In any case, as someone who is in such a politically delicate position, it is not possible to do away the safety which ambiguity grants with different equivalent terms of "being Taiwanese". Your video opens the long controversial topic of benshenren, and waishenren, or those who are native to Taiwan, and those who are literally, from another province. I can only say that you nasty comments to your viewership will not get you far if you intend to become a Youtube partner and make your 100k.
Someone needs to take a history lesson to find out the difference between ROC and PRC. To claim ROC heritage is to make territorial claims of China under the CKS regime. President MYJ is simply making a statement affirming the legacy of ROC. ROC is synonymous with the Taiwanese. Making the claim that one is Chinese, does not suggest that one is from China, as one could be referring to one's ethnicity as being Han Chinese, also the proper scientific term.
@al1427 ROC is not synonymous with Taiwan. ROC stands for the REPUBLIC OF CHINA....literally. My videos have nothing to do with benshenren and waishenren. waishenren is no longer an issue in taiwan. plenty of my friends come from waishenren parents but they 100% identify themselves as being taiwanese. yes, to truly understand the ROC and PRC you need to study history, REAL HISTORY, not fairy tale chinese history.
@TheDopenessism Then Youtube has diplomatically chosen one of two sides (whether to acknowledge the term Taiwanese America or Chinese American) but YOUTUBE does not determine ANYTHING besides YOUTUBE related matters so this statement means nothing to the real world. Taiwan has never been a nation and still isn't today. It remains a province of ROC. So to be politically correct, we are all FROM Taiwan, but we are all Republic of China Chinese, just like someone can be FROM Kinmen but is ROChinese
@mrdx21 why don't you comment on your use of PINYIN? don't have a lame comeback for that one do you? you chinks should stop using arabic numerals too.
@ahbying you obviously behave more like a 'chump' than me. Do not thank me by the way, send your gratefulness to those fucking pricks you mix with. If you want to laugh find a mirror and laugh into it
@mrdx21 hey chop suey...find a mirror? that's your fucking comeback? look around shithead, the world is full of mixed races. thank fucking god i'm not CHINESE like yourfuckingself. you're pure alright, purely a fucking joke. nice. thanks again for making chinese look dumb as shit.
@ahbying Sure you are not Chinese. Who the fuck ever think you are?! You are a piece of filthy shit wearing fake smile in your dick head or whatever it is. BTW, stop speaking Fujianese which is a Chinese dialect stupid cunt like you shall be banned from using it.
@mrdx21 "Who the fuck ever think you are?! You are a piece of filthy shit wearing fake smile in your dick head or whatever it is"??? HAHAHAHAHAHA. stick to speaking chink because your english is shit. i'm speaking taiwanese motherfucker not fujianese. quit hating you fucking loser. once again, I KNOW I'M NOT CHINESE, THANK FUCKING GOD!!! you on the other hand are the smartest chinese person i've met in quite some time...not wonder you guys are fucked. hahaha.
@mrdx21 "you shall be banned from using it"?? hahahahahaha. are you going to stop me from speaking taiwanese you coward ass little chink? hahahahahaha...i wasn't aware you had that authority. PLEASE leave more comments. the more you write, the dumber you look. nice....
@kaiconan 地理!/ geography? your worried about geography? 澎湖、金門、馬祖!? umm, those are part of 台灣 too. what exactly is your point? 民進黨只會說我是台灣人!? what about 中國國民黨!? they call themselves 台灣人 only for elections, but then also call themselves chinese or fucking ROCers. what the fuck is a ROCer? for someone living in Canada, you should know that no one has a fucking clue where the ROC is... it's called 台灣. 地理!? shit...read some fucking HISTORY.
@kaiconan thank you for showing us the amazingness that is 中國國民黨 supporters. this definitely ranks as one of the dumbest comments i've seen anyone make. what fucking nonsense are you rambling about? hahahahaha...
@kaiconan 我沒有水準啦! look what i say before and after fuck, that should be your focus. who cares what language i'm speaking? if you choose to use taiwanese or english, that's for me to decide. 因為有你這樣的人!? i was going to say the same fucking thing about you. 真不知道你到底是拿裡人!? i'm a taiwanese-american, what about that can't you understand? who in canada knows what the ROC is!? taiwan is taiwan.
@kaiconan i understand that aboriginals were the first taiwanese. no one here is saying they're not. however, the definition of being taiwanese today is much more inclusive. by your lame logic, then where did chinese people come from before china? what gives chinese the right to call themselves chinese? shouldn't they call themselves africans? you should get off your fucking high horse cuz the more you write, the less convincing you sound.
@ahbying 看的出來你使中抓著"現今的台灣人"的定義，請問是誰定義？看來你還沒有搞清楚 Chinese People 的 Chinese 是指什麼！Chinese 當然是指 People of China ，那麼 China 當然也是指 ROC 的C ，大部分自卑的人都會怕跟對岸混淆改成 Taiwanese ，這樣就真的把其他地方的人邊緣化。真的很遺憾看到你用一大廢話只是為了想寫 FuXk 而已，你這麼想寫、這麼想念，就乾脆上傳一篇都是 Fuxk 的影片好了～
When you hear Ma Ying-jeou say he is Taiwanese or he loves Taiwan, you would know that an election is coming up because he wouldn't even mention "Taiwan" in any other situations.
如果馬英九開始說自己是台灣人, 或是說自己愛台灣, 你就知道總統大選快要到了.
他在選舉前就整天消費"台灣"這兩字 選後就"馬上"改稱中華台北 之類的矮化名.
Seriously, Ma Ying-jeou loves nothing but one China and communism.
可不可以請馬總統把臉書的回應翻成英文?不要只會玩文字遊戲, how the heck do you translate 中華民族炎黃子孫? (Chinese??) and 中華民國國民? (Republic of China citizen?). The only way to avoid confusion is to say we are fromＴＡＩＷＡＮ
1895/04/之後的台灣人早就跟中國無關了，1945/04/01之後本土台灣人擁有日本國籍，戰敗後卻莫名其妙被變成中國籍這才是問題的根源，the people on taiwan ,只要住在台灣的土地上都可稱為台灣人，誰不可以講台灣人?錯在國籍有問題，本土台灣人目前沒有國籍，而住在台灣土地上的中國籍台灣人士都是從1945/08/15之後才來台灣的.
Taiwan need to REMOVE the ROC FAKE goverment. period! that is s the ONLY solution to make Taiwan a real nation not some stupid "Providence" of ROC or PROC they so called.
低能的綠畜果然都是瞎扯的狠腳色
低能綠畜耍嘴皮的能力要加油囉
happy5body 1 day ago
This has been flagged as spam show
这人长得怪。看得令人倒胃
bluezhaolin 4 days ago
這阿明也說得很複雜阿~ 直接說你是阿英花錢請來的就好了咩~ 講那麼多~
superblf 1 month ago
@superblf 講那麼多? 2 minutes is 講那麼多!? just say you're KMT, 講那麼多. haha...nice try.
ahbying 1 month ago
晕。。。这家伙是不是吃毒奶粉长大的啊？美国也有毒奶粉？共产党洗脑洗得利害，民进党怎么也对民众洗脑，都洗出些脑残东西来。你是人吗？你连人最基本是非都分不清楚。如果你搞政治，台湾就没有未来了。
pkgwin 2 months ago
We appreciate your effort man~ Hope more Taiwanese people can awake up from Ma & KTM's deceptions~
Maverickt38 2 months ago
搬回台灣不代表愛台灣,沒回台灣也不見得不愛台灣,說這種話表示你只是可笑的小綠綠
gtchou0610 2 months ago
馬為台灣打拼?? 的確很打拼，中國來馬上將國旗收起來，國際場合也馬上把國旗收起來。
就稱臺灣人就好，不要說什麼"中華民族"或是"炎黃子孫"，以免外國人分不清你是哪裏人
HIEHIMIKO 3 months ago
這個啊明，請別在搞破壞了，你不是也在國外嗎，至少馬總也是在為國家打拼啊，你只是出張嘴而已，誰都嘛會。
BrianHsin 3 months ago
@BrianHsin i was born in the states. what's your point? 你也只是出張嘴而已...hahaha. 白七! thanks for proving your own useless point.
ahbying 3 months ago
@BrianHsin why don't you just say you're KMT? scared!?
ahbying 3 months ago
@BrianHsin why don't you tell us what you have done for Taiwan? or 你只是出張嘴而已!?
ahbying 3 months ago
@BrianHsin 你現在回這句不也是，正在是只出張嘴而已
thecatof 3 months ago
@BrianHsin 阿明因為愛台灣所以他現在搬回台灣住而且是南部人.....批評人之前請先打聽好，免得罵錯，還要跟人家道歉!
hsiaobugo 3 months ago
為臺灣打拼? 是打拼了什麼? 是為國民黨黨產打拼吧...
aden99999 3 months ago
原來這是 tai-go club,你說是嗎?? miss ahbying.....用不著跟你意見不一樣,就要人滾出台灣,憑啥呢?喝喝.....
stu50332 3 months ago
讚~
VMAUZ 4 months ago
阿明...因為那個人有國家認同錯亂問題,才會講的那麼複雜.
blesstf 4 months ago
美國綠卡讚！
馬英九：美國綠卡讚，進可選、敗可逃！
唯中、唯元：當美國公民、更讚！
asiatw2 4 months ago
In any case, as someone who is in such a politically delicate position, it is not possible to do away the safety which ambiguity grants with different equivalent terms of "being Taiwanese". Your video opens the long controversial topic of benshenren, and waishenren, or those who are native to Taiwan, and those who are literally, from another province. I can only say that you nasty comments to your viewership will not get you far if you intend to become a Youtube partner and make your 100k.
al1427 5 months ago
@al1427 plain and simple...people don't watch videos for the comments that are left.
ahbying 5 months ago
Someone needs to take a history lesson to find out the difference between ROC and PRC. To claim ROC heritage is to make territorial claims of China under the CKS regime. President MYJ is simply making a statement affirming the legacy of ROC. ROC is synonymous with the Taiwanese. Making the claim that one is Chinese, does not suggest that one is from China, as one could be referring to one's ethnicity as being Han Chinese, also the proper scientific term.
al1427 5 months ago
@al1427 ROC is not synonymous with Taiwan. ROC stands for the REPUBLIC OF CHINA....literally. My videos have nothing to do with benshenren and waishenren. waishenren is no longer an issue in taiwan. plenty of my friends come from waishenren parents but they 100% identify themselves as being taiwanese. yes, to truly understand the ROC and PRC you need to study history, REAL HISTORY, not fairy tale chinese history.
ahbying 5 months ago
不要再消費台灣了?!
不要再消費國旗來說你有多愛國?!
愛國是要尊重人民感受~
心態是真心要為人民好~
而不是為了選舉~打口水戰!!
四分之三的國會席次在你手上還….
完全執政~完全牽拖完全不負責?!
TheKomer2006 5 months ago
@mrdx21 Youtube is invented by Steve Chen, a TAIWANESE AMERICAN, NOT CHINESE.
TheDopenessism 5 months ago
@TheDopenessism Then Youtube has diplomatically chosen one of two sides (whether to acknowledge the term Taiwanese America or Chinese American) but YOUTUBE does not determine ANYTHING besides YOUTUBE related matters so this statement means nothing to the real world. Taiwan has never been a nation and still isn't today. It remains a province of ROC. So to be politically correct, we are all FROM Taiwan, but we are all Republic of China Chinese, just like someone can be FROM Kinmen but is ROChinese
galeon110 3 months ago
@mrdx21 why don't you comment on your use of PINYIN? don't have a lame comeback for that one do you? you chinks should stop using arabic numerals too.
ahbying 5 months ago
@mrdx21 "our language"!? who exactly do you think you are? what exactly have you invented?
ahbying 5 months ago
低贱的福尔摩挲豚当然不配称“中国人”，趁早滚出中国的台湾岛去你倭贼干爹家当奴隶吧。呵呵
mrdx21 5 months ago
@mrdx21 thanks for leaving such an amazing comment. great way to make chinese people look better, you fucking chump...haha. thanks for the laugh.
ahbying 5 months ago
@ahbying you obviously behave more like a 'chump' than me. Do not thank me by the way, send your gratefulness to those fucking pricks you mix with. If you want to laugh find a mirror and laugh into it
mrdx21 5 months ago
@mrdx21 hey chop suey...find a mirror? that's your fucking comeback? look around shithead, the world is full of mixed races. thank fucking god i'm not CHINESE like yourfuckingself. you're pure alright, purely a fucking joke. nice. thanks again for making chinese look dumb as shit.
ahbying 5 months ago
@ahbying Sure you are not Chinese. Who the fuck ever think you are?! You are a piece of filthy shit wearing fake smile in your dick head or whatever it is. BTW, stop speaking Fujianese which is a Chinese dialect stupid cunt like you shall be banned from using it.
mrdx21 5 months ago
@mrdx21 "Who the fuck ever think you are?! You are a piece of filthy shit wearing fake smile in your dick head or whatever it is"??? HAHAHAHAHAHA. stick to speaking chink because your english is shit. i'm speaking taiwanese motherfucker not fujianese. quit hating you fucking loser. once again, I KNOW I'M NOT CHINESE, THANK FUCKING GOD!!! you on the other hand are the smartest chinese person i've met in quite some time...not wonder you guys are fucked. hahaha.
ahbying 5 months ago
@ahbying we all know that piece of shit is not supposed to be Chinese. fuck off from our island. Thank you
mrdx21 5 months ago
@mrdx21 "our island"!? hahahaha...nice try yao ming. i had no idea you OWNED taiwan. you fucking moron. nice one.
ahbying 5 months ago
@mrdx21 "you shall be banned from using it"?? hahahahahaha. are you going to stop me from speaking taiwanese you coward ass little chink? hahahahahaha...i wasn't aware you had that authority. PLEASE leave more comments. the more you write, the dumber you look. nice....
ahbying 5 months ago
@ahbying just fuck off, get a life and stop speaking Fujianese. Thank you faggort
mrdx21 5 months ago
@mrdx21 "faggort"!? what the hell is a "faggort"!? you dumb eunuch.
ahbying 5 months ago
@ahbying yeah you faggot I am sorry I miss spell your name.
mrdx21 5 months ago
@mrdx21 hahahaha..."miss spell"? it's misspelled moron. seriously...do you really want to keep making yourself look like a fool?
ahbying 5 months ago
Go Ahbying, go go go ~~~~~~
cathyleetong02 6 months ago
感謝阿明，喜歡你的影片，一直覺得你很中肯。請繼續製作！！
furymike 6 months ago 2
lol why is my video in the suggestions?... it doesnt really relate except that i bought clothes from taiwan..xD
style2bonestv 7 months ago
@style2bonestv haha.
ahbying 7 months ago
我表示 我住台灣，我是台灣人
其他那些翻莉史和耍嘴皮的,電電好嗎?
現在台灣是一個國家，而我是台灣人
想當中國人的，中國就在隔壁，請你趕快回家
a7788995a 7 months ago 4
不知道這個人懂不懂地理啊
台灣是台灣本島，當然說是台灣人啊～
台灣又屬於中華民國的一部份-其他還有澎湖、金門、馬祖(在國際定位上台澎金馬是一起的)，不太懂這樣說哪裡有不對不妥之處！
反觀，民進黨只會說我是台灣人，或者應該叫改國號為台灣國，那你們把澎湖、金門、馬祖放在哪了？住在那邊的人就被邊緣化了喔～
某種程度上民進黨的黨粹程度絕對不比共產黨低～
kaiconan 7 months ago
@kaiconan 地理!/ geography? your worried about geography? 澎湖、金門、馬祖!? umm, those are part of 台灣 too. what exactly is your point? 民進黨只會說我是台灣人!? what about 中國國民黨!? they call themselves 台灣人 only for elections, but then also call themselves chinese or fucking ROCers. what the fuck is a ROCer? for someone living in Canada, you should know that no one has a fucking clue where the ROC is... it's called 台灣. 地理!? shit...read some fucking HISTORY.
ahbying 7 months ago
@kaiconan thank you for showing us the amazingness that is 中國國民黨 supporters. this definitely ranks as one of the dumbest comments i've seen anyone make. what fucking nonsense are you rambling about? hahahahaha...
ahbying 7 months ago
@ahbying 從你的回應就可以看的出來你是一個怎樣水準的人了。滿口髒話、隨便貼標籤，反駁你的意見並不太表示誰的擁護者，真的很糟糕。
如果澎湖、金門與馬祖都是台灣的，請你看看"台澎金馬個別關稅領域"就能知道到底是誰屬於誰。
只是狹隘的用自己的偏見觀點看台灣，不斷的夾雜一些英文又加上一些髒話，台灣就是因為有你這樣的人才會造成族群對立。
順帶一提：為什麼現在很多人想說自己是來自於中國(中華民國的簡稱)，因為更多不理性的人馬上就會貼標籤"賣台"。真不知道那些人是不是因為自卑，所以怕大陸人來。
真不知道你到底是拿裡人，說出這樣的妙論。大概也是中共派來要破壞台灣的和諧吧～
kaiconan 7 months ago
@kaiconan 我沒有水準啦! look what i say before and after fuck, that should be your focus. who cares what language i'm speaking? if you choose to use taiwanese or english, that's for me to decide. 因為有你這樣的人!? i was going to say the same fucking thing about you. 真不知道你到底是拿裡人!? i'm a taiwanese-american, what about that can't you understand? who in canada knows what the ROC is!? taiwan is taiwan.
ahbying 7 months ago
@kaiconan 你為什麼有那麼多水準!? 你超厲害!! 哈哈. talk some more about 地理. that was totally working....
ahbying 7 months ago
@ahbying 當你沒有注意別人在說什麼的時候，也別期望別人注意你在 F字前說了什麼，更何況還是一些狹隘偏激的想法。如果你懂歷史，真正的台灣人應該是那些原住民，而不是先後來到台灣的"外省人"。然後霸佔著土地說"我是台灣人" 或者 " I am Taiwanese"。
應該用更寬廣的心，只要是住在台灣這片土地上的人都是台灣人；心中狹隘才會鑽牛角尖。
來自 Canada 又怎麼了？只有美國人說的話才能聽？這就是為什麼美國人被很多人討厭，自以為的正義才是真正的正義。如果是這樣美國又為何會被恐怖分子報復，其他地方卻不會呢？
台灣就是台灣，我也沒否認，因為它隸屬於中華民國底下的一個省份。
kaiconan 7 months ago
@kaiconan i understand that aboriginals were the first taiwanese. no one here is saying they're not. however, the definition of being taiwanese today is much more inclusive. by your lame logic, then where did chinese people come from before china? what gives chinese the right to call themselves chinese? shouldn't they call themselves africans? you should get off your fucking high horse cuz the more you write, the less convincing you sound.
ahbying 7 months ago
@ahbying 看的出來你使中抓著"現今的台灣人"的定義，請問是誰定義？看來你還沒有搞清楚 Chinese People 的 Chinese 是指什麼！Chinese 當然是指 People of China ，那麼 China 當然也是指 ROC 的C ，大部分自卑的人都會怕跟對岸混淆改成 Taiwanese ，這樣就真的把其他地方的人邊緣化。真的很遺憾看到你用一大廢話只是為了想寫 FuXk 而已，你這麼想寫、這麼想念，就乾脆上傳一篇都是 Fuxk 的影片好了～
(強烈建議滿口髒話類似野蠻人的 ahbying 這樣做)
kaiconan 7 months ago
@kaiconan 澎湖金門馬祖歸為台灣叫做邊緣化，那台灣被歸為中華民國其實也叫邊緣化
jamesccccc01 7 months ago
@jamesccccc01 台灣被中華民國怎麼會是邊緣化? 中華民國是台澎金馬的總稱。
kaiconan 7 months ago
@kaiconan 這就是問題所在，既然中華民國是台澎金馬的總稱，又稱台灣是中華民國的一個省份，也就是中華民國只有兩個省，台澎叫台灣省，金馬叫福建省，這存在極大的矛盾，因為福建省在中華民國其實也是個虛級的機構，台灣這名字實際多了，中華民國這名詞已完全不符現狀，不過你提到金馬這點也是個問題，假設台灣真走向獨立，這兩個地方是否要纳入台灣版圖，還是得問問他們．
jamesccccc01 7 months ago
@kaiconan 井底之蛙類？
postal7896 7 months ago
@postal7896 我只井底之蛙，那麼你應該是井底囉？至少我還站在你的頭上！
kaiconan 7 months ago
支那豬 不是人 會被當人看
謝謝指教~~
ltuppp 7 months ago
笑死人......炎黃是何方神聖......怎可亂認神話人物為祖宗呢？
就算有炎黃這兩人，幾千年前的社會也沒有中華民族這概念吧？“中華民族” 根本就是現代政治產物，和炎黃沒關係。
dumdidolabumbuladido 7 months ago
When you hear Ma Ying-jeou say he is Taiwanese or he loves Taiwan, you would know that an election is coming up because he wouldn't even mention "Taiwan" in any other situations.
如果馬英九開始說自己是台灣人, 或是說自己愛台灣, 你就知道總統大選快要到了.
他在選舉前就整天消費"台灣"這兩字 選後就"馬上"改稱中華台北 之類的矮化名.
Seriously, Ma Ying-jeou loves nothing but one China and communism.
拜託台灣人醒醒吧! 想想這幾年來馬英九跟國民黨是怎麼矮化台灣的! 忘了的話可以來我的channel看一些我收藏的新聞
Conclusion: We will never vote for him, NEVER!!
thetrueinfamous 7 months ago 17
可不可以請馬總統把臉書的回應翻成英文?不要只會玩文字遊戲, how the heck do you translate 中華民族炎黃子孫? (Chinese??) and 中華民國國民? (Republic of China citizen?). The only way to avoid confusion is to say we are fromＴＡＩＷＡＮ
spyke2k 7 months ago
YEAH MICHIGAN!! 阿明學長, GO BLUE!!!
spyke2k 7 months ago 3
@spyke2k hail to the...haha
ahbying 7 months ago
@ahbying Wolverines!
shiningc323 7 months ago
1895/04/之後的台灣人早就跟中國無關了，1945/04/01之後本土台灣人擁有日本國籍，戰敗後卻莫名其妙被變成中國籍這才是問題的根源，the people on taiwan ,只要住在台灣的土地上都可稱為台灣人，誰不可以講台灣人?錯在國籍有問題，本土台灣人目前沒有國籍，而住在台灣土地上的中國籍台灣人士都是從1945/08/15之後才來台灣的.
zero3399ya 7 months ago
精神分裂了吧 連自己是甚麼人都搞不清楚
BernyHsu 7 months ago
馬英九要開始騙票囉
馬英九是台灣人?他已經違背他的政治理念了
abinent 7 months ago
@abinent 騙選票的花言巧語啦 台灣人不能再上一次當了
swdwch 7 months ago
馬英囧出國就變美國人，(( 看三小，我的綠卡沒有失效啦！
kko0219 7 months ago
阿明有臉書嘛：）
yihong0613 7 months ago
@yihong0613 look up "阿明" or "Ahbying" on 臉書. i have a fan page.
ahbying 7 months ago 4
Taiwan need to REMOVE the ROC FAKE goverment. period! that is s the ONLY solution to make Taiwan a real nation not some stupid "Providence" of ROC or PROC they so called.
bryanchou 7 months ago 8
我被馬搞得有點混,我們到底是中華民國國民還是台灣人??
wamfpya 7 months ago
I need to see his ashes to believe that he's Taiwanese which is what he said 3 yrs ago....
taidumei 7 months ago 3