Added: 2 years ago
From: amyrat151
Views: 5,196
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (168)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • ya know whats funny i was just watching evangellion...

  • omg! i love that YGOTAS reference at the beginning XD

  • Who are you calling shorter than Roy's miniskirt?!?!?!

  • Mustang knows what he says...

  • Edward elric is sooo much better than edward cullen and i havent even watched fullmetal but u know read the summary! twilight is over rated!

  • twitch twitch the x-men don't bitch even though they are complealy abused by the public because of soething they can't control, they deal with loosing controll of there powers and you know what they do...they save the freaken world any way despite that fact that people HATE them

  • i have a t-shirt that says team edward elric. i wore it for team day at school. :)

  • Amyrat, I Love You.

  • Cullen doesn't sparkle. He shimmers.

  • @chunchybear

    Does that make it any better?

  • "thx to the writer of fma, the name Edward hasn't been ruined for me forever xD xD xD that was the same thing i was thinking xD

  • You are correct. It's sad how much the book(s) could have been, but she wouldn't let them be. And yet the fan base is so big (most likely from the actors). It took me a while to read the first book because of how it was written. If she let it be darker I think it would have done better. But that's just my view.

  • ty u

  • this is a great vid

    but...

    im pretty sure the x-men are NOT biologicaly related

    other than that i agree with everything mentioned

  • What puzzles me is why people compare Edward Elric and Edward Cullen. They're from different worlds.

  • @ipodgirl95 My guess is that when Fullmetal Alchemist fans hear the name Edward they think Edward Elric, and when a bunch of girls are gushing over Edward CULLEN its kind of really annoying. The FMA fans realize that the Edward from Fullmetal is a much better and more developed character than Cullen and they want to express this opinion... That's what I think anyway.

  • @MrPJD18 It still doesn't make any sense to me. When I hear Edward I think: "Edward." XD But I think that series ruined the word "Twilight" too. I can't say "twilight" without someone going, "OMG I LUV THAT BOOK!!!1!!" I'm like: "No. It's a time of day. Not just a book." -.- ticks me off

  • i was at lunch, and this girl started droning on and on about edward cullen, to the point where even her friends were pissed off. so me and my fma obsessed friends walked over, yelled, "EDWARD ELRIC IS HOT, EDWARD CULLEN'S NOT!!!" then ran away laughing like idiots. luckily for us, the girl refused to talk to us ever again. :D

  • I'm nothing close to a Twilight fan, and i see how pointless it is... But chill! Its just a book tht some weird writer wrote and became famous!

  • Hahah I saw Kira! I like this video a lot

  • I'm rewriting twilight. XD

  • TINY MINI SKIRTS!!! Lol. I love Roy.

  • @whatuhhidk2 random alert!!

  • I love Edward Elric, and pretty much hate all of the Twilight Vampires

    except for Carlisle and Esme

  • "potential" wasted

    girl you just spoke the words I always say

    meyer made twilight crap

    it could have been MUCH better ^_^

  • I'm pretty sure Meyer stole Arakawa's idea of "sparkles". Only military men like Armstrong can pull sparkles off, not puny lil emo vampires.

  • @imthefunnygirl

    I'm not sure Meyer is even aware of FMA's existence.

  • @amyrat151 I know I was just too caught up in the moment haha

  • @amyrat151 She was really a big mega fan of FMA and based a bit of Cullen off Elric

  • I got two things from this:

    One: Spelled out reasons Twilight sucks, (I usually just give the reason, "It's Twilight." when asked why I despise it.)

    Two: You can NOT have Edward Elric, without Roy Mustang. :D

    Great pictures with you rant, I loved the Light Yagami pics when killing "bad people." My question is why Light hasn't jotted down the Cullens' names... talk about wasted potential...

  • Team Edward Elric! Cuz we all know Cullen stole Armstrong's sparkles.☺

  • Ahhhh! I didn't even know she compared the Cullens to the X-Men. Heck, I'm not even that big of an X-Men fan, but I'm kind of disgusted by that.

  • Aahhahhaa, love the PS :'D

  • 1 year ago (2010)

    YEA I GOT A TEAM EDWARD T-SHIRT EEEE IM SO HAPPY!!!

    1 year later (2011)

    What the hell am I gonna do with THIS ugly thing??

    NOW (2011)

    *pulls out sharpie marker* Team Edward Elric HELL YEA!!

  • yes! you used the miniskirt line at the end!!!!

  • Win!!

  • "how much we all suck" Picture of Simon Cowell. You win

  • LOL At Kaiba. XD I love you already, fellow LK fan!

    ...I have to.. O.O

    Ed Elric: Screw the rules, Im smexy! <3

    *Cough* Sorry.

  • The only man allowed to sparkle is Armstrong.

  • im sorry but it is sad that you know what thats dude does in twilight

  • TEAM ELRIC!!! i absolutely love fma u know, by the way the accept their sins, how they're not selfish, they're searching for the philosopher's stone in order to get the other's body abck right? one would die for the other; they try to help others as much as they can, Ed's a prodigy, very smart and so smexy I wish he was real!!!!

  • oh fuck that hurt my soul, my poor childhood was hit by a bus over that quote comparing the cullens to the xmen oh shit my chests hurts..... cant breath

  • 77 fma fans 1 twligt fan O_O

  • twi-vampires: cant use alchemy :P

    vampires cant use automail

    vampires dont have shiny metal

    vampires cant kill homunculi (i say homunculi can kill them) oh and major armstrong has more sparkles :D

    EDWARD ELRIC PWNS!! :D

  • @mononokehimenausicaa Oh yeah, i'm sure Gluttony will find them delicious XD

  • who leaked her book?

  • now that i think about it alice kind of does something (this being sarcastic bashing by the way)!

    in the first book and i quote (kind of) edward tells bella that Alice buys the family clothes and than she wont let them where them more than once and she promptly gives them to charity. OKAY!

    so i guess that is the family trying to be helpful to the human race?

    by the way have a question do you know anything about the midnight sun leak? i want to know if smeyer sued the mess out of he person

  • please tell me the quote at the beginning of this is not true!

    stephenie meyer actually based her characters off of XMEN! that is a joke right hehehaha! right?

  • Isn't alphonse a whiny emo as well?

  • Uh, no....please tell me how? I would personally like to know because I watch the original fma and fma brotherhood.....give me an example...please

  • I perfer Alucard, because he is a real vampire. However, Edward Elric is a good fighter.

  • fuck cullen, he has no reason to go all emo- (i know you already said that XP) and Edward ELRIC does!!- his mom died when he was eleven, he lost his arm and leg, he brother lost his WHOLE FREAKIN BODY. You dont see Edward ELRIC bitching and complaining about that. So, who would you pick, Elric or cullen? (p.s. Edward Elirc is sssooo much hotter than cullen :) ) TEAM ELRIC FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!! XD

  • @boring12343 words or numbers cant express how much i agree with you!!!!!!!!!!!youre right,ed never wines about any of the horrable crap he's been through,he just gritts his teeth and deals with it like the boss he is XD

    TEAM ELRIC ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!

  • @bunnyalchemist07 exactly :)

  • @boring12343 ;) yeah

  • team edward elric ed is not my fav i love envy bt envy die's so i gess i'm team ed

  • you make such a good point! ed is smarter,cooler,and above all,a hell of alot hotter then cullen!!!! GO TEAM ELRIC!!!!WOOT!!!

  • you are so AWESOME! I TOTALLY agree with you!!

  • I SO AGREE WITH YOU!!! It always annoyed me how the vampires only seemed to care about thier shiny volvos when they could be doing SOMETHING. I mean, they're not even helping people in their everyday lives, like normal human beings, they're acctually hiding from society

  • Someone missed the "Like"button O:

    FMA wins.

  • I agree i love edward elric

  • FMA, as I have to express my opinion is a lot better than Twilight. It's more unique, and unlike Bella Swan, the women of FMA can DEFEND. THEMSELVES.

  • @charmedgal888 not only that, but they don't attempt suicide every 5 minutes by flying off a motorcycle to see tay's abs or falling down a hill.

    :/

  • @lauruhhl That too. 

  • I LOVE U 4 MAKING THIS!! and where did u get the seto kaiba picture?! I MUST HAVE IT

  • hah, I thouroughly enjoyed listening to this!! I really liked how you "clarified the point" of the vid at the end, and how the name Edward has not been ruined forever [same here xD] I literally lol'd...especially at Roy's mini-skirt rant at the end xP

  • he has one heroic moment...but I hate him for saving Bella during the car accident.

  • elric is quite lovable

  • Ed's better than al, mostly in the anime.

  • YAY FOR EDWARD ELRIC!

  • Carlisle is really the only vampire I would fall head over heels for. Cuz he's awesome.

  • 5:14

    NICE EYELINER DUDE.

  • Team Edward... Edward Elric...

    Ed Elric has reason to bitch and doesn't use it. Edward Cullen has no reason to bitch and does it all the time.

    I'm sorry Cullen. Everyone has a right to be stupid but you're abusing the privlege.

  • I think you have inspired me to write a scholarly paper about Edward Vs Edward. Danke danke!

  • lol at the end "...and all female officers will be required ...TINY MINI SKIRTS xD"!!!!

  • S. Meyer looks like she had plastic surgery 3 times. You rock, btw. I LOVE your videos! You make excellent points. You are my hero. *_______*

  • i like twilight good enough, but there is no way that cullen could compare to ed!! and all ur points are true!! hehe my name isn't edwardsminesuckers for a reason(i wish i added elric to it tho, so no one confuses it with cullen, that was before i read twilght) good vid and great points!! GO TEAM EDWARD ELRIC!!!! oh, and are u a part of the miniskirt army? just asking

  • @edwardsminesuckers oops i mean my name is edwardsminesuckers for a reason ^^'

  • Elric has a reason to have his emo moments. Cullen does not.

  • I made a shirt that has the "Team Edward" on it...

    Then in the FMA font it says "ELRIC"

    I'm very proud of it

    I can make more if you want one! I'm trying to get money for A-Kon 21 (I'll be Envy but I need to get in!) please help! OTAKUS UNITE! [advertising over]

    You have such a good point and I love Edward Elric

  • Well, I would like to see what it looks like, the shirt.

  • @amyrat151 I'll post a vid. Keep a look out ^^

  • @pixeluvr That sounds like the most badass shirt ever.

  • @pixeluvr I want one! do you have it on the web yet??

  • Go Team Elric!!! ^^ i made a group over this!! ^^

  • I agree with everything you say. I really don't undstand the whole Night themed titles in Meyer's books. I mean, the average episode of Sesame Street is darker and more brutal than Twilight. On a side note, my favorite character in FMA is Scar. He just relates more to my own ideology than any of the others.

  • 0:27 nice lucky star cosplay!!

    and yes Cullen should go burn in a hole with light yagami!!!!!!!

    the both suck and Elric rulez!

  • Go Team Edward ELRIC!!!

  • I'll remember that next time, mom. And so it's your decision whats right or isn't for mankind huh?

  • Mankind, don't you think that's more than a little over dramatic? Seriously, I think you have good amount to learn about how to converse with people who have different view points than yours.

  • @amyrat151 i think its not a little over its just right. Seriously, I know I have good amount of time to learn more about how to converse with people who have different view points than mine. And I don't really care about your opinion on my conversing skills or my love of Twilight, but i do love to argue even if I don't necessarily prove my point.

  • Arguing for arguing sake is pretty pointless, unless that's your way to vent.

    And you obviously care about my opinion other wise you wouldn't have even posted one comment on my video.

  • @amyrat151 No I actually don't care about your opinion ,so I posted a comment that doesn't mean I care about your opinion.

  • Yes it does, if my opinions meant nothing to you, you'd just brush them off, move on with your life. If my words are no consequence to you, why are you still even talking to me. I only replied to you since you posted something in the first place, and that's why this back forth has kept going, becuase of you, not me.

  • @amyrat151 Your the one who replied back the first you should take your own advice and just brush off my comments.

  • Okay, I'm done even attempting to explain myself, this back and forth has become meaningless at best. I've tried to be cordial and civil with you, but it's absolutely clear that you don't understand than. It's also clear that you have no respect for me. And since you lack respect, I'd rather you'd not speak to me anymore.

  • @amyrat151 okie dokie

    :D

  • Cullen, u are not part of the generation of the Armstrong family and u should not sparkles

  • If I could, I'd jump through my computer screen to yours to give you a big hug.

  • @amyrat151 *hugs* I could! XD

  • @TheInevitable22

    hehe nice

  • @TheInevitable22 plus, the only person who's so manly even with the sparkles, is the only one Armstrong :) No one can beat Armstrong in a sparkle contest!

    *sparkles*

  • Hot! You know it, hells to the yeah!

  • @TheInevitable22 TODALY AND ARSTRONG CAN CUT A YEARS WORTH OF FIRWOOD IN 1 DAY GO MAN GO CUT THAT WOOD lol :D

  • TEAM ELRIC!!

  • hell freakin' ya man GO TEAM ELRIC

  • thank u! I have thought this forever. Bella should be the heroine in the story since she's the main character. she doesn't fight for anything, everyone does stuff for her. she can't fight her own battles.

  • well let's see, for one, edward saves bella, and so what if stephenie meyer based twilight off that, did she say which part she based it off of? The Cullens are together as a family and they aren't related. Also keep in my mind that drinking animal blood instead of human blood is helping mankind because they aren't killing people

  • Actively not murdering people is not helping mankind. If that were true you could label someone a good human being just because they haven't murdered anybody.

    One could say this about a dead-beat Dad. "Well, he did leave his wife and three kids, but hey, he's never killed anybody. So let's give him a humanitarian award, he totally deserves it!"

  • How old are 55??? hahahah

  • I'm 21.

  • ha! yea rite

  • No, that's really how old I am. I'll be 22 in April though.

  • you no wat i love about your video?

  • I'm sorry, I didn't understand that. Did you mean "You know what I love about your video"? You know, it's important to use proper spelling and grammar so that people can understand you.

  • @amyrat151 sorry (srry) I (i) didn't (didnt) spell (spll) it right (rite) I (i) will (wll) try(tri) to (2) next (nxt) time (tim). I (i) hope (hpe) when (wen) someone (som1) spells (splls) something ( somthin) wrong (rong) you (u) will (wll) understand (undrstand). Now (now) I (i) feel (fll) like (lik) I'm (im) helping (helpin) mankind too (2)!

  • Was that supposed to be condescending? I'm not being pretensions. I don't think it's unreasonable to expect a native English speaker, which I'm assuming you are since your profile says you're from Phoenix, to be able to converse in English properly. The government doesn't require children to be taught English because of a whim, you know.

    It's not about "helping mankind" it's about presenting yourself as an educated person. Try to show some respect for education and write properly next time.

  • boooo cullen

    GOOOOO EDWARD ELRIC

  • is there even a debate the elric is better than cullen? seriously i hate twilight and i mean HATE it, but these two "people" are compleatly in different leauges, not comparable in any way.. and so far i've hered no one compare them? except in these youtube vids coming from anime fans hating on twilight..

    I do enjoy your video's but hating on somthing that you have no intrest in seams so pointless.

  • Obviously Edward Elric is a much stronger and more admirable character than Cullen.

  • i am a proud member of Team Edward Elric, and cullen should die by Edward Elric's sexy automail!!!

  • @randomnessonly me too!!!cullen should die by either edward elric's super sexy auto-mail or by harry potter's kick ass magic(either way i'll be happy :D)

  • team elric!!!!

    HOW DARE STEPHENIE MEYER BASE THOSE FREAKIN SUCKY CHARACTERS OFF OF THE GREAT X-MEN!!!!!!UNDERSERVING!!!!!!t­he only thing good about that movie is taylor launter shirtless

  • ED ELRIC TOTALLY PWNS CULLEN!!!!^.^

  • Team Elric XD RLZ :*

  • Hmm

    Yes, well if you don't care about what I think about Twilight then why did you even bother to leave me a comment.

    And I talked about Romeo & Juliet in another video, you can watch it if you like.

  • @ilovePat100 wat do ya mean "she filled a space that was needed after Harry Potter ended"? they're two completely different stories that have little to nothing in common with different settings characters and plot development! so plz enlighten me on the situation

  • 3:06 = <3

    5:47 = awesome Death Note FTW.

    Elric pwns cullen fer sure ♥

  • wow..... stephanie meyer u put the x-men 2 shame. how dare she even think of comparing the piece of crap she wrote to x-men!!

    p.s. how DARE u pronounce alcemist wrong!! RARWG!

    ps go team edward elric!!

  • Agreed, X-men has no comparison to Twilight. There is nothing similar. X-men is better <3

  • Super video! Very good theory

  • fuck you shinji!

  • The funny thing is that my older cousin was talking about how bad the twilight books sucked just earlier lol

  • Angel would pwn Edward, XD I mean he's really close to Edward, a stalker and such but he tries so hard to be good. And actually saves other people, Edward is rich and whines. PERFECT RANT! 5/5

  • So would Buffy :)

  • Too right! :)

  • EDWARD ELRIC !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    anyone that says no is way off they're rocker!

    and plus ed has his awesome little brother alphonse{love him}

    the elric brothers help every one, and fullmetal is a cool name and he does not sparkly!

    ELRIC BROTHERS FUCKIN RULE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • You're so right! Cullen's should use their powers to help people not go to high school!

    God, I've never thought of that before...D: Twilight would definetly be better that way!

  • 6:38 Edward's looking fiiiinnneee...

  • Oh and Al is awesome ^^. The Elric Brothers ftw!

  • No contest...Edward Cullen obviously wins...YEAH FUCKING RIGHT. Edward Elric is the Fullmetal fucking Alchemist HOW could the two even be compared? Elric would fucking OWN Cullen.

  • GO EDWARD ELRIC!!!!!

  • I've read and like the Twilight books, I think that they're really great, actually. That's my opinion. But yes, you are absolute right about the whole "hero" thing. Cullen's problems ultimately revolve around things that he causes! That bugs me.

    He's sad, depressed and emo because he chooses it. If he smiled and took life with an excepting grasp he'd be happy and Bella wouldn't have gone through most of the crap she did.He needs to stop feeling sorry for himself because he's a vampire. Go Elric.

  • Ha ha! Perfect spot to include Light Yagami!

    And yes! Edward Elric is way better! Twilight fans can't complain, you gave good reasonsd that are hard to top. Things lkike "Edward Cullen is hotter" isn't something to say.

    GREAT JOB!!!!

  • "Edward Cullen is hotter," huh?

    Well it's not like there's much to Cullen's personality besides his looks, well other than the whole controlling bastard, thing.

    I know people often cast Light as being the anime Edward, which I find highly interesting, because they have so much in common, both having God complexes, both believing humans are beneath them, and both being horrible bastards to women.

  • yeah but Light doesn't need sparkles to be one of the most famous manga characters. Yes he has a god complex, but his personality is way deeper and more mature than cullen. unlike the Gary Stue, Light has reasons to be a megalomaniac, being that he sees the world as rotten. And his IQ would easily beats Cullen's (I mean, he did kill L!). I find it particulary horryifing that some people might be so dense as casting such a fantastic character to another who is so bland.

  • Yes, I would never say that Light is a Gary Stu, never! I was just saying it's sad how girls justify Light's actions cause he's pretty.

    I don't like him much, but he's an interesting character, and he does have reasons for his actions, and thinking people in general are crap, but you're right, Cullen doesn't.

  • Also Light's whole god-complex and being a bastard to women thing is cast in a negative light...where as in Edward's case SMeyer spins his actions positively, when really they're just as bad.

  • Look at the hellsing Manga or OVA alucard could get rid of the entire cullen family in less than 0.01 seconds, hell even Integra hellsings butler could get rid of them all in that amount of time

  • there is another thing that the heros have that the cullens dont.....a weakness.....which makes there vampires boring!!!

  • Hey! I'm a yaoi fan and I'm an ANti - TWilighter.

  • Yes, but there's an imporant difference between yaoi fangirl, and yaoi fan.

  • 7:10 True that! My god all these stupid half-wits girls in my school need to open their eyes!

  • Silly me, I thought the other 'Edward' refured to the character in the Anita Blake seires. Well, any Edward totally beats Edward Cullen. I feel really bad for Robert Pattinson because most of his fanbase is now made up of Twitwats and the unauthorized biography of him made me feel embarassed for him.

    Nice video. You can never have too many Yu-Gi-Oh Abridged references.

  • Man, that was fun. Thanks for making this!! XD

  • Edward Elric PWNS Edward Cullen.

  • Edward Elric PWNS Edward Cullen.

  • hell yeah!

  • I had a laugh at the end with Roy Mustang and his declaration.

    You braught up a good point Edward Elric can kick Edward Cullen's ass any day.

  • I love Twilight, but Team Edward Elric fer sure! X3 Ed could sooo kick that sparkely vampires ass! :D Edward Cullen is somewhat of a whiney betch in the series. XD But you must understand it wasn't a super hero story, it was a romance.

  • But Meyer wanted Edward to be a tragic hero. But he fails as as a tragic hero because he's not a hero.

  • Yeah, and what tragedy does he TRULY have?! Really?! Because it pretty much seems like he gets everything he's ever wanted in life... just like Bella! X(

    THANK you for making this video! I'm glad other people realize this book is overrated.

  • I agree.

  • Team Edward Elric!!!!

  • Edward Elric.... how awesome is he!?!?!

    haha

  • The only positive thing is that at least emo is still trendy.

    You know, this rant inspires me...

  • FMA is awesome :)

    Hell, just about any character named Edward is much better than Cullen.

    Edward Penishands for example. I don't know if there's anything to compare regarding character development, but Penishands is definitely more hilariously entertaining than Cullen.

  • What the...? Is it true?

  • Is what true?

  • That Meyer reads comics.

  • SMeyer...comics...?

    NOOO!

  • I'm Team Edward Elric!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more