@ToFSIMS While I agree the Maria Ewing performance is stellar in the voice and acting categories, Rinat Shahman plays Cherubino perfectly! She looks the part completely, and acts it very well, with wonderful expression in her voice. This performance is also a little more interesting to watch then the Maria Ewing. But, they are both amazing performances, and not easily compared.
@egraceq .Thanks for the comment. I was basing my earlier comment solely on the voice quality and to a lesser extent on acting. But after all, it is only one video and it is difficult for me to determine how much the voice quality is enhanced by the recording vs. actual singer's voice quality.
I agree that Rinat Shahman sang very well and acted the part perfectly, only thing I did like a bit less was the flourish at the end, which is a deviation from the score, I think.
My favourite Cherubino of all time to date. The mezzo soprano Fabiana Katz will be singing it this coming Friday and Saturday. Can't wait to hear her..
Heard her sing Carmen in Baden Baden. Was unbelivable. So good I bought a ticket the next night also. I also heard her Dorabella in Berlin and was exquisite. Danke
Shaham is superb! We just heard her in Sydney singing Carmen. As we all clapped in unison, someone behind me said "wow... wow,,, wow " and that's how my husband and I felt exactly.
Very natural interpretation, 9.9/10!
csabarabh 4 weeks ago 8
almost perfect. I didn't like the flourishes she added at the end.
tibele1000 1 month ago
Adorable!
theinkbrain 1 month ago
THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST IN THE WORLD, THANK YOU ROYAL OPERA
wenarto 2 months ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Not as good as Maria Ewing, I think
ToFSIMS 5 months ago
@ToFSIMS While I agree the Maria Ewing performance is stellar in the voice and acting categories, Rinat Shahman plays Cherubino perfectly! She looks the part completely, and acts it very well, with wonderful expression in her voice. This performance is also a little more interesting to watch then the Maria Ewing. But, they are both amazing performances, and not easily compared.
egraceq 4 months ago 4
@egraceq .Thanks for the comment. I was basing my earlier comment solely on the voice quality and to a lesser extent on acting. But after all, it is only one video and it is difficult for me to determine how much the voice quality is enhanced by the recording vs. actual singer's voice quality.
I agree that Rinat Shahman sang very well and acted the part perfectly, only thing I did like a bit less was the flourish at the end, which is a deviation from the score, I think.
ToFSIMS 3 months ago
This aria requires very good acting apart from the singing and Rinat makes the scene so realistic. Her emotional conflicts are there for all to see.
oakwoodbank 8 months ago 23
My favourite Cherubino of all time to date. The mezzo soprano Fabiana Katz will be singing it this coming Friday and Saturday. Can't wait to hear her..
goblinonacloud 9 months ago
Brava! Che bella voce, io non sapea che cantaste sì bene.... :)bellissimo suono, grande tecnica
ShinyScvivers 9 months ago 7
My fav Cherubino
Cammie010 10 months ago 12
Absolutely delicious.
P1B1U1H1 11 months ago 8
marvellous voice and perfomance, really amazing. I adore this version. Congratulations from Spain
profemanarte 1 year ago 66
This has been flagged as spam show
she is from Israel!! Somehow she reminds me of Tamar, the main character of a novel by David Grossman, who sings opera too in the book.
I love her intepretation as well, superb acting!!
papagena92 1 year ago
New York's favorite Mezzo
NewYorkToimes 1 year ago 5
Heard her sing Carmen in Baden Baden. Was unbelivable. So good I bought a ticket the next night also. I also heard her Dorabella in Berlin and was exquisite. Danke
celebritysiting 1 year ago 9
Shaham is superb! We just heard her in Sydney singing Carmen. As we all clapped in unison, someone behind me said "wow... wow,,, wow " and that's how my husband and I felt exactly.
StringChannel 1 year ago 6
Really wonderful. Thankyou for posting. When is she next singing in London, we'd like to hear her live
AviationClaim 1 year ago 3
She's truly wonderful, this mezzo. We heard her do scheherezade with Simon Rattle. She is such a joy to hear.
ElissaBerardi 1 year ago 6
Best interpretation on Youtube, and what a magnificent voice!
shopofcrafts 1 year ago 4
She's the best Cherubino I've heard in this production. Let's hope she'll come back and do it again next time they do it.
Why we not hearing more of her at Covent Garden... get her back.
iceorgmusic 1 year ago 99
@iceorgmusic we've heard she'll be at the Salzburg Easter Festival this year with Rattle and the Berlin Phil. We are going.
ElissaBerardi 1 year ago 6
perfect!
mcNoa 1 year ago 8