she's a great singer but to i just think that her voice sounds very choral in this song like she's singing with a large group and trying not to stand out (except for more towards the end) but still a great preformance :)
This is such a brilliant song and such a brilliant arrangement and performance. The message at the end just hits you in the face like a truck. Beautiful.
This is just... gorgeous. You know a good actor is present if they can make you laugh one second and the make you get teary-eyed within forty seconds later. That's exactly what Ms. Audra McDonald did for me.
@dawncullen009 Oh my, her breath carries her through the entire song and her diction and dynamics are spot on! I can't believe this is my first time listening to her sing this. Where has she been all my life?
my choir director showed me this song today and i had to look it up! this women sings it so beautifully i think i might sing it at a singing contest(:
This is nice, but she does a version sitting down with the composer, Jason Robert Brown, at the piano that I like better. It is the third one down in the Related Videos on the right. This version is a little overly dramatic for me.
@tswiftchick There is a listing of videos to the right of this video. The last time I looked, the video with Jason Robert Brown was the third one down from the top. Now, it is the second one down. Audra is seated, wearing a black dress, 4:31 is in the lower right corner, it is posted by AudraMcDonaldFan, and as of now, it has 6,385 views.
A perfect balance of beautiful singing and specific acting in service of a wonderfully written song!! Another great perf. by Ms. McDonald! What a talent!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I wish more broadway stars were like Audra...I am studying opera, and I wish broadway cherished it's voices like Audra's rather than some of the "pop-y" belters there are.
She is the only person I've ever seen that actually does it well!! There's so much emotion in those crucial parts, and she does the throw away lines really well... "I'd rather have a yacht". Shows that the character really thought nothing of the wonderful things the guy was offering at the time.
Ok, amazing song, wonderful rendition as always from Audra, but is it just me or does anyone else crave a little more variation in the approach (acting wise) between all the men. I dunno maybe i'm crazy.
Well, this is a concert, if you have seen the musical "Songs for a New World," she does a wonderful job, but it's limited - and a different atmosphere.
A girl sang this in my summer music class seven years ago and I've been looking for the song for that long. I finally found it today, and it was worth the wait, especially sung by this woman with a wonderful voice.
I'm working on this song right now. It's almost there but it's so hard! Just the timing is fast and the song is really wordy! She is incredible though so of course hers is perfect!
OKAY I think I was the only one who heard ABOUT Audra McDonald and watched Private Practice without knowing Dr. Bennett was this amazing several times Tony award winner! !
So many people who sing this so dramatically and overact, but she sings so simply, sincerely, candidly, maturely, like she's telling a story to someone over coffee, but still conveys the fondness and regret that the character has of her memories. Her interpretation is incredible.
um excuse me!!!!!! 8O Audra McDonald is the BEST!!!
shes not forcing anything its called acting. This song is from show called Songs for a New World by Jason Robert Brown (an off-broadway show) and would only make since that she would perform it as if she was on stage.
She is INCREDIBLE. Not only a fantastic voice... but the interpretation. The clarity of meaning behind each word she says... chilling... thrilling... awesome
I grew up with watching her as Grace in Annie, and she is sooo talented it's not even fair! Absolutely beautiful voice. I was in tears the first time I heard this.
this song always provokes so many feelings in me. its plainly amazing. but evn a professional didnt beat this one performance of it a girl in my school did, she made me cry
I really appreciate the way she sang it but i really didnt like it as much as the recording but she did brilliant five stars. And about the l5y thats the musical that got me into jrb so it has a very personal spot in my heart i love it so much!
Aww, this is now unlisted? :( That is a shame, but such an honour to be able to see it even once :)
JannerMaate 7 months ago
this breaks my heart. a million times over.
only audra can have that effect.
LiefsteCamilla 1 year ago
Beautiful!!!! although Ardyth VanScoy would school the living beejeezuz outta you.....I'll get you her contact!
jkarrasch211 1 year ago
17 People would rather have a yacht
StarberryJam 1 year ago
she's a great singer but to i just think that her voice sounds very choral in this song like she's singing with a large group and trying not to stand out (except for more towards the end) but still a great preformance :)
SOMMPAproductions 1 year ago
she is brilliant.
maddycatie 1 year ago
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES <3
leavingthings 1 year ago 6
chills. every. time.
michaelramosmusic 1 year ago 2
My friend performed this for our talent show. I was amazed at what a lovely story thisis.
loserbiotch2 1 year ago
This is the best version of the best song Jason Robert Brown has ever written. Enough said.
dennisdamenace3500 1 year ago
waw!
0honey0U 1 year ago 2
the end of the song is the best part other than her singing.. that end and resolve is BEAUTIFUL!
jwired14 1 year ago
I ADORE this woman!
Feekme 1 year ago 3
Where can we watch this concert?
neilzgrrlfrend 1 year ago
Zij is zo ongelooflijk! Zeldzaam mooi.
Jietp 1 year ago
@Jietp I agree Completely.
ChocolateCaliente062 1 year ago
I love how she goes from pure opera performance voice, immediately to an extremely casual voice
1:10
TribeHazSpoken 1 year ago 2
SING IT!!!
g4thz 1 year ago
I love Audra McDonald...so...much!
kathrynannerussell 1 year ago 2
This is such a brilliant song and such a brilliant arrangement and performance. The message at the end just hits you in the face like a truck. Beautiful.
awkwardbarry 1 year ago
it's so nice to hear this song done by someone with a rich tone like that! I'm so tired of hearing it screamed.
broadwaynut2010 1 year ago
Damn those are some facial expressions.
grahas1 1 year ago 3
wow, stunning :)
if i could like this over and over again i would :) x
CharlieBnana 1 year ago
Who the hell disliked this?
Spces8472 1 year ago 2
@Spces8472 15 idiots...
Bluebaritone 1 year ago
@Spces8472 me
candyfloss739 1 year ago
This is just... gorgeous. You know a good actor is present if they can make you laugh one second and the make you get teary-eyed within forty seconds later. That's exactly what Ms. Audra McDonald did for me.
DEARESTkaitybug 1 year ago 2
I just listened to a few other people singing this song...it's just not the same.
Danceingcub 1 year ago
Audra is phenomenal. Truly blessed with a gift that inspires those of us who would like to follow in those footsteps
DynamoDivo 1 year ago 5
'and i thought, my god'
i cry every time.
LiefsteCamilla 1 year ago 6
I love you, Audra
FitnessNerd 1 year ago 2
Why is she so good? And goregous?
Will Swenson is a lucky man...
BlueJeanBaby012 1 year ago 2
great performance, and I love the orchestral set-up :))
hidveginora 1 year ago 2
Fabulous <3
k9lovemine 1 year ago 2
This was excellent! Excellent!
ChadCraver99 1 year ago 2
where's the Love button?
lindroth7 1 year ago 4
hmmm, not my favorite version at all....she lacks emotion, especially at the end.
Kristy Cates did this best, I believe.
katiekisses04 1 year ago
@katiekisses04 you clearly dont know music. stick to reality shows and smirnoff ice. god i hope youre a troll.
Oreoshakespear 1 year ago
@Oreoshakespear No, no emerald belly button here (but how cool would that be?!)
This version just doesn't do it for me...listen around and you might see that I'm right.
katiekisses04 1 year ago
'and i thought ya know... i'd rather have a yacht'
ahaa lovee thatt partt <33
mammamia4ever 1 year ago
love love love it!!!
trackster3222 1 year ago
This is excellent!
queen2die4 1 year ago
She is amazing!
gabriellecorinne 1 year ago
this song is so similar to Shire's Life Story from Closer than Ever, which was written earlier. I wonder if Brown knew it before writing this piece.
SeiserToledo 1 year ago
Oh my goodness, she sings this song so incredibly well. I will never be able to listen to anyone else sing it! Audra is fantastic.
EtrangerStranger 1 year ago
Amazing breath, diction, and dynamics! You go girl (:
dawncullen009 1 year ago
@dawncullen009 Oh my, her breath carries her through the entire song and her diction and dynamics are spot on! I can't believe this is my first time listening to her sing this. Where has she been all my life?
EtrangerStranger 1 year ago 2
my choir director showed me this song today and i had to look it up! this women sings it so beautifully i think i might sing it at a singing contest(:
Rickjamesbit 1 year ago
I NEVER EXPECTED MY WORDS TO BE POSTED
like1ron 1 year ago
LOL
TrappedNation 1 year ago
Not only her voice is breathtaking, but the acting that she incorporates in this song is so genuine, refreshing and inspiring! Go girl!
Livinlovely22 1 year ago 4
she makes it look soo easy its ridiculous!
juliar90 1 year ago 3
amazing!
lydiamandygrace 1 year ago 2
i LOVE this song :) at my school, we did it in a show called Nights On Broadway and Caroline Daly came and sang it at our school! :)
musicalmelody100 1 year ago
This is nice, but she does a version sitting down with the composer, Jason Robert Brown, at the piano that I like better. It is the third one down in the Related Videos on the right. This version is a little overly dramatic for me.
ChicagoSouthDan 2 years ago
where is that?
tswiftchick 1 year ago
@tswiftchick There is a listing of videos to the right of this video. The last time I looked, the video with Jason Robert Brown was the third one down from the top. Now, it is the second one down. Audra is seated, wearing a black dress, 4:31 is in the lower right corner, it is posted by AudraMcDonaldFan, and as of now, it has 6,385 views.
ChicagoSouthDan 1 year ago
Thank you, It was amazing like everything she does.
tswiftchick 1 year ago
Lolz funny and fantastic :D
MintyRocx 2 years ago
A perfect balance of beautiful singing and specific acting in service of a wonderfully written song!! Another great perf. by Ms. McDonald! What a talent!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
soaringsound 2 years ago
I wish more broadway stars were like Audra...I am studying opera, and I wish broadway cherished it's voices like Audra's rather than some of the "pop-y" belters there are.
saxamaphoneguy1 2 years ago 14
Jason Robert Brown is an amazing composer!
civicplayer 2 years ago 5
incredible
rachhlovee67 2 years ago
That's just... incredible.
iwantin01 2 years ago
She' s from Private Practice
GenaHaensel 2 years ago
Audra McDonald is one of the best singers alive. She sings the lead in Ragtime. Now shes on Private Practice
addaniel1 2 years ago
did she play Sarah in Ragtime?
lalahahajkjklol 2 years ago
yes, she was the original Sarah, and the one on the CD.
addaniel1 2 years ago
I knew it!! ONce I heard her hear and in some other songs as well anyways. hahha She's freakin' amazing!!
lalahahajkjklol 2 years ago
@addaniel1 she is an amazing singer... however she does not sing the female lead in Ragtime... she was in the cast however
Evilqueen1985 2 years ago
isn't sarah the female lead?
AngelOfMusic144 2 years ago
No. Mother is the female lead, played by Marin Mazzie. Sarah is the second female. Audra did however play the female lead in 110 in the shade.
Evilqueen1985 2 years ago
another fantastic show. go audra!
AngelOfMusic144 2 years ago
Really lovely song and such a beautiful performance!
12thLeveIWizardKing 2 years ago
I think I recolect hearing this voice before... Did she sing as the character Pocahontas in the Disney Film?
cloudryda 2 years ago
I think that was Judy Khun. I'm not sure though.
janeite82791 2 years ago
it was judy kuhn, you're right.
AngelOfMusic144 2 years ago
She played Grace in Annie
=]
And is Naomi in Private Practice.
Meghanface16 2 years ago
when did she play grace in annie?
leelee987654 2 years ago
It was in the ABC TV movie a number of years ago. Kathy Bates and Victor Garber were also in it.
ZONEACE 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It was in the ABC TV movie a number of years ago. Kathy Bates and Victor Garber were also in it.
ZONEACE 2 years ago
:) Yep.,
maybebroadwaybabyyy 2 years ago
No dear, that was Judy Kuhn
kahdjahxx 2 years ago
that was Judy Khun.
roseswindler 2 years ago
Her voice is basically angelic. She's amazingggggggggggggggg
kelseyanne08 2 years ago 2
She is the only person I've ever seen that actually does it well!! There's so much emotion in those crucial parts, and she does the throw away lines really well... "I'd rather have a yacht". Shows that the character really thought nothing of the wonderful things the guy was offering at the time.
LozBombandtheostrich 2 years ago 6
It is in E...which is different than the original, which is in D
jayars88 2 years ago
sound like the person who sing in the pocahontas songs
punichr 2 years ago
My heart breaks when she gets to "and I thought, 'My God'" the emotion in her voice is so pure and clear
banthonywhite 2 years ago 54
She is just such an amazing singer and actor.
GilbertFamilySingers 2 years ago 2
what key is this in
Ropo07 2 years ago
oh wow beautiful so sad
MusicalSeussHead 2 years ago
INCREDIBLE!! what an amazing voice and interpretation!
dramablondi13 2 years ago
I love this, it is soo awesome. And I agree she is the only one that can do it!~
dddepin 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Is this the lady from Living Single?!
Akuchan7 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
she's too good for this song:)
MirandaHopeYaLikeIt 2 years ago 5
Audra is the only person who can sing/perform this song and bring me to tears - every single time.
barose1 2 years ago 54
her voice is stunning, her niece's is just as powerful
camtoki92 2 years ago 2
<3 it
MissCamizz 2 years ago
Where can I find the sheet music for this???
laralovesmusic1 2 years ago
Jason Robert Brown Anthology, or a lot of vocal rep books. It's one of the most available JRB songs.
leemute 2 years ago
We are not worthy!!!
prozack1312 2 years ago 3
SHE SOUNDS GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ndbstar729n 2 years ago 2
lol shes good:) isn't she from private practise??/
xlittlexnikkix 2 years ago 4
This such an elegant composition, that takes a tremendous amount of internal connection from the singer to the lyric. And a respect of the silence.
42beaverfootball 2 years ago 2
Beautiful women singing a great song...enjoy this vidio each time a play it..
mroneoftheguys 2 years ago
Ok, amazing song, wonderful rendition as always from Audra, but is it just me or does anyone else crave a little more variation in the approach (acting wise) between all the men. I dunno maybe i'm crazy.
Theater00jock 2 years ago
Well, this is a concert, if you have seen the musical "Songs for a New World," she does a wonderful job, but it's limited - and a different atmosphere.
urbroadwaybuddy 2 years ago
This is such a beautiful song, and Ms. McDonald sings it with so much passion. It's just wonderful.
mesupermommy 2 years ago
Amazing! She is so good! I died when I heard this.
theatreheart 2 years ago
I LOOOOVEEE THIS SONG!
LutzKlutz 2 years ago
A girl sang this for an open mic night like a month ago and I CAN"T get it out of my head. :) (but in a good way, I love it)
jacksparrowismyluvr 2 years ago
Thats a very good song. And the singer is VERY talented. Bravo.
jamesmoonet 2 years ago
A girl sang this in my summer music class seven years ago and I've been looking for the song for that long. I finally found it today, and it was worth the wait, especially sung by this woman with a wonderful voice.
Louanna007 2 years ago 3
Why is she on a TV show when she has this much talent?
0o0vl0o0 2 years ago 4
Well at least she's dispalying it right now in Twelth Night. She's so amazing! Check out the video of her on my page.
G4Rat 2 years ago
She's a famous broadway singer. This is just a little concert. :)
Shmedly16 2 years ago
I'm working on this song right now. It's almost there but it's so hard! Just the timing is fast and the song is really wordy! She is incredible though so of course hers is perfect!
VLAichroth 2 years ago
hmmmm esto es casi una especie de musica salsa que chevere se escucha.
nikorando 2 years ago
I love Songs for a New World!
I am singing I'm Not Afraid of Anything for an upcoming competition!
maggs51492 2 years ago
I've been listening to her Wheels of a Dream from Ragtime, no less amazing than here. Because she's Audra McDonald. I loooooove her!
ObsessedwithBroadway 2 years ago
OKAY I think I was the only one who heard ABOUT Audra McDonald and watched Private Practice without knowing Dr. Bennett was this amazing several times Tony award winner! !
megustasstuu 2 years ago
So many people who sing this so dramatically and overact, but she sings so simply, sincerely, candidly, maturely, like she's telling a story to someone over coffee, but still conveys the fondness and regret that the character has of her memories. Her interpretation is incredible.
InDubiousBattle 2 years ago 8
its almost insane how much i love everything audra mcdonald... its scary. i love her.
sarahsnathan 2 years ago
amazing
lemonlimejuice7 2 years ago
BRILLIANT!!! Audra McDonald is simply beautiful.
wickedphant0m 2 years ago
dont think i liked this version as much
JCHSings12 2 years ago
this is a wake up call! i love her on private practice, i had no idea she sang too
FerventVoice601 2 years ago
Love her, but some of her entrances sound flat at times, even in the recording.
bryan21tx 2 years ago
is this in a different key?
11wantyc 2 years ago
nope
peachpie137 2 years ago
this is definitely a different key. It's much higher.
mper415 2 years ago
yupp
trilis123 2 years ago
SWEET LORD!
This woman can sing!
Lmaoo
I love Audra <3
JmB8207 2 years ago
If I had to pick someone to trade voices with, it would be this woman. I have so much respect for her!
baakal01 2 years ago
Comment removed
ruccpamt 2 years ago
um excuse me!!!!!! 8O Audra McDonald is the BEST!!!
shes not forcing anything its called acting. This song is from show called Songs for a New World by Jason Robert Brown (an off-broadway show) and would only make since that she would perform it as if she was on stage.
takemeout10 2 years ago 2
yes!
noonyboon 2 years ago
Why is she slumming it on Private Practice??
Kesinji 2 years ago
GASP!
That's Audra McDonald on PRIVATE PRACTICE!?
I knew she looked familiar! What is she doing on that showw??
JmB8207 2 years ago 2
shes the best
fiendishlypop 2 years ago
hahahaha. I didn't realize that anyone was such a genius
sorry for bringing you down homey G
MaxJCollins 2 years ago
i went to high school with her..believe it or not..we had a class too!
nbk33vq 2 years ago
artistic genius
artistic genius
artistic genius
biGwoMAaNn899 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Typical female, doesn't know what she wants.
Sconz32 2 years ago
I'm glad she transposed it up. This is a much better key for a soprano. Oh and she was great as always!
TrebleB4Mi 2 years ago 4
She for some reason reminds me of Judy Garland!
hyland999 2 years ago 4
But without the drama and drug addiction.
PeterBluth 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow that was really bad.
fasted227 2 years ago
audra mcdonald singing Stars and Moon? SO MUCH WIN!
SeeAyArhAyStitchez 2 years ago 5
I love this song and most JRB!
And she's amazing!
vaniatis 2 years ago 2
I love her facial expressions! I think she is amazing!
Ndbstar729n 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Um. Hello. Way oversung!!!!
farmgrl36 2 years ago
She is INCREDIBLE. Not only a fantastic voice... but the interpretation. The clarity of meaning behind each word she says... chilling... thrilling... awesome
4trmonutube 2 years ago 2
I love Audra! She has an amazing voice!
BrooklynJuilliard 2 years ago
Chills.
Amazing!
katiedid0209 2 years ago
what a fiercie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
BrOaDwAyBoUnD240 2 years ago
I grew up with watching her as Grace in Annie, and she is sooo talented it's not even fair! Absolutely beautiful voice. I was in tears the first time I heard this.
ObsessedwithBroadway 2 years ago
i didnt know that was her in annie!!!
showersinger34 2 years ago
Yup. She was really good... :)
ObsessedwithBroadway 2 years ago
AMAZING
lavenderb524 2 years ago
I'm commenting again because I love Audra so much.
Three cheers for Audra!
TandAofBWAY 2 years ago
She is so AMAZING!!! OOO. MY. GOD!!!!
jonsmith3030 2 years ago
oh. my. god.
KillerQueenFan99 2 years ago
This woman is the most incredible vocalist. She's got my favorite Broadway voice.
TandAofBWAY 2 years ago 2
such talent.
DivingDiva0594 2 years ago
theres no one on youtube you can sing this song better than her!
tomahillside 3 years ago
Songs for a new world comes to Upstairs at the gatehouse in London feb7th-14 2009 visit the theatre website or ticketweb to buy tickets :D
kevinmax21 3 years ago
this song always provokes so many feelings in me. its plainly amazing. but evn a professional didnt beat this one performance of it a girl in my school did, she made me cry
catlady260 3 years ago
I am in tears right now, this so is so gorg!!
Gracie287 3 years ago
I love this SONG!
jazzypoops 3 years ago
I really appreciate the way she sang it but i really didnt like it as much as the recording but she did brilliant five stars. And about the l5y thats the musical that got me into jrb so it has a very personal spot in my heart i love it so much!
ScottZaborski 3 years ago
this woman knows how to act when she sings!! soo good!!
fibonebone7 3 years ago 2
man she has such a voice... and this song is sooo her :)
learnofme 3 years ago 3
i love this song
93Roses 3 years ago 2
wow, this is great. she looks so sad at the end...
iamthebadkitty 3 years ago 2
I KNOW! It almost made me cry . . .
ObsessedwithBroadway 3 years ago
OMG i LOVE YOU
jessealy 3 years ago 2
I am not Jason Robert Brown's biggest fan but this is simply AMAZING!!!! I LOVE HER!!!
broadwaymusic4life 3 years ago 2
You didn't like "Last 5 Years"?
akaulanav 3 years ago
Actually, that recently grew on me. I mean, how could it not with Norbert Leo Butz on the cd? So yea, good point.
I just think that all JRB songs really sound that same and I am not a huge fan of that with the exception of a few beautiful songs.
broadwaymusic4life 3 years ago