It is appalling that how much bullshit is propagated by the Hindu Rights. All the experts or the subject matter experts favor The Aryan Invasion Theory.
@gorloro You are right, India did have an advanced civilization but not they were not Aryan. Aryans came and conquered the locals. They learned everything from the local people, and gave India the caste system to remain at the top.
The majority of Europe speaks an Indo-European language that appears to have its roots in a Proto-Language that is believed to have originated between the Caucasus Mountains and ancient Mesopotamia including Zagros mountian,.Caucasian race of people" is an invention in 1795 by J F Blumenbach, a German,who based his conclusion on the beauty of a Georgian female skull found near Mount Caucasus.These people believe the Caucasian people began to fracture about 5,000 B.C. its meaning great Kurdistan
obvious, its reveal that any person who attempt to crack down falls hypothesis of the aryan of native of india they have to suffer from the aryan community.... cause they are not able to accept the truth of his past,,,, so it doesn't matter if someone of them protest the some person like thapar...becasue this is its nature.
Romila Thapar does not even know Sanskrit. In fact, Jawaharlal Nehru University, where Thapar and other Marxists studied, has no Sanskrit department! She says that bhakti yoga is just "the complete dependence of the serfs or tenants on the landowners in the context of Indian feudal society." Bhakti is an expression of divine love. Yet Thapar'ss Marxist leanings make her reduce it to the social level, because that is all Marxism is concerned about. She has no grasp of spirituality at all.
Marxists have always been contemptuous towards culture, and Thapar and her Marxist colleagues are the ideological heirs of Thomas Babington Macauley, who want to create Indians who were Indians in blood but English in taste, manners, and character. Hence they recycle British lies. Veer Savarkar in fact believed in the Aryan migration theory! He repeatedly refers to "Aryan blood" in his book "Hindutva Who is a Hindu?" Thus your idea that this is RSS propaganda is in and of itself propaganda.
The indigenous Aryan theory has significant evidence behind it, just read the writings of Koenraad Elst, Michael Danino, Vishal Agarwal etc. The only political motivations are those of Marxist "historians" who repackaged the Aryan Invasion Theory as the Aryan Migration Theory to credit the achievements of Hindu civilization to outsiders.
@prabhatpalpal The only "loons" here are Hindu hating Marxists like Thapar who consider anyone who doesn't agree with their pseudo-historical trash as "communalists." The Aryan Migration Theory is just a watered down version of the Aryan Invasion Theory that Thapar et al were forced to drop after being unable to provide a shred of evidence to support it.
The concept of a separate Aryan and Dravidian people is just as false as the concept of a Hutu and Tutsi people, and just as dangerous.
@si91 You are rejecting all the genetic and linguistic evidences. Moreover, the idea that Thapar is "Hindu hating" only implies your ulterior motive behind opposing the scientific consensus which is promoting your religion - which has nothing to do with the scientific truth of the theories you put forth. You see this as a religious issue and not a scientific issue.
@prabhatpalpal On the contrary, I reject the Aryan Migration Theory precisely on the basis of "all the genetic and linguistic evidences". Namely, that there is none to support the Aryan Migration Theory. I am calling Thapar "Hindu hating" not because I have any ulterior motive, but because she and other Marxists like DN Jha, KN Pannikar, Ifran Habib, and other Marxists accuse anyone who opposes their distortions as being Hindutva ideologues attempting to "saffronize" Indian history.
The Aryan Migration Theory is just as false as the Aryan Invasion Theory. Marxist historians like Romila Thapar , Ifran Habib, RS Sharma, and DN Jha, forced to abandon the Aryan Invasion Theory cling to the Aryan Migration Theory and criticize anyone who disagrees with their version of Indian History as being Hindutva fascists.This deflects criticism from their own Marxist propaganda drawn from the Marxist contempt for culture.
@si91 do you even know what marxist historian means? First of all it is spelled with a small 'm' to distinguish b/w political ideology and history. The chief tenets of Marxist historiography are the centrality of social class and economic constraints in determining historical outcomes - that's all.
@LeanJedi thank you for spreading more lies about the brutish empire in all your comments on youtube, you have been correctly called a scoundrel by Dr. Sam Johnson
@JustAStoner Thank you. Please convey my thanks to Dr. Sam Johnson, whoever he is. But if you are looking for lies and scoundrels, he you don't have to look too far. Romila Thapar, Michael Witzel, Stever Farmer, Fosse, R S Sharma is a good list to begin and end. And if one day, by luck, if you happen to have what Psychologist call SSE (significant emotional event), begin reading likes of Popper, Einstein, Kepler, Newton to realize nonsence created by lier list mentioned above. Peace!
she's being way to nice to not hurt ppls sentiments, the aryans are the harapan/indus valley civilization. aryan meaning noble and civilized people, suppose to be one of the oldes people, have the oldest language sanskrit, not found outside of subcontinent in that form, have the oldest text the vedas, one would think that the oldest matropolis i.e. the indus valley with its unmatched cities with drainage and all would therefore belong to such a civilization! Aryans are not nordic neatherals!
@ImmortalKshatriya I dont blame you for downplaying the fact your biggest accomplishments came from outside invaders.you can follow the strange trend in the west to understate euro. achievement, and deny the similarities between Sumaria and Harrapan culture(try not to stare at the blue eyes sumerian figures used to represent themselves).Your attempt is the sadder because your culture still so highly values those euro features you speak against.
aryan invasion theory, a white supremacist nazi christian british nonsense.
Aryan is a Hindu sanskrit word, used for those people who are spiritually advanced that's all, be they be of any race, color , place or religion.
SathuGopa 1 day ago
It is appalling that how much bullshit is propagated by the Hindu Rights. All the experts or the subject matter experts favor The Aryan Invasion Theory.
statickk14 1 week ago
I am a student of JNU, we know these anti-hindu elements very well. Irfan habib this bitch, kn panikkar all must be drowned in the brahmaputra.
mojorisin08 3 months ago
Aryans: Invasion, Indigenous or Migration?
In Fact Aryans never came to dominate the White Indian culture,
Huge buildings, and architecture there, existed for thousands of years ,
long before Caucasian get civilized.
Aryans=Caucasians; founders of Indus valley culture are Indigenous Non-Caucasian Whites. (Indo-European)
gorloro 3 months ago
@gorloro You are right, India did have an advanced civilization but not they were not Aryan. Aryans came and conquered the locals. They learned everything from the local people, and gave India the caste system to remain at the top.
statickk14 2 months ago
Comment removed
gorloro 3 months ago
Please watch "The Collapse of the Aryan Invasion Theory" by eminent historian Dr. Nicholas Kazanas
laks316 4 months ago
The majority of Europe speaks an Indo-European language that appears to have its roots in a Proto-Language that is believed to have originated between the Caucasus Mountains and ancient Mesopotamia including Zagros mountian,.Caucasian race of people" is an invention in 1795 by J F Blumenbach, a German,who based his conclusion on the beauty of a Georgian female skull found near Mount Caucasus.These people believe the Caucasian people began to fracture about 5,000 B.C. its meaning great Kurdistan
goran21715 4 months ago
obvious, its reveal that any person who attempt to crack down falls hypothesis of the aryan of native of india they have to suffer from the aryan community.... cause they are not able to accept the truth of his past,,,, so it doesn't matter if someone of them protest the some person like thapar...becasue this is its nature.
Divyesh779 4 months ago
Who cares if a couple of Iranians migrated to Northern India, and saw that the Dravidians have built such a magnificant city.
sovietamerican2 6 months ago
Hasn't she already reired?
SatRai 7 months ago
Romila Thapar does not even know Sanskrit. In fact, Jawaharlal Nehru University, where Thapar and other Marxists studied, has no Sanskrit department! She says that bhakti yoga is just "the complete dependence of the serfs or tenants on the landowners in the context of Indian feudal society." Bhakti is an expression of divine love. Yet Thapar'ss Marxist leanings make her reduce it to the social level, because that is all Marxism is concerned about. She has no grasp of spirituality at all.
si91 8 months ago
Marxists have always been contemptuous towards culture, and Thapar and her Marxist colleagues are the ideological heirs of Thomas Babington Macauley, who want to create Indians who were Indians in blood but English in taste, manners, and character. Hence they recycle British lies. Veer Savarkar in fact believed in the Aryan migration theory! He repeatedly refers to "Aryan blood" in his book "Hindutva Who is a Hindu?" Thus your idea that this is RSS propaganda is in and of itself propaganda.
si91 8 months ago
The indigenous Aryan theory has significant evidence behind it, just read the writings of Koenraad Elst, Michael Danino, Vishal Agarwal etc. The only political motivations are those of Marxist "historians" who repackaged the Aryan Invasion Theory as the Aryan Migration Theory to credit the achievements of Hindu civilization to outsiders.
si91 8 months ago
@si91 Nobody, outside this small circle of loons thinks that indigenous Aryan theory is scientific at all.
prabhatpalpal 4 months ago
@prabhatpalpal The only "loons" here are Hindu hating Marxists like Thapar who consider anyone who doesn't agree with their pseudo-historical trash as "communalists." The Aryan Migration Theory is just a watered down version of the Aryan Invasion Theory that Thapar et al were forced to drop after being unable to provide a shred of evidence to support it.
The concept of a separate Aryan and Dravidian people is just as false as the concept of a Hutu and Tutsi people, and just as dangerous.
si91 4 months ago
@si91 You are rejecting all the genetic and linguistic evidences. Moreover, the idea that Thapar is "Hindu hating" only implies your ulterior motive behind opposing the scientific consensus which is promoting your religion - which has nothing to do with the scientific truth of the theories you put forth. You see this as a religious issue and not a scientific issue.
prabhatpalpal 4 months ago
@prabhatpalpal On the contrary, I reject the Aryan Migration Theory precisely on the basis of "all the genetic and linguistic evidences". Namely, that there is none to support the Aryan Migration Theory. I am calling Thapar "Hindu hating" not because I have any ulterior motive, but because she and other Marxists like DN Jha, KN Pannikar, Ifran Habib, and other Marxists accuse anyone who opposes their distortions as being Hindutva ideologues attempting to "saffronize" Indian history.
si91 4 months ago
The Aryan Migration Theory is just as false as the Aryan Invasion Theory. Marxist historians like Romila Thapar , Ifran Habib, RS Sharma, and DN Jha, forced to abandon the Aryan Invasion Theory cling to the Aryan Migration Theory and criticize anyone who disagrees with their version of Indian History as being Hindutva fascists.This deflects criticism from their own Marxist propaganda drawn from the Marxist contempt for culture.
si91 8 months ago
@si91 do you even know what marxist historian means? First of all it is spelled with a small 'm' to distinguish b/w political ideology and history. The chief tenets of Marxist historiography are the centrality of social class and economic constraints in determining historical outcomes - that's all.
prabhatpalpal 4 months ago
lol you moron who are you comparing with what? if you have an SSE ud probably start reading shit instead of naming them together
JustAStoner 10 months ago
She is polite. She is also right when she says you can not have archeology of a language! Rest all she is saying (which is not much) is all BS!
LeanJedi 11 months ago
@LeanJedi thank you for spreading more lies about the brutish empire in all your comments on youtube, you have been correctly called a scoundrel by Dr. Sam Johnson
JustAStoner 10 months ago 4
@JustAStoner Thank you. Please convey my thanks to Dr. Sam Johnson, whoever he is. But if you are looking for lies and scoundrels, he you don't have to look too far. Romila Thapar, Michael Witzel, Stever Farmer, Fosse, R S Sharma is a good list to begin and end. And if one day, by luck, if you happen to have what Psychologist call SSE (significant emotional event), begin reading likes of Popper, Einstein, Kepler, Newton to realize nonsence created by lier list mentioned above. Peace!
LeanJedi 10 months ago 2
she's being way to nice to not hurt ppls sentiments, the aryans are the harapan/indus valley civilization. aryan meaning noble and civilized people, suppose to be one of the oldes people, have the oldest language sanskrit, not found outside of subcontinent in that form, have the oldest text the vedas, one would think that the oldest matropolis i.e. the indus valley with its unmatched cities with drainage and all would therefore belong to such a civilization! Aryans are not nordic neatherals!
ImmortalKshatriya 1 year ago 2
@ImmortalKshatriya I dont blame you for downplaying the fact your biggest accomplishments came from outside invaders.you can follow the strange trend in the west to understate euro. achievement, and deny the similarities between Sumaria and Harrapan culture(try not to stare at the blue eyes sumerian figures used to represent themselves).Your attempt is the sadder because your culture still so highly values those euro features you speak against.
1fangodzilla 8 months ago
@ImmortalKshatriya what a shame that people like you are actively involved in deceiving my countrymen by concocting unscientific crap.
prabhatpalpal 4 months ago
awesome video
shows rss propaganda
wetocool3 1 year ago
@wetocool3 just goes to show how u guys plan to keep the invasion justified
JustAStoner 10 months ago