Music is haraam! And television is haraam, and gaming is haraam, games are haraam brothers and sisters! Sex is haraam! Love is haraam! Enjoying things is haraam! LIFE IS HARAAM! Let's write a new Quran with even more rules and forbidden things.
@sufiwannabe music IS haram in islam....people have been murdered over it by muslims
yep...wife beating is a muslim male RIGHT as given by your dirty prick mohammed - he also INSTRUCTED penalty for non belief/leaving is MURDER
so dont lie....your childish taqiyaa doesnt wash with me
majority of people born into ummah are denied right to choose whether to be muslim or not,& islam has penalty of MURDER for criticising...that IS oppression/denial of human rights
this is a load of CAMEL SHIT!! and everybody knows this...i mean damn, you got pali muslim men having oral sex with black women everyday while claiming to be devout!! these same pali men cuss like pirates and drink hard vodka like the russians! these pali muslim men have videos praising hamas on they facebooks but yet these pali men run in fear of a black man! these pali muslim men cheat on they wives and praise honor killings and yet they say that they treat their wives like queens! BULLSHIT!
Subhanallah......There is a reason why music is haraam, not only does it take one away from the remembrance of allah, but it does also waste your time, and leads ones to astray..........We Muslims should luv what's lawful and hate what's unlawful.....and remember there is a reason why allah made it unlawful.
@Idilabdullahi utter NONSENSE...music is beautiful/therapeutic and exists even in nature
how SICK/DIRTY islam is when it regards music as a major sin...yet approves wife beating, oppression, mutilation of children, denial of human rights, MURDER for non belief
@Idilabdullahi so using right hemisphere of brain is haraam? I wonder if those people who claim they are being tempted by shaitan, just receive signals from the hemisphere they don't use, since they tied functions of understanding arts and music with sins.
Me myself by looking at these three hadiths i believe we should only listen to the song, Nasheed, Naats, Nohas that make us to be close to Almighty Allah, and always keep is to his rememberance doesn't matter if instrument included, but me myself often listen to Nasheed and music without Music.
This hadith may make it clear that not all music and not all instruments are haram:
1. Volume 5, Book 58, No.268:
Narrated Aisha: That once Abu Bakr came to her on the day of 'Eid-ul-Fitr or 'Eid ul Adha while the Prophet was with her and there were two girl singers with her, singing songs of the Ansar about the day of Buath. Abu Bakr said twice. "Musical instrument of Satan!" But the Prophet said: "Leave them Abu Bakr, for every nation has an Eid (i.e. festival) and this day is our EID
Can we agree that rules are supposed to be made clear? Not by a mile are there hadith or any ayat that states that music is forbidden. Perhaps God ran out of words and forgot to mention it? People keep quiting the hadith that states that "there will come a time where people will regard ...and the playing of instruments halal". This apparently refers to a rule that exists in Islam. But where is th rule? Where does God, or the hadith for that matter state clearly "music is forbidden for you"?
Their whole argumentation rests on the assumption that God is vague in rule making. When I read the Quran, it does not seem like God is ever vague. There is plenty "you shall not!" and "you most do" to be found in there. So why do their argument rest on the shoulder of stories that cannot be verified, when the Quran is silent on the matter. And why do they not see that what they are indirectly saying by this argument, is that God is vague.
esta5far ellah el azem , what are u talking about . im thinking about allah every sec , u are not a prophet to tell poeple about that they forgat allah , becouse i accutly thinking about hem all the time alhamdu lelah
so true masha Allah music is haram! for me music in nasheeds is ven worst than in songs because we mention Allahsubhnallah be carefull sisters and brothers!salam
Bukhari vol. IV, no. 537- Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet said, "If a house fly falls into the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (into the drink) because one of its wings has a disease and the other wing has the cure (for that disease) also in no.673
Book 028, Number 5610:
Sa'd reported Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) as saying: It is better for the belly of any one of you to be stuffed with pus rather than to stuff (one's mind) with poetry.
The Hadith Book 023, No. 5113-5120- Ibn Umar reported Allah's messenger as saying that a non-Muslim eats in seven intestines while a Muslim eats in one intestine (Sahih Muslim)
Book 023, Number 5038:
Ibn 'Abbas reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: When any one of you eats food he should not wipe his hand until he has licked it or got it licked by (someone else).Sahih Muslim
Bukhari vol. IV no. 516-"Satan stays in the upper part of the nose all night."
Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: None of you should drink while standing; and if anyone forgets, he must vomit. Muslim
and also:
The hadith-Muslim vol. 1, no. 863 Chapter CLXXIII-Abu Huraira reported Allah's Apostle saying: "People should avoid lifting their eyes towards the sky while supplicating in prayer, otherwise their eyes would be snatched away."
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Nonsense is all that i can say.......dont listen to this if you can......Listen to as much music as you want. If there is a god.....and If he is sitting somewhere to judge us on our actions......I am sure it is not based on whether we listen to music or not.....This is just nonsense.
that is my point. If you go out and commit open error like taking riba or commiting zina, then you have forgot Allah. If you listen to Madonna you have a terrible tastes in music. There is quite a difference, but people seem to be unable to spot it =/
Aasalamu aalejkum wa rahmetullahi wa barakatuhu, jazakAllahu khayran for this video, i just want to infor all that reads my message, music takes away your religion, correct me if i'm wrong but, ones Muhammed (SAW) saw the shaytaan, and he asked the shaytaan, how do you missguide my people? the shaytaan sayd to Muhammed (SAW) whenever your people listen to music they are coming towards me, and that is how i missguide them, and one more thing i hate music, nasheed is better
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
We respect allah.
We got kicked out of asda cause we asked them if they sold qurans, they said go to mosque, but we got kicked outta mosque because we had verucas. I hate you allah, you didnt let me get a quaran. GIVE ME A QUARAN OF I GET ACHMED TO KILL YOU.
was revealed in the form of a bell wich is a musical instrument. if u reaallli want to seek further knowledge on this topic, ther is a good scholar dr tahir ul qadri he has given a few talks bout this music being aloowed so u shud check it out i would like to end this comment with a question...ask yourself listening to naseeds with music does it take you closer to allah swt and the beloved muhammad saw or take you away...if it brings you closer then how can it be haraam....?
What are you talking about? Don't make up things..the Quran was revealed in a spand of 23 years and was not sent down in a book form..Brother or Sister please don't make up stuff! Jazkallah!
hi, i know there are hadith on music being haraam...but you have to look at the time of narration of hadith and to whom it was directed towards..there are many hadith on bad music being haraam..eg...talking bout stuff that is haraam...but to the best of my knowledge there is no hadith which states that music for a good cause is haraam. eg nasheeds and clean music. i know there was a saint in islam who converted 9 MILLIION people to islam just by playing music. i also know when the quran
This is music to commit suicide by, but muslims also use it when they are making love to their goats assholes. Some of Muslims favourite groups are called; Adolf Allah and his Nasty Nazi Nancy Boys, Abdul and the Turd Wranglers and Umma Cumma Uppa Your Bumma. They also love drag queens and any music with the words, baby, sex, f**k, cum,asshole,fudge, faggot and penis in the lyrics. The biggest muslim hit ever was called; "F-ALLAH-CY" sung to the tune of "Y.M.C.A".
Narrated Abu 'Amir (raa) or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari (raa) that he heard the Prophet (sallallaahu alayhi wa sallam) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks, and the use of musical instruments [ma'aazif] as lawful.
Who cares what Bukhari collected of lies about the Prophet? If you paid the same attention to the Quran you would know that Mohammad does NOT know the future or what will happen to us, thus the above is a lie, a blatant lie, exposed by the Quran. see 46:9, 7:188 and 6:50 (but also18:110, 5:109) And if scholars disagree with the above clear ayat and put more weight in Bukharis nonsense...well... .
So basically you think that God is bluffing, when the Quran states that it is fuly detailed (6:114, 17:89, 39:27, 39:28, 16:89, 7:52, 41:3, 6:126, 10:24, 30:28, 43:2-3, 44:2, 3:118) in all these verses we are told that the Quran is absolutely clear, unobscured, and FULLY DETAILED. But now you are telling me that this is a lie from God :( you are saying that it isnt really fully detailed, but that I have to follow bukhari aswell. Is the Quran fully detailed or is it not? it is streightforward
Salaam! there is no doubt in qurran. I think u dot know much about prophet muhammad. If prophet Mozez can covert stick into snake, and prophet Jesez can know what somone eat and save and give live to the dead person with the help of allah, then holly prophet Muhammad has combine qualities of all prophet, you have to belive in allah then qurran then prophet , angels, day of judgement and life after death then you believe(IMAN) will complete. Man there is difference between fully deatiled and lie
peace! But if the Quran is fully detailed, what is meant by that then, according to you? If it is fully detailed and it tells us to pray, we should just do so, and not be annoying like the jews annoyed Moses when he asked them to find a heifer. what color, what age...how many rakat, what movements. Is "PRAY!" not clear enough? If the Quran is fully detailed, then how come you tell me that I need to find the details on prayer outside of it?
now tell me any ayyat that you have to perform salt/prayer in this way,
who tells u that you have offer salt/prayer in this way, when fajar time start and when zohar, i dont know if u read qurran and perform salt/prayer which whay u adopt. If there is a book then there is also need a teacher and his notes to pass the exam. if u dont want to understand go on......
the time you should perform salat 11:114, 17:78 , 24:58 , 2:238 how you should clean yourself before salat 5:6, instructions on prohibitions regarding salat 4:43, how you should do 2:238, 17:110, 2:238; 3:39; 4:102, 4:102; 22:26; 38:24; 48:29, exceptions are found in 2:239. and there is much much more, but this is not enough detail?
Yes, u r right, but u did not answer my first question "The way to perform salat/prayer. I want to insure u that there is not only need of book but also a teacher which allah knows and he send holy prophet. there is only exact way of salt/prayer is present in kitab-ul-salt in buhari/muslim etc. but one last quest that " R U MUSLIM?"
I did answer you question and I provided relevant ayat. And then you go on to say that Allah is simply bluffing when he says that all those details I gave does not mean it is really fully detailed. I understand that there is a teacher, but our teacher is dead, it happened 1400 years ago, BUKHARIS collections of mumbojumbo, half truths and whole lies IS NOT our teacher! Our teacher left us with the message he was teaching around him. The Quran itself. The same Quran God calls fully detailed.
I m very glade to realise that u have good knowledge of Qurran. Now no prophet will come but what do u think his every walk of life which was unidue and greate wanish/lost, no man, that is imposible after 1400 years Qurran and his teaching saying and acts are also stictly followed and true. ther is also contradiction in ur talk, u realize half are truth. those who love ALLAH and prophet will write false HADIS? NO MAN NO
Or in the words of our teacher as found in the Quran itself : "shall i seek another source of law when God have given you his Quran in full detail?" ...Mohammad was also following the Quran, and that was because he believed it to be fully detailed. If the exact way of salat is really to be found outside the Quran, you still insist that Allah is simply bluffing. The Quran that Mohammad himself followed, is not fully detailed. You cannot have it both ways.
ALLAH tells in qurran about salt but he send his prophet to teach people that how to perform salt, yes Qurran is complete but why ALLAH send his prophet, and now he dead, so what do u think his teaching was only those people not for us? I think u need to first read the history of six books of HADIS, when all the things are varified then writter offer salt and then write the HADIS, it was not an easy task. because there is need greate care.
This is reversed logic. You look in the bookd that God calls "fully detailed", a book that has "nothing left out" and in which "nothing is obscured". In this book you cant find the kind of prayer that Bukhari and his interpreters have made for you, and then you conclude that the Quran is somehow not "fully detailed" and thus indirectly you are calling God a liar. Is The Quran fully detailed or is it not?
yor refrence are 100% correct, but you should not only read but also understand it, Your refrence is base on the Macci Surrah which came when Prophet Muhammad were in Macca, and it is directly to those who dont obey God, You find out those things which u like and do not pay attention on complete Qurran. I have revisit and verify you refrence, now tell me how can i obey prophet muhammad, qurran says Obey allah and hi prophet
Then quite obviously they are morons,. Music is NOT haram. This is nothing but bias on part of some scholars who have the nerve to pretend it is from God, when it is nothing but their personal biases.
you are saying that Bukhari is woring that why i m talking to u, music is small issue, u point out the qualities of prophet that he doen not know future, this is wrong he also know with the help of ALLAH
On whoms authority did Bukhari operate? ALLAH's OWN BOOK states that the prophet does not know the future, so why are we having this debate. That was...GODS BOOK states that Mohammad do not know what will happen to any of us. Why is this not clear enough for you? What other books do you have that you read? do you find everything in it that you want?
Give me exact refrence that allah says in qurran prophet dont know the future. when moses has power and prophet Jesis has power then why Prophet muhammad.
even i listen 2 music but i no its haram and inshalla i stop soon if im alive. and may allah forgive me if i die.
and prophet mohammad pbuh said its haram several times. yes its haram i have not saw 1 scholar who said its halal and if dey did say it den dere wrong.
type in dr zakir naik music, and he will tell u its haram as well so will most of the other scholars/lectures/ sheikh feiz/khalid yasin.
Why would God give us a taste for music and then say it's Haram? which he didn't it's not said in the quran. He said Idle talk which can be anything misguiding and singing but not instrumental.
lmfao wot r u on? r u on crack how can u say why wud god give us music den say its haram astagfrilla
why did god give us the knowledge to kill some 1 if its haram , or give us alchohol if its haram or give us zina or other sins. because its a test, wen u listen 2 music u think lifes nufin, if moves u away its shaitarn ive shown u hadiths (sayin of the prophet pbuh) ive shown u quran verse idk if the quran verse is talkin about it but the hadiths state its haram so it is. r u a shia?
r u a shia? cos shias dont even accept hadiths dey just accept quran and say its got 10 spara missin or sum tink or pages lol if ur a shia stop talking 2 me lol no effence looool just leave me alone i tryed 2 help u if u not guna accept the truth den w.e
Even when we said the Hadith is Sahih, there are questions that would emerge when we study the version of the Hadith when it says, "People will make adultery, pure silk, liquor and Ma'azif into Halal." We know that adultery is Haram by another proof and it is a unanimous Hukum. Pure silk is not of consensus Hukum. If a Muslim says Zina is Halal deliberately, then they are considered a kafir. However, if a Muslim says pure silk is not Haram, he is not a kafir.
We know that liquor is Haram as it is in the Qur'an, but where do we find an authentic hadith or Qur'an to tell us that Ma'azif are Haram other than this source. The last point is to get the clear meaning of Ma'azif in arabic dictionaries because there are more than one meaning for Ma'azif. It is acceptable for a Muslim to hear somebody says Makruh but not Haram because Haram is in need of clear-cut meaning and certain narration."
lol wot r u talking about i just showed u 2-3 hadiths about music being haram and ur sayin were do we find a hadith dat music is haram and i showed u verse from quran.
music is haram 100% i listen to it but i try not to and may allah forgive me but least i no its haram u listen to it and u still think its not haram.
What i meant is that Islam is one Islam right? Music has a great controversial issue, SOME allowed it SOME forbid it. BUT why would Allah confuse us? So you believe it's Haram I don't. I don't really think that Quran verse was about music because it's still confusing. Once again why would allah confuse us? Why just not say it straight away? So yes looks like there is more than one Islam these days -we agreed to disagree.
wana no why music is haram u dont even need hadiths or quran if u had a brain u wud see this. ( im not insulting u ).
i use to read namaz abit and go mosque wen i wuz 11 but den i stopped n listenined 2 music and i went astray abit.
and now age 15 i read 5 times namaz i gave music up etc. but now im 16, and i listen 2 music again and i read 5 times pray but i dont read sunats no more, its shaitarn, music gets to u and it makes u go astray. its shaitarn i no its hard to stop listenin to it,
First I listen to music o Thank Allah my faith is great. Second, you still don't know what kind of music I listen to. I don't listen to those who tempt you do sin. I listen to the melody of a soul. I DID get insulted. it's as if you're telling me you cannot think when I have thought about it for so long, i didn't just wake up some morning and say ;oh music can't be haram!'. I did not.
Narrated Abu 'Amir (raa) or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari (raa) that he heard the Prophet (sallallaahu alayhi wa sallam) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks, and the use of musical instruments [ma'aazif] as lawful.
There is a general rule in Shariah that states that everything is lawful unless proven unlawful. There is not substantial proof in this hadîths because of the following reasons:
Sheikh Muhammad Al-Hanuti stated: "The Hadith referred to in saying that it is haram as narrated by al Bukhari is not fulfilling the requirements of the Sahih in al Bukhari's collection.
1) Al Bukhari in Hadith al Ma'azif himself narrated the Hadith to be of a broken chain of narrators in which there is a gap between al Bukhari and the second narrator, so he drops the first narrator in his chain. That is called Mu'allaq. Some scholars tried to connect the chain through other means like whan ibn Hajar did in his dissertation (connecting what is disconnected) in which he connected the Isnad of this Hadith.
But still, one of the main narrators whose name is Hisham ibn Ammar as profiled in Tahthib at-Tahthib by ibn Hajar is not reliable enough for some scholars to be a source of a narration that depends on somebody like him.
Look, it's only haraam in the narrowest and strictest interpretation of the Quran. I'm a Muslim who happens to listen to music, pray five times a day, performs Ramadan fasting and I have the Khalima in my heart. So, did music really turn me away from my faith?
Before you blast me, remember what our faith teaches us: Not to be critical of our fellow brothers and sisters. If you call yourselves decent Muslims, you should respect my opinion.
You don't understand. Music is every freakin' sound around you you cannot say it's Haram. So let's see, hmm. If music is Haram then Birds are Haram, we should kill them they keep us from praying. Also, reading Quran is Haram now 'cause it's yet another kind of music, oh what else? The blowing wind is Haram too 'cause you know Music is Haram!
Life is nothing without music. There used to be music in the mosque of Rassul Allah.
All my life whenever I was told something was Haram I used to think it through not directly believe it because Not ALL Hadith is Saheeh. Face it, you can't kill music.
It's a gift, you can't take it away from the worshipers of God.
Also, the Hadith you provided is Mo'alak. It means it may not even be true.
Quran is the only source of law, AND IF MUSIC IS HARAM ALLAH WOULD HAVE SAID SO IN HIS QURAAN WITH NO CONFUSION! Why would he cofuse us so we fall in sin? MUSIC IS LIFE, make use of it.
[31.6] But there are, among men, those who purchase idle tales, without knowledge (or meaning), to mislead (men) from the Path of God and throw ridicule (on the Path): for such there will be a Humiliating Penalty.
wot is music? its idle tales u idiot. listen to all dese kufrs on rap and stuff talkin bout jesus and stuff its idol talk and its haram. all music insterments except from the drum is haram.
Why first of all I am not an idiot. Obviously I'm a person looking for knowledge. Second, You are not Allah, you cannot really take this one verse and consider idle talk singing. Idle talk can be anything meaningless AND YOU DO NOT KNOW THE KIND OF MUSIC I LISTEN TO. my music isn't idle talk.
You only say that qurran is enough you do not have other thing, now tell me then why ALLAH send 24 hundred thousend prophet in this world. If the book is enough then there is no need of teacher.
and where Qurran says Music is HALLAL.
ha! there is no doubt in qurran, what do u think u can understand qurran, this is not the word of any person, this is word of God, thats why allah send his prophet that he describe the qurran and increase the Iman.
Do you think YOU can understand Quran? God said do not rush to understand. 'Idle Talk' does not mean music. I do not want to repeat myself, but if you wish to forbid GOD'S great grace of music he gave this world then go ahead. You lose, after all.
Abu Hurayrah narrated that Muhammad said group of this nation will be transformed into monkeys and pigs." They said, "Do not they testify that there is no god except Allaah & that Muhammed is His Messenger?" He said "Yes & also they fast pray & perform Hajj." They said "Then, what is their problem?" He said "They use musical instruments drums & female singers. they will go to sleep after a night of drinking & having fun, In the morning, they will be changed into monkeys & pigs."
dawah, one of the disbelievers amongst the Quraish would quickly assemble a group of dancers and singers in order to misguide the people from the path of Allah subhana wa ta'alaa. Ibn Masood, who was one of the Companions of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa salaam said, that indeed this verse was regarding the music.
speak of that which you know with certainty. Allah subhana wa ta'alaa said in Surah 17:36-Speak not of that which you have no knowledge of. Verily the hearing and sight and the heart will be questioned.-Now as regards to music in the Quran, please open your Noble Quran to Surah 31 V 1-6 talks specifically about those who purchase idle talks and the reason of the revelation of this verse is due to the fact that during the time of the Prophet sallahu alayhi wa salaam when he would go out to give
"And do not say lies for what your tongues describes: this is lawful (HALAL), and that is unlawful (HARAM), to lie about God. Those who lie about God will never succeed. They will have small pleasures (on Earth), AND FOR THEM IS A PAINFUL RETRIBUTION" (16/116-117) "Say 'Do you see that which God has provided for you, you make some of it Unlawful (Haram) and some of it Lawful (Halal)?. Say 'Did God allow you to do this? Or do you tell lies about God?" (10/59)
is halal and base their opinion solely on their desires rather than following a clear text from either the hadith of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa salaam and/or a clear text from the Quran. Further, it is important before you give your comment my dear bro in Islam, about whether music was addressed in the Quran or not one should first seek knowledge and then
First to zyka1: Jazkallah Khairn my brother in Islam for trying to get the attention of the muslims and directing them towards following that which Allah subhanah wa ta'alaa and His Messenger sallahu alayhee wa salaam ordered us to follow. Likewise jazakallah khairn for directing the attention of the muslims and reminding them of those acts that are forbidden of which music is one of them. Now, I would like to direct some thoughts and advice to those among the commentators who believe that music
for my stupid opinion,depend to the subject of music,is a matter of a fact who often instrumental music go with immoral text in 99/100 of cases,and this is haram,but when we read an hadith we have see if this hadith confirm something who is writed in coran,but i think who a true hadith cant make a rule more than coran like in this case,may allah accept my good faith in what i say.amin
dont confuse yourself with some saudi's fatwas. Our ears like to hear beautiful sound and that is called fitrah. If i play my guitar and make me forget to perform solat that is haram but still the same if you watch cartoon or plyaing PS in your house and forget to perform solat
when i say our ears like to hear beautiful sound that does not mean only music. SOme of us like to hear the sound of birds. It general. You are the one who said you like to see opposite sex not me. Our eyes like to see beautiful scene like sunset, tree beautiful picture and other things. Please dont confuse yourself. What is haram is haram. What is halal is halal.
When i said i play guitar and piano, that does not mean i play it becoz i want to performe at live stage or concert. I just play it. I repeat I just play it. There is obvious in quran saying that you must control you eyes from looking something that will make us do sinful act.
When I mentioned saudi fatwa not becoz i said all the fatwa is wrong. For example they issued a fatwa on drug which said drug is haram. How can you said that. Most of our hospital including in muslim world used drug. Now it comes to our mind, Drugs or misuse of drugs. Which one is considered haram. That why we need fatwa. Same goes to music. Is it music itself considered as haram or the act associates with music is haram.
Other example is on nasheed praising our prophet. Most our saudi brothers considered it as syirik becoz they said you can not praising prophet as he is a god. But once again i cannot agree. Becoz what? because syirik comes from our state of mind. When we sing about our prophet we dont sing to pray something or to demand something from him. It alway if i need a help i pray to Allah.
but the hadith mentioned in the video is from sahih bukhari, how can you still argue when in it the Messenger SAW gives a clear indication on the status of music by mentioning it with known sins.
Ok i will bring you some hadis for you to consider. I'm not tell you about the hadis becoz i want you to do something with music but i'm sick when people always tell this is haram, this is halal, this is syirik when it comes to certain issue which does not has any accurate dalil like what happen in Mecca long time ago when some muslim scholar said that using speaker in Masjidil Haram was Haram
singing is haram, please stop kidding yourself...and singing to praise the prophet is also haram, it can be considered a form of reverence of the prophet. Please note that the prophet is not to be revered, only Allah (S) is, all praise belongs to Allah. The Prophet was simply a righteous man who brought forth Allah's message, but it is Allah (S) who is to be praised because of it. And not by singing, but by prayers and fasting, hajj, etc.
SO in solat dont you ever said a single word about Prophet. Dont you ever praise prophet muhammad in solat. If praising muhammad is allowed during pray, hajj and fasting what is the problem if i want to praise him outside from that. If you dont know about usul fiqh so dont say a single word about halal and haram. Dont say something you dont know.
I have heard and read hadis on music and most of them are dhaif. I play guitar and piano in my room. Not a problem with that. The problem is when you playing music associate with alcohol, women and other things. For clear picture most concerts and live performance held by western singers were considered haram. But if i want to play my ESP electric guitar in my room and hear some metallica songs who can stop me
I truly agree with u 4 what u have said but i find this confusing...
The Brothers and sisters who sing nasheeds with Musical Instruments they must know that musical Instruments r haram however they still do-786, Native Deen, etc. Their intentions r good as they want to spread Islam as most people nowadays listen 2 R&B hip hop etc. Just to get their attention and know Islam better. U c where I'm coming from?
But thank u 4 making this video. May Allah reward u, insha'Allah.
Aslam alkum do you know where i can download MP3 english nasheeds without music inshallah if so pleaseleave a comment on my channel inshallah and may allah bless you and protect you ameen
1 Sing joyfully to the Lord, you righteous; it is fitting for the upright to praise him. 2 Praise the Lord with the harp; make music to him on the ten-stringed lyre. 3 Sing to him a new song; play skillfully, and shout for joy. 4 For the word of the Lord is right and true; he is faithful in all he does. 5 The Lord loves righteousness and justice; the earth is full of his unfailing love.
so even like for example rap song that rap about islam would something like that be haram and if so how do u stop yourself from listin 2 music werever u go ders music on the streets when u go into a shop even sometimes in elavators
Aishah narrated that during the days of Mina, on the day of 'Eid al-Adha, two girls were with her, singing and playing on a hand drum. The Prophet (peace be on him) was present, listening to them with his head under a shawl. Abu Bakr then entered and scolded the girls. The Prophet (peace be on him), uncovering his face, told him, "Let them be, Abu Bakr. These are the days of 'Eid." (Reported by al-Bukhari and Muslim.)
using voice to make a bass sound, add some beatboxing, mix with singing, it still haram?
I'm confuse, we like to eat tasty food with our mouth, we like to watch beautiful things with our eyes, and we like to hear a great sound with our ears, everything is nikmat from Allah SWT
if they have musical instruments then i dont think it makes them 100% halal, also nasheeds with music is definately better than the songs of the kufar, but the same time the instruments get in the way and all...
"And of mankind is he who purchases idle talk to mislead (men) from the Path of Allaah, without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allaah, the Verses of the Qur'aan) by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment (in the Hell-fire)." [Luqmaan 31:6]
only 'Duf' is allowed during marriage ceremony, Eid, and Walima. Yes, music is described with gambling, drinking and this hadith is in the famous hadith book the MUSNAD, IMAM AHMAD BIN HAMBAL Vol. 2 pg 165 published by MAKTAB E ISLAMI BERUIT.
Narrated Aisha: Abu Bakr came to my house while two small Ansari girls were singing beside me the stories of the Ansar concerning the Day of Buath. And they were not singers. Abu Bakr said protestingly, "Musical instruments of Satan in the house of Allah's Apostle !" It happened on the 'Id day and Allah's Apostle said, "O Abu Bakr! There is an 'Id for every nation and this is our 'Id."
Most of the scholars interpreted lahw al-hadeeth ("idle talk") as meaning singing and musical instruments, and every voice that diverts people from the truth.
Al-Tabari (Jaami' al-Bayaan, 15/118-119), Ibn Abi'l-Dunya (Dham al-Malaahi, 33) and Ibn al-Jawzi (Talbees Iblees, 232) all reported that concerning the aayah (interpretation of the meaning):
"[Allaah said to Shaytaan;] 'And istafziz [literally means befool them gradually] those whom you can with your voice, make assaults on them with your cavalry and your infantry, mutually share with them wealth and children, and make promises to them.' But Shaytaan promises them nothing but deceit" [al-Isra' 17:64]
i have been a dedicated musician. Four years I have played guitar, I'm 17 and it has been a part of my life this amazing gift. I'm not boasting but I am exceptional at writing songs and I am a multi-instrumentalist. I'm a musician you know? So, for a musician to become a Muslim, would so tough coz I'm saying goodbye to something. My family, particularly my dad, would be heart-broken. He'd never get over it. Ive bin tryna get a music course oppurnity at college n i finally got it coz bad GCSEs :(
you know wah annoys me when people know this that music is haram and they make excuses to cover it up by putting sand in your eyes so people MUSIC IS HARAM HARAM HARAM!!! i been trying to get this in alot of peoples headsif you dont follow the prophets sunnah and words why do you call yourself muslim when you deny the prophets words Peace/saalam alaykum :)
well,first off,not all scholars agree with u thatall music is haram.some believe that it is only wind andstring instruments that we cannot listen to, while soem are like u. and i would like that hadith that you'reso called saying that the prophet said that all music is haram.iheard the hadithof the one with the kid playing awind istrument but which one are u talking about.so next time u say something, please dont question our iman, and if ur iman was so strong,u wud stay awayfrom socalled haram.
Music is haraam! And television is haraam, and gaming is haraam, games are haraam brothers and sisters! Sex is haraam! Love is haraam! Enjoying things is haraam! LIFE IS HARAAM! Let's write a new Quran with even more rules and forbidden things.
Didac1111 8 months ago
@sufiwannabe music IS haram in islam....people have been murdered over it by muslims
yep...wife beating is a muslim male RIGHT as given by your dirty prick mohammed - he also INSTRUCTED penalty for non belief/leaving is MURDER
so dont lie....your childish taqiyaa doesnt wash with me
majority of people born into ummah are denied right to choose whether to be muslim or not,& islam has penalty of MURDER for criticising...that IS oppression/denial of human rights
proudfemale 9 months ago
this is a load of CAMEL SHIT!! and everybody knows this...i mean damn, you got pali muslim men having oral sex with black women everyday while claiming to be devout!! these same pali men cuss like pirates and drink hard vodka like the russians! these pali muslim men have videos praising hamas on they facebooks but yet these pali men run in fear of a black man! these pali muslim men cheat on they wives and praise honor killings and yet they say that they treat their wives like queens! BULLSHIT!
peanuts8 11 months ago
what is the name of the first nasheed in this video at 0:30 ?
522365 1 year ago
@522365
SANAKHUDU
afghangangster4life 1 year ago
Subhanallah......There is a reason why music is haraam, not only does it take one away from the remembrance of allah, but it does also waste your time, and leads ones to astray..........We Muslims should luv what's lawful and hate what's unlawful.....and remember there is a reason why allah made it unlawful.
Idilabdullahi 1 year ago
@Idilabdullahi utter NONSENSE...music is beautiful/therapeutic and exists even in nature
how SICK/DIRTY islam is when it regards music as a major sin...yet approves wife beating, oppression, mutilation of children, denial of human rights, MURDER for non belief
proudfemale 1 year ago 3
@Idilabdullahi alright if thats ur reason art in general should be haraam.
niggerfuckshitreborn 1 year ago
@Idilabdullahi so using right hemisphere of brain is haraam? I wonder if those people who claim they are being tempted by shaitan, just receive signals from the hemisphere they don't use, since they tied functions of understanding arts and music with sins.
idosermaniac99 1 year ago
I hope Allah guide me and make me stop playing or listening music, ameen sumaameen !
luvdrumming 2 years ago
@luvdrumming there is no allah...and you have been lied to
islam shows how SICK it is when people are so deprived/taught that music is a sin
grow up...listen to music and enjoy
proudfemale 1 year ago
Very beautiful video, and InshaAllah i will stop listening to music , and u pray for me to stop listening musics ans stuff..
THx
Ashrockstar14 2 years ago
Music is not haram. Demonstrate clear ayat if what you state is truthful.
fucknuaf 2 years ago
*Nasheed and Naat without Music, mistake Apology
milaad123 2 years ago
This is the other hadith about the instruments of Abu Musa:
Vol 6, Book 61, No. 568;
Narrated Abu Musa: That the Prophet said to him "O Abu Musa! You have been given one of the musical wind-instrument of the family of David".
milaad123 2 years ago
Me myself by looking at these three hadiths i believe we should only listen to the song, Nasheed, Naats, Nohas that make us to be close to Almighty Allah, and always keep is to his rememberance doesn't matter if instrument included, but me myself often listen to Nasheed and music without Music.
milaad123 2 years ago
This hadith may make it clear that not all music and not all instruments are haram:
1. Volume 5, Book 58, No.268:
Narrated Aisha: That once Abu Bakr came to her on the day of 'Eid-ul-Fitr or 'Eid ul Adha while the Prophet was with her and there were two girl singers with her, singing songs of the Ansar about the day of Buath. Abu Bakr said twice. "Musical instrument of Satan!" But the Prophet said: "Leave them Abu Bakr, for every nation has an Eid (i.e. festival) and this day is our EID
milaad123 2 years ago
Can we agree that rules are supposed to be made clear? Not by a mile are there hadith or any ayat that states that music is forbidden. Perhaps God ran out of words and forgot to mention it? People keep quiting the hadith that states that "there will come a time where people will regard ...and the playing of instruments halal". This apparently refers to a rule that exists in Islam. But where is th rule? Where does God, or the hadith for that matter state clearly "music is forbidden for you"?
fucknuaf 2 years ago
Their whole argumentation rests on the assumption that God is vague in rule making. When I read the Quran, it does not seem like God is ever vague. There is plenty "you shall not!" and "you most do" to be found in there. So why do their argument rest on the shoulder of stories that cannot be verified, when the Quran is silent on the matter. And why do they not see that what they are indirectly saying by this argument, is that God is vague.
fucknuaf 2 years ago
esta5far ellah el azem , what are u talking about . im thinking about allah every sec , u are not a prophet to tell poeple about that they forgat allah , becouse i accutly thinking about hem all the time alhamdu lelah
mahmoudnij 2 years ago
wot?
fucknuaf 2 years ago
please please tell me the name of the nasheed that is being played thru the video thanks bro :)
telescopeisa1 2 years ago
so true masha Allah music is haram! for me music in nasheeds is ven worst than in songs because we mention Allahsubhnallah be carefull sisters and brothers!salam
beingniqabi 2 years ago
JAZAKALLAH KHAIRAN
abudujana13 2 years ago
im about as far away from being muslimas you can get but i do have to say arabic is seriously a beautiful language it blows my mind
dapuman 2 years ago
alhamdulillah
wildrider100 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
/watch?v=_MkA1UeHi_4&feature=related
JESUS CHRIST THE LORD !!!!
bojan5315 2 years ago
jesus is just a prophect , he is not a god or a child of the god
mahmoudnij 2 years ago 2
Muhammad also taught:
Bukhari vol. IV, no. 537- Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet said, "If a house fly falls into the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (into the drink) because one of its wings has a disease and the other wing has the cure (for that disease) also in no.673
Book 028, Number 5610:
Sa'd reported Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) as saying: It is better for the belly of any one of you to be stuffed with pus rather than to stuff (one's mind) with poetry.
snnicky 2 years ago 4
he also taught:
The Hadith Book 023, No. 5113-5120- Ibn Umar reported Allah's messenger as saying that a non-Muslim eats in seven intestines while a Muslim eats in one intestine (Sahih Muslim)
Book 023, Number 5038:
Ibn 'Abbas reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: When any one of you eats food he should not wipe his hand until he has licked it or got it licked by (someone else).Sahih Muslim
Bukhari vol. IV no. 516-"Satan stays in the upper part of the nose all night."
snnicky 2 years ago 2
Muhammad taught this and also:
Book 023, Number 5022:
Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: None of you should drink while standing; and if anyone forgets, he must vomit. Muslim
and also:
The hadith-Muslim vol. 1, no. 863 Chapter CLXXIII-Abu Huraira reported Allah's Apostle saying: "People should avoid lifting their eyes towards the sky while supplicating in prayer, otherwise their eyes would be snatched away."
snnicky 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Nonsense is all that i can say.......dont listen to this if you can......Listen to as much music as you want. If there is a god.....and If he is sitting somewhere to judge us on our actions......I am sure it is not based on whether we listen to music or not.....This is just nonsense.
arshidp 2 years ago
music make u forgott allah and thing u have to do
mahmoudnij 2 years ago
Perhaps music makes YOU forget Allah. I have no such problem. I am not going to take precautions in my own life just because you are weak in spirit.
fucknuaf 2 years ago
@fucknuaf im listen to music but i never forget allah , im parying 5 days in the day , every day
mahmoudnij 2 years ago
that is my point. If you go out and commit open error like taking riba or commiting zina, then you have forgot Allah. If you listen to Madonna you have a terrible tastes in music. There is quite a difference, but people seem to be unable to spot it =/
fucknuaf 2 years ago
@fucknuaf i mean 5 times
mahmoudnij 2 years ago
Aasalamu aalejkum wa rahmetullahi wa barakatuhu, jazakAllahu khayran for this video, i just want to infor all that reads my message, music takes away your religion, correct me if i'm wrong but, ones Muhammed (SAW) saw the shaytaan, and he asked the shaytaan, how do you missguide my people? the shaytaan sayd to Muhammed (SAW) whenever your people listen to music they are coming towards me, and that is how i missguide them, and one more thing i hate music, nasheed is better
UQK24 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
We respect allah.
We got kicked out of asda cause we asked them if they sold qurans, they said go to mosque, but we got kicked outta mosque because we had verucas. I hate you allah, you didnt let me get a quaran. GIVE ME A QUARAN OF I GET ACHMED TO KILL YOU.
Jessbabee09 2 years ago
was revealed in the form of a bell wich is a musical instrument. if u reaallli want to seek further knowledge on this topic, ther is a good scholar dr tahir ul qadri he has given a few talks bout this music being aloowed so u shud check it out i would like to end this comment with a question...ask yourself listening to naseeds with music does it take you closer to allah swt and the beloved muhammad saw or take you away...if it brings you closer then how can it be haraam....?
glesgaplayerz 2 years ago
What are you talking about? Don't make up things..the Quran was revealed in a spand of 23 years and was not sent down in a book form..Brother or Sister please don't make up stuff! Jazkallah!
OmarChannel 2 years ago
Ask your self this...If a nasheed or music is taking you far away from the Qur'an how can't it be Haram?
OmarChannel 2 years ago
hi, i know there are hadith on music being haraam...but you have to look at the time of narration of hadith and to whom it was directed towards..there are many hadith on bad music being haraam..eg...talking bout stuff that is haraam...but to the best of my knowledge there is no hadith which states that music for a good cause is haraam. eg nasheeds and clean music. i know there was a saint in islam who converted 9 MILLIION people to islam just by playing music. i also know when the quran
glesgaplayerz 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is music to commit suicide by, but muslims also use it when they are making love to their goats assholes. Some of Muslims favourite groups are called; Adolf Allah and his Nasty Nazi Nancy Boys, Abdul and the Turd Wranglers and Umma Cumma Uppa Your Bumma. They also love drag queens and any music with the words, baby, sex, f**k, cum,asshole,fudge, faggot and penis in the lyrics. The biggest muslim hit ever was called; "F-ALLAH-CY" sung to the tune of "Y.M.C.A".
throbule 2 years ago
Sahih Al-Bukhari Volume 7, Book 69, hadith #494v
Narrated Abu 'Amir (raa) or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari (raa) that he heard the Prophet (sallallaahu alayhi wa sallam) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks, and the use of musical instruments [ma'aazif] as lawful.
ishybadboy 2 years ago
Who cares what Bukhari collected of lies about the Prophet? If you paid the same attention to the Quran you would know that Mohammad does NOT know the future or what will happen to us, thus the above is a lie, a blatant lie, exposed by the Quran. see 46:9, 7:188 and 6:50 (but also18:110, 5:109) And if scholars disagree with the above clear ayat and put more weight in Bukharis nonsense...well... .
fucknuaf 2 years ago
Oh man! Qurran also tells us about prayer (salat) but hadit of prophit muhammad tells us the way to perform the prayer(salt), so care about it man.
sohail0399 2 years ago
So basically you think that God is bluffing, when the Quran states that it is fuly detailed (6:114, 17:89, 39:27, 39:28, 16:89, 7:52, 41:3, 6:126, 10:24, 30:28, 43:2-3, 44:2, 3:118) in all these verses we are told that the Quran is absolutely clear, unobscured, and FULLY DETAILED. But now you are telling me that this is a lie from God :( you are saying that it isnt really fully detailed, but that I have to follow bukhari aswell. Is the Quran fully detailed or is it not? it is streightforward
fucknuaf 2 years ago
Salaam! there is no doubt in qurran. I think u dot know much about prophet muhammad. If prophet Mozez can covert stick into snake, and prophet Jesez can know what somone eat and save and give live to the dead person with the help of allah, then holly prophet Muhammad has combine qualities of all prophet, you have to belive in allah then qurran then prophet , angels, day of judgement and life after death then you believe(IMAN) will complete. Man there is difference between fully deatiled and lie
sohail0399 2 years ago
peace! But if the Quran is fully detailed, what is meant by that then, according to you? If it is fully detailed and it tells us to pray, we should just do so, and not be annoying like the jews annoyed Moses when he asked them to find a heifer. what color, what age...how many rakat, what movements. Is "PRAY!" not clear enough? If the Quran is fully detailed, then how come you tell me that I need to find the details on prayer outside of it?
fucknuaf 2 years ago
now tell me any ayyat that you have to perform salt/prayer in this way,
who tells u that you have offer salt/prayer in this way, when fajar time start and when zohar, i dont know if u read qurran and perform salt/prayer which whay u adopt. If there is a book then there is also need a teacher and his notes to pass the exam. if u dont want to understand go on......
sohail0399 2 years ago
the time you should perform salat 11:114, 17:78 , 24:58 , 2:238 how you should clean yourself before salat 5:6, instructions on prohibitions regarding salat 4:43, how you should do 2:238, 17:110, 2:238; 3:39; 4:102, 4:102; 22:26; 38:24; 48:29, exceptions are found in 2:239. and there is much much more, but this is not enough detail?
fucknuaf 2 years ago
Yes, u r right, but u did not answer my first question "The way to perform salat/prayer. I want to insure u that there is not only need of book but also a teacher which allah knows and he send holy prophet. there is only exact way of salt/prayer is present in kitab-ul-salt in buhari/muslim etc. but one last quest that " R U MUSLIM?"
sohail0399 2 years ago
I did answer you question and I provided relevant ayat. And then you go on to say that Allah is simply bluffing when he says that all those details I gave does not mean it is really fully detailed. I understand that there is a teacher, but our teacher is dead, it happened 1400 years ago, BUKHARIS collections of mumbojumbo, half truths and whole lies IS NOT our teacher! Our teacher left us with the message he was teaching around him. The Quran itself. The same Quran God calls fully detailed.
fucknuaf 2 years ago
I m very glade to realise that u have good knowledge of Qurran. Now no prophet will come but what do u think his every walk of life which was unidue and greate wanish/lost, no man, that is imposible after 1400 years Qurran and his teaching saying and acts are also stictly followed and true. ther is also contradiction in ur talk, u realize half are truth. those who love ALLAH and prophet will write false HADIS? NO MAN NO
sohail0399 2 years ago
Or in the words of our teacher as found in the Quran itself : "shall i seek another source of law when God have given you his Quran in full detail?" ...Mohammad was also following the Quran, and that was because he believed it to be fully detailed. If the exact way of salat is really to be found outside the Quran, you still insist that Allah is simply bluffing. The Quran that Mohammad himself followed, is not fully detailed. You cannot have it both ways.
fucknuaf 2 years ago
ALLAH tells in qurran about salt but he send his prophet to teach people that how to perform salt, yes Qurran is complete but why ALLAH send his prophet, and now he dead, so what do u think his teaching was only those people not for us? I think u need to first read the history of six books of HADIS, when all the things are varified then writter offer salt and then write the HADIS, it was not an easy task. because there is need greate care.
sohail0399 2 years ago
This is reversed logic. You look in the bookd that God calls "fully detailed", a book that has "nothing left out" and in which "nothing is obscured". In this book you cant find the kind of prayer that Bukhari and his interpreters have made for you, and then you conclude that the Quran is somehow not "fully detailed" and thus indirectly you are calling God a liar. Is The Quran fully detailed or is it not?
fucknuaf 2 years ago
This is not reverse logic, i first read and understand qurran then Hadis.
how can you understand the life of Prophet muhammad.
sohail0399 2 years ago
The Quran? or perhaps God left out details of the book in which there is no doubt? o_0
fucknuaf 2 years ago
yor refrence are 100% correct, but you should not only read but also understand it, Your refrence is base on the Macci Surrah which came when Prophet Muhammad were in Macca, and it is directly to those who dont obey God, You find out those things which u like and do not pay attention on complete Qurran. I have revisit and verify you refrence, now tell me how can i obey prophet muhammad, qurran says Obey allah and hi prophet
sohail0399 2 years ago
Then quite obviously they are morons,. Music is NOT haram. This is nothing but bias on part of some scholars who have the nerve to pretend it is from God, when it is nothing but their personal biases.
fucknuaf 2 years ago
you are saying that Bukhari is woring that why i m talking to u, music is small issue, u point out the qualities of prophet that he doen not know future, this is wrong he also know with the help of ALLAH
sohail0399 2 years ago
On whoms authority did Bukhari operate? ALLAH's OWN BOOK states that the prophet does not know the future, so why are we having this debate. That was...GODS BOOK states that Mohammad do not know what will happen to any of us. Why is this not clear enough for you? What other books do you have that you read? do you find everything in it that you want?
fucknuaf 2 years ago
Give me exact refrence that allah says in qurran prophet dont know the future. when moses has power and prophet Jesis has power then why Prophet muhammad.
sohail0399 2 years ago
tell me any refrence, where qurran says music is Halal.only u are saying.
this is very simple, YOU dont want to understand.
sohail0399 2 years ago
even i listen 2 music but i no its haram and inshalla i stop soon if im alive. and may allah forgive me if i die.
and prophet mohammad pbuh said its haram several times. yes its haram i have not saw 1 scholar who said its halal and if dey did say it den dere wrong.
type in dr zakir naik music, and he will tell u its haram as well so will most of the other scholars/lectures/ sheikh feiz/khalid yasin.
its 100% haram brother.
ishybadboy 2 years ago
Comment removed
forever6more 2 years ago
omg. ow much times do i gota say this, u just said so wot rasulula (SAW) wud of said its haram
there is about 10 hadiths on music being haram. wot r u on ?
ishybadboy 2 years ago
there are about 10 that say it's not.
Why would God give us a taste for music and then say it's Haram? which he didn't it's not said in the quran. He said Idle talk which can be anything misguiding and singing but not instrumental.
You jst go on with your life i got bored
forever6more 2 years ago
lmfao wot r u on? r u on crack how can u say why wud god give us music den say its haram astagfrilla
why did god give us the knowledge to kill some 1 if its haram , or give us alchohol if its haram or give us zina or other sins. because its a test, wen u listen 2 music u think lifes nufin, if moves u away its shaitarn ive shown u hadiths (sayin of the prophet pbuh) ive shown u quran verse idk if the quran verse is talkin about it but the hadiths state its haram so it is. r u a shia?
ishybadboy 2 years ago
r u a shia? cos shias dont even accept hadiths dey just accept quran and say its got 10 spara missin or sum tink or pages lol if ur a shia stop talking 2 me lol no effence looool just leave me alone i tryed 2 help u if u not guna accept the truth den w.e
ishybadboy 2 years ago
WTH IS WRTONG WITH YOU? I AM A SUNI!
And it was me who tried to help you.
You people just refuse to understand that's all.
forever6more 2 years ago
den if ur a sunni dat means u follow quran and sunah and hadith, i showed u hadith about music and u still disbelive in the hadith why?
ishybadboy 2 years ago
for the last time:
1. the hadith is mo'alak which means it may not even be true.
2. the ayah you gave me isn't about music. You shouldn't rush to explain Quran verses.
3. it just makes no sense. Islam should make sense. This doesn't.
Don't ever speak to me anymore.
forever6more 2 years ago
lmfao the hadith is. Sahih Al-Bukhari Volume 7, Book 69, hadith #494v
its true
lmao
ur just on it
u dont wana belive it cus ur in love wid the music.
wot ever dont talk 2 me if u cant accept the truth den wot ever lmfao
ishybadboy 2 years ago
-1-
Even when we said the Hadith is Sahih, there are questions that would emerge when we study the version of the Hadith when it says, "People will make adultery, pure silk, liquor and Ma'azif into Halal." We know that adultery is Haram by another proof and it is a unanimous Hukum. Pure silk is not of consensus Hukum. If a Muslim says Zina is Halal deliberately, then they are considered a kafir. However, if a Muslim says pure silk is not Haram, he is not a kafir.
forever6more 2 years ago
-2-
We know that liquor is Haram as it is in the Qur'an, but where do we find an authentic hadith or Qur'an to tell us that Ma'azif are Haram other than this source. The last point is to get the clear meaning of Ma'azif in arabic dictionaries because there are more than one meaning for Ma'azif. It is acceptable for a Muslim to hear somebody says Makruh but not Haram because Haram is in need of clear-cut meaning and certain narration."
forever6more 2 years ago
lol wot r u talking about i just showed u 2-3 hadiths about music being haram and ur sayin were do we find a hadith dat music is haram and i showed u verse from quran.
music is haram 100% i listen to it but i try not to and may allah forgive me but least i no its haram u listen to it and u still think its not haram.
u just dont want to admit it.
yes obvisly its haram ask any scholar.
dont make ur own opinons up
ishybadboy 2 years ago
I asked many scholars, I've debated. But you don't wish to give it a chance. I also made a video. But looks like -you got your religion I got mine-
forever6more 2 years ago
astagfrilla la hola wala quwata, islam is 1, why r u spliting it saying u got ur religion and ive got mine? astagfrilla.
can i ask u, wot sect are you ( if ur a sect ).
ishybadboy 2 years ago
What i meant is that Islam is one Islam right? Music has a great controversial issue, SOME allowed it SOME forbid it. BUT why would Allah confuse us? So you believe it's Haram I don't. I don't really think that Quran verse was about music because it's still confusing. Once again why would allah confuse us? Why just not say it straight away? So yes looks like there is more than one Islam these days -we agreed to disagree.
forever6more 2 years ago
wana no why music is haram u dont even need hadiths or quran if u had a brain u wud see this. ( im not insulting u ).
i use to read namaz abit and go mosque wen i wuz 11 but den i stopped n listenined 2 music and i went astray abit.
and now age 15 i read 5 times namaz i gave music up etc. but now im 16, and i listen 2 music again and i read 5 times pray but i dont read sunats no more, its shaitarn, music gets to u and it makes u go astray. its shaitarn i no its hard to stop listenin to it,
ishybadboy 2 years ago
First I listen to music o Thank Allah my faith is great. Second, you still don't know what kind of music I listen to. I don't listen to those who tempt you do sin. I listen to the melody of a soul. I DID get insulted. it's as if you're telling me you cannot think when I have thought about it for so long, i didn't just wake up some morning and say ;oh music can't be haram!'. I did not.
forever6more 2 years ago
Sahih Al-Bukhari Volume 7, Book 69, hadith #494v
Narrated Abu 'Amir (raa) or Abu Malik Al-Ash'ari (raa) that he heard the Prophet (sallallaahu alayhi wa sallam) saying, "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider illegal sexual intercourse, the wearing of silk, the drinking of alcoholic drinks, and the use of musical instruments [ma'aazif] as lawful.
ishybadboy 2 years ago
There is a general rule in Shariah that states that everything is lawful unless proven unlawful. There is not substantial proof in this hadîths because of the following reasons:
Sheikh Muhammad Al-Hanuti stated: "The Hadith referred to in saying that it is haram as narrated by al Bukhari is not fulfilling the requirements of the Sahih in al Bukhari's collection.
forever6more 2 years ago
1) Al Bukhari in Hadith al Ma'azif himself narrated the Hadith to be of a broken chain of narrators in which there is a gap between al Bukhari and the second narrator, so he drops the first narrator in his chain. That is called Mu'allaq. Some scholars tried to connect the chain through other means like whan ibn Hajar did in his dissertation (connecting what is disconnected) in which he connected the Isnad of this Hadith.
forever6more 2 years ago
But still, one of the main narrators whose name is Hisham ibn Ammar as profiled in Tahthib at-Tahthib by ibn Hajar is not reliable enough for some scholars to be a source of a narration that depends on somebody like him.
forever6more 2 years ago
Look, it's only haraam in the narrowest and strictest interpretation of the Quran. I'm a Muslim who happens to listen to music, pray five times a day, performs Ramadan fasting and I have the Khalima in my heart. So, did music really turn me away from my faith?
Before you blast me, remember what our faith teaches us: Not to be critical of our fellow brothers and sisters. If you call yourselves decent Muslims, you should respect my opinion.
VidMastuh 2 years ago
i gave music up 5 monthz ago but 2 day i listened 2 some songs astagfrilla
i cant help it man some 1 needs 2 help me i saw hadiths about day of judgement fire in the ears for ppl who listen 2 music man
ishybadboy 2 years ago
that's becayse MUSIC is NOT HARAM. That's why you can't live without it, it's your human nature.
forever6more 2 years ago
idiot yes it is haram
the hadith states this.
ishybadboy 2 years ago
I have hadiths that state the opposite. Oh weird, I posted a responce and it did not get aproved.
forever6more 2 years ago
You don't understand. Music is every freakin' sound around you you cannot say it's Haram. So let's see, hmm. If music is Haram then Birds are Haram, we should kill them they keep us from praying. Also, reading Quran is Haram now 'cause it's yet another kind of music, oh what else? The blowing wind is Haram too 'cause you know Music is Haram!
PAH-LEASE USE THE BRAIN GOD GAVE YOU!
forever6more 2 years ago
Life is nothing without music. There used to be music in the mosque of Rassul Allah.
All my life whenever I was told something was Haram I used to think it through not directly believe it because Not ALL Hadith is Saheeh. Face it, you can't kill music.
It's a gift, you can't take it away from the worshipers of God.
Quran is the only source of Halal and Haram
forever6more 2 years ago
astagfdrilla lahola wala quwata sayin dere is music in the mosque
astagfrilla la hola wala quwata
ishybadboy 2 years ago
Also, the Hadith you provided is Mo'alak. It means it may not even be true.
Quran is the only source of law, AND IF MUSIC IS HARAM ALLAH WOULD HAVE SAID SO IN HIS QURAAN WITH NO CONFUSION! Why would he cofuse us so we fall in sin? MUSIC IS LIFE, make use of it.
forever6more 2 years ago
allah did say it in the quran.
[31.6] But there are, among men, those who purchase idle tales, without knowledge (or meaning), to mislead (men) from the Path of God and throw ridicule (on the Path): for such there will be a Humiliating Penalty.
wot is music? its idle tales u idiot. listen to all dese kufrs on rap and stuff talkin bout jesus and stuff its idol talk and its haram. all music insterments except from the drum is haram.
get dat in ur mind read the hadiths as well
ishybadboy 2 years ago
Why first of all I am not an idiot. Obviously I'm a person looking for knowledge. Second, You are not Allah, you cannot really take this one verse and consider idle talk singing. Idle talk can be anything meaningless AND YOU DO NOT KNOW THE KIND OF MUSIC I LISTEN TO. my music isn't idle talk.
forever6more 2 years ago
i called u a idiot because ur insulting me sayin use ur brain
ishybadboy 2 years ago
You only say that qurran is enough you do not have other thing, now tell me then why ALLAH send 24 hundred thousend prophet in this world. If the book is enough then there is no need of teacher.
and where Qurran says Music is HALLAL.
ha! there is no doubt in qurran, what do u think u can understand qurran, this is not the word of any person, this is word of God, thats why allah send his prophet that he describe the qurran and increase the Iman.
sohail0399 2 years ago
Do you think YOU can understand Quran? God said do not rush to understand. 'Idle Talk' does not mean music. I do not want to repeat myself, but if you wish to forbid GOD'S great grace of music he gave this world then go ahead. You lose, after all.
forever6more 2 years ago
r u dumb? how is birds haram and quran astagfrilla
music meaning musical instruements read the hadith it says muscial insterment meaning piano guitar etc. u idiot
astagfrilla saying quran is haram wtf
r u on crack read the hadiths dont go round sayin stuff and ur sayin i need a brain lmfao astagfrilla may allah guide u
ishybadboy 2 years ago
this is a beautiful video that proves to everyone that music is HARAAM
borootmohammed 2 years ago
i really think we dont need music it makes nasheed not good i agree on this one still not getting the point why it could be haram
turkmuslim4ever 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Abu Hurayrah narrated that Muhammad said group of this nation will be transformed into monkeys and pigs." They said, "Do not they testify that there is no god except Allaah & that Muhammed is His Messenger?" He said "Yes & also they fast pray & perform Hajj." They said "Then, what is their problem?" He said "They use musical instruments drums & female singers. they will go to sleep after a night of drinking & having fun, In the morning, they will be changed into monkeys & pigs."
james48890743 2 years ago
salam wr wb wats a buff
bestafgnbaplayer 2 years ago
dawah, one of the disbelievers amongst the Quraish would quickly assemble a group of dancers and singers in order to misguide the people from the path of Allah subhana wa ta'alaa. Ibn Masood, who was one of the Companions of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa salaam said, that indeed this verse was regarding the music.
ummzayneb 2 years ago
speak of that which you know with certainty. Allah subhana wa ta'alaa said in Surah 17:36-Speak not of that which you have no knowledge of. Verily the hearing and sight and the heart will be questioned.-Now as regards to music in the Quran, please open your Noble Quran to Surah 31 V 1-6 talks specifically about those who purchase idle talks and the reason of the revelation of this verse is due to the fact that during the time of the Prophet sallahu alayhi wa salaam when he would go out to give
ummzayneb 2 years ago
"And do not say lies for what your tongues describes: this is lawful (HALAL), and that is unlawful (HARAM), to lie about God. Those who lie about God will never succeed. They will have small pleasures (on Earth), AND FOR THEM IS A PAINFUL RETRIBUTION" (16/116-117) "Say 'Do you see that which God has provided for you, you make some of it Unlawful (Haram) and some of it Lawful (Halal)?. Say 'Did God allow you to do this? Or do you tell lies about God?" (10/59)
fucknuaf 2 years ago
"Say 'who has made Unlawful (Haram) the luxuries that God has provided his servants and the good things?..." (7/32)
fucknuaf 2 years ago
is halal and base their opinion solely on their desires rather than following a clear text from either the hadith of the Prophet sallallahu alayhi wa salaam and/or a clear text from the Quran. Further, it is important before you give your comment my dear bro in Islam, about whether music was addressed in the Quran or not one should first seek knowledge and then
ummzayneb 2 years ago
First to zyka1: Jazkallah Khairn my brother in Islam for trying to get the attention of the muslims and directing them towards following that which Allah subhanah wa ta'alaa and His Messenger sallahu alayhee wa salaam ordered us to follow. Likewise jazakallah khairn for directing the attention of the muslims and reminding them of those acts that are forbidden of which music is one of them. Now, I would like to direct some thoughts and advice to those among the commentators who believe that music
ummzayneb 2 years ago
I don't even support Anasheeds, because I consider them as sheytans Trap to catch your mind.
The best music (after the Qur'an) is this here.
watch?v=1pSyYhRYeIM
deathamph 2 years ago
for my stupid opinion,depend to the subject of music,is a matter of a fact who often instrumental music go with immoral text in 99/100 of cases,and this is haram,but when we read an hadith we have see if this hadith confirm something who is writed in coran,but i think who a true hadith cant make a rule more than coran like in this case,may allah accept my good faith in what i say.amin
italianmuslim 2 years ago
sum1**
gujizoop 3 years ago
wats d name of dat 2ndnasheed afta sanakhood 1 can cum1 lz tell me ?? jazakallah
gujizoop 3 years ago
yo wats that nasheed called in the video clip cos i want to know so i can download it. thanx
jehangq 3 years ago
dont confuse yourself with some saudi's fatwas. Our ears like to hear beautiful sound and that is called fitrah. If i play my guitar and make me forget to perform solat that is haram but still the same if you watch cartoon or plyaing PS in your house and forget to perform solat
exuaf 3 years ago 3
Assalamu'alaikum
If you think the Hadith mentioned in this video is daif please tell me.
If you think what the Prophet (SAW) said in it is a saudi fatwa please tell me.
"Our ears like to hear beautiful sound and that is called fitrah."
Our eyes also like to look at the opposite sex
I also used to listen to music alot but Alhamdulillah I have stopped and Insha' Allah I will not continue unless it is proven that Allah allows it.
May Allah Guide us all to the Straight Path. Ameen
Wassalam
breatheair 3 years ago
when i say our ears like to hear beautiful sound that does not mean only music. SOme of us like to hear the sound of birds. It general. You are the one who said you like to see opposite sex not me. Our eyes like to see beautiful scene like sunset, tree beautiful picture and other things. Please dont confuse yourself. What is haram is haram. What is halal is halal.
exuaf 3 years ago
When i said i play guitar and piano, that does not mean i play it becoz i want to performe at live stage or concert. I just play it. I repeat I just play it. There is obvious in quran saying that you must control you eyes from looking something that will make us do sinful act.
exuaf 3 years ago
guitar and piano are haram. the use of musical instruments is haram.
keepitreal17 3 years ago
When I mentioned saudi fatwa not becoz i said all the fatwa is wrong. For example they issued a fatwa on drug which said drug is haram. How can you said that. Most of our hospital including in muslim world used drug. Now it comes to our mind, Drugs or misuse of drugs. Which one is considered haram. That why we need fatwa. Same goes to music. Is it music itself considered as haram or the act associates with music is haram.
exuaf 3 years ago
Other example is on nasheed praising our prophet. Most our saudi brothers considered it as syirik becoz they said you can not praising prophet as he is a god. But once again i cannot agree. Becoz what? because syirik comes from our state of mind. When we sing about our prophet we dont sing to pray something or to demand something from him. It alway if i need a help i pray to Allah.
exuaf 3 years ago
but the hadith mentioned in the video is from sahih bukhari, how can you still argue when in it the Messenger SAW gives a clear indication on the status of music by mentioning it with known sins.
breatheair 3 years ago
Ok i will bring you some hadis for you to consider. I'm not tell you about the hadis becoz i want you to do something with music but i'm sick when people always tell this is haram, this is halal, this is syirik when it comes to certain issue which does not has any accurate dalil like what happen in Mecca long time ago when some muslim scholar said that using speaker in Masjidil Haram was Haram
exuaf 3 years ago
OK I'm waiting for them then. btw you can find some more evidence supporting my view here:
scribd com/doc/6684070/Music-Singing-Are-Prohibited-in-Islam
replace space with dot.
breatheair 3 years ago
singing is haram, please stop kidding yourself...and singing to praise the prophet is also haram, it can be considered a form of reverence of the prophet. Please note that the prophet is not to be revered, only Allah (S) is, all praise belongs to Allah. The Prophet was simply a righteous man who brought forth Allah's message, but it is Allah (S) who is to be praised because of it. And not by singing, but by prayers and fasting, hajj, etc.
keepitreal17 3 years ago
SO in solat dont you ever said a single word about Prophet. Dont you ever praise prophet muhammad in solat. If praising muhammad is allowed during pray, hajj and fasting what is the problem if i want to praise him outside from that. If you dont know about usul fiqh so dont say a single word about halal and haram. Dont say something you dont know.
exuaf 3 years ago
If you want to believe music is haram, it is up to you. But me still music is not haram
exuaf 3 years ago
all the shcolars say music is haraam do they not?
africaRBG 3 years ago
I have heard and read hadis on music and most of them are dhaif. I play guitar and piano in my room. Not a problem with that. The problem is when you playing music associate with alcohol, women and other things. For clear picture most concerts and live performance held by western singers were considered haram. But if i want to play my ESP electric guitar in my room and hear some metallica songs who can stop me
exuaf 3 years ago
Assalaamu Alikum!
i'll say ty! ty 4 this greate video!
arslanraja 3 years ago
Assalaamu Alikum
I truly agree with u 4 what u have said but i find this confusing...
The Brothers and sisters who sing nasheeds with Musical Instruments they must know that musical Instruments r haram however they still do-786, Native Deen, etc. Their intentions r good as they want to spread Islam as most people nowadays listen 2 R&B hip hop etc. Just to get their attention and know Islam better. U c where I'm coming from?
But thank u 4 making this video. May Allah reward u, insha'Allah.
Sweetcandy111 3 years ago
Aslam alkum do you know where i can download MP3 english nasheeds without music inshallah if so pleaseleave a comment on my channel inshallah and may allah bless you and protect you ameen
islamforever08 3 years ago
where did you get the first song listed in the video
ruzebrocks 3 years ago
But the word Haram does not appear on these hadiths....
diggihad 3 years ago
but what is the hadith telling u? to go ahead and listen to nasheed with instruments or better to avoid them?? use common sense bro.
:)
fesabililah 3 years ago
Salamun alaykum,
To learn about the truth of Islam taught by Allah in the Glorious Quran, goto:
mediafire(dot)com/?a4xxeavaana
You might need Word Viewer if you dont have Microsoft Office (google "Word Viewer" for a free download)
A must read for any practicing Muslim. It is the truth in the Quran which the majority of Muslims have abandoned... may Allah (swt) guide us
steeletek786 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Psalms 33:1-11
1 Sing joyfully to the Lord, you righteous; it is fitting for the upright to praise him. 2 Praise the Lord with the harp; make music to him on the ten-stringed lyre. 3 Sing to him a new song; play skillfully, and shout for joy. 4 For the word of the Lord is right and true; he is faithful in all he does. 5 The Lord loves righteousness and justice; the earth is full of his unfailing love.
dag62emailvccsedu 3 years ago
so even like for example rap song that rap about islam would something like that be haram and if so how do u stop yourself from listin 2 music werever u go ders music on the streets when u go into a shop even sometimes in elavators
moroccan1234567 3 years ago
Aishah narrated that during the days of Mina, on the day of 'Eid al-Adha, two girls were with her, singing and playing on a hand drum. The Prophet (peace be on him) was present, listening to them with his head under a shawl. Abu Bakr then entered and scolded the girls. The Prophet (peace be on him), uncovering his face, told him, "Let them be, Abu Bakr. These are the days of 'Eid." (Reported by al-Bukhari and Muslim.)
Bloodlustless 3 years ago
i heard that aswell but some people say it is not a strong hadith
moroccan1234567 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
brothers and sister i fowned a surah that say music misleads ppl see my vid click on my name
magexx368 3 years ago
using voice to make a bass sound, add some beatboxing, mix with singing, it still haram?
I'm confuse, we like to eat tasty food with our mouth, we like to watch beautiful things with our eyes, and we like to hear a great sound with our ears, everything is nikmat from Allah SWT
hybridtraffic 3 years ago 2
so is nasheeds haram then?
kaz5t 3 years ago
if they have musical instruments then i dont think it makes them 100% halal, also nasheeds with music is definately better than the songs of the kufar, but the same time the instruments get in the way and all...
fesabililah 3 years ago
If playing musical instruments is one of the worst things you can do, we are all in trouble.
Why not worry about something that is actually worthwhile. Music is dangerous and bad...okay...sure...
mac26 3 years ago
drums would be like the duf right, under the same category right? thanks
hkballer13 3 years ago
"And of mankind is he who purchases idle talk to mislead (men) from the Path of Allaah, without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allaah, the Verses of the Qur'aan) by way of mockery. For such there will be a humiliating torment (in the Hell-fire)." [Luqmaan 31:6]
muslimahpwincess 3 years ago
only 'Duf' is allowed during marriage ceremony, Eid, and Walima. Yes, music is described with gambling, drinking and this hadith is in the famous hadith book the MUSNAD, IMAM AHMAD BIN HAMBAL Vol. 2 pg 165 published by MAKTAB E ISLAMI BERUIT.
muslimahpwincess 3 years ago
Inshallah i hope that answers your questions salam alaykum akhi :o)
muslimahpwincess 3 years ago
yah, that answers it. jazakallahukhairan. wassalamu alaikum.
hkballer13 3 years ago
jazakallahkair for that aki/ukti
ishkid 3 years ago
what is the last song called? jazakallahukhairan
hkballer13 3 years ago
Narrated Aisha: Abu Bakr came to my house while two small Ansari girls were singing beside me the stories of the Ansar concerning the Day of Buath. And they were not singers. Abu Bakr said protestingly, "Musical instruments of Satan in the house of Allah's Apostle !" It happened on the 'Id day and Allah's Apostle said, "O Abu Bakr! There is an 'Id for every nation and this is our 'Id."
muslimahpwincess 3 years ago
i heard drum instruments are okay. are there any hadiths supporting or against this statement? thanks.
hkballer13 3 years ago
Most of the scholars interpreted lahw al-hadeeth ("idle talk") as meaning singing and musical instruments, and every voice that diverts people from the truth.
Al-Tabari (Jaami' al-Bayaan, 15/118-119), Ibn Abi'l-Dunya (Dham al-Malaahi, 33) and Ibn al-Jawzi (Talbees Iblees, 232) all reported that concerning the aayah (interpretation of the meaning):
muslimahpwincess 3 years ago
"[Allaah said to Shaytaan;] 'And istafziz [literally means befool them gradually] those whom you can with your voice, make assaults on them with your cavalry and your infantry, mutually share with them wealth and children, and make promises to them.' But Shaytaan promises them nothing but deceit" [al-Isra' 17:64]
muslimahpwincess 3 years ago
i have been a dedicated musician. Four years I have played guitar, I'm 17 and it has been a part of my life this amazing gift. I'm not boasting but I am exceptional at writing songs and I am a multi-instrumentalist. I'm a musician you know? So, for a musician to become a Muslim, would so tough coz I'm saying goodbye to something. My family, particularly my dad, would be heart-broken. He'd never get over it. Ive bin tryna get a music course oppurnity at college n i finally got it coz bad GCSEs :(
LiStEnIo 3 years ago
Alsalaam alaykum,
The first nasheed is called Sanakhod.
Tearsofmaheart 3 years ago
salaam alaikum,
could someone tell me the name of the first nasheed pls. Shukran
bobondo 3 years ago
you know wah annoys me when people know this that music is haram and they make excuses to cover it up by putting sand in your eyes so people MUSIC IS HARAM HARAM HARAM!!! i been trying to get this in alot of peoples headsif you dont follow the prophets sunnah and words why do you call yourself muslim when you deny the prophets words Peace/saalam alaykum :)
muslimahpwincess 3 years ago
well,first off,not all scholars agree with u thatall music is haram.some believe that it is only wind andstring instruments that we cannot listen to, while soem are like u. and i would like that hadith that you'reso called saying that the prophet said that all music is haram.iheard the hadithof the one with the kid playing awind istrument but which one are u talking about.so next time u say something, please dont question our iman, and if ur iman was so strong,u wud stay awayfrom socalled haram.
hkballer13 3 years ago