Amy Macdonald - Caledonia

[Scottishnongolfer1]

It's nothing to do with her voice. No one want's to give it to Dougie in the ass.

[sallygardens123]

Gorgeous! A lovely raw voice. Classy - not a hint of X Factor anywhere!

[Breitheamhnaig]

Scottish lassie putting everything into a song which isn't about Scotland, it's about being homesick and you lot complain. Grow up.

[eilidhhendry]

Beautiful !

[choltrig]

Mince version!.

[zGccc]

Crap.

[pillowtalk1945]

Great song beautifully sung.

[kerrygirl00]

nt great but sum bird do..

[burentu]

Man this is terrible.. sh'looks good though..

[Brennna]

OHMYGOD! Way to ruin a beautiful song, by a drunk truck driver. This GARBAGE!

[MeHere1996]

I looooovvvvveeeee this song but it's not the best version I have heard

[BigbLuebeard]

Good tune, but after listening to Ruth Notman's version, all others just pale in comparison

[banditkiddy]

sorry but this is utter rubbish !! shes murdered a good song here.

[Gameguru667]

@banditkiddy lol she's a beautiful lass but I can't help but agree...

[muv1912]

@banditkiddy I'd luv tae hear your vertion!!!

[banditkiddy]

@muv1912 Vertion ??? Surely you mean version, my friend. And no i cant sing to save myself.....................but then again neither can she lol



[muv1912]

@banditkiddy I tend to get dyslexic with a litre of smirnoff in me! difference of opinion "friend", I think she can sing and since she makes her living doing it, means so do plenty more! I think elvis is crap,but I don't look up his songs and slag him off!!!

[jimbo79ish]

it's a good version and it's nice to hear her sing in her own accent not some put on american one

[robbie2737]

I happen to Love her cover of this song....I listen her version all the time,mostly because I really enjoy listening to the tone(s) of her voice...especially in this song..I truthfully believe anyone who does'nt like this version really has no taste for Amy's voice...she's extremely unique!!

[CaberFeidh]

This version should come with a warning to poke your eardrums with a sharp stick before playing. Exceptionally terrible cover of a great song.

[Doug3790]

just a terrible version of this beautiful song. maybe it isn´t her fault but she sings like an drunken guy!

she should do something else - playing flute or so, while not using her voice!

[ttocsify]

i love it.wow.i'm typing while i'm listening and it keeps getting better.

[ppetal1]

Nice voice and diction. I can't understand what most singers are singing since the sixties. (moan groan)- but this girl can do it. She could save the planet and the specii. There's guts there. Go girl go!

[nssisco]

Great song... can't beat Dougie Maclean though!



[helen60199]

Sorry not the best version I've heard !!

[TheBaldybhoy]

Tune and a half !!!!

[BambridgeBardsDavid]

Im sorry but i really dont like this, listen to the version of dougie maclean, its way better

[beingjohnk]

that was great amy well done you should join exfactor alex

[bstn9]

@all those who just hate this version: but it still is a great song, she does have a very unique voice and she is soooo talented. i had never heard this song before and i'm sure many of you will wonder how come! but, i come from a very small country somewhere in the world.. and I really enjoy listening to amy mc donald singing this nice song :)

[jsscdonahue]

sad version of this great song

Who the hell said she was a singer

[d348ck47ss972]

Beautiful lady with an absolutely wonderful voice

[aGleekinTwinPeaks]

well it's not my favourite version, although i really like amy macdonald, but that is absolutely no reason for hating...it's great if different people have a different opinion, so what's the point in being rude????

[xHurdygurdymaNx]

AWESOME AMY

[TheNewMooongirl]

Wonderful.

♥

[gazz7t9]

Love this song amazing

[paully1969]

Love u Amy... Auchencairn xxx

[paully1969]

Love u Amy xx

[robbie2737]

Nothing but pure talent.......Love this Version!!! Amy Rocks!!

[MrJonnyblabla]

Caledonia 4 ever (check out the song from ''scocha'')!!!

[maxfarquhar]

Would have to disagree with you Brend0n, I think the rawness of Amy's version of the song is quite charming.

[d348ck47ss972]

@maxfarquhar I agree with you,,,,,, Brendon is totally off it

[maxfarquhar]

@d348ck47ss972

Glad you agree with me my friend. I'm not at all nationalistic I just think it's a lovely song. Paulo does a good version as well. Maybe I'm a bit biased on that because he comes from my neck of the woods

[Brend0nY0u0wnMyHeart]

i hate amy macdonald for covering that song!!

she ruins it!

[joshalos1]

@Brend0nY0u0wnMyHeart I hate you for commenting on this song! You ruin it!

[gagermel1234]

@joshalos1 WHO could ruin this song?

[joshalos1]

@gagermel1234 True, true.