So great to see a young guy singing the solo bass part.... I don't know why but I always assume it's sung by an older gent.
The tenor sounds very average, but still great, but all the other parts absolutely amazed me. Lovely recording..... I would love to get a CD or DVD of this concert.
I personally prefer Karl Bohm's one. But this one is pretty good too. It's always great to see classical music pieces on youtube. Thank you for putting this.
The tenor piece is the most vital and epic part in this piece, the soul and corner stone of passion that defines this piece and that guy slaughtered it. Very unimpressed with the lack of heart he put into it. The others were wonderful especially the Alto
@kalloused Say, what? His performance sounded fine to me. It's a technically-demanding piece, and he was note-perfect. The fact that you don't personally like his interpretation doesn't mean that it was objectively a "bad" performance.
I wish people would stop assuming that they are the supreme arbiters of the "right" way to interpret musical works. Some people like it one way, some people like it another. This is not a "bad" performance merely because it doesn't suit your personal tastes.
@Walton1008 Singing note for note doesn't make it good. Too fast and sloppy. That is one of the most beautiful pieces in Requiem, it is not supposed to sound anything like this. Do a little research and find a truly great recording of this Requiem then you'll understand.
@kalloused Actually, I've heard many recordings of the Requiem - some, certainly, very different from this one. But I do not believe that there is a single "right" way to interpret any piece of music, or that a particular performance is objectively "bad" merely because it doesn't suit some critic's personal tastes.
non mi piace per niente come entra il soprano!! deve entrare leggermente prima, con un maggiore crescendo, allungando la durata e permettendo anche all'orchestra di far sentire la melodia perfetta!! W MOZART
All were lovely, but that soprano....a voice that is simply Divine. A beautiful interpretation of Herr Mozart's masterwork. It is a bit of a pity that the tenor was so expressive (right choice of word?), he has a fine voice.
I like a lot, I just think the tenor, compared to alto and sopran, sings it operatically, I mean, too dramatic. Don't get me wrong he's got a precious voice, I dream of such a voice, but his slurs in the stupebit and resurget are very operatic, whereas the other soloists are much more reserved. Anyway it is great and I loved it, thanks a lot.
O interpretare intradevar emotionanta si de referinta! Splendida vocea si prezenta basului Francois Lis; de admirat in opera LA PIETRA DEL PARAGONE de Rossini, (video) montata la Chatelet in 2007!
@johndaniels2180 --> impossible to imagine how hard it is to play such an obtrusive brass solo, where pitch is so important, on a trombone!!! unbelievable
Outstanding performance from the singers, especially Tenor and soprano
ChaosFZ8 6 days ago
By far the best version on youtube, no doubt. The tempo is just perfect!
Y3k666 1 month ago
So great to see a young guy singing the solo bass part.... I don't know why but I always assume it's sung by an older gent.
The tenor sounds very average, but still great, but all the other parts absolutely amazed me. Lovely recording..... I would love to get a CD or DVD of this concert.
hotqueekboi 3 months ago
I personally prefer Karl Bohm's one. But this one is pretty good too. It's always great to see classical music pieces on youtube. Thank you for putting this.
Neonalfax 3 months ago
That soprano is excellent!
chavianog24 4 months ago
wow. exiting :P
BloodyWire408 5 months ago
The tenor piece is the most vital and epic part in this piece, the soul and corner stone of passion that defines this piece and that guy slaughtered it. Very unimpressed with the lack of heart he put into it. The others were wonderful especially the Alto
kalloused 7 months ago
@kalloused Say, what? His performance sounded fine to me. It's a technically-demanding piece, and he was note-perfect. The fact that you don't personally like his interpretation doesn't mean that it was objectively a "bad" performance.
I wish people would stop assuming that they are the supreme arbiters of the "right" way to interpret musical works. Some people like it one way, some people like it another. This is not a "bad" performance merely because it doesn't suit your personal tastes.
Walton1008 4 months ago
@Walton1008 Singing note for note doesn't make it good. Too fast and sloppy. That is one of the most beautiful pieces in Requiem, it is not supposed to sound anything like this. Do a little research and find a truly great recording of this Requiem then you'll understand.
kalloused 4 months ago
@kalloused Actually, I've heard many recordings of the Requiem - some, certainly, very different from this one. But I do not believe that there is a single "right" way to interpret any piece of music, or that a particular performance is objectively "bad" merely because it doesn't suit some critic's personal tastes.
Walton1008 2 months ago
This is absolutely adorable ;)
MasterClassRU 7 months ago 2
THa BASS!!! beautiful sound on Sonum
LovvaBoi 9 months ago 3
@LovvaBoi Yes but when I hear him I think he's singing a romantic aria!
mouthmouse 8 months ago
Francois Lis is super""""Még hallunk róla remélem..
duma2591 10 months ago
It sound's like 4 solist's forced together.
-Hold back, for heavens sake!
Ostochskinkmackan 11 months ago
too fast
smorinjo 1 year ago
The vibrato of the alto is perhaps too strong...
CaspiWaltch 1 year ago
davvero discreto il baritono;) una gioia por gli occhi e le orecchie!
ziafumina 1 year ago
Anche se funerea,questa musica è un inno alla vita.
Giuseppe6281 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
... per se purchla????... 0:54 :) :)
Love these kind of mistakes. Otherwise not too bad.
fandango1111 1 year ago
... per se purcla???? 0:54 :) :) Love these kind of mistakes. Otherwise not too bad.
fandango1111 1 year ago
all "g" consonants performed by the bass are worng. It is pronounced as the g in golf in j in jessica.
danijelbratina 1 year ago
@danijelbratina wrong : It's ecclesiastical pronunciation, close to italan : 'g' is indeed pronounced like 'j' in jessica.
cf Erasmus : Dialogus de recta latini graecique sermonis pronuntatione
Chavvvvvvv 1 year ago 3
¡Qué hermosa voz y qué guapo el bajo!
LuzanSiller 1 year ago
excelente, excelente, hermosisimo, bello!
HijadelaIglesia 1 year ago
where is the trombonist rushing to??
davisbone 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
LLJtbone 1 year ago
@davisbone He was rushing it ever so slightly, right when he came in with the tenor. Anyways, he has a really nice sound, <3ing it.
LLJtbone 1 year ago
Sans doute la meilleur version... Tout est bon : La direction, les solistes, et le son. Bravo !
wolfibigoude 1 year ago
per se purchra?...^^ the french love the r^^
musicandi88 1 year ago
@musicandi88 No, he says it correctly. And to his credit, his low note there rocks.
saintsaens21 11 months ago
non mi piace per niente come entra il soprano!! deve entrare leggermente prima, con un maggiore crescendo, allungando la durata e permettendo anche all'orchestra di far sentire la melodia perfetta!! W MOZART
Theclassicmax 2 years ago
Why is the tenor so angry ? :D
Acuslembus 2 years ago
Lovely, lovely rendition! All four sing with compasion and without effort. I must found out what other pieces from this mass were posted! Bravi!
Gclef11 2 years ago
Who on earth is the soprano? She sings so effortlessly with beautiful voice...
jhyounyo 2 years ago
If you pull up on the right side of the screen the names are listed as follows: soprano, alto, tenor then bass.
xmetbass 2 years ago
that last soprano stole the show
YaleU 2 years ago
I prefer the version of Karajan
Theclassicmax 2 years ago
The alto is so pretty! :D
jotatanv 2 years ago
who is the bass??? i am in loveee soo sexyyy ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh bababababa
zasesdea 2 years ago
anddd the mezzo it s so beauty
zasesdea 2 years ago
Gardiner version is better than this....Great job though!
rv8dvd 2 years ago
Una versión impecable. El bajo, excepcional.
alvarorpalacios 2 years ago 6
All were lovely, but that soprano....a voice that is simply Divine. A beautiful interpretation of Herr Mozart's masterwork. It is a bit of a pity that the tenor was so expressive (right choice of word?), he has a fine voice.
jag10fireman 2 years ago
The most perfect version I've found on Youtube of thsi part of the mass! Thank you! :-D
HerrWarja 2 years ago 3
genial mozart, me encanta, y el bajo excelente...
Mamuelyop 2 years ago
c'est bidon, du play back, c'est pas du tout eux qui chantent
janfyslip 2 years ago
Si ce sont eux qui chantent mais la technologie youtube donne l'impression que c'est du playback. J'etais au concert ce jour la.
nadiapatton 2 years ago
Holy French Bai...no complaints, though. Definitely no complaints.
CatalinaDM56 2 years ago
Grande questo basso!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Leluride 2 years ago
5/5 tres bien!
kempff95 2 years ago 2
Mezzo girl makes a face like my cat does when I scratch its back.
amecresse 2 years ago
Does anybody knows their names?
paliba1109 2 years ago
Soprano Diana Higbee
Mezzo Stéphanie d'Oustrac
Tenor Yann Beuron
Bass Francois Lis
Conductor Pierre Michel Durand
nadiapatton 2 years ago
Lol. The tenor is squeaking, but everyone else was flawless. =)
WaitonAlsoSings 2 years ago
excelente interpretación felicitaciones a todos y gracias por subir el vid
excellent performance, congrats everyone and thanks for upload
i dont speak french / no hablo francés
but / pero...
magnifique!
vgdd4 2 years ago
The bass is really cute!!!!! Beautiful in the voice and face :P
Nicodemo86 2 years ago 3
OMG you are SO right! Very hot and beautiful voice!!
FigoItaliano 2 years ago
;)....ma sei italiano????
Nicodemo86 2 years ago
Si, e tu? Penso si haha :-D
FigoItaliano 2 years ago
@FigoItaliano
hai msn? o skype?
Nicodemo86 6 months ago
Magnifique.
quentinhielle 2 years ago
amazing trombonist!
hondaccordriver 2 years ago
TUBBBAAAAA MIRRRUUU<MMMMMM
crankyanker157 3 years ago
I like a lot, I just think the tenor, compared to alto and sopran, sings it operatically, I mean, too dramatic. Don't get me wrong he's got a precious voice, I dream of such a voice, but his slurs in the stupebit and resurget are very operatic, whereas the other soloists are much more reserved. Anyway it is great and I loved it, thanks a lot.
andipipo 3 years ago
Before reading the comments I was thinking the exact same thing; then I thought, well maybe I'm being too much a snob.
Interesting.
lazer58 2 years ago
Wow the singers are excellent in this one, and the tempo is perfect!
RobertAGateley 3 years ago 22
Alto is to die for...Incredible!
johnforell 3 years ago 4
I agree, the alto is really incredibly good! :)
limetime11 2 years ago 3
Wspaniałe wykonanie!
amabeline 3 years ago
!Qué música! La voz de los solistas es bella y muy cálida. El tenor es fantástico. Así cantarán los ángeles...
riddare1 3 years ago
impresionantes solistas
AinuriMadness666 3 years ago
O interpretare intradevar emotionanta si de referinta! Splendida vocea si prezenta basului Francois Lis; de admirat in opera LA PIETRA DEL PARAGONE de Rossini, (video) montata la Chatelet in 2007!
harapalb100 3 years ago
that sopran is really impressive
BassGK 3 years ago 2
wow i felt in love with sopran!
sophie8977 3 years ago 2
Fabulus.....
prokopuoi 3 years ago
Amazing trombonist, sopranos and orchestra.
Here is Chartres Cathedral
date, 29-9-2006
and
Mozart - Requiem 250th Anniversary Concert
This consert is completely amazing.
love2sing4him 3 years ago 2
who are thesingers? can anyone answer?
TROSA2 3 years ago
Yes, it's written !
Diana Higbee, Stephanie d'Oustrac, Yann Beuron, François Lis.
ParUnSoirDeJuillet 3 years ago
YAAAAAAAAAAAAAN, forever !
ParUnSoirDeJuillet 3 years ago 2
who's the soprano? she's amazing!
Jetsettercam 3 years ago 4
Congratulations to the trombonist!
johndaniels2180 3 years ago 23
@johndaniels2180 --> impossible to imagine how hard it is to play such an obtrusive brass solo, where pitch is so important, on a trombone!!! unbelievable
johnuio 7 months ago
Nice performance, save for the accidental slip-ups in words. I love this movement from the Requiem...
drdre333 4 years ago
I love the bass!
jinji15 4 years ago 4