People do not comment on how people conduct. Everyone has their own way of conducting. Conducting should be something you enjoy in your own way. Find what makes you feel gool:)
Speaking from experience as a musician who has seen my share of good and bad directing, I must say that this is excellent conducting that can seen from the back row (where I usually sit) and has plenty of fluidity and emotion. Every director will have a different style, and that is something to be proud of and not to bash. I personally don't see a problem with bouncing as long as you don't end up tripping :). Good Job!
GREAT Job! I played trumpet for 9 years (Marching Band & Orchestra) and was Drum Major for 3 years. Although the bobbing at the knees is not typical when conducting, I didn't really see a big problem with it. Very good conducting, especially with no music in front of you.
Hmmm, I enjoyed this. Although many people dislike how much you moved and some of the cues you gave, I didn't find a problem with it. If many of those who critized your cues watched Leonard Bernstein I wonder what they would say, since he jumped up and down and went really over board, but that's what happens when you get into the music! Its quite natural for some, but most stick to the regular beat patterns, so continue with what you're doing.
Hm. I was looking for a resource recording of Williams' "Summon the Heroes" from the 96 games for some score study, and found you instead.
Were you a drum major in high school? That would explain away all the stylistic choices. Sometimes I find having a baton to be confining.
Music's purpose is to evoke emotion, and your job as a conductor is to convey that emotion to your players. This piece requires the large flourishes and grandeur that you provide - and you're having fun to boot!
I not like the others who have ctricized you.... Note, there were some minor errors and mistakes, BUT, OVERALL a wonderful job... I give an A (95.5 out of a possible 100).....
I have a request though:
Get a recording of
"Till Eulenspiegel" by R. Strauss........
Though it's done in 6/8 it's a REAL BITCH to conduct !!!!! Good Luck .......
Dont want to be mean or anything, but just as "bandboy" said, wtf are u doing with your left hand? And the boxing , what was that good for? But i like the dancing you did, looked really funny ^^
And u should never drop the beat with your hand! You got 2 hands, one for keeping the beat, the other to make directions and conduct the ensemble.
Hi James, I just wanted to leave a few comments. At the beginning your beats are not very clear and if you were conducting a real ensemble you'd have errors. Try not to leave the left hand hanging in the air with no particular purpose, try not to shift body wait so much when cueing. TOO many circular gestures. Head bobbing, the boxing, and dancing is quite unnecessary. Give the ensemble what they need not what you think makes you look good! Try not to be all over the place like a ribbon twirler!
Great arm movements. Now try to compose something that inspires your grandchildren to do the same thing. In a 3D hologram, right in front of your eyes! YAH!
it looks to be like you are doing cues and not really conducting. lol you should be a member of the boxing team if you want to be punching things down like that
LOL
pabloOI208 2 months ago
People do not comment on how people conduct. Everyone has their own way of conducting. Conducting should be something you enjoy in your own way. Find what makes you feel gool:)
Barrenosr15 5 months ago
whenever i listen to this song by a french horn choir (Vienna Horns) i cant help but get into a groove at 0:15 lol.
I love this song!!!!
TrumpetMaster1000 1 year ago
I like it. it was very clean and crisp.
music4dude 1 year ago
lol i like you couch, and wonderful contucting :D you just need the score man
7222Brit 1 year ago
yikes...are you serious? Are you trying to conduct or physically assault someone?
conductordude87 2 years ago
in respons to rocbowl i agree. either way the movement gives it more feeling then just some highschool drum major.
bpconductor2282 2 years ago
Don't move legs! you shouldn't do it, if you want proffesional conducting
luudi1 2 years ago
Speaking from experience as a musician who has seen my share of good and bad directing, I must say that this is excellent conducting that can seen from the back row (where I usually sit) and has plenty of fluidity and emotion. Every director will have a different style, and that is something to be proud of and not to bash. I personally don't see a problem with bouncing as long as you don't end up tripping :). Good Job!
bassbone1785 2 years ago
GREAT Job! I played trumpet for 9 years (Marching Band & Orchestra) and was Drum Major for 3 years. Although the bobbing at the knees is not typical when conducting, I didn't really see a big problem with it. Very good conducting, especially with no music in front of you.
elacaveman 2 years ago
F A I L
helium881 2 years ago
Don't bob your knees and you look like a drum major...idk if thats what u were going for or not...
MusicMaestro87 2 years ago
hahaha, i wish all conductors cued trombones like you (2:53)
gunt189 2 years ago
@gunt189 you mean timpanis and trombones at 2:53?
nice conducting for a non professional conductor...
if you really want a challenge try an opera :D
Penimann 2 years ago
a nada zambito...
eduardoclarinet 2 years ago
A beast! I'm a whore for drama. LOL You delivered it, BUT you still conducted the music effectively!
As a band geek, I don't understand people getting mad @ cues...but if you all expect a robot who oscillates a baton in the x & y planes only...ugh
*puts on flame retardant "I <3 moot" shirt*
NikDLenfent 2 years ago
^.......same here...lol
stupidsax 2 years ago
Hmmm, I enjoyed this. Although many people dislike how much you moved and some of the cues you gave, I didn't find a problem with it. If many of those who critized your cues watched Leonard Bernstein I wonder what they would say, since he jumped up and down and went really over board, but that's what happens when you get into the music! Its quite natural for some, but most stick to the regular beat patterns, so continue with what you're doing.
R. Woods
Clarinetist/Conductor
rocbowl 2 years ago
Hm. I was looking for a resource recording of Williams' "Summon the Heroes" from the 96 games for some score study, and found you instead.
Were you a drum major in high school? That would explain away all the stylistic choices. Sometimes I find having a baton to be confining.
Music's purpose is to evoke emotion, and your job as a conductor is to convey that emotion to your players. This piece requires the large flourishes and grandeur that you provide - and you're having fun to boot!
SeussExMachina 2 years ago 2
I not like the others who have ctricized you.... Note, there were some minor errors and mistakes, BUT, OVERALL a wonderful job... I give an A (95.5 out of a possible 100).....
I have a request though:
Get a recording of
"Till Eulenspiegel" by R. Strauss........
Though it's done in 6/8 it's a REAL BITCH to conduct !!!!! Good Luck .......
Your fave french horn player,
Julaibeeb
julaibeeb 2 years ago 2
Hehe, very funny parody of a conductor! :D
(note the sarcasm)
Dont want to be mean or anything, but just as "bandboy" said, wtf are u doing with your left hand? And the boxing , what was that good for? But i like the dancing you did, looked really funny ^^
And u should never drop the beat with your hand! You got 2 hands, one for keeping the beat, the other to make directions and conduct the ensemble.
Keep trying! (naabcake) ^^
Swexecutor 2 years ago
Hi James, I just wanted to leave a few comments. At the beginning your beats are not very clear and if you were conducting a real ensemble you'd have errors. Try not to leave the left hand hanging in the air with no particular purpose, try not to shift body wait so much when cueing. TOO many circular gestures. Head bobbing, the boxing, and dancing is quite unnecessary. Give the ensemble what they need not what you think makes you look good! Try not to be all over the place like a ribbon twirler!
bandboy1 2 years ago
Great arm movements. Now try to compose something that inspires your grandchildren to do the same thing. In a 3D hologram, right in front of your eyes! YAH!
UseSumLogic 3 years ago
Dude: well done. And one of my fave John Williams scores.
eurasianoblong 3 years ago
Very well conducted, indeed! Also Jon Williams is one of my favourite composers! How long have you been conducting?
PianoNils 3 years ago
some years now. i took a short class in high school and one class at college- and a one month-long summer conducting camp... thanks! god bless!
heyhdjr2 3 years ago
@PianoNils VERY WELL???? THIS GUY IS WAY OF BEAT AND HE CLEARY IS OBSESSED WITH FORMATAS!!!
WilliamsFan221 1 year ago
great but in one part in the middle you were conducting a 2-4 time signiture... but it was great :)
bandrocker14 3 years ago
it looks to be like you are doing cues and not really conducting. lol you should be a member of the boxing team if you want to be punching things down like that
geez
AmericomDPD 3 years ago
i was hoping he was gonna bow
JRo731 3 years ago