I think it's great for a woman to sing the part of Judas in JCS, as it adds an interesting dynamic - but this sucked. She tried to sing it like Carl Anderson... problem is, he's a man with a fantastic range, and this girl needs training desperately. She's not a terrible singer, but she needed to tweak a few notes to make them work with her range. With the right chick, this can work.
We did a production in high school too and had a female jesus. It's all about the actor. I'd rather cast a bester acting female than a subpar acting male for the role if thats what it comes down to.
Girls can do a lot of guy parts, I've seen it. But in this one, I would think it would be more impressive if they could have found a guy that fit in the range.
but you have to remember that the only female part is Mary- what do you do with the rest of your female actresses/singers? But yeah, I think judas works best as a guy.
see i wouldnt have as much of a problem with this version if the song was transposed to an appropriate key for her...thats part of the magic of the song...its in an extremely difficult part of a males range...so its super impressive when a guy does well...however..this SHOULD be a walk in the park for almost any female...
so kudos and all...but i cant give this one any credit...
I think it's great for a woman to sing the part of Judas in JCS, as it adds an interesting dynamic - but this sucked. She tried to sing it like Carl Anderson... problem is, he's a man with a fantastic range, and this girl needs training desperately. She's not a terrible singer, but she needed to tweak a few notes to make them work with her range. With the right chick, this can work.
TheClark456 1 year ago
This isn't the first time there was a female Judas. Plus, this Judas is pretty awesome.
Mistophoenix 1 year ago
We did a production in high school too and had a female jesus. It's all about the actor. I'd rather cast a bester acting female than a subpar acting male for the role if thats what it comes down to.
BLoMaksim 2 years ago
wow! I am impressed. that judas ain't bad
bobbylee1557 3 years ago
I actually liked it better with a female Judas... although this production was so much better live.
Did anyone film Ty & Anneka's version?
AgentQED 4 years ago
Girls can do a lot of guy parts, I've seen it. But in this one, I would think it would be more impressive if they could have found a guy that fit in the range.
AcDcGTRfreAk 4 years ago
but you have to remember that the only female part is Mary- what do you do with the rest of your female actresses/singers? But yeah, I think judas works best as a guy.
BreathBroadway 3 years ago
this is so awesome!! she did an amazing job.
mjrod93 4 years ago
A female Judas???? wtf??????
shmoogle14 4 years ago
It's been done many times. The notes are hardly as impressive with a girl, though. Still, I think she does a decent job.
DrWebflaxFLOO 4 years ago
see i wouldnt have as much of a problem with this version if the song was transposed to an appropriate key for her...thats part of the magic of the song...its in an extremely difficult part of a males range...so its super impressive when a guy does well...however..this SHOULD be a walk in the park for almost any female...
so kudos and all...but i cant give this one any credit...
katram 4 years ago
Sorry, Judas is through and through a boys part.
BLackout77x 4 years ago
oh come on. i've seen some shitty male Judas.
don't you think it should be done by a good girl singer rather a crappy guy singer? maybe none of the guys who auditioned could compete.
mjrod93 4 years ago
so tight.
Happyclark 4 years ago
cant female actresses do any role that male actresses could do??? or am i wrong???
mannyfrancis 4 years ago
what the fuck was that
SimplyStreisand 4 years ago
It is awesome to see a female Judas. Doesn't happen everyday, but this young lady did a wonderful job!!
ravenaten 4 years ago
i'd like to see the last supper between her and jesus
youdontknowjack24 4 years ago
nooooooooo!!!! BLASPHEMY!
grayberg 4 years ago
Interesting indeed, and being objetive, it's well done
Farinelly 4 years ago
interesting to see a female actor portray judas
youdontknowjack24 4 years ago