Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (35)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • thats no kelly she is hotter than that

  • only watching for kelly lol,

  • I don't care what anyone says Diana got ripped off. Fantasia was good but Diana was a million times better a singer that she was/is.

  • KELLY CLARKSON IS AMAZING. PERIOD! This is when American Idol was worth watching!

  • Diana voice rode over everyone else's at the end. Girl has some serious pipes, just sayin'.

  • man kelly's so fuckin amazing. she steals the show

  • Kelly Clarkson's voice..... AMAZING!!! She is awesome, so under-rated. My only hope is that someday she gets ALL the recognition she deserves for all her talents!

  • omg kelly winked!! :D love her sooooo much!! my fav singer!!!!

  • Kelly is AMAZING, WONDERFUL!!!!!!!! BEST EVER!!!!!!!!!! AND FOREVER!

  • I think Diana DeGarmo should have won instead of Fantasia.

  • Kelly is amazing!Her voice is well controlled and she can sing!

  • Diana DeGarmo is really great too,k I can't be believe she didn't get further than she did. I think she's fantastic! Fantasia is one of the WORST contestants Idol has seen to date... NO clue how she won! I think it was pity votes. I USED to like, "Summertime," Til she ruined it for me!

  • Omg fantasia cannnot sing at all! How on earth did she win?

  • kelly clarkson is sooo hot and she is the best singer ever!

  • kelly is such a strong presence.

  • Kelly é a melhor cantora desse planeta!!!

  • 2:31 Kelly :D

  • I don't know what it is, fantasia's voice isn't horrible but i just don't like it. I think Diana had the better voice but obviously Kelly set the bar a little too high for following season winners. I mean the only one that comes close range and popularity wise i think was Carrie. and even then Carrie is somewhat at a disadvantage cuz she does have that country tone, which makes it harder for her to be as versatile as Kelly in different genres which makes it hard for her to sell worldwide

  • carrie's done more for her genre than kelly tho

  • depends on your def. of doing more. Carrie's opened up country to a younger/newer audience, but then again so has Taylor. Kelly hasn't done this I agree, but pop is such a broad genre in the 1st place it would be hard to do this. Kelly has however pushed the envelope more so than many other artists. She doesn't sit still in one genre she crosses over into almost every one and writes many of her #1 hits which Carrie hasn't done..yet. and Kelly gave AI the credibility it needed for following yrs

  • @bigbluegrl23 carrie's genre is limited to 5 females. So much for intense competition?

    Pop is very competitive. Kelly won grammy's over gwen, mariah etc. that's worst braggin'

  • @EvFan1985 totally agee.

  • @EvFan1985 don't forget, she won over classic hitters like sheryll crow and bonnie rieght as well. carrie will win over a lot of the country performers because of her voice. but to be honest, she has no artistic value other than that. kelly has more controll and has fought for her right as a song writer to not only write her own songs but to record them and perform them the way she wants to. Not on how the lable would perfer.

  • and EvFan1985 is right, she is freaken hot !!

  • Fantasia sucks !!

    Kelly is amazing like always, love that girl !!

  • @kcloverkc fantasia has a very whinny voice. I don't know how to put it. I know Kelly belts too but her voice sounds fantastic.

    Plus, her butt is like totally awesome!!

  • @EvFan1985 who are you talking about? Kelly or Fantasia??

  • @kcloverkc

    I meant Kelly's belting is better than Fantasia's screaming

  • kelly is the best singer in the world <3

  • Thanks  for posting I have always been partial to seasons 1 and 2 so anytime I can see Kelly with Ruben that is a plus!

  • ruind it!!!!

  • haha. look at 2:25-30.

    Kelly and Fantasia make the same hand gesture. I found that funny.

  • oh that is hilarious! 'cuz they did it in unison!

  • kelly clarkson is so hot.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more