Rich Siegel "In Palestine" Part 1 Dedication and Song

[baniyas2011]

the fucking jews kill jesus

[aMMarQuteineh]

I am a Palestinian from east Jerusalem (with the Israeli ID), i take off my hat to you and to all the anti-zionist Jewish. let's create a peaceful life. once i finish my filmmaking master degree here in Paris i'l come to make a video-clip for this music if you dont mind.

Shalom

[annebeck58]

I only hope more will hear you and come around to see what's really wrong..

I don't care how often they like to call me names and attack me. The children ARE dying. And, the USA has never been more wrong about whom we've decided to support.

Thank you for this.

Thanks to Gilad Atzmon, for sending my way, too!

[MrNipley]

And thanks to Gilad for the link!

[MrNipley]

Great song, very moving. Faces the truth. Many thanks.

[krispryo]

Beautiful, powerful, emotional. Thank-you.

[freddietz96]

Still taking comments? This is a really nice song for a really decent cause. Gilad Atzmon put the link on his site today, so I checked it out. Abir Aramin? Did I get that right? God bless her wherever she may be. And the haters who troll these things aren’t much—although this sort of thing angers them the most. Their hearts are hard & small, so righteousness confuses them, fails to connect w/ them. Not me, though.

[elucidative]

I would guess this guy is a good fig as in Jeremiahs prophetic dream.

[RenzoColameo]

BEAUTIFUL SONG; Rich. Thanks !

Peace, Freedom, Love & Harmony on Earth.

FREE, FREE, PALESTINE ! *_*

Hugs from Ireland

Renzo *

[StayHuman0]

God bless you angle, you are the most beautiful person i've ever met

God bless your family, your daughter 

[laurahedgedruid]

Thank you. I got to a point where I needed facts about Palestine, so did tons of research on how (the state of) Israel came to be—Israel is a house of cards. I blame American Jews—for indiscriminantly donating to Israel without asking "What are you planning to do with my donation?" Violence—that's what. American Jews' donations have been used to spread violence. Until American Jews stop cow-towing to Israel, nothing will change. On Twitter, I let people know how I feel—I'm pro-Palestinian.

[kdmirza64]

babynee6,stop talking nounsence,it was you people who were enjoying killings of innocent hamas babies and blamming others.Arabs.using babies and children,s as a human shield,even the fuck fox news had said that,and you piece of shit @richpiano,your kind of a people confiscate the land of a pelestinian,s,auschwitz,poland­.full of ruthless terrorists and their leaders.helping all the terrorist activities and cultures from all over the world,now remember the fucks of a great man THE HITLER.

[richpiano]

@kdmirza64 you are clearly insane- will try to figure out how to block you

[kdmirza64]

@richpiano you can,t block me cuz i am a different person,by the way death to israel,pussrael.pussy mother fuckers.

[annebeck58]

@kdmirza64 Honey, you are cuckoo for crazy-puffs! First of all, most of what you said made zero sense. Secondly, IF you looked up the truth about human-shields, and who uses/used them, you would comprehend what you've attempted to post was all LIES.

Be a decent person. Do some research. Don't believe Rich or anyone else- learn the truth for yourself.

And, then? Come back and apologize for the horrible things you've said.

[kdmirza64]

@annebeck58 don,t give me that fucking crab and stop talking nonsense,it was fucking israelies i mean pussraelies who made that country into hell and confiscate the holy land of pelestinians,fuck you and the truth is that you fuckers are the main cancer,terrorist,HIV aids,and worst then a germs.no 2 confiscating someone land is a terrorism,and no 2 it was you mother fuckers who killed thousand of innocent babies,old womans mens and crushed their naibours.fuck israel completely.

[annebeck58]

@kdmirza64 Okay, here's the thing. I do consider the Israelis the terrorists, so I don't know why you're going off on me.

What you said to Rick made so little sense, it seemed that you were calling Palestinians that.

Gah... derr/

[tsayed]

Thumbs up for your work Rich , your song touched my heart , what a sham that children pay the price for this conflict , may their soul rest in peace in Haven , hoping one day we find peace on Earth .

[WorkingAgainstWalls]

Beautiful! Rich is somebody who does something, who acts and does not just talk....

[eileenfleming]

You gave me 'The Chills' meaning a spiritual connection!

In Solidarity with TJP,

xoxe

[moey558]

If only there were more people like you Rich.

Thanks a lot for this gift you've given us.

[Babynee6]

That's so nice of u Rich Siegal, but Jews need to do a lot more than just singing songs. The situation in Gaza is really really upsetting.

[israelipiper]

@Babynee6 Hamas officials living in luxury? Hamas reselling donated wheat for a profit? Hamas destroying a water-slide park because boys and girls attened together? Hamas brutalizing women for not adhering to their taliban-like codes of conduct and dress? Hamas for firing on Israel from civilian areas? Go hand out at the new shopping mall, or luxury hotels, or swimming pool--we never had those in Auschwitz! One of the highest obesity rates anywhere is in Ghazza.

[annebeck58]

@israelipiper Now, I realize I am a bit late to the "party", but;

when you talk about Hamas officials living in "Luxury". do you mean the luxurious Israeli prisons? Where else, in the world, can one nation/state go into another and arrest their LEADERS, legitimately? Nowhere. And, it's not legitimate arrests, but nothing stops the Israeli aggressors.

Sad you believe all of that tripe.

[israelipiper]

@annebeck58 Believe? I am Israeli, % live here! talk to many people on the front line. Lived among Arabs. When were you last in Gaza? Do you talk to Arabs who are sick & tired of Hamas? Look, lots of good people on all sides, but I doubt you have been here and wandered around and seen the places live, Arab or Jewish. Arabs here have a better and fair sense of Israel than many of you in the west. And that's sad. You often support some of the biggest enemies of the average Arab man and woman.

[aljawadn]

Beautiful.

[vionorino]

May god bless u and ur daughter Rich

I loved so much the song after all Music is what feelings sound like.

Take care

Chris

[ThePmk88]

wonderful ,i love it /nice to meet you rich ,come back to Jamaica mon

[Uba58]

Quatro anos após o assassinato,cruel de Abir Aramin.....eu nunca esquecerei!Paz à sua alma!!!

[mahmoudnij]

thats the real jews , the normal the lover the peacer , not like the jew soldier murder and killer and burner of peace , may allah bless those 2 jews

[purefired]

saw this live! awesome

[Melgani80]

Wonderful song, full of hope. Lovely. Sincere. Beautiful. Magnificent.

[PNabilP]

ufff... I LOVE this tune... I already listened to it first time yesterday and now I did 5 consecutive times! Love what you are saying Rich. Thanks again for a great touching song.

[anamdelmar]

It's very important all the task that Jews and Israelis of good will are doing, I knew some at the breaking of the siege of Gaza on 23rd August 2008, and I've continued to meet more. Thank you Rich and the others. Long live free and safe Palestine!

Love to all good willing people.

[PNabilP]

Indeed a great song and very inspiring, thanks for sharing Maria del Mar, and all of my recognition and admiration to you Mr. Siegel.

[rathcelt]

Thank you. Decency is in short supply on this issue. I hope many will look back on their part in this and feel ashamed of their collusion. Fine song and lyrics.

[israelipiper]

@rathcelt Sad that good-intentioned people often support some of the wrong groups from a distance, hurting the Arab people no end. I am a Siegel, too, from Haifa. No one is perfect anywhere, but when you villify Jews and make violent groups seem pretty and dainty you help no Arab. Spend a year here, and you will change at least some of your mind. At least you will see that you are not well informed all around. I see so much good between we Israels and Arabs, even IDF, and you see none. Sad.

[tropicalmist999]

fantastic Song Rich!- well sung and written.

[luxcretia2]

Rich, you almost made me cry

Kay

[RedSkullBeats]

truely inspiritional. would you mind if i sampled this piano? please message me back. would like to share a few palestine dedication tracks my friends have done.

peace.

[dafna64]

I am Palestinian. I dapreciate good Jew's song.

[biastg]

I heard this in person on Sunday evening 8 Nov 2009. It blew me away! Bravo, Rich! Your songwriting, voice, and piano are all first-rate!

[banandababa]

Great beautiful song

[Shamila11]

I love the message, it is so deep...may God bless Palestine and all who need justice...

[israelipiper]

@Shamila11 May God Bless EVERYONE, Arabs and Jews. What, justice is not for Jews? That reveals a lot!

[Shamila11]

@israelipiper

that's why I wrote "all who needs justice"....EVERYONE. especially the ones with more suffering w/o justice...

[israelipiper]

@Shamila11 And many thanks for that comment. So much talk of justice, yet I see here how a non-Jewish definition of Zionism prevails, is declared unGodly filth, worthy of extermination. Zionism of Jews bears no resemblence to the liberal western definitions & representations. This boo-hoo for Hamas? Hamas?? My God, no one who "loves" Hamas as any respect or feeling for the Arabs of Ghazzah. None whatsoever. Arabs are NOT the problem: the liberal west, disattached from reality, IS.

[ranwilk42367]

great song Rich. Very heartfelt.

[danmanjovi]

Congratulations, Rich! I am so appreciative of you adding this important perspective to this defining issue of our time. Keep it up and God bless you and your family.

Dan

[richpiano]

Thanks Pal, for the very kind words. All the best, -RS

[mahmoudnij]

Im palestinain from gaza , i lost 1 of my brothers 2003 , and i hated all jews before and after , i hated all poeple who was jews , but now i see that all jews are not the same , nice job Rich

[richpiano]

I am so sorry that you lost your brother. Thanks for watching and thanks for writing. -RS

[mahmoudnij]

you welcome and , thx for this nice video , the lyrics is really nice

[vionorino]

@mahmoudnij Allah ye7fazak la ahlak ya khayyeh , ur brother is in a better place... The Zionist exterminated most of my family back in 1948 in Jaffa.. Palesine will return..

[TheDretch]

@mahmoudnij How did you lose his brother? Was he a terrorist?

[mahmoudnij]

@TheDretch The israelic army are the terrorist, My brother was walking home from the work. he was 16 years old, and got shooted 42 tank shoots. At jabalya. And btw, there is no palestinains that is terrorist, but there is freedoom fighters. Call them what ever u want, they still freedoom fighters,

[TheDretch]

@mahmoudnij lol I don't think so. The clear majority of the world sees Hamas as terrorists. Only Arab leaders will meet with them I think that says it all. Being a suicide bomber and blowing up a bus is as terrorist as you can get.

[mahmoudnij]

@TheDretch Im not gonna take a debate here with u, But be aware u are the terroist and not us. u know it even if u deny.

[spreadpeaceNOTfear]

Your words & song R destructive weapons against ALL of these children U perpetuate & incite more insane "justifiable"violence,hatred.

If your cause was truly peace(ful resolution) these lyrics & song title wouldnt exclude equal concern for Jewish Israeli children who are being killed.You would protest that just as passionately.

You could be instruments of peace compassion.

May you be blessed w/clarified expansive vision, 4 sake of all including you & the selective children you DO care about.

[richpiano]

During the recent attack on Gaza 437 Palestinian children were killed and zero Israeli children were killed. Prior to the Gaza attack the ratio of Palestinians killed to Israelis killed was about 5 to 1. Israeli children have been killed, and the death of any child is a tragedy, especially when due to the insanity of adults. But the children who are in crisis today are the children of Palestine, not of Israel.

[israelipiper]

@richpiano may mean well, but is repeating lies that have been concocted to make Jews look bad. It is possible to disagree with the Jewish state as one wishes, but it should be based on facts, and not done with such an acceptance of the agenda-ridden media reportage. Well-meaning people should not ever have to find themselves supporting causes based on false information. Can you not help Arab children without buying into lies? Please?

[annebeck58]

@israelipiper Nobody has had to lie to make Israel look bad. They do a great job of that, themselves..and I mean the Zionist Party (state govt) of Israel. I realise that, even IN Israel, not everyone is filled with such hatred for all Palestinians.

You want to change the subject the moment someone speaks out, even for CHILDREN? What is wrong with you?

[kdmirza64]

@annebeck58 yeah,killing innocent babies,good bastards

[spreadpeaceNOTfear]

Until you embrace- and LIVE compassion for every child killed including Jewish Israeli children who are being killed by Arabs-anyone, then YOU Rich are adding to the problem that blocks peace in the MiddleEast

The children are dying in the entire region,on EVERY side Theres no justification for ANYONE including those

you support-to kill any of them.

You are not helping the children, you are HURTING them

all. U clearly don't also protest the killing of Israeli children you're not about peace .

[mahmoudnij]

All you say is bad and wrong ......... and all Rich is saying is the right , you just dont like the peace for others poeple. as like Rich said , the palestinains killed like 1_5 , and the israeli soldiers killed 2000 palestinain and 437 is chidlren , and a lot of womens , and a lot of mens , who was in their job , thats happend 2009 ..... let poeple try to get peace in palestine like what Rich do

[mahmoudnij]

the song is amazing and the man who singing it should be a singer he is very good

[mahmoudnij]

is the singer a jews ? ,

[laroxyx]

Amazing,My prayers for the Jewish people to find peace,but not on the lands and dead bodies of others...

A Palestinian

[mudylafeet]

Absolutely sobering, beautiful song *****