What the heck with this guy? He NAILED it with this song and then abandoned the style when it counted (during the public voting). Had he continued with this style he would have done SOOO much better than what he did.
@ejsanch what are you talking about? He did do this style throughout the competition. I remember Sugar Were Going Down and Forever, some of the better acoustic performances he did. It was the judges who put this performance on the pedestal that Andrew couldn't match for their standards
That's exactly it! None of his performances could match what he did in Hollywood, and although things may have been in that similar style, none of them after Straight Up were as creative. Take a listen to the original song, then listen to his version. Not much creativity, not much went in there. Then compare how he completely made-over Straight Up. No where near the same level.
I've known someone named Andrew Garcia since Kindergarten, & at first, when I saw AI's Andrew, I thought of my friend, but ever since this performance, when I see my friend, I think of THIS Andrew. <3 haha
is the only version of him singing this song on hollywood week? Like did he by any chance rerecord it and has it available somewhere? cuz I LOVE his version of this song and would love to have a clear copy of it
"I love you too mejo"
hellokitty4me 15 hours ago
"Hollywood is a disgusting town." Ellen just cracks me up...
ninanacho111 3 days ago
"I'm goin' to Hollywood! I'm going to ride in a Aeroplayne!"
AznRod 5 days ago
Let's chop of Simons hand, right naow!
Jarganto 6 days ago
His voice reminds me of Bruno Mars.
MartinMechev 1 week ago
I love Cara.
pakantotmiss 1 week ago
Dude has a good voice, but he's not a good guitar player.
hitthecouch 2 weeks ago
Tori kelly @1:39 ??
AsianStyle31 3 weeks ago
Yea, Go, Andrew Garcia :)
jackie24421 3 weeks ago
Innovative.
PedroGunzalez 3 weeks ago
it's a shame he peaked too soon!
MorningRose557 1 month ago
@MorningRose557 that's what she said
adrisi0608 1 month ago 2
Is it just me or do everybody else just watch this video for Andrew's performance and when Vanessa Wolfe's part comes, we turn off the video already.
CloudChronicles 1 month ago 7
@CloudChronicles What's a Vanessa Wolfe?
TheWhiteGuatemalan 1 month ago
Kara is a blithering idiot... adam, blah, blah, blah
wbgorn 1 month ago
pause at 3:19 lolololololo
2021emotional 1 month ago
woooork out
realqjay 1 month ago
umut anil ist besser
TheLeitz001 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if i can get my hands on the low dirty dog how disliked this
epicnot4u 1 month ago
Andrew should realllyy record a full version of this!
Neenz86 1 month ago
@1:39 TORI KELLY!!!! :D
eyesoulated 1 month ago
I have not watched American Idol since Andrew Garcia got kicked off!
nassift25 1 month ago 5
@nassift25 looool, you act like he was some amazing talent. what a joke. this was the best thing he ever did, most of his stuff sucked
kcmet79 1 month ago
0:58
aclies1 1 month ago
you know you're good when the people you're competing against cheer you on
strs4 1 month ago
didn't like it, LOVED it <3
norwayskatergirl97 1 month ago
press 4 and then skip right to the end....the difference could not be any greater lol
theazn07 1 month ago
3:00 white trash lol
theazn07 1 month ago
i'm going to hollywood.. i'm gona ride on uh arrowplane lol
xSAMOANxBLURx 1 month ago
this is the SHIET!
noxxie2 1 month ago
What the heck with this guy? He NAILED it with this song and then abandoned the style when it counted (during the public voting). Had he continued with this style he would have done SOOO much better than what he did.
ejsanch 2 months ago
@ejsanch what are you talking about? He did do this style throughout the competition. I remember Sugar Were Going Down and Forever, some of the better acoustic performances he did. It was the judges who put this performance on the pedestal that Andrew couldn't match for their standards
BeeRock200 1 month ago
@BeeRock200
That's exactly it! None of his performances could match what he did in Hollywood, and although things may have been in that similar style, none of them after Straight Up were as creative. Take a listen to the original song, then listen to his version. Not much creativity, not much went in there. Then compare how he completely made-over Straight Up. No where near the same level.
ejsanch 1 month ago
Personally, I think Andrew's WAYYY better than adam. Adam DEFINILTEY isn't the best artist on the world (at all)....
BriSwagtastic 2 months ago
i cried when i saw this cuz it reminded me of how much i miss paula. but this is an amazing performance!
CookandJohnsGirl 2 months ago
This is my all time favorite American Idol performance..
AlloftheAbuv 2 months ago
This is straight up hot, sexy, music and I want some. Where can I get Andrew Garcias music?
aw73087 2 months ago
@aw73087 he has a youtube channel.
lindsaykeen13 2 months ago
@aw73087 he has a youtube channel
daratinnel32244 2 months ago
great singer!
alobor1 2 months ago
I've known someone named Andrew Garcia since Kindergarten, & at first, when I saw AI's Andrew, I thought of my friend, but ever since this performance, when I see my friend, I think of THIS Andrew. <3 haha
mandiedecember12 2 months ago
3:06 what is this song called?
rockandroll627 2 months ago
@rockandroll627 It's the Shins I'm sure. Not sure about the songname but know it's something with "slang"...should be easy to find.
wazzobazzo 2 months ago
@rockandroll627 New Slang by The Shins.
faquino101 2 months ago
1:30 that judge got no mothafukkin rhythm lol snapper her fingers all of beat n shit :D
GueroVision 3 months ago 7
@GueroVision
munguia19 2 months ago
this was amazing!! what did he place?
rypnen 3 months ago
That was Brilliant:)
GiiorgiiPorgy 3 months ago
aeroplane :D lol
xeonomorphieus 3 months ago
Did J Cole steal andrews lyrics?
dudeyo86 3 months ago 7
ANDREW GARCIA! <333 and crystal
Ang62198 3 months ago
why why WHY SHOULD ALL AMERICAN IDOL CONTESTANTS SHOULD BE COMPARED WITH ADAM LAMBERT ?????? WHY?!??!?!
SaM89876 3 months ago 2
i love Ellen...all the way
MsL3nny 3 months ago
2:31 DID I JUST SAW DIRK NOWITZKI?
dizzyy2k8 3 months ago
beginning is hilarious..classic Simon "that was painful...wrong wrong wrong" lmao
Vertigo2903 4 months ago
YTF
CdawgSingsxx2 4 months ago 4
Unfortunately for him I think he chose his best song/performance too early on. This was awesome though!
asdisciple18 5 months ago 4
skip to 1:02
JesusFreak9186 5 months ago in playlist JesusFreak9186's Favorited Videos 6
the way he sang this song gives me the goosebumps! Amazing!
TheJ3NnY88 5 months ago
no dislikes!!!!dats the spirit ppl....
MsAlienforce 5 months ago
he sounds like jonah hill when he talks
chickensaurusrex711 6 months ago
I LOVE IT!!!
Poor girl, she has to sing after THIS performance :D
MissGiu15 6 months ago 6
I LOVE IT!!!
MissGiu15 6 months ago
I love how that girl said "I'ma get to ride on an arrow plane"! Lmao
ibarra1raul 10 months ago 10
@ibarra1raul LOL! Iknow right!
twilight961113 10 months ago
sweet cover check ours out "straight up acoustic my dudes band"
StrickJay 11 months ago
is the only version of him singing this song on hollywood week? Like did he by any chance rerecord it and has it available somewhere? cuz I LOVE his version of this song and would love to have a clear copy of it
Voileen 1 year ago
Andrew Garcia is still one my favorite artists to ever be on american idol. He had me at Straight Up...
atararaah 1 year ago
Andrew has such and amazing voice its so unique! :D
gymnast68 1 year ago 4
this guy is awesome :D
sistagoofball9121 1 year ago
Andrew Garcia <3
xelizabethdang 1 year ago 85
@xelizabethdang you homosapien
cholofracasado 1 week ago
Hope Andrew and Crystal Bowersox make it to Top 2 this season.. both are so amazing and such original creative artists..
lauriroset 2 years ago 56
@lauriroset and they did!
Ang62198 3 months ago
@Ang62198
Andrew was in the Top 10, not Top 2... eliminated 8th last season..
lauriroset 3 months ago