Ed Butcher has Throat Cancer

[smokahontas1017]

crafter is pathetic

[itabtoo]

crafter sound really good on €666, your past comes..., choose to..., and also in his new band confession, dunno why he sound so suffocated here...

[bleedyourdeath]

you da not fool around whith the holly stuff

[Donatelli13]

ed butcher became the lead singer for a band called eternal lord

[xXxShotgunCoasterxXx]

crafter ftw

[xMOSHLEMx]

What the fuck do you got guys, why are you comparing 2 guys, which got 2 different styles?

It's like you compare soccer with basketball, i mean what the fuck..

[AmeeMonstrous]

I want him back in I Killed The Prom Queen :(

If he don't they should change the band name for Amee Killed the New Guy

[sdmfsdmfn]

lmfao crafter hahah whata fag, ruined the band

[xfaLLen0dAnx]

@sdmfsdmfn Are you stupid?, Crafter was in prom queen a long time before ed butcher was.

[sdmfsdmfn]

@xfaLLen0dAnx your point? crafter fucking blows

[xfaLLen0dAnx]

@sdmfsdmfn y point is that you can't say that crafter ruined the band. Crafter helped make prom queen what it is today.

Butcher only had a short run in PQ and didn't achieve close to anything that crafter did with PQ.

And crafter's a decent vocalist. He's not the best out there, but tbf, he's pretty fucking good nowadays.

[sdmfsdmfn]

@xfaLLen0dAnx butcher>crafter

[JohnKino21]

@itsmeharry1 No shit that's what I said.

[JohnKino21]

@CockneyNutjob4 Why did you overdub the Crafter version over the video? Michael Crafter FTW!! Edd Butcher SUCKS.

[CockneyNutjob4]

@JohnKino21

Did you even bother to read the short video description or are you just mental?

[itsmeharry1]

@JohnKino21 this IS the crafter version

[bloodybirdbrain]

yall got butchrolld.

[AlexMorelocK1]

it isnt Ed butcher its the Michael Crafter version of "Say Goodbye" cause Butcher is with his new ban The hunt for ida Wave

[Orion92786]

@AlexMorelocK1 Ida Wave is his old band, back before he did IKTPQ. After that, he was in Eternal Lord for a bit, and now he's M.I.A.

[aussieman187]

@AlexMorelocK1 no its not

[MrArning]

this is not true!

[AndrewEngage]

wow this is just horrible...fuck crafter

[solongsuicide9]

Ed Butcher <3!

[sk8r835]

ed - sick at high vocals / Crafter is fucking sick at low vocals - there

o and also Crafter is singing hardcore in this aswell

[sk8r835]

ed - sick at high vocals / Crafter is fucking sick at low vocals - there

[blakesc18]

man crafter does not deserve to be in the same sentence as ed butcher ed has the best vocals ever and if iktpq was a deathcore band then he should not be replaced by some hardcore guy who has no highs or lows and his screams are annoying

[HTMLxrulezxd00d]

crafter can go eat a dick, butcher ftw!

[bluie3]

Crafter sucks sooo hard. He has the worst voice. I cant even listen to old Prom Queen because of him. Eds voice is godly. One of my favourites

[CaptainHoyles]

This just sounds... wrong, painfully wrong.

[TeddyCkBone]

they told me tha he got back with Hunt for Ida Wave again after Eternal Lord

[romulus9911]

this is crafter version??? :O

[xxsaldxx]

crafters a bitch....

[MrMrperkun666]

fag core

[yarn1987]

Ed is Currently a Firefighter in scotland.. no joke

[Deanogoesrawr]

@yarn1987 Where im scottish

[DanglyBits101]

Where is Ed now? Anyone know?

[CockneyNutjob4]

@DanglyBits101

Not sure actually. Last I heard, he was kicked out of Eternal Lord.

[lobster272]

@CockneyNutjob4 I heard they took him back in Eternal Lord. Might be wrong.

[resaconne]

@CockneyNutjob4 he is in the hunt for ida wave and he wasn't kicked out of eternal lord , eternal lord died a log time ago

[mlgjesse0]

@CockneyNutjob4 lmfao another band he gets kicked out of????

HAHAHAHAHA hes sucha faggit but a really good vocalist

[XxXDawgmasterXxX]

@CockneyNutjob4 hes in the hunt for ida wave now

[seanisthekingofpie]

@CockneyNutjob4

Well, Im pretty sure they simply broke up.. thats how it was written up in the metallum anyway..

[DIABOLI999666]

@CockneyNutjob4 lol he is a fireman

[thecolourjulian]

@CockneyNutjob4 He is back in The Hunt for Ida Wave

They are fucking epic

[djjorreborable]

@CockneyNutjob4 he's in Confession now

[EdButcherwins]

@DanglyBits101 hes selling all of his stuff! i think he needs money or something! wish he come back with prom queen!

[Rawrcoptar]

@DanglyBits101 He's in The Hunt For Ida Wave now, they've got an EP released and they're working on releasing a new album soon. :o

[temone]

@DanglyBits101 hes doing vocals for the hunt for ida wave

[theycallmekelso93]

@DanglyBits101 He's playing with a band called 'The Hunt For Ida Wave'. They're good, and of course, his wonderful vocals still carry on. They are just recordings though, they don't tour.

[HorizonSlayer]

@DanglyBits101 check out "the hunt for ida wave" i'm pretty sure he's still kicking it with them, doesn't compare to eternal lord though... : /

[kobeandshaqBFF]

@DanglyBits101 the hunt for ida wave last i checked

[joshh180]

@DanglyBits101 This is Ed new band thehuntforidawave

[TermsAndAgreements]

@joshh180 THANK YOU SO MUCH! <3

[cambo91]

@DanglyBits101 not sure where he is but I heard he is a fire fighter now!

[K1LLJ03YD34D]

@DanglyBits101

The Hunt For Ida Wave.

[Brownie5377]

@DanglyBits101

ive heard rumours that he's back with The Hunt For Ida Wave, but not sure

[iktpqwins]

@Brownie5377  I hope so i love THFIW

[Brownie5377]

@iktpqwins

same and even better i love the extra long songs names hahahah

[l4nky2]

@DanglyBits101

he's the frontman for "the hunt for ida wave"

[WNxXcutioner]

@DanglyBits101 Eternal Lord split a few years ago just after the release of their album and the small tour they did. i got a video from one of the few dates he did that i went to.

the last i heard, he was still doing The Hunt for Ida Wave. but he is taking his tiem with it according the recent info given out.

[xysteryxnorma]

@DanglyBits101 hes now back to The hunt for ida wave

[djjorreborable]

@DanglyBits101 Hes in The Hunt For Ida Wave now :)

[xMOSHLEMx]

@DanglyBits101 i believe he's know in the hunt for ida wave or in friday's fallen.

[Bear261186]

@DanglyBits101 hunt for ida wave

[MetalCoreSavedMyLife]

@DanglyBits101 i think he is in his first band again, hunt for ida wave but im not sure :)

[getontop]

@DanglyBits101 he works in a call centre in glasgow i'm sure. he told my mate that he's fed up with the scene and doesn't want to be in a band anymore :(

[Orion92786]

i prefer Butcher and i'm from the US. Crafter's not bad, he's just got a different style. his stuff's more hardcore-oriented, which is probably why it sounds a bit out of place with this, since all of MFTRD was much more metalcore. that all being said, Crafter's still not as good at what he does as Butcher is at his style, and it's funny, cuz Crafter's a cocky ass (watch SN&CL) and Ed's pretty reserved for a metalcore vocalist.

[CockneyNutjob4]

@Orion92786

Yeah I agree, Crafter is a bit up himself, but apparently Ed was being qute cold towards the other members before he left.

[TheKillingName74]

@Orion92786 ed's a shit front man. he never talks to the crowd.

[seanisthekingofpie]

@TheKillingName74

this is true man

[Moyer36]

@Orion92786 Butcher is a pussy. Crafter is where its at. listen to his band Confession. he's dirty as fuck.

[Orion92786]

@Moyer36 I liked the vocals on Cancer until I realized how produced they are. With Ed, you could always hear how real he was. There was no effect; it's his voice, take it as it is. Crafter's voice is much weaker, but he uses the computer to touch it up after. I'll admit that he HAS gotten better in the past few years, but he's still not as good a vocalist as Butcher.

[magicuba]

butcher was a god

[magicuba]

it doesn' t exist butcher was a god

[mitzeylukeblake]

crafter is fucking shocking at vocals, i killed the prom queen definatly aren't even worth listening too unless ed's doing the vocals

[cuntcuntcuntable]

@mitzeylukeblake fuck off...

[cruffrider5]

i wouldnt even listen to IKTPQ if ed didnt sing in it. im syked for The hunt for ida wave getting back together.

[cuntcuntcuntable]

@cruffrider5 agreed on the hunt for ida wave reunion, ed made iktpq sucky

[OmaTheRhcp93]

I like the voice of Crafter, and the voice of Butcher too, for me the Butcher's voice is toward death metal/deathcore

[989jth]

I'm fed up of leaving comments like this for example

Crafter is not shit, its just both Crafter and Ed bring different styles of music to the band. Ed Brings death metal, and Crafter brings the typical Australian metalcore type of vocals

compare some tracks off albums except "Music For The Recently Deceased" with a parkway drive track. it sounds near enough the same, its just typical Australian Metalcore, considering butcher is British and Crafter is Australian.

correct yourself.

[CockneyNutjob4]

I completely agree, you can prefer one over the other but neither is better as they sing different styles.

[989jth]

exactly

[harrypit07]

@CockneyNutjob4 Crafter sucks

[MarionBarber06]

@989jth

Actually crafter is absolute shit

[0Valkyr0]

@989jth Never compare Crafter's vocals to Winston you sick bastard. Never disgrace the almighty Parkway Drive again. They sound nothing alike and saying that is like spitting in the face of Australian metalcore. Crafter is shit compared to Butcher and Winston. End of story.

[Brownie5377]

@989jth

i quite enjoy listening to both versions, but there is of course a difference between them though Winston from Parkways vocals kill Crafters

[Shak3Befor3Us3]

crafter SUCKS compared to ed.

[safetosaydontquoteme]

if you don't like crafter you don't like iktpq, easy as that.

[Shak3Befor3Us3]

ok, lets put it that way then.

[989jth]

@safetosaydontquoteme

well said

[SCREAMOGUY16]

you suk compared to say crafter

[cuntcuntcuntable]

@Shak3Befor3Us3 fuck off...

[callum698]

@Shak3Befor3Us3 agreed but ed butcher turned out to be a dick when he went back to the uk talking shit bout the band and stuff

[loader6989]

this is the original for this song though. crafter is amazing in confessions.

[darcymetal]

baha, crafters def no ed

[SCREAMOGUY16]

if you liked ed butcher over crafter  your UN AUSTRALIAN

[milkeyUK]

clearly.

[TDWP105]

i like ed better and im from usa so yeah...

[SCREAMOGUY16]

@TDWP105 well tht comments was mainly for aussies :)

[cuntcuntcuntable]

@SCREAMOGUY16 sickest fucking comment...

[TheMightyPiepants]

Haha nice. Where did you get the track with Crafter singing?

[CockneyNutjob4]

It was from a special edition of 'Music For The Recently Deceased' that my brother got a while back.