I don't get all these comments giving this person unasked for tips and criticism. I understand it may not be how YOU would play it or prefer it, but it is beautifully played none the less and should just be enjoyed for what it is, a wonderful classic song played with talent and sentiment. Nice job Tomad16, love listening.
A bit rigid, try using a little more swing to get it sounding really nice. Listen to some recordings of this song by jazz pianists to give you a better idea. This is one of my favorite songs to play. Great job!
The bridge is fine, not the augmented that is out of the fake book. My only comment is loosen up. Take some liberties with the rhyth and time and make someone elses arrangmrnt a little more your own
You should be giving credit to Tim Richards who created this arrangement.
Thanks Tim.... Great series.
I especially loved the explanation of McCoy Tyner's use of fourths in impressions, i think in volume 2, its in the other room : ) what a neat sound that has. You really helped bridge me into jazz, and things are feeling a lot more comfortable due to you, thanks! not there yet though....
Fail. Gorgeous sounding piano (from what I can tell), but improperly recorded. The entire thing is clipping. That said, I very much enjoyed the performance. Have always loved this tune.
Jofferman, I'm not stupid. I can hear the clipping and I can hear that this recording has been made on equipment that hasn't had gain levels set. But ignore the clipping, and there's something really nice about this recording. I love distorted, compressed sounding recordings, esp on pianos like this. Loveliness is all subjective. I am a producer and engineer so I know very well that this is not a good recording, but a lovely recording, in my eyes, yes.
Well played, but give me some credit! This is my arrangement of this tune! The 'jazz book' you mention that it appears in is 'Exploring Jazz Piano, Vol 1', published by Schott (2005) - I'm the author. The arrangement also appeared in the fall 2006 issue of the US magazine 'Piano Today'. Tim Richards.
Wow - honoured to speak to the arranger of this piece! Sorry for not crediting you - I couldn't remember what book I learnt this from! I'll update the video description.
Well, thanks for writing this; I and many others clearly love this arrangement! (even when played shoddily!)
Funny you'd remove a comment from Tim Richards, he arranged this! BE FARE! this is the internet... everyone is watching... listening... with a good ear that is. Thanks for the thoughts Tim...
Sonny Rollins improvised this tune a zillion ways each time better than the last. Ellington is one of the great composers of the American Song Book, so it's only natural that various artist will present their own creative stamp on Dukes's standards.
Beautifully done. i have a version of this, almost the same, but much much better on mp3, more feelings. this one is a little robotic compared to the version i got
Very nice!! =)
MrSpid3rFingers 5 months ago
Do you have the music sheet to give to us?
whiteboii1017 6 months ago
i thought i told you to round the wagons pilgrim
donottawaguitar 10 months ago
I don't get all these comments giving this person unasked for tips and criticism. I understand it may not be how YOU would play it or prefer it, but it is beautifully played none the less and should just be enjoyed for what it is, a wonderful classic song played with talent and sentiment. Nice job Tomad16, love listening.
Laylagirrl 1 year ago 2
A bit rigid, try using a little more swing to get it sounding really nice. Listen to some recordings of this song by jazz pianists to give you a better idea. This is one of my favorite songs to play. Great job!
ChiTown7721 1 year ago
awesome
TerrorAndmore 1 year ago
need to work on those voicings
deshi88 1 year ago
Very nice... one of the best versions on YouTube.
CALAVERA63 1 year ago
too rigid...
Alakazam1231 1 year ago
This is the song that Cliff used to play to set the mood with Claire in the early episodes of the Cosby Show. Nice work!
cheetarathundercat 1 year ago
The bridge is fine, not the augmented that is out of the fake book. My only comment is loosen up. Take some liberties with the rhyth and time and make someone elses arrangmrnt a little more your own
jgrunde 2 years ago
Melody in the bridge is not correct..
Doumbeck 2 years ago
O usas mal el pedal
ess14431 2 years ago 3
Creo que el piano está desafinado
ess14431 2 years ago
ma chi suona qui?
antoniettacuomo 2 years ago
chocolately, mmmmmmmmmm luv it
xlearghx 2 years ago
lol?
tomad16 2 years ago
is this you playing? it's very nice. the ethereal melody makes me feel chocolately. :)
xlearghx 2 years ago 5
Yes - thanks :) haha
tomad16 2 years ago 3
@tomad16 Hi, Could you send me the song plzzzz i really like it and i want to use it for my English project, if thats ok with u so plzzzzzzzzz??? :D
ICHIhime151 8 months ago
@tomad16 What do you mean by chocolately? Or chocolatey, if either of you had spelled it right.
JazzBrosif 8 months ago
haha same
headbanger623 1 year ago
This song is my favorite by Ellington. Just wonderful!
DejaMae1103 2 years ago
overkill on the sustain the whole time...other than that it was excellent.
1110131 2 years ago
My favorite part is 1:30
mattsack123 2 years ago
really good man!!!!
fehks323 2 years ago
Very nice job, I do prefer the song to be a bit slower though
rjbassmanatyahoocom 2 years ago
You should be giving credit to Tim Richards who created this arrangement.
Thanks Tim.... Great series.
I especially loved the explanation of McCoy Tyner's use of fourths in impressions, i think in volume 2, its in the other room : ) what a neat sound that has. You really helped bridge me into jazz, and things are feeling a lot more comfortable due to you, thanks! not there yet though....
Ricoshady 2 years ago
yess - fine hands for the piano
rdoister 2 years ago
Ahh, this is lovely. Lovely recording too! The piano sounds gorgeous.
TomPoop 2 years ago
Fail. Gorgeous sounding piano (from what I can tell), but improperly recorded. The entire thing is clipping. That said, I very much enjoyed the performance. Have always loved this tune.
joffermann 2 years ago
Jofferman, I'm not stupid. I can hear the clipping and I can hear that this recording has been made on equipment that hasn't had gain levels set. But ignore the clipping, and there's something really nice about this recording. I love distorted, compressed sounding recordings, esp on pianos like this. Loveliness is all subjective. I am a producer and engineer so I know very well that this is not a good recording, but a lovely recording, in my eyes, yes.
TomPoop 2 years ago
Well played, but give me some credit! This is my arrangement of this tune! The 'jazz book' you mention that it appears in is 'Exploring Jazz Piano, Vol 1', published by Schott (2005) - I'm the author. The arrangement also appeared in the fall 2006 issue of the US magazine 'Piano Today'. Tim Richards.
timrichards2007 3 years ago
Wow - honoured to speak to the arranger of this piece! Sorry for not crediting you - I couldn't remember what book I learnt this from! I'll update the video description.
Well, thanks for writing this; I and many others clearly love this arrangement! (even when played shoddily!)
tomad16 3 years ago
hehe, i was gonna mention... this ain't duke playing!
busessuck1 2 years ago
Funny you'd remove a comment from Tim Richards, he arranged this! BE FARE! this is the internet... everyone is watching... listening... with a good ear that is. Thanks for the thoughts Tim...
Ricoshady 2 years ago
He was the one who removed it (same post twice)... and, I have given him credit..?
tomad16 2 years ago
Comment removed
timrichards2007 3 years ago
Sonny Rollins improvised this tune a zillion ways each time better than the last. Ellington is one of the great composers of the American Song Book, so it's only natural that various artist will present their own creative stamp on Dukes's standards.
BilaalUSA 3 years ago
this is one of my favorite standards of all time, and you play it so well. :)
dethrising 3 years ago
duke was black.. fake
jaumeferrer 3 years ago
hihii think duke was BLACK ...
pascalray 3 years ago
can anyone tell me what hip hop song, besides asheru's mood swing, is sampled from this track?
ArnthorJon 3 years ago
fake
odizzle10 3 years ago
Well done!!!!
54spiritedwill54 3 years ago
i think santana the guitarist copied a little from this
edsterling0 3 years ago
ahuauh, you made me think to that! can it happens... pentatonic has only 5 notes ihihih
mescaleros666 3 years ago
do you have the sheet music?
odelotto 3 years ago
i kind of like this out of tune it sounds kind of creepy and even sadder.
123BubberMiley 3 years ago 2
yeah, i agree
taylorbelote 3 years ago
Nice, but get the piano tuned and post it again
classicjazzcat 3 years ago
great thanks
epistrophy72 3 years ago
exelentes acordes
eveneser7 3 years ago
classic
Nyg76 3 years ago
exelente
eveneser7 3 years ago
la suono meglio io cl clarinetto
djscardixxx 3 years ago
Schnarch!
Lissylein26 3 years ago
excellent
gators12707 3 years ago
This is great!!!!!
Midnytman 3 years ago
exellent!
notyourbussinesguy 3 years ago
AMAZING *_*
bubylugo88 4 years ago 2
Por pura coincidencia llegué a esta maravilla
Jenysia 4 years ago 6
great vid! may i be the first one to cheesily ask where you got the sheets?
pauklzorz1985 4 years ago
it's in exploring jazz piano 1 of tim richards.
Skopjess 4 years ago
thanks!
pauklzorz1985 4 years ago
I played this song on my Bari-sax for a band recital. I fell in love with this song- and nice job :)
Ieraux 4 years ago 2
Which book is this in?
kitkatdog91 4 years ago
I listened to all the versions of this on youtube but this is my favourite. Simple and beautiful
paudical 4 years ago
Haven't seen them all, but this is a great one. This song can be overdone, but subtlely is the best way to play this without a doubt.
This makes me want to go practice piano again.
boxingoutsider 4 years ago
Antonio542 are you Jamaican?
fortis17 4 years ago
Well done!!!! jah blessed!!
Antonio542 4 years ago
Well Played.
VendettaVV 4 years ago
OMG i play exactly the same version!! Haha! Also, try playing it slower, u get more feeling out of it that way!
zzzzippy 4 years ago
This=sheet
predoje 4 years ago
uhm..ya
this isnt Duke Ellington
y3llowsock 4 years ago
Me gusta mucho. Lo encuentro de una enorme finura, simple, elegante, y a la vez respeta el original. Lo tengo en mis favoritos.
joanmarimon 4 years ago
im playing this on trumpet at my school's jazz evening tomorrow and i must admit it is a beautiful piece and i hope i can do it justice!!!
nefynrules 4 years ago
Beautifully done. i have a version of this, almost the same, but much much better on mp3, more feelings. this one is a little robotic compared to the version i got
nozzies 4 years ago
Beautiful, I'm currently working on an arrangement of that piece.
Zeldagamer1337 5 years ago
thanks
MusicmanE 5 years ago
what are the two chords that you used to transition into the modulation (where the lyric goes "rose pedals seem to fall").
MusicmanE 5 years ago
Eb minor 7/9, Ab 7 (I think)
tomad16 5 years ago