This book uses a trite story--the precariousness of life during wartime--and is awfully written. It goes on about the same point endlessly and uses stuffy, romanticized language that will make you gag. Don't buy this book. If you want to read a book about the war-stricken lives of a few, read The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini instead.
I know this comment is pretty late, but your completely wrong. I guess you don't understand how to enjoy art in it's purest form. Steven Galloway's book allows people who may not completely understand the workings of war a deeper insight into what it means and what the people facing it feel. His writing uses themes and a writing style you may not understand. And I would like to see you do better. By the way Khaled Hosseini wrote a great review for The Cellist of Sarajevo.
I'm sure the true hero, Vedran, appreciates you waxing lyrical about the event which he LIVED. Stephen you behaved badly by stealing this man's legacy. Shame.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
They have serbian culture.
Bosnians are Serbs, that think they are better, they are Serbian Muslims, They started killing serbs first, but didnt know what was coming for them, Serbia defended its people, from the terrorist.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Bosnians attacked a serbian wedding as a sign of resistance. Serbs only fought back, and serbia a larger and powerful nation of bosnia, occupied it so quickly,. anything Christian is Serbian, Anything muslim, is from Old serbian decent. Everyone knows that bosnains are Serbs convertated to islam. What to the bosnian muslims haVE in culture? They have nothing, nor in this book, this book is garbage propaganda.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
because it only focuses on one side of the war. I read it, i wanted to see what it wrote about the war. Serbs didnt attack bosnians for no reason, serbs were protecting the serbian majority that lived in bosnia from the Muhadadjini. a radical muslim group. You have to know about both sides of the war. this focuses on negative connotations of the serbs, non about the muslims.
@L4SD4S WOW where did you get that information from, I am pretty sure that you did not live in Bosnia during the war and you are not a Bosnian yourself. Most likley a Serb who thinks that what happened in Bosnia was not bad, or didn't have anything wrong with it. So please refrain from making comments about thing's that you do not know about. Your story and justification of Serb's attack is plainly wrong and it is desrespectful to the Bosnian people around the world, and the victims of the war.
it's interesting how people use other people stories and names without asking them, and it's sure really interesting that the man who never was in sarajevo during the seige uses it to gain money...
@madamesyrin Exactly... I'm from Bosnia, and it's even more sad that there is no people here who could use similar stories to say something beyond nationalism, or cheap proclamation of personal "right" and "freedom", based upon the written laws. No one to speak about the laws beyond the written ones...
@madamesyrin the stories he took were the Cellist's story, some specific bombings like the one on the library and the people buying bread, and the war in general. The majority of the novel was created by him. The Characters Arrow, Kenan, and Dragan were created by him and are not based on anyone who was in the city during the war. He is using his writing to discuss the ideas people have on civilization, and human life, not tell someone else's story just to make money.
@madamesyrin Of course one of the reasons was for money, but that is because he writes for a living. If you were a writer you would write for money as well. He based the novel around an actual event, but it is his artistic exploration into the the human psyche during times such as this. The only story he took with out asking is the Cellist's.
I Love this Video and also I checked out your Channel. Very interesting! If you need any help getting this Video and your Channel exposed to where it is on top in all the searches. I found this site called tubeviews.(net) that has took my breath away. I'm working on my 4th Channel now, this one I just made. My Videos are getting so many hits now. Check it out and keep in touch.
serbs=fascist cunts that should be wiped out
TheViolenceMan 7 hours ago
this author is my creative writing professor at ubc :)
6045310708 5 months ago 3
This book uses a trite story--the precariousness of life during wartime--and is awfully written. It goes on about the same point endlessly and uses stuffy, romanticized language that will make you gag. Don't buy this book. If you want to read a book about the war-stricken lives of a few, read The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini instead.
gaeazadriel 1 year ago
@gaeazadriel
I know this comment is pretty late, but your completely wrong. I guess you don't understand how to enjoy art in it's purest form. Steven Galloway's book allows people who may not completely understand the workings of war a deeper insight into what it means and what the people facing it feel. His writing uses themes and a writing style you may not understand. And I would like to see you do better. By the way Khaled Hosseini wrote a great review for The Cellist of Sarajevo.
channels23456789 10 months ago
@channels23456789 khaled hosseini is a kuss madar, khar kuss... did you know that?
okaecoral 5 months ago
i think this is the best book ever....WAHLAU! makes me cry
bakguteh 1 year ago 2
I'm sure the true hero, Vedran, appreciates you waxing lyrical about the event which he LIVED. Stephen you behaved badly by stealing this man's legacy. Shame.
Ailing84 2 years ago
really an amazing book about the resiliency of the human spirit.
elbriano1000 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
They have serbian culture.
Bosnians are Serbs, that think they are better, they are Serbian Muslims, They started killing serbs first, but didnt know what was coming for them, Serbia defended its people, from the terrorist.
L4SD4S 2 years ago
Just show me a one single sign of a culture in all bad things serbs did to bosnians. You have no culture, maybe you should start from this book.
eminius77 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Bosnians attacked a serbian wedding as a sign of resistance. Serbs only fought back, and serbia a larger and powerful nation of bosnia, occupied it so quickly,. anything Christian is Serbian, Anything muslim, is from Old serbian decent. Everyone knows that bosnains are Serbs convertated to islam. What to the bosnian muslims haVE in culture? They have nothing, nor in this book, this book is garbage propaganda.
L4SD4S 2 years ago
have you really read this book? how could you think of it as a garbage propaganda!?
bakguteh 1 year ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
because it only focuses on one side of the war. I read it, i wanted to see what it wrote about the war. Serbs didnt attack bosnians for no reason, serbs were protecting the serbian majority that lived in bosnia from the Muhadadjini. a radical muslim group. You have to know about both sides of the war. this focuses on negative connotations of the serbs, non about the muslims.
L4SD4S 1 year ago
@L4SD4S WOW where did you get that information from, I am pretty sure that you did not live in Bosnia during the war and you are not a Bosnian yourself. Most likley a Serb who thinks that what happened in Bosnia was not bad, or didn't have anything wrong with it. So please refrain from making comments about thing's that you do not know about. Your story and justification of Serb's attack is plainly wrong and it is desrespectful to the Bosnian people around the world, and the victims of the war.
NotFromDisEarth 1 year ago 15
it's interesting how people use other people stories and names without asking them, and it's sure really interesting that the man who never was in sarajevo during the seige uses it to gain money...
madamesyrin 2 years ago
@madamesyrin Exactly... I'm from Bosnia, and it's even more sad that there is no people here who could use similar stories to say something beyond nationalism, or cheap proclamation of personal "right" and "freedom", based upon the written laws. No one to speak about the laws beyond the written ones...
IvanKaramazov22 2 years ago 2
@madamesyrin the stories he took were the Cellist's story, some specific bombings like the one on the library and the people buying bread, and the war in general. The majority of the novel was created by him. The Characters Arrow, Kenan, and Dragan were created by him and are not based on anyone who was in the city during the war. He is using his writing to discuss the ideas people have on civilization, and human life, not tell someone else's story just to make money.
TotallyzAwkwardz 1 year ago
@madamesyrin Of course one of the reasons was for money, but that is because he writes for a living. If you were a writer you would write for money as well. He based the novel around an actual event, but it is his artistic exploration into the the human psyche during times such as this. The only story he took with out asking is the Cellist's.
TotallyzAwkwardz 1 year ago
Just finished reading chapter 1. Best investment towards literature to date.
Eeeff 2 years ago
Just read this book. An amazing piece of literature. Not to be missed. You really get inside the minds of the characters. Enjoy.
1962HUGGY 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
I Love this Video and also I checked out your Channel. Very interesting! If you need any help getting this Video and your Channel exposed to where it is on top in all the searches. I found this site called tubeviews.(net) that has took my breath away. I'm working on my 4th Channel now, this one I just made. My Videos are getting so many hits now. Check it out and keep in touch.
Thomas Cole
johnspatafora 2 years ago