Kate Winslet is great in this movie!!!!she is one of the best actresses of our generation..whatever thing she does,she does in the most original way!!!
Kate Winslets scene listening to the choir of children,in the small church! Her face did more in terms of acting,in those few moments than I can remember over many years watching the world of cinema.
@beowulven a very smart old man told me that it was that justice does not come without literacy. or something does not come without literacy i cant remember well but do you agree?
If I understand correctly I think it makes great sense. Do you think he meant literal "literacy" (ability to read & write) or some kind of human or spiritual literacy (such as living by the Golden Rule or treating those who are unlike us with respect)?
I like to think that basic human values (a sort of "language of life") are held by all people, regardless of the ability to retain knowledge. But my parents were lefties, so...
I loved this movie, this is what cinema is supposed to be about: making you think and truely moving you. I would rather watch this then some other garbage like "27 Dresses" etc. Anyway, I believe Hanna was suffering from Post tramatic syndrome as well as guilt. You agree??
In my opinion is no a good movie at all.. and but in any case the award would be for the young actor that makes it much better. Kate made a boring and dull performance .. I do not see the point ..
As for the script of the movie .. is rather vulgar, and more of the same. One more excuse to go into the boring topic of the Nazis.
We all know how finish a nazi, in a U.S. pro semite film script. PLEASE!!!!
Saw the film recently. What a pile of Jewish piece of shit. They really try to make you feel all guilty inside. To make you not question them. Most of the film didn't even make sense, she was just acting weird all the time, you never knew what the hell she wanted, sitting quite all the time. There was no Gas-Chamber Holocaust of the Jews.
@Tatasama Yes, yes I am retarded as much as Sydney Pollack and the Owners of The Weinstein Company are not Jewish.
Oh what the hell am I wasting time explaining things... The truth is that you DON'T WANT to understand. For most people, the truth is boring and it hurts.
@cigolone1 Ha the truth is that the main point of this movie is only understood by smart and sensitive people who are always minority and clearly u are not included in that group. Saying that this movie is about holocaust-jewish-propaganda and that it "makes you feel guilty" only shows your poor level and such a bad taste in comprehension. Sorry for you actually.
historically the jews always implement their major frauds during chaotic times while the masses are disheveled such as 1945. In 1939 the author William Dudley Pelley published "The 45 Questions Most Frequently Asked About the Jews With the Answers by Pelley" which detailed how the number of jews in America skyrocketed from 4 million to 12 million during the 1930s. Nearly all of the european jews were deported to America or Palestine before WW2 even began. The holocaust story is outright fraud.
Hanna was deeply ashamed of her illiteracy and would rather confess to a crime than reveal to other people that she cannot read or write. Her illiteracy is supposed to be symbolic of something deeper in the story.
If the academy had been fair I think she should have already won 3 oscars...this one, for little children and for eternal sunshine of the spotless mind.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i hate this movie. Tipical to portray germans again as cold harded orde and discipline loving fuckers, who dont underatand the difference between duty and the death of a human. Please when will this kind of propaganda for retards stop ? oh yeah its from the WEINSTEIN COMPANY miramax blablabla..
And its important for the zionists that they keep remind the europeans about it. Wel maybe we dont FUCKING CARE ! ever thought about that ?
u haf misinterpreted it. it is trying to show us the perspective many would not take in looking at the holocausts. thru hanna, we see ourselves actually empathizing them. ppl who purely do what they are assigned to do. "we are guards. we are supposed to guard them."
@xARMINIUSx somehow that seem really beautiful to me. sometimes its not juz abt how much emotion or sympathy we have towards someone, but the spirit of purely doing our duty. In that very situation, tat was perhaps the best choice of achieving that...
i understand how u feel abt this, juz trying to ask u to see things not in a moral point of view sometimes. cos that often restricts our philosophical understanding of how human being work.
This movie is so moving. It should have won best picture at the Oscars. Thank God Kate won best actress. If her performance in this didn't do it I don't know what would.
The movie is interesting. I would like to know why the "kid" never made a contact with Hanna -face to face or by letter- Whas he ashamed of his affair with her? Was he annoyed with her because She left without saying gob bye? and why He did not help her at the trial.
It was more like he couldnt face her without feeling that she had betrayed him,as much as he had,in his own mind.And he didnt help her at the trial cause he could see she didnt want her secret to be revealed,and rather be in jail than do so.
but the movie adapted it slightly different from the book. michael is supposed to be kinda cold towards her during the trail almost detached of feelings. but i think the screenplay writer wanted more connection of the character to the audience and hence giving him more emotions during the trail.
I did not find they were so detached during the trip (in the book.) He seemed so elated to be in a world where they could be open and public about their relationship. He loved to follow her, he fretted about her dress getting caught in the spokes of her bicycle, and he imagined they would make love all night, but regretted they were too exhausted from riding all day long.
A wonderful movie indeed, one of the best ever made. And I honestly think that making love to a much younger guy is very, very exciting. Something all women in their thirties should actually do. The book is just as amazing as the movie itself. A very well told story.
The movie portraites the GERMAN society as it is - sick-twisted-nimphomaniac- who feels guilty n pass on the outrageous guilt turning it into artistic-sick memory - well done NAZIS
SHAYSHALOM....este film muestra un ser sano, transparente que como Alemana cumplio con su deber.
Me molesto en cambio la judia que viviendo lujosamente en NY..no supo aceptar su perdon. A pesar de todo el daño que los judios hacen al mundo, jamas reflexionan en sus errores.
Me molesto en neo-nazi espanios como tu ke ablas como estupidas criminals - el judios ke tu odias es todo to saves - hesus, einstein, freud, colombus, madonna, dylan, marks, gate, spilberg - all judios - te odias todo? jo meodio tu MALDITA
Yo no generalizo. judio burro ignorante!!!dylan se hizo catolico, a jesus lo mataron uds. Marks nunca los quiso, Madonna paractica esa boludez de uds por snob, spillberg se avergonzo durante mucho tiempo de ser judio jajajaj. uds son MATA NENES PALESTINOS!!!!
dylan es Robert Chimerman - an ortodox jew, Madonna converted n spilberg is dead jew (mertu jedeo) estas estupita kerida armana - GO TO WIKIPEDIA or GOOGLE n check fool girl!
No sabes hablar espanol, pero entiendo lo que estas tratando de decir. Detesto todo tipo de intolerancia. El bastardo de Hitler, espero que se este quemando en el infierno. Que no se rumoraba que el tambien llevaba sangre judia?
y eso que tiene que ver???. Los japoneses perdieron mas gente y supieron perdonar. Los mismos Alemanes vieron su patria destruida y siquieron adelante sin eternos lamentos.
si fuera un judio objetivo y analizara la historia de mi pueblo, me daria cuenta de que tambien se cometieron graves errores y que se estan repitiendo con Palestina,
Palestina es tierra de judios, y aunque no apruebo la violencia de cualquier pueblo que sea, eso es Biblico. Claro que en un mundo ideal, todos nos dariamos la mano, y no habrian guerras.
MI EPIDERMIS DESGASTADA POR TANTAS BATALLAS PERDIDAS MIS NEURONAS HABITADAS POR TANTO CONOCIMIENTO INUTIL Y SUBVERSIVO Y MI ALMA ICONOCLASTA PROCLAMAN SOLEMNEMENTE; QUERERTE SIN AMBIGUEDADES, SIN CODIGOS SECRETOS, SIN NOSTALGIAS; Y SIN CLAUSULAS OCULTAS. ES UNA DECLARACION INGENUA, TRANSPARENTE , Y SIMPLE TE QUIERO jed
I haven't seen it yet but i'm about to tonight. I heard alot about it though!
You can download a movie called "the hours" sad, complicated and confusing but i'm sure you will like it. 2002 production - Meryl streep, Nicole kidman and Julian moore.
haha, you can say that again! God, this film sucked hairy ass monkeyballz! This scene is even more retarded in English than it is in German! I find it so fucking stupid to put everyone in English accents, if this is supposed to be taking place in Germany! Everyone knows that Germans have more in common with Americans than with the English! If you think this film is intellectual, you're clearly an intellectual lightweight. this film isn't even good enough to jerk off to!!!
In my view Kate Winslet is a very overrated actress i believe the academy should get out of its habit of nominating her for every single fucking performance she gives! Particularly The Reader in which she plays a fucking PAEDOPHILE!!!! One can only wonder what she had to draw on from her own life........ if you know what i mean.
props for spelling paedophile correctly! don't forget about the fact that she's also a nazi. the dumbest scene in this shit-parade is by far the last, in which the father starts telling his daughter the story of his love-affair. what kind of a fuck-nut father would tell his daughter about how he used to bang a horny, ex concentration camp guard.
I cannot believe that they tried to lighten the story by allowing Michael to reveal the relationship to his daughter. That was not in the book (thankfully).
why did the father tell her daughter about his affair with the woman...
The father tells his daughter about the affair he had with the woman because, it was the reason for why their father-to-daughter relationship was so cold. He could not get over the fact that the woman he loves had done all this terrible things in the past, and so instead of forgiving and moving on, he was trapped in the past and unable to focus on her daughter.
Well, see how much guilt he must have felt even for only loving a woman he did not know was a guard?
That is one of the key questions in that story: how much guilt does the "younger" German Generation feel and how much gult did the Holocaust Generation had.
This is based on a true story. The person that wrote the book, is actually the kid in the movie. All that the kid went through in the movie, the writer of the book went through in real life.
... can't believe he slept with such a mature woman with just 17 years of age... no? ;)
I know, ever since I saw the movie I couldnt stop thinking of whether if it was real or what..
but it happens all the time.. people can fall in love no matter what age are they, is just that some people prevent that situation by not getting too involved.. but I just love the drama in this movie.. it made me cry all the time!!
Lies it's not based on Berhard Schlink, him and Michael have things in common but it's not based on him and Michael is 15 not 17. He tell her he is 17, he lies...just like you.
its not based on the writer!? oh well... my stepdad must be lying then... and alright 15 or 17... what does it matter in relation with her age... huh?
if ur reading this u cant go back there was a dad who got pissed cuz he got layed off so he went home took a knife than went to his 13 year old daughter and slit her neck! if u r reading this and dont forward to 10 vids the 13 year old girl be sitting on the endge of the bed waiting for tha when u wake up who ever takes care of u will find u in the tube full of bloode with ur throat slit and than the 13 year old girl will come to who ever takes care of u so hury dont be the that unlucky one!
Many critics seem to don't like this movie mainly because of the movie dealt with the Holocaust, child molestation, the fact that she seems to be more ashamed of herself being illiterate than war crimes and etc. But I don't think this film is not THAT shallow for serious movies and it doesn't ask you to feel sympathy for Nazi criminals. It just asks you how much your forgiveness can reach out in order to save yourself from feeling shameful about being innocent but also guilty of your past.
Haha what do you mean by believers? There are photographs, video footage, physical evidence, survivors, confessors, participants, testimonials, memoirs.
Read the book first, it is distressing when you get into the boy and feel what he feels and becomes even more mindbogling when you realise what an internal dilemma and conflict of loyalties he was facing when he finally knew....
Can any wrong be forgiven or can anybody have deep feelings for someone who has done wrong and ....
can you separate both. A devils dilemma but I choose love ... despite all.
The original book was called der vorleser from Bernhard Schlink. But it has been translated and in english it's called the reader. Just like the movie.
Todas las escenas son estupendas, me encanta Kate Winslet desde que la vi en "Titanic" luego hubo años de ausencia, Hollywood la criticó porque según la industria "estaba gorda" pero que más da unos kilos de más o de menos, si su talento es el de un pedazo de actriz. Todo se lee en sus ojos y el joven actor que trabaja con ella, promete.
i loved this scene as well.. he was so in love with her.. my other favorite scene was when she was mad at him.. almost yeling.. and he shuts her up with some very passionate kissing!! haha rather hot... ahem....
I am happy you are questioning it, not claiming it. That makes you eligible to think it through. There are just too many factors that affected her decision, there is one whole life behind it. My recommendation is to watch the movie again. (at least that's what I will do) and literally drink up the beginning by heart, not by senses.
i agree with you this is a extraordinary film very psycologic, enigmatic, at first it seems to be simple but is not at all!! I have watched it twice and still get goosebumps with some scenes!! BRILLIANT performances!! One of the best ever! Kate definitely rules she is on my Fav actress list for sure!!!
please read the book to get a better understanding...she didn't sign up to be a nazi war criminal. she signed up to be a guard. she was just ignorant and uneducated. i'm curious to learn about her childhood. who were her parents and how was she raised?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
you dont need to know how to read to know that killing is wrong or that you dont lock 300 people to die and hear their screams for help and do nothing.
of course u dont need to read to know that but if we judge according on that point of view then all the people, women and men of that area are as involved as this woman that was directly involved in that horrible situation. Everybody knew, some shut to survive. Some just saw the situation happen and decided to not do anything.
I liked this scene. It showed how she reacts to when faced with something to read... that confusion in her eyes, and that shame that she can't read like the boys... so riveting....
I didn't realize at this scene, that she couldn't read at that point. Because they made it look like she was just uncomfortable in public, or something. It wasn't until the court scene, I had realized she was illiterate.
Same here! I thought she was just uncomfortable being seen in public with her very much younger lover. I didn't realize she was illiterate until the court scene either.
Kate Winslet is great in this movie!!!!she is one of the best actresses of our generation..whatever thing she does,she does in the most original way!!!
MaisonIkkoku91 2 days ago
Such a moving film , acted out well by an incredibale cast .
DesirablePeaches 1 week ago
This woman thought she was smart as fuck she was a fucking clown...
sunnyblack15 2 weeks ago
My favorite book 5 stars
dirtydiana49111 6 months ago
IN EFFECT HERE, KATE WINSLETT PLAYS THE PART OF A PEADOPHILE AS IN REALITY IT IS QUITE RIGHTLY, IMMORAL AND ILLEGAL..
SaveSiamPlease 7 months ago
@SaveSiamPlease
Haha, sorry mate, but you're an idiot who didn't get the message of this movie.
Lintflas 3 months ago
meritevolisssimooooooooo
very good ;)))
giulllygiu 9 months ago
I still can't believe the end of this book/film. It's so sad...
thefartydoctor 10 months ago
One of the most depressing films I have ever seen. Bravo
angie4josh 11 months ago
Aw :D
surferdudette19 1 year ago
is there a reason why i got an erection from watching this?
pwnage589 1 year ago
Kate Winslets scene listening to the choir of children,in the small church! Her face did more in terms of acting,in those few moments than I can remember over many years watching the world of cinema.
DONAL914 1 year ago 5
Is it weird to think they make a good couple?
TomKennyIsLovely 1 year ago 3
um dos melhores films que eu ja vi, se não for o melhor !!
Barrettope 1 year ago
a lot of sex scenes in this movie with kate..
darksideXXXXX 1 year ago
@darksideXXXXX
Then, it is a half literature and half XXXXX moive.
I like it.
applesweeter 1 year ago
Comment removed
increible0incredula 1 year ago
whats the name of the province they go to on their hollidays¿?
increible0incredula 1 year ago
I'm going to go out on a limb and say that Kate Winslet is the greatest actor of our time. Apologies to Ben Kingsley.
beowulven 1 year ago 3
The book was the worst thing I've read in a long time.
Why do people give Oprah's opinion of books such credence?
damienmetalwind 1 year ago
i want to watch this so bad, but they took off all those movie sites and now i cant watch it :(
esrapk 1 year ago
can someone tell me the moral of the movie?
rakitipakiti 1 year ago
@rakitipakiti
That Nazis should be unrepentant?
beowulven 1 year ago
@beowulven a very smart old man told me that it was that justice does not come without literacy. or something does not come without literacy i cant remember well but do you agree?
rakitipakiti 1 year ago
@rakitipakiti
If I understand correctly I think it makes great sense. Do you think he meant literal "literacy" (ability to read & write) or some kind of human or spiritual literacy (such as living by the Golden Rule or treating those who are unlike us with respect)?
I like to think that basic human values (a sort of "language of life") are held by all people, regardless of the ability to retain knowledge. But my parents were lefties, so...
beowulven 1 year ago
I loved this movie, this is what cinema is supposed to be about: making you think and truely moving you. I would rather watch this then some other garbage like "27 Dresses" etc. Anyway, I believe Hanna was suffering from Post tramatic syndrome as well as guilt. You agree??
tarathetarantula 1 year ago
In my opinion is no a good movie at all.. and but in any case the award would be for the young actor that makes it much better. Kate made a boring and dull performance .. I do not see the point ..
As for the script of the movie .. is rather vulgar, and more of the same. One more excuse to go into the boring topic of the Nazis.
We all know how finish a nazi, in a U.S. pro semite film script. PLEASE!!!!
tranvozcaya 1 year ago
kate winslet was friggin INCREDIBLE in this movie.
PianoMan1191 1 year ago
just amazing awesome movie =(
wonderful
Thewildwolf79 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Saw the film recently. What a pile of Jewish piece of shit. They really try to make you feel all guilty inside. To make you not question them. Most of the film didn't even make sense, she was just acting weird all the time, you never knew what the hell she wanted, sitting quite all the time. There was no Gas-Chamber Holocaust of the Jews.
The only true quote in the whole God damn movie:
"There is a Jewish organization for everything"
NAZIGASSINGS[dot]c0m
cigolone1 1 year ago
@cigolone1 dman this is not about jewish u ar so retarded
Tatasama 1 year ago
@Tatasama Yes, yes I am retarded as much as Sydney Pollack and the Owners of The Weinstein Company are not Jewish.
Oh what the hell am I wasting time explaining things... The truth is that you DON'T WANT to understand. For most people, the truth is boring and it hurts.
cigolone1 1 year ago
@cigolone1 Ha the truth is that the main point of this movie is only understood by smart and sensitive people who are always minority and clearly u are not included in that group. Saying that this movie is about holocaust-jewish-propaganda and that it "makes you feel guilty" only shows your poor level and such a bad taste in comprehension. Sorry for you actually.
Tatasama 1 year ago
historically the jews always implement their major frauds during chaotic times while the masses are disheveled such as 1945. In 1939 the author William Dudley Pelley published "The 45 Questions Most Frequently Asked About the Jews With the Answers by Pelley" which detailed how the number of jews in America skyrocketed from 4 million to 12 million during the 1930s. Nearly all of the european jews were deported to America or Palestine before WW2 even began. The holocaust story is outright fraud.
GranpaWaltonWasRed 1 year ago
MY FAVOURITE FILM. The most powerful perfomance of Kate Winslet.
GAGAMAMAMAMA 1 year ago
i didnt understand,if she hadnt committed those crimes as she was illiterate then why did she opt for being guilty?
parkerphil20 1 year ago
Hanna was deeply ashamed of her illiteracy and would rather confess to a crime than reveal to other people that she cannot read or write. Her illiteracy is supposed to be symbolic of something deeper in the story.
Solil0quy 1 year ago
If the academy had been fair I think she should have already won 3 oscars...this one, for little children and for eternal sunshine of the spotless mind.
beliza87 1 year ago
Kate Winslet was great. Although personally I think she was better in Revolutionary Road and should've at least been nominated for an Oscar.
HoshigakiKisame3290 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's basically a movie about a paedophile relationship -regarding the age difference -quite inappropriate for a director to make unless it's freudian
outraged4U 2 years ago
i thought that was cute. He didn't make a fight, but proved the lady wrong with his actions. HA <3
MeetMeOnTheEquinox22 2 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
come check out my slide of david =]
krossfan 2 years ago
Ha! Thats funny! Your mother.
saucygiggs 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hate this movie. Tipical to portray germans again as cold harded orde and discipline loving fuckers, who dont underatand the difference between duty and the death of a human. Please when will this kind of propaganda for retards stop ? oh yeah its from the WEINSTEIN COMPANY miramax blablabla..
And its important for the zionists that they keep remind the europeans about it. Wel maybe we dont FUCKING CARE ! ever thought about that ?
xARMINIUSx 2 years ago
@xARMINIUSx this movie is not about that!
u haf misinterpreted it. it is trying to show us the perspective many would not take in looking at the holocausts. thru hanna, we see ourselves actually empathizing them. ppl who purely do what they are assigned to do. "we are guards. we are supposed to guard them."
kohdidi 2 years ago
I understand, but look when they ask her those questions and they reply again: we did our duty, our job , see the movie nurnberg, same thing.
xARMINIUSx 2 years ago
@xARMINIUSx somehow that seem really beautiful to me. sometimes its not juz abt how much emotion or sympathy we have towards someone, but the spirit of purely doing our duty. In that very situation, tat was perhaps the best choice of achieving that...
i understand how u feel abt this, juz trying to ask u to see things not in a moral point of view sometimes. cos that often restricts our philosophical understanding of how human being work.
kohdidi 2 years ago
what is the movie nurnberg?
pakeb 2 years ago
This movie is so moving. It should have won best picture at the Oscars. Thank God Kate won best actress. If her performance in this didn't do it I don't know what would.
slskid 2 years ago 41
She's SUPPORTING in this movie.
LickMyCuntMoFo 2 years ago
shes the leading she and the boy
Tatasama 2 years ago
She has 30-40 minutes on screen, therefore she is SUPPORTING.
LickMyCuntMoFo 2 years ago
but the storys about her all the tim
Tatasama 2 years ago 2
Well she did something right in order to win the Oscar.
slskid 2 years ago 8
@slskid the book was WAAAAAAAY better. read it
nightsky47 1 year ago
Oh I love this movie. Kate winslet is stunning simply stunning.
123AnPost 2 years ago 6
The movie is interesting. I would like to know why the "kid" never made a contact with Hanna -face to face or by letter- Whas he ashamed of his affair with her? Was he annoyed with her because She left without saying gob bye? and why He did not help her at the trial.
emorles 2 years ago
in the book, he says that he was excited when he got the letter.
ohjenxo 2 years ago
I think he would want to remember her as she was with him prior to the trial. Maybe confronting her would have been too difficult for him to handle.
natamasky 2 years ago
It was more like he couldnt face her without feeling that she had betrayed him,as much as he had,in his own mind.And he didnt help her at the trial cause he could see she didnt want her secret to be revealed,and rather be in jail than do so.
hotjames808 2 years ago
@hotjames808 u r right...
but the movie adapted it slightly different from the book. michael is supposed to be kinda cold towards her during the trail almost detached of feelings. but i think the screenplay writer wanted more connection of the character to the audience and hence giving him more emotions during the trail.
kohdidi 2 years ago 5
I did not find they were so detached during the trip (in the book.) He seemed so elated to be in a world where they could be open and public about their relationship. He loved to follow her, he fretted about her dress getting caught in the spokes of her bicycle, and he imagined they would make love all night, but regretted they were too exhausted from riding all day long.
UmmNoWay 2 years ago 5
haha... i meant the court trial...
kohdidi 2 years ago
A wonderful movie indeed, one of the best ever made. And I honestly think that making love to a much younger guy is very, very exciting. Something all women in their thirties should actually do. The book is just as amazing as the movie itself. A very well told story.
Prizak1 2 years ago
Yes I agree
saucygiggs 2 years ago
all i got to say is that michael aka david kross is so amazingly cute.
30255413 2 years ago 28
shayshalom tu as écris le commentaires de loin le plus débile que je n'ai jamais lu sur internet.
Surtsey25 2 years ago
This is a wonderful movie....
FACEmaPUNANY1hunnit 2 years ago
The movie portraites the GERMAN society as it is - sick-twisted-nimphomaniac- who feels guilty n pass on the outrageous guilt turning it into artistic-sick memory - well done NAZIS
shayshalom 2 years ago
SHAYSHALOM....este film muestra un ser sano, transparente que como Alemana cumplio con su deber.
Me molesto en cambio la judia que viviendo lujosamente en NY..no supo aceptar su perdon. A pesar de todo el daño que los judios hacen al mundo, jamas reflexionan en sus errores.
finijfk10 2 years ago
Me molesto en neo-nazi espanios como tu ke ablas como estupidas criminals - el judios ke tu odias es todo to saves - hesus, einstein, freud, colombus, madonna, dylan, marks, gate, spilberg - all judios - te odias todo? jo meodio tu MALDITA
shayshalom 2 years ago
Yo no generalizo. judio burro ignorante!!!dylan se hizo catolico, a jesus lo mataron uds. Marks nunca los quiso, Madonna paractica esa boludez de uds por snob, spillberg se avergonzo durante mucho tiempo de ser judio jajajaj. uds son MATA NENES PALESTINOS!!!!
finijfk10 2 years ago
dylan es Robert Chimerman - an ortodox jew, Madonna converted n spilberg is dead jew (mertu jedeo) estas estupita kerida armana - GO TO WIKIPEDIA or GOOGLE n check fool girl!
shayshalom 2 years ago
pero tu - from wikipedia:
1. Bob Dylan (born Robert Allen Zimmerman on May 24, 1941) ...NOW IS apart of close-knit Jewish community.
2. Karl Marx -...considered himself both of ethnically Jewish n Culture.
3. Jesus - .. was a Jew who was regarded as a teacher and healer...
shayshalom 2 years ago
,Mentiras !!!judio burro.
ninguno de los tres, acordo con el pensamiento arrogante del judio invasor.
judios MATA NENES
finijfk10 2 years ago
No sabes hablar espanol, pero entiendo lo que estas tratando de decir. Detesto todo tipo de intolerancia. El bastardo de Hitler, espero que se este quemando en el infierno. Que no se rumoraba que el tambien llevaba sangre judia?
erosr1 2 years ago
And I speak English too.
erosr1 2 years ago
Se te olvida que mas de 6 millones de judios fueron masacrados? Como si eso no fuera poco.
erosr1 2 years ago
y eso que tiene que ver???. Los japoneses perdieron mas gente y supieron perdonar. Los mismos Alemanes vieron su patria destruida y siquieron adelante sin eternos lamentos.
finijfk10 2 years ago
Pensarias diferente si fueras judio.
erosr1 2 years ago
si fuera un judio objetivo y analizara la historia de mi pueblo, me daria cuenta de que tambien se cometieron graves errores y que se estan repitiendo con Palestina,
finijfk10 2 years ago
Palestina es tierra de judios, y aunque no apruebo la violencia de cualquier pueblo que sea, eso es Biblico. Claro que en un mundo ideal, todos nos dariamos la mano, y no habrian guerras.
erosr1 2 years ago
lussam 2 years ago
the look on kates face was like "shit. these kids are the same age as the guy im dating"
freakyobsessed 2 years ago 4
lmao
edwardcullen271 2 years ago
have u seen the movie? her look wasnt representing that, she was trying to say that even the kids can read but she cudnt.
dinnohim 2 years ago 3
yeah when i watch that clip again,i realise ur right lol
freakyobsessed 2 years ago
i just finished sawing it. A beautiful yet sad movie. I cried. I needed to see this movie. it did so much for me.
Does anyone know a movie just like this?please tell me.
betumene 2 years ago
I haven't seen it yet but i'm about to tonight. I heard alot about it though!
You can download a movie called "the hours" sad, complicated and confusing but i'm sure you will like it. 2002 production - Meryl streep, Nicole kidman and Julian moore.
hannallc 2 years ago
watch zwartboek aka black book.
MartinKrauen 2 years ago
have u seen the movie END OF THE AFFAIR. i hope u will like it
sjunu 2 years ago
it seems to be a good movie. good actors, good story. I will most definitely watch it. Thank you
=D
betumene 2 years ago
ys u sud. really nice movie.
sjunu 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
TO ALL HOLOCAUST BELIEVERS!!!! Watch the playlist on my channel and then visit the website I link to!!!!
TheAntiSeMight 2 years ago
so u said that no people were prisoners lol u are such a retard i even know 2 survivors and holocaust was REAL ok.
Tatasama 2 years ago
I never said no people were prisoners...
TheAntiSeMight 2 years ago
i wanna see the reader with a happy ending version. this film is such a great film.. great act by the boy and kate winslett.
ririwirasatria 2 years ago
It can't have a happy ending.
After all, Hanna was guitly and did not feel any remorse. She was an uneducated average Woman, but she knew she killed innocent.
It just seemed as if killing innocents was legal at that time in German history.
It might not have been illegal , but it was wrong.
So why should she get away with it?
She kind of runs away from her past, but she can only run, but never hide.
schusterlehrling 2 years ago
I love this part... it's funny.... that's what people get for assuming things...
bettescorpio 2 years ago
i thought it was a good film, bit confusing but still :)
MissTashaJade 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Kate Winslet's tits have sure lost their appeal since "Titanic".
Delta0prative 2 years ago
haha, you can say that again! God, this film sucked hairy ass monkeyballz! This scene is even more retarded in English than it is in German! I find it so fucking stupid to put everyone in English accents, if this is supposed to be taking place in Germany! Everyone knows that Germans have more in common with Americans than with the English! If you think this film is intellectual, you're clearly an intellectual lightweight. this film isn't even good enough to jerk off to!!!
NazTb0y 2 years ago
Nace neutro. O vacio. Las experiencias lo llenan y su educacion y valores lo llevaran a ser alguien bueno o malo.
Tatasama 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
In my view Kate Winslet is a very overrated actress i believe the academy should get out of its habit of nominating her for every single fucking performance she gives! Particularly The Reader in which she plays a fucking PAEDOPHILE!!!! One can only wonder what she had to draw on from her own life........ if you know what i mean.
chickbitch21 2 years ago
props for spelling paedophile correctly! don't forget about the fact that she's also a nazi. the dumbest scene in this shit-parade is by far the last, in which the father starts telling his daughter the story of his love-affair. what kind of a fuck-nut father would tell his daughter about how he used to bang a horny, ex concentration camp guard.
NazTb0y 2 years ago
I cannot believe that they tried to lighten the story by allowing Michael to reveal the relationship to his daughter. That was not in the book (thankfully).
cornflaked 2 years ago
.... you didn't get the story at all...
why did the father tell her daughter about his affair with the woman...
The father tells his daughter about the affair he had with the woman because, it was the reason for why their father-to-daughter relationship was so cold. He could not get over the fact that the woman he loves had done all this terrible things in the past, and so instead of forgiving and moving on, he was trapped in the past and unable to focus on her daughter.
TzimasJ 2 years ago
are you aware that it wasn't her daughter, but rather of a completely different woman?
NazTb0y 2 years ago
Well, see how much guilt he must have felt even for only loving a woman he did not know was a guard?
That is one of the key questions in that story: how much guilt does the "younger" German Generation feel and how much gult did the Holocaust Generation had.
That is the key theme of this story.
So you GOT a good point.
schusterlehrling 2 years ago
people shold stop being so dramatic
angelscar567 2 years ago
i dont mean to be ignorant.. but was this a true story!!!
or it just had like a 4% true story...???
I watch the movie yesterday...
terion20 2 years ago
haha why ignorant?
no it aint true. its fictional
bpprom 2 years ago
oh... thanks
I kept reading the other comments..and they kept talking about the book, this and that.. and u know that most books are made after a real situation...
I feel better know... since i watched the movie.. couldnt stop thinking about it.. ... if it happended for real.. jaja
terion20 2 years ago
its based on a book....what i dont know if is the book based in real facts? lol
Tatasama 2 years ago
This is based on a true story. The person that wrote the book, is actually the kid in the movie. All that the kid went through in the movie, the writer of the book went through in real life.
... can't believe he slept with such a mature woman with just 17 years of age... no? ;)
TzimasJ 2 years ago
I know, ever since I saw the movie I couldnt stop thinking of whether if it was real or what..
but it happens all the time.. people can fall in love no matter what age are they, is just that some people prevent that situation by not getting too involved.. but I just love the drama in this movie.. it made me cry all the time!!
thanks for the answer..
terion20 2 years ago
He was actually 15 - at least that's what it says in the book - and she only thought that he was 17; of course he did not correct her :P
saskewoo 2 years ago
Lies it's not based on Berhard Schlink, him and Michael have things in common but it's not based on him and Michael is 15 not 17. He tell her he is 17, he lies...just like you.
SigourneyRoss 2 years ago
its not based on the writer!? oh well... my stepdad must be lying then... and alright 15 or 17... what does it matter in relation with her age... huh?
...but u got a point... i lied
TzimasJ 2 years ago
Hmm, it's okay...you should read the book, it guarantee it will remain in your top 10 books for the rest of your life.
SigourneyRoss 2 years ago
alright... i'll make sure i read it then :)
TzimasJ 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if ur reading this u cant go back there was a dad who got pissed cuz he got layed off so he went home took a knife than went to his 13 year old daughter and slit her neck! if u r reading this and dont forward to 10 vids the 13 year old girl be sitting on the endge of the bed waiting for tha when u wake up who ever takes care of u will find u in the tube full of bloode with ur throat slit and than the 13 year old girl will come to who ever takes care of u so hury dont be the that unlucky one!
supercoolpunk09 2 years ago
Many critics seem to don't like this movie mainly because of the movie dealt with the Holocaust, child molestation, the fact that she seems to be more ashamed of herself being illiterate than war crimes and etc. But I don't think this film is not THAT shallow for serious movies and it doesn't ask you to feel sympathy for Nazi criminals. It just asks you how much your forgiveness can reach out in order to save yourself from feeling shameful about being innocent but also guilty of your past.
koritish 2 years ago 5
...and everybody who made these up
quatrum123 2 years ago
Haha what do you mean by believers? There are photographs, video footage, physical evidence, survivors, confessors, participants, testimonials, memoirs.
It happened.
drovethroughghosts 2 years ago 2
im reading the book
SECCheerleader 2 years ago
Read the book first, it is distressing when you get into the boy and feel what he feels and becomes even more mindbogling when you realise what an internal dilemma and conflict of loyalties he was facing when he finally knew....
Can any wrong be forgiven or can anybody have deep feelings for someone who has done wrong and ....
can you separate both. A devils dilemma but I choose love ... despite all.
wiekie96 2 years ago
what is the book called?
fuckrussianz 2 years ago
The original book was called der vorleser from Bernhard Schlink. But it has been translated and in english it's called the reader. Just like the movie.
wiekie96 2 years ago
but in the book the kid reallly feels things for her, i mean he was in love >?
Tatasama 2 years ago
True, that is why the book is more tragic and gripping...
Can anybody be blamed for loving someone?
smitschagen 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Cool video, check out mine!
MikesRealityShow 2 years ago
anyone know where i can watch this movie online?
summerbeachh 2 years ago
go buy the dvd
thelousyllama 2 years ago
i went to blockbuster and rented it lol
summerbeachh 2 years ago
if you had red the book, you wouldn't have said something like that !!!!!
violetflower91 2 years ago
Todas las escenas son estupendas, me encanta Kate Winslet desde que la vi en "Titanic" luego hubo años de ausencia, Hollywood la criticó porque según la industria "estaba gorda" pero que más da unos kilos de más o de menos, si su talento es el de un pedazo de actriz. Todo se lee en sus ojos y el joven actor que trabaja con ella, promete.
Enfin una pelicula sencilla y que da gusto ver.
glosogar 2 years ago
Poor girl...... she doesn't understand the words on the menu at all, even the kids sitting by can do so(with joy)
It's a meaningful scene!
wasabi1230 2 years ago 12
I agree. She is able to show that element of self-contempt that is carried by her inability to read
erinpilla 2 years ago 6
i loved this scene as well.. he was so in love with her.. my other favorite scene was when she was mad at him.. almost yeling.. and he shuts her up with some very passionate kissing!! haha rather hot... ahem....
jodilyn 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No way..I almost puke seing that scene. Worst couple ever.
semuaputih 2 years ago
beatiful
stephpombo 2 years ago
i love kate winslet
roberttLima1987 2 years ago
that's one of my fav scenes...don't know why - I just like it
footballerwive 2 years ago
watch it online here : xtshare. com/movie/viewfilm.php?Id=164&view=The-Reader
gargouri2001 2 years ago
I am happy you are questioning it, not claiming it. That makes you eligible to think it through. There are just too many factors that affected her decision, there is one whole life behind it. My recommendation is to watch the movie again. (at least that's what I will do) and literally drink up the beginning by heart, not by senses.
Miganiya 2 years ago
i agree with you this is a extraordinary film very psycologic, enigmatic, at first it seems to be simple but is not at all!! I have watched it twice and still get goosebumps with some scenes!! BRILLIANT performances!! One of the best ever! Kate definitely rules she is on my Fav actress list for sure!!!
Tatasama 2 years ago 4
it's really a fanstatic movie!
but i think there are too sex scenes in the first part of the movie....XD
elfetto89 2 years ago
are you complaining about it?
echoteru 2 years ago
Absolutely Brilliant movie
mars7272 2 years ago 4
i agree best i have seen in awhile
dewbunny110362 2 years ago
i started to read the book today.
I CANNOT STOP READING IT !
laka101 2 years ago 2
i have a question.... she was innocent she did not know how to write and read. so why she said that she wrote the report in the court?!!!
was she just ashamed of not knowing how to read?!!!
nariman89nkf 2 years ago
I believe so. She was a proud woman and very strong, so I think she was kind of ashamed of not knowing how to read. I dont know any other reason.
Araso16 2 years ago
what did you think of all the sex in the movie?
hallnoats4ever 2 years ago
yes she was .. she would dead for her proud. she would never say: I can't read!!!
danielledieser 2 years ago
If that's the point of the movie, I promise not to ever express opinion on anything
Miganiya 2 years ago
yes
hallnoats4ever 2 years ago
Because she is more ashamed of being an illiterate than being a Nazi war criminal.
ktchong 2 years ago
please read the book to get a better understanding...she didn't sign up to be a nazi war criminal. she signed up to be a guard. she was just ignorant and uneducated. i'm curious to learn about her childhood. who were her parents and how was she raised?
echoteru 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you dont need to know how to read to know that killing is wrong or that you dont lock 300 people to die and hear their screams for help and do nothing.
cpfishfan14 2 years ago
of course u dont need to read to know that but if we judge according on that point of view then all the people, women and men of that area are as involved as this woman that was directly involved in that horrible situation. Everybody knew, some shut to survive. Some just saw the situation happen and decided to not do anything.
Pandex 2 years ago
she deserved the oscar!!!!!!!!
putthemusic 2 years ago 6
I couldn't agree more.
Farfallavlinder 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hannah Schmidt was a pedaphile. Does Kate Winslet really love underage boys in real life though?
mjay22 2 years ago
no it wsa jjust acting.. he is at least 18
dewbunny110362 2 years ago
what an important scene.i didnt guess it. But my friend guessed it out at this point....
whoisdaboss 2 years ago
I liked this scene. It showed how she reacts to when faced with something to read... that confusion in her eyes, and that shame that she can't read like the boys... so riveting....
erinpilla 2 years ago 2
I love you david kross such a little h ottie!
jocelyna38 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
claro que si
Pappoe79 2 years ago
I didn't realize at this scene, that she couldn't read at that point. Because they made it look like she was just uncomfortable in public, or something. It wasn't until the court scene, I had realized she was illiterate.
GirlPlayXSoCal 2 years ago 4
Same here! I thought she was just uncomfortable being seen in public with her very much younger lover. I didn't realize she was illiterate until the court scene either.
VanessaKrystle 2 years ago
oh please i did realized about it when she asked him to order at the restaurant..She was reading the menu bckwards
Tatasama 2 years ago
I only knew because I'd read the book. But I doubt I would've guessed either.
TwilightBee8 2 years ago
i guessed out at this point
dabaowh 2 years ago
realy?
shokazoom 2 years ago
jajajaj
1Beatlemaniac1 2 years ago
lol
leighgirl123 2 years ago