Added: 3 years ago
From: idolmusic08
Views: 55,933
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (129)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I feel like he tried to force it to be more fluid, and that's not what the melody reflects.

  • Stunningly beautiful. Maybe no one beats Billy Joel, but David did a wonderful job with this.Great arrangement, and the vocals to pull it off without a doubt. I still do not understand how this guy lost.This is one of my favorite songs, and this is probably one of the top 3 performances I have heard . It would have been interesting to hear David do this totally a capella. There aren't many who could pull it off, but he might be one.

  • simon ass alway got somethin smart to say

  • you sound amazing!

  • he's shit!

  • wow.... amazing!

  • His voice is so perfect!

  • So bad, thinking of what song actually is.... only good versions I've found so far are (of course) Billy Joel, and Marianas Trench

  • @xdoo16 Yes to the Marianas Trench. Yes times a million.

  • @WhiteCheddarISbetter and that yes times another million....and another...and another...and then just infinity.

  • @BCDL08 until the end of time

  • @xdoo16 check out sgt sonny

  • @jd7x7jd ???

  • he should've practised his breathing a little more. He's breathing in so loudly it's a little disturbing :/

  • it's not billy joel but i would still pay good money to hear him in concert

  • Nah. Geoff Herrmann covers this song with the UMass Doo Wop Shop about ten times better. .....And has a manlier sounding voice

  • I must admit, it is a beautifu;l song, and when you search itm, you hear all artists showing off vocals by covering. BUT the BEST cover alive with the best harmony is Marianas Trench.

    Search it.

    Watch it.

    Cry.

    Agree with me.

    Proud to be a canadian loving a Canadian band <3

  • @horsebackgirl96 Marianas Trench is the best! Their cover is beautiful!

  • This guy is really young, but he has an amazing voice. Justin Bieber is also young, so he doesn't have an excuse for being a terrible singer.

  • @TransformerslNC ^ this guy knows the truth

  • Lets face it....No one can beat Billy Joel.

  • @lockchain definitely. he's my favorite artist, tied with Coldplay

  • The emotional part in this whole version is far too overdone. IMHO every drip of emotion in this is an calculated work. Perfectly performed but not a tiny bit real. .....

  • David Archuleta's version and rendition of the the song is way a lot better than original and very much heartfelt with all due respect. David's interpretation of the song penetrates the soul. He is simply incredible and absolutely flawless.

  • It was a beautiful song. And because it was David who sang it, made the song even more beautiful. I don't think if Kris Allen or Le D. has to sing this song it will be that beautiful. How if Sanjaya Malakar sings it??LOL.

  • Both Davids were great. I'm glad they can both be "famous" now :)

  • okay, this made me cry. its a beautiful and simple song, and i LOVE it, and his voice (david's) is flawless in this. nothing wrong with it. <3

  • Well, that was rubbish. It's not a bloody R&B song, with all of that atonal claptrap so beloved of that benighted genre. Just sing the bloody melody, you idiot.

  • @lordrosemount was thinking the same thing... he's a good singer, he's just not singing to the emotion of the song.

  • DAVID COOK ALL THE WAY!!!

  • uhh no archie was dropped by his record label... was cook dropped? heck no!

  • Well, David Archuleta ended up doing better than Cook :3 

  • Beautiful! 

  • @pscanyc3 you can ԝatch tv frοm аll οvеr tհe world οո yoսr рc jսѕt by doԝnloadinց ѕοme рroցram, it's ցοt tհousandѕ of chaոոels οn іt. јսst ցo to linevid com (put a . beforе tհе ϲom, іt ԝon't let me pοѕt lіnkѕ for ѕοme reasοո) іt'ѕ а bit priϲey bսt it's jսst οոe tіmе aոd it ԝοrkѕ rеаlly well

  • Can this Paula person be stupider??

  • @skybart More stupid, darling. "Stupider" is not a word. And no, she isn't. He did this song very well. She picked a good one.

  • @lastblakrose

    SYLLABICATION: stu•pid

    ADJECTIVE: Inflected forms: stu•pid•er, stu•pid•est

    And yes, she is stupid--just listen to her. And let's just leave this petty arguing, alright?. As you see above, "stupider" is indeed a valid word. Look it up.

  • Comment removed

  • Cook SUCKS, Archuleta ROCKS!!!!!!

  • I like Cook better but damn was that good. =)

  • HE did Sooo Amzing I love this version :)

  • Archuleta was not choosen as the American Ideal because he too was TOO GAY. "And So It Goes", they continue to beat down all the gays no matter how good they are - NO GAY PERSON CAN POSSIBLE BE AN AMERICAN IDOL. Clay Aiken almost did it, Lambert was way out of the closet, Archuleta was a little too femine, beyond the boyish thing. IDOLS CAN'T BE GAY, ask your right-wing conservative teabagging racist or any republican.

  • @BornGayTaughtToHate - Yeah... too bad David Archuleta's straight.

  • @OutsidersFreak101 RIGHT - So was Ricky Martin, Lance Bass, Rock hudson, Elton John, Freddie Mercury and Alexander the Great.

  • @BornGayTaughtToHate Archuleta is not gay. 

  • @BornGayTaughtToHate It's the voters' choice

  • Very nice "a cappella"...he's really GOOD!!!

  • Well, that was rubbish. Why do these modern singers, and I use the term loosely, seem to think sticking to the actual melody of the song is optional?

  • This doesn't do justice to Billy Joel's great song. For one, it should be sang with the PIANO! The vocal are much different with different instruments. And it is ment to be sang with the piano.

  • @Snampired I agree with you that it didn't do BIlly Joel justice but my jazz ensamble sang it acapella and it was amazing.

  • he so cute >.<

  • Paula u pedophile lol i see u eye raping david all the time xD lol

  • OMG! David's book "Chord of Strength" made the NY Times Bestsellers List! Whoa. CONGRATS David! And his new single comes out in July! Woot!

  • no echo.... meh

  • One of my favorites performances of his!! Beautiful!!!

  • HAWTTTT

  • He ruined it for me. Listen to the original

  • I loved this song when BJ sang it, and I love it just as much or more when David sings it...WOW! Gorgeous!!

  • To me, this was David's best performance, but I loved the song having never heard it before. He is awesome and I'm glad he and David Cook were the final 2!!!!

  • Beautiful voice it shook me very much.

  • put on a tie... Ahhh!!

  • This is definitely one of David A's best performances on the show.

  • One of the greatest songs Billy has ever written!!

  • Even though it seemed like Simon was on drugs. He was just careful not to give David the upper hand. David sang this song superbly. It was all planned for cook to win because simon's people from England do not consider David "all" american. That British idol group should have been fair and honest with David. They misled him and selected this particular song with hidden messages that he would not be the winner. At least according to their twisted agenda. They shouldn't have been bias.

  • i think i just fell in love...

  • One of  THE BEST RENDITION EVER !

  • maybe archuleta didnt win because he was really too young to be an american idol last year. cook is okay but archuleta has better vocals.

  • @LifelessDudee Well didn't Jordin Sparks win at 16?

  • @LifelessDudee david cook was way better!!!!

  • Frizz..gimme a break! Cook was pre-selected because the producers needed a white rocker.

    Archuleta is by far the better singer.

  • I think if he had chosen to do the whole song a cappela, he really could have had a moment. Oh well. Still beautiful.

  • He wanted to.... but the producers didn't let him. The producers didn't let him change the arrangement of Longer too. He wanted to have a sara bareilles feel to longer... But the producers said they wanted him to sing it the way it originally is.

  • haha nej lixom

  • totally agree

  • Just beautiful. Just beautiful. This song rocks ANY WAY, but David did a great job.

  • Hello drifter6276. You are here again in David Archuleta's site. We like to think that you can be Archuleta fan. Go find videos that you can love and enjoy. We are here to enjoy David's singing.

  • Hey guys pls subscribe to dver23's channel and i willl sub back to u!

    this is my challenge!

    So help me

    P.M Me If u did

    Thanks.Btw Not To My Page ok....LOL

  • that was amaziinnngg!

  • The best idol ever, Archuleta...what amazing voice..you do not get tired listening him..he has a great voice, does not matter that producers and simon fixed the show for Cook...Archuleta is the winner of that season and they did a big mistake that may 21/08, the world saw that David Archuleta won tha competition, making AI a unfair show.

  • david archuleta is so cUTEE! <3

  • cute

  • That was so beautiful. :)

  • YES IT WAS!! HAHAHAH!

    i love david!

  • I agrree both david sre so spectacular its so hard to compar cause they have a diffenrt song choices melodys and there just not the same

  • He should have won, he's way better than david cook! i was so mad when david cook won, and he was boring on tour...having to sit through 5 songs in a row

  • I love David!!!!! He is fantastic!!!

  • Simon: I don't think it was outstanding.

    Random Girls: YES IT WAS!!!!1

    ROFL!!

  • personally, i wish he had done the whole song acapella, but this was amazing (like everything he does)!!!!!

  • Just Beautiful. The true winner is RIGHT THERE!

  • i actually

    think this version

    is better than

    the original

  • Both David's are phenomenal in different ways. However, I belive David Archuleta's voice is more pure and consistent each time. He is just better.

  • SQUEEEEEEE!

  • To:chufil, u idiot, im sure ur just another 12 yr. old or some stupid teenager who dont know what singing is. u need a lot to learn about singing... this kid cant sing? wow, its like saying a man has no brain, if u think its boring, why are u listening? ur the fag and the dumbass, u know ur just showing ur ignorance and unprofessionalism here, i pity you. ur not doing any of us a favor here, if you have nothing good to say, just leave and FYI, thats envy right there. You FAG! get a life. Peace!

  • You know, that's really sickening for you to think that he'll ever do porn. That's just gross. Such a good guy like him doesn't even get thoughts about porn. Sicko!

  • Many people continuosly accuse david of over-doing Runs on songs. I think this song showed his vocal prowess. Minimal runs, and yet so polished and beautiful. Everytime this guy sings, it's a miracle.

  • Both David's are awesome. They are true artists and more importantly, they have a genuine friendship and respect for each other.

  • Archuleta farts better than Cook sings.

    The whole thing in rigged...Cook wasnt even trying out when a "producer of a.i." told him to enter, he would win. False win.

  • there both good...david a and david c...but i think david archuleta has a more natural voice...his voice is very very very nice

  • go DAVIDDDDDDDDDDDDDD WE LOVE U AND UR VOICE IS A NATURAL GIFT!! YOU ARE THE NEXT AMERICAM IDOLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL­.WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! (L)

  • I don't get David Cook fans, I can't see how alot of people think he's more talented then David A. I don't even see a comparison. PERIOD. I just don't see it. Cook is better at being a rocker, and playing instruments, but there's so many rockers already David A. is unique. David Cook doesn't have as much range when he sings and I hate the look of pain he gets on his face when he closes his eyes when he's singing.

  • It looks like Jeff Archuleta (David"s Father) Finally backed off and let David be himself and pick his own songs.

  • Yes he can sing anything! he is amazing! I love the Acapella part, beautiful! Bravo David A.!

  • Beautiful! I love you David!

  • why did paula pick such a boring song for him? He sounds amazing though...seriously. I don't understand ppl who bash him (like people here)...then why did you bother searching him up? Anyways..he looked hot!

  • Archuleta rocks..he is a singer, not some ass lick screacher like Cook.

  • you are mean we think he is an awesome singer don't be so rude if you don't like it keep your comments to yourself! he did sing the national anthem just look up david archuleta national anthem on the search tags for him!

  • See, this forum is open to my thoughts and comments. Don't be angry because you are part of the reason his father beats him. Don't be angry that he may win this competition then make one album and disappear like Clay Aiken. Archuletta is not a talented musician. He's a talented vocalist who can only sing music he's given. He'll never write anything of his own, or contribute anything musically outstanding.

  • solusveritas, Dont just come here and insult D.A, i know, you're one of those people who like bashing on people, If you dont like him, why are you watching his video? and leave nasty comments? Why dont u support Cook instead? I respect both Davids coz they work very hard to be there and what you're saying about DA are all biased, and i'm sure DC wouldn't want you as a fan coz ur basically insulting his friend. You must feel like on top of this world now after leaving bad comments,right? Peace!!!

  • archie is the best. even though i don't like ballads, i really enjoyed it

  • This song is BEAUTIFUL, as is Archie himself.

  • His voice is so pure and clear it's ridiculous. I LOVE this kid!

  • His voice is so beautiful - especially a cappella. So talented!

  • duhmazing

  • Simon is sooo funny!

  • yeah.. simon is quite funny.. haha

    but i like it. :)

  • david can sing anything!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more