どこの国が悪いとか、誰が犠牲者で誰が加害者かとか、そういう事を言いたくてこの映画を作ったんではないと思うなー。アメリカ人を責める訳でも日本人責める訳でもない。ただ世界の平和を目指す為に自分自身が変わる努力をするべき。これからは国境なんて関係ないよ。それが戦争で亡くなった人達への供養だと思う。This isn't about blame. Not about who's fault and who's the victim. This is about peace among all humanity. We must respect one another and embrace each other. That's the most respectful things to do to those who died in our war.
you really think so? can you image how they felt because of this weapon? i reallu feelinpleasant from what you wrote here. please never say this again.
The key word you used is "Anger". And anything done in "anger", by default leaves room for "reconciliation". I think bilateral apologizes are always a good thing. --Never too late, never too often. --BTW, very good points you make. Thanks for the discussion.
-So, although the bombs did caused the emperor to make the radio broadcast, which ended the war, was there a need to kill another 275,000 non-combatant civilians, after already killing more then 3,000,000 during the indiscriminant fire bombings of civilian assets? And with the full knowledge that Japan was already in surrender negotiations with both the U.S. and the Soviets, more then a month prior to Aug. 6th...
I think you are missing the point. 1) They didn't walk for 60 years for Japanese. --They walked in hopes of preventing nuclear destruction from spreading throughout the world. (including in China).
The Japanese HAVE apologized for war atrocities in Nanking, Taiwan, Korean and SEA countries. The question is; When will YOU accept the apology? --That will be the day that you understand the deeper meaning of this film.
I don't require an apology from Tokyo for WW2. The militarists who hijacked Japan and started the war either died in the war, committed suicide or faced justice at war crimes trials afterwards. The post war democratic govt and citizens of Japan are not responsible for what the war government forced them to do.
Dropping the bombs "in anger" didn't stop the mass murder in SEA, or the war in the pacific. What brought everything to a halt was the radio broadcast by the Emperor. Most Japanese didn't know about the bombings at the time, but still dropped their weapons after hearing just three words from their emperor: "war is over".
Yes, Hirohito's message stopped Japan's mass murder in China and SEA, but it was Hiroshima and Nagasaki which prompted PM Suzuki and the remaining militarists to leave the decision to the emperor. Had US not dropped the atomics, the war would have dragged on. Who knows how long? No one can say.
You are living in a fantasy world. It does not matter who controls Chinese or Japanese propaganda today, the fact is that millions of Chinese individuals died at the hands of Japanese soldiers during World War II.
I think you are missing the point. 1) They didn't walk for 60 years for Japanese. --They walked in hopes of preventing nuclear destruction from spreading throughout the world. (including in China). 2) The amazing thing about this film is the fact that the American's opened the gate for the first time in 60 years. --This is the first ever step / gesture of multilateral reconciliation for using nuclear weapons on civilians.
You are the one missing the point. 1) No reconcilliation is required on the part of the US. We dropped two atomic weapons in anger, which ended Japan's mass murder in SEA, and NO ONE has used atomics since. Strange thing to march against weapons no one uses because everyone already knows how dangerous they are! 2) A true buddhist would not be attached to war or peace or any outcome, past, present or future. And no buddhist would ever carry around a grudge flame for a day, let alone sixty years.
It's not a "grudge flame"... Its a peace flame in remembrance of those who died, and in hopes that its never used again. There is a BIG difference. -If you understood anything about Buddhism, you would know this. You need to see the film before commenting.
どこの国が悪いとか、誰が犠牲者で誰が加害者かとか、そういう事を言いたくてこの映画を作ったんではないと思うなー。アメリカ人を責める訳でも日本人責める訳でもない。ただ世界の平和を目指す為に自分自身が変わる努力をするべき。これからは国境なんて関係ないよ。それが戦争で亡くなった人達への供養だと思う。This isn't about blame. Not about who's fault and who's the victim. This is about peace among all humanity. We must respect one another and embrace each other. That's the most respectful things to do to those who died in our war.
chuchudegozaru 1 year ago 2
It is impossible that the American understands. Because they think that it is a justice.
The American must carry out the justice of the slaughter.
However, the Japanese must not forgive the atomic bomb. Do not forget.
211yamato 1 year ago
てめえれテキサス親父の話でも聞いてろ
アカアメリカ人め！！
stndbym6129 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
～日本軍馬鹿の栄光～
おまえら馬鹿日本..日中戦争
大日本帝国が残虐中国人
馬鹿日本天皇侵略中国と歴史捏造と謝罪
原子彈根本沒有投日本...馬鹿
pp1314520 2 years ago
應該把那倆個彈投到京都和大阪的！
fjy226 2 years ago
How did the Uighur person's persecution become it?
Does the Tibet people's slaughter still continue?
Chinese doesn't have reflection either.
Therefore, China was made a colony in the powers country.
Barbarous communist state. Communist state good at fabrication.
sakurasakura2424 2 years ago
アメリカ人へ これはあなたたちの為にしているのですよ！
motogotou 2 years ago 5
this is punishment of god
好！好！好！
wuyanniann 3 years ago
you really think so? can you image how they felt because of this weapon? i reallu feelinpleasant from what you wrote here. please never say this again.
Minomonko 3 years ago
thise should have NEVER have happend war and bombs only harm inniconts look at the lovley family in Barefoot Gen a true story thats a very sad film
freacls 3 years ago
この火を決して絶やしてはいけません。
o36k10 3 years ago 6
The key word you used is "Anger". And anything done in "anger", by default leaves room for "reconciliation". I think bilateral apologizes are always a good thing. --Never too late, never too often. --BTW, very good points you make. Thanks for the discussion.
airbornedonzi 3 years ago
-So, although the bombs did caused the emperor to make the radio broadcast, which ended the war, was there a need to kill another 275,000 non-combatant civilians, after already killing more then 3,000,000 during the indiscriminant fire bombings of civilian assets? And with the full knowledge that Japan was already in surrender negotiations with both the U.S. and the Soviets, more then a month prior to Aug. 6th...
airbornedonzi 3 years ago
I think you are missing the point. 1) They didn't walk for 60 years for Japanese. --They walked in hopes of preventing nuclear destruction from spreading throughout the world. (including in China).
airbornedonzi 3 years ago
The Japanese HAVE apologized for war atrocities in Nanking, Taiwan, Korean and SEA countries. The question is; When will YOU accept the apology? --That will be the day that you understand the deeper meaning of this film.
airbornedonzi 3 years ago
I don't require an apology from Tokyo for WW2. The militarists who hijacked Japan and started the war either died in the war, committed suicide or faced justice at war crimes trials afterwards. The post war democratic govt and citizens of Japan are not responsible for what the war government forced them to do.
longlakeshore 3 years ago
Dropping the bombs "in anger" didn't stop the mass murder in SEA, or the war in the pacific. What brought everything to a halt was the radio broadcast by the Emperor. Most Japanese didn't know about the bombings at the time, but still dropped their weapons after hearing just three words from their emperor: "war is over".
airbornedonzi 3 years ago
Yes, Hirohito's message stopped Japan's mass murder in China and SEA, but it was Hiroshima and Nagasaki which prompted PM Suzuki and the remaining militarists to leave the decision to the emperor. Had US not dropped the atomics, the war would have dragged on. Who knows how long? No one can say.
longlakeshore 3 years ago
Your history is very ignorant.
The United States's justifying the atomic bombing doesn't want only to recognize the indiscrimination genocide.
The United States knew the conclusion was attached though the atomic bomb was not dropped.
Japan is percussing surrender in May.
However, it was disregarded until the atomic bomb was dropped.
sakurasakura2424 2 years ago
Japan has not murdered it in China.
The Nanjing event is propaganda of communism.
As many as 731 forces are also similar.
The material of 731 forces was open to the public in the United States.
The historian in anti-Japan that examined the war crime of a Japanese army seems to have investigated.
However, the result came out if there was no one called a war crime at all.
It is disgusted at the propaganda of Chinese communism.
sakurasakura2424 2 years ago
You are living in a fantasy world. It does not matter who controls Chinese or Japanese propaganda today, the fact is that millions of Chinese individuals died at the hands of Japanese soldiers during World War II.
longlakeshore 2 years ago
Methinks these holy monks are carrying a flame they should have quenched and forgotten long ago...
longlakeshore 3 years ago
I think you are missing the point. 1) They didn't walk for 60 years for Japanese. --They walked in hopes of preventing nuclear destruction from spreading throughout the world. (including in China). 2) The amazing thing about this film is the fact that the American's opened the gate for the first time in 60 years. --This is the first ever step / gesture of multilateral reconciliation for using nuclear weapons on civilians.
airbornedonzi 3 years ago
You are the one missing the point. 1) No reconcilliation is required on the part of the US. We dropped two atomic weapons in anger, which ended Japan's mass murder in SEA, and NO ONE has used atomics since. Strange thing to march against weapons no one uses because everyone already knows how dangerous they are! 2) A true buddhist would not be attached to war or peace or any outcome, past, present or future. And no buddhist would ever carry around a grudge flame for a day, let alone sixty years.
longlakeshore 3 years ago
no buddhist would ever carry around a grudge flame for a day, let alone sixty years.
how convenient right?
fruitsofescapism 3 years ago
It's not a "grudge flame"... Its a peace flame in remembrance of those who died, and in hopes that its never used again. There is a BIG difference. -If you understood anything about Buddhism, you would know this. You need to see the film before commenting.
airbornedonzi 3 years ago
Who marches for the Rape of Nanking?
Who marches for countless thousands of Korean women forced to sexually service Japanese troops?
Who marches for 20 million dead in China in the Japanese invasion/occupation?
Who? Japanese Buddist monks? I don't think so.
longlakeshore 3 years ago
ya,i totally agree with u!
do not forget what did Japanese do before
LokYeaHK 3 years ago
ya,i totally agree with u!
do not forget what did Japanese do before
LokYeaHK 3 years ago
ya,i totally agree with u!
do not forget what did Japanese do before
LokYeaHK 3 years ago
これは、絶対にみなくてはなりませんね。
今の日本人に必要な無常の心を取り戻すきっかけになれば、と思います。
hirarin0324 4 years ago 2
記念日って記念はおかしいだろ
matankai 4 years ago
すごく見たいです。
これだけで、既に感動しました。
moyashi24 4 years ago 2
鳥肌。。。早く見たい！
airbornedonzi 4 years ago 2