Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (41)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Fantastic editing!! I absolutely love this!!♥

  • lol..this is good.

  • it raises one question: the ring has a adaptive system that thights himself depending how thick the finger is

    lulz bad english

  • good job, everyone shud love the Rosenman score.

  • Interesting. Good job of editing.

  • Comment removed

  • Very well done. When I watch the original version of the audio I can't stop laughing. But this is good.

  • Wow, this is great

  • This is great! Great work on the editing of the movie to coincide with the audio. I'll be checking the rest of the movie whenever I have a chance.

  • bellissimoooooooooooo

  • Proudfeet!

  • I commend you on your effort here. Very well done. I still prefer the Rosenman soundtrack to Howard Shores live action one. Good job syncing up the audio to the scenes. I can't imagine how hard it was to do this.

  • i like the way it says "three for the tall elf kings" when Galadriel is right in the front of the shot

  • this is really impressive I must say. I used to love this movie when I was younger, brings back memories

  • when you were younger? lol, you must be soooo old now then...

  • not really haha only 20 but I was watching them when I was probably 5 or 6 I think ?

  • return of the king was released like 6 years ago!

  • oohhhh the real movies ! I thought you were talking about the old cartoon version that it is using for the voiceover, not the real films. haha yea that'd be bizarre if the new films took me back haha

  • or DVD5

  • Comment removed

  • Nice Job man!

    I really appreciated it!

  • Comment removed

  • Don't understand you. I did include the Smeagol and Deagol bit. It's between 3:10 and 4:00. I haven't changed it a bit. Thank you for watching and commenting.

  • Sorry about that I got confused with the other guy's LOTR mashup because he didn't include that scene, sorry. :)

  • Thank you for your answer. Now I understand. I have seen the other one.

  • wow, this is great! I saw something like this a long time ago, but it was just the first scene I think. And I think it might have used Bakshi's visuals intead.

  • Superb edit i must say!

  • Very well done ^ - ^

    5/5

  • The funny thing is I thought Peter oodthorpe did the Gollum voice in the Bakshi film, but that didn't sound like him..

  • Not a bad narrator, but I've fallen in love with Galadriel's voice.

    "The world has changed.  I feel it in the water; I feel it in the earth; I smell it in the air."

  • Who hasn't?

    But Cate Blanchett was only 9 years old when the soundtrack was recorded. I don't think she could make it that powerful in those days... :)

  • @xtremespeed128 her voice is cheesy shit

  • @dontleademsomuch that's like saying "we can live without oxygen"

  • very cool! 3-4 years! I'd take my hat off to you, but I'm not wearing one at the moment. haha thanks for this!

  • Fan vad förvånad och överraskad jag blev....skit bra, men jag vill ha dig i hamokken med guran i närheten av ösmo :) Terve

  • I think you should credit Leonard Rosenman for composing the music...

  • Why not? But I don't understand.

    I haven't credit any one in particular. But in my foreword I write that it is a tribute to the original movies and their makers. That means all of the makers in both movies.

  • This is the most creative videos i have ever seen on Youtube.

  • Thank you very much!

    I don't know if you are right about "most creative...ever" - (except it's your personal reflection) but... Thank you!

  • I'm really serious

  • You are a legendary YouTuber

  • Cool Idea WOW a serious LOTR fan..amazing!! Finally someone like me!!

  • You win 5 stars!

  • Thank you, and all of you, fore your comments and stars!

  • That's really cool! Good job! It works quite well!

  • Amazing. More people should see this

  • I agree. This might be the coolest thing I've seen on youtube! Thanks

  • Thank you very much. I will bear your words with me. "...might be the coolest..." Not bad!

    It took me 3 or 4 years to finish all 16 parts. It was worth it.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more