idk y they would choose a non classical singer that was a trademark of the band for a singer with a regular voice..shesnot bad but she doesnt fit Vibeke's place =[
well i have to say that she got a good voice, but definitely every time that i listen to this it feels like i'm listening to some kind of rock band or so... but tristania? definitely not...
I've a theory: Mary MUST be MIND BLOWINGLY GOOD at sex. And she MUST be sleeping with each member of the band after every single concert. That's the only way she can still sing in Tristania.
@DisdainJansen haha yeah I should have. Are you a Floor Jansen fan? If you are, don't do the same mistakes that I did and try to find a singer like Floor, you end up watching Mary 'The Gypsy' Demurtas. :)
Oh my god, what the fuck is she doing? O__o You can't move like that to a Gothic Metal song... She reminds me of Anette of Nightwish, she doesn't fit to the band, either, just like Mary doesn't.
'coz it's a high pitch that can't be reach my chest voice and she is an alto or a mezzo -I think she is an alto though- and she forced herself to reach the high pitch... poor troat... and poor song, she should have down the tune better.
An older song that would be 6 minutes long would be cut down to 4 minutes when "sung" by her. Watch her perform "Beyond the veil" she doesnt sing half the time!
Ugh. Shes so frustrating and embarrassing to look at sometimes. Shes like Ashlety Simpson with that lip-syncing dancing escapade she had.
Im sorry if I sound harsh, but look at her live videos and you would know what I mean.
no disagreement here either! Vibeke had a Renaissance quality to her voice, this new girl has no old quality. She's just screaming or she's making it less dark and more poppy...ick
All she has to do is extend her range to a HIGHER HEIGHT she may be able to sing some of the old stuff w/ a choir.........like the originals. ANyone w/ me?
Well, if you consider that even if she extend her range she will be rejected by many fans o.O -people won't forget this u.uU- it would be difficult way for her.
You shouldn't be talking crap about me when in reality you can't sing Tristania for CRAP. In fact, Mary sings this killed song better than you do. :-) NOW, when did I EVER say she sings better than Vibeke?
Who knows O_O... when they did the casting there were amazing singers, I remember a soprano who has a beautiful and dark voice... she was in the ultimate selection ¬¬ don't know why she isn't the new singer; she was good looking, amazing voice, she speaks english @_@!! She was all they asked for!
Well Vibeke was one of the most important parts of the band -yeah, even the most.- but Tristania has a particulary good sound, the new vocalist though... It would be a good idea to do a new casting, at least for get a second vocalist; a soprano or a mezzo ligera just for songs alike this, because Mariangela is unable to sing this ones, she just don't have the type of voice that is necessary and probably not the knowledge for :(
Oh yeah! is nice see someone who thinks similar to me, I just was think this for Nightwish before, because Annette can't sing songs like 'Wishmaster' that sound bad in her voice... then with Tristania the situation is really bad if the old songs doesn't interpreted by a soprano vocalist :(
It's sad, isn't it? But Tristania don't say anything about this -the new vocalist option.- Anette? You think so? XD well I Think Tarja has a very pretty voice, I consider anette sing very well some songs -actually i like her wishmaster XD her: elbereeeieieieieiee XD it's a pretty fool but I like it XD; I prefer tarja's though XD.- Well we'll have to see what happen to tristania, We can just beg for a second voccalist -a new one would be impossible, wouldn't it?- ^^'
Oh my GOD! What has happened to the fantastic band Tristania? :O I agree with that other guy who commented.. What the wildest hell were they thinking when choosing her? Out of, I don't know... Thousands of singers?
I was saying there was hope for Tristania on another video...but after earing some more new live...I'm simply desperate! Mari doesn't have even half presence and charism Vibeke have...and her voice...I will stay with my old Tristania albums.
I was saying there was hope for Tristania on another video...but after earing some more new live...I'm simply desperate! Mari doesn't have even half presence and charism Vibeke have...and her voice...I will stay with my old Tristania albums.
I like this interpretation actually. It one of my favourite songs and I was quite sure she would mess this song up. When she goes away from the mic you can hear her voice fits quite good to this song (I mean her voice from playback:D). If only she could sing instead of runing and screaming....
ok, i admit i don't really like her, especially if you compare her to vibeke, but...i'll be in sympathy with her, because she's italian like me....so...VAI MARIIIIII xD
hahahha omg!!! What happened with these female-frotned bands?? She screams like a dying cat, it's so amateur LOL. It's too hard to find a girl that can sing metal nowadays and not sound like Shakira or Olivia Newton John.
A "bitch", a "whore"? Who the hell believest thou are? Knowst thou only one thing about her? Tsssss
I agree she is screaming.. but This songs are for lyric voices.. she doth what she canst.. And 'tis pretty cool. I'd rather Vibeke to come back, but she wanth not. 'twill be the future of Tristania.. with or without thee
WTF...?
hederamezzo 11 months ago
Me too, I'd like to cry now. It's so sad what became of them without Vibke!
XInLoveWithMySorrowX 1 year ago
XD goddess! everytime i listen 1:04 i DO think even my cover is better than this... geez, Wacken's version was not nice neither.
SakumaRyuichiNG 2 years ago
idk y they would choose a non classical singer that was a trademark of the band for a singer with a regular voice..shesnot bad but she doesnt fit Vibeke's place =[
LukeSWalker 2 years ago
well i have to say that she got a good voice, but definitely every time that i listen to this it feels like i'm listening to some kind of rock band or so... but tristania? definitely not...
darkis1201 2 years ago
WTF!
I wanna cry.
johnzevanz 2 years ago 6
Is she good at doing something else beside shaking her bum? Not at singing for sure.
MyArseYourMouth 2 years ago
I wanna cry.
iambarbara 2 years ago
I've a theory: Mary MUST be MIND BLOWINGLY GOOD at sex. And she MUST be sleeping with each member of the band after every single concert. That's the only way she can still sing in Tristania.
F355 2 years ago 3
@F355 and maybe you shoud have sex too xDDDD
DisdainJansen 6 months ago
@DisdainJansen haha yeah I should have. Are you a Floor Jansen fan? If you are, don't do the same mistakes that I did and try to find a singer like Floor, you end up watching Mary 'The Gypsy' Demurtas. :)
F355 6 months ago
@F355 well, i like this kind of ending, after all, Mary is a good singer and i like her voice, its really personal! =)
DisdainJansen 6 months ago
good heavens save me, it's horrible.
truskawka92 2 years ago 9
oh my oh my...she can't sing....honestly i can't say she's singing..she's screaming..ruining the song....
SatanIsGuidingMe 3 years ago 2
Fuck Marry this song suits Vibeke only.....this is fucking stupid...sounds like a shit
SatanIsGuidingMe 3 years ago
Oh my god, what the fuck is she doing? O__o You can't move like that to a Gothic Metal song... She reminds me of Anette of Nightwish, she doesn't fit to the band, either, just like Mary doesn't.
Kinslayer89 3 years ago
Comment removed
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago
oh my goodness. why is she screaming the song...
SirenianNightfall 3 years ago 2
'coz it's a high pitch that can't be reach my chest voice and she is an alto or a mezzo -I think she is an alto though- and she forced herself to reach the high pitch... poor troat... and poor song, she should have down the tune better.
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago
Very bad...I'm sorry to say.
mytouniquet 3 years ago 2
lol look at the public :x everybody is choked, nobody's dancing... No hands in the air.... Dude, i think they're traumatized
GodzzBeloved 3 years ago
oh my fucking god!!! What the hell is this??
MyDeathDream 3 years ago 2
she reminds me of Lucia from KMFDM..
Dakedoom 3 years ago
Is this fucking Disco music now? Jesus christ,
What the Hell, Mary!!!!
An older song that would be 6 minutes long would be cut down to 4 minutes when "sung" by her. Watch her perform "Beyond the veil" she doesnt sing half the time!
Ugh. Shes so frustrating and embarrassing to look at sometimes. Shes like Ashlety Simpson with that lip-syncing dancing escapade she had.
Im sorry if I sound harsh, but look at her live videos and you would know what I mean.
MissxBlank 3 years ago
LOLWAT
mytouniquet 3 years ago
Que esquisito... D:
Legume666 3 years ago
earplugs. give me some.
haaaveyoumetted 3 years ago 2
i miss the opera in this song!!!!!
tht's y it was called opera metal to me
nd now i'm confused :(
b/c Mary just butchered a beautiful song
okayzzz 3 years ago 2
Mary needs to STAY AWAY from the old (and AMAZING b/c of Vibeke) Tristania songs!!!
firestarter507 3 years ago 4
horrid!
roguevalov 3 years ago 4
I Miss Vibeke....
c5mila 3 years ago 4
really sux!!!my favorite band.
彻底毁了！
notristania 3 years ago 3
The thing i loved about Vibeke was the haunting feel she gave to the music, she might have whispered a bit, but it made the music amazing!!
haaaveyoumetted 3 years ago
oh.my.god. this was one of my favourite tristania songs and she has murdered it!!!
haaaveyoumetted 3 years ago 2
youre right she is a horrible singer...why did vibeke leave? TT
Aphelion79123 3 years ago
Im not entirley sure why she left, but from what I've heard i think she wanted to be a singing teacher, i think thats why :/
haaaveyoumetted 3 years ago
vibeke left to teach singing, but there is a rumor that she had a baby boy in aug 07...
breathenomore0 3 years ago
no disagreement here either! Vibeke had a Renaissance quality to her voice, this new girl has no old quality. She's just screaming or she's making it less dark and more poppy...ick
DarkWolfen 3 years ago
ma poi ma che cazzo ti urli??ti sembra il modo di cantare questo? ma da dove le prendono ste cantantucole come lei o anette? andrà di moda bah....
ASTAROTH619 3 years ago
mariangela ma torna affanculo in sardegna! hai rovinato una delle mie ex ghotic metal band preferite!
ASTAROTH619 3 years ago
wtf?! mary doesn't know how to sing, she only screeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeams!
p.s.:am i wrong or can be heard playbacks of vibeke's voice in the chorus?
paty666 3 years ago 3
the should hire the girl from SINS OF THY BELOVED.
ImLordRevan 3 years ago
NO she sucks!
mytouniquet 3 years ago 3
U suck
ImLordRevan 3 years ago
pleeeeeeaaaaase
tell her not to scream!!!!
she supose to sing....
my god,I'm just having second thoughts to go tomorrow to see them.. ¬¬
actually..to see THIS...
I would cry!!!!
Keerfin 3 years ago
What a f...in shit...?! What did they do with this band?!
Sylphoe 3 years ago
they just killed it...
=(
Keerfin 3 years ago
Horrível, conseguio estragar a musica
tsotb2 3 years ago 2
OMG! She acts and sings just like laura Pauzini!
She´s not the kind of person for a gothic band.
vinsilfon 3 years ago 3
Have all the band members gotten DEAF??
I can't believe they "like" the way she "sings"!
She is horrible!!!
If they want to keep this creature in the banda, they should at least change the name of the band and respect the "gone TRISTANIA".
Rafathatha 3 years ago 3
All she has to do is extend her range to a HIGHER HEIGHT she may be able to sing some of the old stuff w/ a choir.........like the originals. ANyone w/ me?
xxxthoughtlessxxx 3 years ago
Well, if you consider that even if she extend her range she will be rejected by many fans o.O -people won't forget this u.uU- it would be difficult way for her.
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago
ohh Come one you cannot seriously say Mary sings thsi better than Vibeke?
mytouniquet 3 years ago
Yeah, xxxthoughtlessxxx is asking for much. Vibeke was a complete singer, she have the talent and the instrument.
If they get a new vocalist, at least a second one -a soprano or a mezzo ligera u.ú- they will be able to play the stuff that mary is unable to sing.
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago
You shouldn't be talking crap about me when in reality you can't sing Tristania for CRAP. In fact, Mary sings this killed song better than you do. :-) NOW, when did I EVER say she sings better than Vibeke?
xxxthoughtlessxxx 3 years ago
First o.o "when did I EVER say she sings better than Vibeke? " <-- that was a response to mytouniquet when she wrote about vibeke.
Second: "In fact, Mary sings this killed song better than you do. :-) " <-- ^^ Might be; It's ok for me.
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago
Oh my God, She sings horrible!!!!. Who told her that her voice was good.
Ignites 3 years ago 2
Um everybody that listens to her!
xxxthoughtlessxxx 3 years ago
Affeee
Rafathatha 3 years ago
I'm sorry she did good in other songs But just NOT this one she screams?
mytouniquet 3 years ago
Who knows O_O... when they did the casting there were amazing singers, I remember a soprano who has a beautiful and dark voice... she was in the ultimate selection ¬¬ don't know why she isn't the new singer; she was good looking, amazing voice, she speaks english @_@!! She was all they asked for!
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago
let me tell you that I have no words to add in the commentary because I identify with yours!
.the essence of this band is lost.
g4b4ri3l4 3 years ago
Well Vibeke was one of the most important parts of the band -yeah, even the most.- but Tristania has a particulary good sound, the new vocalist though... It would be a good idea to do a new casting, at least for get a second vocalist; a soprano or a mezzo ligera just for songs alike this, because Mariangela is unable to sing this ones, she just don't have the type of voice that is necessary and probably not the knowledge for :(
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago 2
Oh yeah! is nice see someone who thinks similar to me, I just was think this for Nightwish before, because Annette can't sing songs like 'Wishmaster' that sound bad in her voice... then with Tristania the situation is really bad if the old songs doesn't interpreted by a soprano vocalist :(
Sorcerytux 3 years ago 2
It's sad, isn't it? But Tristania don't say anything about this -the new vocalist option.- Anette? You think so? XD well I Think Tarja has a very pretty voice, I consider anette sing very well some songs -actually i like her wishmaster XD her: elbereeeieieieieiee XD it's a pretty fool but I like it XD; I prefer tarja's though XD.- Well we'll have to see what happen to tristania, We can just beg for a second voccalist -a new one would be impossible, wouldn't it?- ^^'
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago
Oh my God, She sings horrible!!!!. Who told her that her voice was good.
Ignites 3 years ago 3
Oh my GOD! What has happened to the fantastic band Tristania? :O I agree with that other guy who commented.. What the wildest hell were they thinking when choosing her? Out of, I don't know... Thousands of singers?
hermanessences 3 years ago 2
ai meus timpanos....grita mto essa guria..
pandorabrx 3 years ago 2
I was saying there was hope for Tristania on another video...but after earing some more new live...I'm simply desperate! Mari doesn't have even half presence and charism Vibeke have...and her voice...I will stay with my old Tristania albums.
VIBEKE WE MISS YOU!
S1nBl00d 3 years ago 2
Yes, we miss you!! Mari: "meow meow"
that sucks!!
bizzaramele 3 years ago 2
Yes, we miss you!! Mari: "meow meow"
that sucks!!
bizzaramele 3 years ago
I was saying there was hope for Tristania on another video...but after earing some more new live...I'm simply desperate! Mari doesn't have even half presence and charism Vibeke have...and her voice...I will stay with my old Tristania albums.
VIBEKE WE MISS YOU!
S1nBl00d 3 years ago 2
loooool,this is scary
namaria6666 4 years ago 4
Mari mi piace su molte canzoni, ma su questa proprio no.
Le hanno messo un compressore sotto che fa cacare.
arhat82 4 years ago
beh ma alla fine dai non è proprio tanto male...certo se era vibeke era un'altra storia, ma...dopotutto ha anche un'altra tonalità di voce...
imaginary92 4 years ago
Her voice doesn't fit at all with the song, maybe with Tristania too.
SANGREdeLYN 4 years ago
I like this interpretation actually. It one of my favourite songs and I was quite sure she would mess this song up. When she goes away from the mic you can hear her voice fits quite good to this song (I mean her voice from playback:D). If only she could sing instead of runing and screaming....
prosiaq1983 4 years ago 2
Lacuna Coil!??!!
OMG!!!!
I HATE!
jugmetal 4 years ago 2
i want vibeke back ={{{{{
pandorabrx 4 years ago 3
Vibeke is the best singer, we would never see her again in Tristania but... she will stay in all our tristania old cd's T_T!
SakumaRyuichiNG 4 years ago 4
U say it like if she died.
sinsofchrist 3 years ago
That's why I said "in tristania", I don't think she'd sing again with them. You might have taken it too literal.
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago
no not you.The other guy.Sorry for confusing you.:o
sinsofchrist 3 years ago
^^ It's all right.
SakumaRyuichiNG 3 years ago
She suck ;/ Horrible!
BlackSanctum 4 years ago 2
ok, i admit i don't really like her, especially if you compare her to vibeke, but...i'll be in sympathy with her, because she's italian like me....so...VAI MARIIIIII xD
imaginary92 4 years ago
Horrible new singer! O.o
lilaputavaga 4 years ago
singer? XD
SakumaRyuichiNG 4 years ago
Horrible new singer! O.o
lilaputavaga 4 years ago
omg sooo bad :S
mittti 4 years ago
vaya, me habia convencido cuando escuche su beyond the veil, pero esto decepciona tanto
soratajft 4 years ago
There comes a time when being different just goes too far. This doesn't work at all, in my honest opinion.
andyc225 4 years ago 2
she have the same voice that my cat auheaueh miauuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
pandorabrx 4 years ago 2
she sounds a little unsure about how to sing the old stuff, but i think she still sounds mostly good...just different from vib
cowluva 4 years ago
hahahha omg!!! What happened with these female-frotned bands?? She screams like a dying cat, it's so amateur LOL. It's too hard to find a girl that can sing metal nowadays and not sound like Shakira or Olivia Newton John.
Let alone a real metaller xD
JDarkMoon 4 years ago
she sings so bad in this song.. :S
TRISTITIA 4 years ago
And alll the others!
I think she has the power to ruin everything she touches, I mean, sings!
Rafathatha 3 years ago
she sings so bad in this song.. :S
TRISTITIA 4 years ago
she sings so bad in this song.. :S
TRISTITIA 4 years ago
OMG! I have nothing against Mary, but in this song she's like meowing or something ;P
Raisilwen 4 years ago
hey, its not that bad at all... it could have been worse, just try to accept her
Gabor1990 4 years ago
Please!!! you're acting like those blind Tarja fans
symphoniker666 4 years ago
I'm sorry, I can't help it. Mary's voice is just not what the fans of these bands are after. Tarja is also better than Anette. Ahem.
andyc225 4 years ago 2
This was supposed to be a reply to someone's post. Oh well.
andyc225 4 years ago
Just not the same with vibeke
mytouniquet 4 years ago
Just not the same with vibeke
mytouniquet 4 years ago
Just not the same with vibeke
mytouniquet 4 years ago
I prefer Angellore and Beyond the Veil... :)
Klaudhius 4 years ago
A "bitch", a "whore"? Who the hell believest thou are? Knowst thou only one thing about her? Tsssss
I agree she is screaming.. but This songs are for lyric voices.. she doth what she canst.. And 'tis pretty cool. I'd rather Vibeke to come back, but she wanth not. 'twill be the future of Tristania.. with or without thee
YYbubble 4 years ago
LOL...really bad :P
Mrjansen 4 years ago 3
It's horrible. She have no voice and move like in night club.
Please Vibeke come back ;(
ines1986 4 years ago 4
She act like a whore! Only choir helps her -_-
Anomell 4 years ago 2
That was a horrible rendition of the song. Mary may be good at her own style but she murders songs designed for Vibeke's voice
WorldOfGlass 4 years ago 6
omg. mary is horrible and act like a bitch!
drewniana321 4 years ago
Awesome!
drigometal86 4 years ago