I would like this movie better if I knew if it was intentionally funny or not. Example: The scene where they're having a serious discussion about faith, Joaquin Phoenix gives that story about some girl puking. That totally broke the mood for me. Another scene: I forgot what exactly he said, but Mel Gibson said something, with a straight face, to the effect of "I know one thing: they're weak against pantry doors". It's has such a serious tone, but it made me laugh too much to take it seriously.
@s0nic777 It's obvious... :P, two things to explain why they came with 75 or 70% of water, Solution: They don't know that Water can hurt them, and they don't know what it is, Two: They weren't even thinking about Water when the came.
pretty good movie and one of the most suspenseful movies I have ever seen the only dumb thing about it is the aliens can be killed by water which is like well why would they come to a planet made up of mostly water lol
the only things about it that aren't so good are the aliens lose to water (on a planet of mostly water - you would think they would have planned for that) and they cant open doors or even kick them down when they at least seem to be on par or stronger then humans.
of course aliens coming in space ships needing to make crop circles is stupid in its own right. But I can let that pass because its just what aliens do
I do agree with you about the whole water thing, however I think it's supposed to send a message and be ironic that the thing that gives us life destroys them
@Winnuting It's obvious... :P, two things to explain why they came with 75 or 70% of water, Solution: They don't know that Water can hurt them, and they don't know what it is, Two: They weren't even thinking about Water when the came.
Why can't they open doors if they're stronger? They don't know how!! It's like a baby trying to open the door! And remember! They did bust it down! Or something like that.
Merrill, swing away. *Grabs baseball bat* You're going down, *****!
Anikan1005 2 weeks ago
aliens forgot their suits so the water could not harm them
SuperMrBentley 7 months ago
I would like this movie better if I knew if it was intentionally funny or not. Example: The scene where they're having a serious discussion about faith, Joaquin Phoenix gives that story about some girl puking. That totally broke the mood for me. Another scene: I forgot what exactly he said, but Mel Gibson said something, with a straight face, to the effect of "I know one thing: they're weak against pantry doors". It's has such a serious tone, but it made me laugh too much to take it seriously.
Ichiboy900 10 months ago
i loved joaquin phoenix in this movie!!!!!! :D ahh, good times
LoneSola 10 months ago
Just because something is different doesn't mean it's better... however it was quite good.
R2R3L4 1 year ago
what would win aliens alien or signs alien
littlegrimmie1 1 year ago
@littlegrimmie1 The Xenomorphs for sure!!
JohnsParadise 1 year ago
My only problem with this movie is...
WHY WOULD ALIENS THAT DON'T LIKE WATER COME TO A PLANET WHICH IS 70% WATER!?
s0nic777 1 year ago
@s0nic777 Perhaps they didn't know. I look at it as a tribute to War of the Worlds where the aliens died out because of our air.
JohnsParadise 1 year ago
@JohnsParadise
That or a crappy dues ex machina to create a victory within the last ten minutes of the film.
DarkCaduceus 1 year ago
@DarkCaduceus I don't think it was a last minute thing. M. Night seems to work backwards with his films.
JohnsParadise 1 year ago
@s0nic777 why would people go to a deserted rock in the mitle of space for no
reason
CUZ THEYRE BORED
TheHaloCEfan 1 year ago
@s0nic777 why would ppl go to a rock in the mitle of space with out air
for no reason
CUZ WERE BORED
TheHaloCEfan 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@s0nic777 It's obvious... :P, two things to explain why they came with 75 or 70% of water, Solution: They don't know that Water can hurt them, and they don't know what it is, Two: They weren't even thinking about Water when the came.
2cool4u1000000000000 1 year ago
pretty good movie and one of the most suspenseful movies I have ever seen the only dumb thing about it is the aliens can be killed by water which is like well why would they come to a planet made up of mostly water lol
lessthantom2 1 year ago
@lessthantom2 its like 75% water and thats just ocean i wonder what urine would do?
littlegrimmie1 1 year ago
I just saw this last night and it was pretty good yet disturbing.
AnimeGirl4891 1 year ago
Awesome review! It reminded me of all of the wonderful things I loved about this film.
FilmCriticChick 2 years ago
I loved the movie. still scares me today.
the only things about it that aren't so good are the aliens lose to water (on a planet of mostly water - you would think they would have planned for that) and they cant open doors or even kick them down when they at least seem to be on par or stronger then humans.
of course aliens coming in space ships needing to make crop circles is stupid in its own right. But I can let that pass because its just what aliens do
Still I love this movie. one of my favs
Winnuting 2 years ago
I do agree with you about the whole water thing, however I think it's supposed to send a message and be ironic that the thing that gives us life destroys them
thecrunchcorner 2 years ago
@Winnuting It's obvious... :P, two things to explain why they came with 75 or 70% of water, Solution: They don't know that Water can hurt them, and they don't know what it is, Two: They weren't even thinking about Water when the came.
Why can't they open doors if they're stronger? They don't know how!! It's like a baby trying to open the door! And remember! They did bust it down! Or something like that.
Why Crop Circles? I don't know. lol
2cool4u1000000000000 1 year ago
never seen it
biggestsonicnerd 2 years ago
have to be in the right mood
JohnsParadise 2 years ago