Its safe to say there will always be Callas vs Tebaldi debates, rational or not... Its also safe to say that both love this interpretation. Ones may not even admit it.
Where is it written that you can't love Maria & Renata?? Seems to me they are both immortals, both beloved, both sadly gone. Happily we have their recordings to enjoy them equally. This may be heresy for some but I heard both at The Met, have numerous recordinds by both and love both of them. Basta with this sniping between the two camps. BRAVA MARIA. BRAVA RENATA.
With me, there has always been an eminent performance for each of the great arias that surpass all others. For me, this is one of those eminent performances. I have never, in my eons of adoring opera, been as humbled and lush with awe as I was the first time I listened to this performance.
Aparte de que es la mejor Mimí de la historia del disco, en particular su versión de London de 1952; esta voz trasmite amor y es una de las voces más bellas y angelicales de todos los tiempos.
In questo video non dovrebbe essere data la possibilità di commentare perchè nessuna parola può neanche lontanamente avvicinarsi a quello che si ascolta.
PS. La boheme della Tebaldi è il disco più venduto al mondo per chi non lo sapesse.
They both melt my heart. When she knows the material well, she is as good as anyone ever was or will be. I'm going to try to find this DVD. It's a gem.
Absolutely stunning! There are many renditions of this on youtube but this is surely the best. The tone, texture, dynamics, phrasing and all that makes music truly great is inhabited by these two amazing human beings!
@RonaldBarone who are you to say almost good as Callas,can you hear properly.or are you just don't know any thing about any thing?pty isnot a radar in here to top some people to even get into youtub.
@mmisaku I don't know much about opera, like you do. But Callas did, so reading the reviews about Tebaldi, Callas makes clear that she is better. So you know... I was just taking the advice from the best one... that's all. I didn't mean to hurt anymore.
These excerpts should serve as a lesson both in singing and STYLE. Listen to the luscious phrasing and natural class of Tebaldi, the radiant tone of Björling. The current roster of Mimis, including many "famous" ones should be much more modest, and find some guiding inspiration here. Amen.
Continuo a chiedermi perché si debbano sempre leggere tante idiozie. SI SAPPIA E SI DEBBA SAPERE che una tale naturalezza di canto deriva da una padronanza tecnica somma, certo unita ad una voce semplicemente meravigliosa. SI RICORDI CHE IN ARTE LA NATURALEZZA E' IL TRAGUARDO SOMMO!
NO way..she has a great voice..BUT doesn't have the greatness , technique, uniquness that CALLAS has...love Callas' version, that one is more powerful and more heavenly. she is more ordinary soprano lacking the extraordinarity...but of course great woman!
I do love this Mimi. Tebaldi is simply glorious, her depth and range is incredible. Freni would be a close second for her incredible technique. Two of the greatest singers of the century, Bjorling and Tebaldi...together. What a treat.
This is absolutely glorious--Tebaldi at her very best. It exemplifies why hers is the quintessential exposition of the role. This is the Mimi against which all others must be judged. Thanks so much for posting!
Il sontuoso velluto della voce della Tebaldi si trapunge di seta e fili d'oro nell'esecuzione di questo brano. Le note, doviziose di armoniche, risonanze, colori, iridescenze giungono all'ascoltatore solleticandone, ora dolci ora potenti, non solo l'udito ma tutti i sensi: sembra quasi di dover socchiudere gli occhi all'arrivo dei raggi di sole della primavera che squarcia radiosa, come il canto di Renata, le nubi bigie e fa fiorire le rose. Non rammento esiti di tale levatura in quest'aria.
@SensusEtRatio i agree so much with what you say about Renata. when ahe sings " il primo baccio del aprile e mio" it seems that Puccini composed this line just for Renata Tebaldi !
One person who beats it: Tebaldi herself in her first (mono) recording of the opera done some years earlier. Every wonderful quality this video demonstrates PLUS heavenly high pianissimi which she doesn't do in this version.
Yes, I have that recording, and you're absolutely correct. It is better. The only thing this version has on that one is that you actually get to see her!
Either way, Tebaldi is the gold standard for recorded Mimis.
What captivating, glorious singing! This is Tebaldi at the height of her powers and demonstrates why she is my favorite Mimi of all time--embodying the character and vocal demands so naturally.
Il sontuoso velluto della voce della Tebaldi si trapunge di seta e fili d'oro nell'esecuzione di questo brano. Le note, doviziose di armoniche, risonanze, colori, iridescenze giungono all'ascoltatore solleticandone, ora dolci ora potenti, non solo l'udito ma tutti i sensi: sembra quasi di dover socchiudere gli occhi all'arrivo dei raggi di sole della primavera che squarcia radiosa, come il canto di Renata, le nubi bigie e fa fiorire le rose. Non rammento esiti di tale levatura in quest'aria.
Il sontuoso velluto della voce della Tebaldi si trapunge di seta e fili d'oro nell'esecuzione di questo brano. Le note, doviziose di armoniche, risonanze, colori, iridescenze giungono all'ascoltatore solleticandone, ora dolci ora potenti, non solo l'udito ma tutti i sensi: sembra quasi di dover socchiudere gli occhi all'arrivo dei raggi di sole della primavera che squarcia radiosa, come il canto di Renata, le nubi bigie e fa fiorire le rose. Non rammento esiti di tale levatura in quest'aria.
i see .. she probably just worked with her in her coaching technique, because my teacher at college was Renata's only private vocal student & her name is Katerina Musetti
This is certainly the best of Tebaldi's video Mimis. She had such beautiful hands, and I understand that it was Serafin who taught her how to act with them.
Assolutamente insuperabile! Lo splendore tibrico è, in quest'aria, coglibile a piene mani! Una voce fatta di riflessi d'oro puro e di luce di diamante!
Thank you Germantenor for posting this beautifully clear video of La Tebaldi and Borling in wonderful voice. A pleasure always to see your latest postings.
she is very good condition her voice and emotion is nice.i love renata tebaldi since 1968
elvis14ism 2 weeks ago
The best Mimi...
mariop1960 1 month ago
Demasiada maravilla, no la puedo absorber de una vez!!
Lamujerlechuga 1 month ago
Its safe to say there will always be Callas vs Tebaldi debates, rational or not... Its also safe to say that both love this interpretation. Ones may not even admit it.
Replay...
pedr0mg 2 months ago
This is the best Mimi and Rudolfo ever!!!
SPLINTER581 2 months ago in playlist Fler videoklipp från GermanOperaSinger
@SPLINTER581 No I'm trying to remember the "Mimi" who sang with Pavarotti.
Something like Amicho...she was quite young, and the face of an angel. Does anyone remember?
HeatherGlen33 5 days ago
@SPLINTER581 just as good as di stefano & albanese in 1952?
BUTCHIE20100 4 days ago
Grandissima!!!!Non ci sono parole!!!
gabrivenere2008 2 months ago
What a wonderful and well controlled voice. Bravo Renata.
joutneyman 3 months ago
Where is it written that you can't love Maria & Renata?? Seems to me they are both immortals, both beloved, both sadly gone. Happily we have their recordings to enjoy them equally. This may be heresy for some but I heard both at The Met, have numerous recordinds by both and love both of them. Basta with this sniping between the two camps. BRAVA MARIA. BRAVA RENATA.
BUTCHIE20100 4 months ago
Two dislikes. They have no soul.
lightbulb1952 4 months ago
This incredible voice, always above the orchestra...
giorich 6 months ago
Team Callas!
vivelhistoire 7 months ago
@vivelhistoire I hope you are joking. No true Opera fan believes in the Callas - Tebaldi rivalry. Callas is Bel Canto, Tebaldi is verismo.
flicfan416 6 months ago
With me, there has always been an eminent performance for each of the great arias that surpass all others. For me, this is one of those eminent performances. I have never, in my eons of adoring opera, been as humbled and lush with awe as I was the first time I listened to this performance.
shaunclark17 7 months ago
AH. What's not to love in this rendition? Beautiful.
RobLobstuhh 8 months ago
sin comentarios, sus expresiones faciales lo dicen todo, lástima que generalmente hoy en día se haya perdido ese arte
wotancat1 8 months ago
Who was the conductor ?
Where was show this opera ?
When was this opera show ?
conghoan1998 9 months ago
bravoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
mrluistena 11 months ago
Aparte de que es la mejor Mimí de la historia del disco, en particular su versión de London de 1952; esta voz trasmite amor y es una de las voces más bellas y angelicales de todos los tiempos.
MrArthurovenezuela 1 year ago 2
In questo video non dovrebbe essere data la possibilità di commentare perchè nessuna parola può neanche lontanamente avvicinarsi a quello che si ascolta.
PS. La boheme della Tebaldi è il disco più venduto al mondo per chi non lo sapesse.
Buon ascolto a tutti
80Mrmirko 1 year ago 3
"Voice of an Angel". Yes, indeed!
zlatantillifk 1 year ago
Hes not German....hes Swedish,,,,,the Finest Tenor Ever
apopof5 1 year ago
Che artista insuperabile. Grande!!!
mm00046 1 year ago
she surely has the most beautiful voice....best mimi ever
xXxgermanfriedelxXx 1 year ago
Amazing
arn79x 1 year ago
Dreamy....Fantastic Singer. simply the best opera singer
tubechi1 1 year ago
The best, most natural stage/operatic laugh ever! She's delightful.
leoniemikele 1 year ago
Beautiful performance !
mountainsmi 1 year ago
They both melt my heart. When she knows the material well, she is as good as anyone ever was or will be. I'm going to try to find this DVD. It's a gem.
leoniemikele 1 year ago
@leoniemikelewe all MUST CLEAN THE MOUTH BEFORE TALKSABOUT HER.AMEN.
mmisaku 7 months ago
La più grande Mimì di sempre, nessuna come lei...assolutamente magnifica!
Daliagialla 1 year ago
La più grande Mimì...assolutamente magnifica!
Daliagialla 1 year ago
Absolutely stunning! There are many renditions of this on youtube but this is surely the best. The tone, texture, dynamics, phrasing and all that makes music truly great is inhabited by these two amazing human beings!
bluedutch01 1 year ago
She has the most beautiful legato I've ever heard!
dt195k2 1 year ago
She is very good, and so well sang. Almost good as Callas. But still very good.
RonaldBarone 1 year ago
@RonaldBarone who are you to say almost good as Callas,can you hear properly.or are you just don't know any thing about any thing?pty isnot a radar in here to top some people to even get into youtub.
mmisaku 7 months ago
@mmisaku I don't know much about opera, like you do. But Callas did, so reading the reviews about Tebaldi, Callas makes clear that she is better. So you know... I was just taking the advice from the best one... that's all. I didn't mean to hurt anymore.
RonaldBarone 5 months ago
These excerpts should serve as a lesson both in singing and STYLE. Listen to the luscious phrasing and natural class of Tebaldi, the radiant tone of Björling. The current roster of Mimis, including many "famous" ones should be much more modest, and find some guiding inspiration here. Amen.
GoldenAgeSunshine 1 year ago
where was this????????
rodlarocque 1 year ago
Ha! Isn't she just magnificent??!!
Allotmenteer2 1 year ago 3
The most perfect voice as per Montserrat Caballe.
tebaldicallas 1 year ago
Превосходная Рената Тебальди и по сей день лучше всех.
stasja17 1 year ago
最高のミミ。カラスより巧い。
MrTondemohappun 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why does it say German Opera Singer. Bjorling was a Swede, and Tebaldi was an Italian.
Colvillecr 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Why does it say German Opera Singer. Bjorling was a Swede, and Tebaldi was an Italian.
Colvillecr 1 year ago
Why does it say German Opera Singer. Bjorling was a Swede and Tebaldi an Italian.
Colvillecr 1 year ago
Why does it say German Opera Singer. Bjorling was a Swede and Tebaldi an Italian.
Colvillecr 1 year ago
She is ... just perfect!! What an extraordinary voice... I just can not stop listening to this beatifull prodigy!!!
mfrances0503 1 year ago
bellissima, incantevole....
lollycatania 1 year ago 2
The great Aria, the great Soprano, perfect combination - even Bjorling was speechless (Hehe) Thank you GOS!
clevblue 2 years ago 2
I´m speechless!!!....She is the best Mimi ever!!!...Unbelievable!!!
6sushi66 2 years ago 4
Bellissima Sublime La Tebaldi Grazie !
bodiloto 2 years ago 6
The greatest Mimi ever. Perfection
mrrk 2 years ago 6
Fantastic voice shame about bjorling resembling a dirty old man though!
ZsaZsadoll 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I was listening to Maria Callas when I found this video... she ie very good singer, and this aria sounds so good on her voice.
Callas version is better but I really enjoy listening her too.
RonaldBarone 2 years ago
Callas better than this? I don't think so.
mrrk 2 years ago 7
The best !!!
Vannikardinabeib 2 years ago 17
La voce è bellissima, senz'altro... ma linterpretazione.... Si direbbe una delle regine di Donizzetti, no una fioraia / donna di vita.
michaelis2003 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Her voice is excellent of course. But her interpretation?... Does she seem a poor seamstress, or rather a queen taken from some Donizetti's opera?
michaelis2003 2 years ago
Magnifica, mi sono commossa.
Ehebet 2 years ago 3
Increible Tebaldi.
Fanstastico su lirismo, en timbre no la gana nadie, su voz tiene el peso perfecto... y esa risa preliminar al Non so... es maravillosa...XD
Darjaius 2 years ago
Anyone who thinks they need to open [i] vowels should listen to this. So smiley. So bright. It is the essence of her perfect singing. Gorgeous.
MrYankeeTex 2 years ago 3
Nice to hear this in a spinto size voice...
MariaAntoinetteF 2 years ago 4
I understand that the newer is not always the better. Her voice is just what I 've looking for. What a perfect singing!
jirodesouma 2 years ago 17
@jirodesouma Exactly! Thanks for your perceptive comment, since you're obviously much younger than I am (56 and counting).
VivaRenata 2 years ago
There is no age in Music. Superb tape. Love this opera and the ariea. Thanks for posting it!!!
vesterico 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
in this role only Freni and Caballe arrive near Renata
ric220867 2 years ago
Continuo a chiedermi perché si debbano sempre leggere tante idiozie. SI SAPPIA E SI DEBBA SAPERE che una tale naturalezza di canto deriva da una padronanza tecnica somma, certo unita ad una voce semplicemente meravigliosa. SI RICORDI CHE IN ARTE LA NATURALEZZA E' IL TRAGUARDO SOMMO!
SensusEtRatio 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
NO way..she has a great voice..BUT doesn't have the greatness , technique, uniquness that CALLAS has...love Callas' version, that one is more powerful and more heavenly. she is more ordinary soprano lacking the extraordinarity...but of course great woman!
feveroo7 2 years ago
Brava!!!! voce d'Angelo .
MARISOLDELMONACO 2 years ago 3
What a gorgeous gem! How lovely her voice was then. And what an actress! Thank you, GermanOperaSinger, for posting this.
geomusic 2 years ago 8
anđeo
irmirm 2 years ago
She is so great!! I admire her!! I hope someday i'll sing like..jeje
I like her more than Callas..i think Callas' voice was a little nasal..
But the are both so great!!
MilDarkAngel 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She had a beautiful big , however single dimensional voice,mediocre technique ,moderate musicality ,and near ridiculous acting.
Despite problems with the dynamics, here, this role is a relative success for her as was some other not demanding music.
suxmdbab 2 years ago
Not everything is about technique or musicialuty..
You need to have that "something" to succes...And Renata definitly has it..
MilDarkAngel 2 years ago
Tebaldi is not alone a very great singer, but also a superb performer. She IIIIIIIIIIIS Mimi !
Hans NL
qklq42 2 years ago 2
I do love this Mimi. Tebaldi is simply glorious, her depth and range is incredible. Freni would be a close second for her incredible technique. Two of the greatest singers of the century, Bjorling and Tebaldi...together. What a treat.
gigie555 2 years ago
This is absolutely glorious--Tebaldi at her very best. It exemplifies why hers is the quintessential exposition of the role. This is the Mimi against which all others must be judged. Thanks so much for posting!
ifmusicbe 2 years ago
Il sontuoso velluto della voce della Tebaldi si trapunge di seta e fili d'oro nell'esecuzione di questo brano. Le note, doviziose di armoniche, risonanze, colori, iridescenze giungono all'ascoltatore solleticandone, ora dolci ora potenti, non solo l'udito ma tutti i sensi: sembra quasi di dover socchiudere gli occhi all'arrivo dei raggi di sole della primavera che squarcia radiosa, come il canto di Renata, le nubi bigie e fa fiorire le rose. Non rammento esiti di tale levatura in quest'aria.
SensusEtRatio 2 years ago 3
@SensusEtRatio i agree so much with what you say about Renata. when ahe sings " il primo baccio del aprile e mio" it seems that Puccini composed this line just for Renata Tebaldi !
TheValdoro 1 year ago
Renata Tebaldi....a great Italian singer....of Classical Music.......!!!!
fabienik 2 years ago
Faultless perfection!!!!
UBIQUITOUS12 2 years ago 2
Wonderful Renata...
fabienik 3 years ago
I own this DVD, and there isn't this much echo on it.
But this is absolutely my favorite rendetion of this aria. Nobody beats it. The voice. The dymanics. The expression. Better than perfection.
badpdx 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
One person who beats it: Tebaldi herself in her first (mono) recording of the opera done some years earlier. Every wonderful quality this video demonstrates PLUS heavenly high pianissimi which she doesn't do in this version.
troppofiato 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Yes, I have that recording, and you're absolutely correct. It is better. The only thing this version has on that one is that you actually get to see her!
Either way, Tebaldi is the gold standard for recorded Mimis.
badpdx 2 years ago
What captivating, glorious singing! This is Tebaldi at the height of her powers and demonstrates why she is my favorite Mimi of all time--embodying the character and vocal demands so naturally.
ifmusicbe 3 years ago
Oh Renata! How beautiful!
operachad 3 years ago 3
What an amazing voice! Where did you find the video?
iubescanto 3 years ago
Il sontuoso velluto della voce della Tebaldi si trapunge di seta e fili d'oro nell'esecuzione di questo brano. Le note, doviziose di armoniche, risonanze, colori, iridescenze giungono all'ascoltatore solleticandone, ora dolci ora potenti, non solo l'udito ma tutti i sensi: sembra quasi di dover socchiudere gli occhi all'arrivo dei raggi di sole della primavera che squarcia radiosa, come il canto di Renata, le nubi bigie e fa fiorire le rose. Non rammento esiti di tale levatura in quest'aria.
SensusEtRatio 3 years ago 7
DIVA
OmanInternational 3 years ago 5
I love this version
petshopgirl72 3 years ago 3
Aniquilador.
laourite 3 years ago
為何那男的一臉不知所措咧?
vintachen 3 years ago
un pò troppo vezzosa...ma splendida canna...
robertocresca 3 years ago
Incroyable - such a beautiful controlled voice. Lovely to look at also.
Perfec singing.
VivaTebaldi 3 years ago
I could't agree more!
AEphrat 3 years ago
two giants of the opera history !!!
Rephrat 3 years ago
Comment removed
dolcefico 3 years ago
Il sontuoso velluto della voce della Tebaldi si trapunge di seta e fili d'oro nell'esecuzione di questo brano. Le note, doviziose di armoniche, risonanze, colori, iridescenze giungono all'ascoltatore solleticandone, ora dolci ora potenti, non solo l'udito ma tutti i sensi: sembra quasi di dover socchiudere gli occhi all'arrivo dei raggi di sole della primavera che squarcia radiosa, come il canto di Renata, le nubi bigie e fa fiorire le rose. Non rammento esiti di tale levatura in quest'aria.
SensusEtRatio 3 years ago 2
i see .. she probably just worked with her in her coaching technique, because my teacher at college was Renata's only private vocal student & her name is Katerina Musetti
joseyposey88 3 years ago
is your teacher perhaps Katerina Musetti?
joseyposey88 3 years ago
dodi132, is your teacher perhaps Katerina Musetti?
joseyposey88 3 years ago
This is certainly the best of Tebaldi's video Mimis. She had such beautiful hands, and I understand that it was Serafin who taught her how to act with them.
rawdonqueen 3 years ago
Assolutamente insuperabile! Lo splendore tibrico è, in quest'aria, coglibile a piene mani! Una voce fatta di riflessi d'oro puro e di luce di diamante!
SensusEtRatio 3 years ago 3
fantastica
falcoti 3 years ago 4
Herr Singer,
Cannot thank you enough. Bravo.
Donna Tebaldi...osequi.
Just had so much fun. Played this as response to Maestro Pavarotti.
I heard him sing it with Renata Scotto and--others may-- but I didn't like it. Scotto
sang so that one could not make out a word. I love Pavarotti's Italian and Tebaldi's.
francescaemc2 3 years ago 8
Agreed, not a fan of Scotto myself.
GermanOperaSinger 3 years ago
The greatest Mimi ever.
mrrk 3 years ago 3
Thank you Germantenor for posting this beautifully clear video of La Tebaldi and Borling in wonderful voice. A pleasure always to see your latest postings.
sospello 3 years ago
Beautiful.
patjan92 3 years ago