George does it because he hasn't moved onto any other projects since Star Wars, he's had nothing to keep him busy so he's made it a habit to go back and change the original trilogy. He doesn't care what he changes, it mean nothing to him, he just thinks it's fun to see how the scene would play out if he changed say greedo shooting first or vader saying nooo, The sooner he dies the better. No doubt Lucasfilm will release the original trilogy in original form to honor Lucas when he dies.
P.s. George Lucas knows the Nooo was a horrible scene, putting it in this shows he's an asshole. I have many times a day where I could do things just to mess with people when I know they're wrong, but I don't. I'm done being a star wars fan, this shit killed it. I have enough assholes in real life, no need to support another one.
I love all the people who don't get why changing a film or anything that means so much to someone, is "such a big deal" It's just showing the flaw of society that you are joining. You don't care so no one should? Are you that self centered and self obsessed? Go watch Jersey Shore...your opinion matters not. Just because I don't ride horses doesn't mean everyone who does is stupid and we should kill all the horses. By the way...Horses aren't bad people...people who don't get changing star wars m
For everyone who is saying that it's "his movie and he can do what he wants to with it," why couldn't he just put this on one disc and keep it for himself, and instead let the fans enjoy the originals in high quality and not FORCE THEM TO PUT UP WITH THIS LOAD OF CRAP!
I can't wait to see what Lucas changes next. Better yet, I can't wait 'til he announces what went through his mind when he added this crap to one of my favorite movies of all time!
@MasterROBO360 Gee, I'm going to re-release all the Star Wars movies on Blu-Ray, and I want to make some changes to them, and most of the fans seem to dislike Jar-Jar Binks. Hmm...
I think this is the dumb downed version because back in the day the music and acting clearley showed vader needed to make a hard choice but in the end chose the good side and killed the emporor. But now they need him to simply say "no" to make that point across
Suddenly all that added CG and special effects seems trivial compared to Lucas tainting the greatest moment in the Star Wars saga. If you have the original copies, hold on to them dearly because their value has only sky rocketed more, and I'm sure Lucas would want them destroyed.
Vader whined "NO... No..." like a little girl. WTF. My Jedi and Whills, just save me from this horrible change. Someone with the Force, protect the OT from Lucas old man himself, PLEASE !!
@Yodaaaa1 These so called "Fans" That are calling for Lucas head make me sick! You want to save Star Wars from Lucas! that's like saying I wanna protect Nike from Michael Jordan! It's ridiculous... but i'll say this fans like you have won, because he said he's now done with it all! Thanks to all you "Fans" you got your wish..............
@RIPKENOBI Suppose an artist painted something beautiful that had an impact on your life. Now suppose that artist returned to his painting 20 years later to 'enhance' it by putting a big red stripe across it. That is exactly how I feel about what Lucas has done here.
@RIPKENOBI:you didn't read my phrase well. I said "save it from Lucas old man", not from Lucas of 1977 or 1980. He once made excellent movies (a long time ago), but with the time being now he tends to spoil them more than polish them. I don't object to changes, but I don't want a change which DAMAGES the movie. Like if Leonard de Vinci changed his mind later and replaced Mona Lisa's smile with a big grin to show all her teeth. Yeah, victory. Hey, M.Jordan doesn't harm Nike a bit.
George Lucas will never beat Walt Disney himself. I can't believe I am actually quoting Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 3, but all men die, but only some with honor. George would never get that honor as Walt Disney did and that is why Disney's awesome. Star Tours looks way better than any of Lucas's remakes or special effects. In addition, 20th Century Fox was the REAL genius behind the original Star Wars films!
The reason I liked the return of the jedi (the original) was because of this scene. The music was kind off speaking for Vader and made him look more wounreable and humanly then he is represented. I felt empathy for Vader and was stunned the first time I saw him throwing Sidious to his death, Vader didn't need a "NO" to show that he cared about his son and wanted to kill the empreror. The music and the good acting made it clearly on it's own.
You guys are like kids getting all butthurt over simple changes. I really don't give 2 craps about these as long as he doesn't change plots or gets rid of scenes.
i know the fanboys are all whining like little kids, but think about it this way. which is better, two trilogies that bear no continuity together, or a saga that, after some editing, makes more sense. I mean, after filming in the wrong order, and story changes to fit said filming, is it so wrong that he wants to change a few things so that it makes sense as a whole rather than two separate trilogies?
This is really what happened, Vader basically witnesses Mace Windu's death back in Episode III, but now, he witnesses his son dying. That's why he screams "Nooo"
@SpyOperator Lucas could have use Stock Footage of the Prequel Trilogy(as Flashbacks) like Obi Wan's "YOU'RE THE CHOOSEN ONE" Voices & Splice it in for the 3D Released of the Original Trilogy.
George Lucas is not doing this for any other reason than "justifying" that stupid lame no at the end of episode 3... The originals were amazing the way they were. Greedo Never shot first!
Is this really what everyone is on about? I honestly don't think its all that bad. All i care about is the story and luckily enough that hasn't been changed . . . yet. But seriously get over it.
@IngloriousBasterd96 To me they are just a fantastic set of films, to some they defined childhoods, to others its a way of life. I don't mind these changes too much as long as the story is NEVER changed.
@Interioroutbreak69 Vader's childish nos have to be the worst. Whether this justifies Anakin or not, this was stupid. How can this fool be the chosen one
what bothers me the most about this is that you shouldn't be able to hear him say it that loud anyway, the lightning drowned luke's shouting out well enough...
what made this brilliant is how he said nothing when he did this, but you could tell what he was thinkinh by the WAY he did it
I thought being a "fan boy" was restricted to 10 year old kids who have no sense or experience at all. Apparently I was wrong. FFS so what he added it, what the fuck is the problem. All bitching about 2 words, go get fucked (literally).
Interesting. So what, like in another 10 years Lucus is going to add more dialogue after Vader collapses? "Fuck my *destiny,*" or something? In any event, I still enjoy Star wars for what it has always been...fun entertainment.
I have no problem with any of the changes. I actually like them, to be honest. HOWEVER, I do take issue with there not being a purchasable widescreen, cleaned up, but otherwise unaltered version of the movies for those who want them. If for nothing other than collectability, nostalgia, and completeness.
@Vamphaery: But they do have that. The second DVD releases include the unaltered original movies. As far as Blu-Ray goes, we're still shit out of luck, though.
Ok, I think we've well enough established now that George Lucas is trolling us. He took the most ridiculous and oft-derided part of the prequel trilogy and slathered it all over the climatic scene in the original trilogy. He still refuses to let Han shoot first and thus establish his character and he's releasing them in 3D just for to milk it. Trolololololo.
people really its still the same movie little changes thoe they look moe real life now and the no i dont care about i kinda like it shows more emetion from vader sincewe cant see his face ok
Wasn't this a spur of the moment attack? Something that the Emperor wasn't expecting? When he screams "NO!", terribly I might add, you'd think that the Emperor would catch on.
@HaloModder555 To be honest, at this point the Emperor didnt give two craps about Vader. Right from probably halfway through Empire, he figured he could use Vader to turn Luke to the darkside, and dispose of Vader, who at the time was under complete manipulation of the Emporer, thought inside probably questioning his loyalty. In other words, the Emperor was too focused on tormenting Luke until he gave in, that he ignored Vader.
If he didn't care about Vader and was quick to rid himself of him, he would have destroyed Vader the instant he acted out of line. Yes he was focused on tormenting Luke in his last moments, if they were his last moments as your comment implies, in an effort to force him to turn on the threat of his life. No, it was intended that he would destroy Luke as he was content with keeping Vader until a replacement could be found. In this case, Leia. Vader caught the powerful, frail Emperor by surprise.
Nah Emperor had no idea about Leia, Vader did, but the Emperor didnt, until about 3 years prior he didnt even know about Luke.
He saw Luke as his next apprentice. As soon as Vader was reborn into the cyber suit, the Emperor was disgusted. He hated how Vader was less powerful than he was meant to be, but seeing as he reformed the repulblic and technically things went according to plan, he put up with Vader as a further symbol of fear.
Going to further add, this is obvious from the outset of ROTJ. The Emperor practically set up the assault on the second death star. He figured he could crush the rebellion (He hadnt counted on the ewoks though), and use this to show Luke, who he had planned to have watching. He believed because Luke was born out of Padme's torment and is so much like his father, he could use the same thing he did with Anakin, with Luke, and play his emotions.
Who's the asshole that fucked this up? "NO!" was the most cheesiest lines in ROTS. Why do you bring it back? This is worse than the editing of the Krayt Dragon roar.
@NiCk14AlPhA I can kinda see it for that reason. After all, Anakin is the father of Luke and the "fear" that got drilled into him the first place by the Emperor to become the second person known Vader. Not a bad concept just to add those two lines in, doesn't mean the film became a failure. So I completely agree by your hypothesis!
@InsidiousBo The fact that people say the prequels were bad and so many changes are horrible, is one sided. It depends how much people understand the films and reasoning, and how many people just jump on the "worst thing to happen to star wars was George Lucas" bandwagon.
I agree at times changed can be stupid and in some ways, the OT was better, but it doesnt make the prequels bad. They make sense, help fuel the OT AND introduce star wars to a new generation.
Trade Federation primarily, nute gunray is the overlord of that, Darth Maul too as the Jedi realise the Sith have returned but they dont know if he was master or apprentice. And if you wana be REAL technical, Senator Palpatine, as **SPOILERS** hes the Emperor later on, he uses the whole of EP1 to get power.
Thats why i like EP1, it shows exactly HOW events began.
No he should alter them however he wants. Its his series, not the fans.
The fact is so many older people prefer the old ones they forget what star wars is about. Its not about Luke. It never was. It was always about Anakin. Even in the OT. It was about how he turned back to the light side.
If Lucas had not done the prequels, fans would moan anyway wanting them. He did them to explain what happened.
Even episode 1. It explain Ankins early trauma and how Palpatine got in power.
@NiCk14AlPhA that'd be fine if George was altering them for his own personal use. but that fact is george alters these movies, then those versions are the ONLY ones available, it's not like when people complain about remakes, because the original is still available. there's no originals available when he does this garbage. he shouldn't just alter them however he wants to, because he is not the consumer. i don't want a version of star wars where greedo shoots first. george lucas is a fool.
Your both wrong and right. More to the right but still...
Your the consumer but then again he's the one who owns rights and is allowed to change them. This is a technical age, there would be the same moaning if nothing was done about it. Film industry is alive, and you can still buy originals or none changed and all that, plenty of sites show it. If im honest, Star Wars is still as classic and real as it always has been.
@NiCk14AlPhA "Its his series", check again, Gary Kurtz was the talent behind Star Wars, he came up with images that would later become legendary.
Not to mention, I grew up when the prequels came out and I still hate them, don't you know anything about subtly? This scene wasn't about Luke, it was Vader redeeming himself, you didn't need ANY dialogue.
You have no idea that you are being fooled into falling for them CGI toys commercials, anyone who's seen RedLetterMedia knows such.
Images, not story and idea though. Plus its Lucasfilm who makes them.
And i know this is about Vader, and it didnt need it, but its not ruined by it either. Vader says no to himself, in fact Anakin probably screams at Vader and breaks out. Early in the film this is evident of it, when he tells Luke its too late for him, Ankins sorrow is shining through there.
And there is no fooling anything. I still prefer the OT, which i have recorded, even though i grew up with the prequels.
@NiCk14AlPhA Fair enough if you interpret this as Anakin breaking through, but that can easily be told without the 'Nooo!', him throwing the Emperor over the balcony is more than enough to show this, there didn't need to be any dialogue, it's obvious whatever spark Lucas had when he directed Star Wars has died, the man knows nothing about art- hence the patronising dialogue of PT.
@cybersaur No i agree, there didnt need to be any what so ever, i prefer it without dialogue. And well i dont think so. Many of the things in the prequels are ideas that never came to life fully. I think Coruscunt is one of those, along with Vaders talent of flying when he was younger.
All im saying, is that out of some of the changes in the past, this is one of those that isnt SO bad. I mean, it still has that emotional feel, especially now the saga is complete, he said "No" finally to Sidious
@NiCk14AlPhA Well maybe i should say, "No" to sidious and himself. No dount he saw Palpatine doing almost what he himself had done to Padme, realising the Sith stop at nothing for greed.
@NiCk14AlPhA I get what you're saying, but the camera work alone is good enough to tell that the Jedi inside of Vader is returning. The giant "no" really wasn't necessary at all.
@NiCk14AlPhA No, you see, it is an abomination because it's the difference between good filmmaking and hack schlock. The original scene conveyed Vader's conflict and emotional state through pure cinema; lighting, camera work, etc. It was beautifully executed. This just shits all over that subtlety and art with a big dumb hammer to the face, "DO YOU GET IT? IT'S DRAMATIC. GET IT?"
Yeah, we got it before and it was really moving, now it's stupid.
He sounds simple. Just a short "No" as in nope, not gonna happen, now you gonna get tossed. Would have worked. Something understated and final. Change bad. This change? Worse.
my thoughts on it.. while it's endearing i can see why they took it out and which one it actually came from. It's the "no" from Ep. III when Vader had learned about Padme's death.
The art of it all was that you could really feel what darth vader's emotions and facial expression were throughout the movie without him having to speak. Why ruin this?
@pelle1243 sry, fraid not ^^" I always felt the moment before Vader picked up the emperor was a tad empty/missing something, but this is not at all what I had in mind.
The entire point of the scene is that he's making the most difficult decision of his life, and even though we can't see his face, we're going through the process with him due to his body language.
...BUT NO. AUDIENCES ARE FUCKING RETARDS WHO NEED THE MOVIE TO TELL THEM WHAT THE CHARACTER IS THINKING. EVEN THOUGH THEY'VE KNOWN EXACTLY WHAT HE DOES IN THAT SCENE FOR 30 FUCKING YEARS. JUST LIKE LUKE JUMPING INTO THE PIT IN BESPIN. AND JUST LIKE THAT, THE SOUND QUALITY IS SHIT. FUCK YOU LUCAS.
lol. it was literally 3 seconds! sure, it wasn't needed, but i don't see how this ruins the movie at all. sometimes i hate to call myself a star wars fan. you're all just whiny little bitches.
The second "no" is taken from the Episode III ending when Vader learns Padme is dead. That was cheap using the same voice clip instead of asking James E. Jones to dub it again :(
did he really do that? this was so unnecessary. it was much better when we could imagine what Vader was really thinking when he killed Sidious and metaphorically killed himself to redeem Anakin
did he really do that? this was so unnecessary. even if his argument is to make Anakin/Vader come full circle and become Anakin again, it was unnecessary. it was much better when we could imagine what Vader was really thinking when he killed Sidious and metaphorically killed himself to redeem Anakin
George does it because he hasn't moved onto any other projects since Star Wars, he's had nothing to keep him busy so he's made it a habit to go back and change the original trilogy. He doesn't care what he changes, it mean nothing to him, he just thinks it's fun to see how the scene would play out if he changed say greedo shooting first or vader saying nooo, The sooner he dies the better. No doubt Lucasfilm will release the original trilogy in original form to honor Lucas when he dies.
chuggyman1 13 minutes ago
It just sounds cheesy..I wouldn't mind so much, but it's just so cheesy.
MrPie455 6 hours ago
now that sounds really stupid.... should i get the bluray collection or the dvd??? help anyone!!!!!!!!
youthnando91 11 hours ago
He has amazing recovery time for a guy who was just ELECTROCUTED.
OneTrickMouse 1 day ago
P.s. George Lucas knows the Nooo was a horrible scene, putting it in this shows he's an asshole. I have many times a day where I could do things just to mess with people when I know they're wrong, but I don't. I'm done being a star wars fan, this shit killed it. I have enough assholes in real life, no need to support another one.
Iwakuhito10 1 day ago
I love all the people who don't get why changing a film or anything that means so much to someone, is "such a big deal" It's just showing the flaw of society that you are joining. You don't care so no one should? Are you that self centered and self obsessed? Go watch Jersey Shore...your opinion matters not. Just because I don't ride horses doesn't mean everyone who does is stupid and we should kill all the horses. By the way...Horses aren't bad people...people who don't get changing star wars m
Iwakuhito10 2 days ago
Are people seriously making a big deal out of this? I think it fits fine.
TayoEXE 2 days ago
For everyone who is saying that it's "his movie and he can do what he wants to with it," why couldn't he just put this on one disc and keep it for himself, and instead let the fans enjoy the originals in high quality and not FORCE THEM TO PUT UP WITH THIS LOAD OF CRAP!
MasterROBO360 2 days ago
I can't wait to see what Lucas changes next. Better yet, I can't wait 'til he announces what went through his mind when he added this crap to one of my favorite movies of all time!
MasterROBO360 2 days ago
@MasterROBO360 Gee, I'm going to re-release all the Star Wars movies on Blu-Ray, and I want to make some changes to them, and most of the fans seem to dislike Jar-Jar Binks. Hmm...
*This video*
There, that should make everyone happy
giyth 2 days ago
Jeeze, who do you think you are, Vader? Wyatt Erp?
JRYStudios1 2 days ago
do not want
lookatmepleasesir 2 days ago
Wow...that doesn't seem to be that big of a deal.
AbsoluteVirtue18 3 days ago
@AbsoluteVirtue18 well then watch krayt dragon call, jedi rocks, or greedo shoots first
Interioroutbreak69 2 days ago
Wait... No? OHHH I get it now. See, Darth Vader didn't LIKE that the Emperor was torturing his son, so THAT'S why he killed him. Thanks, George!
RevengeOfTheKaizer 3 days ago
Serious Star Wars fans are so pathetic... He said No. this doesn't make this scene bad are you fucking kidding me? Stop crying...
xXNeWorldOrderXx 4 days ago
Wow this is pretty fucked
somepunxguy 4 days ago
HAHAHAHAH
speednecromancer666 4 days ago
I think this is the dumb downed version because back in the day the music and acting clearley showed vader needed to make a hard choice but in the end chose the good side and killed the emporor. But now they need him to simply say "no" to make that point across
SamFTheCriticKid 4 days ago
I don't mind Rontos walking around Mos Eisley and CGI Jabba in New Hope. But wow this is horrible
WillBNunn 4 days ago
Comment removed
chuggyman1 5 days ago
IT'S RUINED!!! OH MY GOD, IT'S RUINED!!! VADER SOUNDS LIKE A RETARD!!!
TheMike000Man 5 days ago 3
Goegre Lucas, Destroying His Own Franchise instead of Moving on to make New Movies.
conradojavier 5 days ago 2
I'm seriously starting to doubt Lucas's sanity.
Colddeed 6 days ago
Suddenly all that added CG and special effects seems trivial compared to Lucas tainting the greatest moment in the Star Wars saga. If you have the original copies, hold on to them dearly because their value has only sky rocketed more, and I'm sure Lucas would want them destroyed.
Jordanime 6 days ago
I officially hate George Lucas
Colddeed 6 days ago
nooooooooooooooo(dot)com
real site
HellsSpot 6 days ago
To be honest, out of all the changes, the jedi rocks song is the worst
Interioroutbreak69 6 days ago
LOL, lightsaber rating bar, in a Star Wars video.
TheMike000Man 6 days ago
Comment removed
TheMike000Man 6 days ago
lucas: james can i get your'e voice for a new scene
james: what
lucas: im adding a new no
james: no
lucas: thats perfect thanks
james:nooooooo
darthmaul446 6 days ago 3
they should just left the no in part 3 not put it in this one
darthadrian98 1 week ago
Vader whined "NO... No..." like a little girl. WTF. My Jedi and Whills, just save me from this horrible change. Someone with the Force, protect the OT from Lucas old man himself, PLEASE !!
Yodaaaa1 1 week ago 10
@Yodaaaa1 These so called "Fans" That are calling for Lucas head make me sick! You want to save Star Wars from Lucas! that's like saying I wanna protect Nike from Michael Jordan! It's ridiculous... but i'll say this fans like you have won, because he said he's now done with it all! Thanks to all you "Fans" you got your wish..............
RIPKENOBI 6 days ago in playlist Liked videos
@RIPKENOBI Suppose an artist painted something beautiful that had an impact on your life. Now suppose that artist returned to his painting 20 years later to 'enhance' it by putting a big red stripe across it. That is exactly how I feel about what Lucas has done here.
Jordanime 6 days ago
Comment removed
Yodaaaa1 6 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@RIPKENOBI:you didn't read my phrase well. I said "save it from Lucas old man", not from Lucas of 1977 or 1980. He once made excellent movies (a long time ago), but with the time being now he tends to spoil them more than polish them. I don't object to changes, but I don't want a change which DAMAGES the movie. Like if Leonard de Vinci changed his mind later and replaced Mona Lisa's smile with a big grin to show all her teeth. Yeah, victory. Hey, M.Jordan doesn't harm Nike a bit.
Yodaaaa1 6 days ago
Why the bloody hell did he add the no? It was FINE THE WAY IT WAS!
anakinfan12002 1 week ago
My childhood.. noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.
Berrylaff 1 week ago
I CAN'T SEEM TO HIT THE DISLIKE BUTTON HARD ENOUGH!
SiDN64 1 week ago
George Lucas will never beat Walt Disney himself. I can't believe I am actually quoting Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 3, but all men die, but only some with honor. George would never get that honor as Walt Disney did and that is why Disney's awesome. Star Tours looks way better than any of Lucas's remakes or special effects. In addition, 20th Century Fox was the REAL genius behind the original Star Wars films!
SirGabriel2076 1 week ago
@SirGabriel2076 "Death comes to us all, but something much worse waits for you. For when you die, it will be... with out HONOR"
BouncingFerretFilms 1 week ago
Vader's respirator is shite.
LetumFilms 1 week ago
This version makes this scene very reminiscent to the Mace Windu-Palpatine scene in Episode III.
killswitchred19 1 week ago
@TheDarthEddie Thanks to the Blu Ray Edition, Vader is STILL EMO! underneath that Mask.
conradojavier 1 week ago
@chuggyman1 They'll Hire some Ewan McGregor look-a-like for the Stunt.
conradojavier 1 week ago
The reason I liked the return of the jedi (the original) was because of this scene. The music was kind off speaking for Vader and made him look more wounreable and humanly then he is represented. I felt empathy for Vader and was stunned the first time I saw him throwing Sidious to his death, Vader didn't need a "NO" to show that he cared about his son and wanted to kill the empreror. The music and the good acting made it clearly on it's own.
HalvLion 1 week ago 16
You guys are like kids getting all butthurt over simple changes. I really don't give 2 craps about these as long as he doesn't change plots or gets rid of scenes.
sems1193 1 week ago
Although "Nooo" is one of the most common lines in Star Wars, this fits well like a hedgehog in my pants.
andraken 1 week ago
Darth Haters
PinkiePie42069 1 week ago
i know the fanboys are all whining like little kids, but think about it this way. which is better, two trilogies that bear no continuity together, or a saga that, after some editing, makes more sense. I mean, after filming in the wrong order, and story changes to fit said filming, is it so wrong that he wants to change a few things so that it makes sense as a whole rather than two separate trilogies?
InhabitantOfOddworld 1 week ago
@InhabitantOfOddworld Amen brother XP
ToroPetrucci2010 1 week ago
Would you all just get over it?
Oh wait, that's expecting too much.
Niko1Linni 1 week ago
This is really what happened, Vader basically witnesses Mace Windu's death back in Episode III, but now, he witnesses his son dying. That's why he screams "Nooo"
SpyOperator 1 week ago
@SpyOperator Lucas could have use Stock Footage of the Prequel Trilogy(as Flashbacks) like Obi Wan's "YOU'RE THE CHOOSEN ONE" Voices & Splice it in for the 3D Released of the Original Trilogy.
conradojavier 1 week ago
@conradojavier actually I'm working on that now.lol like...at this very moment. Great minds think alike I guess
ToroPetrucci2010 1 week ago
@ToroPetrucci2010 I give Lucas a New Idea for the 3D Released.
conradojavier 1 week ago
@conradojavier That WOULD be amazing to see in 3D, my friend :D
ToroPetrucci2010 1 week ago
Why so many dislikes? Somebody can explain?
JotyCauldron 1 week ago
@JotyCauldron Star Wars Die Hard Fanboys.
notforvideos 1 week ago
Mr. Lucas... thank you for retiring.
JaddenSinn 1 week ago
George Lucas is not doing this for any other reason than "justifying" that stupid lame no at the end of episode 3... The originals were amazing the way they were. Greedo Never shot first!
spartanjedi41 1 week ago
Is this really what everyone is on about? I honestly don't think its all that bad. All i care about is the story and luckily enough that hasn't been changed . . . yet. But seriously get over it.
creevaghmiddle 1 week ago
@creevaghmiddle Well fucking said dude, its just a movie right?
IngloriousBasterd96 1 week ago
@IngloriousBasterd96 To me they are just a fantastic set of films, to some they defined childhoods, to others its a way of life. I don't mind these changes too much as long as the story is NEVER changed.
creevaghmiddle 6 days ago
@creevaghmiddle Well said!
RIPKENOBI 6 days ago in playlist Liked videos
If you don't like it. That's what the 'mute' button is for.
jmonkey39511 1 week ago
I don't mind this change.
exhelzar 1 week ago
I dont know whats worse, Greedo shooting first, Vaders childish nos, or the ridiculous Krayt dragon call.
Interioroutbreak69 1 week ago
@Interioroutbreak69 Vader's childish nos have to be the worst. Whether this justifies Anakin or not, this was stupid. How can this fool be the chosen one
dahnamics1 1 week ago
It was going ok until that second retarded "no!"
thenerdcorner 1 week ago
George Lucas won't be happy until money is printed with his face on it or all the original unaltered VHS copies are destroyed.
Cyberspecter125 1 week ago
what bothers me the most about this is that you shouldn't be able to hear him say it that loud anyway, the lightning drowned luke's shouting out well enough...
what made this brilliant is how he said nothing when he did this, but you could tell what he was thinkinh by the WAY he did it
DarkAveVamp 1 week ago
Comment removed
DarkAveVamp 1 week ago
I love how everyones flipping out for him saying No...I love the blue ray changes.
MartyTurco093 1 week ago
I don't know about you guys, but I think it's pretty good.
WookieRebellion501 1 week ago
I thought being a "fan boy" was restricted to 10 year old kids who have no sense or experience at all. Apparently I was wrong. FFS so what he added it, what the fuck is the problem. All bitching about 2 words, go get fucked (literally).
dbzssjgohan 1 week ago
Shit
I ain't mad at cha George
Got nothin' but love ya
Do ya thang boy!
DUNNJIN 2 weeks ago
Star Wars is getting yet another re-release with more changes?
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
AlexSKaras 2 weeks ago
Interesting. So what, like in another 10 years Lucus is going to add more dialogue after Vader collapses? "Fuck my *destiny,*" or something? In any event, I still enjoy Star wars for what it has always been...fun entertainment.
CreeDaylen 2 weeks ago
@CreeDaylen no. Lucas will give Vader a third No. NOOOOooooOOOOOoooooOOOOOO
dahnamics1 1 week ago
I actually prefer this.
Jerred38 2 weeks ago
That's the power of please kids!!!
MDR173 2 weeks ago
I don't have a problem with this, but I do like the original better.
starflame34 2 weeks ago
I have no problem with any of the changes. I actually like them, to be honest. HOWEVER, I do take issue with there not being a purchasable widescreen, cleaned up, but otherwise unaltered version of the movies for those who want them. If for nothing other than collectability, nostalgia, and completeness.
Vamphaery 2 weeks ago
@Vamphaery: But they do have that. The second DVD releases include the unaltered original movies. As far as Blu-Ray goes, we're still shit out of luck, though.
cigoLxeL 2 weeks ago
@cigoLxeL Yeah but they're not cleaned up or widescreen.
Vamphaery 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Ok, I think we've well enough established now that George Lucas is trolling us. He took the most ridiculous and oft-derided part of the prequel trilogy and slathered it all over the climatic scene in the original trilogy. He still refuses to let Han shoot first and thus establish his character and he's releasing them in 3D just for to milk it. Trolololololo.
MeBeMat 2 weeks ago
i personally think it adds more emotion to the scene as you can hear his realizing of what he must do.
MoSockra 2 weeks ago
I have no problem with this....
TooPhatProd 2 weeks ago
Fake. . .
SincerelyFacetlous 2 weeks ago
am I te only one who's okay with this? I don't think its that bad. Obiwans dragon call...I laugh at that.
MMCLProductions 2 weeks ago
As italian I hope that Vader's italian voice had dubbed this Nooo in better way. The italian Vader (or Fener) have a more human voice, in general
AmuroRei89 2 weeks ago
Cool lightsaber!
Oh wait... it's the dislike bar.
Trexmaster12 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
Interioroutbreak69 2 weeks ago
i was thinking of buying star wars on blu-ray, so i rented it first, this scene made me decide to buy a second hand 6 disc limited edition instead
phlayme 2 weeks ago
I am so glad I own Star Wars on VHS
dogsoldier03 2 weeks ago 21
its a mad house A MAD HOUSE
comeon84 2 weeks ago
its a mad house A MAD HOUSE
comeon84 2 weeks ago
people really its still the same movie little changes thoe they look moe real life now and the no i dont care about i kinda like it shows more emetion from vader sincewe cant see his face ok
darthcyon 2 weeks ago
@darthcyon That was the whole point, You can't see his face. But you can still tell he has emotion.
TF2Gmod 2 weeks ago
If he pulled off the helmet and it was Haydenn Christensen, would anyone be surprised?
ngilford1 2 weeks ago
It's better this way. I didn't understand this scene when I say the original version.
Sheraf83 2 weeks ago
Noooooo, why the hell did Lucas that? o.O
steal27 2 weeks ago
Wasn't this a spur of the moment attack? Something that the Emperor wasn't expecting? When he screams "NO!", terribly I might add, you'd think that the Emperor would catch on.
HaloModder555 2 weeks ago
@HaloModder555 To be honest, at this point the Emperor didnt give two craps about Vader. Right from probably halfway through Empire, he figured he could use Vader to turn Luke to the darkside, and dispose of Vader, who at the time was under complete manipulation of the Emporer, thought inside probably questioning his loyalty. In other words, the Emperor was too focused on tormenting Luke until he gave in, that he ignored Vader.
"The Sith, always betray each other."
NiCk14AlPhA 2 weeks ago
If he didn't care about Vader and was quick to rid himself of him, he would have destroyed Vader the instant he acted out of line. Yes he was focused on tormenting Luke in his last moments, if they were his last moments as your comment implies, in an effort to force him to turn on the threat of his life. No, it was intended that he would destroy Luke as he was content with keeping Vader until a replacement could be found. In this case, Leia. Vader caught the powerful, frail Emperor by surprise.
HaloModder555 2 weeks ago
@HaloModder555
Nah Emperor had no idea about Leia, Vader did, but the Emperor didnt, until about 3 years prior he didnt even know about Luke.
He saw Luke as his next apprentice. As soon as Vader was reborn into the cyber suit, the Emperor was disgusted. He hated how Vader was less powerful than he was meant to be, but seeing as he reformed the repulblic and technically things went according to plan, he put up with Vader as a further symbol of fear.
Emperor wanted Luke because of his power.
NiCk14AlPhA 2 weeks ago
@NiCk14AlPhA
Going to further add, this is obvious from the outset of ROTJ. The Emperor practically set up the assault on the second death star. He figured he could crush the rebellion (He hadnt counted on the ewoks though), and use this to show Luke, who he had planned to have watching. He believed because Luke was born out of Padme's torment and is so much like his father, he could use the same thing he did with Anakin, with Luke, and play his emotions.
But he didnt count on the teddybears.
NiCk14AlPhA 2 weeks ago
Who's the asshole that fucked this up? "NO!" was the most cheesiest lines in ROTS. Why do you bring it back? This is worse than the editing of the Krayt Dragon roar.
HaloModder555 2 weeks ago
The scene was better before, but its not actually a complete abomination, if you understand the whole saga, the codes, the conventions, everything.
That wasn't Vader saying no to palpatine.
That was Anakin saying no and breaking out of Vader.
Think about that hypothesis for a second, it sort of makes sense.
NiCk14AlPhA 2 weeks ago 15
@NiCk14AlPhA I can kinda see it for that reason. After all, Anakin is the father of Luke and the "fear" that got drilled into him the first place by the Emperor to become the second person known Vader. Not a bad concept just to add those two lines in, doesn't mean the film became a failure. So I completely agree by your hypothesis!
InsidiousBo 2 weeks ago
@InsidiousBo The fact that people say the prequels were bad and so many changes are horrible, is one sided. It depends how much people understand the films and reasoning, and how many people just jump on the "worst thing to happen to star wars was George Lucas" bandwagon.
I agree at times changed can be stupid and in some ways, the OT was better, but it doesnt make the prequels bad. They make sense, help fuel the OT AND introduce star wars to a new generation.
They're all great films, even ep1
NiCk14AlPhA 2 weeks ago
@NiCk14AlPhA Who is the protagonist in The Phantom Menace?
i7omahawki 2 weeks ago
@i7omahawki
Uhhh....number of foes.
Trade Federation primarily, nute gunray is the overlord of that, Darth Maul too as the Jedi realise the Sith have returned but they dont know if he was master or apprentice. And if you wana be REAL technical, Senator Palpatine, as **SPOILERS** hes the Emperor later on, he uses the whole of EP1 to get power.
Thats why i like EP1, it shows exactly HOW events began.
NiCk14AlPhA 2 weeks ago
@i7omahawki
A-men to that, however in my opinon i dont like this new scene xD
But i can see why Lucas did it...
NiCk14AlPhA 2 weeks ago
@NiCk14AlPhA Everything he said. And please, let's stop bashing every single change made by Lucas, they're not all that bad...
cecckino89 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
kc86er 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@NiCk14AlPhA Still, it wasn't necessary. It's actually more emotionally powerful when he isn't saying a word.
kc86er 2 weeks ago
@NiCk14AlPhA Lucas shoud alter the prequels to fit in with these films, not vice-versa.
cybersaur 2 weeks ago
@cybersaur
No he should alter them however he wants. Its his series, not the fans.
The fact is so many older people prefer the old ones they forget what star wars is about. Its not about Luke. It never was. It was always about Anakin. Even in the OT. It was about how he turned back to the light side.
If Lucas had not done the prequels, fans would moan anyway wanting them. He did them to explain what happened.
Even episode 1. It explain Ankins early trauma and how Palpatine got in power.
NiCk14AlPhA 2 weeks ago
@NiCk14AlPhA that'd be fine if George was altering them for his own personal use. but that fact is george alters these movies, then those versions are the ONLY ones available, it's not like when people complain about remakes, because the original is still available. there's no originals available when he does this garbage. he shouldn't just alter them however he wants to, because he is not the consumer. i don't want a version of star wars where greedo shoots first. george lucas is a fool.
sagerbj86 2 weeks ago
@sagerbj86
Your both wrong and right. More to the right but still...
Your the consumer but then again he's the one who owns rights and is allowed to change them. This is a technical age, there would be the same moaning if nothing was done about it. Film industry is alive, and you can still buy originals or none changed and all that, plenty of sites show it. If im honest, Star Wars is still as classic and real as it always has been.
NiCk14AlPhA 1 week ago
@NiCk14AlPhA "Its his series", check again, Gary Kurtz was the talent behind Star Wars, he came up with images that would later become legendary.
Not to mention, I grew up when the prequels came out and I still hate them, don't you know anything about subtly? This scene wasn't about Luke, it was Vader redeeming himself, you didn't need ANY dialogue.
You have no idea that you are being fooled into falling for them CGI toys commercials, anyone who's seen RedLetterMedia knows such.
cybersaur 1 week ago
@cybersaur
Images, not story and idea though. Plus its Lucasfilm who makes them.
And i know this is about Vader, and it didnt need it, but its not ruined by it either. Vader says no to himself, in fact Anakin probably screams at Vader and breaks out. Early in the film this is evident of it, when he tells Luke its too late for him, Ankins sorrow is shining through there.
And there is no fooling anything. I still prefer the OT, which i have recorded, even though i grew up with the prequels.
NiCk14AlPhA 1 week ago
@NiCk14AlPhA Fair enough if you interpret this as Anakin breaking through, but that can easily be told without the 'Nooo!', him throwing the Emperor over the balcony is more than enough to show this, there didn't need to be any dialogue, it's obvious whatever spark Lucas had when he directed Star Wars has died, the man knows nothing about art- hence the patronising dialogue of PT.
cybersaur 1 week ago
@cybersaur No i agree, there didnt need to be any what so ever, i prefer it without dialogue. And well i dont think so. Many of the things in the prequels are ideas that never came to life fully. I think Coruscunt is one of those, along with Vaders talent of flying when he was younger.
All im saying, is that out of some of the changes in the past, this is one of those that isnt SO bad. I mean, it still has that emotional feel, especially now the saga is complete, he said "No" finally to Sidious
NiCk14AlPhA 1 week ago
@NiCk14AlPhA Well maybe i should say, "No" to sidious and himself. No dount he saw Palpatine doing almost what he himself had done to Padme, realising the Sith stop at nothing for greed.
NiCk14AlPhA 1 week ago
@NiCk14AlPhA
Ah screw it.
Usul573 2 weeks ago
@NiCk14AlPhA Well said mate.
flaminhotz5 1 week ago
@NiCk14AlPhA I get what you're saying, but the camera work alone is good enough to tell that the Jedi inside of Vader is returning. The giant "no" really wasn't necessary at all.
DaBeastlyness 1 week ago
@NiCk14AlPhA No, you see, it is an abomination because it's the difference between good filmmaking and hack schlock. The original scene conveyed Vader's conflict and emotional state through pure cinema; lighting, camera work, etc. It was beautifully executed. This just shits all over that subtlety and art with a big dumb hammer to the face, "DO YOU GET IT? IT'S DRAMATIC. GET IT?"
Yeah, we got it before and it was really moving, now it's stupid.
trinityj1 1 week ago
@NiCk14AlPhA
NNNNOOOOOOoooooooooooooooo!!!!!!
freezerbabies 1 week ago
He sounds simple. Just a short "No" as in nope, not gonna happen, now you gonna get tossed. Would have worked. Something understated and final. Change bad. This change? Worse.
wackywankavator 2 weeks ago
No! NO! WHAT THE FUCK NO. Are you kidding me, why the hell would you mess with this scene?
elieri 2 weeks ago
my thoughts on it.. while it's endearing i can see why they took it out and which one it actually came from. It's the "no" from Ep. III when Vader had learned about Padme's death.
AMelodyLost 2 weeks ago
The art of it all was that you could really feel what darth vader's emotions and facial expression were throughout the movie without him having to speak. Why ruin this?
ProletarianTakeover 2 weeks ago
Is this a joke?
pelle1243 2 weeks ago
@pelle1243 sry, fraid not ^^" I always felt the moment before Vader picked up the emperor was a tad empty/missing something, but this is not at all what I had in mind.
Gyarretto7 2 weeks ago
Luke Skywalker as the Original Trilogy Unaltered
Palpatine as Geogre Lucas
Darth Vader as the Fanboys
conradojavier 2 weeks ago
considering some of the other cheesy add-ins, this is pretty tame guys. Plus i think we can all agree that ep 1's crackhead yoda puppet had to go.
StyrofoamTumor 2 weeks ago
Sigh....
chadrageus 2 weeks ago
And this is the reason I'm not seeing Star Wars in 3D, it's just going to encourage him to keep re releasing and changing them.
The worst part is that he didn't even direct the film and he's altering it
EmoKidRH 2 weeks ago
@Guamx2010 For one thing, it went down the pit along with his hand. Unless of course they changed that too.
ProtoKun7 2 weeks ago
@ProtoKun7
As horrible as that fucking sounds whats more likely to happen is Lucas replaces the legendary JEJ with Chad Vader -_-
akumatekkusu666 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
Interioroutbreak69 2 weeks ago
@Interioroutbreak69 no
youngboysnation 2 weeks ago
The entire point of the scene is that he's making the most difficult decision of his life, and even though we can't see his face, we're going through the process with him due to his body language.
...BUT NO. AUDIENCES ARE FUCKING RETARDS WHO NEED THE MOVIE TO TELL THEM WHAT THE CHARACTER IS THINKING. EVEN THOUGH THEY'VE KNOWN EXACTLY WHAT HE DOES IN THAT SCENE FOR 30 FUCKING YEARS. JUST LIKE LUKE JUMPING INTO THE PIT IN BESPIN. AND JUST LIKE THAT, THE SOUND QUALITY IS SHIT. FUCK YOU LUCAS.
akumatekkusu666 2 weeks ago 2
All the more reason why I'm NEVER selling my original 1977-1983 Star Wars VHS tapes before any changes were made
historyfreakfroman 2 weeks ago in playlist Star Wars 24
@historyfreakfroman you sir, are a god. i wish i was born when these were just being released, i hate my generation
AyJayG002 2 weeks ago
@AyJayG002 Actually my parents owned them, I was nine years old when these movies were re-released in theaters when he added CGI effects
historyfreakfroman 2 weeks ago
@historyfreakfroman still, i envy you
AyJayG002 2 weeks ago
Sounds like he just found out he was knocked up.
JordoF6 2 weeks ago
lol. it was literally 3 seconds! sure, it wasn't needed, but i don't see how this ruins the movie at all. sometimes i hate to call myself a star wars fan. you're all just whiny little bitches.
xsonicx08 3 weeks ago
my balls george, please not my balls
oxygentramp42 3 weeks ago
Huh.....well, Ironically, the only thing I can really say about this change is,
No.
VirtualBoy500 3 weeks ago
uhh,wtf happened to taking out your light saber and stabbing him with it??
Guamx2010 3 weeks ago
The second "no" is taken from the Episode III ending when Vader learns Padme is dead. That was cheap using the same voice clip instead of asking James E. Jones to dub it again :(
Sacrenouille 3 weeks ago
@Sacrenouille They'll let Chad Vader say "NOOOOOOOOOOOO" in the 3D Released.
conradojavier 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
did he really do that? this was so unnecessary. it was much better when we could imagine what Vader was really thinking when he killed Sidious and metaphorically killed himself to redeem Anakin
dahnamics1 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
did he really do that? this was so unnecessary. even if his argument is to make Anakin/Vader come full circle and become Anakin again, it was unnecessary. it was much better when we could imagine what Vader was really thinking when he killed Sidious and metaphorically killed himself to redeem Anakin
dahnamics1 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
dahnamics1 3 weeks ago
Comment removed
Interioroutbreak69 3 weeks ago
@Interioroutbreak69 Because this is a real change Lucas made for the blu ray. It aint a parody.
DEACONFROST11 3 weeks ago
holy shit cameras were better in those days than they are now!
CRYOmine 3 weeks ago
Totally killed the drama.
SJMJ91 3 weeks ago
Fans watch as Lucas alters film, sees what he does, "NOOOOO!" grab Lucas and throw him into the pit of retirement.
BloodgulchPB 3 weeks ago
Lucas: I have altered the film, pray I don't alter it any further.
spartanjedi41 3 weeks ago
@spartanjedi41 lmfao.
RockStarPreacher 2 weeks ago
Why does George Lucas go back to his masterpiece and make it a piece of shit? I hate you for now ruining my greatest childhood memory of darth vader
spartanjedi41 3 weeks ago
George wanted to put a Gungan in Red Tails. He wasn't allowed, so hes going round saying Hollywood is racist. Intergalacticly Racist.