no hay discusion esta mina desafina por no menos 8 veces por tema...se lo discuto a cualquier fan idiotafanatizado....esta mina grita no llega a las notas destruye los temas
She just needs to stop. She is not Tarja and she never will be. she is making Tarja's beautiful songs sound like a dying cat.. I am not the only person who seems to think so.
perhaps I was being a little too harsh, but the point is, if nightwish is going to continue to do songs from the past, then annette needs to work on her pitch, breath control, and tone! These are all key elements to getting the lovely sound that was laid down by Tarja. I mean...I would expect anyone who sang for nightwish to do so.
oh, I forgot one other thing. She also needs to work on her stage presence. I mean...Tarja still has it. Honestly compared to the former singer, Annette needs to realize the shoes she is trying to fill. I have heard she is getting better, but a lot of people are getting a really bad feeling about the future of nightwish.
I think annette sounds fine in the new songs that nightwish has written since she joined....but...they are written for her voice. Like I said earlier, if they are going to do old nightwish songs, then they need a singer who is willing to step up to the plate and not half way do it.
pongan atenciòn al minuto 0:39 ...como no llega la nota alta de la canciòn hasta desafinada esta, y en toda la canciòn le hace arreglos porque su voz no le da para la canciòn ni para ninguna de nightwish por lo menos de las canciones que cantaba tarja....ya las nuevas canciones son otra cosa.
de pendeja nada, mas pendejos fueron otros en su dia....
y la primera q cambio el estilo de esta cancion en directo fue Tarja, esta cancion es pura depresion y tarja la cantaba con esos vailecitos y esos movimientos de su traje q era lo unico q le importaba...
y dejad ya de fardar de anette, q ya han pasado mas de 3 años!!!!!!!!
bueno pero anette también hace bailesitos estúpidos aparte de cantar mal!!!! si ya pasaron 3 años ya es hora de que se den cuenta de que deben de cambiar vocal otra vez!!!
annete is a good singer and everything but i would have to say that tarja sings this song better, no offense but tarja's voice fits better with this song
She sounds like a karaoke singer who is struggling with the song they chose, and gives up trying to sing it right after she finds that she can't hit the right notes.
I like Tarja's version much more. Anette is just singing....Tarja puts emotions into it. I think in this way. Anette was a mistake of Tuomas. You can condemn me, you can say what you want, this is my opinion.
she fucked the song completely , now it sounds like some kind of pop shit! old nightwish's music is one of the most miraculus metal musics i heard. but new nightwish is definetly notthing to compare with the old...
Whenever I think of Nemo now, I think of this version. The vivid, non-diva, over-the-top version :) Hep hep
IKEAFTW 2 years ago 3
R.I.P Nightwish! :D
Bottlehead89 2 years ago
no hay discusion esta mina desafina por no menos 8 veces por tema...se lo discuto a cualquier fan idiotafanatizado....esta mina grita no llega a las notas destruye los temas
tacatovideo 2 years ago
She just needs to stop. She is not Tarja and she never will be. she is making Tarja's beautiful songs sound like a dying cat.. I am not the only person who seems to think so.
CatrinaDarkangel 2 years ago
Anette 's voice is not sounds like a dying cat.....!!
opera124 2 years ago 5
perhaps I was being a little too harsh, but the point is, if nightwish is going to continue to do songs from the past, then annette needs to work on her pitch, breath control, and tone! These are all key elements to getting the lovely sound that was laid down by Tarja. I mean...I would expect anyone who sang for nightwish to do so.
CatrinaDarkangel 2 years ago
if she does not want to work on tone,pitch, and breath control, then they need to play the song in a key that she can work with.
CatrinaDarkangel 2 years ago
oh, I forgot one other thing. She also needs to work on her stage presence. I mean...Tarja still has it. Honestly compared to the former singer, Annette needs to realize the shoes she is trying to fill. I have heard she is getting better, but a lot of people are getting a really bad feeling about the future of nightwish.
CatrinaDarkangel 2 years ago
I think annette sounds fine in the new songs that nightwish has written since she joined....but...they are written for her voice. Like I said earlier, if they are going to do old nightwish songs, then they need a singer who is willing to step up to the plate and not half way do it.
CatrinaDarkangel 2 years ago
I have wtched the video for a second time and....she really needs to work on her pitch..really bad.Her stage presence still needs a lot of work.
CatrinaDarkangel 2 years ago
pongan atenciòn al minuto 0:39 ...como no llega la nota alta de la canciòn hasta desafinada esta, y en toda la canciòn le hace arreglos porque su voz no le da para la canciòn ni para ninguna de nightwish por lo menos de las canciones que cantaba tarja....ya las nuevas canciones son otra cosa.
kttycaballero 2 years ago
I love Anette ^_^
darkdead16 2 years ago
Stupenda...
DarkPassionTia 3 years ago
creo que la cancion esta mejor con tarja
pero me gusta tambien la version de anette
me gusta mas anette para nightwish
DaRkSymphoniCa 3 years ago
esta pendeja cambio totalmente el estilo de esta maravillosa canción, parece una canción distinta!!!
monep23 3 years ago
de pendeja nada, mas pendejos fueron otros en su dia....
y la primera q cambio el estilo de esta cancion en directo fue Tarja, esta cancion es pura depresion y tarja la cantaba con esos vailecitos y esos movimientos de su traje q era lo unico q le importaba...
y dejad ya de fardar de anette, q ya han pasado mas de 3 años!!!!!!!!
Escapist1st 3 years ago
bueno pero anette también hace bailesitos estúpidos aparte de cantar mal!!!! si ya pasaron 3 años ya es hora de que se den cuenta de que deben de cambiar vocal otra vez!!!
monep23 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
What the fuck is that shit screaming??????
monep23 3 years ago
vai a lavare i piatti....tarja nessuno la può sostituire.....x lo meno se ne cercavano una migliore
FecalMatterDemo 3 years ago
io l'avrei detto in modo diverso...però... anche io la penso uguale..annette ha una bella voce ma non per queste canzoni... o almeno secondo me!
cioè nemo cantata da tarja era tutta un'altra cosa!
lelinahot 2 years ago
non è che annette stoni e che non essendo una soprano come tarja deve cambiare il tempo alle parole se la vuole rendere cantabile per lei.
Io la trovo molto brava ma questa canzone semplicemente non andava cantata così...
Satinedog 3 years ago
Prima fila, cazzo. O_____O
1mrco1 3 years ago
This is the end of all hope for the nightwish!
isid83 3 years ago
NOOOOOOOOO
stona stona stona!! BLEAH!!!!!! TARJA FOREVER!!!!!!!!!
isid83 3 years ago
she was screaming to rais voice.
and her "oh how i wish..." just like fish needs some water.
fafara 3 years ago
great quality!
good concert, I was there too!
fabiofigo 3 years ago 3
yeah i know that Tarja is gone and theres nothing we can do about it and blah blah blah... but this is just horrible... this is fucking pop now.
PolkaP1G 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
out of tone.. annette cannot sing songs with sopranos
Dany22889 3 years ago
She cant sing tarjas songs,thats true,becouse she had a difrent voice:)That is normal...
Dzhil 3 years ago 3
que profanacion de la cancion, definitivamente falta la voz de tarja.
HEF74 3 years ago
horrible.. simply horrible... :(
turlumujan 3 years ago
annete is a good singer and everything but i would have to say that tarja sings this song better, no offense but tarja's voice fits better with this song
HieiBlackDragon 3 years ago
anette can't sing this song tarja is 1000 times better
nasko 3 years ago
She sounds like a karaoke singer who is struggling with the song they chose, and gives up trying to sing it right after she finds that she can't hit the right notes.
justanamehere 3 years ago
I like Tarja's version much more. Anette is just singing....Tarja puts emotions into it. I think in this way. Anette was a mistake of Tuomas. You can condemn me, you can say what you want, this is my opinion.
LadyRoseDepp 3 years ago 2
ehm, i think you have no idea of music...
of course anette puts emotion in it too!!
and i think its just stupid when people more than 1 year after anette has come are still insulting her!!
when will you finally accept her?!
PoetaOdoris 3 years ago
"I think you have no idea of music"
I think this was a bit too much... You don't even know me
And believe me, I gave to Anette a chance. I tried to accept her, but I simply can't...and I don't think that I'll ever be able to do it.
LadyRoseDepp 3 years ago
ok, but then just stop listen to anette!!!
and stop insulting her
you can listen to tarjas solo project!
PoetaOdoris 3 years ago
she shouldnt sing this song... its a really bad performace, she should just sing the new songs, they fit much better to her.
SharonDenAdel394 3 years ago 3
ragazzi, ma ve la ricardate la voce di tarja??? ma dai non c'è partita ...
gimmifix 3 years ago
minchia tid, eri vicinissimo!!!!
D3NNY00 3 years ago
what kind of camera did you use? this is like one of the best live clips. sound and looks good
viciousmoon 3 years ago
a simply sony cybershot! the result is quite good cause i was in the first row and i didn't use zoom =)
TidTid 3 years ago
mera i should get. thanx.
viciousmoon 3 years ago
she fucked the song completely , now it sounds like some kind of pop shit! old nightwish's music is one of the most miraculus metal musics i heard. but new nightwish is definetly notthing to compare with the old...
Irongates55 3 years ago 3
uccidete la bestia che soffre!xD
TARJA TORNAAAAAA ç_ç
urumi2RS 3 years ago
mai nulla di più vero fu scritto !!!!
gimmifix 3 years ago
bella vista=)
jericho667 3 years ago
posso dire che non c'è paragone?;__;
grazie per questo video!^^
nightwish666 4 years ago
ma è vestita come le spice girls?
SlowlyWither 4 years ago
fckin good quality
nightwishfanib 4 years ago
anette's style is soo cute
iloverevenge 4 years ago 8
La neve *_*
kairigiu 4 years ago