I have found a website that has two other arrangements by Guilmant and Stetsenko. Apparently the Guilmant transcription is much richer than the Dupré transcription, but I think either one is beautiful. You can find it on this webpage: imslp.org/wiki/Wir_danken_dir,_Gott,_wir_danken_dir,_BWV_29_(Bach,_Johann_Sebastian)
No, it was originally written for Violin solo, then he made a transcription for orchestra and organ. Bach never made a solo organ arrangement of this piece... if he had then we'd all play that one instead of the various transcriptions by Guilmant, Dupre, Isoir, Guillou, and others.
To some, I might seem quite ignorant; however, I'd argue that the organ realisation of the Sinfonia from Cantata No. 29 is superior to the original work for solo violin. All of that notwithstanding, it certainly takes on a new life with the pipe organ.
I'd go so far as to say on a violin it's downright dull. The recording is substandard, but you can tell the instrument really gives it life, and a definite sense of majesty.
this is an original piece from Bach for violin.. partita III for violin solo on Emajor. Interesting interpretation on the organ. shame about the sound quality.
When all stops will be installed, the organ is going to have 127 speaking stops (no extensions) and 155 ranks. Today the organ is divided 6 manual divisions (Hauptwerk,Oberwerk,Schwellwerk,Fernwerk,Chamade and Auxilaire) and two pedal divisions (Hauptpedal and Fernpedal). Some symphonic ranks are allready there, but they have not beeing installed right now. This organ is the best example for the late romantic organbuilding in Germany!
This is so beautiful! I have a recording of Michael Murray playing this arrangement. How can I get this arrangement? I can't find it anywhere...
wavejaco 1 year ago
@wavejaco
hi, me too, I have this recording of Michael Murray, it is GREAT!! ;-)))
But I don't know where to find this arrangement ;-((
maestroholland 1 year ago
I have found a website that has two other arrangements by Guilmant and Stetsenko. Apparently the Guilmant transcription is much richer than the Dupré transcription, but I think either one is beautiful. You can find it on this webpage: imslp.org/wiki/Wir_danken_dir,_Gott,_wir_danken_dir,_BWV_29_(Bach,_Johann_Sebastian)
wavejaco 1 year ago
@maestroholland
I made an arrangement for piano.
anonymusum 1 year ago
i love this version for the first time I heard Diane Bish was playing it
MelloCash 1 year ago
That organ really is incredible - the reverb makes it sound fantastic!
StrangeWizzard 1 year ago
This organ is beautiful!
StrangeWizzard 1 year ago
Who is playing the organ on the video?
rix1rix2rix3 1 year ago
Bch original wrote it for keyboard and perhaps later he trancribed it for violin and lute,cantata no 29 has this piece in solo organ
tuxedomoon 2 years ago
No, it was originally written for Violin solo, then he made a transcription for orchestra and organ. Bach never made a solo organ arrangement of this piece... if he had then we'd all play that one instead of the various transcriptions by Guilmant, Dupre, Isoir, Guillou, and others.
codeman2008 2 years ago
Thank you, that was lovely.
Korea4Me 2 years ago
Oh, die Orgel in Kevelaer. Ein wunderschönes Instrument!! Da geht mir immer wieder das Herz auf.
orgelschmiddy 3 years ago
My brother, Sean, played this on the organ at St. Marys Cathedral Killarney.
I was at a wedding, and I walked up the winding, old , stone staircase, to the organ loft where he was playing, - it was so seldom that we met,
I had a videocamera in my hand,
When the majority of the congregation had left, - I asked him to play the sinfonia to cantata 29,
My chest bursting with the power of the pipes, (and with pride)
I stood there transfixed, for the duration,
I forgot to turn on the camera.
Maxdesander 3 years ago
Great story. I agree, the Sifonia is absolutely breathtaking!
learning41230 2 years ago
this organ has "only" 4 manuals
auxiliar and chamades can be coupled to all manuals.
its a little strange written in the internet
jonasjonas91 3 years ago
To some, I might seem quite ignorant; however, I'd argue that the organ realisation of the Sinfonia from Cantata No. 29 is superior to the original work for solo violin. All of that notwithstanding, it certainly takes on a new life with the pipe organ.
cstroh32 3 years ago
i agree...i think it commands more from the organ...where with just a violin it could become boring...know what i mean?
handelfan610 3 years ago
I'd go so far as to say on a violin it's downright dull. The recording is substandard, but you can tell the instrument really gives it life, and a definite sense of majesty.
willowthebored 3 years ago
perfectly done
rix1rix2rix3 2 years ago
this is an original piece from Bach for violin.. partita III for violin solo on Emajor. Interesting interpretation on the organ. shame about the sound quality.
spirosis1 3 years ago
spirosis1: Correct. Virgil Fox played it in E Major and at more the violin tempo...
VirgilFoxMusic 2 years ago
This may be the most wonderful music in all creation!
3512032 3 years ago
When all stops will be installed, the organ is going to have 127 speaking stops (no extensions) and 155 ranks. Today the organ is divided 6 manual divisions (Hauptwerk,Oberwerk,Schwellwerk,Fernwerk,Chamade and Auxilaire) and two pedal divisions (Hauptpedal and Fernpedal). Some symphonic ranks are allready there, but they have not beeing installed right now. This organ is the best example for the late romantic organbuilding in Germany!
screammachine87 3 years ago
This organ stands in Kevelaer, Germany! A wonderful pleace!
Henrid81 3 years ago
Mighty impressive, why a fragment?
bangwezl 3 years ago