When I heard Johnny Cash sing Gordon Lightfoot's song it sent chills up though my spine. Though Don Williams did a nice version to Gordon's greatest hits!
I love Don williams...but the Lightfoot version is better. You can feel it more in Lightfoot's voice...almost like he is not singing it, but breathing it in and out.
This is one of the best versions I have heard. Even better than Gordon. I have many of his recordings, but never heard this one before. Any way he is one of my favourite recording artists. Great!
This song could have been written about me and my ex-wife. I haven't thought of this song in years. Was doing a search this morning for Don Williams songs and ran across it.
One thing is true, Don's vocal tone has remained with him throughout his entire life. Gordon's sort of lost his voice over the years as it sounded back in the 70's. Don still sounds amazingly good at his age. He's remained consistent throughout his career.
@JOYisREAL Maybe not "better" in a sense of words, but Don's version is definitely good musically. He does have a different vocal tone than Gordon Lightfoot, no doubt, but i'm sure he sang the cover with Gordon's blessing, otherwise it would not have been permitted to be done.
i'm going tosee Gordon tonight in Greensboro N.C. if there is aversion that Gordon would sit and listen to other than his own,im sure it would be this one. Don will be in Greensboro March 24 ihope i can make that one too
Well, I'm not Mr. Lightfoot but I'm glad your brother cut this.
My wife used to fall asleep listening to her dad and uncles singing your brother's songs. Even now I know that I can snap her out of a sad mood by playing one of Don's songs.
Thank you brother for me, it's the little things like that that help in the very hard work that is a good marriage.
@AustinRogers1 This song reminds me of being a little boy who lived for going for a ride with PaPaw...i was still innocent, had never had my heart broken, had no concept of how short life is, and i was sitting next to my Grandpa, who was God in my eyes, as he sang it wholeheartedly on the way to the farm to catch the turtles that came out of the creek to munch our lettuce lol. I love your brother's music- it was played at PaPaw's funeral and still makes me feel loved to hear it<3
HEY! Gordon Lightfoot is alive and well and innocent. He wrote this song after seeing an old black and white movie about a haunted wishing well and thought what a great idea for a song. I know this because I am CANADIAN and have been to several of his concerts, and I just received my ticket to his concert next May 21, 2011. Sheesh! The stuff you find on here. Really.
HEY! Gordon Lightfoot is alive and well and innocent. He wrote this song after seeing an old black and white movie about a haunted wishing well and thought what a great idea for a song. I know this because I am CANADIAN and have been to several of his concerts, and I just received my ticket to his concert next May 21, 2011. Sheesh! The stuff you find on here. Really.
Gordon Lightfood opend the book, Don Williams nailed it and Johnny Cash closed the book on this song. It's all a mather of taste, I'm not saying anyones best. Although I think the original deserves the most credit (in any case) I personally like Johnny Cash his version best.
I have always loved this song by Gordon , but I have always loved Don Williams. And in all the concerts I have seen, I have never seen him do this song. This is awesome
He sings from his heart. His words are soo pure and anyone can relate to his messages even though it is a Gordon Lightfoot song. Don williams just brings it out to me in a different way. Nothing but the upmost respect. My father introduced me to some of his songs and i can't stop listening to them.
Why isn't this fine singer on television ? This man is a great singer with a unique style. All you see on television these days are boys that make noise, not artist that make music. Our country men needs more men singers like him.
@elvinrock Not sure, but no matter what, he's an honorary Okie after writin' a hit like Tulsa Time !! Long live the Gentle Giant & his pork chops !!!
my dad loves these songs and weve past 2 hr now lisining to his songs even when u think ist super boring its not cuz just hering him sing the songs and smile makes it all worth wile
@cmmorty99 There are very few people within the country & western industry here in the USA who can even hold a candle to Gordon Lightfoot. They would include Kenny Rogers, willie Nelson, Kris Kristofferson and Don Williams.
@dudabraga Maybe she has a different look, some added color, but underneath she is still the beauty she always was. Perhaps you have to look a little closer now days, but you can find her if you try...
MY GIRLFRIEND told me bout Don Williams!! i didn't know him!! it's a real revelation for me!! very chraming voice and words for the heart and the spirit too!!
Just found out recently that Don Williams was part of "Pozo Seco" singers back around 1970- their lps were among the first I taped for play aboard a DD.
Same avoidance of "in your face" and excess. Plus, Susan Taylor.
Don Williams is singing this song, not Cash. Only a few of Don's songs didn't reach the top ten. Cash couldn't touch him, and only his addictions made him public more than his music. You are the Man Don and your heart as well as your songs is warm and beautiful..
"Don Williams will be inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame during a formal ceremony later this year. The prestigious announcement was made Tuesday morning (Feb. 23) by the Country Music Association."
I've heard a couple of Don's recordings before, and he's always impressed me. This is no exception. His interpretation of Gordon's classic tune is really beautiful.
Very nicely done. I' ve never heard Don before. He softens the edges that both Gordon and Johnny have when they sing this. BTW, I sing this song to my daughter every night at bedtime, and this version is the closest to how I sing it :-D
U gotta be very careful when U take on the solid talent of others and attempt their music & songs. I just hate it when ppl/ companies adapt material they should have left alone. Ian Tyson is solid and original and has the voice and talent to prove it. k d lang, the planets perfection in a female voice, can sing anyones song! A lot can try, but a classic version should be left alone.
This is a really beautiful version of Gordon Lightfoot's signature song. Takes a lot of courage to step up to the plate to sing a song that someone else has "
branded" and Don sure does it justice. Johnny Cash's version is poignant in its own way and courageous on his part to sing it on his American Recordings series, which was at the tail end of his life after his wife, June Carter, passed away. Johnny's interpretation has its very own beauty considering the point in his life.
this is the very best version of this song, Lightfoot's is amazing, but this is absolutely touching, Don is the best... a great legend, and if someone out there has not heard his voice they are truly missing out.
Cash's version is pathetic. As I listened to it I kept thinking if he was performing it on American Idol he would make the show, but only as the joke artist to be laughed at by all. His was truly a sad and horrible rendition of a great song.
what a horrible thing to say about such a great man, he was oviously at a very old age when he recorded, kinda like the song hurt, but it was not pathedic, whats is pathedic is you posting such negitive thins about elderly people who have given so much to music and charitys and so on........
@danescott1962 I thought Johnny did an incredible job with Hurt, as he did with any cover I ever heard by him. I've not heard him sing this, but I can't see him butchering it.
@frebert If you think about it, it took alot of guts to do that. Maybe it was his way of saying goodbye. 'course now that I'm over 50 I can appreciate that kinda stuff. None of us knows when their end will come. I just hope to live that long & be able to feed myself & not be in a diaper, let alone sing & produce music. Far be it from me to criticize one who traveled as far, high & low as the immortal Johnny Cash, all in one lifetime. Long live the Man in Black...the Original Outlaw!! Souie!!
Johnny Cash sang this when he was close to death. His version has a life of its own and is beautiful in its own way. its not a dick length contest. Just different versions of a beautiful song.
@immovable1, my kids are 18, 20, and 22. Cash's last recordings opened their eyes to some music they would have not known. They love all of his music, Cash transended more generations than most will ever hope to! RIP the man in Black.
@lucky8274 Lucky8274 Just to throw in my 2 cents, I have a real problem with a person who molests & kills someone, then is allowed to sit around watching TV, enjoying free room & board; the next 30 or so WorldSeries & SuperBowls; eating ReeceCups, free condoms w/free medical-dental care the rest of their life, as their victim is gone forever. What we really need is appeals process reform to shorten it. THEN we can put these creeps to sleep for good as it was intended. THAT will save $ !
True that... Always good to hear from the great state of Texas......... Never lose that Southern Pride! Might sound funny coming from a Canadian but I sure wish Canada was more like Texas in some ways... Need the right to pack the hogleg for protection nowadays. Peace...........
Why thanks buddy I ussually dont think the average canadian to be praisin texas and supportin southernpride, and yes everyone needs the right to death penalty its a lot more effective then keepin someone in jail for a lifetime
Nicely put... I ain't the "average Canadian". They tend to be too bleeding heart for my liking....freaken sheep! They want us all to feel guilty for living on the land that used to belong to the indians..................sheesh! Now it belongs to the east indians, and chinese and every other ese there is .......... anyhow great song!
@niobe00 ok so your sayin that if i kidnapped, raped and killed a young child I still shouldnt get the death penalty, or if I brutally stabed a family to death and ground up their bodys to meat I still shouldnt get the death penalty. Some people deserve to die for the atrocities they commit instead of rotting in a jail eatin up tax payers dollars. Now im a pretty compasionate person just not to phsycopath serial killers
@kyuss4me Wait just a minute. Are you saying Gordon Lightfoot wrote this song while he was on Death Row?! Amazing !! I guess that could be. After all he IS Canadian isn't he? Wow, so much talent up there in the Great White North!! Bob & Doug, Anne Murray, Gordon Lightfoot AND SCTV !! Gone are the good ol' days my friends. Long live John Candy !!
Just one thing wrong with this rendition: it's too good.
thepoint08 1 week ago
so smoooth
evoking96 2 weeks ago
He is sop smooooth
evoking96 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
When I heard Johnny Cash sing Gordon Lightfoot's song it sent chills up though my spine. Though Don Williams did a nice version to Gordon's greatest hits!
anne91276 3 months ago
Comment removed
anne91276 3 months ago
nobody loves him like I do...;)
ChristineJett1 3 months ago
what year was this done? and who did the original? there are like 25 versions
16fraserthegreat 3 months ago
@16fraserthegreat The origional singer and writer is Godon Lightfoot 1971, check him out, he has hundreds of masterpieces
2dogsaf 3 months ago 2
@2dogsaf I hate this damn song !
carnut476 1 month ago
I love Don williams...but the Lightfoot version is better. You can feel it more in Lightfoot's voice...almost like he is not singing it, but breathing it in and out.
beefwellington007 4 months ago
10 dislikes? how could ya not like this
chunkyjitsuguy 4 months ago
Comment removed
chunkyjitsuguy 4 months ago
Don Williams is the best singer ever in my thoughts.His music touches my soul
kjbmwj 4 months ago 2
What's that hat called?
flatheadpower2000 4 months ago
Don Williams is the Lionel Ritchie of country music.
ahealthydoseofdoubt 5 months ago
i just cant get it back :( i wsh i cud
carluke30 5 months ago
I like this version better.. Lightfoot's is great but This one hits me more profoundly then the original does..
fcspike 5 months ago 2
not bad but........
matt221ify 5 months ago
its impossible for don williams to do a bad remake. he has IT.
1288dallas 5 months ago 8
Sorry its crap.There only one gordon lightfoot
mrnatty122 5 months ago
Awesome job. He is the only other person I like doing this song besides Gordon obviously! I never get tired of this song, ever.....
freak2376 6 months ago
Not as good as Gordo
jstech84 6 months ago
Brilliant version. Haven't heard this version from Don before.
47ph 6 months ago
He's on tour this tear. go to his website.
MrPorterhouse 6 months ago
This is one of the best versions I have heard. Even better than Gordon. I have many of his recordings, but never heard this one before. Any way he is one of my favourite recording artists. Great!
mightyquinn62 6 months ago 2
Is this from one of his 70's albums, or a more recent recording? I ask, b/c I know he did release an album of covers at some point in the mid-90's.
Rockstaralan 6 months ago
beautiful version, but I like Gordon's version better. :)
318artillery 7 months ago
This song could have been written about me and my ex-wife. I haven't thought of this song in years. Was doing a search this morning for Don Williams songs and ran across it.
unclebentoall 7 months ago
Love both Don's and Gordon's versions. Where Gordon makes the song haunting almost, Don makes it mournful. Both great!
LoveDeath97 7 months ago 9
Love both Don's and Gordon's versions. Where Gordon makes the song haunting almost, Don makes it mournfull. Both great!
LoveDeath97 7 months ago
always gives me chills great song
tacosandpussy 7 months ago
There both good Don and Gordon are the best they broke the cast when they where given to this earth they still got it to
blueeyes5399 7 months ago
good version
Obelisk2290 7 months ago
pure class singer of this great song brilliant!!!!!!!
noele10 7 months ago
Very good job on a great song!
Starliner57 8 months ago
Very nice.. he does the song very well.. thank-you for posting :)
RoryNights 8 months ago
One thing is true, Don's vocal tone has remained with him throughout his entire life. Gordon's sort of lost his voice over the years as it sounded back in the 70's. Don still sounds amazingly good at his age. He's remained consistent throughout his career.
joevs21001 9 months ago
Don is singing someone else's song. Gordon is sharing a painful chapter in his life. How could any sane person claim Don's version is "better"?
JOYisREAL 9 months ago
@JOYisREAL Maybe not "better" in a sense of words, but Don's version is definitely good musically. He does have a different vocal tone than Gordon Lightfoot, no doubt, but i'm sure he sang the cover with Gordon's blessing, otherwise it would not have been permitted to be done.
joevs21001 9 months ago
@JOYisREAL Don does fine, but Gords version is way better
64fairlane305 7 months ago
One of the greatest voices of all time. Sadly Don retired and doesn't do performances anymore.
joevs21001 9 months ago 2
@joevs21001 don is performing at the american music theater in lancaster, pa this coming august.
missmopar28 9 months ago
@joevs21001 Thanks for the info. I actually live pretty close to Lancaster, PA, thanks, I might have to check that show out.
joevs21001 9 months ago
i'm going tosee Gordon tonight in Greensboro N.C. if there is aversion that Gordon would sit and listen to other than his own,im sure it would be this one. Don will be in Greensboro March 24 ihope i can make that one too
2dogsaf 10 months ago
@2dogsaf ive seen him twice in knoxville tn. met him after shows too. i hope to be able to make massey hall. even if i have to hitchhike
yamahonkawazuki 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This Is really good, but Lightfoot is just perfection to this song, but this is pretty close
ThatsBryan 10 months ago
This Is really good, but Lightfoot is just perfection to this song, but this is pretty close
ThatsBryan 10 months ago
geweldig nummer
devilsdance24 11 months ago
Just very nice,like all his songs,thx 4 uploading...
nanodinedaliko 11 months ago
he is the most amazing male singer alive
ilovekim4 11 months ago
hey don ######!
msmisty999 1 year ago
I love Gordon, but my boy Don takes the cake with his rendition
tlfbooboo 1 year ago
Gordon Lightfoot ...Don Williams...both Great's in my views...my view of the world wouldn't be the some without either one of them!...
Xbellatri50 1 year ago 2
Nobody does it better. This is Awsome.... 1965 Adrian Cronauer said"make love,not war"! Ya...Listen this song. baukiki ,Thank you...
69catpower 1 year ago
Nobody do it better. This is Awsome.... 1965 Adrian Cronauer said"make love,not war"! Ya...Listen this song. baukiki ,Thank you...
69catpower 1 year ago
Nobody do it better. This is Awsome.... Thanks
69catpower 1 year ago
Comment removed
devilsdance24 1 year ago
geweldig nummer
devilsdance24 1 year ago
Comment removed
mollysangelique 1 year ago
velvet baritone pipes on this guy..... smooth as silk
JerichoDitch2 1 year ago
One of my favorite singers singing a song by one of my favorite songwriters . Love this guy
TheWarped45s 1 year ago
i like don and gordon lightfoot both, they have two of the most touching voices..
MrCokeman468 1 year ago
WILL YOU MARRY ME, DON?
Malena64100 1 year ago
great stuff!!
eddiemac303 1 year ago
I am sure Gordon is happy that my brother Don cut this song. I am sure.
AustinRogers1 1 year ago
@AustinRogers1
Well, I'm not Mr. Lightfoot but I'm glad your brother cut this.
My wife used to fall asleep listening to her dad and uncles singing your brother's songs. Even now I know that I can snap her out of a sad mood by playing one of Don's songs.
Thank you brother for me, it's the little things like that that help in the very hard work that is a good marriage.
lesterclaypool1 1 year ago
@AustinRogers1 This song reminds me of being a little boy who lived for going for a ride with PaPaw...i was still innocent, had never had my heart broken, had no concept of how short life is, and i was sitting next to my Grandpa, who was God in my eyes, as he sang it wholeheartedly on the way to the farm to catch the turtles that came out of the creek to munch our lettuce lol. I love your brother's music- it was played at PaPaw's funeral and still makes me feel loved to hear it<3
woostergino 1 year ago
Good cover but I like Gordon Lightfoot better.
SweetLouF64 1 year ago
Lov'n this song
sweetcherrypieyum 1 year ago
lots of people have recorded this song only don could do it as well as lightfoot
2dogsaf 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
HEY! Gordon Lightfoot is alive and well and innocent. He wrote this song after seeing an old black and white movie about a haunted wishing well and thought what a great idea for a song. I know this because I am CANADIAN and have been to several of his concerts, and I just received my ticket to his concert next May 21, 2011. Sheesh! The stuff you find on here. Really.
TheZAMBONILADY 1 year ago
HEY! Gordon Lightfoot is alive and well and innocent. He wrote this song after seeing an old black and white movie about a haunted wishing well and thought what a great idea for a song. I know this because I am CANADIAN and have been to several of his concerts, and I just received my ticket to his concert next May 21, 2011. Sheesh! The stuff you find on here. Really.
TheZAMBONILADY 1 year ago
Comment removed
JrAndrewKent 1 year ago
Gordon Lightfood opend the book, Don Williams nailed it and Johnny Cash closed the book on this song. It's all a mather of taste, I'm not saying anyones best. Although I think the original deserves the most credit (in any case) I personally like Johnny Cash his version best.
ColdStab 1 year ago
I'm thankful for both Don Williams and Gordon Lightfoot.
BIGTROUT01 1 year ago
heroes often fail. best part for some reason =)
HellscreamGarrosh 1 year ago
Great song. Did he write it? or Gordon?
StevieB1362 1 year ago
I have always loved this song by Gordon , but I have always loved Don Williams. And in all the concerts I have seen, I have never seen him do this song. This is awesome
lillithanne 1 year ago
My Dad's favourite singer. Always make me cry when I hear him.
elephantbarbiegirl 1 year ago
He sings from his heart. His words are soo pure and anyone can relate to his messages even though it is a Gordon Lightfoot song. Don williams just brings it out to me in a different way. Nothing but the upmost respect. My father introduced me to some of his songs and i can't stop listening to them.
mihale75 1 year ago 6
I love Don Williams' voice & how he does this.It's beautiful. But, if not for Gordon Lightfoot, we wouldn't even have this song to enjoy.
geneobug 1 year ago
Love this Great Gordon Lightfoot song..... Don Williams is.......The Gentle Giant.......:)
STRUMMERBOY1975 1 year ago
Who would have thought anyone other than Gorden Lightfoot could sing this song, absolutely beautiful
Papafuz 1 year ago
My favorite country singer ever. long life Don.
ADEL4B 1 year ago 2
@ADEL4B Amen to that
rhinewine01 1 year ago
Why isn't this fine singer on television ? This man is a great singer with a unique style. All you see on television these days are boys that make noise, not artist that make music. Our country men needs more men singers like him.
VinnyCap777 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
JrAndrewKent 1 year ago 2
@JrAndrewKent A speller you ain't !
StevieB1362 1 year ago
Comment removed
JrAndrewKent 1 year ago
Wow "The Gentle Giant" is just amazing there is just nothing more to say
JrAndrewKent 1 year ago 2
Can someone tell who is better? Gordon Lightfoot or Don here?
originalpauper 1 year ago
Comment removed
rhinewine01 1 year ago
@originalpauper Gordons the mainman.
russellperry1 1 year ago
@originalpauper That would be The Gentle Giant (Don Williams)
JrAndrewKent 1 year ago
@originalpauper that would be The Gentle Giant (Don Williams) and that's coming from a canadian
JrAndrewKent 1 year ago
there is only one better version,thatsgordon lightfoot's original. this is even brtter than gordons more recent remakes
2dogsaf 1 year ago
Don's Songs are so moving.
Poppyhadley 1 year ago
pekná verzia peknej piesne
MrJkubec 1 year ago
So sweet....so wise........Love the Giant.......
Licmycat 1 year ago 2
Reminds me of Festus.
PupuTheClown 1 year ago
deft the best song by the best singer
668725 1 year ago
<3 :')
BEAUTIFUL
<3 :')
justforfunize 1 year ago
This man is a good singer.Is he a Texan or from Nashville? I never saw him on Television. Singer Elvin Rock
elvinrock 1 year ago
@elvinrock on May 27, 1939 Don Williams was born in Floydada, Texas, U.S.
JrAndrewKent 1 year ago
@elvinrock Not sure, but no matter what, he's an honorary Okie after writin' a hit like Tulsa Time !! Long live the Gentle Giant & his pork chops !!!
StevieB1362 1 year ago
my dad loves these songs and weve past 2 hr now lisining to his songs even when u think ist super boring its not cuz just hering him sing the songs and smile makes it all worth wile
plumm96 1 year ago
Fantastic cover to Gordon's song. His voice treats this great song like no other cover.
buffey 1 year ago 2
WOW!! He really nailed this!
therealno12 1 year ago 18
Ah the gentle giant does it again...
cmmorty99 1 year ago 14
@cmmorty99 There are very few people within the country & western industry here in the USA who can even hold a candle to Gordon Lightfoot. They would include Kenny Rogers, willie Nelson, Kris Kristofferson and Don Williams.
CANADIANPACIFIC2816 1 year ago
God bless Texa(n)s...
larry2lizard 1 year ago
Don and Gordon are both very good on this song,don't know which one I like better.
jamesojld 1 year ago 3
better than Gordon....
d1sailer 1 year ago 3
@d1sailer Wrongo bongo. This is very, very far from being better than GL's recording.
Jitpring 1 year ago
this was the america i like
dudabraga 1 year ago
@dudabraga Maybe she has a different look, some added color, but underneath she is still the beauty she always was. Perhaps you have to look a little closer now days, but you can find her if you try...
pinworms70 1 year ago
This is a great song and Williams is a great singer but Gordon Lightfoot is much better, you can't compare him with Don.
mbnyus 1 year ago
Love him And What he sings about.
segerrocks 1 year ago
Great song and Don did a great cover of it IMHO.
What a voice.
luvangil 1 year ago
MY GIRLFRIEND told me bout Don Williams!! i didn't know him!! it's a real revelation for me!! very chraming voice and words for the heart and the spirit too!!
Peter Stevens
darkalono 1 year ago
Awesome! they call him the gentle giant, what a voice
meetcha2nite 1 year ago 2
I first heard this song on "trigger happy tv" and instantly fell in love with it!
deanbeauty 1 year ago
dom wiliams is beatiful song ,the best song ,il beleve
natirejo 1 year ago
true magic.
TheNigelr 1 year ago
if you could read my mind. lovely darling. thank you
danroy100 1 year ago
Just found out recently that Don Williams was part of "Pozo Seco" singers back around 1970- their lps were among the first I taped for play aboard a DD.
Same avoidance of "in your face" and excess. Plus, Susan Taylor.
A voice of sanity.
woodscritter 1 year ago
Beautiful!
weeeeoooow 1 year ago
he's got a clear nice voice wonderful so smooth no need to shout just soo smooth love it.....
reglap2002 1 year ago
Don is the best...his talent...what a man, how they should be...
deucedoll 1 year ago
highwaymano12. 2nd that, not heard this before.
MrBoshadyn 1 year ago
don williams will never get the recognition he deserves. he is the best at what he does.
nothadnotbad 1 year ago
This puts johnny cash to shame.
1dillontaylor 1 year ago
Really nothing Don sings that I don't love.
OldGuyNo1 1 year ago
Comment removed
StephaneDoucet78 1 year ago
I like this version but I love the original one of Gordon Lightfoot.
lonesomechaser71 1 year ago
Don Williams is singing this song, not Cash. Only a few of Don's songs didn't reach the top ten. Cash couldn't touch him, and only his addictions made him public more than his music. You are the Man Don and your heart as well as your songs is warm and beautiful..
singmeluv 1 year ago
@singmeluv I respect your opinion, but you know nothing about Johnny Cash.
00253 1 year ago
@singmeluv i agree. i find cash average at best. don williams forever
1dillontaylor 1 year ago
one of the greatest singer with greatest songs!
"Don Williams will be inducted into the Country Music Hall of Fame during a formal ceremony later this year. The prestigious announcement was made Tuesday morning (Feb. 23) by the Country Music Association."
motion for a comeback on stage!
nieliznieh 1 year ago 2
yeah this is a pro singer.. check us out.. were up and coming band.. hes a legend
ameridack 1 year ago
I've heard a couple of Don's recordings before, and he's always impressed me. This is no exception. His interpretation of Gordon's classic tune is really beautiful.
badnewsBH 1 year ago
luv this one....brings back good oldmemories....thanx alot...
strugglingman1 1 year ago 2
Very nicely done. I' ve never heard Don before. He softens the edges that both Gordon and Johnny have when they sing this. BTW, I sing this song to my daughter every night at bedtime, and this version is the closest to how I sing it :-D
13kalgsto04 1 year ago
Don Williams aka The Gentle Giant. you missed alot. check him out
dammitsthename 1 year ago
U gotta be very careful when U take on the solid talent of others and attempt their music & songs. I just hate it when ppl/ companies adapt material they should have left alone. Ian Tyson is solid and original and has the voice and talent to prove it. k d lang, the planets perfection in a female voice, can sing anyones song! A lot can try, but a classic version should be left alone.
VALMARIESASK 2 years ago
This is a really beautiful version of Gordon Lightfoot's signature song. Takes a lot of courage to step up to the plate to sing a song that someone else has "
branded" and Don sure does it justice. Johnny Cash's version is poignant in its own way and courageous on his part to sing it on his American Recordings series, which was at the tail end of his life after his wife, June Carter, passed away. Johnny's interpretation has its very own beauty considering the point in his life.
sandladyvb 2 years ago
Why the pre-occupation with Johnny Cash?
This is Don Williams singing Gordon Lightfoot's classic and doing it rather well.
DasHearach 2 years ago 2
this is the very best version of this song, Lightfoot's is amazing, but this is absolutely touching, Don is the best... a great legend, and if someone out there has not heard his voice they are truly missing out.
cruelcowgirl16ok 2 years ago
frebert should see a doctor. not only to open up his ears, but more seriously: to open up his heart...
nickythebastard 2 years ago
If you could read my mind that would be kinda creapy.. but i know one thing. We need Don back!
LorenaKittleson 2 years ago 3
Top 3 singers to do this Song:
Gordon Lightfoot
Johnny Cash
Don Williams.
Dash171 2 years ago
Cash's version is pathetic. As I listened to it I kept thinking if he was performing it on American Idol he would make the show, but only as the joke artist to be laughed at by all. His was truly a sad and horrible rendition of a great song.
frebert 2 years ago
have to agree here love johnny cash , but he crucifies this song , lightfoot ftw
Abdiel1812 2 years ago 2
what a horrible thing to say about such a great man, he was oviously at a very old age when he recorded, kinda like the song hurt, but it was not pathedic, whats is pathedic is you posting such negitive thins about elderly people who have given so much to music and charitys and so on........
danescott1962 2 years ago 2
@danescott1962 I thought Johnny did an incredible job with Hurt, as he did with any cover I ever heard by him. I've not heard him sing this, but I can't see him butchering it.
piercedsquid 2 years ago
@frebert If you think about it, it took alot of guts to do that. Maybe it was his way of saying goodbye. 'course now that I'm over 50 I can appreciate that kinda stuff. None of us knows when their end will come. I just hope to live that long & be able to feed myself & not be in a diaper, let alone sing & produce music. Far be it from me to criticize one who traveled as far, high & low as the immortal Johnny Cash, all in one lifetime. Long live the Man in Black...the Original Outlaw!! Souie!!
StevieB1362 1 year ago
@Dash171 Johnny Cash should not have recorded this song, its just disturbing the way he did it.
Select verses are meant to soar, and his Cash's voice just sounds sore.
Some of Cash's final recordings seemed a bit contrived and less inspired. His rendition of this song to me is to me one of them.
immovable1 2 years ago
Johnny Cash sang this when he was close to death. His version has a life of its own and is beautiful in its own way. its not a dick length contest. Just different versions of a beautiful song.
NRAforlife67 2 years ago
@immovable1, my kids are 18, 20, and 22. Cash's last recordings opened their eyes to some music they would have not known. They love all of his music, Cash transended more generations than most will ever hope to! RIP the man in Black.
6GUNSOUTH 1 year ago
Statistics show that 100% of the criminals put to death, never commit another crime. Don Williams is the best!
flcracker9 2 years ago
Comment removed
lucky8274 2 years ago
@lucky8274 Lucky8274 Just to throw in my 2 cents, I have a real problem with a person who molests & kills someone, then is allowed to sit around watching TV, enjoying free room & board; the next 30 or so WorldSeries & SuperBowls; eating ReeceCups, free condoms w/free medical-dental care the rest of their life, as their victim is gone forever. What we really need is appeals process reform to shorten it. THEN we can put these creeps to sleep for good as it was intended. THAT will save $ !
StevieB1362 1 year ago
Don't get me wrong Don Williams is great but goosebumps and throat lumps only happen for me when Lightfoot sings it............
kyuss4me 2 years ago 2
Agreed nobody can beat Gordon with his amazing voice; however this version is VERY good
graidstin 2 years ago
True that... Always good to hear from the great state of Texas......... Never lose that Southern Pride! Might sound funny coming from a Canadian but I sure wish Canada was more like Texas in some ways... Need the right to pack the hogleg for protection nowadays. Peace...........
kyuss4me 2 years ago
Why thanks buddy I ussually dont think the average canadian to be praisin texas and supportin southernpride, and yes everyone needs the right to death penalty its a lot more effective then keepin someone in jail for a lifetime
graidstin 2 years ago
Nicely put... I ain't the "average Canadian". They tend to be too bleeding heart for my liking....freaken sheep! They want us all to feel guilty for living on the land that used to belong to the indians..................sheesh! Now it belongs to the east indians, and chinese and every other ese there is .......... anyhow great song!
kyuss4me 2 years ago
@graidstin you think you'd still speak like that if you were on death penalty?
wow, with people as compassionate as you the future really looks bright...
niobe00 2 years ago
@niobe00 ok so your sayin that if i kidnapped, raped and killed a young child I still shouldnt get the death penalty, or if I brutally stabed a family to death and ground up their bodys to meat I still shouldnt get the death penalty. Some people deserve to die for the atrocities they commit instead of rotting in a jail eatin up tax payers dollars. Now im a pretty compasionate person just not to phsycopath serial killers
graidstin 2 years ago
this is beautiful song.
i can't imagine that this sort of commentary belongs associated with it
dantheLeafsFAN 2 years ago
100 percent correct, ty, there are still people with some mental capacity
danescott1962 2 years ago
Hey niobe00 With bleeding hearts like you the future really looks fucked to me.... If I could read your mind.............
kyuss4me 2 years ago
@kyuss4me Wait just a minute. Are you saying Gordon Lightfoot wrote this song while he was on Death Row?! Amazing !! I guess that could be. After all he IS Canadian isn't he? Wow, so much talent up there in the Great White North!! Bob & Doug, Anne Murray, Gordon Lightfoot AND SCTV !! Gone are the good ol' days my friends. Long live John Candy !!
StevieB1362 1 year ago
@StevieB1362 You forgot The Trailer Park Boys you fat fuck American idiot.
kyuss4me 1 year ago
dont allow yourself to be put in a position to be on death row.
MrFreshtodth 2 years ago
completely right
FirstBloodHC 2 years ago
He makes this song his own. He was certainly born to sing
Gentlegianttoo 2 years ago
I just LOVE Don William voice.
Dontgupt20 2 years ago
Comment removed
Dontgupt20 2 years ago
nice version
andy2u69 2 years ago