Selena Gomez & The Scene - A Year Without Rain - Live@ Ellen (22. September)

[nanaax7]

how come she always sings low and never reach high notes ??

[KuniumiKun]

Her voice is Amazing!!!

[gummybeargigglez]

I don't think it's fair to say she is a bad singer, I think all she needs is a little more power which can can come easy with lessons as she already has natural talent. With that said, she has a better voice than I will ever have. Lol ♥

[Juliabelieber11]

Ok, I've noticed that people are saying that she can't sing live, but really she isn't bad at all! I think she's a FAR above average singer. And I don't get why girls hate her for dating Justin Bieber, yes I like Justin Bieber too but but I know I'll never date him, and neither will any of his other fans, so they might as well be together. And they are fricken cute together!!! So let em be :)

[shanny1413]

okey I know selena may not be a great singer cause she cant sing live but she can sing like her songs arent that autotuned cause she is singing very quiet like she cant sing loud or anything I love her so much <3

[rockinpoison89]

she sounds out of breathe most of the time why ???

[BobbieBombshell]

omg i love selena gomez n hope that u1 day i can meet her hah aha ha lol n i love all of her songs n she still sings awesome n live every celebrity singer sounds alittle different live love u selena gomez <3 :D

[67britneyfan]

shut the fu*k up she can sing she was grate i wold like 4 all u all that said she can sing post a video of u all singing the song u wold get a BIG BOOOOOOO..GROW UP.

[sweetgirlbrandi01]

Love selena but she doesnt have a great voice.

[DanMarie96]

you can always tell when she is lip syncing and when shes not because now shes not and she doesnt even attempt the notes that she hits on her cd\\

[joy2theworld21]

i hate how she goes like chyou instead of you

[joy2theworld21]

shes way better at acting Taylor Swift is the best at singing

[jonnyisleet]

You people are fucking morons. She nailed this performance. You try doing it, and see how you sound. You'll sound like a piece of shit compared to her.

[pechuches]

Some actors just shouldn't become singers but she's ok.

[yourmommm123]

at least she's classy and beautiful :) keep your head up girl!

[MatildeTepest]

No canta tan bien en vivo pero hay que considerar que cuando ya vas creciendo y teniendo experiencia vas mejorando! :D y esto se gana con los años! :D

asi que todos mis animos para selena gomez!! :D

[yootubeloobe]

Eh, okay... :/

[FanRebaMcentire]

OH COME ON!!! THIS IS A BEAUTIFUL SONG. SHE IS JUST NOT GOOD AT SINGING IT.

SHE CAN'TT SING!! SHE CAN'TT SING!!

[watsmehname]

first. SHUTUP

second. its live.

third. she is just EFFING nervous.

=DD

[kissme4eva98]

@watsmehname

shes not always gonna be nervous sometimes she just doesn't have good days 

[KaJerstin]

Also, keep in mind how nerve-racking it is to sing in front of a TON of people! Especially on a television show!

[KaJerstin]

Its not that she's a bad singer... She just gasps between lines of the song, so it sounds worse..

[mnoe30]

q feo q canta en vivo por dios

[jjflyme]

4 a young woman this is fantastic screw with me

[Invaderzim1478]

what the hell is this?...fuckery? leave the singing to demi bitch :p

[TheHellequinne]

Clearly she's nervous, clearly she doesn't sing that well, and she really needs to work on having presence while performing... More vocal lessons, but she is beautiful and I think that's all there is to her.

[FanRebaMcentire]

SHE CAN NOT SING!!!!!!!!!! There are people out there who actually sing, and has better talent. It's very unfortunate. Please.... selena stick with acting!!

[flora323]

wow! this one is good. good job selena. u can sing

[Zoe22028]

u ppl have no lives because instead of comminting on selenas voice how about u lisin to ur self and see how good u sing and selena's alot better than all of u ppl because she acts like a human being jeez u ppl really are jerk! how about pplif u have somthing to say thats mean and just suck it up and just shut up!

[99memaw]

Give her a brake,Yall cant sing anybetter than Selena

[randommmmmmz]

she cant sing...

her videos and songs are just COMPLETELY autotuned...

no hate.... used to like your voice a lot but just noticed it was all fake :i

[PinkEcstacy]

@randommmmmmz yup

[huxley12s]

i going to see her in concert on 8/5 with my uncle or my aunt

[SelGomezMusicForever]

Omg people, she made like one freaking note error, get over it. She sounds fine. And she doesn't suck shelselovering. I bet you couldn't sing any better.

[shelselovering]

She sucks. not going to dance around it.

[pokermark97]

I can probably sing better than her, and I barely have any power in my voice at all :/ She's famous because she's pretty and for her role in waverly place, or whatever it's called. She can't take high notes at all and can't sing.

[Missingyounow29]

Selena can't sing high the part rain because she is not those people who yell at people and those people who yell at little high they could hit high notes but selena is not those people who yell and Miley yell sometime so thats why she could hit high note and Selena would never yell she only said it normal not yell infront of people's face

[TheManuthebestify]

@Missingyounow29

Wrong! Sele knew how to sing the part "RAiN"! If you haven't the ears, buy two, darling! ;)

[Missingyounow29]

she's not lip singing,you could tell because it a little better singing than the cd and its awesome that she sing live

[goeylovegreen]

sorry, but i can't lie that her voice is not that good.

[adazhou930]

@goeylovegreen

Thts so sad it sounds perfect

[1997giselle]

she sounds amazing, great, awesome all these things

[amandaseyfried22]

She is doing great live, why are you all so mean about? Stop hate everyone and start love everyone beginig with yourself...!!!

[slb1996ily]

She cannot sing at all.

[JOMO997]

she does suck live.... it may sound ok but that doesnt mean it's good. this is why:

1. thin voice.. example.... a year without RAAAIINNN... she can't hit that part...

2. do u hear her breaths??? that means she can't do it without back up singers...

3. she just stands there

thanks for reading :)

[starprincesslou]

@JOMO997 agreed. i dont think she exactly SUCKS but shes not GOOD at all.

[mlebrox2]

@JOMO997 not saying anything mean but if she takes breathes and if you can hear them it means it's live  but she can just stand she's not expected to dance as the song doesn't have 1 sorry i'm just saying i'm never like this really

[JOMO997]

@mlebrox2 i know... but it's not like breaths.. how do i say this... she like PANTS... it's like she doesn't have enough air for the long notes... i know ur not mean btw :)

[ChloeJoyyy]

Selena Gomez is awesome ! <3

she has improved live [:

[kerrithetomboy]

the back up singers suck! she sounds good

[itjuhXD]

wow she improved live ,that's something we all can say xD

[solracaujiane2]

i dont like her hair in this video otherwise she is the hottest women i have seen and yeah i knw who megan fox is....

[David2466]

her voice sounds like it is to deep to sing

[paulovictorwan]

Só acho que ela deveria ter soltado mais a voz igual a musica de estúdio, mas adoro a Selena!!!

[suzimuah]

She nailed every high note shes really good live! im not a fan of her, dont care for her to much but truth be told she nailed this song live :)

[TheFear1611]

She is a really good singer live.I was really surprised because I thought she would be bad as everyone suggests.Please stop spreading stupid rumors.Can't you see she's AMAZING?

[Ammoroso29]

She need breathing exercises

[linkRlov]

yes she sounds okay here but maybe her voice sounds weak on this song only compared to round and round or sick of you

[queenofqueens1o1]

shes gotten a lot better at singing live. love this song:)

[ashlynaethyr]

shes not comfortable on stage, she doesn't have a strong voice either.

Compare miley and taylor swifts strong voices to hers...even demi lovatos.

Selena cant sing.

Im sorry I love selena but not as a singer

[evolutionofwords]

@ashlynaethyr demi lovato probably has double or three times the range selena has. she sounds like she can only sing about one octave. im sure demi can at the very least least do 2,but most probably more. selena should stick to acting.

[ashlynaethyr]

@evolutionofwords

agreed

[shiningstars1997]

@ashlynaethyr i agree. =) miley has got talent, i dunno why ppl say she doesnt... she's good. and taylor is great too but to tell the truth i think miley's a better singer than taylor

[DisneyLove33095]

not that she is that bad, just don't like this

[K9Ry]

Pues no canta tan chido en vivo... ahahahaha =S... pero al menos se avienta a cantar y no hace los tipicos blayback jajaja =D

[03kellykelly]

atleast she do it live and don't say it's live and she do lip singing

[mstudmuffin]

falsetto..all the time.

[iloveedward9381]

it sounds good :) and all u ppl say she has a bad voice at least she goes live and she has the nerve to do it :P

[evolutionofwords]

@iloveedward9381 well if youre a singer you have to sing live. its odd to say what you just said. you cant be a pro and not sing live. so it isnt about being brave. its your job. its like saying an athlete is brave for playing in front of people. thats what they get payed to do. so if they play bad you cant say oh at least they played in front of people. selena isnt a kid at a talent show. she gets fame and millions. you cant cut her so much slack.

[gardevoir111]

she sings well live :D better than some people who can't sing for their lives and lip sync =.=

[leslieesomething]

to all of you who think she actually sings well... you're on drugs. sure she can kind of stay on key and what not, but she has a meek voice and when she does try to make it stronger she sounds like she's yelling. she's alright but i really don't think she's meant to be a singer.

[TheRealMarkBoehm]

@leslieesomething okay, so shes not jennifer hudson and her voice is soft. it doesnt make her a bad singer. she hits notes, has a nice voice, and enjoyable songs.

[leslieesomething]

@TheRealMarkBoehm well then anyone who can afford singing lessons can be a singer since that's all it takes to have a trained voice! really, just because someone can hit notes it doesn't make them a singer. there's a difference between soft and meek voices, by the way. and i'm not trying to be an asshole hahah it's just that in my opinion, she's better off as an actress.

[TheRealMarkBoehm]

@leslieesomething well J-Lo is better off as an actress, but she still sings. Beyonce is better off as a singer than an actress. Just because theyre BETTER as one than the other doesn't mean they can't be both. 

[leslieesomething]

@TheRealMarkBoehm well J-Lo can actually sing. i'm just sayin, from my point of view, she's not a great singer. maybe i'm just picky about this because i'm a singer myself, but in my opinion she's just another trained voice. nothing spectacular.

[xjonaslovatox3]

@leslieesomething totally agree with you.

[SuperConcertKid]

shes real good live

[XoSelenaFanfictionoX]

SHES SO MUCH MORE BETTER NOW!! ITS SCARY, THEY DONT AUTO TUNE, ITS JUST HER BEING NERVOUS AND ''DANCING'' TO MUCH, look up her performance at jingle ball..ITS AMAZING!!

[mrstaylorswift9]

she would look prettier with less makeup

LOL she dances like a sims character

[leslieesomething]

@mrstaylorswift9 hahhahhahahahahaha made me lol!

[mrstaylorswift9]

she can sing okay

but it sounds NOTHING like her cd voice

my sister can sing better and my sister sucks.

[CandyCat2010]

she can´t sing

[TheFunnyChannel2009x]

I think shes really good live at least she can sing live =]

[abigiggle98]

she's ok but they must auto tune her voice ALOT on her cd's

[mobilecupcake13]

Thumps up if you've seen those green earpieces in other live performance :D

[1234foufou]

selena soo pretty selly fan forever <3

[shawnaleelee]

i think she just needs to gain confidence and PERFORM. then i think the strength in her voice will naturally build and come through. cause right now her performances are a little boring and weak.

[Ogmazoo]

bbbbbbbbbbbbbaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaad­dddddddddddddddddddddddddddddd­dddddddd

selena WHY

[Nishiwaa]

This is the only vid ive seen her reach the high notes at the end. Compared to other singerss she actually soundss like her actual video song. She's getting so better.

[ginasocute]

No offense, I sing better than you :P

[minhchauta]

This is a siger? All I see and hear is just a pig or a cơ screaming and running on the stage where people standing. I HATE SELENA GOMEZ. I LOVE MILEY CYRUS.

[Music4Ever878]

@minhchauta Well selena hates you too. And miley is a druggie. :)

I LOVE SELENA GOMEZ. And if your gonna watch one of her videos and you DON'T like her,,, then DONT leave a comment. :)

Have a good day! :)

[minhchauta]

@Music4Ever878 Well, I don't need Selena Gomez to love me, who needs a bitch love them? And u know what? I just realize a real bitch have bitch fans and one of them is u. Hahaha! Have a perfect day!:)

[hlithao123]

she is so good and does people say she sucks

[TheSecretmission]

Jesus, what you sing bad! And false, and you're very FAKE! (I'm a fan of the songs she sings NOT false.)

[Karina25ful]

she has an amzing voice!!!

[EGOxZENTRUM]

its cool that she doesn't use playback!

[DANCEfanaticc]

selena is so beautiful! she has grown so much vocally too. luv her!!

[bakarina]

I'd rather listen to Taylor Swift.

[blueocean9uk]

i luv her voice she got nice tone she is classi not like those prostitues out there singin

[katiesaccount1]

I think she is not a good singer but at least she sings live and doesn't go like all those "artist" that lipsync, and I really think she'll get better and better she just needs practice and a good voice trainer(if she want then she can) you should see that she's trying and don't see all her flaws... :/

[bkwrm10]

she doesn't have the best voice but she's improved since her first performance and i don't think she sounds awful

[ThePatryk033]

xjonaslovatox3 here ine live Selena is The best

[TheRealMarkBoehm]

I LOVE HER VOICE! AND THIS SONG! AND HER!

[yasashiibunny34]

IDK why people say she cant sing!! because it sounds good... and at least she sings live

[TheRealMarkBoehm]

@yasashiibunny34 I swear i've said this before...but no one listens!!

[yasashiibunny34]

@TheRealMarkBoehm yah i mean hillary duff she doesnt sings live...ashlee simpson does playback...and there are so many artists that sing awful and selena sings fine bcuz she sounds good....

[TheRealMarkBoehm]

@yasashiibunny34 Thank you!!!

[evolutionofwords]

@yasashiibunny34 cos its bad hun. she hit a few ok notes but so can the average person who doesnt make music or millions. compared to demi,miley and even taylor, selena is bad. you cant even make a comparison. the song isnt bad fair enough but then again selena didnt write. so shes not a good singer,she doesnt play live instruments or dance and she doesnt write a lot of her music. um, why is she famous or supposedly good?? come to think of it what makes her a musician??

[flex5991]

miley cyrus tampoco tiene una gran voz que digamos !!! pero lo que la hace deslumbrante es la puesta en escena que tiene ,toda esa actitud y garra ... eso es lo que queremos ver en selena gomez y es lo que le falta ... queremos ver esa chica arriesgada y sin timidez como en la serio... TE AMO SELENA Y CREO QUE PUEDES MEJORAR AUN MAS!! por cierto su voz esta mejorando cada diaa a diferencia de unos meses atraz :)

[xChipznDipx]

O_o........ umm.. she did alright.

[Hejdiii]

okay i thinks she's great live... NO ONE sings like on the cd's except if it's a concert cd.. duuuh... and the fact that she sings live is awesome - so many others lipsing... so just back off... she's much better than so many others.. and it's not that different than the cd.....

Love your music Selena!!

[jinny329]

@Hejdiii agree with you,she sings almost like the cd's.a very good voice,but hope she could take a break,she sounds a little tired recently.

[RunRideReadRee4444]

@Hejdiii ahem adele

[TheLindaPham]

she is breathing to hard ._.

[mayris286]

because recorded songs are fake

[janeselenafanbrasil]

Selena voce é nota 1000,quem critica tem inveja!

Selena you note is 1000, those who criticize are jealous!

[juxmi101]

Is she using her diaphragm at all? Her voice is really weak.

[PeaceLuvAly]

the chorus is where she sounds best.

i think she should stick to acting :/

[sMILEYfan125]

@PeaceLuvAly lets see you sing live then

[RaysianVenus941]

i hate her dress

[MyLillystar]

@RaysianVenus941 there is nothin wrong with her dress

[RaysianVenus941]

@MyLillystar no mandy i hate it.....

[MyLillystar]

@RaysianVenus941 why? explain ur self

[DmslilAngel103]

she's not amazing but she is good. she's improved a lot too.

i personally love her voice and i'm starting really love her live voice too.

[laurierose14]

For all those out there saying she sucks live, then you lot obviously don't know what a real artist is then. A real artist actually sings the songs live, not lip-synchs like you see mostly everyone else doing. Selena is a really good singer, and this version is really similar to the studio version so don't hate her just because she's actually being a real artist.

[DakotaSilva1]

She need's volcal mixers

[0Jenni1]

wats that green thig in her ear?

[SelMgomez1000]

@0Jenni1 ear plug dumbo

[Amberdanielle31791]

Wow!! She sounds alot better.....but when she first started... It sounds like she was whispering lol but alot better

[MrMusicalbum3]

I Think she´s now alot better than her last album ...... I Guess Now she realy can sing ;)

[CJSmith8793]

They must change her voice ALOT for her CD's cause she sounds nothing like her recorded voice here... She has a weak voice.

[Anathi100]

@CJSmith8793 i dont know wat u think CJ but her voice is perfect

[CJSmith8793]

@Anathi100 i think she sounds nothing like her recorded voice

[Keziasmusic]

@CJSmith8793 There's this thing called being nervous, even celebrities get it sometimes!

I don't even think she sounds the slightest bit weak here, and even if singing wasn't her greatest talent, she's a role model to kids and teens all over the world, she worked hard, and I think she's great at what she does :)

I also think walking around and dancing a bit wears your voice out, and as you practice and perform more, you get used to it, she's mainly known for acting, FOR NOW! :))

[Rachelleloveux]

@CJSmith8793 Hey ,i think you're right but i looked a lot of video of selena singing during a concert and she never have the same voice as in her clip !! :/ I don't think she's a bad singer but just ... her voice is modified ... Do you see what i mean (( sorry i'm french and i don't speak english verry well :$ ))

Buuut i looooove Seeeleeenaaa Gomeeez ♥♥♥

[davidgoei]

i really hate selena gomez :)



[cutiepie9608]

she sings so great..everyone needs to stop hating her..

[SecretStaar]

she is awseome =) Love this song =)

[appequa]

shes such a good singer i love herrrrrrrrrrr

[MsEvanightwish]

why does everyone says she's bad ? i think she's pretty good (: so fuck all the haters!

[luvmiley95]

well she cant really sing it right live but shes def getting better b/c if u compare this with her first live performance than its so much worse lol

[silvialee]

Sure she can't really sing but what is really respectable is the way she carries herself. She has class and atleast when you watch her you don't ask WTF is this its just kinda bland. But I'd still prefer her over Miley anytime.

[CJSmith8793]

@silvialee Well I'm pretty sure my tone deaf dad sings better than Miley so of course anyone would prefer Sel of Miley (Anyone with ears) haha

[Attractive65]

she's wonderful!!!!!!!

[Agus005]

I dont care she cant o can sing , she is awesome!

[mrsjellyful]

even th she cant hit the high notes shes not lip singing! shes trying hur best and shes improved a lot over the past time!

[animezzz4ever]

she is soo great but everyone says she cant't sing live but i really don't understand that becaus she sings so beutiful live!

I LOVE YOU SELENA! YOU ARE THE BEST<3

[AsAiNkUeChAgUrLo]

she may be like britney spears but she dont lip sing so thats what we should like about her and she os not a slut................not britney is but she is looking like one.......i do like her music though.....

[Sherelyna2012]

miley would do this song so so much better

[PrincessNurcii]

Selena get better and better !! (:

i love you selena ♥

[morillonvm]

: /

[tassie961]

Well she has definitely improved. Remember her first ever performance. The one on Dancing with the stars?

[maraelaine07]

i think she's getting better.. she may not be that good but atleast she's not lip syncing.. go Sel! =)

[Sweetopialicious]

Thumbs up if you agree , that from 2:00 she actually sings pretty good .That's my opinion.

[hiimlo]

1:13 / 1:14 LOL

[lorapple]

Song is great yeah,but in live she sings like poop ;D but little better...



[skjreyes2213]

what r u guys talking about i wish i could sing like her!

[xomisuraco]

sucks dick

[FANstar111]

Selena i love you...

great!!!

and i love Ellen

[MissStylerin300]

selena gomez love you .. xoxo

i loovvee youu soo much you my idol ...

miley love you also :)

[BigHealthKiCK]

she learned how to sing, wow.

[DemiLovatoUpdatesHQ]

UGH!!

[NEWYTPaujonasgirl]

WOW SHE DID IT GREAT! i agree.. shes better thn miley cyrus :D

[theeby08]

omg selena gomez is better than miley cyrus no a fence