Added: 1 year ago
From: Randy19977
Views: 145,654
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (423)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • key's voice is very masculine! nice!

  • taemin's voice improve so much!

  • i love their voices. <3

  • I'm addicted to Onew and Jonghyun's voices, but key's voice is really sexy

  • Look at Onew on 3:08 !!:DD Staring and smiling at Taemin thinking "Sigh.... Proud of my son....Or was he my daughter...? *Onew Condition*" ........... Lol i really have a weird imagination xD

  • I put this song on my ipod just for 1:40 - 1:43 ♥♥ xD

  • I listened to this after two years and felt so touched...

  • 3:11 - Onew: *Damn Taemin is hot* *smiles* LOL

  • 1:57 - 2:02 Taeminie, your voice is so smoootthhh

  • OMG SHINEEEEEE . YOU GUYS IMPRESSED ME TOO MUCH.

  • This is talent.

  • 1:40-1:43 onew, oh my gosh.

    T___T

  • wow. just wow.

    shinee forever :|

  • Where is Minho?

  • @oramaloveshinee This was when he had his leg injury :(

  • FAINT*

  • for eng subs: /watch?v=tMN1nkHS39c&feature=r­elated

    quasimodo starts around 8:15 but you should watch the entire performance :D

  • english subs???

  • My Onew Voice beautiful♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥Happy birthday♥♥♥♥♥♥

  • Onew is the best singer in this article, it's inspiring, it caused me to cry :)

  • Onew Kills me with her beautiful voice ..... I love him so much!! <3

  • wow per qualche strna ragione mi hanno fatta piangere...sono fantastici..nn ci sono parole...:) shinee 4ever!!!!

  • WOW ! I want to cry every time i hear this song ! There is an awesome harmony between them, the lyrics & the melody... They all have wonderful & powerfull voices as their ways. I almost forgot the fact that MinHo wasn't here how much this song is great ... ♥

    JongHyun : great, hot & powerful

    Onew : awesome & sweet

    Key : great, sweet & sexy

    TaeMin : amazing & deep

    ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥

  • Where's Minho? :O

  • @Never4mind This was when he had his leg injury so he wasn't here D:

  • If its one thing that make Shinee songs nice, its the perfect combination of their voices, almost like a harmony.

  • Perfect <3

  • they all close their eyes -_-

  • Taemin may not be the best singer, but he has the best voice. he really knows how to emphasize emotions in his lines, and I love the ripply-ness in his voice >< so gentle yet filled with emotion...

  • @aiayumi i agree. his talent is focused more on dancing then on singing but he is still like the other a technically good singer. they all have really good control which is something you dont always see.

  • OMO ! How Onew look at Taeminnie from 3:11 to 3:14 *-*

  • i wish Key and Taemin would have as much confidence as Jonghyun and Onew in this song. thats the only thing lacking. they ROCK but they would rock more if they just relax a bit :)

    OMG! ive never noticed that Onew has almost Chestnut eyes *_* as if he needs to be more attractive <3

    and Jonghyun's 03:30 gave me goose bumps! when he said "im trying, dying, crying for you baby" my eyes teared up. hes not my bias but theres no way in hell that hes not the most talented! his voice can move a mountain!

  • They are angels from heaven!

  • each member in SHINee has their own unique vocals! :D I love all of them's!

  • 3:16-3:20 my fav <3

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Onew isn't even trying. He has a beautiful voice

  • Thumbs up if you think Taemin had a sore throat.

  • I've always loved this song but seeing them sing it live, and seeing Onew singing brings me to tears. I love them so much <3

  • Onew oppa smooth voice.....

    I <3 it.... ^_^

  • this song is so beautiful, makes me cry everytime... ♥ and their voices are so awesome <3

  • I adore this song. Amazing.

    And the boys are so powerful :)

  • miracle jonghyun : ) 'n sweet voice taeminnn

  • I LOVE ALL THEIR VOICES BUT TAEMIN JUST HAS THAT CUTENESS gaahh <3

  • im in LOVE with onews voice but...wheres minho? and jonghyuns voice is powerful

  • @iamchibisango re hab due to injury from dream team

  • where is minho??

  • aahhhh i always get tears in my eyes everytime i listen to this. their voices are just so angelic. <3

  • *DIES*

    And this right here is exactly why SHINee is the best! ♥

  • shinee is the best just like dbsk..no one cant beat this 2 group!!!

  • Jonghyun's voice!!!!<3

  • Am new to SHINee, can't believe i've been obsessed to them

    so fast, one of the reason is how their ability to sing in live,

    almost like listening to their CD, love them all !!

  • amazing...

  • taemin-ah !neon jeongmal yeppeo! u'r not a baby anymore *'_'*

  • their voices are amazing XD

  • GUYS!!!!! ELLEN FROM "THE ELLEN SHOW" IS GONNA INVITE A KPOP GROUP! IF YOU ARE A SHAWOL THEN PLEASE GO TO HER CHANNEL THEELLENSHOW AND WRITE SHINEE IN THE COMMENT BOX!!!!!!!

  • One of my Fav song..

  • @NADIAHsubyr i love this song too :)

    

  • i like taemin's voice

  • This performance is JUST AMAZING.. Onew voice is PERFECT ..

    Jong's voice too.. Key too.. Tae too.. Damn . I LOVE SHINee

  • How the hell does Jonghyun get his voice to get that high. He is AMAZING.

  • i really dont like how they kept using autotune here,, they can totally sing without it!

  • Omg!! Taemin i actually love you!!!

    After watching Taemin do one of Jonghyun's high notes in a live performance when Jonghyun wasn't there listening to his notes now aren't as impressive as i expect them... still freaking amazing though xD

    But.... i really do feel Minho's absence! He doesn't sing that much but it does sound kinda empty without him =(

    Onew and Key awesome as always

    Taemin! <3

  • @floanne21 but the performance when he covered Jjong's high notes was like two months after this one, so he..improved? haha :)

  • Thumbs up for Jjong's high note. :D Beautiful harmony~ Though Taemin sounds a bit shaky.

  • Fantastic *_* Jonghyun :'D

  • taemin love love

  • you know what...i'm not minho biased but i've hear him sing and his voice is pretty nice and has this sweet thing on it at it's weird because his voice (when his talking) is very deep and all while singing very sweet and well rapping is obviously his specialty...

    to the rest...onew's voice is my favorite his voice is sweet a feel like i'm melting or something every time i heart it...

    every member has their own strengths...

    and well that's just my opinion...

  • This is my fav song from this album. god it's fucking amazing life!

  • WOW to their voices. Crystal clear. But where's my minho?

  • JonghYun *_______________*

  • @ipohkengyeah I really don't think it's okay to say 'ppl who can't sing at all will think Minho is a good singer'. I understand people are entitled to their own opinions. But you can't go off telling people who their fans of because they actually think and see their bias has talent. Because last time I checked, believing in your bias IS being a fan. :/

  • @muffincakeeex actually, it was my mistake for giving a sarcastic remark. ur right. minho cant really sing its fact, but thats not the reason he's not here. each people are entitled to their own opinion is a dangerous remark. some things are meant to be right. for a rapist, his right opinion would be, pretty girls should be fucked by me.. though it is obviously wrong. lets say we all know taemin is good in dance. if in my opinion i say, taemin dance is bullshit. am i stil right?

  • @ipohkengyeah And what the hell are you bringing up a rapist thing for? That has NOTHING to do with what this conversation is about! It's not even fucking relevant! In fact, to even compare something like that to a singing topic is SO fucking WRONG. You know what else is wrong? The fact that Minho isn't even in this video, but because he's not, you bring up COMPLETE FUCKING BULL about how he can't sing. Yes it's his weakness, but that's not the reason he wasn't here. He was injured.

  • @ipohkengyeah Honestly, you're really something else to be commenting on a SHINee video, knowing how many people are Minho biased. Were you looking for an argument? I'm not even Minho biased. In fact, if I had to put SHINee in order, Minho would be second to last, because I'm Jonghyun biased. But even I'm fucking smart enough to not go off ranting about how "crappy" Minho is. And even though I favor him less, I still acknowledged the fact that he has some talent.

  • @ipohkengyeah I honestly, HONESTLY, hope to God that you don't even consider yourself a SHINee fan. I hope you don't. Because one who doesn't like a member for their talent, but for their looks is just plain shallow. You really think you have the right of way here, don't you? Don't even fucking do me a response back. You just disgust me. I'm done here, GOODBYE. ^_^

  • @ipohkengyeah Also Taemin. He may be popular in Japan, but you REALLY think SMENT would make him lead singer of Replay JAP version if he didn't have a good voice? Minho doesn't sing much in songs, but he DOES sing. Do you really think SMENT wouldn't let him sing in some of their songs if he couldn't sing at all? Like you said, SM is smarter than that. watch?v=7j3OEW1Jmjs&feature=re­lated <- HERE, he even had his own solo. He may not be amazing, but he CAN sing.

  • @ipohkengyeah Actually, I'm usually not the type to jump into conversation. But it's really not a okay to talk to a person the way you are. I'm a HARDCORE Shinee fan. I've acknowledged that sure, Taemin and Key aren't AMAZING singers like Onew and Jjong. But if they weren't great, you think they wouldn't have as many solos in songs as they do? Some songs even have Key singing most of it. So how would someone be able to say that he's not a good singer when he gets alot of solos?

  • How Onew bites his lip at 3:13, staring at Taemin sing.

  • Jonghyun!!!!!!!! Saranghae!!!!

  • Jonghyun voice Is the best !!! He got the most beautiful voice I ever heard!!! Btw poor Minho .. U still a good rapper though!! ;) jjong!!

  • i cry everytime i watch this. onew's voice is just so... :')

  • I'm sure the one disliking this is Minho because he couldn't be with this breathtaking performance...(It's sad that he couldn't be there...)

  • WHERE IS MINHO?!

  • @LOVEISSTATIC minho cant sing.. so he's not ere.

  • @ipohkengyeah he's still a part of SHINee though :( they could have let him rap xD

  • JONGHYUN becomes so emotional when singing

  • @LOVEISSTATIC what he said wasnt true... he was injured so he couldnt perform is what i heard

  • @ipohkengyeah thats not true

  • @july551 is it? show me a video where he sings beautifully .. dun be denial fangirl..

  • @ipohkengyeah well then u show me a video where he didnt sing beautifully? Stop jumping to conclusions just because he isnt here... He was injured and he couldnt perform

  • @july551 everyone acknowledge and even minho himself knows he's not a good singer. if u do not know that, how are u a fan of minho. whut a shame.. type in minho n yuri singing.. see how he out of key... there's a reason why he's only a rapper and so little parts in every shinee songs.. u think the SM people are stupid ? i love minho as i said, but its a fact he cant really sing.. that depends on ur perception as well. ppl who cant sing at all will think minho is a good singer...

  • @ipohkengyeah well of course hes not the best singer out there and it doesnt mean u need to bash him or anyone else.Y r u only looking at his weakness and not his strength? Key also raps in the group for just a little so does that mean he is a bad singer??And yes Or course i agree that Jonghyun and Onew and the best singers in the group but i minho cant sing then y is he in SHINee? Is minho couldnt sing they why the heck did SM take him in to train?And if u were a fan of SHINee

  • @july551 im talking about singing my dear. why are u so stupid ? i never say he rap poor or he looks ugly. if i look at his weakness, i wouldnt mentioned hes so handsome and so charismatic in the first place. im talking about fact that he really cant sing. because i said fact, means i bash him ? then i say jonghyun is good, means i falter him ? its just the truth that jonghyun can sing well whether i like him or not. because its the fact. whether i dislike taemin or not, he sitll dance well..

  • @july551 the only one who could sing in shinee is obviously jonghyun n onew.. taemin has nice voice but his techniques is not that developed in terms of head voice.. but hes stil young and alot potential.. onew is known for his voice cracking though he sings good.. jonghyun is one of the top singers in KPOP.. key voice is not dat good.. if ur pure shinee fans u would know that.. why jonghyun n dbsk hero stands in mid, because they are lead vocalist while main vocalist at the side.onew n junsu

  • @ipohkengyeah u would like them all and NOT bash about then. U cant even call urself a fan after that and then why are u even here??And does everyone need to be able to dance freestyle to be good? WEll Jooyeon in After School can't dance freestyle so she cant sing? And r u calling all the rappers in groups people who cant sing? Like Amber,Yunho,Gahi,Taecyeon,Hyun­a,Zinger,Junhyung,Eunhyuk,Hwa Young ,CL,G-Dragon,T.O.P.?So just because if u dont have a solo performance ur suddenly a bad singger?

  • @july551 i duno why ur so stupid and talk on other things. its jjust how boyband works. they are main vocalist, main dancer, rapper.. of course each and everyone had their own strengh and weaknesses. thats why they form a band and become so great like tvxq because they covered each other weaknesses. i never even said u must have a solo performance to be a gud singer. BUT ITS BECAUSE IF UR GOOD, PEOPLE WILL LET U HAVE SOLO PERFORMANCE. common sense.

  • MOST IMPORTANT IS, I DUNO WHATS UR DEFINITION OF SINGING BEAUTIFULLY. PEOPLE WHO CANT DANCE WILL THINK, OH THIS GUY DANCE GOOD.. its something relative. i mean SHINEE IS A FAMOUS BOYBAND. they must have a certain standard. i sing for my school and clubs as well. does that mean im good enough to be a singer. not really. do u know how to sing ? if not, this is a useless debate.. and seriously, all the names u gave above cant really sing..

  • it is not that, beacuse minho doesnt sing as good as others, i dislike him. dun take things the wrong way. as much as i love tvxq, i have to admit yunho and changmin voice is not really suitable to sing.. they had all the techniques, high pitch n etc.. but the "bornt voice" is not nice. jaejoong originally had tis husky sexy voice thats why with the trained skills, he became such great singer.

  • @ipohkengyeah .... im not taking it the rong way. And changmins voice is a bit better and higher since Yunho is a rapper and yea i agree with u about Jaejoong and just like Junsu <3 (my fave) that he is born with the voice but some voice can improve just like Taemin did when he started and for Jaejoong a heck of a good trot singer too with that voice ^^

  • @july551 yea dats what im trying to say... i also agree changmin voice is a bit better.. thats why they do as a band... when jaejoong n junsu sing, the other 3 do background harmonization in their acapellas. while in dance, yunho and junsu always switch place in the middle. each member had own good n weakness. boyband r human too

  • @ipohkengyeah yea ik what u mean but when u said minho can't sing then it would of better if u said his strength too like if he raps or his charisma. like minho's not here because like he can't sing as well as others and there no rapping part rather then he can't sing at all.Cause mostly every band or group has a rapper and that would be one of minho's strength

  • @july551 dat was a mistake on my part sorry. luckily ur understandable.. as a matter of fact, all shinee members can actualy dance very well. of course taemin is sth beyond the rest. minho sure can rap, but the degree of skills is not really that great if u know what i mean. sth like, al dbsk members obviously can sing, but the degree of skills that hero n junsu had is beyond the rest.

  • @ipohkengyeah yea thats what i just wanted u to understand what i was trying to say 

  • @ipohkengyeah Well he does have solos and tons of then type in 101107-[Fancam] SHINee Minho solo "If You Leave" (Full Song) @Hello Taiwan Fan Party

  • @july551 do u know what is singing beautifully ?? im not talking about singing karaoke. ppl who do not know how to sing or dance, when they see others doing better, they'll think its very good. minho is known for his deep voice. even onew said dat. do u actually know about mixed voice, vibrato, high pitch and all ? dont just say he's good because he's ur idol. i love minho too for his looks and charisma not singing.

  • @july551 in every shinee songs, minho only raps and even his lines are only 1-2 . rappers are known for not good in singing like eminem, lil wayne, travie mccoy n others... thats why they are rapper instead of really a singer.. are u even shinee fan to not even know that. minho could dance choreographed dance but not freestyle.. do u know that ? and pls, show me a video where minho sings beautifully?is there a solo performance by minho or in variety shows? NONE.. do u even know whut is singing

  • taemins voice is so sweeet! x3

  • omg onew's "saranghe" at the end just . .DEAD

  • Minho????

    

  • their naked skin is sexier than any girl I'm vexed >_______<

    Love you shinee <3

  • Onew's voice is such a lullaby <333

    Dang his voice is my favourite in SHINee!

  • DBSK & SHINee = YunJae & JongKey

  • Beautiful song! Great performance!

  • omg i love there solo's there voices are great :D:D:D I love jonghyun!!

  • This song makes me tear up every single time... their voices are like angels, maybe even beyond that... ;__________;

  • onew is just perfect singing~ his voice just made me melt...this is one of the few songs that makes me cry TT TT

  • What i can say? P E R F E C T

    Thanks SHINee..

    Italy Love You

  • I really love how they sing with all the emotion, it sounds so beautiful (especially Onew and Jonghyun) and I am totally impressed by Taemin his abilities ....really surprised, <3

  • onew!!! <33

  • 3:10 . cute ontae moment. that was the most adorable loving smile everrr. x) onewww <3 <3

  • They're just beautiful *-*

    I think all of them sing the song perfectly :3

    And even if they're not singing it perfectly, they're just people like us :3

    But where's Minho? -_-

  • @2vampirlady2 he hurt his foot

  • Onew, OMG You're killing me, like really....I almost couldn't get through the video because I LOVE you so much!!!!! I feel like I'm about to EXPLODE!!!! I love this song and the emotion they put in it...there are no words!!!! Oh God, I hope I don't cry!!!!!

  • i love this song! i love onew ! i love shinee!!

    no, seriously onews voice is really angelical ;_; !

    when i hear this song i feel weird...in a good way xD!

    thanks for the vids!

  • I have a feeling I may have already posted this but from 1:36 that is my favorite part from Onew! >.< It just sounds so, magical and stuff ;P

  • why does onew's voice sound so ... fake and robotic ? :S

    it sounds awesome ! :D

  • onew's voice is magical. i love onew's singing ._.

  • 사랑해 샤이니!!!!!

  • Could someone explain what they mean by your bias, or my bias? >.<

  • @catchycatherine your all time fav k-pop guy / or girl . . . its used alot on tumblr like my bias is minho

  • @catchycatherine If i say 'my bias is Taemin' it means that 'my favourite member is Taemin'. This is just an example. The definition of 'bias' is favoritism in (a person) or to cause influence...:) xxx

  • one of the best songs ever ^-^ Onew's sweet voice. Jonghyun's awesome vocals. taekey still did quite a good job to make this song damn freaking nice.

    Dinobby,

    I'm trying dying crying for you baby..

  • ONEW's voice. Absolutely amazing. <3

  • love your hair taemin...sooo cute....

    love you key and onew...:)

  • i wonder how high can jjong go.... his vocal range is so wide! and onew, you really melt me with your singing!

  • I Love SHINee no matter what. I Hope we will meet....someday.

  • im so proud of taemin! and hes not even my oppa bias!

  • jong is getting down! love him!

  • This is exactly why Jonghyun is my bias!

  • OMOM! They are amazing!!!!! I have never heard a kpop group sing without the backgroud cd track that has there voices on it! Have any other groups like Super Junior go on this show and sang with out the back up volcals?

  • 사랑해샤이니~ <3

  • I think that this is better than the album version (: It really brings out the emotions of SHINee members. They have such beautiful, mesmerising voices. I hate it when my friends say that kpop artistes have plastic faces and whiny, fake voices. This is totally living proof that not all kpop peeps are like that. SHINee Saranghae ♥ I love you Key and Onew oppas too! U-KISS and SHINee = best kpop groups EVER xD

  • @xXBlueBerries OMG! Totally agree with you! We both love SHINee and U-KISS! ♥

  • Notice that everytime Taemin sings, Onew looks at him proudly. =D he must have been so proud that Taemin had improved his singing. =)) at 3:12 was cuuute. =)

  • Jonghyun is amazing! The best voice in SHINee, in my opinion (: And Taemin is so damn cute ç_____ç

  • Comment removed

  • this just overall took my breathe away. how is it possible for 4 guys to be this perfect? i swear i felt empty as soon as the last note of this song played. beautiful shinee<3

  • Onew literally made me cry here. God.  :'(

  • Right now...I am crying...involuntary.

    I don't even have to know what their saying, but I still feel the sadness behind the meaning of the song and I just...cry.

    Absolutely beautiful :)

  • Onew at 00:38 blows me away every time XD

  • KEYbb~~~~~` i love you and your voice like no other♥ ♥ ♥

    gtfo haters

  • This gives me actual goosebumps. The emotion they put into their singing is breathtaking. If only Minho was in this D:

  • wow I love there voices here......... onew, jonghyun, taemin, and key there voices improved wow super super love SHINee.....

  • love

  • i love the audio and the music!!!! wow love there voices i wish minho is here so the music is perfect SHINee quasimodo........ love SHINee

  • Gorgeous, gorgeous. I simply love how their voices blend in all together so smoothly. Each one of them is unique yet amazing. SHINee, fighting! Never give up because you are simply too awesome! ♥

  • Everytime I watch this I cry. They mean so much to mean.

  • Onew.. he really melts my heart..

    it's not only because his beautiful voice, but also his expression and the way he sing it, he makes us can feel the sadness in the song..

  • @ellesharon i'm a Key biased but i can see that Onew has a natural warmth from the look to his voice

  • @luckydotloveg I know, I love Key but I am Onew biased ^^

  • ahvkgbhrjkvtnqerjcwenl (that was my jaw hitting the keyboard) ....... (that was my heart exploding leaving me incapable of any further commenting)

    SHINee <3 <3

    Onew's voice never fails to stay perfect and smooth~

    Jonghyun's high notes stopped my heart time and time again

    Key's powerful voice leaving us all breathless

    Taemin's vocals improving more and more, ranking him right up there with his hyungs...

    SHINee..is..love..

  • @december022snow...someone said he was in the hospital because of an injured leg from dream team:(

  • where is Minho? why i can't see him???

  • Is Jonghyun voice training Taemin?? They sound so much alike <3

  • how is this song so perfect?

  • where's minho?