Joy Division were a post-punk band, The Killers are a pop band and Carpathian were a hardcore band. They are obviously going to sound completely different. Shut the fuck if you don't like it and go any listen to another version.
Great job making an otherwise classic indie song mainstream as fuck. I applaud The Killers for at least trying to recreate the song with a sound that was in the same non-mainstream spirit as the original.
i'm looking for a lost Shadowplay cover i had on an old CD and stumbled across this. not weak at all, i fuckin love the instruments and the vocals aren't bad either. very energetic.
I feel no emotion at all coming from this song.....wow.... really dont like this cover. And people dare to dizz the killers version, which may be a bit more poppy than the original but sure kept more of it's soul than this one.
@JuanCarlosX007 this one adds soo much emotion! listen to him!
i dont wanna be dissing, but joy divisions singer, despite being a lyrical genius, just basically talked the lyrics... the drop tuned, shouted carpathian version does it so much more justice than the killers :)
hahaha people actually think this is a good cover? it's a slap in the face to Joy Division..
TheRealAndyCue 5 days ago
This is HOW is supposed to be done!
AmethystAnarchyAngel 1 month ago
Good good good good good good goodๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆๆ
jellylolita 1 month ago
Good cover!!!!
avk64 1 month ago in playlist Carpathian
awesome cover
efeee 1 month ago
Holy shit so good.
FatGreasyNerd 2 months ago
Nice
TheVenncat 3 months ago
fucking love this
TheDallywally13 3 months ago
Joy Division were a post-punk band, The Killers are a pop band and Carpathian were a hardcore band. They are obviously going to sound completely different. Shut the fuck if you don't like it and go any listen to another version.
blindestoftheblind 4 months ago
It was sounding good, until
he opened his mouth.
chiefmachine24 6 months ago
Fuck off s.e. discrimination, fuck off.
xROTTEDxBRAINx 7 months ago
good cover guys !
youcantkick 7 months ago
The Silversun Pickups version is amazing if you like acoustic.
Robobert731 7 months ago
@Robobert731 The Silversun Pickups lead vocalists has a whiney self deprecating style, what is there to like about that.
ralphbendix 2 months ago
The best cover of this song i've ever heard... Thank you!!!"
avk64 8 months ago
The baest cover of this song i've ever heard... Thank you!!!"
avk64 8 months ago
they ruined this song along with the killers. the song was better off not covered
kickrocks91 8 months ago
@kickrocks91 ruin it? they're expressing their love for joy division. seriously.
xamadeix 4 months ago
Ian Curtis would be happy to hear this. Rip.
xamadeix 10 months ago 6
@xamadeix I second that, Mate.
astimegoestoshow 10 months ago
Great job making an otherwise classic indie song mainstream as fuck. I applaud The Killers for at least trying to recreate the song with a sound that was in the same non-mainstream spirit as the original.
KingKombat95 11 months ago
@KingKombat95 your a goose.
MrAnderssen15 8 months ago
@KingKombat95 you're a goose and a half. you goose.
ixsavedxlatin 7 months ago
I like this song better when it sounds bleak, but this is better than the killers.
halfcabdisaster7 1 year ago
fuck you The Killers, this is how you do a cover
rocketsfalls 1 year ago 9
@rocketsfalls your actually kidding right...
xjohn2006 1 year ago
i'm looking for a lost Shadowplay cover i had on an old CD and stumbled across this. not weak at all, i fuckin love the instruments and the vocals aren't bad either. very energetic.
sparkpenguin 1 year ago
Have Heart shirt!
prahfit619 1 year ago 4
I feel no emotion at all coming from this song.....wow.... really dont like this cover. And people dare to dizz the killers version, which may be a bit more poppy than the original but sure kept more of it's soul than this one.
JuanCarlosX007 1 year ago
@JuanCarlosX007
fuck off emo boy
shanetones 1 year ago
@shanetones actually this style fits the Emo criteria better than The Killers. Check on Wikipedia faggot.
bp56789 1 year ago
@JuanCarlosX007 this one adds soo much emotion! listen to him!
i dont wanna be dissing, but joy divisions singer, despite being a lyrical genius, just basically talked the lyrics... the drop tuned, shouted carpathian version does it so much more justice than the killers :)
TheSkateboardingTaco 1 year ago 4
Weak ass cover of an otherwise masterful song.
surebetcom 1 year ago
@surebetcom Why do you think its weak?
0Chelsea0Smile0 1 year ago
@surebetcom
your a weak ass person
shanetones 1 year ago
God damn its a good cover
joshyhillbilly 1 year ago 24