this song reminds me of my wife i love you baby you always had to fight fo everything well now you have me by your side and ill sacrifice anything and everything to see your smile and those beautiful brown eyes light up 4 years and counting
i loved her before she was becoming yah know ........ sluty. no offence to her but y cant u just be not a slut and be a role model for little kids. what do u think thye see u shanking ur butt?
i don't understand how people call her singing shit. not just this particular video, but in general. hate her for whatever reason, you can't call her a bad singer.
@xmarsbars yes you can, she really is not a good singer... she is less than ok and she takes advantage of the fact that no one has high enough music standards
each time i see her live she is awesome with strong pretty voice::: !!! You can say the opposite ! this video just say that i'm right :) Love miley ! she's talented and mature! :D
Some times people say she become star because her Daddy star((((((but that FALSE)))))))))shut up))))She STAR because its Hot Strong Miley)i love you)))
I absolutely love this song and the message that it sends, but Miley Cyrus should not be singing it. She may be a talented actress, but a singer, she is not. Her voice is just not good if you really listen to it and stop getting swept up into your adoration for her. She should just give up on trying to sing and focus on her acting career.
miley can do watevea she want and all the haterz just help her cause the more u hate the more famouse she becomes and the more you start rumors or say shes a hore or watevea the more it makes you look bad so go ahead contune to hate but itz only hurting ur self.. IM A MILEY SUPPORT MILEY 4LIFE
Gotta give it to her, at least she CAN sing. Unlike people like Selena Gomez, Hillary Duff and a bunch of other pop star/startlets. And I'm not a Miley Cyrus fan!!
wow this song is soo inspirstional! theres a poem i learned in scool and its just like this song..its called another mountain..its basiclly stating that the mountain is the struggle that u face while trying to get to your goal :) i wonder if that poem inspired her to write this song! :D
I Dont Why People Call Her Whore And Stuff. I Dont See Anything Wrong With Her Of Course Now Because She Wears Short Shorts In Her Video WOW! I Love Miley And I Dont Kare Wat People Say :)
she has such a beautiful, natural voice. i don't understand how some people can think differently. everyone is entitled to an opinion, and it may just be mine, but this girl can sing!
woow, i seriously despise people who hate on miley 4 no reason!! 1 of the comments that ivv read that i cant stnad is that her teeth r messed up, who cares!! she sings amazingly, nad she is beautiful so y does that matter?
@awesomepurplesox are you serious? Either you are a hater or you are deaf either way you are an idiot anyone who says that this performance sucks or that she sings poorly don't know what they are talking about.
I don't care what anyone else says. Miley knocks this song out of the park. She owns it, top to bottom. Many popular singers can't do nearly this well with pitch, timing etc.
She's a pretty good singer, folks. Anyone who can do better, feel free to go for it!
Why the hell do people say she isn't an insperation, because of the clothes she wears? Whats the point...loads of people wear shorts......but they mean inspirations, because she always followed her dreams, and it shows how far you can go.
great inspiration to teens........... she's wearing shorts that should be burned... smoking salvia(she has little kids that look up to her). at least she's not using auto tuno. =)
@randomxmonkeys This isn't to be mean. But the reason the most fans love her is because they love her voice. and we now its sounds rough and cracky but i like it. And she can sing great. But not as great as demi lovato or beyoncé but i don't care
@randomxmonkeys ffs... maybe you should stop listening to her music then if u only are gonna post stupid comments... her voice is good live and on cd you just have to find what kinda music you like morron-.- has nothing with her to do that u dont like it its you self... so stop comment her videos...
Seriously i dont deny that she sounds good in those slow songs like the climb or when i look at you. But no offense, she can't sing those hip hop songs such as party in the usa or cant be tamed in live.
This is just amazin tbh, her voice is so powerful :)! i love miley and it really gets me mad when people hate on her, because she has an awesome voice and i would sell everything i have just to see her lol :)
This is my favorite performance by her. She so talented, her voice is really strong, and it it seriously the best out of all her live performances. This video proves that she can sing. And FUCK ALL YOU HATERS.
And you can't call someone. Slut without getting to know them, because you can't be judged on something like that just because of what you wear etc it's if you sleep around and use guys and shit like that. Xo
It's a costume, every pop star wears a costume on stage to perform. So she's not dressing like a slut. If you would focus on the performance and the music, you wouldn't be bothered by what she wears. And what a person wears doesn't make them a slut, it's who the person is that makes them a slut. If they sleep around they are a slut, Miley isn't. At the end of the day she's still Miley, the sweet person who does alot for charities like this.
@CinCinBreezy I totally agree with you. She has her own style and to be honest I love it and in no way makes her look like a slut. Whoever said that needs to actually find the right definition. And a slut would do charities because they are so up themselves. Sorry this just had to be said. Like your comment. :)
@jetsat100 if you dont think shes a good singer fine thats your opinion, but don't go on her videos if you don't like her singing, because its not like you can do any better
@jetsat100 yeah i agree! all those disney stars suck! well, they don't have a special voice or something.... They're all the same! they act... they sing a little and then: BOOM everybody loves them even if they're not that good! not hating or anything! cause i love miley's songs but all those disney stars are the same (: (sorrt my english is not so good)
This is all a facade.She doesnt really care.I guess maybe she just wants publicity or a more wholesome image or something,because I have a friend who babysits this 4 year old who got backstage passes to one of her concerts, and,while backstage she saw that she took pictures with the kids,but she didn't even acknowledge them. She basically just ignored them and didn't even act like she cared.And that was their last dying wish. Miley Cyrus is probably the biggest bitch known to man kind.
Everything about miley,is beautiful.She has a wonderful voice.l love her just the way she is.You can't improve on perfection.Well done miles,ur amazing.Peace & godbless:)XX
you guys can't stand here....sorry your gonna have to clear out you guys can't stand here LOL
but Miley is a good singer. i didn't know if she was so i watched this and i was pleasantly surprised! she's really good
SilentHillEmzie 4 months ago
she should make a duet with adele, there voices would sound good together :)
elih48 5 months ago in playlist More videos from thefashionpatrol
the best version of that song
kobioor 5 months ago
miley can sing very good live without the back up singers, all by herself. but selena cant sing without back up singers and auto tune
ranifadhila 6 months ago 17
@ranifadhila
YEA!!!!:D
supermileyfan1712 5 months ago
This Is By Far The Best Live Version I have Heard Of This By Miley, Vocally BEAUTIFUL! Loud, And Clear With A Sexy Husky Sound Yeah I'm Loving It
ninjabluewings 6 months ago 4
I LOVE YOU!!!MILEY!!!
nicky16smile 6 months ago 7
miley is soooo awesomee!
bubbleyumcrazzy 7 months ago 6
Miley
Simply the Best!!!
Engager77 7 months ago 8
i love her voice
nerdzara 7 months ago 11
YOU CAN'T SIT WITH US!
cleanpalette 7 months ago 3
Beautiful singing...............<3
bismamughal 8 months ago 8
mmmm... I don't really like her but that's because the things she does .. but she actually can sing. Great job this one!
Siemoontjuh 8 months ago 3
amazing !
JenniferAlbertsson 8 months ago
this song reminds me of my wife i love you baby you always had to fight fo everything well now you have me by your side and ill sacrifice anything and everything to see your smile and those beautiful brown eyes light up 4 years and counting
tomde3 8 months ago
i loved her before she was becoming yah know ........ sluty. no offence to her but y cant u just be not a slut and be a role model for little kids. what do u think thye see u shanking ur butt?
justina104912 9 months ago
im excited im going 2 her concert! (gypsy heart tour)
nacyfreeze 9 months ago
cool ending
prinsessasvakt 9 months ago
i loveuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
newmoonfanna13 9 months ago
Miley is one of the few singers whose voice are really easy to recognize...ie: Rihanna, Katy Perry, etc
tangoctuanh27 9 months ago 9
Liikee
MeLiemaus1 9 months ago
omfg? Y there is 8o dislikes .. miley <3
cam3810 9 months ago
miley grow up so fast, so be carefull miley take ur life in this world. and welcome to the real world.. :-P
bethicute 10 months ago 4
I like she has a special voice, very different. I like it!
Naneoc 10 months ago 8
i love you and song so coooooooooooooollllllll
T1erlo1000 10 months ago 3
hahahhahhhhhhhhhhh
qtiex 10 months ago
Perfect performance
f0cusen 10 months ago 2
ers la mejor miley...!!! =)
roxnellyn 10 months ago
sHE SINGS GOOD BUT I LIKE SELENA GOMEZ MORE!
1. SELENA GOMEZ
2. TAYLOR SWIFT
3. VICTORIA JUSTICE
4. ALANA LEE
MILEY IS MY LAST FAVE SINGER
Silena0310 11 months ago
i don't understand how people call her singing shit. not just this particular video, but in general. hate her for whatever reason, you can't call her a bad singer.
xmarsbars 11 months ago 10
@xmarsbars yes you can, she really is not a good singer... she is less than ok and she takes advantage of the fact that no one has high enough music standards
quakeroats0316 10 months ago
Her hair is beautiful! (Random comment)
Other than that, beautiful song, I love how she sings live.
nessaholichu 11 months ago 9
genius...it was superb. how can you people say she isn't talented and all that stuff...are you deaf???
13sept90 11 months ago 9
yay! she is an amazing singer. not like so many radio artists who cant sing a lick in key without autotune *cough* katy perry *cough
cbpenguin 11 months ago 9
she sings exellently live
HayesLauran 11 months ago 13
i vomited
Yurnero4RS 11 months ago
@Yurnero4RS thats too bad for you isnt it:(
cookieCRUNCHER2 11 months ago 8
shes just an example of perfect
IsraelValdezJrr 11 months ago 9
bad recording, but WAY better live
thefallenangel001 1 year ago 8
Better than studio version ; ]
TheMartusiaP 1 year ago 45
This is the Miley we love!
charicesunshine 1 year ago 9
she even sounds better when she does live
supernatural641 1 year ago 7
this is very good! omgsh
EmmaJoJa 1 year ago 5
so good......She is the best....
RachelsmileKim 1 year ago 6
each time i see her live she is awesome with strong pretty voice::: !!! You can say the opposite ! this video just say that i'm right :) Love miley ! she's talented and mature! :D
kinouchan08 1 year ago
i loveee miley you??/
dancemarituna 1 year ago
She actually is a really good live singer :D
spaghettisauce123321 1 year ago 4
why do people say she sucks live?
she's amazing !! <3
xxsmilerzxx 1 year ago 2
Comment removed
DeanneLucify 1 year ago
I love you miley
vanessa46683 1 year ago
I'm glad she sung it in it's original Key of E here as opposed to that acoustic tour version.
HarryDickus 1 year ago
Still prefer Hilary Duff
RedCitizen1 1 year ago
@RedCitizen1 why come here if you have nothing good to say?
supportonmiley 1 year ago
love her <3
97thea79 1 year ago
i love her voice, hair, teeth, face,
everything xxx
TheBroReal 1 year ago
so eine tolle stimmte!! ***_***
Marlencheeen 1 year ago
Brilliant!
shaydeelady 1 year ago
Some times people say she become star because her Daddy star((((((but that FALSE)))))))))shut up))))She STAR because its Hot Strong Miley)i love you)))
TheCuteFreek 1 year ago
I absolutely love this song and the message that it sends, but Miley Cyrus should not be singing it. She may be a talented actress, but a singer, she is not. Her voice is just not good if you really listen to it and stop getting swept up into your adoration for her. She should just give up on trying to sing and focus on her acting career.
NeverShoutingNever1 1 year ago
she is amazing I love this song is so beautiful!
loliyconan 1 year ago
miley can do watevea she want and all the haterz just help her cause the more u hate the more famouse she becomes and the more you start rumors or say shes a hore or watevea the more it makes you look bad so go ahead contune to hate but itz only hurting ur self.. IM A MILEY SUPPORT MILEY 4LIFE
prettydx3 1 year ago
How can people say she can't sing? HOW?
SamsChannel7 1 year ago 4
Gotta give it to her, at least she CAN sing. Unlike people like Selena Gomez, Hillary Duff and a bunch of other pop star/startlets. And I'm not a Miley Cyrus fan!!
liamsmommy81 1 year ago
She can't really sing. The only reason she is famous is bcuz of her dad. she can't really act either
hanah32465 1 year ago
it's not because i'm obsessed with her,but she's good.her voice is great and she can sing.
Poison4Fuckers 1 year ago
wow this song is soo inspirstional! theres a poem i learned in scool and its just like this song..its called another mountain..its basiclly stating that the mountain is the struggle that u face while trying to get to your goal :) i wonder if that poem inspired her to write this song! :D
ThreeRandomDays 1 year ago
I Dont Why People Call Her Whore And Stuff. I Dont See Anything Wrong With Her Of Course Now Because She Wears Short Shorts In Her Video WOW! I Love Miley And I Dont Kare Wat People Say :)
LiveeLifeeHappii 1 year ago
she has such a beautiful, natural voice. i don't understand how some people can think differently. everyone is entitled to an opinion, and it may just be mine, but this girl can sing!
balletgurl4 1 year ago 5
Wow great show
flipdoggz711 1 year ago
Luv Miley Cyrus,,,, whyyy was someone asking uuu 2 move
waltdisneyworld2011 1 year ago 43
@waltdisneyworld2011 No, not us. The security guard was telling the kids to stop pushing the defective rail. They didn't want anybody to get hurt.
thefashionpatrol 1 year ago 21
lmao great inspiration. TA LOKA?
LindaaaCamile 1 year ago 2
She sounds really good here.
xSapphireAK 1 year ago 2
She is like an Angel <3
TheDRAMAQUEENxD 1 year ago
@shady12384 i dont know? im wondering thtA 2
myahanna1 1 year ago
woow, i seriously despise people who hate on miley 4 no reason!! 1 of the comments that ivv read that i cant stnad is that her teeth r messed up, who cares!! she sings amazingly, nad she is beautiful so y does that matter?
hchappyful 1 year ago
well. I love Miley and her voice very much !
she's the best singer and her voice is very very very perfect.
tranphuongha 1 year ago
Wow ,This is amazing .Her voice is so better ,and I love this part : 4:37
I love you Miley :):*
TheMartusiaP 1 year ago
Ok 1) voice just straight out sucks!!!
2) she messed up her own damn song
3) her freaking teeth make her look like a horse...
-___-'
awesomepurplesox 1 year ago
@awesomepurplesox
so you sing better than miley and look much prettier than her?
oh, then why don't you be a star?
snows19 1 year ago
@awesomepurplesox u jelly
chargebug 1 year ago
@awesomepurplesox looks like your jelous
drakeandjosh789 1 year ago
@awesomepurplesox jealousy is a dirty disease.
mcpannesi 1 year ago
@awesomepurplesox
1) okay shes got a really strong voice and its actually worth listening to than other artists
2) well know you know shes really singing and not lipsyncing ?
3) i like horse
Ronichew 1 year ago
@awesomepurplesox are you serious? Either you are a hater or you are deaf either way you are an idiot anyone who says that this performance sucks or that she sings poorly don't know what they are talking about.
f0cusen 8 months ago
She is so amazing, I love her "lion" hair <3
azazaz104 1 year ago
I LOVE THIS GIRL
Jiulia187 1 year ago
I love Miley she is amazing!!!
Angeleish 1 year ago
She as a strong voice! So beautiful :)
kiduxafofaful 1 year ago
Miley is really amezing!! <333
TheSardientje 1 year ago
fu*k all of you people who say shes a stripper and a slut especailly you mrt8rock
turner778 1 year ago
Wow....she really is good!
Love you Miley!
r0ck99videos 1 year ago
Good. Good.
r0ck99videos 1 year ago
Ha I love how she sings thru her nose and her freaking HUMONGOUS over-bite lol. Sarcasm.
AprilBlazze 1 year ago
WOW!!!! Go miley!!
mileyrockz1122 1 year ago 7
I don't care what anyone else says. Miley knocks this song out of the park. She owns it, top to bottom. Many popular singers can't do nearly this well with pitch, timing etc.
She's a pretty good singer, folks. Anyone who can do better, feel free to go for it!
tchris67 1 year ago 2
Why the hell do people say she isn't an insperation, because of the clothes she wears? Whats the point...loads of people wear shorts......but they mean inspirations, because she always followed her dreams, and it shows how far you can go.
JJCLover64 1 year ago
she sings so beautifull¡¡¡
mileypopcorn 1 year ago
great perfomance
Nicolah10 1 year ago
@shady12384 Los Angeles. At a mall called The Grove.
thefashionpatrol 1 year ago 14
i hate miley Cyrus
mrt8rock 1 year ago
i hate miley cryuse
mrt8rock 1 year ago
@mrt8rock if you hate her why watch vids of her
rockinpersonality123 1 year ago 103
@mrt8rock u hate her so much that u cant even spell her name rite. and just wondering, y do u look up her videos?
hchappyful 1 year ago
Very strong, beautiful voice :)
Chelleyy100 1 year ago 93
@randomxmonkeys i agree
122333phoenix 1 year ago 3
great inspiration to teens........... she's wearing shorts that should be burned... smoking salvia(she has little kids that look up to her). at least she's not using auto tuno. =)
eshaaa0 1 year ago
shes not very good live
TXCAS08 1 year ago
@randomxmonkeys This isn't to be mean. But the reason the most fans love her is because they love her voice. and we now its sounds rough and cracky but i like it. And she can sing great. But not as great as demi lovato or beyoncé but i don't care
margotpeeters 1 year ago 2
i lovee the echo they put to the mic!! she sounds sooo cool!!
lilialou92 1 year ago
i love miley, others just can't understand her. dont mind other people if their not doing anything wrong to you...
kaylfrue 1 year ago 3
Not Many People Can Sing LIVE.!
Hateers Goo Away
TabithaDupuis 1 year ago 9
Not Many People Can Sing LIVE.!
Hateers Goo Awat
TabithaDupuis 1 year ago
wow, she sang great here. her control is incredible. even though she doesn't have a smooth voice, she has complete control of it! awesome job miley!!
dYe00t 1 year ago 4
@randomxmonkeys ffs... maybe you should stop listening to her music then if u only are gonna post stupid comments... her voice is good live and on cd you just have to find what kinda music you like morron-.- has nothing with her to do that u dont like it its you self... so stop comment her videos...
TylorUpg 1 year ago
Seriously i dont deny that she sounds good in those slow songs like the climb or when i look at you. But no offense, she can't sing those hip hop songs such as party in the usa or cant be tamed in live.
pureblacksky 1 year ago
she isn't an awful singer but considering how famous she is i'd expect her to be much better. I've seen so many superior youtube covers.
questions117 1 year ago
the music was boring :(
fiiiqah 1 year ago
man i love her voice. i dont know why there's so many haters
blobbygirl 1 year ago 11
she dressed pretty hereXD
unique3606 1 year ago 3
she is getting better and better
i love her
EENDJUU 1 year ago 4
Amazing voice! ;)
owieczkaa92 1 year ago 3
oh my why cant they stand there
BTJSHUFFLER123 1 year ago
People who think that she doesn't have talent, is so stupid! Seriously! ;)
kuffert11 1 year ago 2
she's got b00bz
jordywillems 1 year ago
I love this song, but I have no interest in her disney fame or her attempt to be a older than she really is, but I'll stil listen to this.
HayaKusanagi 1 year ago
CHILLLS!!!!!!! OHmygod this is incredible, i seriously just got goosebumps when she hit that first prechorus, amazing
xoxAshh137 1 year ago
ammmmazing voice.very well performed.
sneha795 1 year ago 4
her hair is like... perfect
& so is her voice (x
lol <33
RAWRsingit 1 year ago
Comment removed
SkySkyRandom09 1 year ago
This is just amazin tbh, her voice is so powerful :)! i love miley and it really gets me mad when people hate on her, because she has an awesome voice and i would sell everything i have just to see her lol :)
Mckenziiee123 1 year ago
@MilesAmourx I agree!
XxNo1MileyCyrusFanxX 1 year ago
This is my favorite performance by her. She so talented, her voice is really strong, and it it seriously the best out of all her live performances. This video proves that she can sing. And FUCK ALL YOU HATERS.
MilesAmourx 1 year ago 8
Miley favore it this !
llutub1 1 year ago
this is the best song she ever sang live.
JIJSTRESSTIKCHILL 1 year ago 4
that was amazing! how can people think she's bad?
juliexoelizabeth 1 year ago
@juliexoelizabeth no like bad as a bad role model shes just well gross....
Nikkiz200 1 year ago
I wonder why ppl always judge on the personality of celebrities
it's not like we are their friends in real life.... how do we tell they're gd or bad
yeahyeahnatnat 1 year ago 5
Wow that wasn't bad at all! I'm kinda impressed! :)
gymnut83 1 year ago
really good live song
MayaSummers 1 year ago
I wanna meet her. She is awesome. I wanna sing with her... duet. tell me how can I do that? Im from poland;P
michal1135sobieraj 1 year ago
its good song ilove you miley <3
2304Kristine 1 year ago 2
she sings very good ;) but I think, she will be the next Britney Spears^^ ...
siisterz4liife 1 year ago
@siisterz4liife yea
me 2
starmona94 1 year ago
LOVE her. no matter what.
honestgal03 1 year ago
wHY DO i LUV HER SO MUCH? :') luv ya Miley <3<3<3<3<3<<3
1992MileyLover 1 year ago
climb<3
3an8i97 1 year ago
She's amazing, and is my idol :)
She's sounds good live too !!
And you can't call someone. Slut without getting to know them, because you can't be judged on something like that just because of what you wear etc it's if you sleep around and use guys and shit like that. Xo
greeksoccerbabe 1 year ago
so good and cool shes my role model
mrsdegrassigirl1 1 year ago 4
I think this is the best ive seen her sing live
summerzgal96 1 year ago
i love miley,,but now i don't like her that much when the song can't be tamed came out..
antonettesulit 1 year ago
did she just say miley was inspiration to teens everywhere... fuck me
fitzy431 1 year ago
she's good. but i dont like when he dressed like a slut. :(
i love her <3
haydleanderson 1 year ago
It's a costume, every pop star wears a costume on stage to perform. So she's not dressing like a slut. If you would focus on the performance and the music, you wouldn't be bothered by what she wears. And what a person wears doesn't make them a slut, it's who the person is that makes them a slut. If they sleep around they are a slut, Miley isn't. At the end of the day she's still Miley, the sweet person who does alot for charities like this.
CinCinBreezy 1 year ago 3
@CinCinBreezy I totally agree with you. She has her own style and to be honest I love it and in no way makes her look like a slut. Whoever said that needs to actually find the right definition. And a slut would do charities because they are so up themselves. Sorry this just had to be said. Like your comment. :)
AliannaHarveyson 1 year ago 3
Def. one of her better live performances....most aren't to good
Missylin210 1 year ago 2
lol is that john Lennon playing the guitar??!!?!?
Deem54 1 year ago
guess you guys cant stand there... lol
ilobchukbass 1 year ago
she is so awesome!
pompeldemoes 1 year ago
wow miley favorited this video!
MissOanaDivina 1 year ago
It´s Cool
Herbertaliebste2313 1 year ago
Wow....She is very good...I Love Miley Cyrus..
MrsBean97 1 year ago
compared to most stars today, especially disney channel ones, she's very talented.
PrehistoricPlague 1 year ago 2
@PrehistoricPlague
Agree
SuduxxRosa 10 months ago 2
l mean i'ts not bad ,but honestly that'not the stuff what we expect from a good singer.where are the ppl,who really CAN sing,c'mon.
jetsat100 1 year ago
@jetsat100 if you dont think shes a good singer fine thats your opinion, but don't go on her videos if you don't like her singing, because its not like you can do any better
ilovevolleyball12ify 1 year ago
@jetsat100 yeah i agree! all those disney stars suck! well, they don't have a special voice or something.... They're all the same! they act... they sing a little and then: BOOM everybody loves them even if they're not that good! not hating or anything! cause i love miley's songs but all those disney stars are the same (: (sorrt my english is not so good)
melissamougin 1 year ago
This is all a facade.She doesnt really care.I guess maybe she just wants publicity or a more wholesome image or something,because I have a friend who babysits this 4 year old who got backstage passes to one of her concerts, and,while backstage she saw that she took pictures with the kids,but she didn't even acknowledge them. She basically just ignored them and didn't even act like she cared.And that was their last dying wish. Miley Cyrus is probably the biggest bitch known to man kind.
hsd234 1 year ago
woow
i want her voice xoxo
3MysteriousGirlszz 1 year ago
she just doing nice thing to come on tv but selena doesnt do those things to come on tv shes just nice
Msbadgirl20101 1 year ago
Everything about miley,is beautiful.She has a wonderful voice.l love her just the way she is.You can't improve on perfection.Well done miles,ur amazing.Peace & godbless:)XX
ur fan forever,Keith White(Megamileyfan1)uk.
TheMegamileyfan1 1 year ago
is she a christian????
eamedrolf 1 year ago