黎明leon lai 1991 華東水災籌款走音

[nitesec]

好明顯一開始入錯key, 當年電視直播我已經預到佢會走音

[auholun1995]

1:04



[auholun1995]

1:06



[xingxing14]

比起今日果d走音當食生菜啦

[lemonlovestea]

我覺得佢之後個表情好可愛XD

[yukigagaga]

ok ge 不過真係好笑ge

[chrissylixoxo]

Laugh die me lol

[Sykespan]

虽然走音还迷倒亿万fans可见他魅力没法挡

[cting5]

@frying0stingray

眞的不知你立什麼心腸！

[MolsonpEx]

11歲樂基兒睇住你xD

[lewis167]

真係唔關佢事

係彈琴果個彈高左key

[SinoZouiS]

1:06

[PandaWenSi]

其实只不过是他开头唱高左个key。。 leon走音都甘可爱嘎 :)

[drkkyip]

In fact, it is NOT Leon's fault.

First of all, the pianist used too high a key Bm for Leon as the song is supposed to be Gm. When Leon could not reach the note on F# and totally silent on G and A, the pianist discovered his fault and also skilfully lowered to the key to Gm for Leon to finish the remaining part. The pianist was also skillful to cut the second part short and gave melody leading for Leon to follow.

When we see other's faults, do see why it comes and how to avoid or rectify it.

[drkkyip]

In fact, it is NOT Leon's fault.

First of all, the pianist used too high a key Bm for Leon as the song is supposed to be Gm. When Leon could not reach the note on F# and totally silent on G and A, the pianist discovered his fault and also skilfully lowered to the key to Gm for Leon to finish the remaining part. The pianist was also skillful to cut the second part short and gave melody leading for Leon to follow. When we see other's faults, do see why it comes and how to avoid or rectify

[neihomai8]

@drkkyip watch the video again, leon started the key first and then the pianist followed. so it was leon's fault that he started with the wrong pitch that he couldn't handle himself

[drkkyip]

@neihomai8 but I notice that, before Leon opened his mouth, in the initial 2 beats, there was indeed a sound with a B note coming out. I wonder that was really the leading note from the pianist. Anyhow, to be very exact in the initial pitch without instrumental lead is not easy unless you have perfect pitch. And if Leon was experienced enough, he could have felt that his voice reached the impossible zone of G and A and so he could have rapidly changed to falsetto to avoid embarrassment.

[francesckong]

以前d歌手走一走音比人有排笑,而家好多歌手走音係家常便飯

[TSMSiemens]

虽然有点走音，可是他还是坚持把整首歌演绎完，可见他真的很专业­，而且他懂得从错误中学习，他现在唱歌比以前进步多了，加油，黎­明天王！！！永远支持你！！

[BillboardClassic]

i remember this one 20 years ago.

he is classy and this is classic

[max0715]

我覺得最重要係因為大走音 而且佢又忍唔住笑左

[MegaSkytree]

有品德的人, 都不會嘲笑別人的過失 ,只有沒有道德, 品味的人士, 才會這樣做,年長要成為年輕人的榜樣, 因果循環, 將來自己也可能會給別人取笑？

[lau5566932]

笑足20年 真好幾好笑 HAHA

仲要 走左幾次音 甩左 一小段 

[MegaSkytree]

第301期蒙牛酸酸乳中联榜港台榜的冠军，是黎明的《See You Latter》，作品是一首带有上世纪雷颂德(微博)式舞曲口味­­的作品，而这首歌在第二周上榜就能拿到冠军，也说明“四大天王­”­魅力依然、人气依然。

以上資料來源:-

301期蒙牛酸酸乳中联榜港台榜：黎明人气依然

作者: 腾讯娱乐, 發表於: 2011-05-31, 13:42 (1 日, 8 小時53 分鐘前) @ ....

ent.qq.com/a/20110531/000204.h­tm

[MegaSkytree]

發表回覆

事實勝於雄辯,黎明最近新歌-SEE YOU LATER,在香港和中國都有很好的成績:-

第301期蒙牛酸酸乳中联榜港台榜的冠军，是黎明的《See You Latter》，作品是一首带有上世纪雷颂德(微博)式舞曲口味­的作品，而这首歌在第二周上榜就能拿到冠军，也说明“四大天王”­魅力依然、人气依然。

网易娱乐4月13日报道 最近一直有大动作的天王黎明，最新执导的MV作品《迟D见》（国­语版名为《See You Later》），开创了全球3D真人头动画身制作MV的先河，并­于昨天在香港某院线举行了隆重的首播仪式，全港娱乐媒体齐聚，共­同见证了这场香港音乐市场的盛事。席间，黎明更被记者封为“MV­教父”，基于多年来一直对香港本土音乐作出的成绩与贡献，黎天王­获此封号也当之无愧。

以上資料只供各位分享.

[MegaSkytree]

我希望各位可以作正面的評價, 這MTV已是二十年前的,

直至現在,黎明仍然不斷受到批評,若各位都是生于九十年代,

佢D歌由細聽到大,應該這樣說:[佢以前唱得不好,現在進步

很多, 值得一讚.] 若是黎生的fans,都知道佢進步不少.若不是

fans, 可能很少聽, 又 如何能中肯的評論呢?

[mg1228]

佢一入已經唱高左key，唔係駛乜入piano救佢...

[MegaSkytree]

Don't laughing at him, It's very impolite. His EQ is very high.

In this situation, he insisted to singing the whole song. From

this matter, he gave the positive message to us, although

we may meet some difficulties in my life, but we will be

successfu if we insist to try our best. His spirit is

admirable.

[itisafineday2009]

次次睇都笑!

[lingpakkei]

其實首歌幾好聽，不過佢唱,,

[MegaSkytree]

@lingpakkei This MV was 20 years ago. Pls search to watch

the MV of 2010 年度十大勁歌金曲表演-the song is 情深說話未曾講

which is also in this area. He sang very well. Have you listened

to his songs before. Many people have never heard his songs and

give negative opinion just like a little child who hasn't grown

up and carries out the adult's orders without his personal comment.

The child don't know how to distinguish right or wrong of things and

only trust others' opinions. Pls study more and comment.

[airbornin]

@lingpakkei 祝願你在工作中有任何的出錯也會被人嘲笑一生一世, 無論你幾努力都好, 別人也認為你沒工作能力, 因為你曾經犯過一次錯誤, 永世也要被看貶... 你覺得我在咒你? 我只係想你易地而處!

[lingpakkei]

@airbornin

你這樣生氣是為甚麼了？我講一句都唔得？我根本沒有惡意貶低他！­也沒有打算嘲笑他一生一世！

佢D歌我由細聽到大，咁我的確覺得佢唱得唔好喎:O

喂，你喺我一句「其實首歌幾好聽，不過佢唱」睇到D乜？睇到我無­視佢既努力？有咩？

而家我冇覺得你咒我，我只覺得你屈我！！

[lobelia2]

沒有才華的‘歌手’

[earthgroundful]

@lobelia2 It is only your comment that he is not the talent

singer. Have you listen to his recent concert? Please

search to hear, you may have another opinions about

him. If it still cannot change your comments about him,

please don't watch his mv because you dislike him and

prejudice against him. If you still want to criticise him,

please watch his mv and recent concert again and then

make comparison but not only give wrong comments

to mislead others.

[lobelia2]

@earthgroundful

awwwwwww, fanboy gets offended by a little criticism. that's part of life. deal with it. you must be a 15 yr old girl

[earthgroundful]

@lobelia2 I think if you want to criticise, pls spend much

time to understand him first but not just say he is not a

talent singer without any evidence or supporting to mislead

others. Be a mature adult, it is important to speak truthfully. I

don't understand you, so I will not comment on you. Many fans

tell the truth about him in this case but you only criticise that

have covered the whole truth. It is unfair to him. Sorry, I am

not 15 yr old girl. You make the mistake again.

[lobelia2]

@earthgroundful

be that as it may. but the fact of the matter is that in my opinion he has no talent. you may say you want about the man. but you have to learn to take criticism. it's all part of the entertainment industry. i think that he has no talent at all, and it's my freedom to express my thought. if you disagree with me then so be it. i do not need to backup my statements with proof or evidence. it is my opinion and therefore i own it.

[earthgroundful]

@lobelia2 If it is the fair comments, I will accept but if it is unfair

critism, I will reject. Yes, it is the entertainment industry, smart

one knows how to distinguish the critism "he is no talent" is correct

or not for without proof or evidence. I hope the other people will

search his recent concert to watch(2001, 2005, 2009), may be

have different comments on him.

[justinwong02714]

笑笑下，咁就笑左20年

做歌手真係難

[banditex2010]

哈哈哈哈哈走音!?

[WindLakeMountain]

＠dagoodwatcher 講得甚對！這一個 "ANDY LAU劉華 LEON LAI黎明經典大合唱 1 " !可以為證！已離世嘅寶詠琴當年捐獻五萬元點唱這一首。而他已經­離開現場而再跑回來。為善而給無恥人唱至今天，其心可明！

[MrKint1129]

但他已經很好...仍然很堅持唱下去...

[kinosukai]

看回同一年同为筹款所拍摄的《豪门夜宴》，

黎明对于自己的走音表现得很豁达呀

[WindLakeMountain]

講真，其實吾係走音，而係失音！

[ray1443224]

之前果段又比人del左,哈

[weige2006]

有大將之風

[jing713]

好笑！！！！！！！！

[phyllisppp]

點解清唱會有龬琴伴奏既？

[dagoodwatcher]

@phyllisppp 大會樂隊已收隊，因為其實籌款亦完畢。黎明開始都話咗清唱，並無­諗到有人能伴奏嘅！綱琴公司未接收，綱琴手未能離開，其實都未得­人同意，自告奮勇，好有表現欲，佢的確又似好心做壞事！

[missclaudia12a]

一向不喜歡黎明, 但很佩服他走了音還保持專業一直唱下去.

[stefyu]

我覺得佢唱得好好,好得意哈哈哈

走音仲可以咁有大將之風!

抵我細細個鐘意佢到而家!

某些人只針對黎明,其他人走音卻不罵他

[linedancehongkong]

雖然走左音,但我覺得好好聽

[TCEYDD]

唔講劉郭2人, 其實張學友都一樣咁走音, 印象之中係唱愛是永恆, 不過黎明同傳媒/同行關係真係唔太好, 當時差不多比99%傳媒+同行落井下石 (甚至唱到e+), 真係唯一夠膽企出黎支持下黎明, 講句公道說話既人只得張國榮............



[schlepp2012]

黎明,好可憐,為了籌款,比人笑左20年

當時聽,覺得佢走音好誇張

但今日再聽,只係覺得現今歌手偶有失場的表現

不用日講夜講,幾十年後又講一餐

[doraemon2151]

呢首歌原key係Bb, 呢度佢唱個key係D, 高左4個key wor!!

"立定決心以後分離" 個"心"同個"分"係A4, 唔係個個唱到架, 加上leon聲底比較低, 換轉當年既郭天王同劉天王都未必唱到啦, 佢地係後期D歌先越黎越高音姐

反而"我又怕心難死" 個 "死"字係 F#3, 咁都走音就離譜左D

利益申報: 本人並非leon fans, 不喜勿插

[WindLakeMountain]

未知道各位有多大年紀，又或真懂唱歌否？懂音樂，未必懂唱歌！你­們可以嘗試如當年的黎明，在身體不適下，已經不在現場，知道有人­願意捐獻點他唱歌。於是他再乘車回到現場，從球場繞道跑上台，即­時清唱（那個伴奏的真懂這首歌的音？他只在彈他自己的琴鍵而矣）­，相信你必體會明白。便會明白為何會走音！或許他應飲一兩口清水­，以滋潤聲帶！再者，換轉這是另一位大歌手，相信反而會被原諒！­就是當年在勁歌金曲，張學友不是一樣的走了音？但始終沒有如黎明­一樣地給人唱通街至今！他還藉口說給別人的音影響了！又沒有人提­及！而黎明的走音事，差不多廿年，想，都是因為樹大招風！出度不­久，居然有富太點唱！為款項增多不少！

[airbornin]

@WindLakeMountain 講得好~ 已經差不多20年仲俾人狂插這次完全趕返現場完全無準備之下的演­出, 仲要俾個徐日勤整高左幾個key, 喂, 大佬呀黎明當年仲係新仔一名咋, 你地鬧左咁多年仲唔夠? 別人50/60分已經讚得好好, 黎明拿80分都仲無僅僅合格, 每次都係咁挑剔佢, 找佢錯處, 佢承受左幾多壓力呀? 佢今日唱功已經穩拿80分, 都係多得雞蛋裡挑骨頭的人. 亦非常佩服黎明能夠承受巨大的壓力及被無理批鬥

[airbornin]

@WindLakeMountain 講得好~ 已經差不多20年仲俾人狂插這次完全趕返現場完全無準備之下的演­出, 仲要俾個徐日勤整高左幾個key, 喂, 大佬呀黎明當年仲係新仔一名咋, 你地鬧左咁多年仲唔夠? 別人50/60分已經讚得好好, 黎明拿80分都仲無僅僅合格, 每次都係咁挑剔佢, 找佢錯處, 佢承受左幾多壓力呀? 佢今日唱功已經穩拿80分, 都係多得雞蛋裡挑骨頭的人. 亦非常佩服黎明能夠承受巨大的壓力及被無理批鬥

[WindLakeMountain]

@airbornin 你都講得好，懂事理！俾人踐踏，其實都因為高於水平，突出之理！­這樣才不至使自己低於他人，相距太遠！

[fatko123456]

@WindLakeMountain 走音就走音啦，仲死撐

[WindLakeMountain]

@fatko123456 證明你係唱吾到歌既人，所以妒忌靚仔黎明啦！今日仲有人上載，證­明嫉妒無寧日既真理！梅艷芳當年係台上都係唱吾到黎明既歌而為自­已掩飾！到今日黎明都無為自己辯護過！只係我地呢啲見義勇為嘅人­為黎明不值！無論如何，清者自清，濁者自濁！

[TheFlashDwade25]

@WindLakeMountain 講咁多做乜 ? 走音就走音 其他理由都係籍口

人類就係現實 我冇興趣研究你背後既因由

走音就要俾人恥笑

[WindLakeMountain]

@TheFlashDwade25 咁你又搭嘴做勿！黎明唱歌有為自己辯護過咩？你講咁多都係自暴其­短！就係吾識唱歌，妒忌一時走音既歌手居然後來被人冠為天王！

[TheFlashDwade25]

@WindLakeMountain 我有話黎明為自己辯護咩 ?

我係串你地 d 戇鳩仔為佢辯護咋

我妒忌黎明做乜 ? 我又冇發明星夢

你搞返好 d 邏輯先啦

冇啦啦企出黎俾人侮辱 戇鳩仔

[WindLakeMountain]

@TheFlashDwade25 有諸於內，形諸於外！滿口污穢之言，顯然是未開化、未受教育之人­的表達方式！難怪未懂得人家所表達的內容是甚麼，還要學人辯論！­居然學人講邏輯！＂黎明唱歌有為自己辯護過咩？＂係一個問題！表­明黎明的氣量沒有一般人之膚淺！其為人之溫文儒雅與敦厚過去廿多­年可見一斑！可見同類人才會支持他！

[TheFlashDwade25]

@WindLakeMountain 弱智 講成段又都係到掩飾自己講既野唔夠 point

走音走到咁仲有咩可以辯護 ? 唔好神化黎明啦 低能仔

[earthgroundful]

@TheFlashDwade25

[earthgroundful]

@TheFlashDwade25 you dislike Leon,pls don't watch his video .

Agree to @WindLakeMountain‘s opinion, he is a wise,kind,calm,tolerant person.

He has donated much time to work for charities to help the poor(e.g. 公益金... etc) After his mistake

in singing in 1991,he tries his best to improve his singing.Now his singing worths 80 marks(his

fans comment). Please please don't blame on him anymore. It is unfair to him. Thanks thanks..

thanks thanks thanks.....a lot!!!!

[WindLakeMountain]

@earthgroundful You have sharp eyes! But the guy won't understand what you have said.

[earthgroundful]

@WindLakeMountain My typing in Chinese is the worst so I use English instead.

Would you mind to translate them into Chinese to let more people understand.

Thanks!! We are all support Leon because of his humble, sincere, serious

personality and also kindness, sympathy towards the poor.

Nice to recognize you!

[WindLakeMountain]

@TheFlashDwade25 原來你真係弱智兼眼盲耳聾！

[TheFlashDwade25]

@WindLakeMountain 你講乜呀呀 廢柴 ? 戇鳩仔冇啦啦講句野覺得自己好有 point ? 食屎啦去

[WindLakeMountain]

@TheFlashDwade25 吾怪得啲空氣咁臭啦！！！！原來你係食屎嘅！以為講一兩次你可以­會精啲，但係，因為盲兼聾！幫你傳話嘅點傳呀？所以之前我都話囉­未受過教育嘅人係咁吾開化嘅！連啲已經係渣滓嘅嘢，已經入咗馬桶­囉，你都照食，仲要叫人食！我就吾會食啦，容勿易會好似你一樣咁­口臭呀！你應該吾好食，做下公德將呢啲嘢送去菜田施肥，咁就可以­唱歌唱得好過黎明啦！空氣都會清新啲而吾會再受污染囉 !

[TheFlashDwade25]

@WindLakeMountain 你真係戇鳩鳩咁 我打成段有 point 既野串你

你回 d乜野俾我 ? 講埋 d 小學雞野 你答到我其中一個 point 先啦

講成段野都廢既 好心你唔好再係到獻世啦 廢柴

[WindLakeMountain]

@TheFlashDwade25 你的表現，有知識之人士都明白，我所說的全對！證明你自己的料子­是如何，兼且真的很禮義廉！

[TheFlashDwade25]

@WindLakeMountain 你咪扮君子囉 癲狗咁講完一 d 廢話

俾人串到應一應 又扮返有禮貌 ? 最撚憎就係你 d 咁既人

又要冇料 又要企出黎俾人屌 又要扮君子

[PerfectDiver]

@WindLakeMountain 張學友 勁歌金曲走音 ? 有無得睇下??

[frying0stingray]

@WindLakeMountain 你真得很會為人找藉口

[ytwsd]

@doraemon2151 雖然我唔係太識樂理,只識唱K,但我聽番都覺原佢真係彈高左個K­EY

[NickyTong]

@doraemon2151 應該說高左2度/4個半度吧-.-

手歌係咪佢開始自己唱d key呢?如果係就真係冇計... 佢唔小心開錯左...

[lwc888]

@doraemon2151 Oh cmon is it really 4 keys higher? Even I can sing this. If it was really a lot higher, I wouldn't be able to.

[WindLakeMountain]

@doraemon2151 其實懂聲樂嘅，都會明白，公平說話，四大天王，音域最廣嘅係黎明­，唱歌吾係念口王！唱歌可以講係傳達感情為要，張學友亦吾係唱得­最好嘅一個，佢只係聲大與厚，其實真係各有千秋。張學友同一個富­太係籌款合唱，不論唱功與感情，亦不及她唱得好，亦不見得有人批­評。

[lkmfatyip]

應該是為了籌款而唱的吧..

沒有預備好, 狀態好差

[258943364]

李克勤當年真係慘!

[174063444]

呢段片真係刪唔完 LOLLL