When they play the comparison of Nicola and Kimberley, Nicola is clearly the BEST singer, and actually not just between these two, but live, she is by far the best. I think Nicola is gorgeous, Louis is two kinds of an ass... a JACKass and a DUMBass. I'm glad Nicola was chosen 2nd to be in the band, before Nadine, Kimberley and Sarah. I don't think they would have been as successful as they are without ANY of the 5 girls. They are an amazing group.
You know theres only one or two things that nicola needs to do to make herself stunning....the reason people think she's ugly is because her features are naturally out of sinc...if she used a little color on her eyebrows and a nice bit of deep lipstick to make her lips look a little fuller she would look absolutely stunning.....the other girls are just lucky that they have facial features that are already near perfect. Nicola dosen't deserve to be called ugly,so far from the truth, poor girl:(
At that time she was usings tanning products....Geri is actually quite patronising there too... saying that Nicola could be the token less beautiful one in the band...The fact is though Geri can patronise here but Nicola can sing, dance and look great in Vivianne Westwood, all things that Geri Halliwell can't do. And she isn't a publicity driven, narcissist....
I'm waiting for the day (I just know it'll come) when Nicola becomes an international star... and I hope that they show this video over and over on TV when it happens.
There an even better band now they have left Louis Walsh.... No wonder poor Nicola has insecurites about her looks, thankfully her bandmates love her and don't have Louis predjuiced views... Nicola was just 16 then... Louis came so close to wreaking the band before it started... the right girls got in and thats is why they lasted beyond his influence...
I have read their book All That Glitters and it is horrifying what Louis left them to deal with, it is amazing that the survived because they were teenagers and they had to work it out themselves... They lost their first tour manager in a car crash on Christmas Day, two weeks after getting together...Cheryl got into terrible trouble, Nicola was getting slated for her looks, while her family was spliting up, Sarah are being attacked for being in the band and Louis was no where...he left them.
People call them manufactored but they are actually self made..They worked so hard together to make it work... They have a regular song writer and a team to work with but they always had influence on the songs that where written and they kept themselves going under all the odds against them...
That's so true. I hate it when people talk about them like they're talentless hacks who have other people do everything for them. They're so talented and have worked hard for their success.
It takes the talent to be successful not beauty. Beauty is so far is shown so much in the U.S. that's all to sell, but not a song to make a record. It's dumb that way, which I feel Geri on that last compliment.
this proves geri was right. and louis too (cause of kimba), but nicola did get in the band and look how far she has come! and i think she is stunning :) and what a hell of a voice she has...
they need to show case her singing like that in girls aloud songs more
i honestly dont get why people say nicola isnt good looking?? shes fit! fair enough she aint a supermodel .. but not many are! ... they talk about her here as if she has 3 head?
thats what i thought. Im mean shes not ugly, i think louis just really picks on the fact that shes not the best lookin and means to protects his favourites
Nicola should of been in the 10 in the first place,lewie just did,nt like her for the look and yet she has the best voice of all of them,i,m so happy they had that devor , thats the other nicola that would,nt play ball and kicked her out to let are nicola in,i say our nicola as i voted for her many times,these girls rock.
lousi thinks he knows everythin about girlbands he always goes on about it but this proves that he know nothing yes i totally love kimba but anyone can see nicola is way better in singing in dancing and she is sexy and beuatiful and being quirky can be a good thing nicola gives off a messege as if you - like geri said - it can be a good thing to have someone thts not stereotypically beuatiful to give the band more versatility shes my fave I LOVE HER
Kimberly got her plae cause one of ther girls was too old. Then One of the final ten (another Nicola) read the contract they were supposed to sign and refused saying they were not going to get paid enough so Nicola got in at the 11th hour man I'm a nerd
Nicola's great and i'm so glad both the girls made it into the band in the end - but i totally agree Kimberley was the right choice. Yes Nicola's got a better voice but Kimberley does have a nice voice, is a better dancer, is absolutely stunning, is the most unbelievably sweet and likeable girl, and has more charisma. Overall i definitely think Kimba is the better of the two.
I agree! Geri's not a great singer, and she knows that. I dont think it was a bad decision having a member of the worlds biggest girl group to judge the show. At the end of the day Geri was right about Nicola!! GA wouldnt be the same without her
ur right, it's not like he's one to put someone else down just because of their looks! ;) Nicola definitely doesn't look as bad as he is making out anyway.
I can;t believe louis kept saying he didn't like nicola cos of her looks! anyway just cos she isn't all glamorous doesn't mean she's not pretty. he didn't even listen to geri, he just wanted hot and glam girls in the band. i'm so glad nicola got in cos she has an amazing voice <3
but finally Nicola and Kimberley are in the band xD...
... This is a prove that the people who choose the members of a reality music band sometimes go wrong. I can't imagine GA being succesful without Nicola or without Kimberley
geri is soo right, you DONT have to be too beautiful to be a singer..nicola have a good voice.. that guy should just shut the f* up! he dosent look any better!
Judging from Nicola's audition and this clip, it's clear that Louis was very anti-Nicola and Geri always backed her. Glad to know Nicola got in and she shut Louis' mouth being one of the most consistent performers. God knows what was he thinking when he picked weak girls like Emma or Lynsey over Nicola
Geri only went for nicola because every band needs a ginger one! haha i love nicola
DrMarthaJ 1 month ago
If I were Nicola, I'd be giving Louis the finger, like "bitch look where I am now."
fiftysevenhypocrites 3 months ago
I think Louis wsa a bit harse on Nicola
Kaynas1988 5 months ago
I'm so glad they both made it :)
memandi2 6 months ago
My god, Louis is such a fucking tithead. This makes me wanna throw him in a well.
What a prick he is.
SweetAndCrazyAngel 8 months ago 3
Geri in a kinda "Fat slags"-fashion(I´m talking about the movie)...
Halliwellsson 1 year ago
this is horrible!!! louis is such a dick!!
i mean how can cheryl bag lily allen when she criticizes nicola, and then its acceptable for louis to?
lomaaz 1 year ago 2
When they play the comparison of Nicola and Kimberley, Nicola is clearly the BEST singer, and actually not just between these two, but live, she is by far the best. I think Nicola is gorgeous, Louis is two kinds of an ass... a JACKass and a DUMBass. I'm glad Nicola was chosen 2nd to be in the band, before Nadine, Kimberley and Sarah. I don't think they would have been as successful as they are without ANY of the 5 girls. They are an amazing group.
doda 1 year ago
I think Geri and Loui were quite horrible about Nicola!
They knew back then that Nic had a much better voice than Kim, but went for Kimba as she's very attractive.
I do like Kim, but her voice is very weak compared to Nics strong vocal range, and she's aslo not a bad dancer. ;)
Hotlips4000isback 2 years ago
You know theres only one or two things that nicola needs to do to make herself stunning....the reason people think she's ugly is because her features are naturally out of sinc...if she used a little color on her eyebrows and a nice bit of deep lipstick to make her lips look a little fuller she would look absolutely stunning.....the other girls are just lucky that they have facial features that are already near perfect. Nicola dosen't deserve to be called ugly,so far from the truth, poor girl:(
boppy100 2 years ago 5
At that time she was usings tanning products....Geri is actually quite patronising there too... saying that Nicola could be the token less beautiful one in the band...The fact is though Geri can patronise here but Nicola can sing, dance and look great in Vivianne Westwood, all things that Geri Halliwell can't do. And she isn't a publicity driven, narcissist....
emmyjo720 2 years ago
I'm waiting for the day (I just know it'll come) when Nicola becomes an international star... and I hope that they show this video over and over on TV when it happens.
daaviichoon 2 years ago 3
How shallow does Louis sound? Nicola is clearly talented! x
naddingtonb 2 years ago 9
At least this proves these shows aren't fixed - cause Nic got in.
emobabe1993 2 years ago 4
louis just manages to prove time and time again how bad he gets it wrong
hes shit and doesnt have the faintest idea of what he is talking about
nicola is the most talented member of the group because she can sing AND dance well
marcusmooney23 2 years ago 13
There an even better band now they have left Louis Walsh.... No wonder poor Nicola has insecurites about her looks, thankfully her bandmates love her and don't have Louis predjuiced views... Nicola was just 16 then... Louis came so close to wreaking the band before it started... the right girls got in and thats is why they lasted beyond his influence...
emmyjo720 2 years ago 7
I agree with everything you said, especially about them being better now that Louis is gone.
PsionicJedi 2 years ago
I have read their book All That Glitters and it is horrifying what Louis left them to deal with, it is amazing that the survived because they were teenagers and they had to work it out themselves... They lost their first tour manager in a car crash on Christmas Day, two weeks after getting together...Cheryl got into terrible trouble, Nicola was getting slated for her looks, while her family was spliting up, Sarah are being attacked for being in the band and Louis was no where...he left them.
emmyjo720 2 years ago 2
Yeah I heard about that stuff too. It's so great that they managed to pick up the pieces and keep going, despite all that hardship.
PsionicJedi 2 years ago
People call them manufactored but they are actually self made..They worked so hard together to make it work... They have a regular song writer and a team to work with but they always had influence on the songs that where written and they kept themselves going under all the odds against them...
emmyjo720 2 years ago
That's so true. I hate it when people talk about them like they're talentless hacks who have other people do everything for them. They're so talented and have worked hard for their success.
PsionicJedi 2 years ago
Louis is the hack..
emmyjo720 2 years ago 3
Definitely.
PsionicJedi 2 years ago
It takes the talent to be successful not beauty. Beauty is so far is shown so much in the U.S. that's all to sell, but not a song to make a record. It's dumb that way, which I feel Geri on that last compliment.
irismey 2 years ago
this proves geri was right. and louis too (cause of kimba), but nicola did get in the band and look how far she has come! and i think she is stunning :) and what a hell of a voice she has...
they need to show case her singing like that in girls aloud songs more
skenj 2 years ago 9
louis's a fuckin tool its so obvious he's gay too
dodgeyjammer 2 years ago 2
i honestly dont get why people say nicola isnt good looking?? shes fit! fair enough she aint a supermodel .. but not many are! ... they talk about her here as if she has 3 head?
throwashape 3 years ago 19
thats what i thought. Im mean shes not ugly, i think louis just really picks on the fact that shes not the best lookin and means to protects his favourites
makemelaughxxx 2 years ago
i love louis walsh, luckily kimberly and nicole BOTH got in:D
blackhairedlovley 3 years ago
Abselouely lovee Nicolaa and louis needs to look at her now she is successful and beautiful in a way thats different but amazzingg :) x
random952008 3 years ago 6
Louis is well known for being wrong.
NDawn 3 years ago
is this a singing comp and he wudnt put nicola in cz shes qurikey.
Nicola is the best singer imo
CherylTweedy93 3 years ago 8
Nicola should of been in the 10 in the first place,lewie just did,nt like her for the look and yet she has the best voice of all of them,i,m so happy they had that devor , thats the other nicola that would,nt play ball and kicked her out to let are nicola in,i say our nicola as i voted for her many times,these girls rock.
tazzarman 3 years ago 5
lousi thinks he knows everythin about girlbands he always goes on about it but this proves that he know nothing yes i totally love kimba but anyone can see nicola is way better in singing in dancing and she is sexy and beuatiful and being quirky can be a good thing nicola gives off a messege as if you - like geri said - it can be a good thing to have someone thts not stereotypically beuatiful to give the band more versatility shes my fave I LOVE HER
girlsaloudfan121 3 years ago 5
you are totally right.Girls Aloud wouldn't be the same without Nicola.she's really great and her voice is the best!
djdiu 3 years ago 9
Does someone know what Nicola and Kimberley where singing???
Pls Answer..
THANKZ!!
A11K9L7A7 3 years ago
lady marmalade
girlsaloudfan121 3 years ago
oh my god i cant believe they dont see what a babe she is and she is a great singer i am shocked Louis was that against her
cokieblume 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i love pussy and p3nis hahaha!
someone lick my puss eI
azeeen21 3 years ago
its funny how they're both in it now, how did nicola get in in teh end?
ness1ness 3 years ago 3
Kimberly got her plae cause one of ther girls was too old. Then One of the final ten (another Nicola) read the contract they were supposed to sign and refused saying they were not going to get paid enough so Nicola got in at the 11th hour man I'm a nerd
cokieblume 3 years ago 3
Nicola's great and i'm so glad both the girls made it into the band in the end - but i totally agree Kimberley was the right choice. Yes Nicola's got a better voice but Kimberley does have a nice voice, is a better dancer, is absolutely stunning, is the most unbelievably sweet and likeable girl, and has more charisma. Overall i definitely think Kimba is the better of the two.
BorrowedHeaven86 3 years ago
i prefer Nicola but geri only supports her because she is a fellow ginger!
robtime 3 years ago
I'm sorry, but asking Geri Haliwell to judge the talent of a singer is like asking Joan Crawford to open a daycare center.
garyifny 3 years ago
Um doesn't she have experience from being in a girlband? thats all you need to be a judge you dont need to be able to sing.
brendasback 3 years ago
I agree! Geri's not a great singer, and she knows that. I dont think it was a bad decision having a member of the worlds biggest girl group to judge the show. At the end of the day Geri was right about Nicola!! GA wouldnt be the same without her
spunkinmarky 3 years ago 8
Nicola sang/sings WAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYY better than Kimberley, and as for being 'quirky' - it's called charisma Louis, you dipstick!
Imagine Nicola hadn't made it... proof Louis hasn't got a clue about girl groups.
cambridgechris 3 years ago
NICOLA !!!!!
brownertoxic 3 years ago
and if he puts his arm around one more Spice Girl or kisses them on the cheek i think i might throw up!
busy19 3 years ago
Asshole louis..Nicola the best..<3
noartist01 3 years ago
A Spice Girl and 2/5s of Girls Aloud?! Brilliant!
pretre5 3 years ago
Poor Geri, jewknowhatimean?
yourmomkby 4 years ago
omg louis is such a cow
hw can he not like nicola, so wat she aint pretty but she can sing beta than da rest.
adezco 4 years ago 5
ur right, it's not like he's one to put someone else down just because of their looks! ;) Nicola definitely doesn't look as bad as he is making out anyway.
bub6l3s 3 years ago 2
didn't she leave coz she was pregnant?
divaindahouse21 4 years ago
Why did hazel leave
sigo3453 4 years ago
It turns out she was over the age limit.
gmd5 4 years ago
nicola doesnt look all that great nowadays but i think she looked perfect here. god knows why ppl think shes not pretty.
4MyPeople84 4 years ago
Ginger Nicola all the way!
Blonde doesn't suit her, IMO...she looks too pale
CyPam 4 years ago 4
omg he's gingerist!!!!
Ki3ran14 4 years ago 6
he's more like a Spice Girlsist!!!! If that even makes any sense.
busy19 3 years ago
I can;t believe louis kept saying he didn't like nicola cos of her looks! anyway just cos she isn't all glamorous doesn't mean she's not pretty. he didn't even listen to geri, he just wanted hot and glam girls in the band. i'm so glad nicola got in cos she has an amazing voice <3
WatchHowUPlay 4 years ago 11
does anyone know if there is the clip of Nicola being told she got into the final 10 on here?
trsk2000 4 years ago 5
I don't like louis!
He was so anti-nicola he didn't even listen to Geri!
Nicola had such a better voice than Kimberley!
I'm so glad Nicola got in the band!
She really showed Louis!
SimpsonsRockz28 4 years ago 25
@SimpsonsRockz28 Yeah but so did Kimberley get into Girls Aloud
Kaynas1988 5 months ago
Ok, now we all know that Kimberly can't sing. Good for her.
helluicki 4 years ago
Kimberley most definitely can sing, although I don't think Lady Marmelade is the best song for her.
nieson0727 4 years ago
but finally Nicola and Kimberley are in the band xD...
... This is a prove that the people who choose the members of a reality music band sometimes go wrong. I can't imagine GA being succesful without Nicola or without Kimberley
myshow 4 years ago 8
i dont tink nicola "ugly"
i tink shes very beautiful!
i love the colour of her hair
irishlassy18 4 years ago 13
Don't get me wrong I love Kimberley but she can't come close to Nicola's voice.
fashionistakim 4 years ago 5
i agreee!!!
Tuuperoinen 4 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
nicola is the ugliest of the bunch but she is cool!
yuexiaobing 4 years ago
nicola is a million times better, in every way!
seymorebuttts 4 years ago 2
Nivola is thousand time better singer than Kimberley!!!!!!!!!!!!! and now she is more sexier than Kim. !!!!!!!!!!!!
Tuuperoinen 4 years ago
geri is soo right, you DONT have to be too beautiful to be a singer..nicola have a good voice.. that guy should just shut the f* up! he dosent look any better!
kahraba 5 years ago 2
They're both really good, and they're both in the band. I think the general notion would be "yay".
nieson0727 5 years ago
Judging from Nicola's audition and this clip, it's clear that Louis was very anti-Nicola and Geri always backed her. Glad to know Nicola got in and she shut Louis' mouth being one of the most consistent performers. God knows what was he thinking when he picked weak girls like Emma or Lynsey over Nicola
CyPam 5 years ago
louis really has no idea does he... not picking nicola or eton road for shows like these and instead picking people like the mcdonald brothers lol
tommydng 5 years ago
Nicola is actually better than Kimberly damn that old man btw Go Geri!
JPSexy4Ever 5 years ago
Nicola is beautiful n a gr8 singer n needs more leads! This vid proves she can sing better than Nadine!!
epsonmicrosoft 5 years ago
Nicola is beautiful!
gmd5 5 years ago
I don't get it did Nicola not get through to the final ten at first? did they let her in after like the did Kymberley? Someone enlighten me please!
gmd5 5 years ago
IIRC, one girl left the show, so Kimberly was brought back, and then later the same thing happened and they picked Nicola.
maryxmary 5 years ago
nicola SO should have gone through, she is clearly better
seymorebuttts 5 years ago
im so pleased kimberleys a looker or she wouldve been screwed against nicola if it was on voices n then imagine wot ga would have looked like
runningdeeper 5 years ago 2
funny how they both got in...
foxibabz21 5 years ago 2
WHAT A TIT I LOVE NICOLA
nicolalover06 5 years ago 2