roger waters lisbon 2006 sheep

[ColtinNotChicken]

He is totally lip syncing here.

[chris01837]

Jon carin is amazing, unsung hero of Floyd for the past 24 years.. Playing Keyboards, guitars, singing.. Also the only musician to play on all of Roger & David's 2006 shows, sometimes playing the same song but different interpretations for both shows.. Incredibly versatile musician...

[bolinha198]

i was tthere : D

i am 15 years old and i already saw roger waters live 3 times he is by fare the best artist of all time

[RushRules4]

he sounds awesome. I was surprised.

[jimromerulez]

thanks for this!!!

one of my all time fav floyd songs. unfortunatly I was born too late for the legendary 77 tour

[conman45011]

I wish all musicians were this good live

[COMMUNISTPHILOSOPHY]

keep out of politics Roger, stick to music

[MrDodstink]

Animals is a great album which this song is taken from.

[aldo3864]

este concierto esta en dvd

[uh0oo]

Could someone tell me the setlist for this show?

[LegoPatapon]

@uh0oo If this like the original "In the Flesh" tour, then it is the songlist for "Animals" and then the songlist for "Dark Side of the Moon"

[LocurasDegaister]

en vivo me rompe la cabeza

[DocRoe92]

I was there!!! I was only 13 but i still remember sheep and it's one of my all time favourite Pink Floyd songs, especially the epic rolling guitar riff half way through!!!

[mtatrip]

eu apareco aos 9segundos!!! heeheheh valeu estar a frente desde as 4 da tarde.. lol =)

[carochaGTI]

EU FUI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[gingerninjadave420]

les' version is better

[semtex2you]

wot do ya get?

[ultraluis3]

where's algie in here?

[dud0r]

hehe they grabbed the mic from roger before the final mastering and effects - thats not how it would sound to the audience :P anyway, he is a G O D. Rip Mr. Wright btw, you will be missed a lot :(

[semtex2you]

bol316 when you can do better, come se us. ya see, i happen to know rog. just calm down...oi!

[soulfly525]

Rock in Rio Lisboa rules. At 2010 we have more. Portugal rules, men.

[HeartshapedSun]

Roger might be 64 years old, but he can still sing and play! :)

[rottweilerdoberman]

Is it just me or can you spell worth a shit???

[justiniscoolohyea]

is it my of is his bass out of tune?

[pinkfloydn1fan]

as like such as and iraq

and no his bass isn't out of tune

[justiniscoolohyea]

lol major mistake. and lol it was 10 months ago

[FlipTeixeira]

Mais um belo concerto em Portugal..

[sharpiedawg]

i remember in winnipeg

when it was the red pyro

the whole mts centre was all red like couldnt see anything but red

it was intense

so was the whole show

[rcallan]

His singing voice is pretty fucked now though.

[lloydee123]

4th ROW FROM THE FRONT. . . .o2 ARENA!!!!

[ciftode]

everyone just shut up...there could of never been a Floyd without EITHER Waters or Gilmour....period...a band ia band and none of us really know the inner politics between them. rock on

[woodledog]

@ciftode Truth

[Rickyzinho]

I was in this gig!! fantastic.. absolutely amazing show

[Nolby]

Roger has some amazing talent packed into his brain

[orbie30]

gilmour and waters just like lennon and macca great and two different entities.

[youset1983]

Definitely the Waters' talent was the lyrics and concepts. And music! He was the songwriter, not Gilmour.

[hearnzy22]

Seen the man twice and he is by far the most creative and outspoken musical genious the grace the earth.

Hearnzy

[albenabeaufort]

Roger is the best singer and songwriter and the HOTTEST MAN EVER!!!!!

[orlandos]

That's Richard Gere, isn't it?

[albenabeaufort]

Hell no, Roger looks much better than Richard Gere

[MadLovesComin]

In my opinion, he IS the best songwriter ever.

Great song, not as good as the studio version in my opinion, but still very nice. Something what I like better about RW is that he picks challenging songs to play, like Dogs in his previous tour and now Sheep. Unfortunately David Gilmour often plays the same songs over and over again throughout the years.

[narokath]

I disagree. Gilmour played echoes, which might be the most challenging Floyd song.

[SoldierGoth]

Damn, Roger Waters is got to be the best songwriter EVER.

[Xboxliv3]

I wish they would make one more very big concert and do as many songs as humanly possable.

[aaakkkk]

oh and i forgot nick mason, i thought he was drumming for waters but it doesnt appear to be him in this video

[aaakkkk]

this song really can't be played without gilmour and wright

[axeeugene78]

hell it's not that much about the bass line. he's not singing, he's shouting and not in the good waters way:(

[bol316]

Not to mention Waters isn't playing the bassline right at all. He is playing very lazy. I understand you are old Roger but theres never an excuse for lazy playing. Heck i think the old Roger would agree with me on that.

[jorkanmx]

When did Waters plays an unlazy bass riff?

See Emily Play, another brick in the wall aren't sounds familiarly?

The best One of these years bass' lines was performed by Gilmour. Definitely the Waters' talent was the lyrics and concepts.

[bol316]

He needs Richard Wright and David Gilmour BADLY here. The guitar work especially is subpar.

[MrPelintra]

thank you roger for that night

[rogerwaters11]

But it the closet thing to it! Gilmour won't even think about playing any of these songs that Waters does!

[TheFukaiMori]

Waters is a great master, I love his music!! But... isn't Pink Floyd =/

[dud0r]

async and not masterbus recorded, there are some channels missing e.g. the synth which comes in every end of the textline. Additional FX on the voice of roger.. but anyway, thats a good quality. the flying pig is missing this was great!

[amaximillian]

Roger is the great master of Pink Floyd!!! I had a great opportunity to see him in Rio, playing @ Apoteose!!! Unique show!!! Amazing!!! Unforgettable!!!

[Rockgod4u]

is there any way to ban these assholes that advertise those stupid webcam sites? Get a real girlfriend you fuckin loser!

[InsideOutRW]

september 30, 2006 Noblesville Indiana. GREATEST CONCERT OF MY LIFE!!!!

[soulfly525]

Great. Rock in Rio Lisboa 2006. Viva Portugal.

[kronlof2]

Love this!! Saw him 3 times. Would go anytime!!

[27o348]

sw them in belgium 2007, best scow ever seen and heard!!!And I saw a lot, a big lot !!! 59 jears old I am, love music since I was in pampers!!!

[CarFanatic95]

i also saw him in mansfield, MA. it was an awesome show.

[NUSHMIKE]

roger god waters

[WeHaveLostTheWay]

God wouldn't just relive old albums, year after year....

[khstein]

Saw them in Atlanta, best arena show in years!

[sloburnt]

vancouver

[NUSHMIKE]

bravo

[sloburnt]

nice to see this awesome footage again, I was HIGH as hell watching this show thurs night

[chrismacy55]

Where did you see him at Sloburnt...?

[skellevis]

I saw them on arrow's rock festival in holland 2006 It was amazing 3hr darkside of the moon

[vooden]

easily one of the best arena shows I have seen in the last five years (Oakland 6/19/07). He is a rock icon. If you have a chance to see this show don't pass it up.

[theguitarguy39]

I'm going to see this show in Boston next Month, looks good

[sethmanjette12]

Its awesome I saw him in mansfield

[angelone069]

Just saw Roger last night in ottawa Ont Canada. Was better than awesome!! He's still got it at 63 HEIGHTENED EVERY SENSE POSSIBLE his music and voice were both bang on Hope there will be a Dvd to follow 2007 world tour.

[markhynde]

Animals has always been one of my all time fav albums, (a classic)

[geoffrodriguez]

Cheers for the upload. Shame it cuts off at the end, that last guitar part is the best bit!! lol Saw Roger and the band last night at Earl's Court and his voice was a lot better. This was my favourite song along with 'Any Colour You Like' from DSOTM.

[dpitd]

i saw roger at nec in birmingham he was not miming but like all singers they use all aids open to them.Listen to the pulse DVD im sure Gilmour has a back up or am i a paronoid? if you want to hear a great singer listen to jim reeves if you want to hear a great VOCALIST listen to ROGER WATERS

[dpitd]

he has a great voice

[lebanterfeind]

rogers voice was never great, but this takes the biscuit

[tourbatos]

where are the remaining tracks of this show?please post!!!this production!!!

[ultraluis3]

get a life you fuckin asshole

[tourbatos]

is this gonna be a dvd?does anyone know?i saw him in greece, it was awesome

[robnbob]

i think radio kaos is the best album by far!

[NattMoore]

Dude, thank you for posting this. Animals is my favourite album, and this is my favourite track.

[tallinvegas]

I agree so under rated but so powerfull for the period of time for which it was written. Cant wait to see you in vegas Roger. Keep rockin old man!!!!

[jethroboogie]

fantastica video and song i remember this song when he came to mexico

[tyandambika]

saw this show in bombay india ... unbelievable ... go see him do floyd better than floyd can do floyd when he comes to north america

[josepyGDB]

This album has got to be one of the most meaningful political statements, on a massive scale, the music industry has ever produced. "Pigs on a wing"...brilliant! One of my all time favorites in both musical and lyrical genius. Both awsome and chilling to behold.

[boerni1976]

Think, one of the best`s Floyd-songs!Really Rocking

[Mageta7935]

wow i like how they keep the guitar players in the dark even though they are what drove that entire album i aint diggin the bass being the main instrument

[bahjazz]

I'm a little weird, I guess, but one of my favorite albums is Pink Floyd's "Animals", where this song is from. Interesting to hear "Sheep" live.

[leandrofairich]

eu amo pink floid!

[johnnyc2712]

Why doesn't Roger get a knighthood? He is the best poet of his generation.

[lukesmailbox]

I think if he did he'd probably decline the offer, because of his political stance, and I'd imagine he'd some criticism to the British Monarchy, in fact I don't think he even lives in the UK anymore in protest, but I don't know. Buy your right he is the best poet of his generation. David Gilmour should get one for his charity work, he has already received a OBE.

[grinchybanana]

wait what are you talking about? decline what offer? and why don't you think he lives in the UK. And where doe's he live now? just wondering.

[lukesmailbox]

He now lives in New York. He left England in protest over its governments ban of Fox Hunting.

[grinchybanana]

why i thougt he was vegan or something?

[lukesmailbox]

I was surprised too!

[joseph8777]

Gilmores crazy changes have always been the best part about that song.Not bad though.

[ellyfish1]

Can't wait to see him at MEN in May!!! Anyone else going?

[jerryskid1]

This was and incredible tour. Will it ever be released on DVD?

[kidamathias]

i just got back from seeing him tonight, i was there about 2 hours ago and his singing was perfect! sounded exactly like he did back 30 years ago!

[maniacguitar]

yep same, I saw him yesterday in Monterrey Mexico and he just NAILED the songs!! The set looked better here though :(

[MoreGilmour]

I'm so sick and tired of everyone bashing Roger cause he can't sing like he did when he was 30...well, lets see you yell the way he did when your 60...I think he does a damn good job.

[knoppba1]

But to think that he wasn't singing most of the words, or that he is not playing the instruments that he is holding is retarted. You will note that he only puts his hands in the air when he goes to play a note like an A (which is an ope string note) in Comfortably Numb, that is when he puts his hands in the air.

[knoppba1]

Just so you know, Norbert Satchel confirmed on Roger Waters's In The Flesh tour that there some pre-recorded vocals to help him out. One obvious example is the scream in The Gunner's Dream, and I am going to guess that the "train" of the "riding the gravy train" in have a cigar was prerecorded, too.

[RaggedTiger70]

IMHO Roger Waters could lip-sync the entire show if he wants and I'd still love it and go and buy the DVD afterwards. We're lucky he's touring at all. He definitely doesn't have to prove his talent at this point.

[sethmanjette12]

i agree, i wouldnt care if he sat and read the lyrics no instruments as long as i got to see him live.

[viper722]

but he isnt (if he is) lip synching on eclipse. the rumors tell that the lipsynching is on Have A Cigar, Fletcher Memorial Home, Gunners Dream on Rock In Rio, Time, and Sheep.

[ginamina28]

I've posted a comment above about 'Have a Cigar' ... he's not lip synching as I was in the 6th row and his mic didn't work ... we heard him ... when they turned it on it was clear it was his voice coming through.

[madness008]

Find this vid Roger Waters - 9 - Eclipse (Montreal 092106)

thats where hes flat and quick on 2nd line

then find Eclipse - Roger Waters (which was added september 12th)

sings first lines differently.

clearly hes really singing so stfu

[madness008]

ok i have proof hes not lip syncing (this was a big deal to me.) Just watched two bootlegs of "eclips" at shows taped about 2 weeks a part and right away one of then he starts a little flat and he says "all that you see" very quickly. In the other he sings it regular time and less off key. Took 2 minutes to debunk this rumour. If he does lip sync a couple parts cuz of effects on his voice i dont care as long as hes really singing most of the time.

[madness008]

hes not necessarily lip syncing the video is clearly like half a second ahead of the music. You can tell for sure during the closeup of the drum roll right before he starts singing. You see him smack the cymbals and then afterwards you hear the crash. I think if they prerecorded his voice hed sound a lot better too! A good way to tell would bew to find a couple performances on here and see if his voice sounds exactly the same. Ima do that now.

[SimzDubz]

That was a very good show i have some video too of the show on my channel!

[alphabetgreen]

I think he's singing it really well, considering the release date of Animals. Have you heard his voice on Amused to Death? Magnificent album, but boy, his larynx hasn't half been put through the mangle.

[ginamina28]

I agree, best album ... the horse voice adds digity to his words!

[alphabetgreen]

What's your favourite track on that album? Personally (and this after a lot of listens) I like What God Wants part 3.  Great climax when the guitar comes in.

[ginamina28]

I like 'Three Wishes' right now ... it changes every week. First it was 'The Bravery of Being Out of Range' and then it was 'Watching TV' ... Great music, I hope he tours it before he gets too old.

[alphabetgreen]

I'm not surprised it changes every week. It sounds different every time you listen to it. That's the secret of good music. I can't imagine him getting too old to do anything.  He seems to have aged better than the rest of Pink Floyd. He was really ugly in the sixties.

[ginamina28]

I know, I wondered if anyone else thought that. He's also mellowed and become quite polite!

[alphabetgreen]

Do you remember when David Gilmour used to look like an angel? Really good looking. He looks strange now, what with his pot belly and bald head, so does Nick Mason. Rick Wright hasn't changed at all, save for his hair turning the colour of snow.

[ginamina28]

You are so right, he was stunning. I read in Nick's book that he did some modeling before becoming a musican. He did underwear ads! He is 60 now ... but Roger is 63! Lifestyles I guess ... Roger has been single more! Ha ha ...

[alphabetgreen]

Very good point. I'm divorced now, and I look 14. By the way, I read Nick's book as well, thoroughly enjoyed it. It prompted me to give Syd Barrett's music a second chance, so I went out and bought 'Piper at the Gates of Dawn'. Some of it's nonsense, but a lot of it is quite charming. Have you heard it?

[ginamina28]

Not his solo stuff ... I'll give it a try.

[alphabetgreen]

Piper at the Gates of Dawn is Floyd's debut album. BTW, my favourite CD by Floyd is the Final Cut, especially the title track. People here in UK seem to disagree with me. In fact they even go so far as to say that Gilmour rescued Floyd after the Final Cut. To me, that's bloody nonsense! A Momentary Lapse of Reason is an awful album. David Gilmour has a beautiful voice, and he is THE definitive Floyd lead guitarist without question. But he can't write songs for shit! Agreed?

[ginamina28]

I have heard Piper ... it's fun '60's stuff ... I have A Saucer full of Secrets too. As for the Gilmour led Floyd, I am not totally pleased with the lyical content, but I am a Roger Waters fan! I can't get enough of anything he wrote and hope for more.

[alphabetgreen]

You didn't think Gilmour's tunes were bad as well? I agree. I am very much a Roger Waters fan, before Pink Floyd, and certainly before David Gilmour.

[muhjaheed]

fuck dude....this guy is just far out man...existential you know....

[LouDawg808]

do any of you guys think its a good idea to not listend to any Pink Floyd music weeks before the tour? so when you go itle sound better and fresh? Note: this is coming from a fan who knows every PF song by heart.

[17wilmot]

9/17: Great show: FIRST HALF: In The Flesh, Mother, Set The Controls For the Heart Of The Sun, Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Have A Cigar, Wish You Were Here, Southampton Dock, The Fletcher Memorial Home, Perfect Sense parts 1 and 2, Leaving Beirut, Sheep.

SECOND HALF: Dark Side of the Moon. ENCORE: The Happiest Days Of Our Lives, Another Brick In The Wall (Pt 2), Vera, Bring the Boys back Home, Comfortably Numb.

[alphabetgreen]

What about the Final Cut, one of the most moving songs of all time?

[gilmour70]

wish it was with all original 4 members

[jansenmann]

too true, the dynamic is perfect eh, although if anyone is going to see him in the US this month, I assure you that he will utterly blow you and anyone else away..

[ginamina28]

Don't we all ... maybe ... hell froze over for the Eagles. It's up to Gilmour as Roger Waters has publicly stated he would do it and he asked both Gilmour and Wright to do The Dark Side of the Moon tour. Mason was there for the key shows (which I saw one of).

[viper722]

thank you codyguitarsrv. good to see someone actually agrees with me!

[codyguitarsrv]

He didn't lipsync for christ sake...for those that think he did...give the Animals album a listen...and you'll see that he is singing a lot different than he is here...granted he was younger back then but for fucks sake...he is NOT lip syncing....Roger ain't a sell out.

[elkhounds]

I've seen alot of videos on Utube where the sound wasn't directly in sync with the video...probably an error that occurs during upload....at any rate, I think Roger would be the last person in the entertainment industry to even consider lip syncing to a live show.

[jansenmann]

Well, I saw Roger in London's Hyde Park and you will not be disappointed.

[velvetvenom]

seems to me the sound was going 2 fast on the video, thats all. roger miming seems pretty unlikely to me.

[insidethewall]

you better watch out!!! there maybe dogs in the way!!!

[Blump1]

*there may be dogs about

[markusmachado]

I need a dvd or I'm gonna kill myself

[ginamina28]

Me too ... I saw the show twice and I still wish for more!

[markusmachado]

In The Flesh DVD was so amazing, I'm begging to see more pink floyd (and water's) classics on high quality production like that one.

[jimmyneeson]

I Love oul Roger... and this is no disapointment. Fantastic.

[pedroz69]

Quem me dera ter lá estado! Onde é que eu estava com a cabeça!?

[LoozerJustin]

Is anyone else disturbed that Roger is not playing bass guitar OR singing this tour? They have his parts recorded and hes just whispering/grunting the whole bit through. 0 people who worked writing this song are playing it right now.

[ginamina28]

He was doing both at the show I saw him at ... I know because he was standing right in front of me for three separate instances @ Shoreline. He came up the sides and stood and played right in front of several people!

[LoozerJustin]

How could he stand infront of you while singing? His microphone is stage center, so I doubt you 'saw' him actually singing. I havn't seen his latest tour but he is always throwing both of his arms in the air while someone or something is still playing the bass line. There is a video of Roger performing The Gunner's Dream (on YouTube) which you can clearly hear two of Roger's voices. One is loud and clear and the other is respective to his mouth - soft and horse.

[ginamina28]

Well, at Hollywood Bowl, the 8th, I was 6 rows back in the center, right in front of him, and he was singing and playing bass. His mic didn't work for the first few lines of 'Have a Cigar' and we all heard him. He was horse by the end of the show. At the Shoreline show on the 10th he wasn't singing when he came up the ramps but playing his bass and smiling at all of us who congregated in front of him. He did the opening bars of 'Money' ... that's how I know he was playing.

[ginamina28]

Did you even go to any of these show??? Watching the delayed tapes from here tells you nothing! I guess your name pretty much explains it.

[viper722]

wtf is with everyone who claims that roger was lip syncing during this concert. anyone with ears can tell hes not. has anyone else heard this rumor cause i think its complete bullshit. I love roger...pink floyd is my favorite band. i love sheep...its the my favorite off of animals (the most underrated album in history). its got a really easy bassline, that i play in my band. anyways, great video. i cant wait till he comes to massachussetts in august...ill be in the front row!

[ginamina28]

I know for a fact that he wasn't at the Shoreline Show because he cut all of the lines short. Plus it sounded different than the show at Hollywood Bowl two days prior.

[dalkavuk2]

yesterday he was in istanbul. it was amazing!!!

[pipejara]

la raja!!!!!!!!!!!

[kubrick070]

Awesome

[Arnni]

im off to one in hydepark sheep is one of my fav songs. I Play it in my Tribute Band also

[Bone73]

Animals is my fav album. When I go in September I hope Waters plays atleast one from that album.

[amusedtodeath3478]

What show are you going to?

[pnkfld73]

I am going to the first show at Greatwoods in Mansfield,MA. I cant wait!

[busstopratbag]

I was there. It was an amazing show!

[Bone73]

This video is great. Anyone going to his shows this year, or anyone know the song list he is playing for the shows? I am going in September.

[pepitoleches]

It's Amazing !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Alexmircica]

Animals is one of the best Floyd albums ever. Thanks.

[alphabetgreen]

I agree. So much better than DSOTM and WYWH. I really like the Final Cut as well. It seems that my taste is really strange to other people, because I think that 'A Momentary Lapse of Reason' is the biggest load of pretentious bollocks ever written/performed/recorded. Crap, so it is. David Gilmour has a great voice, and is an amazing lead guitarist, but he CANNOT write music.

[Alexmircica]

Final Cut is also one of my favs. People just have to remember Rick Wright's quote: 'the floyd is bigger than all of us..' They are multifacetied!