15岁新加坡女生的星光踢馆表现非常惊人！震撼全场！ - 2009-08-07

[aumanfung]

張韶涵－不痛

[euyansangable]

她以前在比赛的时候，和一位女生谈了两年的恋爱。是个同性恋。现­在变＂直＂了，较了一位男朋友。好下贱喔！

[TheresaTHYYY]

@euyansangable how could you say someone cheap when she turned straight? Are you jealous of her dude.

[euyansangable]

@TheresaTHYYY Jealous? Maybe for the fact that she could sing pretty good. That is all. But she do not have the look/voice/height/quality. Just a fake wannabe from singapore.

[xxxxxls]

@euyansangable "from singapore" not required, it seems to express biasness.

[huangyt9]

hey, not bad, but she could add more feeling to it.

[allenitsg]

唱功很厉害。尤其这样小的年龄，前途不可限量。这歌唱的很好，但­的人没感觉，只是惊叹，哇，唱功了得。

听歌不完全是听唱功，所以经常看到，有很多歌手唱歌很差，却能大­红大紫。

[mundz86]

hello lip sync?! is live ok?

[Coolypan22]

Please let me know if anyone agrees she's out-of-tune at 0:31. It didn't sound right. Plus, she sounds a bit unstable like she's going out-of-tune anytime if she doesn't control. 100% not a natural singer, sorry.

[waggietoo]

waggie lipsync, take a look

[theonlyandoneful]

whats this song?

[franklinfrc2521]

不太明 , 凡事亦應該鼓勵 , 你們有本事都應該自己站在台上 再給全人類聽 獻出自己歌聲 或者 放膽出來表演一下 .

不要太過批評人 少少批評可以改善 太多會令參賽者本身信心 減少 那又何必呢?

這女生改善一點會有前途的 慢慢改善 還有時間

[R53UL3]

she sound good

[cherylfanful]

不好聽﹐太做作

[natbouffi]

She looks like Selena Gomez...

[myfangirl123]

She is my pri school mate ^^ LOL.

[hys52018]

感覺,...有才是越來越多了,...請問這歌名是?

[qq95248qa]

@hys52018 張韶涵－不痛

[hys52018]

@qq95248qa thanks

[sparrowch]

15歲唱起來感覺比張韶涵還滄桑

[sparrowch]

從小學唱歌的就很容易變得很油= =|||

失去歌曲原本帶有的自然感

[Pounds90]

啃甘蔗..

[Nee904]

I like her techniques. That all. But great singer though. :)

[switebabygal]

not bad not bad.. XDD jyjys!! XD

[ccf672]

ㄏㄏ 叫人家要尊重

但是連son of a bitch都出來了

根本自婊好嗎zzz

[eliza885]

i just think that the problem with u all is u dont know how to appreciate people's voice :)

[judy7818s]

一開始聽覺得還不錯說 後面開始覺得怪怪的=ˊ=..."

[zxc7391456]

前奏應該是清的柔的慢慢帶出來 副歌 唱出感情來 如果都用一樣的力 會不曉得你重點擺在哪裡

[456789145]

可以考慮去發展 歌仔戲

[he01445297]

收皮~!

[york611]

真的好油.....

[zxc7391456]

站在他旁邊的男生是?

[iphopad]

不要以台湾人的中文水平要求新加坡人吧???

[13ayam504]

唱功的確不錯，總覺得她刻意顯現她的唱功很厲害。

這首歌聽起來應該是舒服的，

為什麼要唱的這麼用力?! 整首歌的感覺都被破壞了!!

# 愛韶涵 !!~ #

[vivi7m]

很厲害的唱功 但是張韶涵有讓我起雞皮疙瘩...

[sanmi1981]

他適合唱音樂劇...不是流行歌！！！

[xiala1980]

Beautiful!

[pikachu921015]

她很厲害

可能只是經歷不夠

沒那感覺

[vicky5917kt]

我比較喜歡張韶涵唱的

[MISSBBLJB]

What song is this??

[boomsf]

油油油油油油油油油油油油油油油油油油油~~~~~~~~~~~­~~~~~~~~~~

[anqiang1991]

恭喜啊 aijia

[456789145]

唱的太用力了 高低起伏 太做作

沒有把這首歌 慵懶 的 感覺 顯現出來!!

[0804Leonid]

@456789145 说的很对 不过唱的真的好啊



[456789145]

@0804Leonid 唱的不錯 但太用力

[456789145]

@xieyihui33 So? My English is not good. So I use the translator. This is my personal feeling.

You come from Singapore, but does not mean you can just curse. Other players, sing bad, that assessment is directly express their feelings. I know. You are very strict laws in Singapore.If the police let you know that you say such things to me, I believe , You will be arrested !

[a1997411z]

@xieyihui33 come on this is a competition u know? what u mean by "hurtful"? criticism makes improvement. and your singaporean mother never teach you not to insult others with vulgar? even if taiwan gonna to be part of china is that ur problem? wish you die earlier than us, trash

[YangChaoFan0204]

@a1997411z You eat with that mouth?

[a1997411z]

@YangChaoFan0204 yea what's ur problem?

[YangChaoFan0204]

@a1997411z FODA-SE

[ccf672]

@xieyihui33 Don't self-criticize, thanks.

[lnodokal]

@xieyihui33 nigger umad?

[imsaker]

@xieyihui33 Your comment reflect your respect.

[kevin4630603]

@xieyihui33

1.你英文也沒有多好，請亮出你的老美證件並亮出你的英文檢定等­級，謝謝。

2.好的歌手，是會接受別人的評論的，從不好的地方慢慢改善，才­會進步才會更好。

3.老朽不認為新加坡的教育會讓你滿口髒話，閣下母親看見你這樣­會很傷心的:((。

4.老朽覺得你根本是來釣魚的。

[elementall1029]

@xieyihui33

Shut up,rubbish

[jonaslimrenwei]

正!

[jazzgrace]

skilled but dun like....

[hippochai]

說實話,不好聽=做作,好聽=太油...= =15歲<<<很大了,已經發育了,是男生的話聲線都變了,忠言­逆耳,良藥苦口...如果是5~6歲的小孩還可以拿年齡來壓,但­是15歲了就請接受事實吧...為什麼那麼多人覺得他沒感情?是­因為真的聽不到感情在裡面= =但也沒有人否認他唱歌好聽這點~~~大家只是說實話~:)

[weeagona]

she sings well, ppl r just to jealous about her

[Arcanasification]

@weeagona Can you think before you talk?We are not meaning to hurt her!We're just saying some place that we think should be better

[xDloveguardingstarxc]

我觉得大家不应该这样批评她，毕竟她只是一个15岁的小女孩。因­该说，一个15岁的女孩能够又能够这么成熟又稳厚的歌声来表达这­首歌的每一句，很不容易。我觉得他以后一定会成功，会是新加坡的­骄傲！

[tippy0410]

好宏伟的声音啊.....又不是在唱京剧...

[1959hwe]

同意maydytoh 所說的,我們之所以喜歡凝聽某位歌者的聲音,是因為這位歌者的聲­音感動了我.所以我會喜歡聽,她是很會唱的人,但沒感動到我

[TheHappynhealthy]

老積,賣弄,欠缺15歲應有的天真.

[Evangielle]

/watch?v=VqnR81b4E80&feature= related

这个我有被感动到。

[ucs680903]

很有power啊

聲音真的很超齡

[s8700846655]

他當唱女高音阿 唱的這麼緊

[pos0936]

他的唱法不是流行歌的唱法吧



[iamkabexd14]

好像沒什麼大感動~ 不過也好聽~

[BentleyLeung]

這般不是唱歌,是嗌歌.

[Alexchoong7311]

Good

[clintyoung1234]

有些职业是需要talent的. 唱功感情可以后天补,但声音没有深度,不够浑厚.也没有特性就只­能把唱歌当作爱好,而不是职业.否则这个方向发展会很有限.这个­孩子好像嗓音不太具有talent. 闭眼听不能让人有任何触感.

[OnlyLoveKorea]

不錯囉 ~ 想想你們15歲在幹嘛吧~



[pennyus21]

feel boring!

[ws6103]

15歲能這樣 很厲害了啦!! 給點鼓勵吧? XD

[paui15973]

難聽得要死~~感情ㄋ 你是冷血動物嗎??

[iphopad]

我爱 特别是只用耳机听的时候

[bybluezero]

這個歲數還是比較易控制聲線...唱功在這首歌上,展露不了太多­,感情上...嗯...有待改為吧...

[chrisluvjh]

cmon ppl she's still young thats y

[MsJJable]

好難聽

沒感情的歌聲比鑽牆還難聽

[Gandharacentralasia]

her voice is amazing

[lamce3226]

哇 正到爆 咩名

[lamce3226]

哇 正到爆

[Happy88dog]

油腔滑調

[CherieSQH]

她在唱 大戏 

[zhuzhuyii]

= =我觉得有点像7月歌台的style..（一点啦>.<）



[beeee74960]

像25歲-.-

[zbb123hk]

很有技巧...但並不動人..

感覺不到任何感情呢..~

[Arcanasification]

紧握过的双手那边好像好怪 >< 比较喜欢张韶涵的》。。

[ChueNT0725]

當時15歲已經很厲害, 15歲只是唱得有點油, 只是改改就已經能登大雅之堂

[darling2potato]

覺得很油==

[hotszmung]

很好

[miniclucy]

有技巧 但是過度使用 會使這首歌變得太油 沒有這首歌原本表達的情感

[findherthere]

@miniclucy 赞同。

[dingleenomoaa]

這首歌是這樣唱的...

[HappyZHENable]

有点做作，有点怪怪的，不过还蛮喜欢他常别的歌



[Nesherteo]

力度有待加强。。。



[rubytg]

15 歲 就有勇氣到台灣參加比賽，勇氣可嘉，雖然歌聲還沒有到完美無缺的­境地，但畢竟還小，有進步的空間！

[IamStevenHaHaHa]

外型就出局了

[Calabrien]

What is her name? I like her voice but I don't understand chinese :)

[terrencemy1563]

很有技巧，其實很不錯，不過不是每個人都會喜歡公式化的唱法～（­被打死）

[rainyspan]

歌是唱的很好 音量足 聲音高 但聽到耳朵裡卻不舒服 對我來講說

難聽點可以說像是一種燥音，一點也沒勾起我聽歌的意願，吵!!!

[GarySung1212]

很會唱，但是歌曲的呈現有情感上的空洞。六十分



[2909shan]

拜托，谁能唱得那么棒呢？ 

[MooNPrInC3]

哈哈。。。原来新加坡的不是很自然，一点老派 和只有花架子的歌手可以在台湾拿高到满分！

[Vichyo27]

回你大陸

[annie9609]

怪怪的...不过声音还真的蛮有power咯...唱张惠妹或A­lin的歌应该不错...

[angelixgal]

chinese people are just so critical.

cmon man, she's FIFTEEN. WHAT WERE YOU DOING AT FIFTEEN?

[maydytoh]

唱功真的很好，但總覺得她的聲音沒觸動到我的心，不是很悅耳。最­重要的是缺少了一個東西。。。那就是感情。。。她唱這首歌沒帶感­情，感覺不到任何悲傷的情調。純粹只是個人意見，不是故意傷人。­不好意思。

[baodi1982]

声音不是很自然，唱法有点老派。新加坡的教学方法就是这样，没有­实力只有花架子。

[amospng]

Who are You ????? to insult our singapore education policy . Please Wait up your idea ok

[baodi1982]

@amospng One thing you have to know is I only indicated the singing teaching situation in Singarore rather than education policy in Singapore, which is not my point. It can not be denied that this girl is talented in singing. However, she needs a better vocal educator who can amend her unnecessary power and pronunciations in pop vocal. Frankly, there is little developed singing teaching circumstance in Singapore due to its lacking music industry policy.

[suddenpee]

@baodi1982 You go find her other videos where she sang normally... She purposely sing this way dood

[ultramanlll]

@baodi1982 stupid dog from australia talk so much for wad faggot

[sydneywhz]

@baodi1982 Seriously dude, what goes through your mind when you decided to post something so insensitive?

[ailytan92]

太沉了~这首长音部分应该是要飚上去的，不应该为了让有powe­r而让它沉下来。。。专音很怪~

[koey1543]

我覺得她聲音和一些r&b的歌很合

[AlwaysHAHAHAHAHA]

虽然厉害唱歌但是感觉很骄傲

[daizy00704]

聲音太有力太有POWER 不太適合這首歌 可以換另一首會比較好

但無可否認她能唱 有自己風格 有屬於自己的聲音和一定的唱功 `

[sealuise]

Excellent!!

[jessie20042005]

我覺得挺好的

[feifeifeiiii]

很油



[mr9396]

ching chong chang

[shaniel951753]

可不可以先抓一下這首歌的感覺, 唱得太用力了

連接好像用京劇之類的腔調去圓,

輕重和咬字太過執著, 有點像在賣技巧多於表達歌曲

但不能不說, 她在同齡中很突出很有力量

[WABISUKE1990]

@shaniel951753 什么叫个人风格？

[xiajianbian]

在新加坡比赛第二名

[beagoodking]

才15歲給人一點進步的空間好吧!! 

[jfeng2000]

没感觉 。 。。。

[ss333333ss]

她的聲底比較厚，所以能唱出有點搖滾的味道，可是明顯沒有聲樂技­巧，而致音準有點不穩，強音還會發抖，呼吸氣息沒練好，共鳴也不­夠，所以聽起來音色沒有動人之處，雖然她很有音樂感和表現力，但­這樣pushy的唱，很容易唱壞嗓子！十五歲的殺傷力，因為技巧­不足，更可能傷到自己！

[karebear0o0]

她选的歌感觉和她形象不是很符合。总之，feel不对。技巧还不­错了。

[vintage816]

i like !

[gkt5e]

for those who comment bad about her,ask yourself if u know music...

[yelinncyk]

她是新加坡《校园super star》亚军

[kathleenocy]

her way of singing make ppl dont feel like listening to her if she sing such songs. soo pro also no point already LOL.

[870911julia]

我覺得好像有一點點兇ㄟ

你們有覺得嗎



[xviian]

@yunru123 LOL thats not the point, you said she is way better than angela.. And btw im a singaporean and i watched her in competition before, and you said she is better than angela.. too exaggerating imo..

[JJ6384]

先在再新加坡演戏！



[abbychau2000]

出氣的時候聲音太大了, 在家沒練好嗎?

[boycher2000]

不是怪怪的 是不順 畢竟才15歲

不太喜歡她唱沉"默" 的口音

整個聲音就是太自信 讓人不舒服

[maniaweng]

I'd have to say... worse than expected...

Forgetful; Sounded Old; Karaoke... Try close your eyes and listen, then... you'll probably get it. I hear the song but there's no soul and emotions in it...

[ts086933161]

口音沒問題，重點可能在新加坡聽多了那邊或其他地方樂團及歌手這­種轉音太多拔。

後遺症 要有特色:)

[tinkavon]

不是怪，那叫大调变小调。我觉得她的转音比张韶涵的好听多了～

[xviian]

@tinkavon lol? angela is definitely better 100000000000000000000000000000­00 times

[wl150046]

好滿的歌聲...

[zczzq]

不知道爲什麽我想到了蒙古大草原。。。

[KaitonAoko]

她的声音很老 = =

[3swildforce]

-.- ~ 她唱转音系歌有点不适合~ 如果是唱 我是一只小小鸟 可能还不错~ 不过绝对赢不了丁当 =X

[0936551648]

很不像15歲的聲音, 太假了

[Sorry86873727]

很厲害 可是好像在考試交作業

唱歌還是要唱到人心坎  =ˇ=

聽完很快就忘記了...

[ExTenSlon]

oooo. Just wanted to say that giving her this kind of marks.... is undermining the effort of every other singer who has sang up there. haha

[Fantasia976]

I think i clever then u

[mk1230240800]

他的聲音有力量  但是有些地方好像要輕柔的時候他卻以力量帶過有點奇怪.....­.我覺得啦=)

[gokusun327]

轉音的地方會搶拍

[HyourinmaruROX]

hi guys, im singaporean, but sorry s'porean fans, i gotta say this song is baaaad. first of all, by looking at her face u lose the mood to listen to her sing . and although she made no technical mistakes with the song, i did not feel the emotions at all. go listen to 蕭敬騰-世界唯一的你 in the same program if u find me wrong.

n to ppl from other countries, this is not the best from singapore, hardly. it's juz that many of the good singers have to cope with their studies n did not participate locally :D