Immigration Gumballs (5 min version)

[BrutusHayek1776]

Beck trivialized the fact that millions could be pulled out of poverty by simply moving and working in new country, lengthening the lives of millions by several years if not decades. According to research by Lant Pritchett, the average Haitian's income increases by a factor of 23 by simply moving to the US. Immigration restrictions prevent him from doing so. To the extent that that policy keeps his income low, preventing a businessman from voluntarily hiring him, US policy is to blame.

[axelandro93]

care

[smarfling]

Good argument, very cogent. Can I have some gumballs now?

[BrutusHayek1776]

If lifting 1,000,000 people out of poverty a year is not worth it, in Beck's version of ethics, then he must think Oscar Schilndler is irrelevant because he only saved 1,200 from the gas chambers. 1,000,000 people are still 1,000,000 people regardless of how many other people are alive in the world. Beck's argument are collectivist to the core and ethically disgusting.

[69leiska69]

@BrutusHayek1776

And you compare saving lives with giving a change to move in more developed country? Right on.

Have you ever heard that people should take care of themselves instead of furious breeding even without a change of feeding their own children?

[NewsLaw]

US take only educated imigrants, right?

Now if 1 mil of poor imigrants work in US and earn 2000-4000 $/month. he keep for him 1000 $ and the rest of the money send it home to the family. The poor guys with 2$/day now recieve more money...to have a better life. From 1000 $ send in home country you can help 18 poor people!!!!

- so, you see how 1 million of imigrant can help 18.000.000 of poor people!!!!!

Now, what if....they send more then 1000 $?!?!

[Albin249]

What part of "ILLEGAL" don't you understand?

[lost2fairyfate]

@Albin249 THANK YOU!

[MaudsPas]

Succession.. How about just informing the public, youtube is a great tool. Spend 5 min a day commenting on highly viewed immigration videos. Make informed, level headed responses. Or link this video. ?v=1pgz6ZCqhtg

Read the comments give thumbs up to comments that address illegal immigration as a serious problem.

[swamimans]

another example of white twisted logic. why dont you go back to europe nazi's

[JackJ1957]

5. Nearly 35% of all inmates in California detention centers are Mexican nationals here illegally.

6. Over 300,000 illegal aliens in Los Angeles County are living in garages.

7. The FBI reports half of all gang members in Los Angeles are most likely illegal aliens from south of the border.

8 Nearly 60% of all occupants of HUD properties are illegal.

[swamimans]

@JackJ1957 and most people on welfare are white! and yes social security , medicare and medicaid is considered welfare. its money you are getting way in excess to what your putting in. this is why these programs cant be funded with todays dollars. one thing i like about jews is their spread of multiculturalism. whites have terrorized the world for atleast 500 years. you are heartless and machinelike. no matter what land you go to you kill the natives or enslave them.

[JackJ1957]

@swamimans Laws should apply to all regardless of color. White illegals should be deported the same as brown ones, etc. The statistics I posted happen to deal with the vast majority of illegals who are in the U.S., which are Mexican, because they share a long border with us.. I simply believe we should have the same policy toward illegal aliens as Mexico does. Wouldn't that be fair?

[JackJ1957]

1. 40% of all workers in L. A. County ( L. A. County has 10.2 million people) are working for cash and not paying taxes. This is because they are predominantly illegal immigrants working without a green card.

2. 95% of warrants for murder in Los Angeles are for illegal aliens.

3. 75% of people on the most wanted list in Los Angeles are illegal aliens.

4. Over 2/3 of all births in Los Angeles County are to illegal alien Mexicans on Medi-Cal, whose births were paid for by U.S. taxpayers.

[bonesdoc11]

Could not agree more. It's also time we stop being the last hold out country that still grants citizenship to anyone born here no matter what their parentage. We are the last country stupid enough to continue that archaic and self destructive law.

[NoHelpWanted]

@bonesdoc11 Remeber it is not Constitutional to have anchor spawn. The cheap labor supporting politicians are just ignoring the laws and most espcially the CONSTITUTION and it Amendments

[bonesdoc11]

@NoHelpWanted I couldn't agree more, they should all be thrown out!

[brazosdedios]

Excellent presentation explaining want I envision and am strategizing for how to help them where they are, rather than trying to justify bringing "everyone" to the USA. I agree with another poster that probably very few are motivated by compassion to bring poor here, for most people it is all about maximizing profits.

[Spawnomite]

Let the "illegals" become legal and vote Democrat permanently.

[Ninjaculation]

I don't think the reason people want third world immigrants to come to the U.S. is because they want to save them from poverty. They want them to come here so that they can work on our cars, make our food, clean our dishes, and be our nannies.

[kauters]

i wish he did a speech on uk immigration with eastern europeans! i live in an area that has more polish than anywhere else in uk. on 160 kids out of 600 in our local school were born in england! we are moving that needs to stop!

[rtgoodson]

@kauters I would be more worried about the Muslim and African immigration into the UK over the Polish. The Polish will eventually blend into society while the later will not. Take care.

[YankeeTom63]

There are some states who pose the same question about brain drain. ( how do we keep our graduates in ( enter state here ).

[oisch001]

this guys is goood. wow.  he is soo persuasive. i dont agree....but wow it doesnt matter...hes good.

[myentourage]

Excellent! Im a liberal who believes all people should have an equal chance in life. But that being said you cant argue with facts. The more that comes here legally and illegally the more that the poor people here stay poor, those same new immigrants get added to our poor and we as a nation lose. very well done!

[SiggeStjaernstoft]

Immigration isn't all about helping third world countries. There are obviously better methods for that. Immigration is even more about treating people with the same respect and give them a proper chance since they anyway have come to, and searched for a better life, in a foreign country.

[hillmanranchgal]

this puts it all in perspective. Our congress people should see this. Let's compassionately help 3rd world countries control their disease and over population. Secure our borders, have methodically LEGAL immigration sensibly and not "emotionally". God bless Arizona for stepping forward and actually UPHOLDING and acting on FEDERAL LAW since our Fed gov won't. They are cowards. Meanwhile we suffer financially and with heavy crime.

[rtgoodson]

@hillmanranchgal The US donates billions in charity each year. The time has come to revert back to the 1965 quota system that stabilized our demographic population by focusing on European immigration followed by non-European skilled immigration. We already have the work force for low-skilled labor.

[jollyradical]

@rtgoodson Very true, though it's probably too late in some countries. Even if immigration is again restricted, with much higher birth rates, Non-European immigrants are already in sufficient numbers to become the majority in a few generations.

[rtgoodson]

@jollyradical Pretty much. Have you visited California or New York? Mutlicultural/multiracial hell. Look at the issues created by the increase of Muslims and Non-Europeans into Western Europe. A prime example is Malmo in Sweden or the rampant white flight from the cities. Diversity and Multiculturalism breed conflict.

[jollyradical]

@rtgoodson Believe me I know, I'm in NY and you're right diversity is a source of conflict. I don't mind a little diversity, but there have to be limits. A host population and culture should never allow themselves to be overwhelmed by a foreign one.

Here in NY whites are moving back into Harlem which is a famous black neighborhood and the blacks are protesting the gentrification and that they're being displaced. Funny it's never mentioned that Harlem was originally a white Dutch settlement.

[rtgoodson]

@jollyradical Hmm...I wasn't aware of the increased white migration into Harlem. I can't think of a reason why this would occur other than the cost of living. To be honest, New York and California are gone, and I would prefer it if the South left the Union again. I give the US 25-100 years before it splits apart due to the changing demographics, cultural differences, and political views.

[jollyradical]

@rtgoodson Yes, the lower rent and because police keep the riff raff in check thanks to Giuliani's reforms. Harlem's a lot nicer and cleaner now, but the instant it becomes unsafe again it'll be white flight all over again. The South never really did leave since they lost, but I'm supportive of that idea because we're being dragged into a socialist, third world hellhole. Some states will eventually have to consider secession even if it means civil war. Maybe the sooner it happens the better.

[rtgoodson]

@jollyradical Negative, the South legally left the Union in 1861, and we've been under Federal Occupation since 1865. The War of Northern Aggression was nothing more than an illegal act of treachery by our northern kinsmen, and Sherman, Lincoln, and Grant were all war criminals. Also, a civil war is a military conflict between two factions fighting for control of the same government. That was never the case. Hence, historians have incorrectly named The War of Northern Aggression.

[jollyradical]

@rtgoodson You're right. I looked it up and there was nothing illegal with the Confederate states seceding and the certainly did leave the Union. I stand corrected. As for civil war, Merriam-Webster defines it as "a war between opposing groups of citizens of the same country" not factions fighting to control the same government. Civil war or not, the term 'War of Northern Aggression' is quite accurate.

[rtgoodson]

@jollyradical Finally, secession talks will occur at some point in the future due to our mounting national debt, shifting minority-majority demographics, and cultural conflicts across the nation. Nations always rise and Empires always crumble. I find it funny that people actually think that the US will last forever. For example, my native Dixie would have the 5th largest economy on the planet as an independent nation, and they would have a social and fiscally conservative government. Deo Vindice

[jollyradical]

@rtgoodson I agree, secession is in our future. Lacking the same conditions and threat of war, I don't know if seceding southern states will opt to form the old Confederacy again, but who knows. A new Dixie would be a major power. The US is a wealthy nation so any grouping of American states would be a major world economy.

[rtgoodson]

@jollyradical I agree. However, the Southern States, if they left the Union again, would certainly consider a move to reform under the CSA banner. We're tied to each other in history, culture, dialect, religion, ethnicity, and politics. Native Southerners already consider themselves as a nation within a nation. On the other hand, I can't make that argument for the rest of the country.

[jollyradical]

@rtgoodson That makes sense. The southern states are tied to each other in many ways so I can imagine a new CSA on the negotiation table. I wouldn't loose hope for the rest of America though. Texas might choose to become an independent republic again. The New England states are tied by colonial history and a similar liberal political mindset. They would be a major economic power at least. Places like Hawaii and Puerto Rico also have a very independent nature.

[rtgoodson]

@jollyradical As I said before, it would take a major catalyst to cause a secessionist movement across the nation, but, in the end, every nation devolves or evolves at some point. With regards to Texas, they're the only state in the Union with a legal document that specifically states their right to leave via treaty. Finally, I haven't lost all hope in the US, but, as a student of history, our outcome is already well-documented. Sadly, we're fighting the globalist & multiculturalist agenda.

[GoHardMG]

@rtgoodson ohh man i live in the south the ppl from other states are almost outnumbering the natives.

[rtgoodson]

@GoHardMG True. However, it's generally conservatives escaping the liberal policies of the north or west coasts. On the other hand, I have seen a large influx of non-whites into the area (mostly around major cities), and this bothers me on some fronts as it slowly destroys our cultural and ethnic heritage (Miami is a good example of this).

[GoHardMG]

@rtgoodson ehh well I dont know what to say its not just occurring here you know its planetary immigration. Tons of middle eastern and africans have moved to Europe. Theres also been numerous amounts of White Germans & French that have moved to Mexico. We still get tons of brit's moving here as well. I really dont have any Idea of how Miami is I have not been to MIami since I was a little kid, I do know there are tons of Cubans, Puertoricans and haitian.

[GoHardMG]

@rtgoodson But yeah a lot of causes of immigration have to do with socioeconomic problems, as well as problems that have occurred due to corruption and other government secret agenda. But anyways I really dont like the Idea of a melting pot but rather a buffet!!!!!!!!!!!

[rtgoodson]

@GoHardMG A difference exists between controlled (limited) and uncontrolled immigration. Like it or not, multiple ethnic/cultural groups can't coexist within a single nation-state on mutual terms. You point to the African and Muslim immigration into Europe, and I simply point to the increase of racial violence, riots, and cultural differences that currently exists within that scenario.

[GoHardMG]

@rtgoodson yup yup old world problems that are trying to be fix with the same crap we have been doing for years. I think its time for a change and new ideas to handle the situation, to me the problem is the same as in trying to preform surgery with a surgeon book from the 1800. Everything is out of date our society, or ideology, are ideas of solving the problem the problems wont be settle with a dam wall or laws, wall never work non have really ever worked. Everything needs to be updated!!!!!!

[oooodin]

the leftist politicians are flooding the west with the "surplus" of the 3rd world as the 3rd world cannot sustain theire numbers anymore..god have mercy when the west cannot sustain the tidalwave anymore because all hell will break lose as countrys collapse into anarchy and war.

[rtgoodson]

@oooodin Exactly.

[JonaBay]

When was this made?

[megagagnon1]

@JonaBay this was made in 1990

[rocketsredglare101]

Illegal immigration is a tax on the working poor and has kept wages low for decades.

Legal immigration via mostly fraudulent worker visa programs is bringing in 125,000 foreign workers EACH MONTH and is wiping out the middle class - Visa workers are not smarter or harder working, they are younger & cheaper.

We need an immigration moratorium and to make E Verify mandatory & stop re electing traitors that try to shove another amnesty up our as**s. Join Numbersusa, read Vdare(dot)com

[barbarianatgate]

GabriellaNoel, your points are valid except for one key point of logic - its OUR infrastructure, and we have the right to protect our resources and the responsibility of stewardship of our country. We need to limit the number of people using these resources, and guess what? It shouldn't be people who were born here, so that only leaves those that weren't. Don't turn a logical argument into a whine about how "the rich are evil and business is bad." If you had your own business, you'd understand.

[GabriellaNoel]

Numbers enjoyed the cheap labor that produced all the gumballs that they needed to make this video with. However, they blame Immigrants for the infra-structure damage that the production of these gumballs caused. Normally, it would make sense for the corporation to take corporate responsiblity and pay additional taxes to repair the infrastructure damage that occured during the production of these gumballs. However, numbers knows scapegoating the issue is a way to avoid themselves a tax increase,

[GabriellaNoel]

I suppose this idiot forgot to talk about the marbles "fathers" that have been detained and deported and taken away from their children and spouses. Numbers are a bunch of "right winged nuts" that try to con people in to believing that Immigrants damage the infrastructure. The truth is that all people damage the infratructure. The members of numbers are upset because they enjoyed the cheap labor of Immigrants and do not want to avoid a tax increase for themselves by scapegoating the issue.

[EyeLuvUSA]

Those 'fathers' (and mothers) CHOSE to come here illegally and knew there was the risk of being deported so they shouldn't have married and had children. It's their fault, not ours.

[Tuppington]

we can probably say for certain that some spanish comunists knew that forming a government would serve to turn people on each other more, and history proved them right. the abandonment of the anarchist struggle led to some right wing atni communist nut running the country.

[rockstarofredondo]

Of course--this is just common sense. The issue of poverty is not location, it's government oppression, which is worldwide. Leaving one place & going to another does nothing to address that issue. I'd like to leave the US because I am sick of the police state but I would be doing nothing to deal with the issue of the police state. It's the same thing everywhere: Government/corporate tyranny is the problem. Deal with that & you deal with the root of every problem the people of this world face.

[rocketsredglare101]

Please help Numbersusa get more members by leaving info about them in your comments on youtube. Every little bit helps.

Numbersusa and their members helped stop the last two Amnesties, did you?

[rocketsredglare101]

We need Comprehensive Immigration Reform in 2010. Next year we need to get rid of Chain Migration, Anchor babies, make e verify Mndatory for all employees, jail employers that hire foreign workers with mostly fraudulent worker visas and to have an immigration moratorium so the millions of ilegals that came in the last decades can become Americans and not be driven to colonize us by their ethnic advocates. Go to Numbersusa to join a million other Americans that stopped the last Amnesties.

[rtgoodson]

@rocketsredglare101 No, we need to repeal the immigration laws that date back to 1965, and then strengthen and enforce our immigration policies from there.

[MAJEZTICSENZ19]

as an ilegal immigrant fighting my case for a minor crime my first crime ever which was getting a fake id to have some fun at a club which i had lost my wallet with school id's and all i know i can bring alot of benefit and be productive in this country if i can just get that chance,how many blue marballs you have there?gangs lowlifes etc?take all the blue marballs out!the bad ones and give every one that lives in the name of justice a chance im sure you would have that to half!i share your idea

[usrevolution2]

IS IT TIME? Go to USRevolution2 (dot com) and get the flag of the Second American Revolution. It looks exactly like the Betsy Ross flag, but with a Roman numeral "II" in the center of the 13 stars. They are in all 50 states. Click the "Videos" tab on our website & see the flag spreading from Hawaii to North Carolina. When this flag goes viral 95% of profits will go to patriot candidates, and 5% will go to me so I can retire before I die. They are $19.95 + postage & handling.

[Tuppington]

first, your link is a malicious website.

second, "patriot candidates"? as in, candidates for election? what a joke. when the people of spain put their revolution on hold in the 30's to set up a parliament the fascists exploited the differences between them and the Spanish Republicans in a "divide and conquer" strategy...

same thing is gonna happen to whatever dopey party you set up.. its gonna deject from the will of the constituents and become another blaze, corporate friendly liability.

[mrhulot101]

When I leave a comment on youtube I always add the url for numbersusa(dot)com and vdare(dot)com to let others know about the sites that have educated me the most about immigration. i can't thank Roy enough for providing me a free site where I can fax my immigration traitors in Washington and let them know how I look forward to voting them out next election. I also leave immigration comments on realclearpolitics(dot)com and link to numbersusa, every little bit helps. You all should try it.

[Avishkush91]

Someone finally gave a true answer to the immigration problem. Most people either choose a more liberal approach of letting them all in or the more conservative approach of not letting anyone in.

Both are wrong, because you can't accept everybody and you can't stop everyone from entering a country, it's just too complicated either way.

The best solution is actually helping the third-world residents having a better life. If their lives won't be shitty they wouldn't want to mass immigrate.

[Tawaxyon]

He did make a point of how we could help them, but let's say an immigrant came here and became teacher. I believe that person would rather be teacher here In Usa than in the third world. So why we stop giving millions of people a better life just because we can't help the rest in the third world?

[bugsme10]

Immigration is why Rome fell.

[350Scrambler]

Obomba will never comprehend this VDO.

[skepticismjoe]

LOL,  you are correct.

[ihumpvids3]

he is saying mexican and immigration like its a bad thing

[matthias4085]

this is the greatest video, any little kid can understand it... why is it the liberals can't?

[swamimans]

i think no european white stock knows anything of humanitarian concern. colonialism and neocolonialism is pretty much what white people are about. where do you think third world poverty came from. european colonization, economic and political manipulation to steal resources.

[Kimoshnikov]

if you came across a tribe of people sitting on a gigantic gold nugget and doing nothing with it, wouldn't you want to take it too?

but be warned, when they found out they were too ignorant to realize it's value, they will want it back!!!

Third World is where it is due to its own choices. We can only help them make choices.

[swamimans]

the term "third world" is a european word and its not racist. If you have a problem with immigration then stop coming to the so called third world.

[rtgoodson]

@swamimans How many people do you see immigrating from the first world to the third world? The answer is none. Take care.

[swamimans]

@rtgoodson have you heard of the america's , india, south africa, all of latin america and so on. whites have forced themselves all over the world destabilizing the world economic order. whites have their uses but its time to breed you out.

[NoHelpWanted]

@swamimans I suppose you support being behind 3 centuries like India, Afrikaans, Latin America, South America, China, Caribbean, and Arabic... I bet you miss the sacrifice of human beings. Funny I am beginning to think it is a good idea only I would PURGE the bad out with a laxative.

Since we got Social Justice, America has hit the pits I will agree. But we invented this machine you are using to spread your propaganda of lies, race and hate... Get back behind the donkey and plow

[Tuppington]

yeah like choosing to not happen to be around highly productive domesticatable crops and animals. take a look at the book "guns germs and steel" by jared diamond.

to say that the entire population of say, new guinead got that way from simply being dumber than europeans is racist.

[rtgoodson]

@swamimans Yes, blame the white man for everyone's problems. That argument is getting fairly old.

[srvinfinity]

Read 721508's comment on the state of the UK and see the future, if not the present of the United States. "The flood gates are open and the social sevices are strain" and I say DRAINED!!!!

[skills1ent]

good point. but I hope they got the general idea!

[Blackjack555]

What happens when a jar is full and continues it's process? It overflows.

[AreThereNoMoreNames]

Many liberals support immigration because it's the easiest way out, and it makes them feel like they're helping people.

[Perkelekeitto91]

If you say same things in Europe, you are going to be accused for racism.

[mkayser0]

If you have a guest worker program, you can bring in about 1 million temporary workers a year, send them home with fat wallets, and help the US as well as the developing world.

Consider a very impoverished neighborhood in the Bronx. Should you let people from the Bronx work in Manhattan? Why not, right? Same logic applies to temporary worker programs. They don't have to stay forever, just long enough to help the USA (cheaper labor) and their home countries (the money/skills they bring back).

[UnwittingCattleCom]

Yeah, I never got the idea that immigration should be controlled by corporate greed, why can't we pick a group or quota based on a small number who could really benefit, or want to live in the US.

Why do we import people who hate what we stand for, are arrogant, and leave with the money we pay them.

I say bring 1000 starving people from poor countries give them a place to live for a while and then feed and educate them. Chances are they'll be so grateful they'll go back home and help others.

[CaJeffO]

CONSIDER THIS. Roy started speaking to our Congress in 1999. And, they didn't listen to him. ALSO SEE = The Movie "IOUSA" it was published OCT/08. That movie reveals our National Debt was only $997 Billion in 1981. Remember Reagan did the first amnesty in 86'. Since then our national debt has skyrocketed.

When Obama hit office our National Debt was $11.5 Trillion. Then Obama committed America for another $10 Trillion & supports AMNESTY!

[joejjl]

C'mon. What percentage of poor hispanics go back to help others? This would be a great idea as long as we *REQUIRED* them to go back and help others.

[RacingFansWorld]

"Why do we import people who hate what we stand for, are arrogant, and leave with the money we pay them."

lol - I believe this is still a Democratic Country. You are free to do what you will with the money your earn. I notice you fail to mention that they use the money they earn to pay Social Security & Income Taxes, Rent/Mortgage, Car Notes, Grocery's, etc...

[Caspasho]

@UnwittingCattleCom thats just stupid tho

[NoillegalAliens]

Everyone,

send this to your entire email list.

It is the least you can do, then join ALIPAC, FAIR and NumbersUSA.

[mensrightsmovement]

(with my previous comment, I meant to say),,,

Whenever immigrants come from certain countries, their population increases as usual. Plus, whatever population migrated to this country, those numbers will easily "bounce-back", in addition to their normal increase.

I've visited several third world countries, and most have a long standing tradition of creating big families.

[mensrightsmovement]

Awesome! I've put this on my Website.

Also, he should consider, these nations ALWAYS bounce back, when immigrants come here.

[marcoviti]

This guy is right. Plain and simple.

[susandrn]

You can't argue with this guy's facts and logic. You may not like it,  but that's the way it is, and people had better take note...

[nightworld0092003]

@susandrn Those 1 million people. Let me show this gentleman how this 1 million people are helping the world. Foreign remittance earnings of 2006:

India $26.9 billion

China $22.52 billion

Bangladesh $ 5.5 billion

Philippines $12.7 billion

often foreign remittance earnings are the key sector for economical growth why? for example if a country allows FDI what happens is the companies comes and take advantage of natural resources whereas remittance helps the local.

[a3patriot]

Awesome demonstration explaining immigration.

[happyjose23]

Educational

[kats9livesfive]

Amen...We need to care about our own citizens that are suffering.

[abbeyharry1952]

interesting video-thanks for sharing NoillegalAliens

[721508]

in the u.k. the floodgates have opened as more and more countries are allowed into the E.U., more and more immigrants come to the u.k. We now have a case where they will live many to one house and work below our minimum wage. We have cases of companies only employing polish workers because their cheap. our health services, police forces, social services, schools are all under strain. Its going to get far worse.

[jefeisdguard]

Wow! This is great! Makes perfect sense!

Remember, flying on a plane, the stewardess goes thru the rehearsed procedures of where the doors are & all of the safety requirements... she also tells us about the oxygen masks.

She tell us to make sure we put them on ourselves first before helping out our children or other passengers! Right?

Can't help ANYONE if your passed out!

Let's help others by helping get America stronger!

First things first, though... deport all the illegals!

[KKKn50cal]

This is the greatest vid I've seen on illegal immigration.

I for one have always said tht mexicans need to go back to mexico and fix their own country.

[3Haydens]

While I approve of LEAL immigrants...I despise the illegal alien. I have said for years...thirty years since college. FIX their homelands!!!! NO immigration and NO trading with countries who abuse their OWN people, like Mexico, South Africa, Kenya, etc, etc!!! NO free trade with China!!! Buy American!!! Keep the jobs here, NO outsourcing or they are GONE. Neilsen ratings a HUGE monopoly, just laid off 300+ Americans for Mexicans!!! STOP THIS, NOW!!!

[Avishkush91]

Finally a guy who makes sense!

3Haydens I wish there were more like you...