David Gilmour And Roger Waters live 2010. Comfortably numb.

[joyke66]

Mr Peace ...Roger Water can't make peace with his music mate David Gilmour..i think his toooo afraid of Gilmours guitar.....awesome.....

[Weisstot]

holy crap i woulda paid 1000 to be there

[MrSyd1984]

We have this footage thanks to David Gilmour who had someone film the show cause Roger had all the recording devises banned! (rolling stone interview/oct 2011)

[beilever777]

wtf, are we using piece of "made in china" crap to record this. Or did this guy drop his camcorder.

[OpusRuspee]

What it must feel like to be the people right in front...I'd be able to die peacefully and fulfilled following that experience!

[limeliter]

Exactly.....listen to the Concert !

[tchevy173]

Why would anyone talk during this performance.

[xander6957]

FLOYDIANS KNOW BETTER!

[dutchmanabq]

I cant believe that people are talking and moving around!!!

[juanpablo19813006]

there is definitely Nick mason ... they should meet again and be Pink Floyd. Big Roger Waters, David Gilmour Large ... greetings from Antofagasta-Chile

[shanferg1]

Thats great to see them on a stage together again

[MarkMurphy1978]

One day I want to come across someone who says to me "Oh, I saw David Gilmour and Roger Waters performing live at some charity gig once and I stood on a chair during the last guitar solo and waved my arms about". At which point I will break his bloody legs.

[enkej2]

COME BACK AND PLAY A REAL CONCERT FOR YOUR REAL FANS!! Not for these unappreaciative drunks....*sob*

[antifacistppl]

@enkej2 or the children god forbid...

[enkej2]

@antifacistppl Nah, that's Ok! Let the money go to them if they like, just don't tease with these "concerts" when they can play a real big one instead! We are all longing to see them!

[danielnradu]

"Wooooooo - play Born to be Wild!!!"

[anbreatnach]

Jaysus, how did that crowd of ignorant fuckers get tickets to see Gilmour and Waters? I've seen pub bands treated with more respect.

[xramcam]

@anbreatnach Agreed. Unless these wankers were contributing a couple million $ a piece, they do not deserve to be in the presence of immortals.

[avbalfonset]

yo comverti a la mia al fluido rosa.37 años juntos

[burningdust]

Random Chatter? Really you wanna talk over Roger Waters?

You have nothing of ANY importance to say; SHUT UP and let the music dominate. grrrrr.

[51006ja]

Where was this small gig ?

[lrodriguezb]

No, Nick wasn't in this Gig.. The drummer was Andy Newmark

[agustinmartinezaaa]

gilmour sos un genio

[PreacherofZaZ]

Does anyone know if Nick was drumming at this gig too?

[papasieg]

Want to see you guy play this long and still play like that hahaha

[papasieg]

wow



[woutervincentbff]

My girlfriend said that pink floyd is stupid an for old people

Now i'm single :D

[pitufanegra]

@woutervincentbff don´t worry, she´ll be old,stupid and without musical criteria.

[shiona0906]

@woutervincentbff hahahaha class

[burningdust]

@woutervincentbff Good man, do whatcha gotta do.

[wvrust]

@woutervincentbff Your better off lol



[kevenbelangerharbour]

@woutervincentbff my girlfriend says the same thing and jsut for that i always put pink floyd in my car... well that might explain i never had sex since the last 6 months... but doesnt matter pink floyd gives me harder orgasm :P

[MrRon1507]

@woutervincentbff -  Your ex-girlfriend's a retard !!!

[turockandar]

@woutervincentbff You made the right choice!!!!

[woutervincentbff]

@turockandar i know :)

[hectorjuliodiaz]

@woutervincentbff

Correct decision.

[Mamertum345]

@woutervincentbff - best thing you've done in your entire life so far!!!

[jacker257]

@woutervincentbff lol ur a smart man. i wudda tried to get her to like them. but once u go into simple spoon fed music like lada gaga n beiber ect than u cant go back

[woutervincentbff]

4:44

Asshole >:(

[inibo]

David Gilmour is a blazing fire.

[Fendergreats19933]

Me : Dad i'm going out

Dad : No your not it's your bed time

Me : But Three people disliked David Gilmour and Roger Waters live 2010 Comfortably numb video

Dad : They What where's my hammer ?

[Floydandfriends1]

It seems that one moron is so dumb and drunk that he stands in front of the cameras!

[lucky44124]

If there is 200 people or 200,000 people David Gilmour brings it!!!

[staffo76]

3 PEOPLE ARE UNCOMFORTABLY NUMB TO GOOD MUSIC

[kaizer316]

cant believe some stupid ignorant fucks are talikin through this performance and haven't a clue what they're witnessing

[burningdust]

@kaizer316 Damn "ME" generation probably texting too. Self centered fools.

[favvio]

:'D

[holicat098]

i'm again young!

[fotzenjonas]

dave`s guittar gave me goose pimmples!

[Secondlifecreator]

@fotzenjonas

goosebumps :P

And yes his guitar, and voice are by far the signature sound of Pink Floyd.

[23RYDADDY23]

I would have given basically anything to be in that crowd. Please do a tour boys!!

[parkateer]

that was fuching crazy.

[haynesallica]

its amazing ive seen at least 40 versions of this live and he never plays it the same twice , i doubt he ever remembers how to play the album version now lol

[cubsfands29]

@haynesallica he played the album version on is show he did with roger waters on the wall tour this year

[cubsfands29]

@haynesallica he played the album version on his show he did with roger waters on the wall tour this year

[drew0808]

So nice to see David Guilmor and Roger Waters.

[8P1NK15FloyD90]

i would have pulled a roger and spit in they face disrespectful fucks :(

[Doques]

I hear a bunch of people in this video not singing but talking while this is happening in front of them... What is wrong with them?

I want to shoot that guy at 4:42.

[Doques]

I hear a bunch of people in this video not singing but talking while this is happening in front of them... What is wrong with them?

PINK FLOYD the best band ever

[ChrisMagoo99]

wow, I did not know this happened. I didn't think they'd ever get back together

[ZPClaudio]

it´s amazing!!!

[nabxf]

paul mccartney and ringo disliked this

[animalstudios]

Holy shit i wish i was there

[themetalchef]

Pink Floyd is the only band that can pull off TWO lead singers with a dead one being the inspiration for all.. Whens Waters Gilmour picked up and made the songs his own.. PF the best band ever..

[doirevomba]

Pink Floyd are the dogs bollicks. Seamuse's.

[nabxf]

@doirevomba well played!!

[DJKickstarter]

Rick and Syd looks down smiling I am sure

[spootboy123]

4:41 SIT DOWN, DOUCHE!!

[speechpessi]

@spootboy123 nah...he's having the most amazing experience in his life...don't tell him how to enjoy it!

[Bartjimmy]

@spootboy123 SUCK !

[OrlandotheAxe731]

@spootboy123 Drunk bastard...

[joshsettlemyer]

two people suck an mighty big donger, but there are almost always 1 or 2 people like this on any song. Maybe they are band members just trying to get a rise out of people

[TheBeatlefloyd]

i just love that this happened in general glad theyre cool with each other again.. there is gonna be the luckiest crowd in the wrold who gets to see Dave on the wall playing for Roger's tour 1 night

[gaiola48]

Hear What's good enjoy the ride

[evilmboard]

for those who know about music this is a legendary reunion.

I really hope they can reunite again for the wall tour

[jimjr155]

yo, dude at 4:40, get down!!!!!

[herrbaur1]

would do anything to see this in person

[ihaveaverybadcold]

i feel so sorry for roger waters.....hes so into (which is a good thing) but i feel as though the reason he is is because he misses playing with them for so long...such a deep pain i could only imagine

[Crisrockin]

I am polytheist, because I worship those 2 gods there on stage. Can you fucking blame me?

[MrKorbendalas]

Waters & Gilmour together? On one stage? No bullshit? No gibberish? Luv this one, whatever they would be playing like..

[themahermax]

@MrKorbendalas 

[RecycledAmerica]

This video almost made me cry. Besides Live 8 and the fact that they are actually willing to do something on stage together.  I wish Rick was still living so badly and that we could see the real Floyd together again. So, so very sad it will never happen again.

[wetley09]

I love how he plays the solo how ever the hell he wants whenever the hell he wants. Love em all.

[avinash199424]

if that guitar solo dint make u high then i bet half a kg of wont be enuf for u idiots to get high...

[TheAMick1]

Gorgeous Performance but it will never be Pink Floyd again without Richard Wright who created all the unique moods associated with The Floyd. RIP Rick you are always in my thoughts

[SpyrosMitrakos]

Wondering how much would cost a ticket?

[Failstrand]

@SpyrosMitrakos I would've given my right arm to have seen this, it really doesn't matter what it would cost

[randomdave30]

Maybe David, Roger and Nick could reform Pink Floyd again - and given his history with both Roger and Pink Floyd, Jon Carin would be ideally placed as keyboardist.

Maybe....

[GuitaristPAX]

No one can do it like the original Authors...for all you "guitarists" out there...Gilmour's Solos have made HISTORY...No Arpeggios, No Fancy Tapping shit...Just GREAT, EMOTIONALLY CHARGED MELODIC PLAYING....Listen to it....Learn it...Know It...Live it....Dark Side of the Moon stayed on Billboards Top Lists for over 741 weeks...141/2 YEARS! No OTHER BAND IN HISTORY HAS DONE THAT & NO ONE EVER WILL...Seek Who YOU ARE AS AN ARTIST & THEN TELL THE WORLD HOW YOU FEEL...That's when you have "MADE IT"

[zqzqpj]

F ing awesome!!!!!!

[daytripper57]

SHUT THE FUCK UP YOU ARE WITNESSING PINK FLOYD IN AREA LARGER THAN MY LIVING ROOM, YOU STUPID IDIOTS HAVE NO IDEA WHAT IS IN FRONT OF YOU.

Waters & Gilmour > Lennon & McCartney

[cardo1111]

Roger has recruited some really good guitarists, but no one can play this song like Gilmour.

[gobenko]

I actually envy the people who manage to see that live... it is great to see them doing gigs together

[epica901]

how could you dislike this :S:S



[777CLASSICROCK777]

crying

[xratiugx]

This is awewome!!! David Gilmour is the best guitarist out there, and with Roger Waters and Nick Mason!!! amazing

[CaseyCain85]

It's nice to see them up there together again <3

[thepatient08]

I can't believe everyone is talking...

[floydman64]

Wish they we're here!

[trazanhund]

David Gilmour is the good boy and Roger Waters is the bad boy :)

Roger have consulting a shrink, so he feel better now.

I can only agree, PINK FLOYD are the best band ever!

[Pe6ek]

The original inspiration for "The Wall", was Roger's frustration with audiences that didn't come to their shows for the music. And what does this audience do? They freaking talk all the way through a legendary performance. Idiots.

[yogonauta]

esa gente parece unos zombies!!

yo estaría brincando y gritando hasta quedar afonico.

malagradecidos

[auswitch]

@yogonauta habria que estar ahí para saberlo, pero muy seguramente estaríamos gritando como lunáticos...

[mberke2]

I don't know what it cost to get in to see this gig but I would have paid anything short of a body part to get in. It's a shame there were people there who couldn't appreciate what it means to see David Gilmour and Roger Waters share a stage after all these years.

[sbr388]

Just a few easy simple fixes would have made this gig much better. First and foremost the FUCK in front of the camera needs his legs broken ASAP.Second would be that a drum kit of a large size be smashed over the drummer's head for screwing up the end and last but not least all the F.M chatterboxes and phone whores be drop kicked out the door.

[Vieted]

bloody hell, I can`t believe my eyes by seeing these people. I`m really excited by seeing this video from my laptop, and I would shut some tears by seeing this live...but these people, they act like having a teaparty.

They could better do the dishes and watch to Justin Bieber or something,

[nomisbeth]

It is such marvelous feeling to hear the voices and accords played as they were originaly sang...I was about to shed some tears...

[eyectormetal]

Mi vida por verlos juntos en vivo en la Argentina solo una vez!!!!..My life for see them one moment in Argentine at the alive concert!!!

[tteu123]

What the fuck?!!! Look at that bunch of idiots in the crowd... Half of them were probably like 'Who's Roger Waters?! What's Pink Floyd?';

I would've sold my soul to see this live.

[usuxxors]

@tteu123 ya those ppl have no clue what they are expereincing not a fuckin clue

[BigKdiddyDaddy]

These people are seeing the greatest guitar player ever play the greatest guitar solo ever, and they act like Drunken teenagers. I wish they would shut up. Cheering is one thing but all the talking is not right.

[MafalRuse]

HOW I WISH I COULD SEE ALL THE CONCERTS ...

[MOSKII58]

what are wrong with these people is this a dream or what!!

[therealblkraptor]

wow... this is a small venue for them.

[8188ify]

Rock in Rio neles!!!

[rizwantakkhar]

That has to be the shittiest crowd I've ever seen. What the f-ck is wrong with these people? There would have been a better crowd if they had reunited in PAKISTAN for f-ck's sake.

[busstopratbag]

Its so weird that they're playing together on stage for the first time in years and everyone is talking as if it were a regular rock cclub.

[bd80]

1 youtube user doesn't know the word "music"

[Deathshuck]

@bd80 wow indeed. what a loss, huh?

[MafalRuse]

@bd80 make it 2 now! how is that possible?!

[joacka]

@bd80 make them 3

[SolidLittle]

I don't think that the crowd knows how lucky they actually are to see these two legends togheter. If I had been there, I probably would have fainted.

[cyrusdm86]

@SolidLittle so would have I.

[MrDodstink]

When Roger and David aren´t coming only though waves the perfection is accomplished!

[R7pl]

Where it was?

[paddlehard2]

Like they perform in some bar with not so interested people...

[HereticWarfare]

I hope they reunite and get Nick too, it's sad that Rick is gone, but come on, just tour the Floyd guys, it would make so many people so happy. Myself included.

[FREDMAROONED]

pink floyd ruleeeeeeeeeeeeees!!

[Westsidepaulie]

get your faggot ass off of the dude's shoulders and let the people behind you who paid money to see this show actually see this

fucking ass munching cocksucker!!!

[MrDonbago]

4:40 get the fuck out of the way!!!!

[spermatoman]

por que mierda todo estos conciertos son en otros paises ajajajaja mejor suerte para la proxima

como me gustaaria que volvieran a tocar juntos en pink floyd aunque jamas volvera a ser lo mismo

me ocnformare con seguir escuchando pink floyd a la espera de que uno de los dos venga a chile

[1mlb704]

Oh how I do love Pink Floyd...

[stupidancee]

but then people are not silent

PINK FLOYD that are the best band ever

this to these people should be a privilege

the best thing that ever happened to them in life

will be difficult to see david gilmour join again with roger waters

is a unique opportunity

[mountainbmx]

@stupidancee i saw it two weeks ago...... my reaction when I realised it was him on that wall.... OH MY FUCKING GOD!!!

[seupoat]

@stupidancee You have got to be stoned out of your mind and just for that alone I will join the party and add a thumbs up for your incredibly incoherent sentence!!!!!! Good lord!!!!!!!!

[webweavert]

Awesome stuff! It makes you wish they'd reunite and start touring again. I saw David Gilmour with Richard Wright, and Roger Waters in separate concerts, both back in 2006. Just saw Roger with The Wall, which was a great concert, but it made me think it could have been awesome with the other members of the band.

[idontknowstudios]

nick mason would of been there but the event was full of rich people so he didnt want to he said hed rather do a thing like live 8

[MrMusclemadness]

I have seen roger do the wall 3 times on this tour. I cried every time at certain points. I would shut my eyes and just try and think about david playing with him.... I hope to see them reunite again for SOMETHING. I am amazed that people are talking and carrying on. It makes me sick. But it IS a benefit and was not announced in any fashion. some people just don't appreciate the moment they were a part of.

[kevin4peace]

OH MY GOD. How could these people talk during this epically historic moment? At about 1:03 I would have died.

[MrMatthew3423]

I was there!!!!!!!!!!!! PINK FLOYD 4EVER AND EVER!

[jostin246]

Just unbelieveable! I would have cried my balls off.. I would have never thought David and Roger would play together again.. thats a dream! Hopefully he plays with him in december..

[charlesenn]

After the show I'd spend the next two weeks kicking the sound man in the balls.

You get two legends together playing one of the most perfect PF songs in existence

and it sounds like that?? WTF??? Did they do a sound check? And I'm not talking about the sound quality of this recording, I'm talking about the onstage nightmare!!!

[fatas412]

@charlesenn I disagreed with you at first, and then i heard davids first solo, and i wanted to kill the sound man.

[Nolby]

4:41....SIT THE FUCK DOWN

[1958Sleepy]

Oke. That went well. Let's call Nick and do a complete "The Wall" in Wembley as a final farewell off Pink Floyd. Guess i'm dreaming.

[Smurfman256]

damn, Roger sounds as good as he did in 1979. And so does David.

[adamohmg]

fuck this entire audience. They have no clue what they're witnessing.

[adamohmg]

why are people talking during this concert. Wankers.

[survivor1077]

Best concert in my life. 1993, Torino, Italy. What a gift!!

[sk8erchase]

what the fuck kind of crowd is this... i would have died

[YYZDRUMR]

I fucking hate when people are talking in the audience. SHUT THE FUCK UP!!

Can't you see you're watching musical geniuses?

[wagimawrpf5692]

I DARE TO DECLARATE THAT THIS WAS BETTER THAN THE BIG FOUR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[pc4funlan]

They Really Rock... ! Always Have and Always Will !

[hektikal]

You can say what you want but i got tears in my eyes.. wish it was a few years back..

They could have done this with the 4 of them..

everything has a reason they say..

Glad they teamed up anywayz :)

Gonna see roger next year.. hope David is with him..

who knows ;)

Thanks for the upload!!

[madbetamax]

Amazing! But these videos would have been better if the drummer bothered to learn the songs. Is that asking too much?

[cubsfands29]

dear whoever stood up during the solo,

i would love to beat youre face in with a bat.

sincerely cubsfands29

[scoosh14]

@cubsfands29

I Will Provide The Bat...

[bollen91]

@cubsfands29 i will provide a recording.

[gleemo1]

one of the best guitar solo's ever bar-none!!

[noveltyskateboards]

i would give my left nut to see this with gilmour, nick, and if mr. wright flew down from heaven and played the keys.....i don't know what i would do!!!

[slimshady0297]

Nice, the fucking asshole getting up as soon as David starts playing.

[slipyourhips]

@slimshady0297 yeah really, WTF?

[carneyfex]

Oh give the guy some slack, it's very hard NOT TO stand up when THAT is happening in front of you.

[GCalla420]

come on roger and david, put aside your issues and get nick and do a floyd tour, i just saw roger and it was amazing as always, but this was only a few months ago and sounds great, the fans need a pink floyd tour, maybe some sunny day in the future it will happen