It is a bit strange the evolutionists are resorting to ridiculous legal arguments to try to win a scientific argument. Imagine the courts decided ID was science - are you telling me the evolutionists would accept that judgement. The very fact they had to take the issue to court to silence opposition suggests to me that evolution has something to hide.
@kkkaldav It was taken to court on the grounds of what was deemed scientific in education.
In scientific terms, you can do whatever you want. There are groups out there that engage in supposed 'Creation Science', but they largely bastardise the work of others and manipulate it to extract unwarranted conclusions; very few(if any) do original research.
If you do think modern biology has something to hide, go and look for it. But look for it in a university library.
Intelligent Design is both an oxymoron in nomenclature, as well as dumb science. It is no more scientific than saying "The theory of gravity is just a theory. I believe gravity is our sins holding us to the earth. Teach Immoral Attraction side by side with the 'theory' of gravity."
How frustrating it is to see people supporting Expelled. As an engineer working on a double major in biology, I just find it appauling how Stein and the ID proponents undermine the scientific method with psuedoscience crap.
Haha! This idiotic movie wasn't shown in european movie theaters, it was too poorly made and the subject too ridiculous. This is like some "astrologer" making a movie telling how astronomy and physics is being taught now instead of "astrology". Evolution is a proven and observed fact. Look up *Evolution* in wikipedia and also the chapter *Fact Of Evolution* in wiki. Look also up what a *Scientific Theory* is, it's a model explaining the facts, like the fact gravity or the fact evolution. :)
You have your facts the wrong way around. Atheism is rather quickly beginning to be realized as the leading 'belief' in what people believe.
And as for Athiests and being happy, you clearly have either not met many people or you have a terrible impressino on people and what their emotions are. The Athiests are probably the most 'happy' people in the world, the only ones who arn't always trying to appease some imaginary friend and being feared of being tortured for all eternity.
The only reason Athiests seam to be mildly agitated at the religious people is because they cannot see how people can be so frustratingly narrow minded and so stubborn not to accept the facts around them that there is no devine creator who loves all of us and that will reward us with an eternity in paradise. Every religion is based on immortality, dieing and then some how coming back to life, whether it be reincarnation or going to a wonderous paradise with virgins to 'pleasure' yourself with.
And what precisely would that 'proof' be which you are talking about, I did not in any place even give the slightest hint that I had been proven wrong by you or anyone, if you could fill me in on the details it would be much appreciated.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You must get your facts right, Atheism is not a religion, there are various lines which sepparate us from people with bronze age beliefs. Athiests do not praise 'sacred' profane objects or create rituals, pray in any form, or believe in any form of supernatural beings.
Do you even know what the term 'religion' means? The definition is a strong belief in a supernatural power or powers that control human destiny, if you would know anything about Atheism, you would know that we do not believe in any form of a supernatural being which creates us, nore do we 'praise' people at all. We do not belive in anyone being sacred, you make these claims with no facts to support your theories, I suggest to actually research before you comment.
Who told you Atheism is a religion, look in a dictionary for the definition of 'religion' and then look in there for 'Atheism', I'm pretty sure you will find they differ a great amount. All religions aim towards immortality, and some how living eternally, if you can give me one religion that doesn't have this then I might reconsider, while your trying to find that, also look for a religion that doesn't believe in a supernatural being(s) that had created everything. Atheism does not beleive those
Well, after reading more of the views posted here, I'm left with the nagging thought of how corporate media just plays us for sheep, attempting to keep us locked into pointless polarizing banter, none of which does anything more than entrench the status quo, which equals ignorance and big short-term corporate profits. Ben Stein is nothing more than a free-wheelin' free market kind of guy, who just happens to have his dick caught in the corporate genital cuff.Someone get this man some pliers!
And yet despite your nagging thought of corporate polarization, here you are part of it. Carrying your opinion forward, this would mean you are aware of the wet cement but walk in it anyway???
"Freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." Sure, make an untrue statement at the onset of an argument and what are you going to do? You're going to try to prove it's a true statement, not that it's untrue. Smell like the Neo-con assertion of the myth of liberal media to anyone? I've got a idea, let's play: Win Ben Stein's Intellignece! It's worth absolutely squat! Boy did this guy's career need a bump, or what? Ben, do the world a favor and go back to Comedy Central!
the idiocy on display in stein's quixotic and ill-informed campaign against "big science" is matched in intensity only by the staggeringly inane comments from fans of this puff piece who are jejune enough to contend that it will not only "save science"
Pooper, you are ignorance at it's best - fearful of all that isn't yours. No contradictions - just a lot of ad hominem attacks and name calling. Not surprising. It's all people like you have.
"False Premise" You are so clever. You stand around all day long with "Faux News" signs and laugh at yourself too, right?
Congrats! I nominate you for the poster-child for the "No intelligent design here" movement. You will convince a lot of people. Go ahead - call me some names. ROFLMAO
sorry "Papa", but what people like myself have is a rich appreciation for life's complexities that don't rely on supernatural suppositions to fill in the gaps in our current understanding.
and as for the "ad hominem" attacks,
see your own response:
pot, meet kettle...
really, though, enjoy your fable.
you are the supreme being's masterwork, the centerpiece of his cosmological agenda.
entreat him in the dark when you are fearful, unresourceful, envious, or afraid.
Nah - just giving you back a little of your own. Don't like it huh?
In addition to life's complexities, I also find wonderful richness in the ironies... like those who actually prove the point of the movie by denouncing it and expressing the clear hatred that is depicted by it.
Sorry - no fear or envy here. Yet another ignorant assumption propagated by 30 second sound bites of those who tell you they have done your thinking for you.
Even there own propaganda is dismal, pathetic, and, actually, quite embarrassing to their cause (Cheers for the boost to Atheism, morons!).
And, on the side, I don't know what cereal packet the film maker got his credentials from. The film is laughable at best, degrading to every single theist at worse.
".. and new ideas are denied their proper voice .."
New ideas? Being created by god is a "new idea"? :))) You must be kidding! It's impossible to find ANY OLDER IDEA than this! (expressing it in a modern scientific jargon, doesn't make it new)
"freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science."
Two great truths cant contradict eachother,Theres just to much perfection in this world to just ignore facts.Evolution is a way of thinking and so is creationism,Scientific material is subjected to hipothesis (objective lead influenced by thouughts and emotions, its impossible for a human to work without emotions because then we wouldnt be humans) Einstein believed in higher creator and Darwin came to work with him. Believing there is a creator means theres a logical explenation for everything.
Two great truths cant contradict eachother,Theres just to much perfection in this world to just ignore facts.Evolution is a way of thinking and so is creationism,Scientific material is subjected to hipothesis (objective lead influenced by thouughts and emotions, its impossible for a human to work without emotions because then we wouldnt be humans) Einstein believed in higher creator and Darwin came to work with him. Believing there is a creator means theres a logical explenation for everything.
Um, most evolution accepters are theists. Did they even do the slightest bit of research? Oh right, they just didn't care because that information is far too inconvenient for their little propaganda piece.
I recommend looking up videos by the Christian Kenneth Miller on YouTube as you totally dismantles all of cdesign proponentsists' claims.
please....ya it must be so hard to be a christian only 93% of Americans and its been about 250 years so that means in 1,500 years you will be the minority! i feel so bad for you
So true. It is just christian's obsessions with persecution. They love feeling like someone is holding them down. Free the information! Let the theologians teach biology and the physicists teach religion!! :) pure horse shit. Ben Stein is an oppurtunist pig however he is also a well trained propagandist (former Nixon speech writer)
How is evolutionary theory different when an atheist accepts it as opposed to when a theist accepts it? Putting aside any irrelevant metaphysical beliefs a person might ATTACH to the theory, how is the THEORY ITSELF different whether or not an atheist or a theist accepts it?
I do accept Zeus as my god. It's these dishonest cdesign proponentsists who don't even understand the science they criticize who are delusional enough to think Yahweh is the designer when that was Cronos. These moronic Christians won't be so arrogant when they're suffering in Tartarus for all eternity.
"did i fit the part of an atheist? I think i sounded just like one... haha"
You're a moron.
I want religion taught in schools as part of religious education. That means teaching all the worlds religions. Religions are an important part of understanding cultures and history.
What religion has no place in, is science classrooms because that's not how science works. Science works on what's falsifiable, "gods" would be supernatural and not falsifiable, therefore not science. Try again.
That's you're opinion. If you need that to feel secure and happy in this world then I'm happy for you.
Jesus the man probably once did exist. But like any other popular person in history myths arise over time about them. Jesus wasn't unique. Myths get passed down through the generations, several died and some survived. Islam, Judaism, Christianity the 3 big ones.
Be an adult and think critically about all things, even about yourself Spec. ;)
They all apparently happened in you personal life. You've attributed them to prayer, that's convinced you, that's fine.
So all the people that prayer for their children to recover from cancer are.. what? Doing it wrong? People praying to be saved from a murderer are in a prayer queue on hold?
Miracles don't happen. Prayer don't work. Placebos do. Full recoveries can happen. It's medicine that helps people not prayer. Don't be a fool.
"If i lay hands on the sick and pray in the name of Jesus and they are instantly healed... is that a placebo? No... that is a miracle... "
Please shut up. There's a million dollars waiting for you at the James Randi Foundation. Not to mention a Nobel prize if you can prove such powers. What are you waiting for? Why are you wasting your time on Youtube comments when you could go out and heal cancer?!
when you realize the truth and it changes your life... you give away the best you have for free... but you will never understand that cause you are stingy and only think of yourself...
People all over the world are healing people of diseases right now... and you wont even believe it...
go to liberty MO... my friend Doug can show you 1st hand miracles
or am i just talking balls...
go write a book on how we evolved from dirt or something...
Think of all the people you could reach with that money Spec. You can heal people with miracles the monies yours already. Go and sign up. Prove your healing to skeptics. Show us for the fools we are. You heal one person under test controls and you will have demonstrated something never seen before.
Or is it that you are talking balls, you despicable lunatic?
Prove us fools wrong Spec. Please! Prove me wrong! I mean it!!
I am not as smart as scottish atheists... who use... proper grammer... and puncuation...
its a habbit... sorry...
haha
despicable lunatic!!! now we are getting somewhere!!! tell me how you really feel
If God allowed me to heal someone under your specific test controls I would. I have never tried. its not important for me to heal someone on tv just to prove you wrong. I just want to help people and be obedient to the great commision
A simple test of your powers and already you dodge. Go to a childs cancer ward and cure them all. Go on.
I have made my feelings clear from the very start. You disgust me. Not only because you're a bare faced liar. But because of the nature of the lie. To claim healing powers but alas only if "god allows you to use them".
I don't hate religious people. But I hate liars. If you had even the slightest ability to heal you would be world famous and there would be no atheists I guarantee it.
If you give away the best you have for free, why are you talking to people on the internet? why don't you sell your computer and give that money to charity?
And you can't use the excuse "God will lead me" as you know very well the God you believe would not like to see you sit comfortably here as people suffer. there are children dying, you're completely selfish as well. (It's a natural animalistic trait... that we have obtained through evolution. :) But now you're a hypocrite too.
Propaganda. Your plot has been explosed for the fraud that it is. cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists
as soon as Intelligent Design gathers some data and submits papers for peer review it can be considered a valid hypothesis and can even be taught in science classrooms. We cant just call things science because we want to, they need to act like science.
Oh infallible corndog maker, how did the universe first come to be? It popped into existence from nothing, on its own accord, you say? Interesting belief. How did life first form? It popped into existence via some unknown, unprovable process, you say? Interesting belief. If your religion is based on belief, why can't someone else's? Should either religion be taught in public schools?
If anyone were saying the things you're attributing to me, I wouldn't want that taught in science classes also. so we are in agreement. The only one claiming those things however, is the imaginary straw man version of scientists that creationists claim exists. This will be the "scientist" attacked in this movie.
I don't know why you claim to know what I believe. I do advocate teaching science in science classrooms. The reason creationism should not be taught in science classrooms is because it is not science where as big bang cosmology and evolution are scientific theories which came about by the use of the Scientific Method regarding the diversity of life on earth and the expansion of space and time in the universe. creationism should also be taught, but in classes of world religions or philosophy.
Evolution is not a result of the scientific method, it is a philosophy that is an untestable, faith based exaggeration of real events and data. It is essentially the origins story for atheism, which is a religion that has no business being taught in schools.
Read a book, daniel. Correction: read a book that doesn't star Jesus. You don't understand the science. cdesign proponentsists have no intention of recognizing any "designer" outside of Yahweh & you know it. It's already been debunked for the sham that it is. Science requires falsifiable claims and must pass peer review. If ID was real science, it would get in the schools naturally like every other scientific Theory instead of shamelessly trying to bypass the scientific process w/ the courts.
an atheist is a person that dose not believe in a god or gods. you are an atheist about Zeus. that will change because Zeus should get = time in the classrooms too.
SCIENCE IS NOT A DEMOCRACY YOU DOLT. Science is about facts and theories. If they withstand scrutiny they become an accepted part of science.
Fuck you for trying to make this an emotional plea for "fairness" and playing the underdog. This is thinly veiled religion. Teach ID in religous studies. NOT IN A SCIENCE CLASSROOM!!
Democracy = majority rules. So yes, science IS a democracy - in our country at least. These anti-religious bigots have the stranglehold on this "democratic science" and this is actually what the movie is about. Thank you for supporting the flick!
What does doing good science have to do with being anti religious?
And perhaps I wasn't clear with my last comment. Science and politics should not mix. A vote isn't cast as to which theory is the most popular. Some theories fight very hard to be accepted. What speaks is evidence and the theories abilities to predict the outcomes of experiments. This movie is just a long anti science whinge.
As a further clarification science is blind to nationality, religious belief and political affiliation. The results of experiments should be the same no matter what country you're in. Evolution is not disputed among the worlds scientists. The only places that seem to have trouble with it are countries with strong religious convictions hmmmm. If Americans want to be considered a laughing stock go ahead. It'll hurt your countries economy in the long run.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
they teach about the "big bang" in science classrooms... and yet it goes against many universal laws... shouldn't it get throw out? along with thousands of other lies?
nahhh... what would we have to replace it with? God created the world? NO WAY THAT CAN'T HAPPEN! that means that we have to admit he exists and we should follow his rules!!! NO NO NO NO
NO RELIGION IN SCHOOLS... haha...
did i fit the part of an atheist? I think i sounded just like one... haha
Specilum, apparently you don't know the basic evidence in favor of the big bang - do you know about red shift, Penzias and Wilson, COBE and WMAP and what their results mean? No? Then how can you say ANYTHING honestly?
because I see miracles happen in the name of Jesus right before my eyes. I dont need to understand Penzias. I understand the word of God. it is real and 100% truth!
If i see miracles happen on a daily account, then that proves my God(Jesus) is real and has power over all. He can heal the sick and raise the dead.
what can your big bang do? nothing but lead you into more questions that will take up the rest of your life. then you will run out of time.
Specilum, take a few minutes to look up the items you mentioned, you need to know about them to avoid looking foolish in debates. Please tell me the most intense clear miracle you have witnessed.
people with deaf ears being able to hear again. blind people being able to see again. people with back problems instantly being fixed. does that work?
Specilum, not people in general, specific people. For privacy you don't need to tell me their names, but you must know them. Better yet, since this is so important, they should be willing to come forward with their stories but for ethical reasons you cannot reveal who they are without their permission. Then you need medical examinations recorded before and afterwards. This is the bare minimum.
Farvision... I dont need any of those things... YOU need those things because you can't believe the truth you hear. Those people do come forward with their stories and share with others the truth.
The Bible and Jesus have never said I have to heal someone and then set up control groups to do further tests.
I just heal them in the name of Jesus and then tell them the truth about God. and disiple them and teach them so they can do the same to others
No, Specilum, you need those things too to use this youtube, your computer, any drugs you take, to drive your car, to makes phone call, etc etc etc. You don't know how the technology came about. So far you have not given even a single case - Do I have to conclude that you are avoiding because you don't have any evidence to back up your claims? ONE solid example is all I'm asking for, just one that you can verify.
watch the video on my favorites - miracles of healing - or watch raised from the dead.
I dont need to know how an internal combustion engine works to drive my car... I just know it works and trust it to get me to work... same idea here... I dont know the exact change that takes place in a persons body when I command it to be healed in the name of Jesus... I just know it works, and I put my faith in the Bible, and Jesus :-)
Now you also need control groups who had the same diagnosis before and did not get healed in an equivalent time. You also need to have the medical records so you know it wasn't from a medical procedure. There was a beautification done where the person was being treated; such cases need to be thrown out because treatment is not a miracle. You need to double blind the experiment. Finally, you need enough examples to get a statiscally significant result so you are not fooling yourself.
I'm sure I've forgotten lots of things: proper protocols for human experimentation. These are all things that scientists have to face when testing a drug no wonder they are so expensive! But you can't neglect them. Anecdotal examples are nice but it's REALLY easy to be fooled by apparently exciting results! I know, it's happened to me many times! Then one has to come back to earth when one realizes the trivial explanation or whatever. Rarely one DOES have a cool result - and those we publish!
It is a bit strange the evolutionists are resorting to ridiculous legal arguments to try to win a scientific argument. Imagine the courts decided ID was science - are you telling me the evolutionists would accept that judgement. The very fact they had to take the issue to court to silence opposition suggests to me that evolution has something to hide.
kkkaldav 1 year ago
@kkkaldav It was taken to court on the grounds of what was deemed scientific in education.
In scientific terms, you can do whatever you want. There are groups out there that engage in supposed 'Creation Science', but they largely bastardise the work of others and manipulate it to extract unwarranted conclusions; very few(if any) do original research.
If you do think modern biology has something to hide, go and look for it. But look for it in a university library.
AkiThePirate 1 year ago
Free speech is anything but curbed in science.
Inteeligent Design had more than its say both when it was known as creationism and when it relabelled itself.
Both times it failed, miserably! Not only that but it tried lying too and still failed.
Expelled? no. Flunked? Yes.
ProcInc 1 year ago
Psuedoscience
ojoreakatheoj 2 years ago
But seriously- wtf is the point of attacking something as a religion?
...just before the end, the said "YOUR beliefs are being expelled"
funincluded 2 years ago
the RELIGION of secular humanism?!
annaomeara 2 years ago
I read your comment and found no irony or contradiction.
Just kidding
...but seriusly
funincluded 2 years ago
How exactly are 17% of people oppressing the other 83%?!
Hilarious.
imaginenoreligion 2 years ago
They sure weren't subtle about who their target audience is.
internetaccount122 3 years ago
Intelligent Design is both an oxymoron in nomenclature, as well as dumb science. It is no more scientific than saying "The theory of gravity is just a theory. I believe gravity is our sins holding us to the earth. Teach Immoral Attraction side by side with the 'theory' of gravity."
smokezero 3 years ago
How frustrating it is to see people supporting Expelled. As an engineer working on a double major in biology, I just find it appauling how Stein and the ID proponents undermine the scientific method with psuedoscience crap.
baudiirocz 3 years ago
its only because its not making a dam bit of sense...that all
mastersduhgree 2 years ago
I wouldn't call the movie AMAZING...
okkima 3 years ago
AMAZINGLY STUPID
jormorcastan 2 years ago
I'm fully ready to stop this debate lol they are stressfull on me I'm getting old:)
I didn't mean to get into one really.
I hope you have a good day!
And I'm certain your next post will be very insightfull indeed.
thanks
hopefullliving 3 years ago
O,and by the way I write dictionaries so I guess you have to believe me.
hopefullliving 3 years ago
I asked you what scientific method your using for your belief if religion.
When you can site the method I will believe you when you say you've arrived at your belief or unbelief scientifically.
All your other talk respectfully is mere opinion. Like my opinion.
So how do we decide what religion is "scientifically of course?"
hopefullliving 3 years ago
lol so science and hard evidence = oppression?
if thats the case id rather be "oppressed" than indoctrinated from youth into irrational and unconditional superstitious beliefs
sekkingu 3 years ago
sad...
hopefullliving 3 years ago
Haha! This idiotic movie wasn't shown in european movie theaters, it was too poorly made and the subject too ridiculous. This is like some "astrologer" making a movie telling how astronomy and physics is being taught now instead of "astrology". Evolution is a proven and observed fact. Look up *Evolution* in wikipedia and also the chapter *Fact Of Evolution* in wiki. Look also up what a *Scientific Theory* is, it's a model explaining the facts, like the fact gravity or the fact evolution. :)
winterstellar 3 years ago
God is on the uprise in the world. Atheism is shrinking worldwide.
On another note I've never met an atheist that I thought was really happy. I guess absolute selfishness doesn't work very well.
hopefullliving 3 years ago
You have your facts the wrong way around. Atheism is rather quickly beginning to be realized as the leading 'belief' in what people believe.
And as for Athiests and being happy, you clearly have either not met many people or you have a terrible impressino on people and what their emotions are. The Athiests are probably the most 'happy' people in the world, the only ones who arn't always trying to appease some imaginary friend and being feared of being tortured for all eternity.
shlunko 3 years ago
Thats only in America, religion is growing percentage wise your facts are wrong.
And you clearly don't know what an opinion is when I said "I've" never met a happy atheist. (Thats whats known as an opinion)
And I have it based on the evidence I've seen.
Take theamazingatheist for example or that other guy who has lots of subs who always is angry with religious people THESE ARE NOT HAPPY PEOPLE.
hopefullliving 3 years ago
The only reason Athiests seam to be mildly agitated at the religious people is because they cannot see how people can be so frustratingly narrow minded and so stubborn not to accept the facts around them that there is no devine creator who loves all of us and that will reward us with an eternity in paradise. Every religion is based on immortality, dieing and then some how coming back to life, whether it be reincarnation or going to a wonderous paradise with virgins to 'pleasure' yourself with.
shlunko 3 years ago
O so now you've started off with being proven wrong by my proof behind my opinion and you still hold to your religion.
You have great faith like many of the athiest I've met before.
Praise be to Darwin brother!
hopefullliving 3 years ago
And what precisely would that 'proof' be which you are talking about, I did not in any place even give the slightest hint that I had been proven wrong by you or anyone, if you could fill me in on the details it would be much appreciated.
shlunko 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You must get your facts right, Atheism is not a religion, there are various lines which sepparate us from people with bronze age beliefs. Athiests do not praise 'sacred' profane objects or create rituals, pray in any form, or believe in any form of supernatural beings.
shlunko 3 years ago
You must get your facts right.Atheism is very much a religion.
Atheists praise sacred people like Darwin.
They congregate. They worship their intellect. They claim nothing while in a world of evidence.
Clearly religion.
hopefullliving 3 years ago
Do you even know what the term 'religion' means? The definition is a strong belief in a supernatural power or powers that control human destiny, if you would know anything about Atheism, you would know that we do not believe in any form of a supernatural being which creates us, nore do we 'praise' people at all. We do not belive in anyone being sacred, you make these claims with no facts to support your theories, I suggest to actually research before you comment.
shlunko 3 years ago
lol who told you religion was a strong belief in a supernatural being etc?
What scientific method do you site to make such a claim?
You obviously have drank the Koolaid they gave you.
And yes again,atheism is as much a religion as christianity.
Please no more suggestions on this subject if you please. I know more about your position than you do imo.
hopefullliving 3 years ago
Who told you Atheism is a religion, look in a dictionary for the definition of 'religion' and then look in there for 'Atheism', I'm pretty sure you will find they differ a great amount. All religions aim towards immortality, and some how living eternally, if you can give me one religion that doesn't have this then I might reconsider, while your trying to find that, also look for a religion that doesn't believe in a supernatural being(s) that had created everything. Atheism does not beleive those
shlunko 3 years ago
Well, after reading more of the views posted here, I'm left with the nagging thought of how corporate media just plays us for sheep, attempting to keep us locked into pointless polarizing banter, none of which does anything more than entrench the status quo, which equals ignorance and big short-term corporate profits. Ben Stein is nothing more than a free-wheelin' free market kind of guy, who just happens to have his dick caught in the corporate genital cuff.Someone get this man some pliers!
drumrunner 3 years ago
And yet despite your nagging thought of corporate polarization, here you are part of it. Carrying your opinion forward, this would mean you are aware of the wet cement but walk in it anyway???
Papadoc1000 3 years ago
"Freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." Sure, make an untrue statement at the onset of an argument and what are you going to do? You're going to try to prove it's a true statement, not that it's untrue. Smell like the Neo-con assertion of the myth of liberal media to anyone? I've got a idea, let's play: Win Ben Stein's Intellignece! It's worth absolutely squat! Boy did this guy's career need a bump, or what? Ben, do the world a favor and go back to Comedy Central!
drumrunner 3 years ago
false premise media corporation presents:
a "documentary" by nasal ignoramous
and 10th-grade biology failure, ben stein...
the idiocy on display in stein's quixotic and ill-informed campaign against "big science" is matched in intensity only by the staggeringly inane comments from fans of this puff piece who are jejune enough to contend that it will not only "save science"
(killing the patient to save it
-grand idea!)
but also save "all of humanity" as well.
-no intelligence required...
poopfeet 3 years ago
Pooper, you are ignorance at it's best - fearful of all that isn't yours. No contradictions - just a lot of ad hominem attacks and name calling. Not surprising. It's all people like you have.
"False Premise" You are so clever. You stand around all day long with "Faux News" signs and laugh at yourself too, right?
Congrats! I nominate you for the poster-child for the "No intelligent design here" movement. You will convince a lot of people. Go ahead - call me some names. ROFLMAO
Papadoc1000 3 years ago
sorry "Papa", but what people like myself have is a rich appreciation for life's complexities that don't rely on supernatural suppositions to fill in the gaps in our current understanding.
and as for the "ad hominem" attacks,
see your own response:
pot, meet kettle...
really, though, enjoy your fable.
you are the supreme being's masterwork, the centerpiece of his cosmological agenda.
entreat him in the dark when you are fearful, unresourceful, envious, or afraid.
no name calling here...
poopfeet 3 years ago
Nah - just giving you back a little of your own. Don't like it huh?
In addition to life's complexities, I also find wonderful richness in the ironies... like those who actually prove the point of the movie by denouncing it and expressing the clear hatred that is depicted by it.
Sorry - no fear or envy here. Yet another ignorant assumption propagated by 30 second sound bites of those who tell you they have done your thinking for you.
Papadoc1000 3 years ago 10
wow. a bit slow on the draw, eh papa?
did it take you all this time to come up with just the right level of acrimony for a good "youtube burn"?
don't mince words, boyo. how do you really feel?
remind me again how ignorant i am...
and if you feel up to getting down to matters of substance, step right up.
you love to remind people how stupid they are.
on what grounds are YOU qualified to do so?
another "university of google" grad feeling his oats, perhaps?
yawn...
poopfeet 3 years ago
What a brilliant movie. Not only will Expelled save science, it may end up saving all of humanity.
The lies and hatred these uneducated atheists spew must be stopped, even if it takes using their own hostile tactics against them.
TheJaredJammer 3 years ago
Oh, the religious really are stupid!
Even there own propaganda is dismal, pathetic, and, actually, quite embarrassing to their cause (Cheers for the boost to Atheism, morons!).
And, on the side, I don't know what cereal packet the film maker got his credentials from. The film is laughable at best, degrading to every single theist at worse.
PR0GRAMMING 3 years ago
LOL, if Ben Stein is a movement on the rise, then it is also a movement about to do a full frontal faceplant
ThrakhathOfKilrah 3 years ago
a bowel movement on the "rise", perhaps...
poopfeet 3 years ago
LOL, that was a good one
ThrakhathOfKilrah 3 years ago
This is a good clip
DoulosQuinn 3 years ago
i am a secular humanist! I admire Dawkins too :)
silly creationists, trix are for kids.
vondunkelheit 3 years ago
Why doesn't the film just be upright and say it is an attack on "Secular Humanism"? It has nothing to do with Darwinian evolution.
eupraxsophy1986 3 years ago
Because Darwinian evolution is the Secular Humanist's shield.
spymaster2 3 years ago
Unless she's anti-evolution and agreed to it, of course.
Ianthe236 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I find it despicable that "Sam," the woman shown to participate in the blasphemy challenge, is used as the avatar for this channel.
Ianthe236 3 years ago
d'you know her? there's a button she could press to complain about an inappropriate avatar.
MarbleMad 3 years ago
".. and new ideas are denied their proper voice .."
New ideas? Being created by god is a "new idea"? :))) You must be kidding! It's impossible to find ANY OLDER IDEA than this! (expressing it in a modern scientific jargon, doesn't make it new)
InfidelMichael 3 years ago
"freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science." "freedom of ideas is no longer tolerated in the world of science."
horsepowerz 3 years ago
HAHAHAHA!!! what a joke...
JimNagle87 3 years ago
atheistic darwinianism, hahahaha.
Pelonetillo 3 years ago
Two great truths cant contradict eachother,Theres just to much perfection in this world to just ignore facts.Evolution is a way of thinking and so is creationism,Scientific material is subjected to hipothesis (objective lead influenced by thouughts and emotions, its impossible for a human to work without emotions because then we wouldnt be humans) Einstein believed in higher creator and Darwin came to work with him. Believing there is a creator means theres a logical explenation for everything.
circotico 3 years ago
Two great truths cant contradict eachother,Theres just to much perfection in this world to just ignore facts.Evolution is a way of thinking and so is creationism,Scientific material is subjected to hipothesis (objective lead influenced by thouughts and emotions, its impossible for a human to work without emotions because then we wouldnt be humans) Einstein believed in higher creator and Darwin came to work with him. Believing there is a creator means theres a logical explenation for everything.
circotico 3 years ago
Um, most evolution accepters are theists. Did they even do the slightest bit of research? Oh right, they just didn't care because that information is far too inconvenient for their little propaganda piece.
I recommend looking up videos by the Christian Kenneth Miller on YouTube as you totally dismantles all of cdesign proponentsists' claims.
mjr256 3 years ago
please....ya it must be so hard to be a christian only 93% of Americans and its been about 250 years so that means in 1,500 years you will be the minority! i feel so bad for you
hooah91 3 years ago
So true. It is just christian's obsessions with persecution. They love feeling like someone is holding them down. Free the information! Let the theologians teach biology and the physicists teach religion!! :) pure horse shit. Ben Stein is an oppurtunist pig however he is also a well trained propagandist (former Nixon speech writer)
PotheadPundit 3 years ago
I KNOW HAHA being a writer for Nixon i probably wouldn't want to tell my audience haha
hooah91 3 years ago
"Atheistic Darwinianism?" What exactly is that?
How is evolutionary theory different when an atheist accepts it as opposed to when a theist accepts it? Putting aside any irrelevant metaphysical beliefs a person might ATTACH to the theory, how is the THEORY ITSELF different whether or not an atheist or a theist accepts it?
EvoLIEtion 3 years ago
LOL. jc is a moron
mjr256 3 years ago
256, you are a moron because you do not accept Zeus as your god. Apollo died for your sins. if you believe that you will be saved.
marjoe77 3 years ago
I do accept Zeus as my god. It's these dishonest cdesign proponentsists who don't even understand the science they criticize who are delusional enough to think Yahweh is the designer when that was Cronos. These moronic Christians won't be so arrogant when they're suffering in Tartarus for all eternity.
mjr256 3 years ago
lol @ religion of secular humanism
jcbeta730 3 years ago
"did i fit the part of an atheist? I think i sounded just like one... haha"
You're a moron.
I want religion taught in schools as part of religious education. That means teaching all the worlds religions. Religions are an important part of understanding cultures and history.
What religion has no place in, is science classrooms because that's not how science works. Science works on what's falsifiable, "gods" would be supernatural and not falsifiable, therefore not science. Try again.
ScottishAtheist 3 years ago 3
Id rather be a moron and be right than be "cool" and go to Hell and be wrong...
you are a grown adult... start thinking like one...
watch some of my favorite videos... or even the one i posted about a guy getting raised from the dead after 3 days... with documentation...
or did he just evolve out of the grave?
Jesus Christ is real!!! WAKE UP!!!
Specilum 3 years ago
"Jesus Christ is real!!! WAKE UP!!!"
That's you're opinion. If you need that to feel secure and happy in this world then I'm happy for you.
Jesus the man probably once did exist. But like any other popular person in history myths arise over time about them. Jesus wasn't unique. Myths get passed down through the generations, several died and some survived. Islam, Judaism, Christianity the 3 big ones.
Be an adult and think critically about all things, even about yourself Spec. ;)
ScottishAtheist 3 years ago
i do think critcally... and when I see miracles happen in the name of Jesus... my critical thinking tells me that Jesus is real...
and when I read the bible and it makes sense and explains the world and all the events going on... I believe the bible...
I KNOW JESUS IS REAL AND IS WHO THE BIBLE SAYS HE IS...
the problem is this... you don't know who Jesus is... and I want to share the truth about him to you...
YOU ARE SO SMART THAT YOU ARE GOING TO MISS GOD!!!
Specilum 3 years ago
Shouting doesn't lend credence to an argument. You're doing a lot of it.
"when I see miracles happen in the name of Jesus... my critical thinking tells me that Jesus is real"
Name a miracle.
"and when I read the bible and it makes sense and explains the world and all the events going on I believe the bible"
What you believe is irrelevant to the facts.
"the problem is this you don't know who Jesus is and I want to share the truth about him to you"
Keep the garbage to yourself.
ScottishAtheist 3 years ago
name a miracle? haha ok
my wife's stomach pains (that she had all her life) dissapearing when she got prayed for...
my mother (who was sick with 3 diseases that are incurable by medical standards) beating all 3 of those and getting a clean bill of health...
20 years later she got sick and died (3 years ago)
before she died... for 2 days the Lord opened her eyes and she was able to see 2 angels in the room. just to comfort her...
there are just a few small ones that have happened...
Specilum 3 years ago
And how could these possibly be validated?
They all apparently happened in you personal life. You've attributed them to prayer, that's convinced you, that's fine.
So all the people that prayer for their children to recover from cancer are.. what? Doing it wrong? People praying to be saved from a murderer are in a prayer queue on hold?
Miracles don't happen. Prayer don't work. Placebos do. Full recoveries can happen. It's medicine that helps people not prayer. Don't be a fool.
ScottishAtheist 3 years ago
wow... I cant believe how blind you are...
Ill pray that God does a work in your life...
If i lay hands on the sick and pray in the name of Jesus and they are instantly healed... is that a placebo? No... that is a miracle...
if Jesus cant heal and do the things that happened in the bible then its a bunch of garbage... but he can heal thru us...
thats how you know its real!
otherwise it is just a weak craptackular religious experience you are following!
Specilum 3 years ago
"If i lay hands on the sick and pray in the name of Jesus and they are instantly healed... is that a placebo? No... that is a miracle... "
Please shut up. There's a million dollars waiting for you at the James Randi Foundation. Not to mention a Nobel prize if you can prove such powers. What are you waiting for? Why are you wasting your time on Youtube comments when you could go out and heal cancer?!
Or.. is it that you're talking balls? hmm
You're either an idiot or insane which is it?
ScottishAtheist 3 years ago
HAHA... yes... I am in it for the money!
when you realize the truth and it changes your life... you give away the best you have for free... but you will never understand that cause you are stingy and only think of yourself...
People all over the world are healing people of diseases right now... and you wont even believe it...
go to liberty MO... my friend Doug can show you 1st hand miracles
or am i just talking balls...
go write a book on how we evolved from dirt or something...
Specilum 3 years ago
Why...do...you...write..sentances...with..so...many...periods...?
Think of all the people you could reach with that money Spec. You can heal people with miracles the monies yours already. Go and sign up. Prove your healing to skeptics. Show us for the fools we are. You heal one person under test controls and you will have demonstrated something never seen before.
Or is it that you are talking balls, you despicable lunatic?
Prove us fools wrong Spec. Please! Prove me wrong! I mean it!!
ScottishAtheist 3 years ago
its a continuation of my thinking...
I am not as smart as scottish atheists... who use... proper grammer... and puncuation...
its a habbit... sorry...
haha
despicable lunatic!!! now we are getting somewhere!!! tell me how you really feel
If God allowed me to heal someone under your specific test controls I would. I have never tried. its not important for me to heal someone on tv just to prove you wrong. I just want to help people and be obedient to the great commision
Specilum 3 years ago
A simple test of your powers and already you dodge. Go to a childs cancer ward and cure them all. Go on.
I have made my feelings clear from the very start. You disgust me. Not only because you're a bare faced liar. But because of the nature of the lie. To claim healing powers but alas only if "god allows you to use them".
I don't hate religious people. But I hate liars. If you had even the slightest ability to heal you would be world famous and there would be no atheists I guarantee it.
ScottishAtheist 3 years ago
if the Lord leads me to a cancer ward... then I will go there...
otherwise I will continue to do things as he leads me to do...
you can call me a liar all you want... sooner or later you will know the truth...
I hope for your sake it is sooner than later...
Jonathan
Specilum 3 years ago
"if the Lord leads me to a cancer ward... then I will go there..."
Ah of course, how convenient.
And you have the nerve to wonder why I call you a liar. You're a complete nutjob mate.
ScottishAtheist 3 years ago
Thanks :-)
I still with the best for you... even if you think im a nutjob...
Specilum 3 years ago
If you give away the best you have for free, why are you talking to people on the internet? why don't you sell your computer and give that money to charity?
And you can't use the excuse "God will lead me" as you know very well the God you believe would not like to see you sit comfortably here as people suffer. there are children dying, you're completely selfish as well. (It's a natural animalistic trait... that we have obtained through evolution. :) But now you're a hypocrite too.
cariosus 3 years ago
Propaganda. Your plot has been explosed for the fraud that it is. cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists, cdesign proponentsists
mjr256 4 years ago
as soon as Intelligent Design gathers some data and submits papers for peer review it can be considered a valid hypothesis and can even be taught in science classrooms. We cant just call things science because we want to, they need to act like science.
CorndogMaker 4 years ago
Oh infallible corndog maker, how did the universe first come to be? It popped into existence from nothing, on its own accord, you say? Interesting belief. How did life first form? It popped into existence via some unknown, unprovable process, you say? Interesting belief. If your religion is based on belief, why can't someone else's? Should either religion be taught in public schools?
danielgolfspar5 3 years ago
If anyone were saying the things you're attributing to me, I wouldn't want that taught in science classes also. so we are in agreement. The only one claiming those things however, is the imaginary straw man version of scientists that creationists claim exists. This will be the "scientist" attacked in this movie.
CorndogMaker 3 years ago 5
oh sorry... i was just pointing out that what you believe isn't science.
danielgolfspar5 3 years ago
I don't know why you claim to know what I believe. I do advocate teaching science in science classrooms. The reason creationism should not be taught in science classrooms is because it is not science where as big bang cosmology and evolution are scientific theories which came about by the use of the Scientific Method regarding the diversity of life on earth and the expansion of space and time in the universe. creationism should also be taught, but in classes of world religions or philosophy.
CorndogMaker 3 years ago 3
Evolution is not a result of the scientific method, it is a philosophy that is an untestable, faith based exaggeration of real events and data. It is essentially the origins story for atheism, which is a religion that has no business being taught in schools.
danielgolfspar5 3 years ago
Read a book, daniel. Correction: read a book that doesn't star Jesus. You don't understand the science. cdesign proponentsists have no intention of recognizing any "designer" outside of Yahweh & you know it. It's already been debunked for the sham that it is. Science requires falsifiable claims and must pass peer review. If ID was real science, it would get in the schools naturally like every other scientific Theory instead of shamelessly trying to bypass the scientific process w/ the courts.
mjr256 3 years ago
mjr256, good point.
marjoe77 3 years ago
an atheist is a person that dose not believe in a god or gods. you are an atheist about Zeus. that will change because Zeus should get = time in the classrooms too.
marjoe77 3 years ago
Yes. Zeus killed his father Kronos and till now he is the only great god. Or why should the story about the christian god be more true than that?
LePfannenwender83 3 years ago
liar.
crumbinator 3 years ago
Zeus should be tought in schools
marjoe77 3 years ago
SCIENCE IS NOT A DEMOCRACY YOU DOLT. Science is about facts and theories. If they withstand scrutiny they become an accepted part of science.
Fuck you for trying to make this an emotional plea for "fairness" and playing the underdog. This is thinly veiled religion. Teach ID in religous studies. NOT IN A SCIENCE CLASSROOM!!
ScottishAtheist 4 years ago
Then by all means, teach evolution in a zoo, not the schools.
mooglecharmed 4 years ago
Democracy = majority rules. So yes, science IS a democracy - in our country at least. These anti-religious bigots have the stranglehold on this "democratic science" and this is actually what the movie is about. Thank you for supporting the flick!
mooglecharmed 4 years ago 4
What does doing good science have to do with being anti religious?
And perhaps I wasn't clear with my last comment. Science and politics should not mix. A vote isn't cast as to which theory is the most popular. Some theories fight very hard to be accepted. What speaks is evidence and the theories abilities to predict the outcomes of experiments. This movie is just a long anti science whinge.
ScottishAtheist 4 years ago 3
As a further clarification science is blind to nationality, religious belief and political affiliation. The results of experiments should be the same no matter what country you're in. Evolution is not disputed among the worlds scientists. The only places that seem to have trouble with it are countries with strong religious convictions hmmmm. If Americans want to be considered a laughing stock go ahead. It'll hurt your countries economy in the long run.
ScottishAtheist 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
they teach about the "big bang" in science classrooms... and yet it goes against many universal laws... shouldn't it get throw out? along with thousands of other lies?
nahhh... what would we have to replace it with? God created the world? NO WAY THAT CAN'T HAPPEN! that means that we have to admit he exists and we should follow his rules!!! NO NO NO NO
NO RELIGION IN SCHOOLS... haha...
did i fit the part of an atheist? I think i sounded just like one... haha
Specilum 3 years ago
right on specilum!! Zeus created the world. we have to admit Zeus exists and should follow his rules.
marjoe77 3 years ago
Specilum, apparently you don't know the basic evidence in favor of the big bang - do you know about red shift, Penzias and Wilson, COBE and WMAP and what their results mean? No? Then how can you say ANYTHING honestly?
farvision 3 years ago
"how can I say ANYTHING honestly"
because I see miracles happen in the name of Jesus right before my eyes. I dont need to understand Penzias. I understand the word of God. it is real and 100% truth!
If i see miracles happen on a daily account, then that proves my God(Jesus) is real and has power over all. He can heal the sick and raise the dead.
what can your big bang do? nothing but lead you into more questions that will take up the rest of your life. then you will run out of time.
Specilum 3 years ago
Specilum, take a few minutes to look up the items you mentioned, you need to know about them to avoid looking foolish in debates. Please tell me the most intense clear miracle you have witnessed.
farvision 3 years ago
people with deaf ears being able to hear again. blind people being able to see again. people with back problems instantly being fixed. does that work?
Specilum 3 years ago
Specilum, not people in general, specific people. For privacy you don't need to tell me their names, but you must know them. Better yet, since this is so important, they should be willing to come forward with their stories but for ethical reasons you cannot reveal who they are without their permission. Then you need medical examinations recorded before and afterwards. This is the bare minimum.
farvision 3 years ago
Farvision... I dont need any of those things... YOU need those things because you can't believe the truth you hear. Those people do come forward with their stories and share with others the truth.
The Bible and Jesus have never said I have to heal someone and then set up control groups to do further tests.
I just heal them in the name of Jesus and then tell them the truth about God. and disiple them and teach them so they can do the same to others
THAT IS THE GREAT COMMISION...
Love ya
Specilum 3 years ago
No, Specilum, you need those things too to use this youtube, your computer, any drugs you take, to drive your car, to makes phone call, etc etc etc. You don't know how the technology came about. So far you have not given even a single case - Do I have to conclude that you are avoiding because you don't have any evidence to back up your claims? ONE solid example is all I'm asking for, just one that you can verify.
farvision 3 years ago
watch the video on my favorites - miracles of healing - or watch raised from the dead.
I dont need to know how an internal combustion engine works to drive my car... I just know it works and trust it to get me to work... same idea here... I dont know the exact change that takes place in a persons body when I command it to be healed in the name of Jesus... I just know it works, and I put my faith in the Bible, and Jesus :-)
Specilum 3 years ago
Now you also need control groups who had the same diagnosis before and did not get healed in an equivalent time. You also need to have the medical records so you know it wasn't from a medical procedure. There was a beautification done where the person was being treated; such cases need to be thrown out because treatment is not a miracle. You need to double blind the experiment. Finally, you need enough examples to get a statiscally significant result so you are not fooling yourself.
farvision 3 years ago
I'm sure I've forgotten lots of things: proper protocols for human experimentation. These are all things that scientists have to face when testing a drug no wonder they are so expensive! But you can't neglect them. Anecdotal examples are nice but it's REALLY easy to be fooled by apparently exciting results! I know, it's happened to me many times! Then one has to come back to earth when one realizes the trivial explanation or whatever. Rarely one DOES have a cool result - and those we publish!
farvision 3 years ago