The tempo is just right for a Bach minuet!This is not an etude to play it fast, but in fact Minuet is a dance played during Bach's times by nobility. Just try to imagine those guys jumping around fast with all the wigs and costumes... It can be played even slower, for a more artistic expression, but I find your feel quite natural. And your teacher will agree with me, MoonlightSpy, you are doing well.
Thank you MoonlightSpy. You have helped me learn this piece by playing at the tempo you like. I have no lessons at all, but love the piece and hope to learn it. It seems tricky to me. I admire all of you musicians!
I recently started playing piano and this is my first piece , taught i can't play it well (well, i had only 3 lessons) yet. ^^ Good job, i hope I will get good like you ^^
ya i have been playing the piano for 2years. So you ahve been playing for sum years now huh? oh and by the way thx for clearing up what the tempo should be^^
its good, but its too slow.
happygirliesmartie 3 years ago
its supposed to be super slow.. durrr.
ameliapd93 3 years ago
U know, someone marked my other comment BAD.
BUT, I AM GONNA STICK WITH IT.
I am trying to get this on a musical mobile.
ITS SO GOOD.
I LOVE IT.
1992peter 3 years ago
The tempo is just right for a Bach minuet!This is not an etude to play it fast, but in fact Minuet is a dance played during Bach's times by nobility. Just try to imagine those guys jumping around fast with all the wigs and costumes... It can be played even slower, for a more artistic expression, but I find your feel quite natural. And your teacher will agree with me, MoonlightSpy, you are doing well.
greekcydippe 3 years ago
Thank you...I appreciate your comment
MoonlightSpy 3 years ago
Thank you MoonlightSpy. You have helped me learn this piece by playing at the tempo you like. I have no lessons at all, but love the piece and hope to learn it. It seems tricky to me. I admire all of you musicians!
henrypaz 4 years ago
Thank you! And I hope you get better than me^^
MoonlightSpy 4 years ago
I recently started playing piano and this is my first piece , taught i can't play it well (well, i had only 3 lessons) yet. ^^ Good job, i hope I will get good like you ^^
Aninora 4 years ago
It's nice you play it with feeling. But it might be better if you play it a bit faster?
dcolwell 4 years ago
oh! thx for the tip!
MoonlightSpy 4 years ago
BRAVO BRAVO
CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP
You need to have your music placed on a C.D. fair and square!!
1992peter 4 years ago
You're kidding right? Come on, Really? ^^
MoonlightSpy 4 years ago
no
please post some more.
I LOVE MINUETS BUT MINUETS ARE EVEN BETTER WHEN THEY'RE PLAYED SLOWLY.
PLEASE POST SOME MORE.
PLEASE
THE BEST ONE I LIKE PLAYED SLOW IS THE MINUET IN G MINOR FROM THE ANNA MAGDELINA BACH NOTEBOOK.
I LOVE THAT ONE.
YOU'RE DOING GOOOOOOOD!
1992peter 4 years ago
i'm begging ya.
you're great.
i'm fixin to place you in me favorite's list and rate ya *****.
I LOVE SLOW MINUETS.
ESPECIALLY THE ONE IN G MINOR. BRAVO
1992peter 4 years ago
Well thank you. I'll try to post more :)but you know, things happen unexpectedly
MoonlightSpy 4 years ago
THANKS.
REMEMBER.
YOU PLAY BEAUTIFULLY!
You're welcome.
GOD BLESS!
1992peter 4 years ago
Great job!!
ilovemusic998 4 years ago
i can play it five times faster
flaminboy2 4 years ago
So I don't care I play it the way I want to express it :P
MoonlightSpy 4 years ago
the notes i have say "slowly and calmly" so not much faster than what is played on this video is probably ideal.
ecspade 4 years ago
Nice, how long you play the piano? 2 years? I also played this menuet (about 3-4 years ago)
bashado 4 years ago
ya i have been playing the piano for 2years. So you ahve been playing for sum years now huh? oh and by the way thx for clearing up what the tempo should be^^
MoonlightSpy 4 years ago
play it like you like.
you're in me favorite's list and you've been raited by me as a *****.
1992peter 4 years ago
Ignore msiukA. It's an interperation. Bach didn't set any specification for this minuet on tempo. There is no "Perfect interpretation".
iiirdeyeheretik 4 years ago
I guess you are right but now that masiukA brought it up I like it better faster -_-
MoonlightSpy 4 years ago
i will tape myself playing, at my speed, my teacher says mine is perfection, u have the song down really well, perfect, only speed up alot.
MasiukA 4 years ago
LOL ok...hee hee
MoonlightSpy 4 years ago
way way too slow....
MasiukA 4 years ago
How fast is it supposed to go? can you tell me?m PLZ!!!BTW thanks for telling me
MoonlightSpy 4 years ago