 year ago
This and "that" sequence in Singin' in the Rain, for me, are the greatest clips in musical film history...
priapus56 1 year ago 2
O shit still one of the most amazing films and for me Garland's best as an older Judy . The Oscar was hers by right sorry Grace Kelly...
poshmum 1 year ago 5
damn right it was and it still is
AdamMichaelMercer 1 year ago
Judy seemed to hate that head of hair of hers. She was always messing with it in some of the live performances I've seen, and to see it here in the final cut of a movie is kind of funny to me.
TheJoCor 1 year ago
I think that my heart just fell to the bottom of my chest..... Judy thank you:)
zjkrone 1 year ago 29
Listen to Zing! and she'll make it pop back up again(:
Garlandfan94 1 year ago 2
@zjkrone That's how I feel when I hear Judy sing this song.
mauretania111 1 year ago
No doubs WHATS So Ever that Ms Garland was one of the vioces of the 20th Centurry, the other of course Ms Streisen, who both have us the songs of our emotional expressions we have for each other! Thank You Both. Of course, 5 Stars!!
DF09 1 year ago 2
beautiful :)
DangerKoala007 2 years ago 2
It doesn't get any better than this. No offense to Grace Kelly, but Judy deserved that Oscar. One of the greatest performances ever,
marypeck 2 years ago 3
Judy Garland was always 'larger than life' itself, and her performance in 'A STAR IS BORN ' is nothing short of MIRACULOUS......a performance UNPARALLELED in motion picture history.--Judy Garland,56 years later, remains EASILY the greatest female singer in the entire history of film. Easily. Grace Kelly,winning the Academy Award for 'the country girl' is,i think, one of the LOWEST moments in Academy Award history...the Oscar was 'clearly' Judy's !!! Brad Savage ---
Lifelong fan.
alzahad 1 year ago