I agree. It needs drums and bass. Rob Ellis should have stayed on the drums. His piano chords don't fit against those PJ's strumming. Tim Farthing could have switched to bass.
Love PJ's voice here ... it sounds so deceptively unpolished and raw, yet steady.
And no, those two Polish chicks while technically skilled singers do not do this song justice in my opinion, sounds as if they're attempting to oversing it.
w porównaniu z HEY i AGNIESZKĄ CHYLIŃSKĄ to jest bardzo cienkie wykonanie.wiem,że ta wspaniała piosenka jest tej pani,która teraz śpiewa,ale ta pani nie dorównuje ani troszkę skali głosów naszych cudownych rodaczek.to,co stworzyły one we dwie(czyli aga i hej) jest tak piękne,że aż pszechodzą ciary.CUDOWNE.dziękuję.
@Alec0209 w porównaniu z HEY i AGNIESZKĄ CHYLIŃSKĄ to jest bardzo cienkie wykonanie.wiem,że ta wspaniała piosenka jest tej pani,która teraz śpiewa,ale ta pani nie dorównuje ani troszkę skali głosów naszych cudownych rodaczek.to,co stworzyły one we dwie(czyli aga i hej) jest tak piękne,że aż pszechodzą ciary.CUDOWNE.dziękuję.
Please stop being rude telling us how much better a polish version is of this song, we can judge for ourselves. Your opinon is just another grain of sand on the beach.
@peterjgreaves Some covers really are better than the originals (majority of listeners like cover better) for example "whiskey in the jar" and theres nothing rude in saying it loud, face it
I'm amazad at her facility here... I dont know why, I mean she does it as easily at the big day out on Rid of Me, but here it just struck me, her voice is simply perfect
ja się w 100% zgadzam z przedmówcą. słabo słabo i jeszcze raz słabo. w Mam Talent odpadła by na eliminacjach! w ogóle ten głos ma jakiś taki nieciekawy i po 10 sekundach piosenki już jestem nią znudzony. Nosowska z Chylińska na łeb ją pobiły. surowy głos PJ? chyba jednak nie
co jest, polaki dyskutują po angielsku między sobą haha ;d kawałek mi się w ogóle nie podoba. co z tego że ładna jest, jak nie śpiewa w ogóle czysto, w dodatku wokal słabo wykończony jest.
haha pewnie angol jakiś :D czysto to znaczy że intonacja conajmniej nie rani. wykończenie to to wszystko co jest między nutkami - artykulacja dźwięków.
aha, no teraz rozumiem. pewnie w muzie robisz? no nic, moze ta nieudaczna, intonacyjnie kaleka i majaca problemy z artykulacja Harvey, kiedys wzniesie sie na wyzyny dostepne tylko wybranym i w przyplywie szalenstwa zagra jakiegos dobrego covera. np: '' winna, niczyja i pieprz az do bolu '', czy inna swiatowej klasy produkcje.
troche sie bawie. same jej umiejętności myślę że są świetne ... ale te trzęsące się dźwięki to efekt źle przygotowanego kawałka. ona śpiewa trochę niżej niż w ogóle potrafi. a wystarczyło go jeszcze raz nauczyć się ale o jeden dźwięk wyżej. i "by było". a covery? covery to nie jest najbardziej ambitna zabawa świata. tyle że "ludzie lubią" :)))))))))))))))))))))
ok check out white chalk, all of songs from her stories from the city, stories from the sea album-her best i think! her earlier stuff is amazing too incredibly raw, very guitar based-like rid of me and man size.
uh huh her album is a master piece. her new project with john parish a woman a man walked by is amazing..i went to their concert and almost died.. is amazing how she connects with the audience..
Heya :) thanks to everyone for replying i've checked most of them and theyre all very good, so i congratulate you on your good taste, so just yh thnx a lot!!!! :P
That's rite mate. I love PJ Harvey's raw sound. Chylinska's part is warmed up a bit (Nosowska sticks with the original sound-like, but that's her recognizbale style [kinda similar to PJ's). Still good though.
Hmm... The problem is... Why are you trying to compare Nosowska (Hey) & Chylińska (O.N.A.) version with the original one? They both are really good but far different from each other and imposible to compare.
when was this recorded?! it would be nice if people who videos on here would actually put some info. under info. words to the song is not really info.!!!
I think Hey make a similar noise but in no way reach the molecular depth of delivery that PJ uses as standard in all her work, I'm sure hey would not say their version is in any way superior to any of PJ's, but have given it to a wider audience, which is good.
F@#%IN GREAT!!!!! Thanks for sharing!!! Where did you find this LIVE, if you do not mind me asking???? I saw this tour in NYC!!!!! Do you have more????
bardzo podobało mi sie to ze chylińska w wykonaniu z Hey zaspiewała to po swojemu aintrepretowala to jak chciała to było niesamowite.Kasia nosowska zaspiewala ladnie ale zabardzo podobne to oryginału
This has been flagged as spam show
I love the piano chords. It just makes the song sound so much more beautiful.
xxkarinka19x 3 months ago
Comment removed
xxkarinka19x 3 months ago
life ain't kind
inaians 4 months ago
Absolutely Hauntingly Beautiful.
foundfruit 5 months ago
Absolutely Beautiful.
foundfruit 5 months ago
How come this video doesn't have over 10mln views? I don't understand this world.
maverickmarcin89 6 months ago
yes, she is crying.. havent seen her cry like this on stage.. This song and 'beautiful leah' soundtracks to my life..
theskyturns 7 months ago
Live in...?
Beautiful song + album <3.
annamadaisy 7 months ago
fuckin jebus her hair is desh
kaykieslice 9 months ago
what's kind of guitar is that?
Lois1980 9 months ago
Comment removed
Lois1980 9 months ago
Is she crying? this song is amazing
ParaParaschiva 10 months ago
Uwielbiam tą piosenkę.
SayuriMatachashi 10 months ago
A Goddess Walks Among Us !
uwillbe 10 months ago
Agnieszka Chylinska & Hey (nosowska) Tam sa jaja, jest moc i energia.
Caroolyn19 11 months ago
i miss the drums and bass from this though.
maybe cause i play bass and love the groove this song has?
tcdowning666 1 year ago
@tcdowning666
I agree. It needs drums and bass. Rob Ellis should have stayed on the drums. His piano chords don't fit against those PJ's strumming. Tim Farthing could have switched to bass.
m06een00 6 months ago
śpiewa ładnie ale ma małe cycki :P
hubercik23 1 year ago 2
@hubercik23
a co ma jedno z drugim wspolnego?!
druga czesc komentarza zupelnie nie na miejscu.
OllalaG 11 months ago
@OllalaG nie spinaj się tak :P
hubercik23 11 months ago
@hubercik23 Fuck you.
iLikeCookie88 11 months ago
@iLikeCookie88 ok im gonna fuck myself :)
hubercik23 11 months ago
@hubercik23 Have fun.
iLikeCookie88 11 months ago
@iLikeCookie88 r u mad? :P
hubercik23 11 months ago
@hubercik23 Yes, I'm mad - PJ is a talented woman and all you can do is talk about the size of her boobs. Feck off!
iLikeCookie88 11 months ago
@iLikeCookie88 I agree with u :) she's talented woman ;) what i told abut her boobs was joke :) calm down :]
hubercik23 11 months ago
@hubercik23 Er.. I am calm!
iLikeCookie88 11 months ago
I want to bang her so much.
Christoffuckers 1 year ago
geez i been listenin to her for a long while now but i never realized she was so flippin beautiful for real...i wish the drummer had been playing.
singingfeces 1 year ago
What do i have to do to get into this woman's band?
BACCHUS441 1 year ago
quanto è bella.. (lei)
7kurosawa7 1 year ago
Love PJ's voice here ... it sounds so deceptively unpolished and raw, yet steady.
And no, those two Polish chicks while technically skilled singers do not do this song justice in my opinion, sounds as if they're attempting to oversing it.
adamcrookedsmile 1 year ago 5
Hey(katarzyna nosowska) MTV Unplugged - Angelene ft Agnieszka Chylińska. the best cover by big star from Poland
SuperLeepa 1 year ago 8
pj is the best i love her so much she is great live and in a league of her own innit ?x
cptdc 1 year ago
Thankyou for this video. ; )
vishuiqual 1 year ago
w porównaniu z HEY i AGNIESZKĄ CHYLIŃSKĄ to jest bardzo cienkie wykonanie.wiem,że ta wspaniała piosenka jest tej pani,która teraz śpiewa,ale ta pani nie dorównuje ani troszkę skali głosów naszych cudownych rodaczek.to,co stworzyły one we dwie(czyli aga i hej) jest tak piękne,że aż pszechodzą ciary.CUDOWNE.dziękuję.
chrupencja007 1 year ago
great video.
Alec0209 1 year ago
@Alec0209 w porównaniu z HEY i AGNIESZKĄ CHYLIŃSKĄ to jest bardzo cienkie wykonanie.wiem,że ta wspaniała piosenka jest tej pani,która teraz śpiewa,ale ta pani nie dorównuje ani troszkę skali głosów naszych cudownych rodaczek.to,co stworzyły one we dwie(czyli aga i hej) jest tak piękne,że aż pszechodzą ciary.CUDOWNE.dziękuję.
chrupencja007 1 year ago
Please stop being rude telling us how much better a polish version is of this song, we can judge for ourselves. Your opinon is just another grain of sand on the beach.
peterjgreaves 1 year ago 17
@peterjgreaves Some covers really are better than the originals (majority of listeners like cover better) for example "whiskey in the jar" and theres nothing rude in saying it loud, face it
Kazomenes 1 year ago
@peterjgreaves much much better! Your version is just another grain of sand on the beach
faraofffaraoff 6 months ago
@peterjgreaves - polish version is just a great tribute to PJ Harvey.
simonnavoy 5 months ago
Hm. This song is amazing. But version of Agnieszka Chylińska and Katarzyna Nosowska is very, very, very amazing and beautiful.
BonesTemperanceBrenn 1 year ago
in you tube nosowska chylinska mega better cover angelene
selestat76 1 year ago
I love you, Polly Jean Harvey!!!!
pattyhansen 1 year ago
@pattyhansen
we all love you polly jean... cheers from italy!!
TheJaddjamil 1 year ago
salinger fan here!!!
malt0987 1 year ago
i doon't like this versin.
I prefer hey&chylińska version. ;)
Liveey 1 year ago 3
@Liveey
I totally agree :)
Eiinaar 1 year ago
@Liveey I agree with you.. Their version has the power...
aniazsk 1 year ago
@Liveey actually, we can't say PJ Harvey's Angelene is version. It's HER song, but I have to agree that their cover is better, more powerful ;)
WickedMargot 1 year ago
sometimes I think this song has written to me...
Such a pretty lie...!
amanecerOT 1 year ago
Sometimes I think this song has been composed to me...
Such a pretty lie...!
amanecerOT 1 year ago
PJ Harvey <Kate Bush & Kristin Hersh.The absolute cream of contemporary song craft.Not of all time,but NOW.
TumbrelJockey 1 year ago 2
I'm amazad at her facility here... I dont know why, I mean she does it as easily at the big day out on Rid of Me, but here it just struck me, her voice is simply perfect
KalikaInLeather 1 year ago 2
sad song
budmotor 1 year ago
She looks like one of Tolkien's elves in this video. That's meant as a compliment.
She is the prettiest mess I've ever seen.
kooshari 2 years ago 4
pretty mouth and green my eyes
"linda boquita y vertes tus ojos"
9 stories
J.D. Salinger
nice link.... dont you think?
vermasvidrio 2 years ago 4
Two thousand miles until I reach that open road...
niqa07 2 years ago 11
this version is very nicee!!
keniapowa 2 years ago
Madrigal!
usergently 2 years ago
Is this Desire was her masterpiece
keeblin 2 years ago 5
... was one of her numerous masterpieces :)
malfaitw 2 years ago 8
ja się w 100% zgadzam z przedmówcą. słabo słabo i jeszcze raz słabo. w Mam Talent odpadła by na eliminacjach! w ogóle ten głos ma jakiś taki nieciekawy i po 10 sekundach piosenki już jestem nią znudzony. Nosowska z Chylińska na łeb ją pobiły. surowy głos PJ? chyba jednak nie
neowojtek 2 years ago
co jest, polaki dyskutują po angielsku między sobą haha ;d kawałek mi się w ogóle nie podoba. co z tego że ładna jest, jak nie śpiewa w ogóle czysto, w dodatku wokal słabo wykończony jest.
mysticvintage 2 years ago
no co jest, POLAKI, co tam, jak tam? prosze, wytlumacz mi jak sie CZYSTO spiewa? no i jak sie WYKANCZA wokal, to naprawde interesujace.
weremia 2 years ago
haha pewnie angol jakiś :D czysto to znaczy że intonacja conajmniej nie rani. wykończenie to to wszystko co jest między nutkami - artykulacja dźwięków.
mysticvintage 2 years ago
aha, no teraz rozumiem. pewnie w muzie robisz? no nic, moze ta nieudaczna, intonacyjnie kaleka i majaca problemy z artykulacja Harvey, kiedys wzniesie sie na wyzyny dostepne tylko wybranym i w przyplywie szalenstwa zagra jakiegos dobrego covera. np: '' winna, niczyja i pieprz az do bolu '', czy inna swiatowej klasy produkcje.
weremia 2 years ago
troche sie bawie. same jej umiejętności myślę że są świetne ... ale te trzęsące się dźwięki to efekt źle przygotowanego kawałka. ona śpiewa trochę niżej niż w ogóle potrafi. a wystarczyło go jeszcze raz nauczyć się ale o jeden dźwięk wyżej. i "by było". a covery? covery to nie jest najbardziej ambitna zabawa świata. tyle że "ludzie lubią" :)))))))))))))))))))))
mysticvintage 2 years ago
@mysticvintage
nie rób wiochy, tylko się zapisz na lekcje u prawdziwego nauczyciela gitary. Na lekcjach z youtube daleko nie zajedziesz ;]
gadom88 2 years ago
a już kupiłem sobie osiemsete za samo udzielanie lekcji takim jeleniom jak ty :))))
pozdrawiam
mysticvintage 2 years ago
jeśli to, co właśnie usunąłeś było twoje, to faktycznie jelenie ;)
gadom88 2 years ago
zapraszam na koncerty. :))
wierzę że każdy jest jeleniem. to w nas.
mysticvintage 2 years ago
im a new Harvey fan i looove this song! does anyone wanna reccomend any of their particular favourites to me? :P
razmataz13drums 2 years ago
ok check out white chalk, all of songs from her stories from the city, stories from the sea album-her best i think! her earlier stuff is amazing too incredibly raw, very guitar based-like rid of me and man size.
232198745 2 years ago
uh huh her album is a master piece. her new project with john parish a woman a man walked by is amazing..i went to their concert and almost died.. is amazing how she connects with the audience..
ixtehh 2 years ago
Is This Desire ? my favorite album of her's,
Uh Huh Her too ! White Chalk is good too !
tracks i like most....
It's You
The Devil
The sky Lit Up
Dear Darkness
Missed
itchycitizen 2 years ago
ckeck out :
Henry Lee
Loosing Ground
Black Hearted Love
AliceNess11 2 years ago
greatings
I'm a new fan too :D
rub til it bleeds,me-jane,rid of me,darker days of him and me,you said something,one time too many...hmm there are more but...anyway I like these :)
FragileLittleAngel 2 years ago
Heya :) thanks to everyone for replying i've checked most of them and theyre all very good, so i congratulate you on your good taste, so just yh thnx a lot!!!! :P
razmataz13drums 2 years ago
just as I posted the comm I realized that a bunch of others have done it as well :D
you're welcome :P
FragileLittleAngel 2 years ago
That's rite mate. I love PJ Harvey's raw sound. Chylinska's part is warmed up a bit (Nosowska sticks with the original sound-like, but that's her recognizbale style [kinda similar to PJ's). Still good though.
85gdawid 2 years ago
Hmm... The problem is... Why are you trying to compare Nosowska (Hey) & Chylińska (O.N.A.) version with the original one? They both are really good but far different from each other and imposible to compare.
angouleme89 2 years ago
when was this recorded?! it would be nice if people who videos on here would actually put some info. under info. words to the song is not really info.!!!
deadlycamera 2 years ago
Hey i Agnieszka Chylińska - Angelene
check this.....this is really good Cover...
pozdro foxd2
adagio100 2 years ago
aktualny there is no compere.
dobryluku 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Pj Harvej - Angelene is good but Agnieszka Chylińska&Hey - Angelene is better!!!!!!!
szymesi 2 years ago
no, it isn't. hey is one step away from becoming a pj harvey tribute band.
Jurgis1990 2 years ago
I think Hey make a similar noise but in no way reach the molecular depth of delivery that PJ uses as standard in all her work, I'm sure hey would not say their version is in any way superior to any of PJ's, but have given it to a wider audience, which is good.
marxman00 2 years ago 4
Check our polish Cover , It's worth to see:
Hey i Agnieszka Chylińska - Angelene
In my opinion better than original one.
foxd2 2 years ago
I agree.
Oulllka 2 years ago
not better but good
6artek 2 years ago 3
hauntingly catchy :)
kernowrock555 2 years ago
the studio version is much better. the best i'd say.
siasiekw 2 years ago
Incredible. I am moved..
Apogee777 2 years ago 6
YES, IT IS!!
wujag 2 years ago
so beautiful...................
anADIRAL 2 years ago 3
Beautiful. Amazing. Heart wrenchingly sweet & addictive. Love this version - Thanks CaptainJet.
syr1811 2 years ago 3
F@#%IN GREAT!!!!! Thanks for sharing!!! Where did you find this LIVE, if you do not mind me asking???? I saw this tour in NYC!!!!! Do you have more????
thebends28037 2 years ago 3
yess!! what concert is this?
marco83p 2 years ago 2
Prettiest mess i've ever seen... :)
goreckibg 2 years ago 22
hey sang it better...
i think...
marioooo93 2 years ago
You're deeply confused, I think !
marxman00 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm glad for you , but wow, you're either in "Hey" or totally deaf.
marxman00 2 years ago
it appears everyone from poland and their grandma covers angelene because hey did. it's very bizarre.
Jurgis1990 2 years ago
bardzo podobało mi sie to ze chylińska w wykonaniu z Hey zaspiewała to po swojemu aintrepretowala to jak chciała to było niesamowite.Kasia nosowska zaspiewala ladnie ale zabardzo podobne to oryginału
ROSEwppl 2 years ago 7
she's great
19wings80 2 years ago
I don't understand why this song isn't more popular in the mainstream. It's pretty.
NotADood 2 years ago 2
youtube:
Hey i Agnieszka Chylińska - Angelene
it's even better
kamilontko 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no it isnt:S
julietavalon 2 years ago
my first name is angeline
prettiest mess you've ever seen
ykonstanza 2 years ago 2
świetne
koluszki 3 years ago 8
this is beautiful!!!
sss104 3 years ago 7
zajebisty kawałek
mycys 3 years ago 21
wow!
ilovetoplayinsnow 3 years ago 4
cudo
czubeczek031207 3 years ago 5
Stunning! Thank you for posting this beautiful song!
butihavenone 3 years ago 6
Every song I listen from PJ Harvey makes feel so good she is such a good artist I wish I could see one of her performances.
jcl424 3 years ago 12
thanks for posting the words to all these songs
super1114 3 years ago 20
This is a beautiful version of this song! Thanks for posting it.
beautyofbeing 3 years ago 29