Added: 4 years ago
From: alicecullengirl
Views: 107,592
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (435)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 'Find the magic, go and grab it...'

  • no its better if she was a girl

  • acully sounds better this way

  • nah she aint better guy or girl , but she would be better dead :O

  • She Wears Too Much Make Up That You Can Thought Her Like a Guy Disguised As a Girl..HaHaHaHaHa!!!::P:P

  • Hey i love your video please come to see my show, love ya ♥

  • that sounds better lol

  • i love this song

  • I thought she was a guy

  • Omg u r an idot That isenr even her dog !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and a girl can just stik on a wig a a bit of makeup and they look like a completly diffent person .... its hard for a man to do that !!!!!!!!!!!!1 THIK OOOOOOOOOOOO

  • lol true this song souns so much better like this

  • LOL it took 1 minute to get the whole idea. sorry boys and girls i dont listen to her songs.. this song sounds nice when it s supposed to be sung by male :p

  • this sound better like this

  • why do you have to put hate on this poor girl? I know she's not the same, BUT SHE SGROWING UP DAMMIT so leave her alone!

  • MYOB

  • i am with maja924 so do not be mean comet983 us miley fans like her so dont bemean brats never get what thay whant so be nice to her and miley rocks u do not now what a u r talking aboute so stay out oother business she is not talking to u comet983 myob is what it is called

  • ha i wish a guy wuld actually sing this song.

    :D

  • cool song/voice! uh i mean yeah miley is a girl and you can never change that, and we like her as girl.............*few secnds later* umm the voice is a little cool but hey i like her as a girl...miley lovers pls dont be angry at me and also 2 miley haters.

  • omg i thught this was gunna be dumb but its not bad acturally like a guy lol id like that song

  • not to be rude, but her songs sound better deeper

  • shes cute

  • whoa she sounds better like a guy :]

  • listen you, Miley is a girl and sorry you cant change that. Start living with the fact that a GIRL can be the most famous person in the world. And and a guy as Hannah Montana? Give me a break they imageined a girl and they got a girl. So remove this sick video and get a life. And dont disable coments you coward. This is the truth and dont send me some e-mails i'm not gonna answer. Miley you rock like a GIRL and we love you like a GIRL!!!!! <3 <3 <3 <3

  • wow shut up,, hes makeing a joke,, when did he ever say he was against woman supremisy, so why dont you calm your hormones there,,

  • wow i wasted 3 mins and 28 sec of my life looking at a lame hannah montana photo no offense hannah montana luvers!!! i like her to buttt this vid is lame no offense

  • yourock

  • ha its actually quite good!!!!!!!!!!! mabye if a guy sang it some of the lyics should change its funny a guy saying candy coated!!! lol good job ;)

  • cant say i agree...i agree, this one song is better. but no guy would sing such girly songs no matter how good they sound. and the story/theme is just more interesting with a girl. guys wouldnt make such a big deal about things or be so dramatic about things. :D i love this video, and it is an interesting thought, though.

  • esta weno

  • hey i like like this a lot wow!!!!!

  • don´t understand

  • there goes 3:28 i can never get back=l

  • this is stupid its just a pic of her sitting down with a dog...that doesnt meen she'd be betterr as a guy.I like her the way she is

  • WOW. it wasn't about the picture...the song was one of hers adjusted to make her sound like a guy.

  • hate it hate it hate it i love miley like she is

  • i agree this is stupid i hate it just as much as you! she was born a girl and when they cast the part of Hannah they needed a girl if she was a boy they would have made her oliver or Jackson! i love Miley the way she is! the way she was born is the way every body ( normal people) likes her!! hopefully

  • this is much better

  • this rocks

  • you cant have one picture to prove something and you are rude

  • she reminds me of one of the chipmunks. the only difference is that I like the chipmunks MUAHAH.

  • holy shit this is much better

  • VaG loves Milo Cyprus haah xD Im sorry 5 year olds but miley cyrus isnt

    that good

    open your eyes and look at how much better Milo Cyprus is. At least he doesnt wear that much make up to hide his uglyness!! :D

    so yes , face the truth loveliess <3

    (:

  • you should all leave miley to be the way she is and not every 1 has to be perfect for you all to like them...people these days just dont see the good things in some one just all the negatives = I

  • she's fine the wiy she is why wid she be better aff as a boy :/

  • ew look it's a straight edge whore who sends the jonas faggets picture in the showers.

  • haha its good both ways<3

  • i like it both ways.

    Whoever's singing this is probably really hawt, i imagine...

  • its really great, i liked this song!! much better than the original 1 !!!1

  • wow thats amazing...did you alter her voice? well if its a guy you know hes got to be hot but if its her voice altered then she needs to change to a guy

  • that is awesome how di you do that who is singing it

  • i mean she's pretty but she acts wierd.

  • wow... her.. i mean heshe's music is actually tolerable this way. lol imma go do this to all my gf's little sisters' cd's

  • It is good

  • omg

  • lol i love the guy voice i agree!:D

  • that sounds so good ! :O

    But I like her as girl xD

  • lolxs...but i can't see the edited pic??! y is dat so?

  • haha, the picture isn't edited, just the music ^^

  • wtf is she sayin miley is miley so go screw ur self lol

  • whoa it does sound good

  • i saw a shirt today that had hannah montana on it w/ a mustach.

    hahaha

  • with that photo of miley their it just makes it sound like a woman with some rlle rlle wierd boyish voice. if you put a guys pic there it would sound like a guy is singing.

  • good editing ive never heard this song b4 so i actually thought this was a guy singing and it doesnt sound half bad!

  • THIS IS GAYY AS HELL!!!

  • i so like girl version better!

  • i like the guy version but i still like her as a girl i mean comon

  • the guy version is way WAY better

  • its rlly good both ways i thnk funny video!!!!!

  • what the fuck i dont get it help someone

  • LOLZ

    it does sound better!

    some guy band should redo ALL of her songs:

    for everyones pleasure!

  • ...oh em gee...

    she would actually sound good as a guy...

    but she is a really good singer as a girl :]

    xoxoxo Kat

  • merci de m'avoir répondu !!

  • comment elle s'appelle la chanson ?

    music ?

  • la chanson s'appelle "Good and Broken" par Miley.

    tu voulais savoir ca?

  • i like guy version WAY better

  • this sounds good but I LIKE MILEYS VERSION WAY BETTER!!!

  • This is FAR better!

  • SO MUCH BETTER!!!!

  • something u wont see nor touch ever

  • this

  • awesome

  • Miley Cyrus is awesome! I love her music! Miley Cyrus is great as a girl!!!!!!!!!! She would NOT MAKE A GOOD GUY AT ALL.

  • miley rox

  • i hate miley as a girl SHE SUCKS!!!!GUY WAY BETTA

  • wow i love the way she sounds as a guy cause i think she rather sucks as a girl

  • Wow is really better in a guys sound...And I think Miley Cyrus is prettier when she is young...

  • omg it does sound good as a guy!!!

  • She sounds so good as a guy!!!

    How did you do that?

  • she is soo much better as a guy sorry miley your awesoem but you sound good as a guy

  • i hate it stinky

  • shes way better as a guy!!!!

  • O M G, I could listen to boy version of Miley Cyrus all day!!!

    She sounds great as a guy, but I love Hannah Montana.

    Oh well, she was born a girl.

  • Best vid ever xD

  • miley is so better as a girl xxxxxx

  • no she is soo stupid as a girl

  • Actually SuperHeroNICOLE

    A fag is a BUNDLE of sticks, not a PILE of sticks...

    But you were REALLY CLOSE...

    Keep Trying lol

  • LOL tru say

    this would ACTUALLY be a better song if she was a boy LOL

  • this is better i hate her guts but if a guy was actually singing this i would be in love with it, i mean it sounds hott if it was an actuall guy...

  • omg she does sound btr as a guy i hate her voice as a girl but i luv her voice as a guy

  • i hate her...this is much beter HA!

  • you hate her? what did she do to you , stop hating her she is way better looking then you'll ever be

  • i so agree

  • omg u r soo mean! stop hating!

  • wat its true she sounds btr as a guy i mean she actually sound good as a girl wen i hear her music i run 2 my dog 2 make sure it isnt being tortured

  • that wasnt that bad really.. i mean i would actually download her..or his songs lol

  • hey pplz im new so check out my vids!plz! :) (:

  • That was one of the most boring and stupid videos on youtube

  • miley's cool, so is milo

  • wtf

  • r u serious u think she sounds better as a girl ur crazy she doesnt even sound good as a girl btw im still checkin 2 make sure she is actually a girl

  • my wewe is sexy kiss it joe

  • wtf stay away from joe jonas hes mine!!!!!!!!!!!

  • well im sorta in the middle i like her as she is but she would be cool if she was a guy!

    Oh well she was born a girl

    lol

  • no she wouldn't. Everyone says that her low voice is bad but it's just plain talent

  • she sounds hott =D lmao and I hate Hannah Montana/Destiny hope/Miley Cyrus.. lmao.. but she sounds sexy as a guy =D

  • that sounded actually inda good.

    but huh?

  • I agree. Way better.

  • omg!

  • i don't think so.

  • thats the most sexxiest guy voice miley would have if she was a guy :/

  • this miley cyprus will be the next britney spears/paris hilton kinda celebrity

  • woww it would be better as a guyy ;] ha

  • ik riteif miley was a guy then he would sound so much sexxier and hotter....but the bad thing is that miley is a girl and i dont like miley :/

  • wow! man she would be too

  • that dog is so cute ahhhhhhhhhhhhh

  • ok then omg

  • lmfao it actally sounds really good :P

  • omggg amazingg!

  • freaking awesome

  • THATS AWESOME :)

  • Wow that sounds really gay,

  • a fag is also a cigarette

  • did you know a "fag" is a pile of sticks? HAA!

  • haha that's awesome.

  • the dog shes holding is her old dog that just died :(

  • which dog? doesn't she have like...

    Loco, Tag, Roadie... what are the other ones i can't remember the other dogs

  • Miley cyrus is a fag

  • thats an understatement.

  • What an understatement

  • it means that her being a fag is just the begainning of all her issues.

  • hahahah this is actually pretty good and creative

    not many people do this

    so people can shut the fuck up :)

    you did goood, and agreeable, she sounds better

    but i do like her tooo

    sooooo, yeah all the haters can just NOT listen to this :)

    HAVE SOME FUCKING IMAGINATION ASSHOLES! :)

  • Ok?....GAY!!

  • Load of Rubish.

  • Woah.. Sometimes changing the pitch just makes sound like weird deep voice but this really sound like a guy.

  • I thought she was already a guy

  • dudee me to!

  • Ha Lol

  • this is dumb

  • this kind of sounds like Cher..

  • LMAO

  • OMFG....this is fucking awesome *woot-woot* i could get down to boy version of miley all day ahhhh ahahahahaha lolz...flippin funny ...flippin awesome vid...xD

  • i like the original miley cyrus version.

    and,im not a fan,but doesnt mean i hate her.people need to stop hating

  • ohhhhhhh yyyeeeaaahhhhh i hate miley anyway but if she is a guy her name would be milo hahaha milo ROCK ON!

  • nice, whos the guy singing he's great it sounds realllyy good

  • it's Hannah Montana x] they just made her voice deeper.

  • are you serious? daaammmm lol thanks wow hahaha she would sound better

  • fer reallz :]

  • Hmmm...yeah I guess she would be hot if she was a guy <3 And her voice is okay in a man voice too...but when she's a girl, she sings a lil bit better and she's pretty aleady, sooo...Yeah. And yes, I am a fan of hers.

  • AMEN TO THE TITLE

  • I LOVE THE DOG <3