I'm sorry but no matter how good of an actor you are, you cannot sing Sondheim. This guy obviously has little classical vocal training, and therefore can't preform the piece close to mediocre. His voice sounds like it's dying.
I've seen many performances of this musical and listened to many and this Henrik is the worst. He's dreadful, hysterical, over-acting, frantic, over-the-top, starting way too strong and not letting the song build in pathos and comedy. He needs a valium.
no he's not. he's very good and plus Sondheim is right there teach it to him, so if he was so bad would have told him. I know, Sondheim is veru honest.
This young singer is talented, but notice how he keeps jumping into the character's anger. That's such a typical impulse in film/stage artists today. And Sondheim is calling him on it, as he should. Anger, attitude, sexiness, that seems to be the dramatic repertoire for most today. Real drama contains more subtlety though.
From my experience w/ this play & Henrik, you're supposed to be a little weirded out by the character; I think this guy really captues how insane Henrik is.....
It's funny that Sondheim himself thought the idea of assigning specific instruments to different characters was pretentious, and yet now we see directors who are reviving his musicals and using just that dramatic device (namely Sweeney Todd and Company.)
thank you, i've also thought how ironic that is. Im not a fan, especially Sweeney Todd, its a score based somewhat on film scores so it should be full and loud, not lame and sparse
Gosh, to be directed by Stephen Sondheim would be soo amazing. He is a genius. I wish i could meet him before he dies, hes almost going on 80 already.
Yup, there is, actually. That's the way Sondheim wrote it. I've heard it in two productions, one in the West End, and one in local theatre. It's jarring, but it's intentional.
Forgive me, but let's agree to disagree. Sondheim pitched that note to show Henrik's discordance with the rest of the world in his frustration. And you should *never* perform something in a way different from what the composer wrote in front of the composer; he'll always correct you, and besides, it's rude.
Oh - and a singer *IS* a musician, thank you very much. We just use a different instument. :-)
I was referring to bobbystormont's first comment. To me it seems a bit simple to label a note as "horrible", dissonance is usullay needed to make the music move forward. You don't want to listen to 3 hours of consonant chords (unless you are a fan of Morton Feldman).
I totally just got that the cello is a symbol for his schlong (you-know-what) when Sondheim says "that's when he grabs his cello and starts pumping away at it". Brilliant.
sondheim's critique is right on the mark. the singer has a good voice & he's very handsome, but is in service to himself rather than to the character. he doesn't get what sondheim tells him about a scandinavian breakdown. if henrik had the energy which the singer demonstrates, he wouldn't be as stuck as the character is supposed to be. the singer has the look of someone who could go places, but i don't think he will artistically, at leas, tbecause of his unwillingness to let go of himself.
This guy was great...i don't understand why people are calling him cocky towards Sondheim. He took direction extremely well and asked questions because he wanted to understand the character more fully. I would rather ask Sondheim questions about a character that he created rather than doing something that I do not understand.
@brth77 sorry but even after three attempts to take the anger out of the "all you ever hear is later Henrik" he cannot do it, he has programmed himself to perform it one way and there is no flexibility, If anything he is too dumb to take any changes on board, A performer who has a sharper character would pick up on what is being said and deliver on the second run not still getting angry on the third.
Not surprised we have not really heard of this performer since.
the way Sondheim looks at him and tilts his head shows just how much of a brilliant man he is. This is one of my favorite musicals of all time, and I think this guy was incredible, he took direction well and it was amazing.
I much enjoyed the rendition--it sounds almost note-for-note like the British recording from the mid-70s--and I don't think the singer's arguing w/ Sondheim but feeling his way (and Sondheim's reactions affirm this).
yeah. you could kind of tell, this is a guy who thinks he's a lot better than he actually is, probably not use to people giving him advice, i mean come on...he questioned SONDHEIM. if sondheim told me to play anne a little sluttier, i'd do it! plus good lord he couldn't sing, even the lower stuff, and he's playing emotions. he's "being" mad etc. can't believe these students were from such a prestigious school.
Honestly, though I am a very critical person, I really think that this man has talent. Not only that, but the third time he started, he really did take the direction well. He completely changed the tone behind his words and reworked major phrases on the spot, which is impressive.
As to the falsetto, he's still young, and those notes are meant for an experienced opera singer.
Though he IS very cocky towards Sondheim (even questioning the direction!) the guy is NOT painful to listen to.
He keeps saying "yeah", "uhuh", "yes", but is ye really listening? He can't take direction. You can really manage with any voice; one would just say that he has more of an actor's voice than a singer's voice. The problem is that he can't act.
Hahahah!! I can't help but laugh near the end. Starting 8:11, Sondheim looks like he's mentally telling the guy 'what a load of crap this is!' And when he finally says in the end 'that's terrific..and then he coughs, it seemed like he was trying to convince himself to believe what he just said...that yeah this guy is terrific...yeah right!
wow. sondheim is being extremely kind. this guy is absolute crap! i dont think ive been more uncomfortable watching or listening to something before in my life!
I think he has singing talent, but he just sounds like he's singing the wrong way. It seems like he's possibly singing from his throat instead of his diaphragm.
He has a charisma,especially in the company dvd. love that turtleneck he wears. Definately doable from this point back. I think he looks sort of scruffy these days.
krealle: haha sorry I had to look through all of this because I couldn't figure out what I was replying to. But with regards to the falsetto, in that the musical is actually closer to an operetta, I feel like Sondheim wrote the song intending the part to be sung full voice. However, I guess it's kosher if the acting can make up for it, but in this case I feel as though he falls short.
I think luffy210 is referring to the recent Broadway revival of Sondheim's Company, in which the actors also played instruments, and would often carry them around even when acting in a scene (the oddest to me was April walking into Bobby's apartment with a tuba, before they sleep together on Bobby's piano).
I'm sorry but no matter how good of an actor you are, you cannot sing Sondheim. This guy obviously has little classical vocal training, and therefore can't preform the piece close to mediocre. His voice sounds like it's dying.
anthonycutillo1 3 weeks ago
"We had everybody carrying an instrument around and it started getting....pretentious."
Tell that to John Doyle.
ThePhantom135 3 months ago 2
lol "a scandanavian breakdown"
superduffman22 5 months ago
this guy is bad
crackerpopskikay 6 months ago
I bet he's an actor more than a singer. You can just tell.
elh666 8 months ago 3
@elh666 - Neither I suspect. Can't take direction
wobblydog 1 month ago
8:11 - 8:16 Songgasm
jakatak1134 9 months ago
Comment removed
jakatak1134 9 months ago
i would die to perform in front of Sondheim.
TheNicholasRodriguez 10 months ago 3
This guy is quite a bad singer...
TheNicholasRodriguez 10 months ago
The ideals of Sondheim are magical, completely magical. I'm learning more from this than I do normal lessons.
rebelsinger123 1 year ago
3:13... this audience has dirty minds XP
JonnoGradian 1 year ago
this guy is bad.his falsetto makes my ears hurt
hottieho13 1 year ago
I want to have Stephen Sondheim's babies before he dies,i love this man.
hottieho13 1 year ago 3
that chair looks terrible
r0llskyay0 1 year ago
This guy's good, but I just have a problem with the way he hits those high notes. It sounds too choppy when he jumps from chest voice to head voice
PrettyPearl244 1 year ago
is it just me or does this guy sound a lot like the original Jekyl/Hyde?
Laffing4Meds 1 year ago
this guy sounds like the original Jekyl/Hyde. does anyone agree or am i just weird?
Laffing4Meds 1 year ago
I've seen many performances of this musical and listened to many and this Henrik is the worst. He's dreadful, hysterical, over-acting, frantic, over-the-top, starting way too strong and not letting the song build in pathos and comedy. He needs a valium.
Levraphael 1 year ago
@Levraphael
no he's not. he's very good and plus Sondheim is right there teach it to him, so if he was so bad would have told him. I know, Sondheim is veru honest.
jam90jaay 1 year ago
I LOVE STEPHEN!!!!!!!!!!!!! Even though he's 80 years old and i'm a man, i seriously want to marry him. Love. Him.
TommyBoy249r 1 year ago 3
@TommyBoy249r well, if your gay your in luck!he"s gay and has a 32 year old boyfriend! i wish i was a man!he is sooo sexy
hottieho13 1 year ago
@hottieho13 seriously? lol
firestartertwistedfi 3 months ago
This young singer is talented, but notice how he keeps jumping into the character's anger. That's such a typical impulse in film/stage artists today. And Sondheim is calling him on it, as he should. Anger, attitude, sexiness, that seems to be the dramatic repertoire for most today. Real drama contains more subtlety though.
lindenprof 1 year ago 5
From my experience w/ this play & Henrik, you're supposed to be a little weirded out by the character; I think this guy really captues how insane Henrik is.....
bigblonde26 2 years ago
This guy can hit serious high notes! He's sorta crazy looking though...
yippedoodah 2 years ago
@yippedoodah It's only falsetto. Pretty much anyone could do that if they trained their voices in the right way. And he does look a bit terrifying!
katebushboi 2 years ago
Good god, this young man is quite out of his mind. Look at his expressions!
linnetgoon 2 years ago
Fascinating! Thank you! So interesting to hear Sondheim explain details...
Grawp55 2 years ago
I really liked his performance and i'm just being honest.
Luluismypomeranian 2 years ago
This guy scares me! I'm totally being honest!
fashionglindaguru 2 years ago
this is my dream... to be able to do this one day.... learn from the master himself
Melensko 2 years ago
It's funny that Sondheim himself thought the idea of assigning specific instruments to different characters was pretentious, and yet now we see directors who are reviving his musicals and using just that dramatic device (namely Sweeney Todd and Company.)
Angelus22 2 years ago 4
thank you, i've also thought how ironic that is. Im not a fan, especially Sweeney Todd, its a score based somewhat on film scores so it should be full and loud, not lame and sparse
smeggers0329 2 years ago
@Angelus22 Yes and the singers were horrible. I wish they would bring back the original.
adamskyb 2 years ago
*sigh* 8:11 is hilarious. Just hilarious!
asmileisspecial 2 years ago 5
LLOOLLLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!! SO so so so funny.
he looks like a brilliant creeper enjoying the demise of someone he loves! LOL! <3
sbort 2 years ago
Jeez it's really creepyy
proopsforpresident 2 years ago
It's a bit scary to be honest!
proopsforpresident 2 years ago
I just love the way Sondheim watches the people singing in this videos lol
dudufallen 2 years ago 4
Gosh, to be directed by Stephen Sondheim would be soo amazing. He is a genius. I wish i could meet him before he dies, hes almost going on 80 already.
aloha12214 2 years ago 3
Same here! I really want to meet him. This sounds silly but every morning I wake up and get scared in case I turn in the TV and hear he has died :(
asmileisspecial 2 years ago 2
These days, that's not silly at all!
KatherineXIX 2 years ago
dude, im with you on this one
carecare91 2 years ago
The man has the ability to explain what he wants so that one understands. amazing.
glmiri 2 years ago 2
hey is this a dvd or vhs? Where can i buy the full thing?
dragonhalfchao 2 years ago
what a fucking AMAZING opportunity... god that would make my life..... jesus.. the kid's okay.. this song is fucking impossible
bflo710 2 years ago
Sondheim is a genius, but it's hard to work with an off-pitch and accented singer...
haastyle2006 2 years ago
That's a HORRIBLE note at around 5:35 - there's just no excuse for that, on anyone's part.
bobbystormont 2 years ago
Yup, there is, actually. That's the way Sondheim wrote it. I've heard it in two productions, one in the West End, and one in local theatre. It's jarring, but it's intentional.
rakshasa7 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
In that case, Sondheim is in the wrong - musicians and singers should take the liberty of changing it.
bobbystormont 2 years ago
Forgive me, but let's agree to disagree. Sondheim pitched that note to show Henrik's discordance with the rest of the world in his frustration. And you should *never* perform something in a way different from what the composer wrote in front of the composer; he'll always correct you, and besides, it's rude.
Oh - and a singer *IS* a musician, thank you very much. We just use a different instument. :-)
rakshasa7 2 years ago 35
Ehm, do you mean that the note is off pitch, or simply that it is dissonant?
eragon841 2 years ago
Dissonant, and thank you for asking.
rakshasa7 2 years ago
I was referring to bobbystormont's first comment. To me it seems a bit simple to label a note as "horrible", dissonance is usullay needed to make the music move forward. You don't want to listen to 3 hours of consonant chords (unless you are a fan of Morton Feldman).
eragon841 2 years ago
what sodheim writes, goes :)
hellooldfashion 2 years ago
oops, *Sondheim, with a "d" :)
hellooldfashion 2 years ago
facepalm
henrysvg 2 years ago
Anyone know where i could find the sheet music for this online? I've only found it on amazon in the full score so far and that's $75!!
jhlds1512 2 years ago
Try Bookfinder or ABE online. Or, if you live in Portland, OR, Powell's music books shop.
rakshasa7 2 years ago
Wonderful! Thanks so much for posting this!
Divinedancedivas 2 years ago
later henrick later
haha love it
BleakleyCutler 2 years ago
I totally just got that the cello is a symbol for his schlong (you-know-what) when Sondheim says "that's when he grabs his cello and starts pumping away at it". Brilliant.
AtLastOnTheGround 2 years ago 3
sondheim's critique is right on the mark. the singer has a good voice & he's very handsome, but is in service to himself rather than to the character. he doesn't get what sondheim tells him about a scandinavian breakdown. if henrik had the energy which the singer demonstrates, he wouldn't be as stuck as the character is supposed to be. the singer has the look of someone who could go places, but i don't think he will artistically, at leas, tbecause of his unwillingness to let go of himself.
pjcgatsby 3 years ago
So wonderful & informative to watch! wish I could take a master class from Sondheim! :)
LaLunaDellaNotte 3 years ago 2
all of you who are saying he's awful are the ones questioning Sondheim, not him!
jhlds1512 3 years ago
Woah, this dude is awful.
fromthefirstmoment 3 years ago
This guy was great...i don't understand why people are calling him cocky towards Sondheim. He took direction extremely well and asked questions because he wanted to understand the character more fully. I would rather ask Sondheim questions about a character that he created rather than doing something that I do not understand.
brth77 3 years ago 17
@brth77 sorry but even after three attempts to take the anger out of the "all you ever hear is later Henrik" he cannot do it, he has programmed himself to perform it one way and there is no flexibility, If anything he is too dumb to take any changes on board, A performer who has a sharper character would pick up on what is being said and deliver on the second run not still getting angry on the third.
Not surprised we have not really heard of this performer since.
wobblydog 1 month ago
the way Sondheim looks at him and tilts his head shows just how much of a brilliant man he is. This is one of my favorite musicals of all time, and I think this guy was incredible, he took direction well and it was amazing.
guacamoleroxmysox 3 years ago
I much enjoyed the rendition--it sounds almost note-for-note like the British recording from the mid-70s--and I don't think the singer's arguing w/ Sondheim but feeling his way (and Sondheim's reactions affirm this).
kbsabin 3 years ago 4
yeah. you could kind of tell, this is a guy who thinks he's a lot better than he actually is, probably not use to people giving him advice, i mean come on...he questioned SONDHEIM. if sondheim told me to play anne a little sluttier, i'd do it! plus good lord he couldn't sing, even the lower stuff, and he's playing emotions. he's "being" mad etc. can't believe these students were from such a prestigious school.
biancacom333 3 years ago
towards the end he starts looking at the piano player... that is a huge sign of a bad attitude.
fiorsolas87 3 years ago
haha when Sondheim says "grabs his cello and starts pumping away" some guy in the back interprets it a little differently :)
kattleweiner2 3 years ago 4
interprets it exactly as Sondheim intended. Henreich is a sexually frustrated character.
krealle 3 years ago 4
Honestly, though I am a very critical person, I really think that this man has talent. Not only that, but the third time he started, he really did take the direction well. He completely changed the tone behind his words and reworked major phrases on the spot, which is impressive.
As to the falsetto, he's still young, and those notes are meant for an experienced opera singer.
Though he IS very cocky towards Sondheim (even questioning the direction!) the guy is NOT painful to listen to.
doomwhatelse 3 years ago
Love this song!
MushroomLake 3 years ago
Down boy!
Sorry, couldn't help myself. I'm not one to talk though, I can't act either... *raises eyebrow*
Saiyne 3 years ago
He keeps saying "yeah", "uhuh", "yes", but is ye really listening? He can't take direction. You can really manage with any voice; one would just say that he has more of an actor's voice than a singer's voice. The problem is that he can't act.
exiron0202 3 years ago 2
Hahahah!! I can't help but laugh near the end. Starting 8:11, Sondheim looks like he's mentally telling the guy 'what a load of crap this is!' And when he finally says in the end 'that's terrific..and then he coughs, it seemed like he was trying to convince himself to believe what he just said...that yeah this guy is terrific...yeah right!
nicolette1018 3 years ago
This is why if something tells you you're good, you should never take it seriously...
ACK!!! HIGH NOTE! *dies*
Saiyne 3 years ago
Sondheim=Genius. Genius like I can't even conceive. So meticulous. Must have been really hard for the singer, but it'll make him a better singer.
keauxgeigh 3 years ago 2
I'm sure the singer throughly enjoyed the lesson.
-jcr
NSResponder 3 years ago
oi his accent sort of ruined it when he sand but he has a good voice
yamiwings18 3 years ago
that poor guy....lol, he does well, but needs some work, both singing AND facial expressions...I thought he was going to pass out!
GreyEyesCrying 3 years ago
that guy's falsetto was *painful* to listen to. but i enjoyed that rest of it.
downinahole193 3 years ago 3
wow. sondheim is being extremely kind. this guy is absolute crap! i dont think ive been more uncomfortable watching or listening to something before in my life!
jmervini 3 years ago 4
I think he has singing talent, but he just sounds like he's singing the wrong way. It seems like he's possibly singing from his throat instead of his diaphragm.
TJSimulation 3 years ago 6
@jmervini
I don't know why this asshole chose to sing this song when he doesn't even have the notes! He sang the top in falsetto... wtf
rlee1976 1 year ago
sondheim wrote the piano part that play the pianist too?. The harmony and the changes of moods are incredible.
aprendizdepianista 3 years ago
This guy is a bit cocky, but I have to say very talented.
Sondheim is hilarious and looking pretty gorgeous, as usual.
chocopopo 3 years ago 3
I Can't wait to see 'A Little Night Music' again. Brilliant!
ronwilliams753 4 years ago
was this ever a dvd? I hope it was
nightcrawler42 4 years ago 3
am i the only person who thinks that sondheim is one of the sexiest men in the world...aside from poe, ortega, and einstein...lol
theatre14u 4 years ago 36
He has a charisma,especially in the company dvd. love that turtleneck he wears. Definately doable from this point back. I think he looks sort of scruffy these days.
mytimesteps 4 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yeah...actually he looks really scruffy, and fat...kind of like patrick stumph in his early career..lol (spell check)
theatre14u 4 years ago
ha no i want to have his children; before he dies :/
dreyfoostheatra 4 years ago 4
Ya forgot Oscar Wilde!:D
bigblonde26 4 years ago
@theatre14u omg i thought I was the only one who found him sexy!!!!!
hottieho13 1 year ago
the teaching that these students received was priceless!
livetheatre 4 years ago 3
The frustration in that boy when Sondheim was telling him he needs to do better.... :-D
Leave it to Sondheim to break down these singers opinion of themselves lol.
jazzitlikeopera 4 years ago 3
*touches her ear*
Hmmm... Yes.
Saiyne 3 years ago
Omg I lOVE Sondheim!!! he is a GOD!!
now...look at the face he makes at 8:10 it is HILARIOUS!!! Like soooooooo funny....i cried i swear!
Sondheimgirl 4 years ago 3
I just fell off my chair!! 8:10-LMAO!! Still I would love to have Sondheim make that face at me!!
mytimesteps 4 years ago 4
He looks kind of like the gnome version of Simon Callow at 8:10.
ImhotepsAshes 4 years ago 2
i had an awfully good laugh too, that expression is great
lainieyeoh 4 years ago
Is it kosher to use so much falsetto? I mean he nailed it, it just caught me off-guard.
maryjivinjane 4 years ago
Completely kosher to use that much falsetto.
krealle 4 years ago
really though?
theleadingplayer 3 years ago
Yes? It said that you replied to my comment... but I'm not seeing how really though...
krealle 3 years ago
krealle: haha sorry I had to look through all of this because I couldn't figure out what I was replying to. But with regards to the falsetto, in that the musical is actually closer to an operetta, I feel like Sondheim wrote the song intending the part to be sung full voice. However, I guess it's kosher if the acting can make up for it, but in this case I feel as though he falls short.
theleadingplayer 3 years ago
what a brilliant song!
i love sondheim. what an amazing composer
TriquadKatie 4 years ago
Wow sondheim's music is soo amazingly un-hummable. Yet its so complex and difficult. I wonder why he does that.
orca1142 4 years ago
this is great for sondheim lovers and students/actors alike-thanks for posting
saigonbabe 4 years ago
Sondheim is a genious no doubt anymore to me! I would sell my niece to any obscure shaik for his harem to get the chance of one lesson!!!
solitudinarian 4 years ago
fook me i av 2 sing this song in january...as i am henrik in my uni production of a little nite music! quite scared lol
JayMair 4 years ago
Yay--Sondheim!
Love his expressions--it'd be awesome to read a theatre review by him
I heard he wrote puzzles and I'd be curious about how they'd be.
GaminattheBarricades 4 years ago
I love how sondheim says that people carrying instruments around is really pretentious.
oh, foreshadowing...
luffy210 4 years ago 4
i thought the same! it made me laugh.
vendettealouette 4 years ago 2
How was that comment foreshadowing? Forgive me, I'm not a Sondheim aficionado (yet...I'm working it).
Awakening126 4 years ago
I think luffy210 is referring to the recent Broadway revival of Sondheim's Company, in which the actors also played instruments, and would often carry them around even when acting in a scene (the oddest to me was April walking into Bobby's apartment with a tuba, before they sleep together on Bobby's piano).
chimpshrimp 4 years ago
This was also the case with the 2005 Revival of Sweeney Todd, also directed by John Doyle, who directed the Company revival.
tinytimton 4 years ago 2
what was the case???? do tell!
actressgrl 4 years ago
I think they just meant the whole "the actors playing the instruments" thing.
blackpython 3 years ago
when I saw this, henrick was holding the bow wrong, haha. I figured that's at least someone from the pit could show him how to hold it.
bassman462 4 years ago
"That's what prompts him to grab his cello furiously and start pumping away at it." I love it!
DannyHiggs 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Thanks for quoting the video we already saw.
MatthewwMatthew 4 years ago
I really love this. I always knew cellists were hot...
LuPoneLips 4 years ago 2
He certainly seems like a much better actor than a singer - but a good actor, though.
jmdixon 4 years ago
Love the Sondheim teaching videos. Keep them coming!
jrblover 4 years ago 2