@TheCreativeMedia2011 as you watch further indepth in the movie, based on what the "Secret" piano sheet, it says you are bound to the one you see at first sight meaning the first person you see will be the only that can see you, so when she took those steps with her eyes closed to the classroom, she was expecting him to be there but the other girl was there so only she can see her.
That's odd. If she wrote that in the past it should have already been there. Unless they are in alternate universes where the time runs differently from each other, in which the 'past' of Jay Chou corresponds with the 'present' of that girl. Somehow all actions that apply to that particular desk correspond with both universes.
lol... anyone find out that the music sheet is an operational guide for that old piano (as the piano is branded as 'secret' as well as the cover of the music sheet) thumbs up is you see that~
I spent 3 hours rummaging through my school's pianos after school to check whether there were any hidden music sheets under pianos....so I can time travel and find my girlfriend >:o but no such luck :'(
but how could nobody not see her? i mean during the piano battle, when xiaoyu asked about the duel and what was happening, the girl next to her answered her...go look at it later?
still weird: in his time only he could see her, but in her time ...in picture gets that all see him...maybe cause piano was destroyed...Dam the best drama, so sad still cry when remember
SJ Leeteuk & Ryeowook lead me to watch this. Leeteuk had been tweeting this few weeks ago && he was talking about how good the movie is as well as Jay Chou's Piano skills. he even played the black key etude @ radio show. This movie is like 3rd in my list (after windstruck & my sassy girl). One of the best movies ever!
Not ghost!! She just travelled to the future. The secret says ' at first sight marks ones destiny' refers to that the first person she sees after travelling to the future is the only one that can see her . So she's not practically a 'ghost'
this is where the movie gets confusing, ok so if she goes back 20 years isnt she still alive when the 5 months past and shouldnt she be old now??? its so confusing.. :P
thank the Lord I study in a chinese school.... lao shi showed this to us but we ran out of time and were gonna continue watching NEXT YEAR!!! sorry lao shi can't wait for next year :D (next year's only just about a week from now.... but STILL!!! )
xiaoyu can only be seen by one person per visit to modern world, anyone looking at her will only see empty space. she time traveled by playing that certain song on that certain piano.
that is so creepy!
beapanganiban 2 months ago
Alright this is starting to remind me an awful lot of Clannad, with the paranormal twist and all. o____o
xAiiRPLANES 3 months ago
@xAiiRPLANES I was thinking exactly the same thing.
HalloMyNameIsBob 3 months ago
this part is definitely the most interesting, what a twist
masta865 3 months ago
i was him,i willl say "OH MY FREAKING GOD!!" when the words suddenly came out..
mikalol123 4 months ago
she ghost writer
Invisiblefiyah 4 months ago
holy shit is she like a ghost or something
gdialpha 4 months ago
I am sooooooooooooooooo confused on the story.....ive watched this three times already and i still dont understand the story.
LovelyMNGurl02 5 months ago
where is she (xiaoyu) when he comes to her home?? why only her mom there?
muktid 5 months ago
If she was never there from the start, why was the other girl talking to her while the piano battle was going on?
TheCreativeMedia2011 5 months ago
@TheCreativeMedia2011 as you watch further indepth in the movie, based on what the "Secret" piano sheet, it says you are bound to the one you see at first sight meaning the first person you see will be the only that can see you, so when she took those steps with her eyes closed to the classroom, she was expecting him to be there but the other girl was there so only she can see her.
LasttWish 5 months ago
That's odd. If she wrote that in the past it should have already been there. Unless they are in alternate universes where the time runs differently from each other, in which the 'past' of Jay Chou corresponds with the 'present' of that girl. Somehow all actions that apply to that particular desk correspond with both universes.
KageKonohagakure 5 months ago
I like how she said "voyage" in French instead of English. She did graduated with French major after all.
HowYaDoingMon 6 months ago
lol... anyone find out that the music sheet is an operational guide for that old piano (as the piano is branded as 'secret' as well as the cover of the music sheet) thumbs up is you see that~
qys99abcd 7 months ago
I spent 3 hours rummaging through my school's pianos after school to check whether there were any hidden music sheets under pianos....so I can time travel and find my girlfriend >:o but no such luck :'(
local1114 7 months ago 3
WTFCAUGHT ME OFF GUARD!!!!!DAMN!!!
slashers32 7 months ago
LOL !! i thought it was scary but its not !!!! hahaha it felt scary when the guy went to the girls home... haha (the names are hard to remember) XD
01minhan01 8 months ago
@toffietuff
If you watched near the start it said who ever you see first blah blah....
Means like who ever she sees first can only see her back..
Hope this helped for you to understand :)
littlejamie97 8 months ago
but how could nobody not see her? i mean during the piano battle, when xiaoyu asked about the duel and what was happening, the girl next to her answered her...go look at it later?
toffletiff 8 months ago 3
@toffletiff the girl on xiaoyu's left is talking to the girl on xiaoyu's right
BreakingHit 5 months ago
still weird: in his time only he could see her, but in her time ...in picture gets that all see him...maybe cause piano was destroyed...Dam the best drama, so sad still cry when remember
TheShakaLT 9 months ago
first i thought it was signs of schizophrenia, then a ghost form the past, then it turns out that there is a time machine.
nice plot...
TanMeenator 9 months ago 2
dont get she is a ghost??what tha hell??
TheShakaLT 9 months ago
@TheShakaLT
yeah, thought the guy was schizophrenia, but it makes sense towards the end.
TanMeenator 9 months ago
whoa , probably how u kiss had their 033mv idea, they used a girl who looked similar with similar uniform.
MusicLMAO 10 months ago
is the mom just trying to pretend that xiaoyu wasn't dead???
AvBopper 10 months ago
If we dared do that to our desks in school we would get expelled...lol.
mrsxierox9 10 months ago
SJ Leeteuk & Ryeowook lead me to watch this. Leeteuk had been tweeting this few weeks ago && he was talking about how good the movie is as well as Jay Chou's Piano skills. he even played the black key etude @ radio show. This movie is like 3rd in my list (after windstruck & my sassy girl). One of the best movies ever!
pilarians6 10 months ago
@pilarians6 wow...really? didn't know that they also know jaychou...
zatismksb 10 months ago
@zatismksb yes. SJM is also grateful to Jay Chou coz Jay Chou composed a song for SJM's album, Perfection :)
pilarians6 10 months ago
@pilarians6 he is???? wow.. very talented jay chou ;')
superyesung20 8 months ago
-3 such a wonderful story
yaxiongjiayou 10 months ago
just love that part where they're talking to each other by writing on the desk. brilliant.
TheWoodlandBerry 11 months ago 3
@TheWoodlandBerry Thing is, she never got to see what he wrote. :(
pennieeyaj 9 months ago
@pennieeyaj exactly the problem :'(
TheWoodlandBerry 9 months ago
I saw this before.. So I wasn't that surprised :/
SIAOSIAOx3 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wooooaaahh!!!???!!! is this kind of scary!!! !!.
mynameisjely 11 months ago
got so freaked out.. o.O
MsMiiiYao 11 months ago
@MsMiiiYao same! o.0
jiingleful 11 months ago
so scaryyyyyy ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh i scared i will have nightmare tonight!!!! grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr stupid!
jiingleful 11 months ago
@jiingleful MuAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA !!
Dante24516 11 months ago
Not ghost!! She just travelled to the future. The secret says ' at first sight marks ones destiny' refers to that the first person she sees after travelling to the future is the only one that can see her . So she's not practically a 'ghost'
trajicishere 11 months ago
Anyone else notice how his dad started smoking again?
wtothez 11 months ago
ohhmyy ! diz part really make my tears non-stop . so meaning to say that she's been a ghost all this while ? i'm confuse ehh .
onor94 11 months ago
Goddamn it; this part made me cry. D:
Michirukov 1 year ago
so she's a ghost?!..o_O
08ining 1 year ago
what does the thing at 0:40 say?
zemphyre 1 year ago
@zemphyre Motivational stuff. Learning is [cut off]
L4DWonton 11 months ago
I KNEW IT
it was all a lie...
iBadx3 1 year ago
this is where the movie gets confusing, ok so if she goes back 20 years isnt she still alive when the 5 months past and shouldnt she be old now??? its so confusing.. :P
sonyyaaj 1 year ago
Is it just me or is this really creepy? But it might just be the fact that it's 1 o'clock in the morning.
thereignofdarkness 1 year ago
@thereignofdarkness SAME! I WAS TOTALLY FREAKED OUT! ISH! I WAS EXPECTING THIS TO BE CLASSICAL MUSIC MOVIE! ISHHHHHHHHHHHHH
jiingleful 11 months ago
ugh, if only we could see her old self in the present when they went ot her room. It wouldve been interesting
joetheazl 1 year ago
COOL . Shes a ghost :D
ninamaemi 1 year ago
All this time Jay Chou takes drug??
muscismyh3art 1 year ago
thank the Lord I study in a chinese school.... lao shi showed this to us but we ran out of time and were gonna continue watching NEXT YEAR!!! sorry lao shi can't wait for next year :D (next year's only just about a week from now.... but STILL!!! )
Thank you to whoever uploaded this :D
cupcake8080 1 year ago
at first it seems like a normal love story, cute with a GREAT soundtrack, then the ghostly desk writing part just screws me over @_@!!!
SoraKitazawa 1 year ago
i want to know what happened to that desk after he disappeared all of a suddenly.
i wonder what the students were saying about that? and his dad? i mean your son is gone forever!....
JNLauj 1 year ago
my mind... blown!!!
schizophrenic24 1 year ago
my mind... blown!!
schizophrenic24 1 year ago
wow im thankful i went to chinese school and i am chinese for once O_O
PrincessSakuno 1 year ago
i like how he doesnt question his sanity when he sees writing on the desk magically appear out of nowhere . (:
TheRealWHINNIEchan 1 year ago 63
omg! its like hes insane, seeing gohsts!
scans4uni 1 year ago
What's the name of the song that starts playing at 4:38? It's so nice!
imhuntingforwitches 1 year ago
Comment removed
137828730 1 year ago
@imhuntingforwitches Lover's Tears 情人的眼淚 (singer:姚蘇蓉)
137828730 1 year ago
its a little bit confusing. but overall, it is a GREAT movie ! thumbsup.
cheerfulqerr 1 year ago
i still dont understand the story, its so confusing ><
ninjagaru 1 year ago
@ninjagaru
xiaoyu can only be seen by one person per visit to modern world, anyone looking at her will only see empty space. she time traveled by playing that certain song on that certain piano.
Harry3248 1 year ago
lol i thought the teacher was a pedo :P
theivychen 1 year ago
sh*t the bed this is dramatic >.< i remember wen i first watched it and i thought she must be a ghost :P
damstrzz18 1 year ago
HOLY CRAP! it freaken scared the shet out of me for a sec there lol also the last episode, but its cool lol.
Tendo513 1 year ago 45
@Tendo513 where last episode?????????
jiingleful 11 months ago
awesome!
lovediegoyroberta 1 year ago
Omg! Love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
cindy4051662 1 year ago