If Shujaat is a legend...then who are Vilayet ji..Ravi Shankar ji ? Don't DEGRADE this title just like that.....Shujaat is a good sitar player & that's all....LEGEND is something else....& KOI BHI "LEGEND" BAAN NAHI SAKTA...
I was at a live concert of Ustad Shujat Khan today in Seattle area..only time will tell you if he is a legend...and also know that just by labeling one"Guruji1", doesn't make any idiot a GURU....
Shujaat Khan is the living legend - parvez, das, chaudhary are unbelievable players, absolute. but no one has this charisma while playing like shujaat khan -
In indian classical music a gharana is basically a "school" of a particular style. They are musical lineages following a particular musical style. Some gharanas play a "Mine is better than yours" game of rivalry. It is silly but very human. These two players are from two of the biggest rival gharanas.
The beauty of this performance is that it is a meeting of gharanas. Does not happen often mostly because of EastCoast/WestCoast style "we are the only valid gharana" bullsh#%. Enjoy this and praise their open minds and huge talent.
Please!!!, if you are going to say either of these players are anything but top level players you are totally uninformed or maybe high. Both of these players are considered by the general ICM community as unquestionably great players. If you think you know enough about ICM to criticize them you are either ignorant, or you are a gharana bigot that cannot accept the greatness of players from other gharanas.
fortunately iwas preswnt at the concert where my guruji great artiste of imdadkhani ghrana pt. kashinath mukherjee and great artist of patiala gharana vidushi meera banerjee were on the first row in chair. it is aconcert at music loverand noble organise shri jayanta chatterjee's house [sunny towers]
Partho JI = a force to be reckoned with
BABAMUGHALBABASAHEB 7 months ago
this man has no equals....he understands how to blend perfectly ..
jpandyaraja 1 year ago
This looks most like Ranajit Sengupta (Rana) and NOT ParthaSarathy.
baydnina 1 year ago
Masallah Kya bat !
mskhansitar 1 year ago
the sarod is rubbish! sitar is beautiful...
rituparna09 1 year ago
Comment removed
mohanroy1 1 year ago
Did someone in the audience offer Partho jee iodine and gauze after the concert?
paagaldas 2 years ago
Both artists are amazing. It is so nice to listen to Rag Yaman played so beautifully. Thanks for posting the video.
configmap 2 years ago
Great!! The Great!!
MrHtanna 2 years ago
If Shujaat is a legend...then who are Vilayet ji..Ravi Shankar ji ? Don't DEGRADE this title just like that.....Shujaat is a good sitar player & that's all....LEGEND is something else....& KOI BHI "LEGEND" BAAN NAHI SAKTA...
guruji1 2 years ago
I was at a live concert of Ustad Shujat Khan today in Seattle area..only time will tell you if he is a legend...and also know that just by labeling one"Guruji1", doesn't make any idiot a GURU....
girishragini 2 years ago
@guruji1 but i do think shujaat is a legend......he is much more forthcoming with his style than pastmasters
were.......and he understands the mood of the time much better.....you dont have to be old or dead to be
a legend ....Shujaat has more than earned that title
jpandyaraja 1 year ago
Shujaat Khan is the living legend - parvez, das, chaudhary are unbelievable players, absolute. but no one has this charisma while playing like shujaat khan -
thelenious 2 years ago
Are you sure the sarod player is Partho Sarthy and not Ranajit Sengupta?
ayondeep 2 years ago
Sarod player is definitely Partho Sarothy
voxtabla 2 years ago
shujaat khan is totally "top tier" i think its fairly obvious theyre just playing around with this simple gat and having fun with it
princessjesus 3 years ago 3
I'm NOT saying that these guys are bad, but not top tier
but just a bit below
27jackets 3 years ago
Stony, Im sorry but looks like ur the one who's ininformed!
In the indian classical firmmiment in Mumbai and Kolkatta
These two are NOT top tier!!
A ggod example of top tier sitarists would be Shahid Parvez, Kushal Das, SHubhroto Roy Chaudhary,
As far as Sarodists are concerned its AAshish Khan, Brij Narayan, Amjad ALi KHan and Tejendra Majumdar
If you listen to what they are playing you'll hear its relatively simple stuff. A basic Yaman gat in simple rythm.
CInt on next post
27jackets 3 years ago
The gat start on the unusual point of the 3 matra.
Subodas 3 years ago
What contrasting capabilities!
paagaldas 3 years ago
what does the word Gharana mean? at a gues id say its styles or schools of playing?
TimTimmenycharoo 4 years ago
In indian classical music a gharana is basically a "school" of a particular style. They are musical lineages following a particular musical style. Some gharanas play a "Mine is better than yours" game of rivalry. It is silly but very human. These two players are from two of the biggest rival gharanas.
stoney68 4 years ago
The beauty of this performance is that it is a meeting of gharanas. Does not happen often mostly because of EastCoast/WestCoast style "we are the only valid gharana" bullsh#%. Enjoy this and praise their open minds and huge talent.
stoney68 4 years ago 2
Please!!!, if you are going to say either of these players are anything but top level players you are totally uninformed or maybe high. Both of these players are considered by the general ICM community as unquestionably great players. If you think you know enough about ICM to criticize them you are either ignorant, or you are a gharana bigot that cannot accept the greatness of players from other gharanas.
stoney68 4 years ago 2
Shujahat is brilliant sitar player,,,
SitarMusic123 4 years ago 5
Please add more and more such great music!
gangotry 4 years ago
Give me more Parth Sarathy, he is quite good. Shujaat is talented but lack of talim has done him in, that's why he has to play other's composition.
StevenBhullarSr 4 years ago
Weird statement. This is really nice composition and it is good to see he is open to playing it.
sitariya 4 years ago 3
It is Khansahib's inner security that allows him to play a composition from another gharana. How many musicians do you know who would do that?
kamalhyder 4 years ago
Tbats nonsense. Its time we moved away from archaic principles. Shujaat Khan is a stalwart of the sitar, gharana snobbery aside.
iloveagoodbrew 3 years ago
fortunately iwas preswnt at the concert where my guruji great artiste of imdadkhani ghrana pt. kashinath mukherjee and great artist of patiala gharana vidushi meera banerjee were on the first row in chair. it is aconcert at music loverand noble organise shri jayanta chatterjee's house [sunny towers]
souravbrata 4 years ago
is this parthosaraty or ranajitsen gupta??? looks like ranajet!!
scottybuddha 4 years ago
This is Partho Sarathy.
kamalhyder 4 years ago
please add the other 170 minutes! hehe
gurubhai 4 years ago