Added: 4 years ago
From: onix90
Views: 1,951,335
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,439)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • amazingly beautiful voice!

  • I was fortunate enough to see this in 05'.........What a fantastic preformer and show. Wish I could go to the new one???? (Vegas show) Never know ???

  • Tina turner sang with more soul than celine but I still like her version.

  • Comment removed

  • CD very better the voice than TT

  • Better voice control but not the raw energy Tina Turner infuses into the tune. TT does better job.

  • Kuwait's right! Beautiful :)*جميل

  • i must disagree. celine dion does not improve this song. this was written and produced by phil spector for tina turner and tina really delivers . celine has taken the rock and roll and soul out of this song and made it just bland.

  • @mr5341 you should listen to her when she sang at this song at the VH1 Divas 1998. she ws amazing.

  • Ok a saw a video of Tina Turner singing this and i can clearly see that Celine does it a least a billion times better !

  • She can sing every song and every cover and she probably does the cover better then the artist himself :D

  • Omg the dancers crack me up! 

  • Mr Blobby had a christmas number 1 and sold a lot of records . Does that mean he can sing ?

  • Those two babes walking next to Celine from 0:14 to 0:30, have the SEXIEST walk moves EVER.

  • She looks like a model <3

    Amazing singer, beautiful face and body and amazing personality :D

  • Are you people serious with your comments. This woman can't Sing.Lyrics are when I was, not when I wash a little girl.You OBVIOUSLY don't know the difference between someone who can sing and someone who can't .

  • @colinodonnell1 sorry that her native language isn't english and pronouncing words differently comes with that

  • @MMegaminx I'm sorry but it does not alter the fact that this woman cannot sing.Listen to the original version and compare them.

  • @colinodonnell1 she can't sing? what about those like 300 million albums she sold? maybe you're the one who can't hear

  • Comment removed

  • do u guys agree that she sounds alot alike Elvis

  • Way, way, way too many video cuts...can't actually get a feel for the floor show, which was probably awesome, but enjoyable video anyway.

  • Way too much echo on Celine's mike. Great version regardless.

  • Wow...Wife and I are Huge Cher fans, saw the Vegas show 14 times. I have never been a huge Celine Fan....Wife IS! She showed me the Set List for Her...And I liked 3 of the covers whe did. Show I checked them out. Result????CANT WAIT TO SEE HER LIVE!!!!

    This song is a Classic tune folks...

    She NAILS IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Cant wait to see her do it live...And the Stage production is UNREAL!

  • She has a great sound to her voice <3

    I personally adore her singing?And covers are meant to be exactly that - covers!Different from the original,bringing a new refreshing feel to the original track

  • I like the original Tina Turner version MUCH better, especially the original promo vid version with Spectors Wall of Sound. Celine is a technician, no argument there, but she doesn't bring any of the original raw vocal emotion and strain... A very "pretty" version. I was more impressed with how she managed to interface with that wind machine to get her hair to blow just right in the auditorium...

  • great version shame shes not a lady boy or i would fuck her arse twice

  • 140 people didnt like it... they loved it!

  • excellente cette vidéo, Celine super sexy, trop bien, Merci Amicalement Aline

  • Celine is as sexy as a chemical castration.One ugly Ruth Buzzy impersonator.

  • @pipesrussell *Buzzi

    PS: You're a faggot.

  • she has a GREAT!!!! voice... no doubt... but some songs need a little more energy!!!.. she's too glamourous for this kind of song..

  • she has a GREAT!!!! voice... no doubt... but some songs need a little more energy!!!.. she's too glamourous for this kind of song..

  • SARA GOMES- Tina Turner - River Deep mountain high

    See this video.

  • BEST!!!!!

  • Very Good For Celine, Why not check out ceribrock90 and listen to her version, one of the best!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Glee version is way better

  • Diffrent! But not bad. People u must check HERO OF A FOOL frm JENNIFER RUSH here on youtube. Its gving chickenskin.

  • wow its a lot of dancers!!!

  • Any performer who sings a song made popular by another faces a challenge. Each of the other performers mentioned here fell seriously short of their mark one or more times in their career. Celine's version is not bad, simply different than other versions.

  • I like it. But it's sounds like "litter Girl"

  • Celine does this effortlessly... clearly she has total control of her voice and covers it without wrecking it - shit - she does most covers better than the original... THIS ONE IS BETTER BY FAR BY CELINE...

  • This is not the same as Tina Turner :( She is the best ...

  • I love Celine but black music is black. There are some like Eric Burdon with the good touch of black voice. So I say to some of musicans, dont touch if your'e not "SOUL MUSIC" aibled.

  • Comment removed

  • celine is more of a.... slow song person.... shes..not really river deep mountian high...=/...sry to fans..

  • Can't stand this butchery of Tina Turner;s song; she would have been 300% better without all the crap and to have simply done the song under a isolated spot light without all the props...she/her voice doesn't need it.

  • She hits those notes so effortlessly. I love both Tina's and this version

  • Celine sang this great

  • wow celine dion nailed this song... simply the best...

  • It doesn't have allways to be crackling and rough to be strong good and Rocky!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • @chocholeitze no she is not! there are better voices than hers. she ruined heart's song alone. plus she lipsynchs all the time! She is crapola!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • this is one of the greatest of many beutifull Celine interpretations, exuberant with emotions.So powerfull and full with Rock.

  • This sucks...

  • Good one Celine, but you need to do it nice and ROUGH.

    This needs crackling passion.

  • Lol loved the choreography

  • Celiine River Deep Mountain High???????/ Like Michael Bolton (remember him?) doing Jamed Brown!

  • Oh gosh, I love this so much. She sounds great!! :]

  • AWESOME!!!!

  • I LOVE this version. It's good to see that some artists still can make their own version of such a great song. Phil Spector sound, I like it.

    Meat Loaf's (and Karla Devito's off course) version from 1978 is rocking:

  • @Rostely watch?v=9mVs2-s9Vtk

  • She could have 3000 dancers on stage and this version still won't be even be close to as good as Tina Turner. Not really her fault she doesn't feel the passion required for this song. 

  • whoa... autotune much?

  • Celine you're looking HOT!!!!! The songs not too shabby either.

  • She sounds tired... It' really time for a HUGE come back, new sound, same quality! It's been to long now!!

  • i love it when ppl say that she wil never be better then tina.. and wondering why shes even singing this song cause she cant do better... well who the fuck cares that she doesnt sing the song better then tina... she still has an amazing voice and im sure shes not trying to be better. so many people have sung this song and celine does that million times better then all the other ppl thats try. so stop whining and if you dont like dont fucking listen to it.

  • I love her version and the dancing behind her. She isn't Tina nor does she think she is. They are both great but different than each other. We can all enjoy whichever we like best. Why must it be necessary to slam the one you don't like. Just don't watch them.

  • She is amazing. The dancers are amazing. The band is amazing...

  • She is my favorite singer; GREAT MOvie

  • thee  bestt

  • Where the F.... is she sexy?Don´t kid.

  • Is she kidding with this? Who suggested to her that this was a good cover song for her 'voice'? Disgusting, lame, soulless pablum. Only Tina Turner can do this. Allison Durbin's cover at least doesn't make me want to slit my wrists instantly. Or hers.

  • u r trying soooo hard celine,,,,but got to accept that tina is THE BEST!!!

    just cant compare<.

  • @michikotanaka81 Wrong, Jean Terrell of the Supremes and the Four Tops did it best! I love Celine though!

  • Fat middle aged american women have no class , Tina turner blows this cheesy caberet singer of the planet , just listen to the Phil Spector version its gutsy and real , get serious if you really love music ..

  • luv sexy.....wowwww....*..*

  • When I thought I could see nothing more ridiculous the the comparison between Lara Fabian and Céline Dion, you guys come with Pia Toscano. Why can't people just enjoy these three AMAZING performers with AMAZING voices?

  • celine you are amazing!!love tina and celine..no comparison they are both great!!

  • I actually like Celine's version of this better than Tina Turner's. But then again I am biased.

  • I just love. I love Celine Dion.

  • Comment removed

  • The difference between Tina and Celine is..... Tina has soul, power and she sings like a hurricane... Celine has and is nothing

  • this definitely takes a back seat to Tina Turners version. Celine sings it well. Tina put her heart and soul in it. big difference. sorry Celine..

  • @JAYLEE169 exactly. Tina Turner's version moves me. Celine always sings well all the time...but I always feel something lacking...and I heard Tina's version and I was like ' yes, that's it'.

  • @MsFockit i agree. Celine has a nice voice but Tina got you going in a hurry. nice comment and thanks for your reply.. have a good one..

  • Fantastic.... Queennn..¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­¡¡¡¡¡¡¡

  • She just doesn't put the soul in it that tina did

  • Effortless

  • I feel as though she is not fully singing the song

  • What an amazing performance. I can't wait to see her in Vegas!

  • Amazing! <3

  • y si aceptamos la diversidad? fue un homenaje ella bien lo dice en el inicio, disfrutemos de estas voces maravillosas sin comparar

  • shes like canadian or german or something, shes definantly not from here. shes still amazing though

  • She sang the hell out of this song. Fantastic.

  • Cut the crap. This is pure entertainment. All you pseudo music critics need to move on. Even Tina doesn't sound like Tina anymore.

  • I love Celine Dion! She is my idol!!

  • She makes it look so flawless to sing.

  • Omg . This was horrible. Don't get me wrong Celine is a great singer but she cant do Tina Turner's song,

    How dare Celine do that song and to mess it up.

    Celine does not have a soulful voice that is required to sing this song.

    I can see some like Fantasia remaking this song instead of Celine Dion.

    Overall Celine this was not the song for you to remake over.

    It is disrespectful to Tina turner in my opinion and to all the soulful singers out there who could have done this song better

  • @trw11131 when Celine does remakes its as an homage to the original artist. She isn't trying to be better per se, she just wants to go out there and sing her favorite songs. I'm sure you sing your favorite song by your idols. This is exactly what she's doing. I think she would agree with basically the whole world, that no one can touch Tina. Just let her have her fun.

  • @ArmondodevonStrizer At the end of the day this song was just not for Celine. Even when times goes one if someone tries to sing a Celine Dion song they have to sing the song as good or even better than Celine did. Rule of thumb if you are going to do a legend's song over please make sure you come correct when you do it. And with all due respect Celine is a great singer but again she did not do a good job when remaiking Tina Turners song.

  • @trw11131 Im sure Celine would agree that this is not her style or her song. She just wanted to do something for an artist that she likes. If Celine was at home singing this song it, then you would have no problem. Sometimes people do sing songs that aren't for them especially a Tina song. I mean come on, no one can come to her songs and try to do "Tina."

  • @trw11131 I think you might be mistaking a gravily voice or a growly voice for having a soulful voice. Celine has soul no doubt her tone is just clear when she goes up for high notes it's clear and easy not a strained as Fantasia or Tina Turner, this doesn't mean she doesn't have soul.

  • This song works with deep voice,not soft voice. Thats why it doesnt work...i have to go now its makin me queezy...ps love celine but no.

  • lmfao, just sucked the soul right out. Only Celine could do that.

  • She shouldn't be singing that song.

  • มันส์มากกกกกกกกกก

  • i personally don't think it's that great. glee does it 100 times better

  • Celine <3 Amoo!!!!!!

  • @CDionLive Yes, I saw it, and you're right, it is so much better than this version, the power was there. Celine was a lot younger too. Thanks so much for leading me to the 1994 performance, it is miles above this one.

  • @CDionLive Thank You. I will check that video out. I have nothing against Celine, she's a beautiful woman and has a beautiful voice as well, and I'm sure I would enjoy seeing her live. I'm sure you're right as to the different arrangement causing the power drain. Thanks again.

  • Amooooooo

  • Awesome voice, no soul.

  • soooooooo hot

  • i love that blond chick on her right side in the beginning

    Celiene cant pull this song off, disappointing

  • I think she did a great job! Sure she needs more raw emotion but, for her, this is pretty good.

  • I like this version, I like her French accent.

  • Linda Celine <3

  • Celine has a very powerful voice listen to its all coming back to me now. However this song was just not for her. She sang it too softly not enough emotions.

  • hÊh_ÁNý_gÙÿs_wÁñt_tÖ_chÄt_wÌth­_mÉ

  • Eu estava neste show no caesars palace las vegas e a performace de Celine Dion não e mais a mesma desde 1998 quando fez divas live ela cantou no show river deep,mountain e foi melhor, hoje sua voz está roca mais grossa as notas agudas não são mais perfeitas.diz o crítico se shows Welington Bruno.

  • While I agree that Celine has a great voice, this song isn't for her. There's no emotion or power in her version. She's just singing the song. Every version I've seen of Tina Turner doing this song is spectacular, be it from 1971 or 2009, there's just no comparison, Tina is just miles above her contemporaries, and that's all there is to it. Tina was singing this number when Celine was in diapers...lol...

  • @edcoll61

    Right you are, Ed. Celine is just following some choreography she hasn't even understood, even though she might mimic the steps and sounds. Young Tina Turner doing this same number is a bombshell by comparison. Dion shouldn't even expose her limits by doing this Tina's own number.

  • @edcoll61 I agree. I've seen Melissa Etheridge sing it and she ROCKED it!!

  • Chuck Norris please do little favor to americans ears, kill Justin Bieber and Lady Guga.

  • SEXY??????? are you on crack

  • @shaniaisgod Great music, bad video. The dancers sucks.

  • This song doesn't need back-up dancers. Just Celine, a full orchestra to back her up and a rapt audience.

  • wow not tina.... but is it CELINE? yes!

  • Not the same power as Tina.

  • i love celine version way better

  • Celine is such a thief ;l /watch?v=7DrgIgnvamo compared to tina's exact same entrance / song /watch?v=rjpve1LoqiE&feature=r­elated ;l thiefffff......

  • Tina is the Queen!!!

  • Beautiful, I like ti :)

  • LOVE DION BUT SHE KILLED IT I'M SORRY GLEE AND TINA IS WAY BETTER

  • acho esta musica sensacional

    com certeza 

  • I agree, she seems to have an off day here, it's not the usual voice... Othr clips of the same song where here voice is as brilliant as usual are simply world class performance. Miss her, she's not very present at the moment...

  • haha i'm weird. i love her little one eyebrow at 2:48

  • who is pia toscano , an italian pizzaiolo ?

  • BULLSIT

  • SPETTACOLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • PIA TOSCANO DID SING IT BETTER THAN CELINE DION.CELINE DION SOUNDS LIKE SHE HAS SOMETHING IN HER MOUTH... HAHAHA... GO PIA!!!! WE MISS YOU.

  • @graceeb1  YEAHH!!

  • She sounds like she has a mouthful of crap.

  • @amesguy515 LOL

  • Big stage, lots of dancers, heaps of distractions. Great try Celine but Tina doesn't need the dancers and the big production to be the best at this.

  • WOW THIS IS A GAY SHOW Lol

  • Pia is in the process of becoming like Celine and Tina. Stop comparing, she looks up to these divas and you can trust that she will be as successful as Celine.

  • I don't dislike Pia Toscano, in fact I don't care either way. But think about what some of you Pia fans are saying. Celine Dion has sold 175,000,000 albums. You guys are saying Pia Toscano, who came NINTH in American Idol, is going to be better than Dion, (the highest selling female artist of all time), despite the fact that last season's WINNER has not even sold 150,000 albums? Wake the fuck up.

  • Comment removed

  • @Doctors2Advocate LOL....yes yes well said! she is good but not GREAT as CELINE. too overrated and self-assured Pia Toscano, that's why she was booted out.

  • @Doctors2Advocate I agree with you 1000000%! Celine is a LEGEND! Pia's just a talented singer...

  • @Doctors2Advocate celine sounds like she has a lollipop in her mouth. she doesnt have much of a voice

  • @CafiaMamacho how dare you

  • @CafiaMamacho yes somthing proplem whit sound ?

  • @Doctors2Advocate I actually had no idea who Pia Toscano was until your comment. Thanks :)

  • Who say Pia Toscano is amazing, maybe she is good but not great..sorry that's my opinion. Celine is the BEST of them all.

  • Tina's got this one... hands down!

  • totally hot

  • Who the hell is Pia? Don't know her, I guess she's an unknown. As far as I'm concern Tina and Celine are both equally talented and both have done well.

  • @habakkuktang Pia Toscano is an aboslutely amazing singer from this season (season 10) of american idol! Look her up!

  • I love Celine, but I have to say this is one of her weaker perfomances... Pia just blew this song away! Greastest performance on AI to get booted off prior to the final 7....

  • pia is nothing compare to celine.. shes the best singer in this song,, u ppol cant even sing like her nor pia nor tina turner..!

  • No one sings this song like Tina Turner.

  • No comparison; Celine is the best at this song.  The whole reason Pia got kicked off is because she attempted something so far beyond her abilities. People compared her to the pros and it sounded awful. Thats why she is no longer around........

  • @danna3945 I totally agree with you. She (Pia) is an overrated and too over confident that's why she deserved to be booted out.

  • We can begin make comparisons to Pia's version and this one. But you can bet Pia will be on a stage like this very soon.

  • Comment removed

  • Tina sang this far better, and Tina's far sexier. Having said that, Pia Toscano sang this better on American Idol than Celine did here (and I wasn't a Pia Toscano fan)

  • Damn, so many stupid dancers.....

  • way better than Pia last night!